@MadMonzer's banner p

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

				

User ID: 896

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 896

Not all of Twitter is MAGA, but MAGA Twitter is MAGA, and Musk is part of MAGA Twitter - both in that he is a major supporter of Donald Trump, and in that he mostly likes/promotes/interacts with other MAGA accounts.

Yeah - you obviously aren't going to maintain Western Civilisation with Old Order Amish. Whether or not you can maintain it with car-driving Mennonites is an open question, but the odds don't look good. David Friedmann's account of Amish "law" in Legal Systems Very Different from our Own was that Amish minimise trust-requiring interactions with other Amish under a different Ordnung, let alone the English. If the same is true of Mennonites more broadly, then they aren't going to be building a 5nm fab any time soon.

The original coinage of the term "Deep State" referred to the Kemalists in the Turkish military, who would threaten to coup any elected government they didn't like. I would say that a "Deep State" is a faction that:

  • Mostly consists of career government employees (in the Turkish case, career army officers)
  • Has a political agenda beyond self-enrichment that could bring it into conflict with the elected government (in the Turkish case, Kemalist secularism)
  • Has the ability and will to effectively oppose the elected government such that it gets more of its agenda than conventional democratic logic would predict.

My steelman of the MAGA complaint about the Deep State is

  • There is a GOPe Deep State consisting of career military officers, career national security professionals, and academics, consultants and arms company executives who revolving-door through these positions. It has an agenda of promoting "American hegemony" and the so-called "Rules-Based International Order" through forever wars, and is more loyal to Israel than the United States. It enforces its will on the elected government by surveillance and blackmail of officials, and if that doesn't work by wilfully sabotaging military operations.
  • There is a Blue Deep State consisting of career bureaucrats in the domestic policy arms of the government and NGO/academic types funded by them. It has an agenda of wokestupid anarcho-tyranny. It enforces its will on the elected government by selective leaking to sympathetic media.
  • These two factions may or may not be allied. It doesn't matter. Both should die in a fire.

Note that this is a specific theory that not ever MAGA supporter would agree with. In particular, Moldbug's Cathedral is the opposite of the Deep State - Moldbug says that the career government isn't an independent power centre - it is taking orders from the NYT and Harvard. Whereas the Deep State theory is that the NYT and Harvard are doing what they do in order to retain access to funding dispensed by the Deep State. Similarly, pervasive petty corruption and laziness is a different critique to the Deep State critique, although both can be true simultaneously in different parts of the government. The army was the least corrupt part of the pre-Erdogan Turkish government.

What Congress gives, Congress can take away. Per Moldbug, Congress also has investigative powers which can be used to end the career of individual mid-grade Deep Staters. The reason why there is no effective accountability of the CFPB to Congress is that Congress is feckless, not that it lacks the necessary powers.

I would say Robin Hanson is on Mars rather than being on the right. The only reason he reads as right-wing is that the left have put effort into hating on him after he turned out to be a secret HBD-believer, whereas the right ignore him.

Scott Sumner and Kevin Erdmann on housing economics, and macro more broadly.

Haidt is a leftist who opposes wokestupid insanity. He is about as conservative as Matthew Yglesias or Ezra Klein.

Bjorn Lomborg is an intellectual, but wouldn't consider him a conservative or right-wing thinker - he's just a global warming skeptic.

My read of Lomborg is that he isn't even a skeptic - he is someone who is willing to spin the scientific consensus (as found in places like the technical bits of IPCC reports that activists don't read) in an anti-alarmist way. There is an obvious market for this, but it is pretty small compared to the market for mouth-frothing rants about scientific fraud by Commie conspiracies - in fact it appears to be small enough that Lomborg alone creates a supply of moderate anti-alarmist takes that exceeds the demand.

The fact that Lomborg is mostly correct makes his relative obscurity compared to the alarmist crazies and the conspiracist crazies a somewhat embarrassing failure on the part of humanity.

That's not much of a rejoinder when this system of the best and brightest in the richest and most information dense time in known human history can't figure whether men can get pregnant or not.

The system is perfectly clear that cis men can't get pregnant, and that FtM transsexuals can (but are unlikely to if they are on hormones). The system struggles to say what the modern meaning of the word "men" is, but that is a question about linguistics and not medicine. For the avoidance of doubt, this is pathetic, medical organisations offering muddled views about the meaning of words is bad, and they should either learn linguistics or stick to medicine and leave the meanings of words to dictionary makers.

Trump handily won.

Because FPTP in the electoral college magnifies small wins, particularly in the situation we are in where most of the key swing states are in the Rustbelt, so they tend to swing in the same direction. But the actual margin of victory in terms of votes was small - 1.5% in the popular vote and 1.7% in the tipping-point state.

The only recent election where the popular vote was closer was Bush v Gore. The tipping point state in the electoral college was closer in 2016 (0.8%) and 2020 (0.7%) but 1.5% is close by historical standards.

Given that most polls claim a 3% margin of error, the polls predicting a toss-up were correct.

but aren't a lot of honest left-of-center people REALLY embarrassed about how huge portions of the movement are being revealed as government funded astroturf?

Musk has told enough lies about what DOGE have found (most notoriously, claiming that Politico Pro subscriptions were grants funding left-wing coverage on politico.com) that honest left-of-centre people have tuned him out as a lying liar. More broadly, his decision to use MAGA Twitter as his main tool for disseminating information about DOGE means that he has put himself into the MAGA Twitter bozo bin from the point of view of leftists, centrists, and Fox News watching conservatives. If someone accuses me of being the second gunman behind the grassy knoll, molesting babies in the basement of a pizza parlour with no basement, and petty corruption, I am not going to be embarrassed by the petty corruption allegations even if they are true.

The legal argument here is snark, but the underlying point is serious. Musk has now successfully defended two lawsuits (over "pedo guy" and "funding secured") on the basis that he is a notorious shitposter, everyone knows he doesn't fact-check his tweets, and only a moron in a hurry would believe anything based on a Musk tweet. Nobody who isn't in the tank for Musk is going to be embarrassed based on a Musk tweet without receipts, and the receipts DOGE have provided have been laughably inaccurate.

Focussing only on unambiguous mistakes - i.e. avoiding decisions which one side thinks are bad for partisan reasons:

If we are restricting ourselves to the Federal government, then the worst mistake is invading Iraq with no clear political goal or plan in place for the post-war occupation. If Scott Sumner and Kevin Erdmann are correct (and their models are based on sound theory and have a record of making correct predictions) then the second worst mistake was misreading a housing market borked by fundamentals (YIMBY supply restrictions driving mass migration out of Blue cities in general and SoCal in particular) for a speculative bubble, causing an avoidable Great Recession. With one exception (failing to approve rapid antigen tests for COVID-19 fast enough or to approve sufficiently many competing manufacturers to make them cheap), all the other serious, unambiguous mistakes seem to be downstream of those two. The botched rollout of healtcare.gov was the most embarrassing mistake, but it turned out to be orders of magnitude less expensive than Iraq or housing.

If we include Federal, State and local government failure then my list looks like (order is a guess):

  1. NIMBYism and the attempts to obfuscate the damage it is doing.
  2. Reversing the Bratton/Giuliani era reforms to policing that had successfully reduced both crime and incarceration.
  3. Iraq
  4. The US's worst-in-class COVID response, getting both more deaths and more practical damage from restrictions that any other rich country. Most of the mistakes were not federal, which is why it is lower down the previous list. Apart from the lack of rapid antigen tests, key severe, unambiguous mistakes are keeping elementary schools closed after it became clear Zoom school wasn't working and elementary school age children weren't spreading the virus, retaining outdoor restrictions after it became clear the virus mostly spread indoors, and retaining any restrictions at all after the most vulnerable groups were vaccinated.
  5. Bush Jr's FEMA, Gov Landrieu, and Mayor Nagin collectively botching the response to Hurricane Katrina.

with the Bozo the Clown award for the most hilariously stupid, most total, most humiliating failure that doesn't make the list because the cost wasn't high enough going to CAHSR.

There is one I would add to the list, but I think most people would see it as a partisan issue rather than a clear mistake - Merrick Garland slow-walking the prosecution of Donald Trump for the events leading up to January 6. If the indictment drops a year earlier - critically, before Trump was the presumptive Republican nominee - then the ridiculous New York false accounting case never happens, nor does the Section 3 disqualification litigation, both sides (and SCOTUS) have an incentive to get through the immunity litigation faster (because Trump can't delay the trial beyond election day) so either Trump is ruled immune or the case goes to trial before the first primaries, the partisan temperature around the case is generally lower, and if Trump is convicted then the Republican Party has an open primary to find a non-felonious nominee. I think all three possible outcomes (Trump convicted, Trump acquitted, Trump conclusively ruled immune by SCOTUS) are better for the health of American democracy than what we got.

The distinction between "there was a massacre of Christians and Alawites" and "there was a massacre of Alawites in which a small number of Christians were collateral damage" is precisely the sort of question a functioning MSM (which we mostly don't have) would be able to answer but the developing alternatives do not - because the MSM was able to put a known-trustworthy journalist in the field and do actual shoe-leather journalism. Social media amplifies the kinds of anecdote that the algorithm expects to go viral in a way which means you have no idea of the relative frequency of different events, even when this is immediately obvious to someone on the ground.

It was also a failed state and didn't control its territory - Chiang and Mao are fighting each other before the Japanese surrender.

which all told, and given the circumstances Ukraine is in, are actually pretty generous.

The written deal on offer at that meeting, to the best of our knowledge, was that Zelenskyy signs a mineral deal which in expectation transfers value from Ukraine to the US, and gets nothing in return. Trump was explicitly not offering any kind of security guarantee or military assistance, and can't offer a ceasefire because negotiations between Trump and Putin are still at the talking-about-talks stage. Zelenskyy had successfully negotiated the negative economic EV of the deal down to a de minimis level, and was in Washington to sign a mostly-irrelevant mineral deal as a confidence-building measure.

Assuming all parties were acting sensibly rather than having a destructive snit, something happened immediately before or during the press conference that made it clear that the mineral deal - or rather the as yet unwritten deal that the mineral deal was a confidence-building step towards - didn't work. And it is fairly obvious what that disagreement was. The two key negative turning points are when Trump asks Zelenskyy to come out in favour of a ceasefire (Zelenskyy is quite properly unwilling to do anything that reads as committing to support a US-negotiated ceasefire until he knows what it might look like) while Zelenskyy asks Trump to promise further military support against Russia if Russia misbehaves (which Trump has made clear he doesn't want to do). The disagreement is that Trump sees the end goal as Ukraine agreeing to a ceasefire negotiated between the US and Russia, and Zelenskyy sees the end goal as changing the balance of power such that Russia might plausibly agree to a ceasefire on reasonable terms.

either long ago (the US civil war) or far away (russio-japanese)

From the perspective of the Europeans making the decisions that led to WW1, the US civil war was further away than the Russo-Japanese war - losing the Russo-Japanese war had been a real threat to the regime in a European Great Power, which is the sort of thing that attracts attention.

Today, the only result of granting the Afghans citizenship would have been that all of them moved to the US. The same thing can’t really work. The crime in Iraq, by the way, was siding with the Shias, something many intelligent analysts warned Cheney and Rumsfeld about. It was possible to purge the Baathists and yet maintain a minority-rule Sunni power structure (they tend to be more competent than Shiites in Iraq, certainly militarily) with some token Shiite representation, and that’s what should have been done. (Not that I supported that war, but if it had to happen…)

Siding with the Shia turned out to be necessary to create an Iraq that would not tolerate Al-Quaeda (or ISIS) operating in its territory. Baathism was living on borrowed time by 2001 (it was originally a product of the Cold War) and even if you could have found a more compliant Baathist strongman to replace Saddam, the US lacked the skills to do so. The only other Sunni-aligned political faction that was able and willing to violently suppress the Shia were the jihadis.

The fundamental strategic stupidity of the Iraq war was that there were three anti-American factions in the Middle East (Baathism, Salafi jihadism, and the Shia fundamentalism of Iran). But they weren't an Axis of Evil - they hated (and still hate) each other more than they hated America (but not as much as they hated Israel). Invading Iraq involved taking on all three simultaneously instead of defeating them in detail.

It seems a lot less destabilizing if "I deserve this territory because our leader founded the cities" and "my nationality inhabits the place" is preferred to "I have this ideology and I want to spread it".

That's as may be, but it was destabilising enough to cause World War II, where Hitler's stated casus belli was precisely protecting the rights of ethnic Germans outside the internationally recognised borders of Germany.

You do not want to reopen all the historical grievances over European borders.

Who made the rule that 'annexing territory is uniquely bad'?

The victorious Allies at the end of WW2 (notionally including the USSR, although they partially ratted). At the time we made this rule, our armies and those of our client states controlled essentially the whole world except China (which was a failed state).

Where was it agreed that you can have a war to install a puppet government but not annex? Would it be OK if Putin just set up more puppet governments, more people's republics like Donetsk and Luhansk? No, obviously not.

The rules don't allow you to have a war to install a puppet government - although arguably they did allow you to have a war to reinstall a pre-existing puppet government that had been overthrown by its own people. The US invasion of Iraq was against the rules - this was not controversial at the time. The people claiming it was within the rules were lying about WMDs in order to protect Tony Blair's domestic position, but the key players in the Bush administration wanted to set a precedent that the rules no longer applied and the US could use its superior military power to do what it wanted.

The exact same people were bitching before Russia annexed those people's republics and after, they'd just find different words.

Russia has been establishing client states inside the internationally recognised borders of other countries since long before the Euromaiden and DPR/LPR. Transnistria was carved out of Moldova in 1990, Artsakh out of Azerbijan (by Armenia with Russian support, rather than Russia directly) in 1991, South Ossetia out of Georgia in 1992, and Abkhazia out of Georgia in 199. The 2008 Russo-Georgian war was triggered by a Georgian attempt to reconquer South Ossetia and Abkhazia, which is why "Who was the aggressor?" is a scissor.

If "We respect the currently-existing internationally recognised boundaries of sovereign states" is a foundational principle of the so-called rules-based international order (and it is - it is essential to the peace of Europe given the artificial nature of borders in eastern Europe) then Russia has been violating it since as soon as post-Soviet Russia was a functioning state.

Agreed as regards Western Europe - we have our own liberal and leftist political traditions which don't grok American progressivism and which American progressives grok even less. We also have our own idiotarian left tradition which has unthinkingly imported American progressivism without applying it to local conditions - but this has a lot less pull than people insist it does, and essentially none at all in France. But American progressives have tried to shame countries for insufficient progressivism - it just doesn't work.

When I pointed out the lack of US progressive bullying of Japan over insufficient progressivism (and there are obvious targets re. the role of women, immigration, outcaste treatment of barakumin) I realise I was implicitly comparing it to the bullying of mostly third-world countries over feminism, LGBFAGMORON, etc.

which is driven by rural and religious attitudes, not shitty neighborhoods.

This is a distinction without a difference. Rural areas that are not subsidised by commuters/retirees who make money in the city and spend it in the country are poor, have crap amenities other than access to nature because of the high cost of proving them in remote areas, and preferentially retain dumber people. The first two of these points have been true for a long time (since before 1900 in the UK, probably around 1950 in the USA), the third since time immemorial (idiot and pagan are derived from Greek and Latin slurs for country bumpkins respectively).

There has been very limited attempts by American progressives to attack Japanese culture. There were coerced changes to Japanese culture immediately after WW2, but they were bipartisan (MacArthur was profoundly not a progressive - he would be fired by a Dem president for being based in an insubordinate way and would have been McCarthy's running mate if McCarthy had managed to run for president).

But since the end of the US occupation, the only attempt by US progressives to shame Japan for insufficient progressivism was when right-wing Japanese politicians started publicly paying respect to the memory of various controversial WW2-era Japanese leaders.

Despite having been consistently aware of the current thing since the 1990's, I don't know anything about the LGBXYZSNORE situation in Japan without looking it up, indicating that it has not been the current thing in my lifetime.

Interesting question - is this an unprincipled exception or is it just a case of Japanese internal affairs not being on the radar?

Hybrids are also a straightforwardly superior technology to pure-play ICE for pretty much every use case except long-haul freeway driving. They're not backyard-maintainable, but nor are modern ICEs. (And the backyard-maintainable ICEs of the late C20 were so polluting that in a world where alternatives exist, they really shouldn't be allowed in cities or suburbs).

I still miss those illegal German diesel engines that cheated the emissions tests though. Performance competitive with petrol, and you could get from London to well past Edinburgh on one tank of diesel.

Tangentially, in USA it seems that the prime thing a regular man fears about prison is ass-rape. In Russia, everybody knows that ass-rape in prisons is reserved for the underclass, such as faggots.

My understanding is that being gay on the outside was merely one of many ways you could become a petukh in Russian prisons. Online accounts agree that the local vor could declare any inmate to be a petukh based on broadly subjective grounds like "not defending his honour" or "behaving dishonorably towards another inmate" and that once you were raped once your status as a petukh was unambiguous across the whole prison system.

I thought one of the main purposes of property registration regimes - including car titles - was certainty around liens. If the car is titled in Trimble, a lien against it in Trimble should be valid regardless of where the owner lives. Anything else leads to an absurdity, as the instant case demonstrates.

I completely agree, for me that book diminished the characters of both Bean and especially Ender, gutted the emotional impact of Ender's journey, and twisted the entire narrative of Ender's Game into a lame-assed Xanatos-style manipulation by proxy. Weak.

Doesn't Ender think that the plot of Ender's Game constitutes him being the victim of lame-assed Xanatos-style manipulation by proxy? The setup for the Speaker/Xenocide/Children trilogy is Ender's struggle to atone for/undo the xenocide he was the unwitting tool of.