MadMonzer
If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your
No bio...
User ID: 896
The modern concept of asylum originates immediately after WW2, and the way it developed in the first ten years or so when the system actually functioned as intended was as permanent resettlement for refugees who couldn't go home because their home country had either ceased to exist as a result of the war, or had a new government who didn't want them back.
Skimming the opinions, Barrett writes the dissent joined by the three liberals (is this a common lineup? I thought Barrett was normally more libertarian than Roberts) and has the better of it if you treat it as a straightforward statutory interpretation case. The majority are right that this could lead to an absurdity (although it doesn't seem to in the instant case - if the facts are as stated then in this case the poor water quality was caused by San Francisco discharging sewage.) But the Constitution gives Congress the power to pass bad laws, and I think Barrett is right that in this case they did.
Unlikely. Trump loves the kayfabe.
At this point, sending troops to the Mexican border is kayfabe. The Biden-era problem wasn't that the government wasn't catching illegal immigrants - it was catching them and releasing them because the process for working out what to do with them was slashdotted. If you credibly threaten to speedy-deport the latest wave of border-jumpers, or to throw them in the oubliette while the immigration judges work through the backlog, then they stop coming. Have stopped coming, even.
The work of Ha-Joon Chang has convinced me that
- Most (but not all - in particular Hong Kong didn't) of the Asian development success stories relied on smart industrial policy rather than laissez-faire
- Depending on what your industrial policy is, tariffs are often a useful tool to execute it.
But there doesn't seem to be an industrial policy behind the Trump tariffs - in the sense that I can't work out which industries Trump wants to promote and which he doesn't.
There is a separate problem that development-orientated industrial policy is impossible when you are at the technological frontier because the knowledge you need to think about the economy ten years out simply doesn't exist. Whereas if you are trying to go third-world to first quickly you know that you start with textiles because everyone does, do car parts before cars, don't do aerospace or semiconductors until you are ready etc.
The even thornier problem is that the supply chain for high-end semiconductors appears to be too big and complex for one country, even the US or EU, to host a full-stack semiconductor industry. Right now ARM, TSMC, ASML and Zeiss are all close-to-irreplaceable in their niches.
My dear chap, I’d say it’s much more common amongst the British, having seen in the City more than one investment banking intern or junior humiliated for the wrong kind of shoe or wearing a shirt with a breast pocket (or even, on one occasion, wearing a pocket square).
My old bean, if a British merchant banker brought his pet monkey to the office to watch the juniors try making small talk with it, the monkey would be wearing a suit.
True - I'm at work so I can't watch the video, and assumed the smoke alarm was in a government office.
I think the chance of Trump and Musk making a serious attempt to do something like this is about 60% (being deliberately vague about the meaning of serious attempt) and if they my wild-ass guess outcome prediction is:
- 40% Truss/Sunak level incompetence means that the administration loses the support it needs to do something like this
- 30% Success
- 20% Failure because institutions are more robust than I thought.
- 10% Failure because Musk and Trump fall out with each other and Musk blows Trump up Cummings v Johnson style
As I have long said, the only real test is immigration.
Unfortunately, the test that matters is the 2028 election, and by the time you get there it is too late. Think about Trump's first term - whichever side wins and gets to write the history, the main thing that gets written about will be the disputed 2020 election. (The pandemic response will be glossed over because the events that happened, in particular the Trump administration being much more Covidian than the MAGA base wanted it to be, don't fit into either side's preferred narrative).
the type of people incapable of replacing a smoke alarm battery
Genuine question - do we know if this is that people are incapable of replacing the smoke alarm battery, or if they are not allowed to by a union work rule?
Trump has shitposted that he could use the Insurrection Act to send troops into Blue cities to arrest illegal immigrants. If illegal immigration is legally an "invasion", there is no reason why the power to fight the invaders doesn't extend to anywhere you can find them.
I still don't think that Trump is going to make a serious attempt at establishing permanent one-party rule. What would be the play, exactly?
- Centralise power in the President through impoundment authority, unitary executive doctrine, subordinating Senate-confirmed Cabinet members to informally-appointed advisers like Elon Musk etc. This is being done, and appears to be succeeding. The Constitutional limit is the counterveiling power of Congress and the Courts. The inbuilt rural bias in the Senate means that Trump could be as popular as Jeffrey Epstein and the Democrats would still struggle to get to 60 seats - with reasonable effort by the administration by 2026 we will be in a world where the only tool a Democratic Congress with say 300 Reps and 59 senators has to oppose the President is to shut down the government. It looks like Trump is already floating a trial balloon about ignoring SCOTUS on the USAID impoundment case.
- Establish politically reliable, centralised tools of violent repression. Purge the officer corps and FBI leadership. Invoke the Insurrection Act on some spurious pretext so that troops can be deployed to Blue cities. The point isn't to go full brownshirt before 2028 - it is to establish escalation dominance to ensure that the next step goes smoothly.
- End competitive elections for the Presidency. There are at least two really obvious ways to do this: the constitutional one is for sufficiently many purple states with Republican state legislatures who are voter-immune due to gerrymandering to switch to legislative appointment of presidential electors. The strongman one is for the outgoing VP to ignore the 2022 Electoral Count Reform Act (saying it is unconstitutional), to count the electoral votes himself, and to disqualify enough electoral votes based on bad-faith allegations of fraud to declare the losing candidate the winner. This part of the playbook was written down by Eastman, Trump tried to run it in 2020, and a willingness to run it in 2028 was a requirement for Vance to be considered for the VP slot.
- Use the normal populist-authoritarian playbook to consolidate power (Orban and Erdogan are the best modern examples) - use process-is-the-punishment lawsuits to drive uncucked media out of business, withhold funding from State and local governments who don't play ball, establish an regulatory anarcho-tyranny for medium and large businesses such that a company which pays Danegeld to the Party doesn't need permission to do things and a company that doesn't can't get it, selectively prosecute regime opponents for three-felonies-a-day bullshit, selectively refuse to prosecute regime allies for political violence such that opponents are not physically safe, in general try to make conspicuous sycophancy a pre-requisite for career advancement in as many domains as possible.
We can argue whether Trump was joking when he said he wanted to be a dictator, override the constitution, arrest insufficiently loyal Republican congressmen etc. but he did say it. You say "What would be the play?" but the plays have been very publicly called. The points above are all things Trump has said he will do, is doing (or tried to do last time in the case of 3), and has retained the support of the GOP in the country while doing. The case that democracy is safe basically comes down to "Trump would never say a Democratic election victory is fraudulent unless it really was fraudulent." (which is obviously false given his record) and "The guardrails that held in 2020 will still hold after Trump has had spent four years deliberately undermining them." (which is rather optimistic, unless there is a Dem landslide in the 2026 midterms or Trump manages to lose GOP support through some piece of shocking incompetence).
I agree with you that Trump is probably not going to pull the above playbook off by himself, but Musk is clearly extraordinarily competent, and appears to be on board with it. Giving betting odds on how likely all this is to actually happen is hard, because under the most likely scenario there won't be a "mask off" moment that the bet can settle against unless the Democratic candidate wins the 2028 election by more than the margin of Bush v Gore style shenanigans and Vance overturns it anyway.
Globally, presidential autogolpes are the usual failure mode of presidential democracy. From an international perspective, the surprising thing is that it hasn't happened in the US already. (There were close shaves under Lincoln and FDR).
Causing the rather odd situation that almost everyone perjures themselves in the citizenship oath. The oath still includes "I absolutely and entirely renounce and abjure all allegiance and fidelity to any foreign prince, potentate, state, or sovereignty" but the law no longer requires new citizens to actually do that, and most don't.
Do you even need to go that far? As I understand it, they could simply say "Their citizenship was not guaranteed by the constitution, but it was not banned and we already chose to grant it"
But you didn't. The statute granting citizenship to Americans born in the US uses identical wording to the 14th amendment. And the statute can't be changed by executive order either. If "subject to the jurisdiction thereof" does exclude children of illegal immigrants, then Trump signed an executive order ordering the Department of State to continue issuing passports to non-citizens born before the date of the order. There are also non-citizens with passports, SSNs, etc, and a lot of citizens who no longer have documentary proof of citizenship.
If Trump and Eastman are correct about the meaning of "subject to the jurisdiction thereof" then the government has been misapplying the law for decades and the resulting mess requires urgent Congressional action to fix. Cynically, the executive order is a trial balloon to get the constitutionality of the whole thing in front of SCOTUS quickly and they are planning to do the work of abolishing birthright citizenship properly once they know it won't be thrown out.
The specific subset of lying referred to in the KJV as "bearing false witness against thy neighbour" is a particularly grievous sin. Falsely stating that a friendly country has been overtaken by drug cartels qualifies. I'm at work so I don't have time to look up the specific punishments in Dante, and in any case Trump plans to be in the reserved front row seating for Nobel Peace Laureates, so he will be closer to the Fire than Dante suggests.
In the highly likely event that Trump cares not a jot for his immortal soul, there is also the point that the US-Canada relationship is nonzero sum. The Trump administration presumably has some kind of good outcome in mind which requires mutual cooperation. Telling gratuitous lies makes that harder, both because it signals bad faith (up to and including outright malice) and because it makes it harder for the other side to work out what you actually want (hence this thread).
Well, the Beer Hall Putsch didn’t get traction,
Also the Kapp Putsch, but that got even less traction.
Napoleon deposed the Directory to become Emperor in the first place. The Hundred Days don’t count because it was a constitutional monarchy and hadn’t even managed to dismantle his imperial institutions. I’d also give Napoleon III half credit for couping himself.
Napoleon was still under arms when he couped the Directory. Napoleon III never served (except briefly leading from the front as Commander-in-Chief), so it wasn't a military coup.
Whoever comes home from the war will end up controlling the governments of Europe.
Has anything like this ever happened in the real world? (Starship Troopers describes something like this, but is fiction) The specific case of "demobbed soldiers stage a coup, against a democracy" hasn't had many chances to happen because democracies don't fight on that scale very often, and as far as I aware has never happened.
There are plenty of cases of "successful army stages a coup led by its generals while still under arms" (this is basically all of Roman history after the Marian reforms), but I don't think there has been one against a democracy - Tom Holland in Rubicon argues that the reason why the Roman Republic became vulnerable to coups was because the Marian reforms changed the social composition of the army such that most soldiers were too poor to have a meaningful voice in the Centuriate Assembly (which elected the consuls, and was originally set up with the specific intention of overweighting veteran votes).
I agree the Battle of Athens comes close, but it was an uprising against a blatantly rigged election, with the victory condition being "find and publicly count the hidden ballots". I do not think something like the Battle of Athens happens in a working democracy - not least because under normal circumstances the loyalties of returning veterans would be divided between existing political factions.
Thinking about it, the nearest example is probably the October Revolution in Russia - the Bolshevik's power base was the enlisted soldiers in the Petrograd garrison.
Elon is de facto a high-ranking executive branch official. He was described by a supporter in the thread on the "five things this week" e-mail as deputy CEO of the US executive branch, and wants to be seen as such internally. The norm against governments (as opposed to private citizens or political parties) interfering in foreign elections absolutely applies to him.
The exchanges (mostly of backroom staff) between the US Democrats and UK Labour party on the one hand, and the US Republicans and UK Conservative party on the other, have been going on unobjectionably since at least the Reagan/Thatcher era. 2024 is slightly different in that the MAGA Republicans prefer to work with Reform, which didn't have the infrastructure in place to do such exchanges party-to-party so they ended up in effect working with Farage personally. The outrage on the right was (while real) both clueless and entirely hypocritical. The claim @FirmWeird is making that Starmer started something is straightforwardly false.
I remember at the time that the British Deep State used sympathetic media to grumble about the unusual level of support John Major's Conservative party gave to Bush Sr's failed 1992 re-election campaign and worrying that the Clinton administration would be hostile to the UK as a result. They weren't - they returned the favour by helping Blair in 1997, and in turn that didn't affect the ability of the Blair and Bush Jr administrations to cooperate after 9-11. We used to be able to distinguish between party-to-party and government-to-government interactions - I think that stopped when US partisanship got so bitter that the idea that a politician could speak for the country in a non-partisan way became quaint.
The norm that private citizens don't interfere in foreign elections, or that political parties qua voluntary political associations don't interfere in foreign elections might be a good one, but it isn't a norm that actually exists. There is a norm that incumbent executive branch officials don't interfere in foreign elections, and it is a good one (and should probably be extended to backbench legislators). But even that tends to fall apart when one country's perceived-existential issue is another country's partisan controversy - as with Ukraine supporting the party that doesn't want to hand it over to Russia, or previously with Netanyahu's 2015 speech to Congress (explicitly co-ordinated with Congressional Republicans as an attack on the Obama administration) against the Iran nuclear deal. I'm sure we are going to see Canadian politicians attacking the Trump tariffs in ways which they see as standing up for the Canadian national interest and American Republicans see as partisan interference on behalf of the Democrats.
The other problem is that social media context collapse means that people don't always bellyfeel that they are getting involved in foreign politics when they poast about something that shows up in their timeline in the same way a domestic political item would.
Metric fucktonne, surely?
Reform) An American fuckton
[The US ton is 2000 pounds whereas the imperial ton is 2240 pounds, almost exactly equal to a metric tonne. I think Reform would reduce immigration if they got in, but by a lot less than they promise to. I agree that the Tories wouldn't.]
I think not wearing a suit in a place other people are expected to wear one is usually a performative flex ("You can't enforce your petty dress code on a Man of Destiny like myself".) and therefore disrespectful to the host, though mildly so. This is obfuscated by the fact that western PMC norms are not to publicly dress-code people, but to quietly tut-tut behind their backs and freeze them out of mutually beneficial interactions in the future.
In the case of Musk, it was a performative minor humiliation of the rest of the Cabinet by Trump with Musk being the tool ("You have to obey the rules but he doesn't because I am the Boss and I say he is specialer than you.") - my impression of US business culture is that some form of performative minor humiliation at the start of a new job is common and expected among the kind of people who have broadly positive memories of fraternity hazing - but doing it in public is trashy.
Obama did nothing to deserve the prize, but most people think he wasn't actively evil in the way that Arafat, Adams, Tho etc. were - they did less than nothing to deserve a Peace Prize. He is only "similarly undeserving" to them if you actually think he is evil, which MAGA Americans mostly do and the rest of us don't.
Why do you think Putin is demonstrating willingness to make peace in a way which goes beyond the default? He has always been happy to discuss terms on which Ukraine might surrender - and neither Putin nor Trump has made any public statements that suggest Putin would accept a reasonable peace deal, even a temporary ceasefire on the current front line.
One of the reasons why I am suspicious of Trump's motives here is that he is generally acting as if the key fact about the path to peace is that there is already an offer of a deal from the Russian side which preserves Ukrainian sovereignty in the territory Ukraine currently controls, and the reason why the war continues is that Zelensky is unwilling to accept it. This simply isn't true. Someone needs to bring Russia to the table as well as Ukraine, and Trump consistently talks and acts as if this is not the case. The model of Trump where his words and actions make sense given his goals is one where he thinks the best achievable outcome is a Ukrainian surrender with minimal additional bloodshed.
I find Trump's desire to win a Nobel Peace Prize (if he does, indeed, want one - all I have seen on this point is speculation) truly bizarre. For as long as I can remember American conservatives (and Tom Lehrer and others from the more cynical left) have mocked the Peace Prize based on the wickedness of some of the most famous laureates.
I personally believe that Donald Trump has already well and truly earned his place in the illustrious company of Yasser Arafat, Gerry Adams, Le Duc Tho etc. (I assume MAGA supporters would throw in the EU, Kofi Annan and Barack Obama as similarly undeserving cases.) But I don't see why he would be making an effort to have this fact publicly recognised.
Heck, Kamala lost, but the coalition she tried to throw together was certainly some odd bedfellows, like Liz and Dick Cheney.
In a world where one side is MAGA, the coalition-defining message of the other side is "America is basically okay and can continue to get better incrementally, so cleansing her with fire and the sword would be really fucking stupid." Biden was able to articulate that message while he still had a functioning brain. Harris tried and failed to.

Sierra Leone is less genetically homogenous than other similar-sized African countries because it is where the British released the slaves seized by the West Africa Squadron. This points against a genetic basis.
More options
Context Copy link