@MadMonzer's banner p

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

				

User ID: 896

MadMonzer

If you're talking to me, my preferred pronouns are you/your

4 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 06 23:45:01 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 896

It's not that low wage jobs on a CV are a problem - even now an elite university or graduate employer would rather see "worked at McDonalds" than "sat at home playing Fortnite" - it's that paid work is a much smaller positive than more socially prestigious unpaid activities you could be doing instead. And one-marshmallow-eaters optimise for the future value of the CV, not for disposable income in the present.

Also meritocratic competition for upper-middle class teens and young adults is far more intense than it was back in the day. Given that you don't need the money, working in a McJob when your competition are polishing their Ivy League applications with extracurriculars/building a list of public GitHub commits/using unpaid internships to network into cool jobs is loser behaviour.

If there was an expectation among elite colleges and suchlike that a well-rounded upper-middle class upbringing included paid work then this would be different, but I don't think it ever was. Paid holiday jobs were common for upper-middle class kids in my social circle back in the day because it was worth it - the amount you could earn in a McJob was a lot more than the amount of pocket money it was socially acceptable for an upper-middle class family to give a teenager. But the ones who spent their summers travelling weren't seeing as doing anything wrong, just as regrettably broke once they got to University.

It isn't a forecast at all - it is a nowcast. It is the Fed's best estimate of what is happening right now, but won't be officially reported until Q1 GDP comes out at the end of April (provisionally) and late June (as a final official number). The numbers are annualised quarterly numbers, so a 5 percentage point shift in growth means that (if the nowcast is correct) the economy is, right now, 1 1/4% smaller than predicted.

DOGE has fired about 35,000 people so far who won't have new jobs yet. In addition, about 75,000 workers are on the payroll but not working because they took the 8-month buyout, and 10,000 are locked out at USAID. That means 120,000 former government employees are no longer contributing to GDP. There are 133 million full-time workers in the US, so ~0.1 percentage points of the 1.2 point drop is due to government cuts.

There is for raw materials, which is what Canada exports.

Or, to cut the crap, the US goal is a quick Ukrainian surrender and Russian victory. This will get the dead bodies off Trump's TV set. (There will still be dead bodies as Russia genocides the Ukrainian population of the territory they occupy, but the Russians won't allow the media to report on them).

long as there is a thin sliver of land left between poland and russia as a buffer

If that is a US goal (or even if it isn't), they won't get it. A core Russian war aim is to turn Ukraine into a client state. Belarus doesn't work as a buffer between Russia and Poland, and a Putin-controlled Ukraine won't work either for the same reason. A neutral buffer state (pre-WW1 Belgium is the classic example) works because both sides understand that violating it's neutrality is kicking off the big one. Trump is committed to the idea that Russian violations of future-Ukraine's neutrality should not be a casus belli for the US.

Also postwar political violence in the South meant that the 1876 Presidential election could not be counted. Hayes was not chosen as POTUS over Tilden as the result of votes being cast and counted, but because a botched Democratic scheme to bribe the neutral chair of the Electoral Commission led to him resigning.

The US elections that happened in the worst security situation were the 1862 midterms. I haven't found any detailed account of how they were run.

I think 'hold on to power' can be equivocated with 'hold onto life'. If he takes a bad peace deal (even if necessary or forced to do so) there's a good chance he'll be dead within a year.

Zelensky has had numerous opportunities to bug out, starting on day 1 of the invasion. If he wanted to bug out and surrender tomorrow, the Trump administration would help him do it, because that achieves their goals in Ukraine. He could just have told a suitably senior aide that he didn't want to go back to Ukraine.

I do not think the ultranationalist opposition in Ukraine is powerful enough to whack Zelensky outside Ukraine. OTOH the Russians are, and might be daft enough to try.

Arresting draft dodgers is completely normal behaviour, even in peacetime. And every country has had enough draft dodgers that if Twitter had existed there would have been enough material to make pictures of draft dodgers being arrested go viral.

It is electing draft dodgers President that is the exception, dear Americans. (This isn't a partisan dig - the Dems, GOPe and MAGA are all guilty)

The relevant question is not "Is the number of draft dodgers greater than zero?" It is "Are there significantly more draft dodgers in 2020s Ukraine than in other democracies at war?" And unfortunately any reliable statistics that exist on that point have not been published. But the battlefield performance of the Ukrainian army profoundly doesn't look like the textbook examples of an American client state army who doesn't want to fight (e.g. South Vietnam, Iraq, Afghanistan).

The original Christmas BMJ parachute metanalysis that the linked 2018 paper is satirising is also a classic of the genre, although now unfortunately paywalled. Magic internet points to anyone who has a pirate link.

Most foreign spies operate under diplomatic cover - rule 1 of Cold War era intrigue is that the Soviet military attache is a spy. So they get expelled rather than prosecuted if caught, and their children don't get citizenship as children of diplomats.

British food does not deserve the reputation it gets, but it got that reputation on top of wartime rationing because British used to take a quiet pride in maintaining a stiff upper lip at things being shit and being grateful for what they're given.

Also that Britain (alongside Belgium and the Netherlands, which do not exactly have a reputation for fine dining) industrialised and urbanised before refrigeration, which means that we went through a long period where most of the population did not have access to fresh food.

Unfortunately that offer is only good for pigeons.

The UK, as a sovereign state, has the right to exclude any non-citizen it wants, for any reason. (In some cases we would need to withdraw from treaties like the Refugee Convention or the European Convention on Human Rights to do so legally, but treaties have exit clauses).

I just did, from a UK IP, using a weak pseudonym.

Seriously, the UK establishment doesn't have a brief to protect Nigel Farage or Melanie Phillips. If it was illegal to say the things they are saying, they would be arrested. The UK hate speech laws require the speech to be "threatening, abusive, or insulting" as well as discriminatory against a protected group, so if you are polite and don't insult identifiable individuals you are not breaking the law. I don't support these laws, but I don't support foreigners lying about them either.

In the context of the recent riots, the much bigger difference is that the US has an unusually high bar for substantive incitement charges (which carry much higher sentences than hate speech charges) - if you poast "There are asylum seekers at 10 Acacia Avenue. Wouldn't it be a pity if someone burned the place down?" from your mother's basement and someone you never met who read the post does, in fact, burn down 10 Acacia Avenue then you are likely to be convicted of incitement to commit arson in the UK, but this would probably be 1st-amendment protected in the US.

Investigating "non-crime hate incidents" is stupid and the police should stop doing it, but the operative part is "non-crime" - none of the stories you hear about them involve someone being arrested, prosecuted, locked up etc.

EOP staffers are, in general, not "Officers of the United States" - nothing they do legally matters except in so far as it results in a signed order crossing the Resolute Desk - legally, even the White House Chief of Staff is just an Assistant to the President. (The use of the Presidential autopen complicates this a bit, but that is the principle). The EOP staff who can do things on their own authority (like the head of the OMB, who has an official role in the process of signing off CFR regulations) are Senate-confirmed.

The "inferior officers" clause in the Constitution requires Congressional action - by default all Officers of the United States are Senate-confirmable, but Congress can by law exempt inferior officers. So if someone is acting as an Officer, they either need to be Senate-confirmed, or appointed to a specific "inferior office" created by Congress.

So the question is whether either the de facto head of @DOGE (i.e. Elon Musk) or the administrator of the United States DOGE service (i.e. Amy Gleason) is acting as an Officer of the United States, rather than an assistant. Telling a Senate-confirmed agency head, "You should fire these people/cancel these contracts or I will tattle on you to POTUS." is not acting as an Officer. Breaking leases and cancelling contracts on his own authority probably would be. Signing cheques for the Treasury (or modern equivalent) is definitely acting as an Officer. If, as has been alleged in numerous places, DOGE is overriding the decisions of departments with Senate-confirmed heads about how Congressionally-appropriated funds are spent, then that is an Office and the person who does it is an Officer, and the Appointments Clause is being violated because neither Musk nor Gleason nor anyone else in DOGE has been confirmed as an Officer by the Senate, or appointed to an inferior office established by Congress.

For 1, I also want to ask what costs of living are like in each place, because that is as relevant as your salary.

The difference in material standards of living between the UK and the USA is real, and large, particularly for the upper-middle class, and within the upper-middle class particularly for doctors and programmers. But this is obfuscated by the fact that the consumption bundle of an upper-middle-class suburban Londoner (which includes low-crime, low-filth walkable urbanism) is close to unavailable at any price in the US and the consumption bundle of an upper-middle-class suburban American (which includes one light-duty commercial vehicle per adult used as personal transport) is taxed into oblivion in the UK.

I'm strongly concerned about technological unemployment, and the US is one of the countries that is most capable of weathering the storm without too much social disruption. This isn't something that can be taken for granted, but it has a much better manufacturing base than the UK does, and is far wealthier overall.

I find this surprising. The US seems to me to be in an unusually weak position to handle technological unemployment in that:

  • One side of the political fence is opposed to a redistributive welfare state in principle, and has a particular hate-on for unemployed working-age adults. The best the GOP is likely to offer the technologically unemployed is deliberately unpleasant make-work jobs.
  • The US has a worse-than-average fiscal position compared to other rich countries, and a political system (Presidential democracy with separation of powers) which obfuscates responsibility for fixing it.

I personally endorse all of these, so I wouldn't be worried about some kind of test of American Values. Hell, the fact that the UK lacks these is a driving reason behind my desire to treat it like a temporary pitstop.

The "life in the UK" test (which is our equivalent of the US civics test, but harder) is hilarious on this point. The test was brought in by Labour in 2002, so the original version included a whole load of woke questions like "What year did women get the vote?" or "How do you report your employer for discrimination?" and then the Tories replaced most of them with "right-wing" questions like "Who wrote Rule Britannia?"

This demonstrates two problems:

  • Countries can't always agree on what their values actually are except on an "I know it when I see it" basis. In the US this mostly comes down to "Was the New Deal a betrayal of American values, or the fulfillment of them?"
  • You can't test values with a pencil-and-paper test - you just test ability and willingness to cram for the test.

It's a huge system with a ton of rot that is essentially a preview of what would happen with single payor in the U.S.

The VA isn't just a single-payer system - it's a "fully socialised" - i.e. single-payer, single-provider system. Among 1st-world countries, only the UK, Denmark and (for the publicly-subsidised part of their system) Singapore do this. Medicare is a single-payer, multiple-provider system as are the national healthcare systems (also called Medicare) in Canada and Australia. Canada goes further and bans most self-paid top-up care, something very few countries do (and in particular the UK and Australia don't).

All serious proposals I have seen for single-payer healthcare in the US are basically Medicare for all. We know what that looks like (Canada or Australia) - it offers a much better patient experience, at a much higher cost to the taxpayer, than the UK NHS.

And not even the Christmas BMJ. I had high hopes after seeing it came out on the 25th, but wrong month.

I remember when Canary Wharf (the secondary London financial district with the skyscrapers, for Americans who don't know) hired a falconer for pigeon control duties. If you decapitate or shoot them you have to kill an awful lot of them before the problem is solved, but pigeons have an innate fear of sparrowhawks and after the first bird-on-bird nomming incident les autres are effectively encouraged.

That said, if you hang around Trafalgar Square you will probably still be fed illegally by tourists.

Of these, I want to look at invading armies in particular. Why are they not subject to jurisdiction?

You can't, under customary international law, prosecute lawful combatants (i.e. enemy soldiers who have a chain of command, wear uniforms etc.) for the normal crimes (murder, arson, unlicensed driving etc.) that they commit in the course of invading your country. I'm not aware of this being documented in any treaty, but it is a very old rule, and it is a background assumption of things like the protection for PoWs in the Geneva Conventions.

Hence invading armies are not subject to the jurisdiction.

You can't take the temperature on a site that shows you an algorithmically-curated selection of what is being posted. It just tells you what Musk wants you to see, either for (his) business or (his) pleasure.

Please do not use the word "literally" metaphorically.

There are many people in the UK (Nigel Farage most obviously) who have made a good living out of saying things they insist you are not allowed to say. That is because you are allowed to say those things.

There are still too many things that are illegal to say in the UK, to the point where if you didn't say "literally" I would accept that you were engaging in permissible exaggeration and not argue, but one of them is not "the UK has the right as a sovereign country to exclude net-taxpaying immigrants on cultural grounds". And if it isn't illegal to say, it isn't literally illegal to say.

Continue training in the UK and resign myself to life here. It beats India. This is more or less something I can count on.

You also have the option of completing training in the UK and then moving to a country like Australia that wants to poach British-trained doctors.

And the people most statistically likely to make anti-immigration the core of their politics are Red tribers. Funny that.

The same is true in the UK, except that the UK culture war is more generational than tribal. The people who benefit financially from immigration are homeowning pensioners, who are also the core demographic for anti-immigration politics.

Hardcore immigration opposition is driven by culture, not economics.

When I was taught public speaking in an old-fashioned English private school, this was summed up as "Look up, slow up, speak up."

This remains good advice. When I have to correct colleagues or family members on public speaking, speaking too fast is the problem about 80% of the time.

Listen to the great audio book readers and podcast hosts for exemplars.

Reading bedtime stories to children is remarkably good practice. They switch off if you go monotone. If you get good at it, children remember it to the point where extended family bedtimes get reorganised around your visits.