Skibboleth
It's never 4D Chess
No bio...
User ID: 1226
Maybe it's a redemption arc for murdering a bunch of Korean fishermen?
How did it go from "stop drug smuggling" to "regime overthrow"?
Marco Rubio really wanted to do it, and sold it to Trump as a big dick move.
Good thing that problem only afflicts Them, not Us!
Rather unfortunately, actually. The general illiteracy of even relatively high status conservatives is a major part of the right-wing crank problem. The US could use a serious conservative movement rather than the current crop of grifters and conspiracy theorists.
I am believing my lying eyes. Problem is, people here keep telling me not to, because what I see paints a very unflattering picture of them and their allies.
Why not have public events and take randos off the streets?
You don't want randos off the street. As another commenter mentioned: street randos includes a raft of unserious people (I don't think you actually have a ton motivated young men and women). Plus, with any political organization you have the problem that growing the organization benefits the organization but may not benefit the individuals who currently make up the organization.
much bemoaned the lack of elite human capital
Lack of EHC is an external critique. Most Republican organizers wouldn't agree with it.
You mean the thing that got a couple people on Twitter mad and had virtually no wider play in conworld? Which was discussed (and read) significantly more by liberals?
I feel pretty good about the thesis of cons don't read + right-wingers are okay with corruption as long as it isn't specifically welfare fraud.
If a 23 year old guerilla journalist (who was not particularly rigorous in his methods) was able to blow this up, then why didn't legacy media go after this low hanging fruit?
It took about six seconds of googling to find a NYT article from the end of November, a month before the viral video was released. I think your premise is wrong.
To answer the question "why is it blowing up now?": as Hanania has noted on a number of occasions, conservatives by and large don't read. Neutral tone (or even hostile) print journalism isn't going to catch their attention the way video is, even (especially) if the latter is sloppy. For the administration, it's a useful distraction from their own parade of fraud and corruption scandals and an excuse to do what they want to do anyway. Plus the president is a social media addict.
I have to be honest, this seems like you, personally, have a disdain for Protestantism's decentralization and comparative lack of ritual. Like, yes if Ramaswamy started the Church of Ramaswamy and tried to convince everyone he was a Christian now, everyone would think it was laughably fake and/or he'd lost his mind. But it's not at all clear to me that he'd be taken any less seriously if he became a regular church-going Baptist or Lutheran (e.g.) than a Catholic. Possibly moreso, since the RCC has a reputation for attracting LARPers. Nikki Haley converted from Sikhism to Methodism and as far as I can tell no one significant has called her sincerity into question.
Most business is conducted in committees, but virtually every rep has committee assignments. With 11k representatives, I could easily envision a situation where the vast majority of reps do very little except vote to organize the House and handle constituent issues.
I imagine you'd end up with a house-within-the-house that dealt with the vast majority of business.
house of representatives having 1,000 members
Weak. Return to the original apportionment ratio of 1-30,000. Bring on the Small City of Representatives.
(It would make gerrymandering harder and less impactful, though the dynamics of an 11k member house would be very weird)
Also fun and exciting: raiding an enemy tribe, catching them asleep, slaughtering their fighters, and leading their women and children home in ropes to their new lives as slaves—carrying the remains of their husbands and fathers, already in steaks for the party.
I see Yarvin is once again back to LARPing as a psycho.
Voting is symbolic war.
Political campaigning, much like military campaigning, is 99% tedious and unglamorous shit, and even the exciting bits are quite often exciting in the wrong way. Militaries resolve this by not allowing soldiers to quit (and, often, by not allowing them to refuse to participate). Political parties don't have such tool kits available, so they have to resort to cheap carrots. Which is to say, we already do what Yarvin proposes, just not through an app. Politics, especially local politics, operates heavily on a prestige economy, where you can climb the ladder just by being willing to show up and do boring organizational work.
The problem is that Yarvin is wrong. Most people don't crave this level of political engagement. Trump's big success is with low-propensity voters who are like 50/50 on whether they can be fucked to fill out their entire ballot in presidential election years. Votr^tm badges are not going to persuade them to commit massive amounts of time and effort in political ground game. They want to watch the game, they don't want to be out on the field getting demolished.
An app as an organizing tool would have limited utility, anyway. You could rally the grunts, perhaps, but an open registration tool would be hilariously vulnerable to sabotage and subversion.
instead of continuing to try and make people angry and pissed off, which hasn't worked
It has worked. The problem confronting Trumpism isn't that its supporters aren't motivated. It's
a) they have a ceiling of 51% of the vote, meanwhile about 40% of the country wouldn't piss on them if they were on fire and the marginal Trump voter will desert or stay home once it becomes clear he won't/can't deliver on his fanciful promises.
b) the gaps between their promises, their ideas, and their competence are insurmountable (but that's populism for you).
I think the internet has just been devastating for Protestantism. I don’t really think there are any “serious” Protestants left.
I don't know what you mean by "serious" Protestants. There are clearly plenty of Protestants who are serious about their beliefs. If you mean that Evangelicals are tacky and unintellectual, I won't argue, but I don't see why that would make it unserious (plus, I think the main difference between megachurch evangelicals being tacky and Roman Catholics having ornate gravitas is about 1500 years). I'm also unsure on the role of the internet in this - Evangelicals started on their current trajectory well before the internet. And, of course, Evangelicals are not all American Protestants.
I don't think it's true that Protestantism isn't taken seriously. Rather, Protestantism lacks the centralized hierarchy, unified style guide, and Ancient Traditions^tm of Catholicism and Orthodoxy, which puts it at a disadvantage with people who really like those things. The aesthetics/values/ideas of American Protestantism (especially capital-L Liberal Protestantism) are heavily conflated with general American aesthetics/values/ideas, and, much like American culture as a whole, lives in an eternal present. The power of Catholic identity is not that it is inextricably tied to America, but that it isn't.
Southern Baptist. Evangelicalism as a whole heavily enmeshes Protestant Christianity with a certain flavor of American nationalism.
The efforts by modern Catholic nationalists to insert themselves into the founding ideology of the United States is a weird sort of stolen valor. They were always a small minority, even in the places that were meant to be tolerant of them like Maryland, and American Republicanism was strongly associated from the outset with Protestantism. One of the Intolerable Acts pertained to toleration of Catholics! And, of course, anti-Catholicism flared up again with large scale Catholic immigration in the mid-19th century.
(You can, of course, admit Catholics into the founding mythology, but then you have to admit basically everyone)
Ramaswamy's mistake is backing the wrong horse. The Blue tribe has no shortage of meritocratic strivers (albeit, rarely to the degree of the stereotypical Asian immigrant). By contrast, meritocracy/achievement is not a premiere value for blood-and-soil conservatives, who generally prefer loyalty, hierarchy, and - above all - lineage. Some second gen immigrant with the wrong religion telling them they need to hustle harder is never going to fly.
America as an attainable idea is consistent with the founding meta-principles of the country, but is not really compatible with the present American conservative movement, which is dominated by nativists who view Americanness largely as a function of in-born traits rather than demonstrated values.
Of course, this begs the question, who counts as American? And we end up with the "Heritage American" discourse that has been popping up lately.
"Heritage American" is just the latest formulation of the idea of Real America, which goes back quite a ways under one guise or another. It holds that, white, conservative (and usually rural and uneducated) Christians are the true heart of America. To the extent that you deviate from this prototype, the legitimacy of your participation in American society and politics is questioned or outright rejected.
It's not a coincidence that the idea isn't very coherent. It's often invoked by people who trace their ancestry to Catholic immigrants from the mid-19th century, or by people whose heritage ancestors that give them a claim to special status are people who literally repudiated their allegiance to the United States. The point is not to assemble an intellectually consistent basis for who really counts. That would exclude many, if not most, proponents, and in any event they're not really interested in cutting out some Polish American whose ancestors came in the 1880s as long as he votes the right way. It's to create a fuzzy category that legitimizes the aforementioned idea of Real Americans while avoiding any question of values (which are largely anti-American).
If Vivek moved here, converted to Catholicism
Shouldn't he be converting to, like, Episcopalianism or Presbyterianism or something? Catholicism is the religion of low-skill immigrants trying to replace the founding stock of America.
That has less to do with the immaculate conduct of ICE and more to do with the lawlessness and brutality being the point, whereas ordinary police officers are supposed to maintain public order.
Also, Baghdad Bob-tier denials from DHS, which Trump supporters credulously devour.
There's another very obvious explanation: Democrats don't actually care. The Epstein files are largely a conservative populist fixation, and Dems really only got interested when they realized it might be a wedge between Trump and his base.
Practically speaking, the files are probably more useful unreleased. People hoping for a smoking gun are likely to be disappointed, since all we're likely to get is more confirmation of what we already knew: Trump is a creep, Epstein was friends with a lot of celebrities, etc... There probably isn't a photo of Trump fucking a thirteen year old, but as long as he insists on holding stuff back you can insinuate that there might be. And Trump's narcissism is such that you can expect him to balk at releasing everything even if he can easily weather the resulting storm.
I don't think anyone cares about Bill Clinton. One of the major differences between Trump supporters and... everyone else, including Trump supporters when dealing with anyone other than Trump, is that the former have some overriding devotion and loyalty to Trump, and will thus forgive (or rather, deny the existence of) any fault, no matter how egregious. For everyone else, their supporters' relationship with them is far more instrumental because all of these guys - including senior leadership - are fundamentally replaceable to both the party and the voters.
Like, when Hastert got tagged as a pedo, nobody was saying "I'm going to reevaluate my conservative politics because of this" or "actually molesting children isn't that bad" or even "he didn't do it". This was because Hastert was not a load-bearing component of American conservatism. You could think Hastert was guilty and still be a Republican. Clinton (or even a prominent Democrat who actually holds office right now) being involved in sex crimes would be distasteful, but few would have a problem feeding them into the woodchipper. Trump, by contrast, is Trumpism. You can't hold Trump accountable without the movement self-immolating. And because normie conservatism has been completely hollowed out by the Trump cult of personality, you're stuck with him even if you privately refused to drink the Kool-Aid.
"The GOP/Trump is hiding all the really incriminating stuff"
I mean, plausible. That plus the heel-dragging and the current admin's habit of comical denialism encourages this kind of suspicion.
Well, the biggest reason I replied then was because that's when I saw it. I didn't have time to write a reply until now-ish. I don't live on this forum and semi-regularly get quite busy.
Regarding the subject of varying opinions, you're missing the point. Of course people have varying opinions. But you cannot say "nobody is saying X" when there are people saying X right next to you. You really shouldn't be saying "nobody is saying X" when you are saying X. You, specifically, call out accusing gender traditionalists of holding up idealized historic gender relations as a kind of strawmanning and then proceed to hold up idealized historic gender relations: "It's largely women that have a problem with this in 2025, not men. They're the ones who want to hold men to historic conventional standards of behavior." (emphasis mine) I did not "blow past" this. The fact that historic conventional standards of behavior do not reflect what you seem to think they did is my point.
There are two fundamentally different views you can have on this type of thing.
This is also missing my point. Suppose you think motherhood is the most valuable thing a woman can do. Great, awesome. Surely if motherhood is that important, women deserve say and rights comparable to men. Why, then, do our gender neo-traditionalists complain about gender equality and claim that men are entitled to a privileged status on account of all the special responsibilities they assume? Why is men's work held up as load-bearing while women's work isn't?
"Human mating is too important to leave to individual initiative" does not in any way imply a male-led social order, and yet for some reason the people saying that always seem to come back to it, as if women are the ones who need to be convinced to settle down. There might be some half-hearted condemnations of male promiscuity, but it usually gets written off while the focus is always on bringing women to heel. (In point of fact, I don't think men or women need to be pushed that hard to settle down - most of this discourse is focused on highly visible outliers, but that's a separate matter). I rather strongly suspect that this is because they want women in a subservient social role. That, in turn, is because they see women as inferiors. Certainly, I have enough firsthand experience seeing that a lot of men really don't like dealing with women as peers.
Men don't have a problem with abandoning gender roles because a man will date across his station in life.
That's very clearly not true in both particulars. To the first: a lot of men (including people here) very pointedly complain that they find this or that aspect of modern life emasculating. Witness the anger over "HR ladies", "feminization of the workplace", demands for bringing back traditionally masculine jobs, etc... This rebellion against the breakdown of old gender roles is a huge part of the appeal of manosphere-type media. To the second: men are generally more willing to date down than women, but less willing to date up (see also: feeling emasculated). Yeah, there aren't a lot of female doctors who want to marry male plumbers; there also aren't a lot of male plumbers who want to marry female doctors.
Likewise, there are a lot of behavioral social scripts that govern our interactions, but it is far from obvious that unequal gender relations are the 'best' way to handle things. As with the mating problem, there seems to be a strong preference in right-wing spaces for social scripts that subordinate women. Obviously, that's not terribly surprising - anti-feminism is what marks them as right-wing in context - but it shows the same tendency to insist new things can't work even as they are actively functioning. Very clear, men are capable of treating women with common decency, regardless of the enforcement of gender roles. The fact that many of them don't (and actively resent the suggestion that they should) is an indictment of them as individuals, not a particularly compelling argument for traditionalism.
Seems to me you have a hard time coming to grips with the fact that several people here know exactly what I'm talking about.
I'm sure there are a bunch of people here who feel persecuted on account of their interactions with women. I find it hard to believe they've never been told 'good job' or 'I love you' unless they are incompetent and have incredibly toxic families and social groups, neither of which are gendered issues.
Romania and Georgia did it.
Did they? Decree 770 was one of the first things to go after Ceaușescu got got, and in the interval required a totalitarian enforcement apparatus (and resulted in an enormous number of abandoned children). This is less 'conservative' and more the kind of thing conservative anti-communist writers would make up to make communism look bad. If your policy proposal leads to people overthrowing you and shooting you on TV, I think it's safe to dismiss its viability (and yes, I'm aware that the Romanian Revolution was not about this specific issue, but you can't separate totalitarian policy from totalitarian regimes).
Georgia, as far as I can tell, basically pulled the same "please have sex" maneuver a lot of countries have. It just somewhat unexpectedly appears to have worked, unlike, e.g. Japan or Denmark. Great that it worked for them, but the fact that it hasn't elsewhere indicates they either got lucky or there's some Georgian idiosyncrasy.
I'll duck some of the idiosyncrasies of the world of Avatar re: people with superpowers and how that might affect gender norms, and instead talk about what kind of story ATLA is. Namely, a fairly classic adventure fantasy in which virtually every character who matters is a warrior of some kind. You must be able to kick this much ass to participate in the plot. And that's the sticking point: "women can be warriors" isn't about literal military service (none of the main characters are soldiers anyway, and to my recollection the show takes a pretty negative view of militaries in general), it's about the idea that women are people whose agency matters and who aren't presumptively incompetent. The character who is most prominently on the receiving end of this messaging is Sokka, who begins the story as an overt sexist who discounts the ability of women to not only fight but to do basically anything non-domestic (an attitude that is still not uncommon).
"Well why don't they show it some other way" - it's not that kind of show. It's a children's show where people solve problems with the power of friendship and elemental superpowers. As I said, everyone who matters is a warrior, which is maybe not the greatest implicit message for children's television, but it shapes the kind of story-telling you get.
"The most radical position you can hold in modern politics is believing people before the 1960s were sane and had rational motivations for doing what they did."
Aside from the fact that that's clearly not true and is just bravery posturing (and/or is an oblique appeal to tradition), 'sane and rational' does not equal correct or morally justifiable.
One of the marvelous things about the Motte is how often you'll get one Mottizen saying "no one is saying X" in the same thread that another Mottizen is saying "X, and furthermore X doesn't go far enough." Or, hilariously, the same comment.
I don't know where this denigration of traditional vocations like motherhood come from.
It's sort of implied when one says that a) motherhood is the highest aspiration for a woman b) women don't deserve to have an equal voice in society because the things they do are less valuable.
I've never met a single detractor you could ever say this to without them trying to shove back down your throat the proposition that the mid-20th century wasn't some kind of utopia, as no conservative I've met has ever said that.
It's largely women that have a problem with this in 2025, not men. They're the ones who want to hold men to historic conventional standards of behavior. Men have no problems living a life emancipated from the 'sexist' norms of treating a woman with respect and common decency if that's what they choose and insist on.
We're back to the rose-colored vision of historical gender relations. "Treating a women with respect and common decency" has not been all that common. Aside from the sheer volume of dirtbag (or outright abusive/predatory) behavior that was written off, women's status was generally contingent on conforming to extremely confining standards of respectability. Fall outside of that and you were fair game.
Nor, frankly, do I think it's correct to say that traditional gender roles are enforced primarily by women. I don't think critics of traditional gender roles have much issue with the idea that everyone plays a part in enforcing gender roles, but that includes the massive role that men play in enforcing standards of masculinity on other men - especially in conservative spaces, which tend to be especially intolerant of perceived effeminacy. Failing to meet these standards can quickly make you an object of mockery and contempt in the eyes of other men.
As an aside, I find it worrying that you find treating people with respect and common decency is not a universal basic obligation. Like, why would dismantling gender norms lead to men treating women badly? This would lend credence to the misandrist perspective.
Men literally never hear words like "thank you," "I love you," "appreciate it," "you do a good job," etc., a single time in their entire lives.
I'm sorry, what? I think you're basically wrong in your assertion that gender roles are primarily enforced by women, but it's at least arguable. This is so unbelievably alien that I'm left thinking that you're trolling.
No one has said all conservative solutions to address the problem are going to work. But it's 'only' a conservative solution to the problem in nature that's likely to work.
Why? Every conservative solution I've seen proposed is some flavor of putting the toothpaste back in the tube, ignoring that the world has changed in innumerable ways.
- Prev
- Next

Preliminary prediction: no substantive change in Venezuela. Maduro is a bad guy, but he's not any sort of political keystone and the authoritarian machinery is still in place. Long-term impact is that US further cements its reputation as being erratic and untrustworthy for the sake of Big Dick maneuvers. Increases the odds of nuclear proliferation as well.
Maybe I'm being overly pessimistic, but unless the US is about to actually invade Venezuela to install Machado I don't see why the Venezuelan regime wouldn't just put one of their own in the big chair.
Aside: unclear what the legal basis for this is beyond "my own party is too cowardly to hold me accountable". I've seen people draw comparisons to Just Cause or Urgent Fury for obvious reasons, but in the former case Panama declared war and in the latter case it was always kind of dodgy and at least had the figleaf of urgency regarding protection of US citizens. I guess they're going to try and spin this as law enforcement?
edit: wow, Trump does not sound okay in this presser. Also, apparently we're going to run Venezuela.
More options
Context Copy link