@VoxelVexillologist's banner p

VoxelVexillologist

๐Ÿ‡บ๐Ÿ‡ธ Multidimensional Radical Centrist

1 follower   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 04 18:24:54 UTC

				

User ID: 64

VoxelVexillologist

๐Ÿ‡บ๐Ÿ‡ธ Multidimensional Radical Centrist

1 follower   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 04 18:24:54 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 64

I mostly agree with this description with a note that the largest exception I've seen is a complete lack of motion from universities and graduate degree holders to rename the masters degree. Even from institutions and people that I've seen replace the name elsewhere.

No thread about Javascript will grow as fast as one about religion, because people feel they have to be over some threshold of expertise to post comments about that. But on religion everyone's an expert.

I have occasionally thought that the Culture War is really just bike shedding at a much larger scale, with which this description seems to agree.

It is interesting how fast the discussion has pivoted from largely-theoretical "AI safety" a year or two ago, which Google was quite prominent in (Gebru etc al), to ChatGPT and actual results. It almost seems like the reverse of the Jurassic Park quote: "Your scientists were so preoccupied with whether they could, they didn't stop to think if they should".

I think the biggest problem with that argument is that cars pretty much entirely kill unintentionally.

While I'm not completely onboard with anti-car YIMBY urbanists, I think they have a reasonable point that most automobile "accidents" are the result of avoidable negligence, and that our auto safety standards reflect a growing allowance for carelessness on the part of drivers. IMO limiting road-legal cars to 90mph (5 over the highest legal speed limit in the country) with strict liability and enforcement, and limiting power to fairly modest acceleration would anger a lot of gearheads but probably save lives overall. Europe does reasonably well with average velocity enforcement of time between fixed measurement points.

I'm not opposed to people owning performance cars, but I don't think they should be "performing" on public streets. There's probably some reasonable middle ground with separate "road" and "race" modes in car computers that I'd be willing to go along with.

It appears that the warrant canary on the Contact Us page still states it's for 2022. Although I suppose it's possible we've been contacted by the relevant authorities.

SARS-CoV-2 transmission rates changed drastically for no apparent reason during the pandemic, so if you started an intervention during a high transmission period you were almost certain to see a drop in transmission.

Given the rather infamous multi-wave structure of the 1918 pandemic, I thought it was interesting to see the same structure play out in real-time. Early on many pop sci sources seemed to suggest that this was largely a result of changes in social behavior, whereas in hindsight in 2023 it looks pretty clearly dominated by the various variants spreading through the population. I suppose even the remaining samples of 1918 virus that we've studied don't provide quite the level of robust genome-over-time data that we have for today: the sheer scale of viral replication provides a variety of mutations that IMO gain-of-function research is unlikely to even poorly approximate in the near future.

I suppose this isn't surprising in hindsight, but it's interesting to look back on how much we thought we understood about respiratory pandemics in early 2020, and how little we actually knew (spoiler: it's airborne!).

One of the concerns about drastically changing the health care system is that, despite it's flaws, people using the system are concerned that changing it could make it worse in at least their local case. People want to "keep their doctor," and aren't sure whether their doctor covered by their current insurance would take Medicare For All. For better or worse, the folks shouting about "keeping government out of my Medicare" don't directly care that the government is paying, but they do care if they have to change doctors or pay more out of pocket: major changes to reimbursement rates or rules could absolutely cause their doctor to drop Medicare patients.

While insurance companies often mix things up (changing in-network providers to out-of-network annually), there isn't much trust that a federal solution would be better. Witness the SNAFU that was the launch of the ACA exchanges, or that the states promising to move to single-payer at the time have all quietly dropped those plans.

Helicopter money for healthcare probably polls better because it changes these things less directly by distorting the market and is difficult to compare.

I think a decent fraction of America's troubles in this regard happen because our rules enforcement mechanisms target the middle class. There is an entire class of people (including those disturbing your train ride) who are functionally judgement proof. They aren't afraid of a fine because they can't pay it anyway, and so aren't dissuaded from all sorts of anti-social behavior.

There is also a very middle-class sensibility that instinctively opposes criminal punishment for things that can mostly be enforces with fines.

On the other hand, there's the poverty tax example about how a rich man buys an expensive pair of boots that last 10 years, and a poor man has to buy a new pair of cheap boots every year, and in the end the rich man actually spends less money.

I've always found this claim hilarious. There is an element of truth that the cheapest options are sometimes not cost effective, but if you look at cars, the total cost of ownership is pretty clearly lower for a Toyota than a BMW.

I've owned lots of boots and running shoes in my life and would solidly recommend options in the middle: the really fast Nike carbon-plated shoes are known to break easily (as it turns out, they sacrifice durability for weight and speed), and I wouldn't recommend the cheapest shoe on AliExpress either. But a normal model from a reputable brand might make 5-600 miles if you are gentle with them.

I am fairly convinced that Western lockdown policies only happened because a fearful public health apparatus followed China's playbook in a panic. Nobody gets fired for following the general consensus.

Exactly how much better we could have done at the time is unclear to me. Notably, it took seemingly forever to acknowledge it's airborne spread, and challenge vaccine trials would have probably saved lives and ended it sooner. But this is something that will probably never get a firm answer.

Are we committing some crime against them? What if we think we've designed them to like it? It still seems all very I Have No Mouth, and I Must Scream.

I think there are a whole host of ethical questions about consciousness that don't (yet?) have good answers like the ones you ask. What is ethical for a consciousness that can be trivially duplicated or paused indefinitely? What level of intelligence merits protection?

You would think modern ethicists (or sci-fi authors) would be interested in these sorts of things, but I haven't seen much. They seem very focused on "alignment" or wrongthink, rather than the IMO hard questions. Open to, er, novel suggestions if anyone has discussed this more deeply that I've missed.

SVBโ€™s depositors will almost certainly get almost all (or all) of their money back, likely very soon.

From what I recall, the last time this happened in 2008 to Washington Mutual and Wachovia, both banks were acquired within a few weeks by JPMorgan Chase and Wells Fargo, respectively. As far as I know the depositors were made whole as part of the deal. I obviously can't speak to the details here, but the Treasury has ways to incentivize such a merger, and if the shareholders and bondholders lose out, the assets might even cover the deposits.

On the other hand, those actions didn't prevent the rest of the excitement that happened in 2008.

I want to hear the steelman for qualified immunity, because the most salient times it comes up are when itโ€™s being abused.

I think there's a place for something resembling a minimal version of qualified immunity: we should protect civil servants from criminal prosecution for carrying out their duties in good faith, or we won't be able to hire any good civil servants. Minor mistakes in the moment, especially for a high-stakes roles like police officers, are unavoidable.

But I will agree with you that current jurisprudence goes way too far in assuming good faith.

I have no particular claims regarding the 2020 election, but the 1997 Miami mayor race in which Xavier Suarez was removed from office for ballot fraud is probably the most obvious recent memory example of what some are claiming happened. Per the wiki article:

While Suarez was not personally implicated, the prosecuting circuit court judge cited the district as ''the center of a massive, well-conceived and well-orchestrated absentee ballot voter fraud scheme.'' People working for Suarez's campaign were found forging voter signatures, including at least one of a dead citizen.

The 1997 race was particularly recent during the 2000 election controversy in Florida. I have no information regarding more recent elections, but while I'd like to think it can't happen these days it doesn't seem completely impossible.

The way that DEI is now, seemingly, DEIB - "B" for "belonging", because "inclusion" was not inclusive enough, it seems

I have qualms about the term of "belonging" to an organization: they don't own me, and never will. I realize it can also refer to more affirmative group membership, but it's such an obviously two-faced word choice that I have trouble taking it seriously.

Do you have a citation on that second point? I haven't seen any hard data on that, but I think it may be confounded by frequency with which men are forced into more dangerous situations for criminal violence via occupation (night shift, security guards, etc) and their statistical propensity for perhaps-careless-but-not-illegal risk taking.

All we can say with certainty is that...

I would observe that an absolutely minimal reading of your items here would match the level of representation of DC, the Northern Mariana Islands, US Virgin Islands, American Samoa, and Puerto Rico in the US House: each is allowed a delegate with no voting power. In theory a "voice", but in practice basically no actual power.

In addition to the double-dipping argument mentioned by another reply, it's important to highlight all of these costs are entirely artificial.

The economics of internet infrastructure are weird. Companies at the core (Tier 1) don't pay for connectivity to each other at all. They get paid by Tier 2 and 3 networks that can't summon the requisite connections and data flow to qualify.

Honestly, the fact that a decentralized Internet with global connectivity to almost everyone works is quite the technical and political feat.

But yes the fact that Comcast, part owner of competitor Hulu and cable TV operator, can do this is probably a tad disappointing.

It may have also been useful as a reward at the end of a laborerโ€™s dull day, turning the bland water of his evening into pleasant wine.

Until relatively recently, wine and beer (even low ABV) may well have been preferable because they generally are safer for various water-bourne diseases. Also tea, in which the water is heated.

Whatโ€™s different here, exactly?

In a legal case like this, there are several broad categories of questions that have to get answered. The first one relevant here is standing, in which the court considers whether or not it should consider the merits of the case in a later step. Standing here includes who, if anyone, was wronged. In particular, SCOTUS likes to reject cases on standing because it typically doesn't set precedent for future cases. Some are (wrongly IMO) trying to argue that no one was harmed by this decision. I don't like this idea because it suggests that certain subsidies are entirely beyond review.

If the court finds standing, it will consider the merits of the case: was this action allowed by the (rather vague) statutory text passed by Congress. There is plenty of case law allowing subsidies in many instances. The Executive here points to a few catch-all clauses to justify this action.

There are some limits in how much power Congress can grant to the Executive, but exactly where that limit is and how far the Executive can stretch the letter of the law is a legal question for the court that seems likely to fall to the partisan split.

I've seen people try to argue that there is no standing, but I can't find them convincing because the general argument implies that government debt forgiveness is never subject to judicial review. If this were such a plenary power of the executive -- because we never can go far enough in the courts to read what Congress wrote -- that would seem to mean that pretty much any forgiveness plan would be acceptable, including downright stupid things like "debt forgiveness for contributors to my campaign." There be lots of dragons.

I haven't seen anyone argue that the specifics of this case cause a lack of standing, so I've taken it largely as a sign that the people making such arguments are partisans for whom the ends justify the means.

If you talk to women in their 20s youโ€™ll learn that a chunk of them go on dates and expect a relationship with a man who has no intention of having one. This is because of social media induced higher standards, hyper-competitive labor market induced higher standards, the decline in slut shaming, and last but not least dating apps.

Despite how much Millennials and Zoomers make fun of Cold War suburban "keeping up with the Jones'" standards chasing, widespread social media adoption seems to have driven the trend to eleven. Sure, the material aesthetic is somewhat different -- less quintessentially suburban -- but the rampant self-comparison to "influencers" who are often quasi-professionals at producing Instagram vibes certainly goes beyond healthy role models in many cases.

In real life, the half-Asian guys I know do just fine with women. I suppose if they did have antipathy towards their white fathers they wouldn't tell me, but it doesn't seem like something that's obviously true.

I don't have any hard data to go on here, but I wouldn't be surprised if the ones with antipathy disproportionately grew up with a single mother -- I can absolutely see how a mixed-race child with trouble fitting into the side of the only family available to them could blame their absent father, especially if there's an easily seen "my mother was just a fetish for him" or something like that.

I guess the question is how to minimize the effect of [literal memes] on a population.

I think there is also a question of determining which memes are harmful, which on the edges is fuzzier than it sounds. There are plenty of positive memes (the notions of democratic governance and enlightenment liberalism come to mind), and some negative ones like suicide clusters are pretty universally seen as harmful -- barring a crowd of unironic nihilists out there. But the more nuanced memes tend to draw disagreement, often becoming fodder for the Kulturkampf. Is organized religion a harmful meme? Personally, not in most cases, but many arguments to the contrary have been made earnestly.

Even if there were a mechanism for minimizing memes (beyond the simple "countermeme harder" which just raises the temperature), I'd be concerned about exactly what you'd choose to target with it.