I'm talking about life expectancy at 20 years old.
Not if the apostles were in their 20s at the time of Jesus' ministry, which they probably were
Life expectancy estimates for that period, for a common person, vary a lot but they should be between 30 and 40 years, so the earliest dates for Mark place it just out of the average life expectancy. If you take into account that the author of Mark is not jewish, as the historian consensus goes, and that few people would have witnessed Jesus in the first place, because if it was a big phenomenon it would have lots of non-christian sources, that means the oldest gospel was written when less than 10% of the potential witnesses were alive and in a different country.
You can call it living memory, that's just a matter of definitions, but it doesn't give you the conclusion that you are hoping for (that they couldn't have lied).
The early critical scholars put them 100 years out or more, out of living memory of the depicted events
40 years is already out of living memory!
The book of Job is a weird example to argue a non-human-focused deity since it's about god taking an interest not just in humanity but in a specific individual human.
But more generally, look at how god is used in practice. When you get cancer they say "well this is God giving you a trial, pray and you'll get through it" not "that's just a random occurence, nothing to do with God". When you die they tell your family "X was a good person, devout to God and you'll meet him again in heaven" not "who knows if God saved him or not, let's hope for the best". When somebody kills your mom they tell you "God will punish evildoers, he might escape human judgement but not divine one" not "well maybe the murderer was really devout and he's going to heaven, no way to know".
God to most people is servicing some important psychological needs, it's hard for that role to be covered by Engineer God that mad a turnkey universe or by the mathematical abstraction of classic theology. And that's the real problem of evil.
I think you are being a bit too rosy on the favorability of modern scholarship to christianity. Yes, the mainstream position is that Jesus existed but it's a completely hollowed out character, that he existed is the only thing they agree upon: not the bethlehem story, not the baptism, not any part of his preaching and not the passion (except for dying on the cross). Yes, Paul existed but most of the letters are fakes. And the dates for the Gospels are in fact postulated to be very late (40 years at minimum, it's an ethernity) and in a different order than what tradition would have them. And the historicity of Moses has taken a hit.
Even given the right circumstances I don't see the constellation of minor denominations finding another anchor point besides inerrancy.
Why are some Christians so intent on rejecting evolution?
We were actually talking about it a couple of weeks ago. I haven't changed my opinion, it's hard to reconcile with genesis both on a factual basis and on a narrative basis.
It also intersects with the problem of where moral authority comes from. The answer has to be mainly "the bible" but which version and how do you interpret it correctly are hard questions so the answer also typically involves the words "apostolic succession" which is easy to hold if you are the catholic or orthodox, harder but still possible if you anglican or lutheran, but essentially impossible if you are an evangelical whose church was founded in the 1800s in america. Then you only have the bible and it kinda has to be read literally, so as to make your correctness obvious. Hence fundamentalism and the creationist, geocentrist, flatearthist memes that then spread back to other denominations.
Interesting, however it's only the original source for a few of the questions (and one, question 12) was changed so as to make it more ambiguous.
Is anyone here a member of the California Lawyers Association or knows someone who is?
Tl;dr: I've become interested in figuring out where the fake Louisiana Literacy Test comes from and my last lead is Vol. 16 of the Public Law Journal from 1992, which is not available online but that members of the CLA can request.
Long version. The test probably got famous in 2013 when Slate published an article about it. Readers got suspicious, because it looks typeset with microsoft word, and Slate investigated it and published a followup article where they basically admit its fake but they are looking for the original version.
That should have put this thing to bed, however the fake test enjoys enduring popularity to our days. It gets posted to reddit every year at least once, Business Insider fell for it, so did BuzzFeed and Harvard all after Slate was already skeptical about it. A year ago YouGov sponsored a 1M views video about it and here's another one made not even a month ago.
I think people just like tests and they like to believe tall tales about racism and the Louisiana Literacy Test falls into that intersection. But that doesn't matter.
What matters is where it comes from. These days if you bother to look for an authoritative source you'll find it on the Jim Crow Museum website, which has had it since 2012. Back when the Slate article was written you would have gotten it from the Civil Rights Movement Veterans. Now it hosts a more reasonable, and realistic, version of the test but it still has a footnote about the old, fake, version it used to host: "At one time we also displayed a "brain-twister" type literacy test (...) We removed it because we could not corroborate its authenticity, and in any case it was not representative of the Louisiana tests in broad use during the 1950s and '60s.".
The history of that footnote is its own fun rabbithole, that one can investigate with the wayback machine. It was first added in the summer of 2013, probably in response to Slate's investigation and it said "Note that the circa 1964 test linked to above was reproduced by civil rights activists for better readability. Click here for a scan of a similar test which may have been the original for the reproduced version or quite possibly from a different parish" and linked to a typewriter version (more on that later). A month later the note is removed without explanation. Two years later, in 2015, it gets re-added, now it says "at one time we also displayed a "brain-twister" type Louisiana literacy test. We removed it from this website because it was quite atypical and was probably little used". In 2018 they change it again, still claiming that it was "little used" but authentic. Finally in 2023 it gets updated to the current version.
The typewriter version is more authentic looking but also a lot rarer, I couldn't really find any information about it, except that it was posted by Cher McDonald but I don't even know if she was the first one to post it, or even if it existed before the MS Word version or if it was just an attempt at making a better fake. The fact that the CRMV website stopped linking to it too does not bode too well for it.
The Slate article notes that the person who added it to the CRMV website is Jeff Schwartz (how ironic) who worked in voted registration in Iberville and that it was "the same in all material respects" (on all levels except physical?) to tests that he saw back then and that he found it on "an educational website".
I googled really hard and found that the "educational website" was probably Rethinking Schools specifically from volume 17, no. 2 of 2002/2003 the article "Bringing the Civil Rights Movement into the Classroom" by Larry Miller, a high school teacher from Milwaukee who says:
In this section, because it highlights voting rights and Freedom Summer, I also have students take the 10-minute Louisiana Literacy Test, used to prevent African-Americans from voting. I write on the chalkboard, “Spell backwards, forwards” and “Print the word vote upside down, but in the correct order.” Students always respond with dismay, asking, “Why?” I explain that these are the types of questions African-Americans were asked in Louisiana on literacy tests as they attempted to vote. By actually taking the test, the students are able to see how hard the state of Louisiana worked to stop the Black community from voting. (See the Louisiana Literacy Test.)
which to me can be read as either "this is a honest-to-god reproduction of a test from Louisiana in 64" but also as "I made it up as an example", specifically the part that says "these are the types of questions".
And that's where it ends, in 2002, that's the oldest webpage google can find. The typography would match the era too. Except for one last thing. Inspired by a black activist I put the questions in google books and it turns out that many, but not all (or maybe all but google books fucks up?), come from the same 1992 publication: Vol. 16 of 1992 of the Public Law Journal, published by the State Bar of California. Hence the request at the top. Does anyone here have access to this so we can see the original context of the questions?
Maybe we can figure this out then Cremieux or the other twitter guy I forgot the name of can steal it for his blog.
Because privacy stock price etc, doesn't matter.
Not caring about the personal ethics
You don't know anything about the ethics of this situation. It could have been an open relationship, it could have been a dead relationship, she could have cheated first. The truths of the matter are going to be determined by the divorce court, if there is going to be a divorce, if there isn't going to be a private settlement, if family courts weren't terminally biased against men. So we're never going to know the truth, so we're never going to be able to pass moral judgement.
You're falling prey of the female instinct to read the gossip mag.
Isn't it funny that in the UK having sex with your actual step sister is legal but owning a scene of someone having sex with someone pretending to be his step sister is not? I wonder when they will finally ban VPNs and put up a great firewall, it has to be what this is all leading up to. But maybe not, banning smoking for everyone born after year 2008 is just insane (a kickback to the streetcorner drug dealer electorate maybe?)
It is completely legal for a Eurozone country to trigger article 50 and leave the European Union and therein the Euro
Nope. That's for the european union, not for the eurozone. There is no procedure to leave the eurozone. Once you are in the eurozone you're there and in the EU forever.
you simply issue a new currency and print money to pay property holders at a laughable official exchange rate, giving them cents on the dollar, then briefly switch to using euros or dollars, then issue a new currency. This would require crashing out of the Euro and possibly EU but this, again, is perfectly legal
It isn't. As long as you are in the eurozone you are legally required to follow the stability pact and the eurozone is like hotel california. You might say "it's just fines" but mass deportation would also result in fines, at least in theory.
Lower prices is just something you're supposed to say as a politician. If you vote for a politician because he said "lower prices" you are retarded and I can't help you, but I'm convinced nobody actually does that.
But why not? If humans can exist billions of years before they evolved, before the universe, why not fruit or a snake? It works, though, it pushes everything where we cannot look so it works, I can't deny it. I wonder what the allegorical interpretation for the genealogies going back to Adam is, in this framework.
That doesn't sound like an allegorical interpretation, it sounds like a literal interpretation but placed in, like, a different "dimension" (in the science fiction sense of "dimension").
That sounds swedemborgian to me. He went further and said that hell basically wouldn't suck that bad from the perspective of the souls that chose it, I don't know what Lewis imagined. But I don't think it's the canonical view, that you get a final saving throw after death.
Does it work for you? Imagine the worst person ever, kills and rapes his whole life away, but after death he sees god, says "yep, I guess I was wrong" and just like that he gets the same reward as the most pious of humans. My position has been for a long time that the problem of evil is mostly psychological.
I don't know. Science only happened once in the history of humanity (maybe twice if you count the greeks, but really at scale only once) so it's impossible to establish a causal link. But it makes sense to me that if you psyop every intelligent person into only worrying about the spiritual, because the physical world is evil, they're probably not going to get anything done.
Gnosticism went away probably because of the same trends that made the Dark Ages. The smart people disappeared.
The dark ages had a lot of causes, but I think that a lot of people getting into the mindset that the reign of god was coming soon probably didn't help either. Besides what's making smart people appear and disappear in your model, exactly?
If Genesis is an allegory what is it an allegory for? Because its incompatibility with evolution goes beyond just the factual, it's a narrative incompatibility there is no space for the original sin, for the fall, evolution if anything goes from low to high, genesis does the opposite. Hence Teilhard being censored.
Why couldn't God save his followers in Lisbon from getting obliterated by an earthquake on All Saint's Day, 1755? They lit their candles, gathered in churches. The earthquake knocked them down and the resulting firestorm, earthquake and tsunami razed the city.
What kind of omnipotent, all-loving God treats his followers this way?
Wrong question, wrong approach to the problem of evil. What happens over here is finite, what happens in the afterlife is infinite. If anything the question should be why doesn't God save all his followers like he did with the ones in Lisbon in 1755? Why does He grace only a few infants with death before they get the chance to sin? But the real question is another: can an infinite punishment for a finite crime really be called good?
I will admit my belief is somewhat loaded on the idea that Jesus actually performed miracles. I lean towards this because I don't have a restricted prior against magic, I think all things are possible for the right being, and I think Jesus was obviously somebody because otherwise we would not have a religion about him, particularly one where he died very quickly, a material failure, with only a handful of followers.
I don't buy this argument because we have plenty of contemporary examples of people who were nothing special who nonetheless accumulated a substantial following, think Moon, Joseph Smith or even Hubbard all documented grifters and liars who convinced tens of thousands to millions. If you look at the sources we have about the early church, it's really nothing impressive. A handful of christian texts survive from the first 50 years, almost nobody talks about it. If you compare mormonism today with christianity in the year 200AD, mormonism will look wildly more successful and its basis is some guy saying he read in a gold book that's invisible to everyone but him that he gets to sleep with more than one woman. The success of christianity is far removed from the deeds of Jesus, it only really exploded when it became the religion of the emperor about 300 years later, by that point what exactly Jesus did or didn't do, or even if existed was impossible to know for anyone.
I will stop here, but I thought this could be a fun discussion to be had, because I think it deals with the main adversary of atheism from a different perspective
I don't get what kind of discussion you want to have but I've come full circle from thinking christianity would have had an easier time weathering modernity in the marcionite version, without the old testament, to thinking that we wouldn't have even had a modernity with only marcion. Gnosticism might be logically elegant but, if you think the material world is an illusion or the making of an evil god that you are supposed to escape, you are never going to get anything done, never going to make any progress.
Humanity. Of course. Or at the least a God-given eternal soul.
How do you know what does and doesn't have a God-given eternal soul?
Concern and dislike are different things. The pew poll is about concern. The reason they are concerned is because they don't want AI to take their job, the reason AI applications have so many users is because it's convenient when AI takes someone-else's job.
Suppose we have two groups of people, A and B. Group A generally finds right answers, but for wrong reasons. Group B generally finds wrong answers, but for right reasons. Which group would you rather be in?
I think you are overdosing on philosophy. If group A generally finds the right answers it has a generally correct model of the world. They could be wrong in the sense that newtonian physics is wrong but a better way to think about it is that it is approximately correct under certain circumstances. Your hypothetical presupposes a definition of correctness that's beyond just making correct predictions.
To the general point you were addressing, you shouldn't adopt a model of the world that correctly predicts one thing if it happens to do it for the wrong reasons, because it will be generally wrong.
- Prev
- Next

Suppose there actually was a big event that 50 people witnessed, none of the things Jesus did could have many more original witnesses otherwise we would have non-christian sources about it, about 20% (I don't have the population pyramid of the time so I'm using Nigeria instead) would have been between 10 and 25 (~9) and of those 34% would be alive, so about 3 or 4, living hunderds of kilometers away from where Mark was written.
Besides, we're talking about a text with a completely impossible depiction of the cleansing of the temple, which we can disprove thousands of years later, and yet it's there. Clearly it wasn't meant to be taken as historical in the first place or it never even came across someone who had been to Jerusalem once.
And Paul never met Jesus.
More options
Context Copy link