@aaa's banner p

aaa


				

				

				
0 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 10 13:41:19 UTC

				

User ID: 1105

aaa


				
				
				

				
0 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 10 13:41:19 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 1105

we'd expect plenty of surviving witnesses from an incident in 30 AD.

Suppose there actually was a big event that 50 people witnessed, none of the things Jesus did could have many more original witnesses otherwise we would have non-christian sources about it, about 20% (I don't have the population pyramid of the time so I'm using Nigeria instead) would have been between 10 and 25 (~9) and of those 34% would be alive, so about 3 or 4, living hunderds of kilometers away from where Mark was written.

Besides, we're talking about a text with a completely impossible depiction of the cleansing of the temple, which we can disprove thousands of years later, and yet it's there. Clearly it wasn't meant to be taken as historical in the first place or it never even came across someone who had been to Jerusalem once.

And Paul never met Jesus.

I'm talking about life expectancy at 20 years old.

Not if the apostles were in their 20s at the time of Jesus' ministry, which they probably were

Life expectancy estimates for that period, for a common person, vary a lot but they should be between 30 and 40 years, so the earliest dates for Mark place it just out of the average life expectancy. If you take into account that the author of Mark is not jewish, as the historian consensus goes, and that few people would have witnessed Jesus in the first place, because if it was a big phenomenon it would have lots of non-christian sources, that means the oldest gospel was written when less than 10% of the potential witnesses were alive and in a different country.

You can call it living memory, that's just a matter of definitions, but it doesn't give you the conclusion that you are hoping for (that they couldn't have lied).