I did not know of that. That’s a valid counterpoint. I was more thinking of Fracoist Spain and some early 20th century Catholic aligned dictatorships. To be honest, I struggled to think of non-state Christian examples. Christianity seems to improve the character of a people.
Where is the best steelman of Creation Science? I’ve recently been learning a bit about that subculture, and find it quite interesting. Especially when there exist easier epistemic solutions to a literal genesis like the Omaphalos hypothesis.
Full Disclosure: I come in with the prejudice that the field is mostly post-hoc epicycles used to justify a particular interpretation of Genesis. I want to know why high IQ people study this. I assume I am missing something.
And like I said, the dominant positions in both Christianity and Judaism are that the laws and deeds of the kingdom of Israel are not necessarily indicative of proper conduct today. When the strands of Islam that claim what Mohammad did are not necessarily indicative of good modern conduct are dominant, Islam will cease to face as much Western opposition.
While you may consider them cope, both Christianity and Judaism have large and dominant interpretations that explain why Leviticus should not be implemented in full. While there are liberal Islamic subcultures, the big bulk of Muslims don’t come from them. If Jews were 90% Charedim you would likely consider them pretty terrible neighbors. Similarly if 90% of Catholics were integralist tradcaths who think error deserves no rights*. I think this is a sociological issue rather than a pure religious issue.
- I know Vatican II officially supports freedom of conscience. This is just for illustration.
He’s pretty loathsome. I actually do not think the winged horse thing is the best place to attack Islam; it seems silly, but if you accept miracles it not particularly interesting. I think the biggest dilemma for Islam is the following:
- Muhammad is a moral exemplar that all Muslims should follow. This ranges in mainstream interpretation from he never commits major sins to he literally never sins.
- The Hadiths and Quran are reliable in describing his actions. These actions include slavery, marrying Aisha at 6 years old then having sex with/raping her at 9, and violent conquest and murder.
You have to either soften 1 or 2 to have a religion palatable to westerners. Probably most cultures object to sexually abusing 9 year olds.
The real red pill.
Harry Potter and The Bell Curve
You can do it right now.
Do you think he would still have his job if it were revealed the women he had affairs with were actually men?
While moral universalism is highest and ingroup bias is lowest among Western Europeans, I think that’s a too strong comment. Most African states have quite a diversity of ethnic groups. Most middle eastern states, India, and much of Southeast Asia involves societies where different meaningful ancestry groups coexist. Latin America has very meaningful colorblind cultural currents, and in many cases they are dominant.
I think racial masochism is also a bit complicated since it’s often a mix of genuine outgroup preference with wanting to stick it to “other white people I don’t like.” When blue tribe is muzzled, or is marginal like in many even minimally white Latino countries, race relations are a lot better.
Yes
I did vote for him though. I am a legit supporter.
One the flip side, Hoover did acts like Smoot Hawley which caused the collapse in international trade which caused the depression to get far worse. On the flip flip side, there is still debate over how much individual acts like Smoot Hawley did and Hoover in general followed what was best practices at the time.
Nitpick aside, it’s pretty bad. While not much will change personally, I’m sad Abbott will no longer be governor. He really stood up for Texans.
Agreed. A big reason the balance of power between the legislature and executive plus judiciary is so out of wack is the filibuster making passing bills so hard. Removing the filibuster is a case of removing a less important tradition/rule to maintain a more important tradition/rule.
How do you lose Mississippi …. This is a pretty nasty drubbing.
A collection of essays, including The Will to Believe, by William James. That essay and Is life worth living? have so far been my favorites. I’ve been exploring Pragmatism recently, and I find the school a very useful way to determine how to determine knowledge given humanity’s limited ability to obtain certainty. A few key points that stick out to me:
- If an option is momentous, forced, and live, it is advantageous to make a choice in believing even in absence of sufficient evidence. Basically, if you only get one shot, multiple hypotheses are plausible to you, and neutrality is the same as making a positive choice, it behooves you to pick something. He applies this to religion, but it can be applied elsewhere as well such as in business ventures.
- The goals of “know as much truth as you can” and “avoid error as much as you can” often conflict so you have to choose between them sometimes. Knowing more truths often means believing more falsehoods.
- Much, likely most, of what we “know” is not organized in the form of “justified true belief” but is instead justified, if it is not outright axioms, in a far less orderly and sound way. As a result, one practically must accept a degree of limited justification and “messiness” in your epistemology if you want to maximize the total amount of truth you know.
James reminds me of a reverse Hume. Hume looked at principles like induction and said “we can’t justify this logically”. He tore down “rules” of knowledge and produced skepticism. James seems to do this in reverse; given that so much of what we “know” isn’t logically obligatory, we should attempt to see what sorts of “under justified” beliefs we really can and should hold on to.
Traditionally, and even now, the route for moral uplifting of the dim was via religion and coercion to stay on the straight and narrow from different parts of society. Given that the second is peeled back in industrialized societies due to anomie, you are left with the first.
You had democratic backsliding under Chavez, but not really a full dictatorship until Maduro. The good people of Venezuela voted their way 90% to their immiseration.
I actually think more relevant is the change in power, first with the Antonines, then decisively with the third century crisis and Diocletian where the Italians lost control of their empire. Rome itself ceased to control things well before the state collapsed.
“Sorry man, the main highway all the people in this Bolsonaro neighborhood use is down for emergency maintenance.”
One of my fantasies would be to get a verified report by one of Nero’s agents on Christianity in the 50s or 60s. While I’m not sure it would change much theologically, it would be fascinating historiographically.
I think a core thing with Brazil, and the other unequal parts of LatAm, is that if you’re high enough on the totem pole that you pay both legal and illicit danegelds you can live a civilized and prosperous life. If you have high enough cultural acrimony, such as in Lebanon, or political tensions boil over to make everyone poor, like in Venezuela, you lose that ability. I think your point on worse than Brazil is accurate; LatAm has a lot of cultural and institutional antibodies, mostly via cynicism and low state capacity, that protect it, albeit imperfectly, from turning into Lebanon or Cuba/Venezuela. Even in places with higher ethnic acrimony, like Bolivia, I don’t think you have the hostility you see in Europe. Western Europe seems to have cultural and institutional feature that make Brazilification more, rather than less, painful.
- Prev
- Next

Thank you for the detailed comment. I understand why there are intelligent religious people, I don’t think religion is irrational. Your comment gives a good explanation for why many Christian’s stick with Biblical literalism unless indicated otherwise. For me, I’m still just curious why intellectually many literalists go for what seems to me to be a lot of unnecessary epicycles when there seem to be easier ways to accommodate 6 day creation like the aforementioned Omaphalos Hypothesis or General Relativity. I don’t propose persecuting Creation Scientists, but it does seem like an unnecessary philosophical construct to rationalize literal Genesis with science.
More options
Context Copy link