I was about to give you some rather absurd butterfly-effect scenarios so I appreciate you narrowing this to a more active discussion.
First you point out the practical consequences of the power to enforce private morality: it can enforce other arbitrary rules as well. Therefore we balance the inherent interest to be nosy into private business with the practical problems.
(as an aside: we have sufficiently answered why anyone else cares about private intimate lives here, and now it's merely a practical question of how much to enforce)
People gather and enforce laws about things that plausible worry them, and other's can call them fascist regardless of whether they control the flow of commerce or not. Nosiness seems an inherent problem.
When Orwell writes that fascism restricts sexuality, it seems like he means that these fascists believe there is a link between unregulated sexuality and danger to the public. And he thinks they go to far in practically enforcing it because he disagrees with the magnitude of the danger. If he became convinced it was as dangerous as they he would enforce the same laws? Or does he believe there is never a possible danger to 'public interest' from sexuality.
Second, as to the question of what the point of "advancing" a nation without sex, it seems like the fascists have a notion of what a nation is supposed to do and regard the pleasure of intimacy to be something to overcome. In a way it's like asking a body-builder what the point of living without glutenous eating and slothy relaxion. And then they use violence to enforce it on other people.
Fascism does seem to lead to collapse, which is a strong argument against it on it's own terms. If you claim to desire "strength" then why do you stab yourself? Sticking to the practical theme, I think it's some mix of selfish cruelty and short-sightedness and general power-seeking behavior.
Edit: For a concrete example of this stuff, I think of the arguments certain feminists make against privately viewing pornography. A private consensual sexual act that nevertheless has some arguments for (and against) it's public harm. Perhaps they are fascists.
Asking why anyone else cares for consensual private lives is effective rhetoric against banal edicts about which holes a penis can go into, sure.
Or are you truly asking why anyone cares?
I believe there are no truly private actions. What you do in private has some effect on others in hidden ways that you cannot prevent. This means that rules of public morality have corresponding limitations on private activity.
We can explain this more clearly using some extreme examples that stretch the limits of what privacy and consensual means. But the examples I reach for are not in the spirit of your question. Like private conception of new moral patients, construction of some super-weapon to use against the world, or privately signing away natural rights.
Or we can strengthen the hypothetical by asking whether there are simple limited scope actions done in true privacy with only rational and consenting beings somehow truly sealed from the impacting anything else ever again, that are yet still themselves somehow immoral. Is this closer to your question?
She has excellent awareness of Mr Collins' character. And arguably good judgement of Mr Bingly. And same for other men in the book. So rather it's two men in particular she was wrong about?
Both of them are deliberately deceiving her. One a conman who fooled everyone in her social circle (i think?). The other is too conscious of her low social rank to correct her (she even asks him to justify and he declines).
She is fooled yes, but this cannot be a character flaw. Everyone was fooled. Who judged better than her?
It is a truth universally acknowledged, that a single man in possession of a good fortune, must be in want of mid.
I think you picked a poor example for your joke. Elizabeth was perfectly worthy and good when she first met Darcy and it was due to his flaws that they were not amicable.
He's rude to her and she believes he is a bad person because of it. Her growth in the book was learning that her first impressions of the men around here didn't see their full story. But there was never doubt about that she was worthy of their pursuit.
Here's that initial meeting from the book:
"You are dancing with the only handsome girl in the room" said Mr. Darcy, looking at the eldest Miss Bennet.
"Oh! She is the most beautiful creature I ever beheld! But there is one of her sisters sitting down just behind you, who is very pretty, and I dare say very agreeable. Do let me ask my partner to introduce you."
"Which do you mean?" and turning round he looked for a moment at Elizabeth, till catching her eye, he withdrew his own and coldly said: "She is tolerable, but not handsome enough to tempt me; I am in no humour at present to give consequence to young ladies who are slighted by other men. You had better return to your partner and enjoy her smiles, for you are wasting your time with me."
Mr. Bingley followed his advice. Mr. Darcy walked off; and Elizabeth remained with no very cordial feelings toward him. She told the story, however, with great spirit among her friends; for she had a lively, playful disposition, which delighted in anything ridiculous.
Yeah I think this piece in particular is pathologically rhetoric because he's defending the honor of bay area rationalism from 'institutional bullying'.
The bayarea+math combo is a weakness for his reporting.
His formal training is in philosophy and medicine. Probably helps him with analogies and intuition pumps, but it's also training in sophistry.
Well, it's as they say, everyone's a high decoupler until it's something they actually care about.
He seems to feel personal slighted by how Pinker dismisses the rationalist communities ideas. and wants to write an essay on how Pinker is completely wrong on everything. But perhaps the facts are not strong enough to do that.
But anyway you don't have to dismiss Scott's other work completely. You can rule public ideas-guys in, not out https://slatestarcodex.com/2019/02/26/rule-genius-in-not-out/.
I think about this every time I hear someone say something like “I lost all respect for Steven Pinker after he said all that stupid stuff about AI”. Your problem was thinking of “respect” as a relevant predicate to apply to Steven Pinker in the first place. Is he your father? Your youth pastor? No? Then why are you worrying about whether or not to “respect” him? Steven Pinker is a black box who occasionally spits out ideas, opinions, and arguments for you to evaluate. If some of them are arguments you wouldn’t have come up with on your own, then he’s doing you a service. If 50% of them are false, then the best-case scenario is that they’re moronically, obviously false, so that you can reject them quickly and get on with your life.
A stopped clock sometimes tells the truth because it is so broken it can't tell the difference.
A working yet biased clock is never right. It will always tell you a turned story, always deceive you in direction of it's aim.
No I will not help you find reputable sources of information
For any particular reason? or is that coming in part 2. I may have missed your point here
Would open up opportunity for players to collude: we'll tank our chances to win this game so you guys bet big, if you do the same for us.
Which might not matter much. But it's still the league's best interest to offer a full clear barrier between players and gambling. At least while the public still cares more about this than a gambling partnership can buy.
Necro posting that i finally read this paper, neat. Found out my copy of Pale Fire corrected the italics for "Hiding place".
Is comment ironic? I have a poor sarcasm tell and would like you to speak more plainly here if so. I am uninformed on the object level here I apologize.
You said "It might be another matter if [..] the Secretary of State, CIA director, and Chairman of the Joint Chiefs all told him the Israelis were full of shit"
Skimming parent posts you are replying to right here it seems like other people think that is exactly the case. Do these comments meet your bar for manpliation then? Or do you think they are misrepresenting this information?
(Chairman Join Chief) General Caine replied: “Sir, this is, in my experience, standard operating procedure for the Israelis. They oversell, and their plans are not always well-developed. They know they need us, and that’s why they’re hard-selling.”
The C.I.A. director used one word to describe the Israeli prime minister’s regime change scenarios: “farcical.”
Everyone seems to be against this war now, or is leaking that they were against it. Vance was against it. General Caine was against it. The CIA was against it. The blame is getting shoved off onto Trump and Netanyahu
- Prev
- Next

It really sucks to be under conformist pressure, a lot more with these personal things. Anyone posting on this forum ought to empathize.
Mass technology and authoritarianism seems very dangerous. I'm not sure what to do.
More options
Context Copy link