@georgioz's banner p

georgioz


				

				

				
0 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 07:15:35 UTC

				

User ID: 493

georgioz


				
				
				

				
0 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 07:15:35 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 493

"Morton's Fork: both Case 1 and Case 2 imply that discussing Cartesian-Daemon scenarios is pointless, so since one of them's true this is true unconditionally."

So you declare Cartesian Demon as pointless due to Morten's fork. Again, these are strong presuppositions. Please allow me to play internal critique and put some words in your mouth. An example:

  • "Not being pointless" is disqualifier
  • Morten's fork is valid way to accept or exclude stuff.

That is the modus ponens type of argument.

  • Being able make points is necessary precondition for "discussion intended to achieve truths".
  • Cartesian demon negates possibility of meaningful "discussion intended to achieve truths".
  • I assert that possibility of "discussion achieving truth" is fruitful/possible/valuable/obvious.
  • Therefore Cartesian demon does not exist at least in the form that ever explains anything and I am safe to discard it.

Just to note, this is in no way obvious conclusion. There are nihilists and post-modernists who own this and who say that yes, discussions have no meaning. That there is no non-arbitrary justification to exclude these conclusions and they mock the idea of meaningful truth. Maybe they believe in existence of Cartesian Demon under their own paradigm.

Now maybe you disagree with specific wording, where I assigned to you a presupposition

"I will only entertain paradigms/worldviews/webs-of-belief where meaningful discussion is possible. Cartesian Demon negates this condition therefore I will discard any worldview that entails existence of such an entity"

That is what I guess is your presupposition. But maybe I am wrong and you will chastise me again that I put words in your mouth. So what I am asking for you is to formulate and argument that enabled you to discard Cartesian Demon. And then see it for what it is, so we can dive deeper into the assumptions.