I think it's cool and impressive when someone can play the violin well. In general, I think being able to play the violin is "better" than not being able to play the violin. That said, if there was a pill that made people want to practice violin 8hrs a day like a professional violinist, I wouldn't support giving that pill to everyone (or even most people). The fact that something is "good" doesn't necessarily mean everyone should do it.
I think being gay is morally neutral. I think most liberals feel the same way. A small subset of activists probably think being gay is better than being straight. But even this latter view doesn't necessarily imply a belief that everyone should be gay.
Physically, it works the same way a transformer works -- induction. When you plug your phone (or computer, etc) into the wall, there is a transformer in the circuit stepping down the voltage. There is no basis to be worried about risks from inductive chargers any more than you worry about risks from transformers. Also this isn't some "new untested science" this is Maxwell's Equations, stuff we've understood since the 1860s.
I don't have a constantly running internal monologue. I "turn it on" when I'm thinking about highly verbal concepts, like the particular way I want to phrase something, but in general my thinking is more conceptual and less verbal.
This got me thinking about what my default internal monologue "sounds" like, and I guess it sounds like myself when I was a little boy, like 10 year old me. I feel like the sound of my internal monologue hasn't changed since I was a kid. I can deliberately make it sound different, like I'm currently deliberately narrating this sentence in the voice of Jimmy Stewart as I type it. But by default it's little kid me.
I think the fact that I don't always internally verbalize allows me to think better/faster, but who knows. If I'm working on math then I think in terms of a visual or conceptual image of the math problem. If I'm thinking about music then I just hear the music in my head. Music is probably the form of thinking that's easiest for me, I can internally play back a song with multiple instruments and vocal parts. I have written original songs entirely in my head that I'm not good enough to actually play on an instrument but I can easily play them back internally as though I was hitting "play" on a recording. I have some musical training but am by no means a professional.
I've posted here before about how my wife is considered a "person of color" by employers and universities because she's from Mexico, even though her skin is pale white. Outside of the really clear-cut cases, American notions of race are pretty incoherent. It's not like sex where 99%+ of people can be reliably classified as male or female.
I suspect its going to be hard to find this stuff for products that are still on the market since these processes are closely guarded trade secrets. But if you find any good sources let me know, it sounds interesting.
I shower every day but only use soap/shampoo every 2-3 days since (in my anecdotal experience) excess soap use causes excess oil production and damages skin and hair. So I'm sympathetic to what you're saying. But if someone isn't at least rinsing themself off with water every day or two, they are going to stink.
It is possible that millennials are becoming conservative at exactly the same rate as previous generations even though they are not voting for conservative parties at the same rate as previous generations. Parties are not static ideologies or sets of policy goals. Parties compete for voters, modifying and triangulating their platforms and rhetoric over time.
In the US, Republicans and Democrats have fought each other to a pretty consistent 50/50 stalemate in nationwide votes for several decades, modifying their views on all sorts of issues along the way to maintain that equilibrium. As the overall population has gotten older over time, the equilibrium "stalemate age" (the age when a voter is equally likely to vote for either party) also gets older over time. To put it another way, as the electorate ages it becomes increasingly "cost effective" for the Republican party to cater to older voters, which makes it easier for the Democratic party to attract and retain people in their 30s who might otherwise be potential Republican voters.
If you literally have no clue how to do it, then I can see how more time would not be helpful. But I wouldn't consider that being a "fast test taker" I would consider that simply being unprepared for the test.
In my experience as someone who majored in physics and minored in math, there is almost always some way to use additional time productively on math tests, even if you're stumped by a problem. Re-write the problem in a different form and see if it looks more familiar. Change the coordinate system and see if it makes things easier. Try out various mathematical tools/techniques and see if they work.
Can you be more specific about the type of test you're talking about? I initially envisioned a g-loaded multiple-choice test like the SAT, but what you're describing sounds more like a long-form written answer test based on subject matter knowledge. As another commenter pointed out, maybe you're just a fast writer/typist?
As someone who has always been an extremely fast test taker (and a consistently high-scoring test taker), I still struggle to think of situations where more time would not be beneficial for me. Unless the test is pure regurgitation of memorized lists, or unless the test is so easy that you're scoring close to 100% on the initial pass, having more time to review and refine your answers should tend to result in a higher score.
There's no good reason you should do worse after going back and reviewing answers. More time to think should always be better, ceteris paribus. The only explanation I can think of would be if you're biased toward assuming your initial answer was wrong (e.g. because you doubt your own intelligence or doubt your test taking abilities) and so you consistently talk yourself into changing answers you shouldn't change.
In some contexts, yes, it's used as a sort of a formal or impersonal version of the 2nd-person singular. Especially in customer service contexts you'll sometimes hear a singular "y'all" as a sign of respectful distance between the speaker and the person being addressed.
(Note: my comment is referring to standard usage in Texas and isn't directly addressing the point above about black American vernacular).
I think I'm speaking pretty plainly. I'm asking OP to consider how ChatGPT performs in relation to an average human. This is a pretty common question people consider when talking about AI performance. After all, the Turing Test is one of the oldest and best-known tests of computer intelligence.
I am asking OP to consider these questions as a way of pushing back against statements like the following:
Seeing it underperform so much in my field is giving me a sort of Gellmann Amnesia effect for people touting how it can write code on its own.
"Underperform" is an interesting choice of words here, because it seems that the bar for performance is being set at "subject matter expert." Obviously ChatGPT is not at that level. To paraphrase Arnold Kling on the most recent EconTalk episode, "it's about at the level of an undergrad BS artist who didn't study for the test." But consider how much training and skill it takes a human to reach the level of "undergrad BS artist" and how few humans are able to attain even that level of performance. I think OP should be more impressed with how far we've come. We don't need to go a whole lot further to close the gap between "undergrad BS artist" and "skilled electrical engineer." The former often becomes the latter with just a few years of additional education.
What fraction of human beings alive today do you think could generate something that plausibly looks like SPICE code? What fraction of those could "with some handholding (or, rather, explicit statements of how to fix the circuits) ... get closer to something functional?" What fraction could give "some justification for how it connected the nodes of each individual device?"
my biology teacher was a nun and we certainly never skipped the chapter on evolution.
The Catholic church officially endorses evolution. It's a subset of evangelical protestants who don't believe in evolution, because they believe in biblical literalism and sola scriptura (the Bible alone is the highest authority). So to these kinds of evangelical protestants, "seven days" literally means seven days, end of story.
Because race is an extremely noisy and inconsistent proxy for other things we might care about like culture and genetics. As I asked above, I'm genuinely unclear what OP means by "race" and what qualifies as interracial. This is because the concept is so un-rigorous.
It's like if I decided to separate all dogs into four "races" of dogs as follows:
Race 1: yellow labs
Race 2: black labs
Race 3: dogs with short tails
Race 4: all other dogs
Technically this is a valid way to classify dogs into 4 categories. And these categories are undeniably correlated with things like genetics. But the correlation is tenuous and arbitrary to the point that this classification schema has minimal utility.
The statistics OP linked appear to consider "Hispanic" a race for purposes of measuring interracial marriage rates.
What is an interracial marriage? Serious question.
Am I in an interracial marriage? I genuinely don't know. According to 23 and me I'm 100% Northern European genetically. My wife was born in Mexico, where her family has lived for generations, and only moved to the states as a teenager. She attended the same law school as me, and received a "Hispanic" scholarship I would not have been eligible for. Her workplace counts her as a "woman of color" for diversity reporting purposes. According to 23 and me, she's at least 75% European. She has dark hair, but her skin tone is indistinguishable from mine (both pale white).
I'm friends with a married couple consisting of a Korean man and a Taiwanese woman. Are they in an interracial marriage? They're considered the same "race" in the US but if they lived in Taiwan or Korea their marriage would be viewed as something like "interracial." Their backgrounds are quite culturally, linguistically, and genetically different.
I'm friends with a married couple consisting of a Gujrati Indian man and a European white woman. Are they in an interracial marriage? Their skin colors are quite different, but they are both of Indo-European ancestry and not much farther apart genetically than two random Europeans would be.
If Barack Obama is 50% African and 50% European, and if his wife is 80% African and 20% European, are they in an interracial marriage? If Barack Obama was instead 20% African and 80% European would it be an interracial marriage?
Edit: Remembered another example from my own life. I'm friends with a married couple consisting of a white (Northern European) man and a white woman of Sami (aka Laplander) ancestry. Are they in an interracial marriage? Visually they just look like two white people. But Sami do not have Indo-European ancestry, so this couple is more genetically distant than a couple where one partner is Indian and the other European.
The short answer is that Musk has positioned himself as red tribe or at least anti-blue-tribe, whereas Chappelle has positioned himself as more like heterodox blue tribe.
The average view I hear about Chappelle from blue tribe people I know is something like "his latest stuff has been in bad taste and his quality has gone downhill lately, but he's still a comedy legend and Chappelle's Show was amazing." This type of person would still go to a Chappelle standup show, in the same way someone might go to a Paul McCartney concert even if they don't like any of the music McCartney has put out since the 70s.
The average view I hear about Musk from blue tribe people I know is "he's a narcissistic rich manbaby whose family owned slaves or something." In other words, just uniformly negative.
So I think there's a decent sized slice of the blue tribe that likes Chappelle but hates Musk.
I thought he left the suitcases' contents in hotel rooms but allegedly kept and used the suitcases themselves?
I think most of what gets labeled “neocolonialism” is not colonialism and is basically a good thing. Global trade has lifted enormous numbers of people out of extreme poverty in the past few decades.
If you hold that consensual transactions are generally good, whereas non-consensual taking is generally bad, then there needn't be any tension between opposing colonialism and supporting open borders.
As you note, colonialism violates people's individual rights by one group subjugating another against their will, expropriating their rightful property and reducing or eliminating their rights.
An immigrant entering a country need not do any of these things. He can enter into entirely voluntary transactions to obtain housing, employment, etc. These are transactions where everyone involved is happy to participate and ends up better off; no one's rights are violated.
It is also conceivable that a group of immigrants could band together into a political bloc and use their collective political powers to "colonize" the native population and take away their rights. But there is no particular reason why such an outcome is inevitable or likely. Moreover, such an outcome can occur without any immigration, such as if a country's native protestant population banded together to oppress its native Catholic population. The free movement of people across borders does not require the formation of group identities nor does it require any group to oppress any other group.
I'd argue many of the great enduring works are subversive. The Christian gospels are extremely subversive works in many ways. Everyone thinks Jesus is marching into Jerusalem to take the throne as "king of the Jews," but his real purpose there is to be tortured to death like a common criminal. "The last shall be first, and the first shall be last." The gospels are loaded with stuff subverting the religious and cultural expectations of the time and place.
There's nothing wrong with deciding "this person is so aggravating I don't want to have to read their thoughts ever again".
I do think there's something wrong with deciding that. I think it's definitely counter to the ethos of TheMotte, which as far as I can tell basically boils down to: (1) engage with arguments rather than people, and (2) an argument's validity depends on the facts and reasoning used to defend it, not how "gross" or "aggravating" the argument is. You're not obligated to respond to every user, but if you post here I think you should at least feel obligated to read all the non-rule-breaking responses to your post (especially the "aggravating" ones). We're supposed to seriously engage with criticism here.
It didn't go away, but it lost its cache after about 2010. When I went to college in the 00s, the way to virtue signal was to bike everywhere on a fixed-gear bicycle, carry re-useable hemp grocery bags, put anti-bush and anti-war buttons and stickers on everything you own, volunteer to plant trees and other "carbon offsets," try (and probably fail) to go vegan, and learn to play the banjo or ukulele. People still do this stuff but it's not considered Very Morally Important the way it used to be. The modern equivalent is pronouns in bios, land acknowledgements, etc.

I think it's clear that slavery was economically bad for both the northern and southern states. If slavery had never existed, both the north and the south would have been economically better off in the long run (even if we ignore the economic losses caused by the civil war).
An enslaved person has no incentive to invest in the future; their incentive is to have as low a time preference as possible. There is no point accumulating assets or wealth, since you cannot legally own them. There is little point in accumulating skills, education, or other forms of human capital because you do not own your own labor. This is a system that massively disincentivizes investment and long-term growth. The system may have economically benefitted slave owners, but it was a loss for the US economy as a whole.
More options
Context Copy link