And if God had written Genesis, then he would have known exactly how modern fundamentalists would interpret it. That's the fundamentalist argument: if God didn't want me to interpret it this way, he would have written it differently.
And it's not even difficult to get this from a gloss of Hammurabi's code as translated into English, even without familiarity with the background knowledge, but for some reason when it comes to Genesis people sometimes pretend it's impossible in principle for the text to switch between genres in a similar fashion, and to have been understood to have been doing so at the time by its intended audience.
The difference is that Hammurabi's code was written by a person, whereas Genesis was allegedly written by an all-knowing God who could see the future and could anticipate all the ways in which humans (including far future humans) might conceivably misunderstand his writing. Therefore it stands to reason he would write in the clearest way possible, such that if one takes the text purely at face value, there is no chance of misunderstanding it. If the text is anything other than maximally clear, it implies either that God was ok with tricking people, or that God didn't write it.
I think you are missing two important points.
The first is that evangelicals believe the Bible and Christianity are one-in-the-same. There is nothing you need to learn about Christianity outside the Bible, other than perhaps things that God might communicate to you directly. If an organization or authority figure says something that seems to be in tension with the literal text of the Bible, then the authority figure is wrong because the Bible is infallible.
The second point is that, irrespective of what people think now, most believing Christians and Jews throughout history believed Genesis was literally true. So there are only three possibilities:
- Those people in the past were right,
- Those people in the past were wrong because God wrote the Bible in a deliberately misleading way knowing that it would trick them into believing something untrue, or
- The Bible is not the word of God.
I probably should have said "Every single Word in Scripture is literally correct and not misleading." They don't dispute that metaphors exist, but unless something it clearly metaphorical it shouldn't be interpreted as such. God wouldn't leave room for ambiguity about what is metaphorical.
And I can say for certain that people do in fact believe this, because me and many people I knew believed this when I was an evangelical teenager.
Usually they do in fact follow that part of the bible as well, but they understand it to mean that they shouldn't preach during church services, not that they shouldn't give talks.
It's pretty simple. If every word of the Bible is literally true, then evolution cannot be true. So if you want to believe every word of the Bible is literally true, then you need to deny evolution.
On the other hand, if every word of the Bible is not literally true, how can it have been written by a loving and all-knowing God who wants people to believe in him? Surely such a God would not put deliberate errors or sources of confusion in the Bible. He has omnipotent power and can use that power to write a perfectly clear book, so why wouldn't he? If it turns out large portions of the Bible are false, doesn't that imply it is not, in fact, divinely inspired at all? And therefore all this Christianity stuff is hokum?
It's not that men offered to carry women's books as a way to impress her (or her parents). It's that men were socially expected to offer to carry heavy objects like books for women, and if the man happened to be attracted to the woman then this interaction would also present a good opportunity to flirt with her.
- Prev
- Next

To be clear, the positions I am articulating are the positions I held when I was an evangelical, but not positions I currently hold. I am not a believing Christian anymore, in large part, because I find these evangelical arguments unconvincing. I am just trying to be responsive to OP's request that someone defend the position.
I will try to write a longer response in a few days when I have more time, but I think this point is getting to the heart of the matter:
The core thing that is attractive to people about the evangelical worldview is that it explicitly rejects the idea that the world is messy, confusing, or hard to understand. In the evangelical worldview, the Bible is really all you need to know, and as long as you follow God's instructions, everything will be fine. Confusion comes from either Satan tricking people or people tricking themselves in an effort to logic their way out of following God. This is why atheists in evangelical movies always believe in God but have some sort of vendetta against him. Their premise is that the evangelical worldview is easy to understand and obvious to everyone; only by playing logic games can people attempt to escape its unmistakable truth.
More options
Context Copy link