naraburns
nihil supernum
No bio...
User ID: 100
Can we talk about Rebekah Jones? Should we? I'm honestly incredibly conflicted about these questions. One of the rules of the Motte is that we shouldn't weakman:
There are literally millions of people on either side of every major conflict, and finding that one of them is doing something wrong or thoughtless proves nothing and adds nothing to the conversation. We want to engage with the best ideas on either side of any issue, not the worst.
Discussing Jones feels like walking a tightrope (called "meaningful cultural and political issues") that has been strung over an open toxic waste pit (called "are my political opponents just mentally ill?"). Out of sheer both-sides-ism I want to say "there are surely equally bizarre figures in right wing politics" but I can't actually find any. The best I can do is to say, suppose you combined Marjorie Taylor Greene's extremism with George Santos' fabulism, then made the resulting chimera guilty of the things Matt Gaetz was only ever rumored to have been guilty of doing--that would get you pretty close to Jones, I think. Except that MTG and Santos and Gaetz aren't darlings of reddit and don't command fawning loyalty from major media outlets, which Jones also does.
As a refresher, I first learned of Jones back in the old subreddit, when someone posted about her COVID activism. I don't remember when I learned of her criminal activities, but to simply quote the Wikipedia:
Jones has had prior criminal charges. At the time the search warrant was executed, Jones was facing an active misdemeanor charge on allegations of cyberstalking a former student of hers who was a romantic partner and publishing sexual details about their relationship online. She was fired from her Florida State University teaching position for threatening to give a failing grade to her romantic partner's roommate. She faced prior charges including felony robbery, trespass, and contempt of court stemming from an alleged violation of a domestic violence restraining order related to the same ex-boyfriend, but those charges were dropped. In 2017, she had been arrested and charged with criminal mischief in the vandalism of his car, but the charges were dropped.
Jones faced criminal charges in Louisiana in 2016 where she was arrested and charged by the LSU Police Department with one count each of battery on a police officer and remaining after forbidden and two counts of resisting arrest after refusing to vacate a Louisiana State University office upon being dismissed from her staff position.
Jones went on to say she was going to run for office in Maryland (IIRC), but when that didn't pan out for unclear reasons, she returned to Florida. I don't know how much she has received in crowdfunding from the anti-DeSantis crowd at this point, but two early efforts pulled over half a million dollars. Jones has continued to hold herself out as a "whistleblower," specifically against the DeSantis administration in Florida, even though these claims appear pretty thoroughly debunked.
"Aha!" You might say. "PolitiFact leans left, and debunks Jones, so even the Left is willing to disavow this nut!"
Sure, maybe, to some extent. She went on to win the 2022 Democrat primary to challenge Matt Gaetz for his seat in the House of Representatives, so at least 16,000 Democrats still preferred Jones to someone with an actual legal education and genuinely relevant experience. And yes--by this logic, some 50,000 Republicans preferred the candidate who was under investigation for sex trafficking minors! It's baffling, I agree. But this is one of those "meaningful cultural and political issues" I mentioned--the only way I can make sense of any of this is to take a deep breath and remind myself that most people lack anything approaching coherent principles, they don't care about these details--they only care to win.
Anyway, that's all just the background!
This morning I woke up with this in my feeds.
If you don't want to read "WhitePeopleTwitter" (and I wouldn't blame you), it is a tweet from Rebekah Jones, followed by others, which I have partly reproduced here:
Today's events will tell a story so enraging, heartbreaking and brutal that I'm sure when I'm ready to tell it, no one will ever defend the Florida governor's actions again.
My family is not safe. My son has been taken on the gov's orders, and I've had to send my husband and daughter out of state for their safety.
THIS is the reality of living in DeSantis' Florida.
There is no freedom here. Only retaliatory rule by a fascist who wishes to be king
A week after we filed our lawsuit against the state, a kid claiming to be the cousin of one of my son's classmates joined their snapchat group. They recorded their conversations, and anonymously reported my son to police for sharing a popular internet meme.
They said they had to complete a threat assessment since they received an anon complaint, which both the local cops and the school signed off on as not being a threat. The kids were joking about cops and video games, which included this meme: [pic of a fat cop with text about waiting for a school shooter to commit suicide]
Two weeks later, bringing us to earlier today, an officer told me the state issued a warrant for my son's arrest for "digital threats of terrorism."
I asked on whose orders. The officer said it was the state.
They aren't letting him come home tonight. They kidnapped my son.
I had to get my husband and daughter out of here because CPS now interprets my home as dangerous because they've charged my 13 year old son with a felony for sharing a meme.
Naturally, Jones also provides links to her crowdfunding platforms of choice. The reddit "discussion" is... predictable? Outrage, occasional people (mostly, but not always, downvoted) asking whether this is legit, very few people posting actual information. Well, proles gonna prole I guess. But the headline in the Miami Herald?
13-year-old son of Rebekah Jones, whistleblower who clashed with DeSantis, arrested over memes
So, that sounds bad! But is it really why he was arrested? In fact it is not. He was arrested for posting stuff like this:
I want to shoot up the school.
If I get a gun I’m gonna shoot up hnms lol.
I’m getting a wrath and natural selection shirt so maybe but I don’t think many ppl know what the columbine shooters look like.
Okay so it’s been like 3-4 weeks since I got on my new antidepressants and they aren’t working but they’re suppose to by now so I have no hope in getting better so why not kill the losers at school.
Does your plug have access to guns?
I always keep a knife on me so maybe I'll just stab people idk
As this information was coming out, Jones added to her tweetstorm:
I've been in contact with members of the press whom I trust. They have the videos of the police at my house, of my son being put in handcuffs, of the officer refusing to let us give him his medication, of my 13 year old autistic kid who can't stand to be touched having to spread his legs before going into the back seat of a police car. All of it.
I haven't been given any documents from the state or police. I asked to take a picture of the paperwork and was told no. All they would tell me was the charge. They didn't even read him his rights when they arrested him.
I'm going to the courthouse today. When we're cleared to, we'll join my family out of state.
And aside to get our things, I'm only coming back to see these people in court.
It's not clear when these events are supposed to have occurred; Max Nordau shared video of Jones delivering her son to the police station. Rather, as this tweet suggests, it appears that "Rebekah Jones tried to blame DeSantis and RAISE MONEY off law enforcement stopping a possible school shooting."
I don't know what Jones' problem ultimately is. Narcissism? Paranoia? DeSantis Derangement Syndrome? That she is a habitual fabulist is well-established. That she has profited substantially from vocal opposition to all things DeSantis is a matter of public record. She is a sufficiently shady known quantity that most really big national news outlets seem reluctant to continue signal-boosting her, but the Miami Herald (by circulation, reportedly Florida's seventh-largest paper) still seems happy to run false headlines at her mere behest.
This seems discussion-worthy, and yet part of me wants to just not even post about it because it seems wrong, somehow, to even discuss Rebekah Jones. Giving her any attention at all feels a bit like encouraging a delusional person to persist in their delusions; she clearly wants notoriety, she doesn't seem capable of handling notoriety in a healthy way, surely it would be best to just stop paying attention to her?
But also, this is a kid talking about doing violence at school, with guns or knives. Is narcissism hereditary? Did his home environment contribute to this? [CONTINUED BELOW]
The question is whether Trump was “continuously” outside of NY.
See my reply to @Gdanning below. Knobel seems to have the same problem as Cruciani; it's about nonresidents.
I am intrigued by the Weinstein case, thanks for pointing it out. The money shot there seems to be:
While defendant does not dispute that he spent 264 days outside New York during the statutory period, he maintains that the toll does not apply to residents of New York and that it only applies to nonresidents.
We disagree. The statute does not distinguish between residents and nonresidents, and had the legislature wanted to limit its reach to the latter it easily could have done so.
But this clearly puts Weinstein at odds with substantial precedent holding that residents and nonresidents are distinguishable under New York statute of limitations laws. I agree with you that the reasoning appears results-based and I'm a little surprised the New York Court of Appeals hasn't made greater efforts to clear this up. Is the law in New York developing toward the idea that statute of limitations laws should not be allowed to interfere with politically important prosecutions?
Hmm. That is interesting and also sounds wildly unconstitutional as a matter of Equal Protection. However, even that case does not seem to be very good precedent given Trump's status as a putative resident of New York for the relevant period. Cruciani goes on to say:
Knobel establishes the tolling rule for nonresidents. This state's appellate courts have not yet had cause to define the tolling rule for residents. One might speculate. The general intent of the relevant limitations laws as to individuals who are outside the state is to account for absences that make it difficult to bring a New York criminal to justice. Those rules might well be different for residents who depart from New York for periods that do not, for practical purposes, prevent the authorities from locating them. For example, a state resident's departure for a brief vacation in South America might be thought irrelevant to the People's ability to arrest him. Even a student's sojourn to Notre Dame or Oxford for years, perhaps interrupted for occasional returns, might not be enough to make the student a "nonresident" and thus toll a limitations period. It may be that CPL 30.10 (4) (a) (i), dealing with continuous absences, will be thought to have no applicability to residents. The courts could conclude that absences from New York of residents of the state should instead be assessed solely under CPL 30.10 (4) (a) (ii). That provision tolls the running of a limitations statute only when "the whereabouts of the defendant were continuously unknown and continuously unascertainable by the exercise of reasonable diligence."
From Wikipedia:
The three-story penthouse at Trump Tower was Trump's primary residence from November 1983 until September 2019, when he designated Mar-a-Lago as his primary residence.
Trump's presidency is much more like a student's sojourn to Oxford for years, than it is like an alien committing a crime in a jurisdiction and then fleeing. I appreciate you bringing this case to my attention, but my reading is that it still falls short of the precedent the prosecutor needs here.
EDIT: See @zeke5123's responses to me below and above. I agree that the Weinstein case appears to be persuasive against Trump (though certainly not binding precedent!), so I appreciate having it pointed out. I think it is interesting that the Weinstein case appears to have also been substantially driven by politics rather than by the rule of law.
My understanding is that there is New York precedent for this. The practice is probably unconstitutional as an equal protection violation, but that would end up at SCOTUS.
What precedent?
Cuomo's executive order 202.8 and subsequent orders purporting to pause the statute of limitations from March to November of 2020 (in response to COVID) is the only thing that seems like it might be relevant, here, and even assuming those orders actually expanded the statute of limitations would only squeeze about half of the actions in the indictment into the timeframe. I don't think 202.8 etc. properly apply--see Baker v. 40 Wall St. Holdings Corp., 74 Misc. 3d 381 (Sup. Ct., Kings Co. 2022):
Plaintiff’s counsel misinterprets the Brash decision, which explains that the Governor did not toll all statutes of limitation, but only suspended them, due to the COVID-19 Pandemic, and that he terminated the suspension on November 3, 2020. Here, the statute of limitations did not run until April 30, 2021, and as such, was not affected in any way by the Governor’s Executive Orders. The court is cognizant that several court decisions have interpreted Brash as plaintiff’s counsel has, but is not bound by them, and does not agree with those interpretations.
But even 202.8 etc. do apply as those other decisions held, this is going to take a ruling from New York's Court of Appeals at minimum, and it still won't apply to everything in the indictment.
Have you got anything stronger than that?
From Lawfare's account of the arraignment
How the hell is the statute of limitations not featured front-and-center in every analysis of the New York case? It seems to me that this is by far the most serious "calendar issue" on offer. The indictment itself, on its face, cannot possibly go to trial under any sane and impartial judge. Even if you accept the underdeveloped theory elevating prima facie misdemeanors to felonies, the statute of limitations on the relevant felonies is five years, for acts alleged to have occurred almost six years ago.
I have read claims--though importantly, still no actual legal documents!--that the prosecutor will argue that Trump was not personally residing in New York for most of that time, and that the statute of limitations tolls while he's President. But there is no statutory support or judicial precedent for this. Statutes of limitations typically toll when it is impossible to serve process on someone, usually because they have fled the jurisdiction and cannot reasonably be found (i.e. they're dodging service). To the contrary: precedent is that nothing in the law prevents service of process against a sitting president. The Justice Department does not prosecute sitting presidents, but can (and does) investigate them, and can charge them later for crimes committed while in office. So there is no legal support--beyond partisan abuse of process--for tolling the statute of limitations on a state crime just because the accused holds federal office.
This is the stuff of summary judgment (though again, only assuming the New York judiciary isn't also willing to simply cast off the rule of law so long as doing so seems to harm Trump in some way, which may be too much to assume)--meaning if the New York stuff actually goes to trial, justice will already be shown to be inoperative in Trump's case.
Now, the classified documents and the Georgia stuff are something else, and should be considered in light of the specific circumstances of each potential case. But I have a hard time imagining the judges of New York to be so unhinged as to just steamroll the statute of limitations in pursuit of Trump. Even if the trial court judge goes along with it, I would expect Trump's legal team to immediately appeal, potentially all the way to SCOTUS, just for a summary judgment. Since this is a pure question of law, there is no dispute on the relevant facts (dates offered), and even going to trial would constitute a preventable harm, I cannot see this case ever making it to trial. If it does, it will greatly strengthen my priors against the long-term viability of the United States continuing to exist as a single nation, because it will be strong evidence that the courts of New York have degenerated to "kangaroo" status.
Consider this law review note from 1924. With specific reference to Constitutional questions, the author writes:
The stuff of these contests are facts, and judgment upon facts. Every tendency to deal with them abstractedly, to formulate them in terms of sterile legal questions, is bound to result in sterile conclusions unrelated to actualities. The reports are strewn with wrecks of legislation considered in vacuo and torn out of the context of life which evoked the legislation and alone made it intelligible. These are commonplaces. But they are the heart of the matter of American constitutional law. A failure scrupulously and persistently to observe these commonplaces jeopardizes the traditional American constitutional system more than all the loose talk about "usurpation."
...
The Supreme Court is not a House of Lords with revisory power over legislation, although conservative scholars have suggested that the Supreme Court frankly assume the function implicit in some of its decisions. As part of the ritual of traditional theory, the Supreme Court professes to defer greatly to the legislature.6 Such deference is not merely a gesture of courtesy. It is the formulation of a basic truth in the distribution of governmental power.
...
It must be remembered that advisory opinions are not merely advisory opinions. They are ghosts that slay.
In other words--you're not wrong! It's just that decades and centuries of accumulated legal tradition is stacked against you. Consequently the American legal system, at least, is likely to respond to your question with an invitation--"okay, but since you're the one proposing the change, the burden of persuasion is on you." If you can convince the legislature of your state (assuming you are American) to widely accept advisory opinions, they can do so! At the federal level, however, it would require a constitutional amendment to abolish the "cases and controversies" requirement.
Without generating an incident that goes to court, can someone ask for the court or courts to make a ruling based on current law if there isn't an existing one (or rather, a clear one)?
In the U.S.--not if it's the federal government. Some state governments do permit advisory opinions in certain cases.
If not, why not?
Because the federal court system exists to try "cases or controversies." Some state systems are also limited in this way by their state constitutions.
I'm trying to understand why we can't address unknowns in the legal system sans a court case.
One reason is because, on modern separation-of-powers theory, this is not the job of the legal system, but the legislature. The court is there to resolve specific disputes, not to make law generally. (I believe this is a bit different in civil law systems, but I am not an expert in comparative law.)
To your example:
My understanding of copyright law, for example, is that there has never been a ruling about the legality of all the meme clips people post online w/o permission from the media owners. Nothing explicitly about that, anyways. Can someone ask for a legal review of that practice?
The short answer is no, because copyright is a federal issue and per the Constitution federal courts cannot issue advisory opinions.
it doesn't go far enough in developing a positive public perception of Jews
What bothers me about extant accounts of rampant anti-semitism (in the United States) is the same thing that bothers me about claims like "police are murdering unarmed black men by the thousands"--they're just empirically false. Anti-semitism (in the sense of being anti-Jew) is indeed rampant in many countries in the Middle East--and yet Americans are much more likely to report unfavorable feelings toward evangelicals, and much less likely to report favorable feelings toward Muslims... and so on, and so forth. In fact, in the U.S. no religion is viewed more favorably, on balance, than Jews.
I don't much care about the Holocaust. I don't deny that it happened, I certainly do not share your doubts (as I've encountered them in the past, anyway) about most of the empirical claims made by prominent historians on these matters. But I do think the Holocaust was not special. Wholesale slaughter of ethnic, religious, and political outgroups is the story of human history, and Jews are neither the most recent victims, nor the most numerous. I think it is a better world where we are driven to do that sort of thing less, preferably never, and to whatever extent "Holocaust education" creates that world, I don't have any serious complaints about it. But I do find it absurd to lean on past slaughters in pursuit of present aims. I had nothing to do with slavery in the American South, I had nothing to do with World War II. The people still fighting those battles, from whatever side they fight them, are boring to me.
Literally just take out his game of footsy with election denial and I would argue it'd lower the temperature.
This seems like an odd response given my demonstration that it was election denial from the Democrats that was the serious political defection of 2016.
Honestly I think Trump's Twitter belligerence does far more to distinguish him from (most of) his opponents, than his so-called "election denial." I think there's a very real possibility that I'm just wrong about all of this--that my sense of the Democratic revolt of 2016 is pure presentism, that this is all "business as usual" in American politics, and I am caught in the same trap as many of the people I am criticizing: thinking that any of this is really a meaningful departure from business-as-usual. So I have done my best to make the case that the Great Awokening is a meaningful phenomenon, and that the first presidential election post-Awokening is meaningfully different. If it is in fact Trump himself who is meaningfully different, that would be interesting; I really do suspect he's a symptom rather than a cause, but I could be wrong about that, too. It's just that "election denial" does not appear to set him apart from any of his political opposition, as demonstrated with direct quotes in my post.
But I think it's unlikely they would have been impeached or criminally indicted.
Maybe! There were efforts to impeach Bush; probably depending on what you count as "efforts" there have been at least some efforts to impeach many U.S. presidents. I still see occasional digs from the American Left to the effect of "here's your periodic reminder that Bush and Cheney are guilty of war crimes and should be in prison." So what gets us across the threshold of "generic anti-opposition talk" to "concrete action," at this point?
The threshold does seem to be lower, now. It seems to me that, compared to 30 or 40 years ago, we spend a lot less time talking about what would actually be good for the country, policy-wise, and a lot more time insisting that the opposition's plans are actually illegal, that the opposition belongs in jail, etc. Trump certainly played his own part in that ("lock her up!") but he backed away from it after election. We're now more than halfway through his successor's first term and Democrats in power in New York (not coincidentally, I think, the state that elected Hillary Clinton as Senator!) are actually carrying through efforts to jail Trump on what so far appear to be exaggerated charges. Can a kangaroo court be far behind?
Watching the news media take shots at DeSantis in advance of his anticipated run at the White House, with headlines like "Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis is a Far More Dangerous Politician than Donald Trump" is interesting. Discussions of a national divorce are also not entirely novel in American political history. My worry is that the Left, which has for most of the 21st century been warning America of encroaching fascism, has decided to beat its opponents to the punch on the matter.
"Trumped-up charges" is looking to become the most consequential case of nominative determinism in American history.
Everything is working on my end. @ZorbaTHut, might it be related to this?
Well, now that we are actually having a substantive conversation about it:
The explanation cannot be merely that he won the 2016 election, since many of the other people you mention (Clinton, Bush, Obama, Biden) also won presidential elections.
I personally think the character of the 2016 election matters a lot to this calculus. Hillary Clinton's election was supposed to not only be a sure thing, but the ushering in of a new era: America's First Woman President. And post-awokening, people didn't just want this to be true (as they perhaps wanted it to be true decades earlier)--a large number of people (especially young, especially female, especially college-educated types) felt entitled to it. When Al Gore lost in 2000, the brouhaha over Florida was wild--and yet there was nothing like this happening, at least not where I could see it.
It made for a sobering contrast with 2008, when America's First Black President won his own anticipated victory. Even country music stars were singing his praises. In a nation that has become culturally obsessed with "firsts," with shattering "glass ceilings," and with otherwise celebrating people not for what they actually contribute, but merely for their membership in politically important minorities, 2016 was not a defeat--it was a heist. No less important a figure than former president Jimmy Carter said:
There’s no doubt that the Russians did interfere in the election, and I think the interference, although not yet quantified, if fully investigated would show that Trump didn’t actually win the election in 2016. He lost the election, and he was put into office because the Russians interfered on his behalf.
The much celebrated congressman from Georgia, John Lewis, skipped the inauguration, saying:
I don't see this president-elect as a legitimate president.... I think the Russians participated in helping this man get elected. And they helped destroy the candidacy of Hillary Clinton.
No wonder there were peaceful but fiery protests come inauguration time. The list goes on, but the point is that Democrats did not respond to Clinton's loss in a normal way. Florida's 2000 problems were bad, but at least they were Florida's problems--they were not specifically cultural problems, or problems caused by one or both of the candidates seeking victory at any price. There was a legitimate dispute based on plausible evidence. What happened in 2016, though, was a defection; Democrats responded by abandoning even a pretense of respecting the rule of law. For them to lose was no longer a political setback, but a failure of democracy! Catastrophe! Devastation! Revolution!
The parallel case of 2020 simply cannot be understood outside that context. Reactionaries gonna react. When you slap the "defect" button in an iterated game, your opponent is all but guaranteed to follow suit, and in this case I think that is substantially what Republicans did.
Maybe Trump's personality makes this all worse, somehow. Maybe it wouldn't be so bad if Clinton had lost instead to Rubio or something. But then again--would Clinton have lost, to anyone else? Trump's ability to rally disaffected blue collar labor and increase the Republican share of black and Hispanic votes proved important. So it's difficult to guess how things might have been different, absent Trump.
But it does seem to me that Democrats were much more interested in (and expectant of) a Clinton victory; until he won, Trump was, to them, a joke (at least mostly). Losing the election is one thing; even casting protest votes in Congress against certifying a presidential election has become old hat despite the breathlessness with which the media reported on it in 2020. But being denied the apparent moral victory of being personally involved in electing America's First Woman President was (for many) apparently so, so much more than just another loss. It was, one might say, a crime.
The mod team has discussed this comment in response to a couple of user reports. The result is mixed. I am explicitly not giving you a warning at this time--but I need to say a little more about that, because we are probably going to be dialing up the sensitivity on posts like this in the near future.
This is connected with @Amadan's moderation of @firmamenti and @cjet79's partial modhat comment about it. Since moving over from reddit, moderation has gotten both easier and more difficult in interesting ways. We have far fewer bad drive-by comments and much less brigading from trolls (although, importantly--not zero troll brigading!). We seem to have more users paying attention to AAQCs, both in terms of crafting them and in terms of nominating them, such that many excellent posts don't make the roundup simply because there are so many plausible nominations. These are positive developments!
On the downside, though, low effort comments from more regular users also seem to be turning up more frequently. There is a tendency to rely on shorthand arguments that are both low effort and obfuscatory for new users. This is understandable--as the community coheres it can often feel like certain individuals are just re-treading old ground. But that is something we want to try to mitigate. In this particular comment, your substantive position (that the primary impetus for targeting Trump is purely political, as evidenced by the ceaseless barrage of unusual, contorted, or even spurious charges raised against him) seems defensible, but the way you raise it as though it were obviously true (implicitly building consensus), without furnishing either evidence or argument, brooks no discussion on the matter. That is antithetical to the foundation of the Motte.
I will be writing a longer top post about low-effort posts in the near-ish future, but it seemed worth mentioning here to get people thinking a bit about the problem, hopefully.
High rat (95-99).
The flavor text saying I'm "almost definitely...a programmer" is a little funny since I am definitely no such thing. I do think the apparent overlap between computer science types and philosophy/politics/economics circles is interesting, though.
How long have you been together?
2 years.
So yeah, sounds like she's dealing with the end of the "euphoric" stage. This is more concerning, though:
She has become disillusioned with "companionate love" as well. We call it unconditional love which she claims does not exist.
These are very different things. The standard reductive view on "altruism" is that there's no such thing, because every example you can give, someone else can explain a way as not really selfless. Even the paradigmatic "parent throws themself in front of a bus to save a child" can be explained as "pro-social behavior geared toward benefitting one's own bloodline through the development of a personal legacy" or somesuch. I think it was the philosopher David Hume who suggested that this kind of reductive analysis is unhelpful--our analysis must stop somewhere. But of course these ideas are certainly out there.
But companionate love can still be "conditional" in these ways. The entanglements of responsibilities toward others are often burdensome but they are also widely regarded as essential to a flourishing life. Having children is a lot of work, and yet it is (in my experience) rewarding work. Having good familial relationships often requires a high degree of tolerance, compromise, and forgiveness, and yet familial relationships are usually the most reliable and lasting--and beneficial--of all. Chris Gowans writes a bit about this in his book "Innocence Lost," if I remember correctly--basically he notes that even though there are times when we feel absolutely burdened by even our very good relationships, it is morally important for us to experience and bear such burdens, but also to be aware of when, and to what extent, it's okay for us to put them down anyway. The movie "A Monster Calls" is an exploration of this very idea through the eyes of a child losing a parent to illness.
Now, this bit does sound suspiciously like a woman who is either already cheating, or is exploring the possibility:
As for a one-to-one man-woman relationship, there is an inevitable expectation of returned favours and feelings. Love by its very nature cannot stand by itself. Love always needs a giver and a receiver, someone who loves and someone who is eager to be loved. In my ‘past-life’ love-relationships, my dreams of how I wanted to live life were automatically intertwined with the man I loved – as a woman I gave him the responsibility for my happiness and I expected him to do the same.
Many people describe companionate love as each partner being the other's highest priority. Certainly relationships come with expectations! But the idea that this is a bad thing seems like a red flag to me. It just might instead be a particularly clumsy way of characterizing the end of the "euphoric" stage, which would be less to worry about.
Nobody else is responsible for my becoming happy and nobody is standing in the way of my becoming happy.
I think this is just wrong. Here is one of my most highly upvoted comments on reddit ever:
Humans are social animals. Isolation, as a rule, is bad for our mental health.
To the extent that this is saying, "you don't always have to be in a romantic relationship to have a fulfilling life," it's a good reminder. But with very few exceptions, most people are incapable of being happy while living their lives truly alone. Our brains, for the most part, aren't wired that way. And telling someone that they need to learn to be happy alone before they can be happy together will often only worsen their depression, because they start to take their inability to be happy alone as a sign that they will never be happy at all--
When in fact they would be truly happy if they weren't so alone.
Put a little differently--it may not be your responsibility to make her happy, per se, but if she sees no reason to at least occasionally make personal sacrifices for your happiness, and you see no reason to make similar sacrifices for hers, then you don't really have a relationship anymore--you're just two people sharing a house. Even friends regard themselves as at least minimally responsible, in context-bound ways, for one another's happiness and well-being; otherwise, how are they friends?
We are enjoying each other's company but I miss the heady feelings of the old days.
This is normal; this is how the euphoria stage ends. It can be recaptured at times, with effort. If this is your only real complaint, then you just have to work through it (hopefully with each other's loving help--that seems like a reasonable responsibility to think you have toward one another!). But I have certainly seen relationships where the end of the euphoria stage was accompanied by a drastic reduction in sexual congress, which is totally unnecessary and frequently kills marriages. Communication is important, but don't mistake words for communication. What you've shared so far from your wife is a lot of words that don't say much of practical value. So far I am about half convinced that she still loves you but doesn't know what love is, or doesn't understand how important interpersonal relationships actually are to her because she has internalized a radically individualist mindset that is complete empirical bullshit.
Not enough context, I think. How old were you when you met? How long have you been together?
It is pretty well-documented that the giddy-in-love feelings that have historically inspired longing poetry and outrageous demonstrations of devotion tend to last months, maybe all of two years. It is also pretty well-documented that the cessation of those feelings tends to be a real come-down moment for a lot of people (this is a major contributor to marriages ending after less than 5 years). If you Google "stages of love" there are many further breakdowns you can find, with varying degrees of empirical backing, but--
Not everyone parses stage changes the same way, and your wife may be essentially coming to terms with the fact that she's past the euphoric stage, but it's quite a natural thing. (The evo-psych gloss is that it's a feeling that exists to produce children, since in the giddy-in-love phase, all most people want to do is canoodle--but the natural result of such behavior is offspring, which give you a different and more important reason to continue working together in the "companionate love" phase.)
The risk for people who don't understand this natural progression (or who spit in Mother Nature's face regarding the natural step of creating offspring) is that they think "real" love is limited to the euphoric stage, and they just want to get that same experiential hit over and over again. Whether this manifests in genuine cheating, requests for an "open" marriage, the pursuit of polyamory, etc. will depend a lot on a person's sophistication, self control, commitment to other priorities (i.e. children, long term financial plans), and so forth.
Women do have a greater tendency than men to seek to verbalize all of these feelings and want to "work through" them, which can sometimes result in men feeling like there is a crisis when actually it's just women doing socializing things. The proliferation of "self help" books is "Exhibit A" for that argument, I think. Your wife seems pretty loquacious, poetic even, but not especially sophisticated, at least in her grasp of her own feelings. Almost everyone goes hunting for "meaning" or their "true self" at some point, but those aren't things you find; they're things you choose, one way or another.
If you've been together for more than, say, 5 or 10 years, though, most of what I've written here will be of limited application.
Dunno, but it looks like a ferrofluid reacting to an audio speaker. I think it is a default image that came with the codebase?
Several of us on the mod team have played around with AI image generation and probably that image will eventually be replaced with a motte of some kind, possibly many different mottes in rotation. But as a purely cosmetic enhancement it's not really a top priority for our limited coding resources right now.
Lol what? Did you have a stroke?
Don't post like this please.
This is unnecessarily antagonistic.
Checking your mod notes, it looks like you actually wrote this comment before Amadan modded you for this one (assuming the system isn't lying to me and I read the notifications correctly) but you have put yourself in the difficult position of having multiple bad comments showing up in the mod queue very shortly after eating a ban.
And most of this is downstream of a post that you entitled "Da Jooz totally did it (Negro communism edition)." Like--we get it. You're so edgy! But being deliberately edgy is not really the proper vibe here.
The rest of the post (which I didn't see until post-edit, so it's possible I've missed some things) is not, like, egregiously awful, though it is somewhat evidence-light and "boo outgroup" heavy. But there is a saying about glass houses and stones that I think kind of applies, in a "don't be egregiously obnoxious" sort of way. Posting Chinese-robber type reasoning is always on shaky ground, but when you then follow that up with antagonism toward those who raise questions, this is corrosive to the conceit that we are here to test our shady thinking. I appreciate the retraction in response to the rather decisive empirical counter that was raised against you, but that, too, does not undo the other mistakes you're making more generally.
I'm not going to ban you this time, and I'm not even going to give you a topic ban, but please understand that this kind of posting is exactly why per-user topic bans are so tempting to me. At some point it's like--we get it, you think the Jews are to blame for at least a large chunk of societal ills, but you've shown yourself to be so certain of this that when you post about it, no one can even politely pretend to believe that you are in any way persuadable on the matter. I understand that this is often true of many things people post, but in the spirit of "tone-not-content" and charitable interpretation, we do our best to assume that arguments are being offered in good faith! But that faith is defeasible, and you erode it with posts like this, which in turn strips you of that protection in your other posts.
Next time, you will get a ban, and it's unlikely to be short.
@Rambler beat me to it--if you told me this was written by a language model, I'd be inclined to believe you.
In particular, I notice a lot of deepity happening here--but also more than a little rhetorical sleight of hand:
Across the globe, roughly half of the population identifies as the folkloric entity known as "woman", while the other half identifies as "man".
This seems like a slightly poetic way of saying something true, until you think for a minute and realize it's almost certainly false. Trivially, these are the English words for adult human females and adult human males, and most people don't speak English. That's a shallow objection but worth noticing in part because you've specified a domain--"across the globe"--but you're handling a concept that you are asserting is culture-bound, like language. And this is before we get to the notion of the verb "identifies." What does it mean? Do adult Japanese males "identify" as "otoko" or "dansei" or "yatsu?" I don't speak Japanese but I bet there are some fun academic debates over there about this. Do all adult human males who do not wish they were female "identify" as "man?" Likewise, females as "woman?" Well, no, actually, at least some so not.
The word "folkloric" is just question-begging.
A small but vocal minority identifies as "trans", which challenges the traditional binary understanding of gender.
What's weird about this claim is that it is not only false, it is shockingly false by the lights of trans advocacy. The vast majority of "trans" people clearly reify the traditional binary understanding of gender; they simply decouple it from biological sex. Males seek to make themselves "trans women" by performing (usually, caricatured) displays of what the relevant culture associates with "women." Females seek to make themselves "trans men" in the other direction (though in my experience "trans men" tend instead to downplay any femininity more often than they up-play masculinity). There are some "non-binary" and "genderfluid" types out there who violate this trend, but these seem to be a small minority of the people identifying as "trans."
While some may argue that this is a new and untested phenomenon, human beings have always sought to understand and define themselves in relation to others.
This sentence seeks to undermine the claim that "this is a new and untested phenomenon" with a total non sequitur. Whether people have ever before sought to define themselves in relation to others is irrelevant to whether this phenomenon is new and/or untested.
It is difficult to find evidence that supports the existence of gender as a distinct and measurable phenomenon.
This is a complete fabrication. There are thousands, perhaps millions of social science studies on gender as a distinct and measurable phenomenon.
Rather, it seems to be a concept that is based largely on societal norms, expectations and how one feels about themselves.
All of these things are measurable.
While these norms may vary across cultures and time periods, they are not inherently biological in nature.
They do actually seem to be rooted in biology. Gender norms do differ in time and place and culture, and yet the reproductive aspects of sex and sexuality are clear in gender norms in ever human civilization that has ever existed. The close association of women with children, for example, is inherently biological: without modern chemical intervention, men in the ordinary course do not lactate. How cultures handle this fact varies, but is always rooted in biology. That is just one of many items for consideration.
Gender is a social construct and feeling that is often deeply ingrained in our consciousness.
How can it be both of these things? This seems incoherent. Some feelings are clearly deeply ingrained in human consciousness--hunger, for example. Hot and cold. Sexual desire, probably, at least for many people. How can something as contingent as a social construct be "deeply ingrained in our consciousness?" It's nonsense.
However, it is important to strive towards a more nuanced and inclusive understanding of gender identity, rather than simply accepting the status quo.
Why? What makes it important?
In many ways, gender can be viewed as a type of religion - one that has been passed down through generations and shapes our understanding of ourselves and others. As with any religion, it is important to approach it with an open mind and a willingness to challenge our assumptions and beliefs. Only by doing so can we hope to gain a deeper and more nuanced understanding of ourselves and the world around us.
If by "gender" you mean "the social expectations that come along with one's biological sex," like--sure, we've been challenging those things for centuries. Women dressed as men to attend Plato's Academy in ancient Greece. Shakespeare wrote plays including this stuff. But in my experience it is not trans advocates approaching these issues with an open mind or a willingness to challenge their assumptions and beliefs. In the late 20th century, a host of educational and business opportunities were opened to women that never had been before. The world we live in today has discarded swathes of traditional cultural expectations touching on sex and gender. I think some people have benefited, and I think some people have been harmed. On balance, I'm pretty comfortable with the idea that individuals should be as free as possible, modulo compatibility with like freedoms for others. In most contexts, I don't care how people dress or whether they wear makeup.
But also in most contexts, I have very little reason to play along when an adult human male wearing a dress and a wig tells me he's a "woman" (or worse, a "girl")--especially if he is demanding special treatment ordinarily afforded to females for what are, in fact, biologically grounded reasons.
Bouncing checks?
I first hear this phrase used to describe the ending of Lost (the TV show)--the writers wrote a bunch of narrative checks that failed to clear, or words to that effect. I thought it was apt. I think, as long as Rothfuss and Martin fail to deliver on their promises, they are meaningfully blameworthy. I appreciate Neil Gaiman coming to Martin's defense ("George Martin is not your bitch" or whatever he said) but the only reason I have to respect Gaiman's opinion on the matter is that Gaiman finishes what he starts, so his white knighting here turns out to be a bit self-undermining. Whatever people want to say about muses or mental health or whatever--I'm not saying Martin deserves the electric chair, or even a small fine. I'm saying he and Rothfuss are morally on par with people who have written checks while failing to deposit sufficient funds for those checks to clear.
Perhaps my lifetime of internet fiction has raised my tolerance for unfinished stories.
Perhaps! But also it's a very small thing, in a world of big things. I rarely think about it, except in the context of people finishing books. Most writers don't--new writers, yes, of course, but also, often, successful authors who clearly could (they've done it before!), if they actually cared enough to try.
You've just described, like, 81% of the American public.
Among lawyers, I wouldn't be surprised if that figure asymptotically approached 99%. It seems like every lawyer I meet is an aspiring author--and not just the English undergrads who went to law school because they failed to write their novel.
This even applies to successful authors--George R.R. Martin and Patrick Rothfuss are in the midst of doing the literary equivalent of bouncing checks to their readership. It turns out that spending ungodly sums of money on whatever strikes your fancy is way more fun than writing more books.
In connection with graduate school, I often give the advice "don't go to graduate school unless you simply can't see yourself doing anything else." I think something similar applies to writing, except in graduate school at least you have some structure and feedback built into the process. Until it is the thing that you have to do, you will probably never become a writer.
Certain beliefs and practices should only be formed as a result of rebellion against society, and never be taught directly by authority figures.
I agree. Have you read Neal Stephenson's Diamond Age? I would not call this the thesis of that book, exactly, but it is certainly hinted at very strongly. A couple of quotes:
“The ragged bohemian life holds no charm for you anymore. But would you have reached your current position if you had not lived that life when you were younger?”
“Now that you put it that way,” Carl said, “I agree that we might try to make some provision, in the future, for young bohemians—”
“It wouldn't work,” Finkle-McGraw said. “I've been thinking about this for years. I had the same idea: Set up a sort of young artistic bohemian theme park, sprinkled around in all the major cities, where young New Atlantans who were so inclined could congregate and be subversive when they were in the mood. The whole idea was self-contradictory.”
And:
“The Vickys have an elaborate code of morals and conduct. It grew out of the moral squalor of an earlier generation, just as the original Victorians were preceded by the Georgians and the Regency. The old guard believe in that code because they came to it the hard way. They raise their children to believe in that code—but their children believe it for entirely different reasons.”
“They believe it,” the Constable said, “because they have been indoctrinated to believe it.”
“Yes. Some of them never challenge it—they grow up to be small-minded people, who can tell you what they believe but not why they believe it. Others become disillusioned by the hypocrisy of the society and rebel—as did Elizabeth Finkle-McGraw.”
“Which path do you intend to take, Nell?” said the Constable, sounding very interested. “Conformity or rebellion?”
“Neither one. Both ways are simple-minded—they are only for people who cannot cope with contradiction and ambiguity.”
I suppose if I want to get more of his view on a way forward, I should read his book, The Cult of Smart, but I don't want to just now.
Read my review instead, my review is substantially better than his book, and that's not my way of saying that my review is especially good.
It seems like kids need more physical, sensory experiences, but it seems like a hard pitch, perhaps something to do with laptopping being high status and easy on the body, as is mentioned in the thread on class.
Something else deBoer wrote recently really resonated with me, and seems relevant:
like all political movements, the woke political movement is captured by the urge to occupy elevated status within it
Most educators don't give half a damn about genuinely improving the minds of the children they educate. Sure, they'll performatively care, they can talk a good game because that's the kind of signaling they are expected to deliver. But if you released, say, an adaptive computer program that could deliver a K-12 curriculum to a child at their own pace, with as good or better results than the average K-12 in-person education, without the need to leave their house or pay for school buildings or pay teachers--you would not change American public education in any perceptible way. K-12 school exist primarily to provide free daycare, and secondarily to give teachers government jobs. The movement to "educate children" is entirely captured by people who are extracting resources from the public for their own personal and political gain. That doesn't mean there aren't teachers involved who genuinely care about kids! But their care is largely incidental, except as it improves their ability to signal "cooperate" to the people running the show.
And the show in question is anti body. It has been this way from the beginning--read Socrates complaining about sex and tasty food as distractions from the really important stuff, like pure mathematics, and then check the latest memes on horny jail or eating bugs to save the planet and tell me how far we've really come, 25 centuries later. Once we were promised transcendence through death and salvation; today we are hoping for transcendence through mind uploads. "Disregard body, elevate mind" has certainly gotten occasional pushback (e.g. Epicurus, or more recently the free-love hippies) but attending to the well being of whole humans is not, and has not for most of history been, the goal of the greatest thinkers. In fact many of today's purportedly greatest thinkers will pretend to be deeply offended if you suggest e.g. that being born "into" a geno- and phenotypically female body is in any way pertinent to one's personal, human identity.
In that world, looking for ways to give kids more "physical, sensory experiences" isn't just low-status, it's downright subversive (and indeed: self-improvement through physical exercise is often negatively coded, especially when it arises in masculinity-building contexts).

...aaand I hit the character limit. Well, I didn't have much more to add. But as political figures go, Rebekah Jones was not on my list of people I expected to ever hear about again. How is she still out there participating in society? How does she continue to get attention from the news media? As far as I can tell, she's never accomplished anything meaningful, ever. Her fifteen minutes of fame consisted in raising a large sum of money by being a critic of DeSantis who was willing to take dramatic liberties with the truth. And now there are likely thousands, even tens of thousands of Twitter and Reddit users whose priors just got updated in favor of "DeSantis is a facist" based on a kettle of lies and exaggerations amplified by institutions that will turn around tomorrow and warn us about misinformation.
I'd like to discuss the best ideas my political opposition has, but I'm increasingly concerned that "signal boost liars" is the best idea my political opposition has--or, if not their best idea, maybe just their most pragmatically effective.
More options
Context Copy link