naraburns
nihil supernum
No bio...
User ID: 100
Though perhaps some might disagree, in the least inflammatory manner possible I can only relate that it has mostly been my personal experience that your average woman has the general breadth, depth, and intensity of political, philosophical, intellectual, etc. interests of a bar of soap
The rule isn't actually that your posts must be minimally-inflammatory. Rather, the rule is that you must:
Proactively provide evidence in proportion to how partisan and inflammatory your claim might be.
(Also known as the "hot take" rule.)
You have provided only the evidence of your "personal experience," which is some evidence, but does not sufficiently cover the degree to which your post is inflammatory (and fails to write like everyone is reading and you want them to be included in the discussion, and fails to be charitable, and is in general just very boo-outgroup).
Don't post like this, please.
I don't generally nominate QCs myself (since I'm the final arbiter of what gets into the report) but at a guess, you gave a straightforward and informed take on something most Mottizens know little about. I see a lot of AAQC nominations from people who seem to feel like they've learned something. Of course, it's possible to feel that way while "learning" false things, or while learning nothing at all! But this is not the "actually true and meticulously edited" report.
I was always under the impression that most people understand the terms "man" and "woman" to refer to one's gender, and "male" and "female" to refer to one's sex.
To the best of my understanding, this distinction was introduced, or at least popularized, in the mid-20th century by Simone de Beauvoir. In a nod to horseshoe theory, the people who seem to most resist this in my experience are conservative people who make no distinction because they think social and biological roles are intertwined, and trans advocates who make no distinction because they object to the use of any language that helps to distinguish transsexuals from the biological categories they are emulating.
It seems to me that the trans movement is deeply committed to doing the opposite of tabooing their words. They're not the only ones--I think a lot of the political left, along with many conservative religious groups, flee from clarity a lot. My own prejudice is that this is because they know, at some level, that linguistic clarity undermines their ingroup activism. But Scott Alexander has written occasionally about preserving disclarity in ways that may help to arrive at a slightly more charitable take. Maybe.
I disagree, primarily because (as mentioned in my comment below) there is a definite HBD angle here. There are also some obvious (at least to me) gender issues implicated in the discussion. I'd probably have approved this discussion for outside the containment thread, but I don't see this as a small question, even if it is not presently an active CW issue.
This is objectionably low-effort. Don't post like this please.
Is there any discussion of the body odor gene taking place there? I shower 5-7 times per week but I've known many people, especially Asian women, who could get away with less. I would kind of assume Aella has run her DNA but maybe I'm projecting my own rationalist stereotypes on her there.
I'm more stunned to hear how rarely Aella has sex. I have seen studies that show married people are more sexually active than unmarried people but I would not have guessed that this extended to someone like Aella, who writes about sex and who is something of a rationalist Aspasia. Sex once-to-occasionally-twice per week only marginally exceeds the national standard for healthy adults (which last I checked was about once per week).
This seems like a troll to me. But if it's not a troll, then it's you wishing death on your outgroup without really engaging the argument in a plausibly serious way--for which you have already been banned once.
This is a discussion forum. If you aren't interested in engaging seriously and charitably with the thoughts of people whose views you abhor, then maybe this is not the place for you.
Banned for three days.
My mistake! Warning rescinded.
More effort than this please.
And a Merry Christmas to you!
the culture war by psychos
Don't do this, please.
More effort than this please.
More effort than this please.
The "Webb is a bigot" people don't care about anything except having all PR everywhere pay tribute to their gods.
This may very well be true, but if you're going to say it, you need to buttress it with some evidence or argumentation. Remember that this is the thread for discussing the culture wars, not waging them. That doesn't mean you can't criticize your outgroup, but if you do criticize your outgroup, you're going to have to do it with more effort than this.
And I'd normally leave it at that, but you've accrued a lot of warnings in the last two months. So I'm going to ban you for a week and see whether maybe that makes something stick.
Lesbianism is more political than biological anyway.
Your comment is a bit... curt, I guess I want to say, given the strength of its claims. To much heat, not enough light. Which is not to say there's no light there, but if you're going to assert that lesbianism is "more political than biological," that seems like the sort of thing you should say with evidence, at least a bit. You didn't even hyperlink the idiom--some amount of shibboleth-slinging is bound to crop up in any community, but still it would be better to speak a bit more plainly.
More effort than this, please.
Hasn’t it backfired for Smollet? Haven’t followed him closely but I thought he was done as an actor?
Last I heard, he was out on bail while appealing a jail sentence of 150 days. Pretty tough to sign on to film deals with that hanging over your head. He may or may not be "done as an actor" in the long term, but if he is, it's not because he failed to apologize--it's because he perpetrated a criminal hoax. His failure to apologize may well be a part of his appeal strategy. Actually, the extent to which he has demanded, and continues to demand, his day in court seems almost as unhinged as the hoax itself, but I'm not a criminal defense lawyer so maybe there's something I'm missing.
Might the prosecution have gone easier on him if he'd owned up in the first place? Sure, I agree that it's possible. Prosecutors have been known to show their appreciation for honesty (and simplicity) by making sweetheart plea deals. But my limited experience with prosecutors suggests to me that you would not want to bet any large sums of money on such inclinations.
But has it worked for people like Rebecca Jones? She lost her congressional [b]id, has faced criminal issues, and just generally appears unhinged.
I guess that depends on what you mean by "worked." She lost her bid, but she still got the Democrat nod well after her dismal character was widely and publicly grasped. She successfully raised money for that bid. She's not in jail, somehow.
I also get the impression that most people find Shaun King gauche. He had cachet at one time. But now seems like a fake.
Having a net worth of probably a couple million dollars seems like a decent definition of "worked" to me. YMMV! Besides, it doesn't matter what "most" people think, as long as a couple tens of thousands of them are still buying your books, subscribing to your newsletter, paying you to give speeches, etc.
I take it from the absence of objection that you also admit that the Smollett and Hay cases are also obviously examples of refusing to apologize on factual errors leading to "success," so I regard this point as made.
Regarding moral facts: all I meant there is that you separated "issues of morality" from "facts" in a way that I don't buy. For example, I regard it as a fact that Jussie Smollett's perfidy is a moral failing--he is a blameworthy person, and "the sky is blue" and "Jussie Smollett is blameworthy" are both statements with truth values of "true." This is a meta-ethical position, and not a simple one, so I won't develop it further here, but I did just want to note that you were drawing a distinction that I don't regard as sensible.
Never apologize works well when the issue is one of morality (eg you said x which is y). I don’t think it applies to facts.
Setting aside the complicated fact that I do think there are moral facts, I mean... Jussie Smollett? Or on a weirder scale, there is Rebecca Jones, Forbes Technology Awards 2020 Person of the Year for generating what Ron DeSantis (as far as I can determine, accurately) called "defamatory conspiracy theories." She went on to run for Congress and... well, long story short, this is a woman who definitely never apologizes for the many, many factual distortions for which she is clearly responsible. Or on a smaller scale, but recently in professional philosophy, Carol Hay lied about a presentation she was attending and has steadfastly declined to recant despite attempts by Brian Leiter to shame her into it.
Even setting aside peculiar cases like Shaun King (who appears, to the best of my understanding, to factually just be a white man pretending to be black), there are loads of people who steadfastly maintain expressions of belief in total contravention of obvious facts. And yes, some people do call them out on it, but eventually the people calling for apologies have to move on with their lives.
The basic contours of being motivated to save face are obvious enough, sure, but the part that continues to be absolutely bewildering to me is that dogged stubbornness only makes you look worse!
To people who care about the truth, maybe. But surely you've also heard the advice, sometimes given to celebrities caught up in PR nightmares, to "never apologize?" Sure, if you discover your own mistake or your own agenda requires that you change course, "I was wrong" looks like a cheat code for credibility. But if someone demands an apology, or catches your mistake, owning up looks like an act of submission rather than contrition.
These people are, in other words, treating arguments as soldiers. They're waging a culture war. The original goal of the bad research was never truth to begin with; definitively establishing the falsehood of the initial claim has no bearing whatsoever on the project.
In short: there will be no apology because no one is sorry--or so it seems to me!
What do we know about what makes someone gay?
Very little. Even attempting to study this can be a career-ending choice. This is because causal models often translate into curative models. For example, it is widely agreed that there is no "gay gene," but if there were a "gay gene," then we could use embryo selection to prevent gay children from being born. Likewise I have read some hypotheses that hormones in utero play a major role in sexuality, but twin studies show that twins often don't have the same sexuality (though they do have the same sexuality at higher rates than random chance). So there appear to be biological factors involved in homosexuality, but these factors do not appear to be determinate.
Back when it was permissible to study such things, there were some studies that associated homosexuality with being the victim of sexual abuse. But this tends to paint homosexuality as a negative consequence of a blameworthy action, which is not good PR, so this line of thinking is often very vocally shouted down. Furthermore, the percentages vary a lot--in the one I linked, about a third of homosexual men reported having been the victims of child abuse. So even if that explains every single case to which it applies (which would be surprising), it doesn't explain the other 65% at all.
It seems to me, given the evidence I've seen over the years, that sexuality is just super complex--sufficiently complex that even calling someone "homosexual" or "heterosexual" is often a gross oversimplification. Even stuff like the Kinsey scale barely scratches the surface. Because the human sex drive is so deeply biologically wired while simultaneously being inescapably socially situated, I have very little doubt that it is essentially a complex emergent property with countless biological and environmental inputs. There is no clear causal model for a single individual, much less one that will generalize to multiple humans. There do seem to be some identifiable contributing factors, but even factors with impacts large enough to be measurable fail to be clearly identifiable as overwhelming causes. You may as well ask what makes someone a biologist or a sailor: surely there are causes that explain each case, maybe even some obvious contributing factors, and yet being a biologist or a sailor just isn't the kind of thing that could ever have a single, clearly-identifiable cause.
Is Holocaust denial becoming a more tolerated topic on this forum?
Tolerated by whom?
Revisionists occasionally popped their head up at the subreddit, but as far as I remember, their comments were always downvoted.
Some very highly-upvoted comments in the subreddit were in this vein. IIRC, at least one of those was removed by AEO.
The problem with Holocaust deniers from my perspective is that they're boring. I've been shown a lot of interesting evidence over the years that some number less than exactly six million Jews were killed by Nazi Germany. I've also been shown a lot of interesting evidence over the years that there is basically no way the Germans were directly responsible for the deaths of less than several million Jews as the result of an explicit ethnic cleansing program, which makes the other stuff seem like motivated nitpicking. The religious fervor with which the Holocaust now often operates to shield specific Jews from cogent criticism is often absurd. But the level of ethnic criticism directed toward Jews as a group is even more absurd, especially given the diverse range of orthodoxies and ethnicities contained within the word "Jewish."
There is a phenomenon I have observed, over the years, where young people will discover something (often, sex/romance) that they've never experienced before, that they have arguably been denied for various (good!) reasons over the years but which, as emerging adults, they find very important to their worldview. They then become instant evangelists, full of zeal for the amazing, eye-opening, perspective-shifting truth they've uncovered. I've seen it a lot among the newly-atheist and the newly-political. I've seen it a fair bit in connection with particular diets, with natural childbirth, with animal rights activism. It's very popular right now in connection with race and gender. But I think the same thing happens the first time certain individuals learn that there might be some propaganda and/or nuance to account for in connection with the Holocaust. Suddenly a piece of Sacred Social Machinery appears Broken, and to a certain kind of contrarian mind, it's blood in the water: the frenzy begins.
It's enough of a pattern that I suspect it's built in, somehow, to our social consciousness. I can gin up a just-so evo-psych story if you like, but you can probably imagine it yourself. Doubting the dogmas you've received, and then coming to terms with the world around you, is a story at least as old as human civilization itself. But there aren't a lot of spaces where that sort of thing is tolerated "out loud," so to speak. The stronger the narrative, then, the more likely we are to field its doubters here. It's Eternal September everywhere, but we're one of the only social groups I know that explicitly takes a gentle hand to heretics of all kinds--even our own.
I had initially approved this, but on further examination it's pretty political. Please feel free to post it (and, preferably, with some commentary) in the CW thread.
Depends a lot on who you're proposing to. My own advice would be to establish a budget, discuss that budget with your desired spouse, and then have them participate in ring selection. This may be accomplished in more- and less-obfuscated ways, depending on how much of a "surprise" your desired spouse is going to insist on feeling when you pop the question. But my own experience is that people who value emotional moments like sudden surprise over communication, transparency, and mutual fulfillment are off to a rough start anyway.

There are facts, and then there are facts.
I think very few people in this space is ignorant of the disproportionate share of American violent crime committed by young, male descendants of American slavery. Probably few readers here are ignorant of the disproportionate share of American violent crime perpetrated against young, male descendants of American slavery. And I would even go so far as to suggest that a large majority of people reading your comment are aware that news media "thumbs the scales," so to speak, in favor of hyping up white-on-black crime while papering over the reverse.
The question is, have you written this post in such a way as to grasp these facts with maximum light and minimum heat?
I think, ultimately, no. You've drawn two reports for consensus building and culture warring, and one for AAQC. This is not actually a quality contribution; while it is "edge space" this is actually a comment that has earned you a warning. Your ostensible thesis--"Twitter can expose how the media tries to manipulate you"--is fine. The argument and evidence you bring, however, looks like you were using Twitter discussion as a pretext for a link-dump on how terrible your outgroup is.
The topic is extremely inflammatory, as I suspect you know. So while I appreciate such effort as you did put in to at least include links and examples, ultimately you fell short of the called-for threshold, in part for want of charity and steel-manning.
More options
Context Copy link