@naraburns's banner p

naraburns

nihil supernum

11 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 04 19:20:03 UTC

				

User ID: 100

naraburns

nihil supernum

11 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 04 19:20:03 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 100

The Blue Check circa 2012 was essentially a spoils system. Basically if you had a sufficiently well-connected PR person, they could get you fast-tracked through the process. It was supposed to fight impersonation rather than being a mark of high quality information, but the blogosphere (remember the blogosphere?) was a bucket of journalist crabs looking for ways to stand out. And since the process was neither automated nor quick, the people who got priority weren't necessarily the most likely to actually be impersonated, they were the people who both (A) wanted it badly enough and (B) had the connections to make that happen. And sure, huge A-list celebrities got to jump the queue, but after that it was mostly B-list (or C-list, or...) media personalities begging for Silicon Valley scraps.

Treating the blue check as a signal of information veracity is like, downstream of the anti-impersonation aim, so I can't say it has mutated beyond recognition. But certainly it has mutated. Moving to a pay-to-verify system cashes in on that mutation, kind of, in an I Am Rich sort of way, only instead of signaling wealth, you're signaling a willingness to pay a whopping $8 per month to prevent impersonation and presumably get some other perks as well.

Network effects are huge, so I'm reluctant to predict that Twitter will die any time soon, but I suspect its popularity has peaked.

Sorry again for not being clear about my views on Libertarians and how it pertained here.

No worries. Thanks for being good-natured about the communication breakdown!

Who gives a shit? Brexit, and all separatist movements, are a giant waste of time and political energy. Convincing common people to find honor and pride in being ruled by the near idiot instead of the far idiot.

I fail entirely to see anything wasteful about that. The near idiot might be held accountable, at least sometimes. The far idiot, never.

In general it is my goal to not be ruled at all. This is unachievable to the extent that I am often better off insofar as others are ruled, and so I accept the liberal, social contractarian tradeoff of maximizing my own liberty only to the extent that this is compatible with maximizing the liberties of others.

Otherwise every voter is a vassal of the government no?

Indeed--every voter is a vassal of the government.

Which I don't think is something most people would accept (Libertarians as always excluded.)

I don't want to say this without couching it very carefully, because it's pretty antagonistic standing on its own in ways I don't want to convey, but my initial reaction to this parenthetical was "well a hearty 'fuck you' to you, too"--followed by some indication that I say it with a smile. I'm not offended, genuinely. But if you think in terms of "libertarians as always excluded" then it's no wonder at all that you failed to take my meaning in the first place. If you think in terms of "libertarians as always excluded," then you have a very slim chance of genuinely understanding anything I write, ever. The community even has a rule about this, come to think of it...

In any case the vassal framing was used by one particular side

I didn't know this, but it doesn't surprise me. Except that in this case I would say that the side that refused to use this framing was the side engaging in disingenuous rhetoric. It's literally true, and not in a weird edge-case way; every member state of the EU is a vassal of the central organization. Watching the EU force economic medicine on Greece is exceedingly strong evidence that this is so. Saying "but the Greeks participate in the decision-making process" is classic rhetorical bullshit. Democracy is two wolves and a sheep voting on what is for dinner. Doubtless many vassal states in empires across the ages got to "participate in the decision-making process" before they were ultimately given marching orders disregarding their contribution to the conversation.

it isn't neutral, let alone indisputably accurate

It may not be neutral, and I accept your contextual explanation in that regard. But it does seem indisputably accurate, once you stop excluding libertarians (as, I would contend, you should). So I feel comfortable continuing to call groomers "groomers," Nazis "Nazis," and vassals "vassals," until such time as I have clearer words for the concomitant groups, behaviors, and/or phenomena.

Guess I'm just not sufficiently plugged in to European politics to understand why this would be "inflammatory." In this context, "vassal" just means--

a person or country in a subordinate position to another

As a part of the EU, the UK was legally subordinate to decisions made in Brussels (the administrative center of the EU), so I was just describing the literal state of the law pre-Brexit. When you say "The UK government was far from a vassal" are you asserting something like, "the UK did get to participate in the decision-making process, and therefore was not a vassal" maybe? If so, I don't really buy that; the UK was not EU occupied territory (modulo, perhaps, some worries over immigration) and the UK was not an EU colony (see previous qualifier), but I don't think it's inaccurate to say that the people of the UK ultimately chafed at being in a legally subordinate position to Brussels.

But perhaps I have simply failed to understand something about your objection.

My problem is that it still hasn't been demonstrated to me that the action abolishing Disney's local control benefits the taxpayers of Florida, rather than harming both Disney and Florida.

It benefits the people of Florida by ensuring that the people calling the shots are the politically accountable people, rather than (Californian!) corporations. There may or may not be a pricetag in dollars that will ultimately fall to Florida (I wouldn't even be surprised to see DeSantis backpedal on this under the right circumstances) but the political benefit seems obvious and arguably priceless. (For a much bigger example of this, see Brexit. The economic cost has been substantial, probably, but Brexit did accomplish exactly what it was supposed to: it liberated the UK from being a vassal state of Brussels.)

Lose-lose governance by deterrence does not appeal to me.

Same--but win-lose governance where leftists demand every W and conservatives are expected to eat every L appeals to me far, far less.

DeSantis could have just said "You stick to cartoons, I'll run the state" and decried Disney's intrusion into politics, without wading into the muck with them.

Right--then he's all talk, no action. Pass.

If you're wealthy, you probably own shares in many "woke corporations" and you don't want to get punished for what management does.

Then you should appreciate Ron DeSantis reminding management to stay in their lane, so as to avoid pointless confrontations with government actors. Woke Corporatism is a plague on politics, but it's not going to go away until it negatively impacts enough people's bottom line, so I think it is good to impose costs on corporations that seek to extract private profits by polluting the political commons. Of course, I say that as someone who misses the anti-corporatism of the late conservative Chief Justice Rehnquist. Presumably more pro-corporate conservatives will have a different view.

goofy-ass Disney fight

I feel like this reflects a failure to grasp the best of what DeSantis represents. Now, the Martha's Vineyard thing was, I think, a mistake, most especially since the immigrants involved didn't even leave from Florida. But Disney came out swinging against DeSantis. It wasn't his "goofy-ass...fight," it was Disney's goofy-ass fight. DeSantis' only real choice there was to remind them that they are a corporation and tell them to get back in their lane. Anything else would have resulted in DeSantis looking like a bootlicker who caves to Woke Corporatism the moment his moneyed masters yank on the chain.

Disney owns (and tyrannically enforces) a lot of beloved IP, so there will always be some people who think "Disney hates DeSantis, so I hate DeSantis." But politically speaking, "there are consequences to getting politically involved" was exactly the right message to send to businesses in this case. As they say--if you're going to take a shot at the king, don't miss. Disney sticking its corporate neck out to object to a bill forbidding schools from exposing young children to sexually explicit pedagogy was a horrible, horrible choice. They missed their shot, and DeSantis had exactly the correct response: punish defectors.

People will be dissecting this for a while, but remember that the reporting went rapidly from "Dems will pick up 2-4 seats in the senate" to "Reps will pick up 2-4 seats in the senate." Very little time was spent dwelling on the result no one wanted, which was "50/50 continues."

Now, the narrative will be something like "Republicans can't even pick up seats when Democrats are in the White House for a recession and historic inflation" versus "Democrats can't even pick up seats to pursue abortion-on-demand nationwide." There is some nuance here--Ron DeSantis won big, while Trump-picked candidates appear to be outright losing, or at least struggling. Democrats didn't lose big, so anger over COVID school closures and other education issues hasn't held up as well as the Republicans hoped. But very broadly, I think it's best to interpret the status quo of hyper-partisan "blue no matter who" versus "red or we're all dead" as winning this election.

The up side for Democrats is that they may get one more SCOTUS pick (low odds, but possible), they still have bargaining power over legislation, and they can claim "victory" in the sense of continued Senate control if not in the sense of actually getting the votes they wanted. The up side for Republicans is that they can continue to plausibly point the finger of blame at Democrats for two more years, ultimately strengthening the likelihood of a White House victory combined with a legislative sweep in 2024.

And because there's something for everyone to be disappointed about--predictions of rioting etc. don't seem to have come to fruition.

Have we entered the long, depressing "I'm tired of fighting, now I'm just going to sulk until someone gives me a divorce" phase of political polarization?

tl;dr no.

We are obligated not to racially select our friends, even if this is motivated by a preference for a certain race of friends.

I can't think of any reason at all to accept this premise; this is not how friendship works. While it is presumably possible to go about making friends deliberately, in general I would expect this to be much less effective, and result in much less satisfying friendships, than simply being open to the possibility of friendship and allowing such a relationship to emerge organically. If you're placing something (e.g. "social justice," whatever that means) about your friendships above your own feelings about friendship, you are distorting the very idea of friendship.

So, uh... your philosophy professor is off to a rather dismal start.

If we are obligated not to racially select our friends, we're obligated not to racially select our romantic and sexual partners.

Again, why would anyone accept this premise? The selection criteria for friends and romantic partners don't perfectly overlap; for one thing, most people don't select friends based on who they find sexually attractive (indeed, being sexually attracted to your friends may at times undermine friendship).

Conclusion A does follow--this is a basic modus ponens with the major and minor premises swapped--but the premises are total shit. Neither friendship nor romantic relationships, as I understand them, can be plausibly described in this way.

And somehow it gets worse.

If we're obligated not to racially select our friends, romantic, or sexual partners, this is because race is an immutable characteristic. So, we're also obligated not to select our partners based on any other immutable characteristics.

This is not a premise, this is a whole argument on its own, and not a good one. Where did "immutable characteristic" come from? This was just smuggled in like so much Drano-cut heroin. This isn't the same professor who denies that race is an immutable characteristic, is it? Because if so, damn. If not, maybe you should introduce these two and ask them to argue it out for you.

And then "obligations against judgment based on immutable characteristic X must also create obligations against judgment based on any immutable characteristic Y?" The fuck? This is so far off the logic rails it's not even philosophy anymore, it's creative writing. American Airlines absolutely cannot forbid immutably black pilots from flying their planes, and yet American Airlines can absolutely forbid immutably blind pilots from doing so.

A) I feel like I have a moral obligation not to racially discriminate in friendship

You shouldn't feel this way, because no such moral obligation exists. Rather, this is a weird way of saying that you probably often have a moral obligation to refrain from pre-judging people on the basis of their skin color.

Wouldn't it be incumbent on you to repress or replace that disgust reaction if doing so was within your power?

Why? It might be a good idea, for numerous practical reasons. But I can't think of any reason why you would owe it to anyone to put effort into reconditioning your own emotional responses, unless those responses were directly leading to further direct harms in violation of other moral duties owed.

Desert doesn't solve any of this. No one "deserves" to be your friend or sexual partner. Friendship and romance just aren't that kind of thing.

Note that everything I've said is compatible with the claim that the world would be better if people were less choosy about who they accepted as friends and lovers. Maybe that is true. But one common problem with moral theorists is how quickly they lose sight of the idea that there might be (I would argue: that there is) a range of permissible actions which are neither optimal, nor compulsory, nor forbidden.

Fixed, thanks.

So you're suggesting that broad principles of free speech require public colleges to treat student speech in a content-neutral way, with no special treatment for the communication of ideas we find abhorrent, including racial slurs?

I'm suggesting that there is no "hate speech" exception to the First Amendment. The University of Kentucky is a public institution, and thus bound (through the incorporation doctrine) by the First Amendment.

That seems fine, although it's not the position most public American colleges seem to take (certainly not in practice).

Are you sure about that? I haven't taken a recent poll or anything, but in my experience it is the private universities where this tends to be more of a challenge. Public universities are aware that they are bound by law to permit offensive speech, and failure to do so can result in substantial judgments against them.

In this particular case, the (many!) physical altercations likely give adequate cover to the university if it decides to expel the drunk girl for assault, but only if nobody involved in the process accidentally writes an email or makes a speech about the epithet. If the university says "we're expelling this student for racism," they might very well lose the resulting viewpoint discrimination lawsuit.

In your hypothetical, the student is characterizing being a Nazi as detestable. In the real-life event, the student is characterizing being Black as detestable.

No. In my hypothetical and in the real-life event, a drunk person chooses the word that seems most likely to offend the person they are confronting. "Characterizing X as detestable" is just far, far too much cognition to attribute to someone this drunk.

Nevertheless, the White girl's behavior was grotesque. I have no objections at all to expelling her from school.

As I've said, I'm confident that expulsion solves nothing in this case. But I could probably be persuaded that this girl should be expelled for her behavior (including both heavy drinking and resisting arrest), conditional on other students routinely being expelled for similar behaviors. What bothers me is the idea of expelling students because they said a naughty word (yes, even if they said it 200 times). If the line between expulsion and not-expulsion is "did you say a racial slur," that violates my intuitions regarding the importance of freedom of speech, thought, and inquiry in institutions of higher education.

The article relates Spring's account:

In an Instagram post following the altercation, Spring explained why she had intervened in the first place.

She explained that Rosing walked into Boyd Hall, on Martin Luther King Blvd, after Spring had refused her entry because she did not have an ID card on her.

When blonde Rosing managed to get into the lobby she stumbled as she approached the elevators, which concerned Spring who was behind the front desk.

Spring said: 'I worked a shift tonight where was assaulted and called a n*****, and someone said other racial slurs towards me.

'It is a part of our job that if we see a student that's like very drunk, we are to call an RA to... write a report.

'So I reach my head out of the desk area, and I ask the girl 'Are you OK?'' Spring recounted, 'and she stared at me and started to call me a n*****.'

There is also reportedly video of Spring preventing Rosing from getting into an elevator, and forcing (?) her to sit down, but I didn't watch. Seems plausible that the desk clerk was just trying to do her job, but Rosing was far, far too drunk for that to be a simple proposition. This basic scene plays out in some college every single weekend all over the world, I'd wager, but this particular event has enough of a race angle that the rage-baiters picked it up.

It's a bad look, for sure, but how is this not just run-of-the-mill drunken disorderliness? "Racism" is not really the same thing as racial epithets. If you get drunk and repeatedly call a man a "dick" we don't generally run a story about a "sexist outburst." This strikes me as a wild exaggeration:

extreme racism can happen among the younger generations

Extreme drunkenness can happen among younger generations, for sure. And when your drunk brain looks for the most offensive thing it can say to someone, and your social milieu is one where a racial epithet is the most offensive word you can think of, then the more strongly we disapprove of racial epithets, the more often we're going to hear them from angry, irrational people. Calling that "racism" seems like rhetorical sleight of hand to me.

Imagine a student getting plastered and, noticing her RA's MAGA cap, calling the RA a "Nazi" two hundred times. I can't imagine students putting together a petition demanding the drunk person's expulsion--it would be ridiculous. The drunk girl clearly has some problems, but none of them appear solvable by either tarring her as a "racist" or by expelling her from school.

The Internet wasn't built to facilitate profit-taking. It was built by a combination of academic and military interests--both cultural cost-centers dedicated (at least ostensibly) to advancing the public good. Early on, the Internet functioned to connect a diaspora of high-trust intellectual communities, most of whose contributions to the furtherance of the project went unremunerated.

This is why people keep wanting to re-invent the Internet, in whole or in part: to maximize their own profits. To make it possible for them to make a better living. But if you think that clickbait is bad now, imagine the incentives for producing effective clickbait on any blockchain ledger that executes access contracts instantaneously using ubiquitous crypto tokens as a medium of data exchange! This is not to suggest that something like a basic attention token isn't an interesting idea, but I have a hard time imagining any such system that doesn't immediately get gamed to death. Even Bitcoin itself only continues to exist by accident--it has failed, almost completely, in its original mission to become a decentralized, anonymous digital currency. More than 90% of Bitcoin transactions are pure, unadulterated market speculation.

The primary value proposition of the Internet, because this is how it was built, is in its ubiquitous semi-automated bisexual luxury virtual anarcho-libertarianism. People doing stuff for free and other people benefiting from it for free, while the government and some well-heeled NGOs pick up the tab. The profitable bits are tacked on. Writing for a living is tough, not because we haven't figured out how to properly monetize the Internet, but because there are lots and lots of good-to-great writers who are still willing to do that for cheap-to-free. The choice is not between ubiquitous ads and paywalls; you can also just choose to not traffic in professional material--like playing a free-to-play game and never once dipping into microtransactions or gacha mechanics, fully prepared to quit the moment you hit a hard paywall, because there are other games to play.

Stated a little differently: ad-blockers aren't Freddie's problem--I'm Freddie's problem.

tl;dr: Israel isn't a big economic superpower. Why?

Because it has a population of 9 million people in a geographic territory the size of Wales?

Israel has a GDP per capita better than Germany's, or Japan's, and both of those nations are widely regarded as economic superpowers. Israel's geographic neighbors aren't even in its league. Anti-Israel sentiment in the Middle East and elsewhere also presumably plays some role in suppressing Israeli international trade opportunities. As near as I can tell, Israel is economically punching well above its apparent weight, exactly as your IQ analysis would seem to predict.

I'm not sure what else to say. You have picked two pretty inflammatory topics, presented only cursory evidentiary support for your claims, and then drawn a strong conclusion that does not appear to be at all supported by the facts you presented.

Do you find these objections convincing? If not, why not?

Objection 4 is just circular. "Defining race biologically is a mistake because that's not how race is defined [in the dictionary]" is just a premise being repeated as a conclusion.

The other objections are fine, I guess, but only insofar as your professor also objects to, like, the idea of a "species," or a "breed," or even the term "life." This is classic postmodern language games: if you can't be perfectly correct 100% of the time, then you must have no idea what you're talking about! But this is an isolated demand for rigor; there are likely no terms that withstand this level of demand (with the possible exception of mathematical terms, but even these have been called into question).

On #1, if you need to draw precise lines between groups of people, then "race" is going to be of somewhat limited use (though probably not no use). But how often do you actually need to do that? On the other hand, there are a number of fuzzy lines that are nevertheless useful. If you want to screen people for sickle cell anemia, for example, but you don't have infinite resources for doing so (who does?), then you should prioritize black people. Yeah, you might get overbroad or underinclusive in some cases, but eyeballing "race: black=increased risk of sickle cell anemia" is going to absolutely get you most of the way.

On #2, "scientists" (which scientists?) do talk about race, sometimes, but even when they don't they are often just using a different term that capture the concept of race without using the word. If for some reason you don't like the word race, fine? I guess? But when you tell someone you're interested in the comparative prevalence of sickle cell anemia among the American descendants of enslaved sub-Saharan Africans, at some point someone tired of saying that many words is going to just say "black" and no one is going to be confused by that.

On #3, okay, but some horses are brown and some are dapple and some are gray, and yet somehow we can still tell a horse from a donkey even if sometimes people get that wrong.

On #5, there is no "essence" of race because (per #3!) the biological underpinnings of race are fuzzy-bounded trait clusters. What counts as an "adequate scientific account?" Asians tend to be lactose intolerant. But how do you know any particular Asian is lactose intolerant? Doing a complete genetic screening would be more accurate than looking at someone and guessing that, based on their apparent race, they might be lactose intolerant, but "hmm, this patient appears Asian and complaining of stomach problems, I should ask about dairy consumption" seems perfectly scientifically "adequate" in the scientific context of medical care.

I get the impression that your philosophy professor--as someone teaching philosophy of race, specifically--has a somewhat predictable agenda. These particular arguments show that agenda to be prioritizing the burying of race-as-biology without ever clearly explaining the benefit of doing so. Objection #2 hits closest to the mark--in many sociological or anthropological contexts, "race" is unlikely to be a better concept than fine-grained ethnographic categorization. Discussing the descendants of American slaves and the aborigines of Australia as both being "black" conflates two extremely different populations, separated by thousands of miles over thousands of years. But this doesn't mean race is not a biological concept at all, it means that some contexts demand greater particularity than others, and race is not a very high-particularity concept. In many biological contexts, however, it clearly serves; objecting to its use in those contexts is not philosophically warranted, it's just an attempt to police wrongthink.

I know we aren't always very good at enforcing this rule, but CW posts are still in fact quarantined to the CW thread(s). Please feel free to post there.

There is now a USA Election Day 2022 Megathread for all your deliberatively democratic posting desires.

Sure, I'll put one up in a minute.

EDIT: Here you go.

I get modded every time I outright say "These people want to mutilate and sterilize children."

You were most recently moderated here. Let's take a look at what Zorba said about it:

...right now you're drawing a direct line from your opinion of the outcome to what you believe is the activists' intention, and that direct line implies cartoon-supervillain evil.

And is probably wrong.

So either bring evidence or knock it off with that kind of rhetoric.

This does not quite fit your interpretation of why you were moderated. In your case, you stated your view without bringing evidence. This post did the opposite--brought evidence, of a kind, while failing to state a view. The best way to avoid moderation on high-heat issues is to carefully bring both evidence and argument, along with a heap of charity for the outgroup.

Well, I̵ ̴s̷u̸p̴p̸o̴s̶e̷ t̴̮͒ĥ̷͙a̴̦̒t̶̥́ ̴̞̓I̵̟̍ ̷̢͝c̷͜͠a̶̱͗n̷̫̽'̷͖̇ẗ̸̪.̷̢̫̂̍.̷͔̱̏̈.̴̦̳͐ ̸̡̥̪̄o̸̝̅̋́h̸̛̖̗̰̓͗ ̷̤͔̲͑͗G̵̼͒̎͝o̶̯͇͓̓ḋ̵͈̻͈͛̈́, ṋ̴̞̹͉̊̐̀ͅở̴̱̀̎̂͛!̴̖͓̟̬̊̇̓̾ P̴͕̗͚͙̘̏̿̀l̸̥͚͕̺̤̺̙͇̉̉͆̈́͗̃͘̚ë̸̟̘̟́̑̾a̸͈̗̦̟̘̱͓͊̇͋ș̷̱͚͔̤̀̇́͑͜e̶̘̿́͂̋ ̶̬̈́̒m̷͇̓͗͐̔̿̿̚͝ắ̶̲̫͖̪̺́̈͒̂́͜͠k̸͍͔̙̣̰̖̻̩͆e̴̱̤̤͎̟̐̀ ̴̹̪͇͈͚̉̾̈̚i̷̡̖̹͇̤̝͛̽̎̍t̴̻̓̾͠ ̵̭̿ş̶̧͔͖̹̣̃̂̈́͐̚̕ṱ̴̡̜̀͋̉̃̉̃͜o̶̬̹̒͌p̷͍͖̼͔̓̌͜͝!̷̛͉̎́͐̕͘̚

This is obnoxious, don't do this.

You've managed to garner a pretty impressive array of reports (nine so far) including AAQC nominations and "boo outgroup" complaints. The tone of your presentation is... excessively smarmy, I guess I want to say. It doesn't invite discussion. And yes, some portion of that may be the natural result of you Noticing things you're not, on some views, allowed to Notice. But this is not a space where you get modded for Noticing, this is a space where you get modded for not speaking plainly. Don't connect a few dots and then dangle implications, here. Make an argument. Tell us what you think the evidence on offer tells you.

Admissions inevitably involves a huge amount of illegible subjective decision-making

[Citation needed]

In most of Continental Europe...

The topic is clearly referencing U.S. education and U.S. law (via the Supreme Court of the United States). If you listen to the oral arguments in this case, you'll hear counsel for Harvard and UNC explain the multi-factor "holistic" admissions practices of their respective universities in some detail. "Illegible subjective decision-making" seems like a pretty fair characterization of what they described.

European universities definitely do things differently, no question. Of course, in most of Continental Europe they haven't got universities where half the matriculating class is of Asian descent sitting in the middle of cities where half the local population is of African descent. It's amazingly difficult to even begin to have a discussion about what's happening in such places, especially when a large part of the population is also ideologically committed to denying the influence of biology on academic performance.

Vitamin C denatures at well below the boiling point of water (about 70 degrees Celsius). I'm no chemist, but I would fully expect that vitamin C that leached out of the partial protection of the structure of the vegetable being boiled would be denatured more or less immediately.

"YOU KNOW WHAT NOBODY HATES EACH OTHER ABOUT YET? THE GREAT BRITISH BAKE OFF."

I would like to say "I can't believe anyone would be offended by 'Mexican week' on a cooking show," but of course, I have no trouble believing it at all. The cold open definitely made me say, "oh, someone is gonna be pissed," not because I think anyone should be upset about it, but because I knew someone would be. When I try to steelman this sort of reaction, I just come up empty. If you happen to be Mexican (or even more generally Hispanic) I'm sure it can get quite tiresome to have your heritage routinely boiled down to tacos and sombreros. But I can't think of a single ethnicity, nationality, religion, or other group that is immune from that sort of reduction. So long as you're not being actively and genuinely persecuted, the appropriate response is to just roll with it. People need to stop making mountains out of molehills, and anthills, and level ground.