@naraburns's banner p

naraburns

nihil supernum

11 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 04 19:20:03 UTC

				

User ID: 100

naraburns

nihil supernum

11 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 04 19:20:03 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 100

I'm offended by Carol peeling a goddamn avacado in the episode.

It's heartening to know that I'm not the only person who was taken aback at that. I actually said aloud--"what is she doing to that avocado!?" I had a similar experience with the brownies they did last (?) season. I would personally be hopeless at reproducing the vast majority of the stuff they bake, I know, but that only makes it all the more amusing when they utterly botch what to me is simple American fare.

I quite enjoy GBBO, which I feel is a bit odd because I have never really enjoyed anything like it--not cooking shows (except Shokugeki no Soma), not reality shows, not game shows. I don't go in for competitions and I'm not really a foodie. If I'm watching a "TV show" at all (leisure hours are more often spent gaming), it's almost always either anime or sci-fi. But there is something inescapably wholesome about GBBO. And I know it's deliberate, because in the early episodes there was definitely some reality show style egging on from the crew. But the decision was clearly made to encourage helpfulness and cooperation and camaraderie between the contestants, and the show has been an absolute gem ever since.

I didn't mean to give the impression I thought something was wrong with the system.

Well, I mean--maybe there is! In particular, if regular users like yourself feel discouraged from making QC nominations in the first place, that's something I think we should be aware of and try to account for. So I appreciate the feedback! And hope that you will continue to nominate posts you regard as quality contributions.

To the best of my knowledge, nobody knows the origins of the saying for certain. It appears in pop culture no later than the early 1950s and is hypothesized to have originated with what some perceived as excessive "tricking" taking place during Halloween in the early 20th century.

I typically set up shop at the end of my driveway and refuse to give anyone candy until they perform the ritual threat. If there is precipitation, I'll open the garage and sit just inside. I prefer this to answering my door repeatedly, and this way I can talk to the adults who stick to the sidewalk while sending their children up to doorsteps. It's not a huge time commitment since trick-or-treating generally runs from 6pm to 8pm where I live, and we do get a couple hundred visitors in that span so I would be answering my door every few moments anyway.

This year there were a shockingly large number who had forgotten the ritual threat. "Do you have something to say to me?" was met with "Happy Halloween?" and "Please?" almost as often as "Trick or treat!" The habit of just-walk-up-and-take-candy set in remarkably quickly with some of these kids, I guess is what I'm saying. I assume this is a weird COVID-19 thing but maybe not.

Yeah, @netstack has the right of it. The QCs are community driven, so the less you, personally, nominate, the less the QCs will reflect your judgment on what makes a QC. This month there were well over 200 nominations. The aim is to highlight about ten per week. Some of those nominations are always just people using QC as "I agree," and some appear to be trolling, but the great majority are genuinely good posts. And it used to be that anything with multiple nominations was a shoe-in, but this month had far more multi-nominated posts than ever before, too (possibly as a result of me mentioning that multiple-nominated posts tend to get approved first, which naturally changes everyone's nominating strategies...)

If I had to guess, I think what made the "drunk post" resonate was just that it was honest. It wasn't as self-effacing as FC's concession post, but it was in a similar vein on a different subject. Recognizing and articulating the weaknesses of our own positions is among the prime values that breathed life into this space.

No, he is not currently banned.

What do you give up?

I'm glad it pinged you! I was just noticing that it doesn't auto-generate links to user pages for users with underscores in their name.

That said, I probably won't stay, as FC is completely lying about what I said.

You're welcome to stay, indeed I would encourage it. But I don't read FC as characterizing anything you said, beyond it being a response to a different comment.

in no way did I say that the riots were "necessary"

FC does not say that you said that. FC says the deleted comment you responded to says that.

the deleted comment in question was someone's on-site reporting of the Minneapolis riots, discussing how most people in the community were pitching in to help, and the media wasn't reporting on that

I admit that I have a hard time believing that the comment as you describe it got to a score of -14. I also have a hard time understanding why you would reply to a comment as you describe it with a criticism of the subreddit as lacking empathy. And /u/ridip's response to you suggests that the deleted comment was "openly admitting to criminal activity," which is a long way from the description you've offered.

I don't know what the deleted comment said, but the context cues I see suggest that either you are lying about what happened, or you forgot but just filled in the blanks on your own based on what felt right.

If this is what the intellectual culture has come to, I'm glad I left and have no interest in coming back. Against shady thinking indeed.

I'll invite you, as I have invited so many others, to be the change you wish to see in the world. Maybe FC is remembering wrong. Maybe you are. I have no way to check. But FC did not criticize you or attribute to you any of the things you are complaining were attributed to you. My inclination is to believe that FC's account of the comment is basically accurate, and that your response here is based on you misreading FC's comment as attributing claims to you rather than to the deleted comment.

How's that for "against shady thinking?"

Here is the text:


Epistemic Status : It is 3:16 am and I have returned from the strippers. Auspicious time to begin a post, to be sure. For god so loved the world that he gave his only son... however that one ends. I'm a heeb, idk.

I.

When I was 18 years old, I worked at an inner city liquor store. I became the acquaintance of a man named Smokey. Smokey was homeless. Smokey had his real name tattooed on the inside of his arm "in case he ever forgot it". Smokey was a crack addict. Smokey sometimes beat up his retarded homeless friend, Sean. One time, Smokey and Sean had been invited to Sean's brother's wedding. They kept wearing the tuxes for the next week. Smokey got harrassed by the cops for panhandling. Smokey took the ticket in stride, walked away from the cop, and then from a distance of 50 metres, nailed the cop square in his forehead with an orange. The cop covered in orange juice arrested a Tuxedo'd Smokey. I laugh to this day.

Smokey didn't have a good life. When Smokey was eight years old, his mother was driving him home from school wasted. She hit and killed another child. She went to prison. Smokey went to live with relatives, also drunks.

We don't have a good solution for people like Smokey. Best we do is toss 'em in the drunk tank, or the unpaid fines tank for a week or two, and then let 'em out. Smokey goes back to doing what he does.

When Smokey died of an overdose in a crack house, the church he went to held a service and two hundred people showed up. I lost my shit, man. Here was the first evidence I ever saw of Christians acting like Christ. They mourned a useless fuckup. They sang his favourite hymns and talked about their favourite memories of the wastoid degenerate that was Smokey. What the fuck did Smokey ever do for anyone? Nothing. But they loved him just the same. Most importantly, even though he slept in the alley - he was a Neighbour, worthy of that commandment - "Love Thy Neighbour".

When I was younger, I imagined "if I ever won the lottery..." I would give Smokey a house or some bullshit. Hero complex. Maybe I can save the world.

II.

Cab just dropped me off at the convenience store near my house. I dropped $1200 on private dances with strippers tonight. It was OK. I bought a gatorade to aide in hangover prevention, and I bought a pack of cigarettes.

As I walked home, I walked past a Starbucks. There was a man sat alone at 2:45am, with a colouring book. Colouring a colouring book at 2:45am in a quiet suburb. I asked his name and I sat with him. Matt was obviously homeless. Matt cried because I asked his name. Nobody has ever asked Matt's name. To the world, Matt is a problem. Matt is a burden. Matt used to be addicted to opiates. That, and fertility issues, caused the end of his marriage. He likes 'em big. Her sister was big too, and dropped some weight, and got pregnant, so why can't she? She blamed his drugs, he blamed her weight, and the marriage dissolved.

I took Matt back to the convenience store, and I bought him a coffee, and a pack of cigarettes, and a shitload of candy. I told him to go nuts with a $30 budget. What a prick I am, I spend $1200 on fucking peelers and I give a homeless man $30. He's a meth-head now, no more opiates, so he wanted candy! I bought him some candy. I didn't do it because I felt guilty about spending money on strippers. I didn't do it because the homeless have a desperate lack of sugar. I didn't do it because it maximized efficiency. I did it because it made a human being happy. Matt cried a lot during this. Partially because nobody ever calls Matt by his name, and partially because nobody's ever been so kind to him.

A lot of people have been much more kind to me. They've extended me credit. They've purchased me hundreds of dollars of shit with no expectation of ROI. They've given me gifts they've made.

As I parted, Matt asked me why I bought him food and coffee and cigarettes. I told him it's because there is no government, there are no cops, there are no social workers, there is no God, and there is no Jesus, there are only other people, and I told him to pay it forward. He will likely never have any fucking means to pay anything I did for him tonight forward. If he does achieve the means, he will probably spend it on meth. But goddamnit, he is a fucking sentient being, not a fucking P-Zombie, and he deserves ten times over what I gave him simply by virtue of feeling pleasure and pain and being alive. His birthright is the stars, the same as yours is.

III.

You will never be satisfied that THE AGENCY TASKED WITH PROBLEM SOLVING will solve the problem. You will never be satiated by THE JUSTICE DOLED OUT BY THE TASK FORCE. Hit the fucking ground and fix your backyard one day at a time.

Some part of me hates those fucking Christians who displayed Christian values more than I ever saw anyone do so before, because they fucking did that for a guy they knew and then didn't do it for anyone else. As do most people. People hate welfare because it GIVES MONEY TO THE UNDESERVING OFF THE TAXPAYER TEET. Here's the paradox - nobody is deserving, yet everyone is. You believe in the basic human dignity of everyone, no matter how drug addicted or retarded or crippled they are, or you're my enemy. End of story. I don't care how efficient it is, we're debating a world that recognizes the freedom and frailty of human beings, or Huxley's Brave New World with extra steps.

IV.

And Jesus said:

"Do not give bread unto the poor, as life is a repeated game, and the poor will learn that optimal strategy is not to source their own bread"

Where exactly is the boundary on assets and liabilities that go into net worth?

Wherever you want! Or, more realistically, wherever the government agency you're dealing with wants to put it.

For instance, the sum total of all my future labor is valuable, and events in the present can increase or decrease that value, but it generally wouldn't be included in my net worth (except under the utilitarian accounting that some like to use in these circles).

When you apply for a home loan in the United States, it is common for lenders to ask for proof of salary in the form of paystubs or a contract. I doubt they think of it in terms of "net worth" (but I don't know, maybe they do?) but that is one way the anticipated sum of your future labor is sometimes used to gauge your worth. Actually there are some theorists out there doing research two steps removed from the current system of income tax. First remove: they think we should tax wealth additionally or instead. Second remove: they think that one form of wealth is natural talent, so we should find a way to tax e.g. naturally smart people to deprive them of the unequal advantage they have over others. While I am skeptical the idea will ever get traction outside the ivory towers of academia, there are definitely people out there who want to think about your net worth in terms of all your assets, including your anticipated labor and inherent talents.

Are valid sources of personal wealth just enumerated in a list somewhere?

There are many such lists. Here is one oriented toward business. Here is a list that explicitly excludes labor. Medicaid has its own list. Different states have different approaches to, e.g., the treatment of a university degree as a dividable asset in divorce proceedings.

There is, in other words, no Platonic ideal of "asset" which gets applied in every case, or even most cases. Whether you count someone's assets in a liberal or constrained way usually depends on what it is you're trying to accomplish. For example, I once heard of a case where the IRS valued a certain coin collection at "market value" for the purpose of measuring an estate's worth, but then seizing the coins and crediting only their face value against the defendant's tax bill. There is no such thing as objective valuation. There is only majority hashpower in the blockchain of life.

Not the same thing. The Adidas's deal was effectively an IOU that could be cancelled at Adidas's discretion.

Well, yes, shares of Amazon are not the same thing as a partnership contract. But shares of Amazon are also not the same thing as a house, or a piece of art, or a bitcoin. One thing they all have in common, though, is that they (can) get counted as assets when calculating wealth. Another thing they have in common is that their value can disappear suddenly and without much warning under the right circumstances. Those circumstances differ by the kind of wealth under consideration, but in general that's not the kind of thing people bother to factor in when calculating present wealth.

That seems misleading to say someone is worth something but it's not actually realized

This is how wealth is always reported. And yes, it is misleading--Jeff Bezos is "worth" over $100 billion on paper, but if he were to try to cash that out all at once, there's no way he'd get $100 billion out of it. The price of his stock would plummet faster than he could sell it, never mind finding $100 billion in cash buyers. It seems safe to assume that Amazon stock is somewhat more robust in valuation than Kanye's endorsement deal with Adidas, but the basic principle is the same.

In fact much of Bezos' worth is, in the terminology of the IRS, "unrealized gains." Capital gains are "realized" (and thus, taxed) only during certain events, usually sales. If I sign a contract for $1 billion to endorse Adidas shoes for the next ten years, I can walk into a bank with that contract and take out loans against that deal. If Adidas backs out, well, I'm gonna default on those loans, so the bank might be hesitant to loan too much money on that promise, but they would definitely loan some. We almost always evaluate wealthy people's worth based not only on cash-on-hand, but on a combination of liabilities and assets. A promise from Adidas to pay $1 billion over ten years is an asset, even if it is not as stable an asset as a mansion or a yacht.

The whole discussion in the OP is about whether Drag is sexual, and whether that sexuality makes it inappropriate for children.

This is not how I understood the question, or how I approached it. I took the question on its face:

Is dressing in drag (that is, a man dressing like a woman potentially with makeup and so on) an inherently sexual act?

OP goes on to suggest that this is at the real center of debates about "Drag Queen Story Hour" and so forth, so presumably if we can reach agreement on this question, then we could reach agreement on the latter question. This may or may not be so, but my impression of this framing is that it is a way of trying to get clear about a less-obviously-charged question before worrying about the details of a more obviously charged question. Maybe I'm the one who misunderstood the OP, but I read your leaping straight to "and is this appropriate for children" as missing the point of the discussion.

Your little syllogism of "JP/Feminists say Makeup is sexual >> Drag Queens wear makeup >> Drag queens are sexual >> sexual things are inappropriate for children >> Drag queens are inappropriate for children"

I have never said "therefore drag queens are inappropriate for children" in this thread. I have explained why it seems clear to me that "drag" is inherently sexual, and you have said nothing to demonstrate otherwise, so if you want to have an argument with someone who is saying the things you're saying I'm saying, you're going to need to find someone else to argue with.

you shift that definition to "too prurient for children"

Again--which of my responses to Gillitrut or Gemma are you getting this from?

I feel like you're just spoiling for a fight. I was responding to Gillitrut in an analytic way, describing what comes to my mind when I hear "drag," and also pointing out that I am hesitant to do even this since of course there are many kinds of drag, and edge cases, and etc. I think my analysis is good in part because it also captures the discomfort people often feel in other situations unrelated to drag queens. Others have been quite civil in pointing to counterexamples, and I think in general the question "is drag inherently sexual" is an interesting one for reasons that have nothing at all to do with children. It's not that far from other arguments people have about e.g. whether breasts are "inherently sexual." Personally, I think lots of stuff is inherently sexual, to greater and lesser degrees, and I think that if we were Puritanical or Victorian about those things, I wouldn't personally like it but I would understand the argument.

Sexualized drag shows are inappropriate for children due to content, not because you can point to some banal element of drag as inherently sexual.

Sure, fine, whatever, you don't think drag is inherently sexual, I get it. I disagree, for all the reasons I've cited, none of which you've provided any plausible pushback against, because you're too busy focusing on shit I didn't say.

The OP's question wasn't about what should or shouldn't be kept away from children, but whether drag is inherently sexual. That's the only question I was answering, so following that up with a discussion of what is or isn't appropriate for children seems like an orthogonal and perhaps just uncharitable response. Nothing you've said here is responsive to any of the arguments I raised for the particular claim that drag seems to indeed be as inherently sexual as blackface is inherently racial.

Saying that Makeup is done by women to add to their sexual value, so therefore anyone wearing makeup is engaging in sexual activity, and we should keep that away from children, leads in pretty weird directions by analogy.

If I am in favor of keeping children in the shallow end of the swimming pool, I must by analogy oppose tall drinking glasses, I suppose. Some slopes are indeed slippery, but you seem to have engaged the genuinely fallacious version, here. "If we stop kids going to drag shows, what's next!? Banning dances and bringing back Victorian fashions?"

Eddie Izzard is an interesting case to me, personally, because the first show I saw him in, I didn't notice anything about his clothes. Someone later said something about his skirt and I was like--wait, what? I did notice his eyeliner but guys in show business were doing a lot of weird eye stuff in those days. I have often referred to him as a cross-dresser, but would not spontaneously think of him if someone asked me if I'd ever seen a "drag show." Automatic mental categorization is weird.

Anyway see my comment above re: makeup. As I said--I don't feel like I know enough about any of this to be drawing bright lines around what does and doesn't count. Nevertheless, when someone tells me drag is not inherently sexual, I feel like I am being invited to participate in kayfabe.

The thing that draws my notice in the housewife and Judy Garland examples is the makeup. The earliest arguments I'm aware of that makeup is inherently sexual are from feminists critiquing objectification; for example:

The final category of the disciplinary practices, Bartky holds, are those that are directed towards the display of a woman’s body as an ‘ornamented surface’: women must take care of their skin and make it soft, smooth, hairless and wrinkle-free, they must apply make-up to disguise their skin’s imperfections. Our culture demands the ‘infantilisation’ of women’s bodies and faces.

More recently we see makeup tracked as inherently sexual by Jordan Peterson, who is arguably a 2nd or 3rd wave feminist (via his work coaching women for career advancement) but would likely be disclaimed by most feminists today.

That's a pretty broad culture war spectrum agreement on the idea that makeup, at least in the classic foundation-lipstick-blush-eyeshadow configuration, is inherently sexual. It's not strongly sexual, and I think many, maybe most people do not consciously think of it that way, most of the time. But I think that's one of those ways people kid themselves about our inescapable nature as sexually-reproduced members of a sexually-reproducing species. Noticing that makeup is inherently sexual breaks the kayfabe, but that doesn't mean it's a mistake--to the contrary, what generally breaks the kayfabe is the truth.

Now, I do think @Gillitrut's phrasing is a little ambiguous; I'm not claiming that every man who participates in drag is doing so for personal sexual gratification. But the phrase "inherently sexual act" strikes me as inescapably inclusive of either doing or parodying things that are historically about sexual attraction and value. The objectification of women is not accidentally sexual. (I think this also accounts for much of the discomfort people express at seeing makeup on young girls, e.g. in beauty pageants.)

The best objection I can think of, right now, to my view is that men doing drag could claim to be somehow defusing the objectification of women, by making makeup and sexy dresses just another thing humans do with no sexual connotations whatever. But this would strike me as on par with holding minstrel shows for the purpose of fighting racism. I occasionally hear people claim they are trying to "break down the gender binary" by doing gender-nonconforming things, but sex and sexuality have such a (so far) inescapable biological grounding that it would be very hard to persuade me that this is even an achievable result (modulo transhuman levels of body-mod tech), much less a likely one.

A question: Is dressing in drag (that is, a man dressing like a woman potentially with makeup and so on) an inherently sexual act?

Is blackface inherently racial? Is blackface inherently racist?

"Wearing women's clothing" isn't drag if you're wearing a woman's... sweater, say, or overalls. A guy in a pink parka isn't "in drag." I'm not a big fan of "no true Scotsman" arguments, I don't think I know enough about drag to say there's a bright line here or there. But I can't think of anything I'd call drag, that wasn't at least sexual to the extent of "involving what would likely be regarded as 'sexy clothing' on a woman." I don't think it's plausibly a drag show if you're wearing baggy blue jeans and a loose t-shirt from the ladies' section at Walmart.

In the fight between network effects and identity politics, I think identity politics will win the long term victories. We've all seen what happens when "Twitter, but for conservatives" services get launched. When will we see the first "Twitter, but for SJWs" go live? And will that work out any better for them?

I would not predict Twitter's immediate demise, but I did not really anticipate Facebook's abrupt demise. I've used Facebook for years without much complaint, but in the last year or two they've declared war on my adblockers and serve me 10 ads for every status update I see from people I actually care about. This means I no longer routinely use Facebook or any of their products, even though I've been a piece of their captured audience for more than 15 years.

My students report almost no Facebook use, outside of Instagram, and when I ask them about social media they usually say TikTok or YouTube (the latter of which I do not think of as social media at all). Many also use Discord but for some reason don't seem to think of Discord as "social media." If it was publicly traded, I'd probably buy stock in Discord as the next Facebook-like center of online activity. Most of my students have heard of Twitter, and absolutely never use it.

Twitter won't collapse overnight, and I think Musk has better business intuitions than Zuckerberg, but I think history is against him. At some point enough people will quit that the network effects will collapse. The question is whether Musk can spin the company into something more sustainable before that happens.

Do they not stop to think for one second about the consequences of such an action?

I think what gets me is--maybe there won't be any noticeable consequences. Most, maybe all of these states implemented an "hours of supervised practice" prerequisite. If supervised practice really is enough to accomplish the goals of the bar exam, why in God's name would we continue administering bar exams? That's an expensive, deeply unpleasant process to subject people to for literally no reason at all (queue Meditations on Moloch electroshock discussion).

Conversely, if the exam really does protect consumers in ways that can't be accomplished by supervised practice, what possible justification could there be to shrug your shoulders and say, "well, this year we're just not going to bother?" "Yes, hundreds of lawyers whose legal education was interrupted by COVID, also never had to prove that they learned anything to the state, so... just watch out for lawyers who graduated in 2021 I guess? One in ten should probably not be practicing law?"

But no--we get total doublethink on the matter. The bar exam is absolutely crucial to protecting consumers from incompetent representation, and also a completely optional exercise with no serious relevance to professional competence, somehow.

Let me give you a slightly different example.

In higher education, the gossip right now is revolving around perceptions that students are cheating more, less inclined to come to class, more fragile with feedback and being challenged, less prepared for university-level work, etc. I'm not aware of any specific, careful empirical data here, and there is certainly a tendency among professors to complain about their worst cases. But certainly my own experience has aligned with that of the gossip.

I grew up hearing all kinds of stories about how those who grew up during the Great Depression had a tendency toward hoarding, "upcycling," and so forth. "Post traumatic stress disorder" has come to encompass a lot more than shell-shock these days. What's weird, to me, about post-COVID sociological changes is how just wildly unnecessary the whole mess appears to have been. My students aren't skipping class and sloughing assignments because they lost their families to the plague; they're skipping class and sloughing assignments because most of them spent a year or two living under government lockdowns, being assured all the while that this would not impact their life progression. But it already has.

Did you know that six U.S. states just waived the bar exam for law graduates to become lawyers. The bar exam, which is supposed to be the line between "competent" and "incompetent" representation, and state governments just said--eh, just wave everyone through.

Someone will undoubtedly say--well what were they supposed to do? I get it, really. People spent two years or more improvising at every turn. Mistakes were bound to be made. But it is depressing to me that so much of that improvising involved total abandonment of anything approaching ordinary common sense in favor of absolutely maximum panicking. That sort of thing is bound to have long term impacts.

this argument has been tossed at Georgism for over a century

Why do you suppose that is? The colloquial meaning of "land"--let's say, "the patches of dirt that are not submerged beneath rivers, lakes, or seas"--makes claims like "nobody creates land and it cannot be created, only improved" clearly false. So when Georgists say "land," they apparently have a technical definition in mind that goes beyond what people think when they hear Georgists say "land."

That sets the whole discussion up for failure straight out of the gate, because you're either being deliberately or inadvertently obtuse about the central subject of discussion. In the United States today, the physical coordinates over which people claim ownership are often the least of what their "real property" (as we call owned land) entails. On the prevailing "bundle of rights" view, in addition to the physical coordinates you own, your "property" also includes things like a right of quiet enjoyment, a right of access, a right against trespass, and so forth. Those are real rights, and often they are not the kind of right that you can really put a fair dollar value on.

There is a school of legal thought, "Law and Economics," which holds roughly that the purpose of law is to facilitate efficient economic exchange. Its founder, Richard Posner, has broadly disclaimed its universal applicability. Much of the law is concerned with economic exchange, yes--but not all of it. Individuals have important interests that should not be violated, not even if the majority says so, not even if the majority would benefit. Just as "land" on your view can also mean "the sea," "real property" means much more than spatial coordinates over which you happen to have dominion. Whatever its effects on markets, Georgism fails to appropriately account for its effects on people.

I find the land market to be inherently flawed due to the fact that nobody creates land and it cannot be created, only improved.

The Netherlands would like a word with you.

For the benefit of the community, @naraburns should recuse themselves from trans issues/this debate in future.

Yeah, that's definitely not happening.

Your assertion that I am "unacceptably partisan on this topic," as a moderator, is baseless. In the first place, I was not participating in that conversation as a moderator, and you should not be misled by PM's apparent inability to disagree with me without making that about my janitorial role. (Every. Time.) There are definitely some users whose approach to argumentation... clashes with my own, let's say, and I do often avoid moderating or even talking to them. But frankly we don't have enough active moderators for me to do this in every single instance, so I can't really pre-commit to never moderating such users, even if I rarely do.

(In fact, one of the most frequent moderation discussions we have begins with, "I am really tired of taking shit for modding genuinely horrible posts from this repeat-offender, can someone else do it this time?" Usually, these end up being Zorba's job, but I think we've all taken a turn spelling others at some point.)

The mod team has discussed topic bans for specific users in the past. A similar idea we've discussed is enforcing a minimum word counts on posts--I don't think it's ultimately a viable approach, and I don't think anyone else does, either, but it would shut down a lot of low-effort posting! So far, we've not implemented any such thing, and no serious plans to implement such things is in the works. But given his explosion here, you'd see PM get topic-banned from trans issues far, far sooner than a topic ban on anyone writing the way I've written on the subject. And then we'd inevitably be subject to accusations that this was somehow partisan, rather than a problem of PM telling people they should be eating bugs in a gulag. So that's one reason why topic bans have, thus far, been a non-starter.

If it's ultimately a concern about me setting some kind of example for the community, well. When I was first asked to moderate, the only moderator who raised a concern was @HlynkaCG, and he said something to the effect of "naraburns might like the fight a bit too much" but ultimately was okay with bringing me on. Some on our current mod team had multiple warnings on their accounts when they were chosen by the Doge process. The link between "model citizen" and "motterator" has always been... tenuous, I guess I want to say, in much the same way that some of our best quality posters have also been our worst rules violators. I definitely think more carefully about the rules now than I did when I wasn't a moderator! But if being a moderator was going to prevent me from strongly engaging on interesting topics when I feel like it and have the time, then I wouldn't be a moderator.

Clearly, some people would prefer it that way. Maybe someday, they will get their wish! But today is not that day. And tomorrow is not looking great for them, either.