naraburns
nihil supernum
No bio...
User ID: 100
Not sure where to begin with this really. Governments can't spend in any great capacity without taxation, whether or not you want to call it a 'question of revenue' or not. The government can't borrow without the presence of taxation guaranteeing to debt holders that the government will eventually fulfill its obligations. Nor can it simply 'print money', the consequences of financing expenditure with only creating new money would be absurdly inflationary.
I would recommend you begin by thinking more carefully before making sweeping declarations about what governments "can't" do. The second part of this paragraph demonstrates why you're clearly wrong about the first. Governments can, and do, "simply 'print money'" all the time. And yes--when they do that, it's inflationary! We know it's inflationary because we've watched it happen time and again throughout history. It's weird to say "governments can't do X, because it causes Y" when the suppressed premise is "and we know it causes Y because governments somewhat routinely do X." What you really mean is that governments shouldn't do X, for further reasons to be explained.
A claim I encountered some time ago, that I've been contemplating for a while, is that taxes are now the primary backstop of the dollar's value. You can find other ways to exchange goods and services, you can barter or use other currencies or whatever, but the only way to pay government taxes is with government-approved currency. So at some level you want your transactions to be taxed, because that is both how the currency you have maintains its value, and how you can secure receipts declaring that the government's monopoly on force should not be used to confiscate your property.
The more I think about this, the more I feel like the switch to fiat currency is something we as a civilization have yet to sufficiently digest. Part of me continues to suspect that fiat currency was just a horrible mistake. I'm aware of the reasons why it was done, and the arguments for how it greased the skids for American prosperity. But that's the kind of trick you can only pull once; when you do it, a bunch of stuff comes apart and the sociological distortions created by those trends are hard to predict beyond "probably not great."
But part of me wonders if we just failed to sufficiently commit. A major practical development that ended the Confederated U.S. and gave rise to the Constitutional U.S. was a bunch of unpaid soldiers. Would the question of soldier pay have arisen under a system of fiat currency? I think no--the U.S. cannot run out of dollars. Those dollars might be worthless, but that's a different problem! When the U.S. government "borrows" money, it's actually a bit of a farce; in a fiat system, the U.S. cannot possibly default on any of its dollar-denominated debt unless it chooses to do so (by refusing to print the necessary dollars). "National debt" is just a way of printing tomorrow's fiat dollars, today! And inflation is a tax on people who have money (both now, and later). The question is, if the government collected no taxes, and instead printed money to finance expenditures, would the resulting inflation be a greater tax than extant taxes, or a lesser tax?
That's an empirical question that will presumably depend in great measure on psychological factors (namely, how people perceive inflation versus taxation). It is not an empirical question I think will ever be answered. But this is why I think about the "taxes give your dollars value" argument a lot. If it's right, then one inescapable "cost" of maintaining a functioning system of economic exchange just is confiscating some amount of people's money from time to time--because if you don't, then people will get rid of money as fast as they can, exchanging it for durable goods and other stores of value. And not poor people's money, because they won't think about or understand any of this, but rich people's money, because they are the ones who are most afraid of having their goods confiscated by state-sponsored bandits and extortionists ("revenue services"). To successfully pay the protection racket, they must agree to participate in the sovereign's monetary scheme. But this functionally disincentivizes certain kinds of success, and it makes the task of transforming income into wealth more difficult, essentially protecting the existing rich from competition that might otherwise rise from the lower classes.
This is why the apparent death of small-government conservatism (which was never very healthy to begin with) is so frustrating to me. The appropriate way out of this mess, as I see it, is to keep the government small enough to drown in a bathtub. Imagine a government that collects sales tax alone, and primarily finances expenditures through inflationary money-printing. In such a government, the way to keep inflation low is simple and obvious: keep expenditures down. Every decision to use the government monopoly on force would be accompanied by a tax on everyone with money, in the form of inflation. That's about as direct as accountability gets. And yes--I can imagine that this could be hell on the economy in a variety of ways. But my argument is a moral one. I want to increase liberty, and decrease the use (or threat) of government coercion against citizens doing nothing but living their lives. If stealing was the only road to general prosperity, it would be better for people to make peace with being paupers.
The problem is most legible for the self-employed. For them, income tax is just an additional way of taxing profits after they've already been taxed as transactions. So like--you open up a shop, you charge $100 in labor to fix someone's iPhone. Depending on where you live, you also have to collect 6% or 10% or 12% in sales taxes on that money, to pay to the government. But hey, you've got $100! Well, no, now you also have to pay over 15% in self-employment taxes, and another 5% or 15% or 35% or whatever in income taxes to the government because... why? You already paid tax on the transaction, if it's not enough to support the system of exchange, then raise taxes on the exchange!
It's a little less clear for those who collect salaries or wages, but consider that in the U.S. your paycheck does get taxed directly, as an exchange, before income tax withholding kicks in--Social Security and Medicare amount to a 15.3% tax if you're self-employed, though most people have about half that amount paid by their employer rather than having it come out of their paycheck. That looks much more like a tax on the exchange of services for money than a tax on income per se (though it would be better, I think, if it were a flat fee rather than a percentage).
You might say "well, it's six of one, half dozen of the other" but even if that's numerically true, the math can function as a shell game for government actors. How often have you heard something like, "I don't mind paying taxes because I like to drive on roads!" A large chunk of most state transportation budgets, however, is fuel taxes--which makes sense. If you don't use the roads, you don't pay for (that part of) them. When there's a clear connection between the tax being levied, who it's being levied on, and how it's being spent, that benefits citizens by keeping systems accountable. That kind of transparency can, I think, help prevent cost disease. If your paycheck is getting charged, essentially, sales tax for the transaction between you and your employer, with the explicit purpose of keeping the nation's monetary system functioning, people will think of it very differently than if they're essentially pouring money into a general slush fund for Congress to spend on god-knows-what.
And really, in a system of fiat currency, it's kind of silly to have taxes at all. This is a more complicated argument, but basically the point of taxes used to be that the government needed your money to pay soldiers and pave roads. Under a fiat currency system, the (federal) government doesn't need your money; your money is worthless to a government that can make as much money as it wants. Really taxes aren't even a question of revenue, taxes are just one of many interlocking opaque and unaccountable systems the government and its cronies can use to regulate the economy, or in other words, to control people. For their own good, maybe! But that's the kind of thing I would prefer the government be forced to do explicitly, if it's going to be allowed to do it at all.
So basically, sales taxes are better because they are a step toward government transparency and accountability. It's okay to tax your paycheck as an exchange. But calling it an "income tax" so you can effectively double- or triple-tax certain exchanges (by multiplying the number of "exchanges" ostensibly taking place) is exactly the sort of thing I regard as morally impermissible government behavior.
Why should I read this book to know why I should read?
I mean, I don't know that you should, but since you asked the question "why read" I sort of assumed you were interested in an answer. If you have asked the question insincerely (which seems to be the case) then it doesn't especially matter how I answer you. But if you actually want an answer to the question you took the time to ask, then that is why you should read this book, or the one @baj2235 linked below--or indeed, you could perhaps read many different books, and decide for yourself that you've been right all along ("that was indeed a waste of time and effort--I shouldn't read, and I no longer need to ask the question!") or learn something new ("ah--so this is why I should read, I see now").
So, uh... I apologize for what is ultimately a somewhat low-effort response, but I can't resist. The answer to your question can be found in this book.
Yeah, @FCfromSSC understood me correctly. "Too good to check" doesn't necessarily mean that the story is false--it means:
Essentially, either a tale so perfect, or a confirmation of extant prejudices so wonderful, that to actually investigate, to possibly find out that it's not true, would be a shame.
But this has created a bit of a rhetorical shortcut where people will say "oh, that story seriously confirms $OUTGROUP's bias, so they're not even going to check if it's true, therefore it's false."
I feel like it's necessary in such cases for me to acknowledge things like: yes, Biden suffering from dementia would confirm a number of my existing priors. Nevertheless, we have historical precedent of similar things actually happening, so it should not be regarded as only a partisan position at this point to suspect that the President is mentally unwell. There seem, as you and others observe, to be many good reasons to genuinely wonder whether President Biden is a fully-functioning Chief Executive.
shouldn't we want land to be controlled by the people who can create the most value on it?
I cannot possibly create the most value on the land I own, so, no. I want land to be controlled by bona fide purchasers for value with clean chain of title.
Also, what are the arguments against LVT, besides low-effort "taxes are always bad and raising them is evil?" Genuinely curious for well thought out reasons why an LVT would be a bad idea.
Edit: For those new to this idea, a Land Value Tax in it's most basic form simply says we should tax away the value of the land, and only let people who sell land profit off of the 'improvements' they make, such as buildings, restorations, etc. For instance if you bought a piece of land and tried to sell it 1 year later off pure speculation, doing nothing to the land, you would not receive any profit.
My concern with LVT is that I regard most kinds of property tax (as well as income tax) as fundamentally immoral, for basically Nozickean reasons, and I do not regard that as "low-effort" in the slightest. I am fine with sales tax, insofar as government facilitates exchange through the medium of regulated money; when you use the government-facilitated exchange, you should also pay for the maintenance of that exchange. I am okay with property tax to the extent that the use and enjoyment of your property depends on government police powers protecting borders and private property rights, but even here I favor strong homestead protections; for property you live on, especially, I regard tax foreclosures as strictly immoral. In the U.S. today, almost all tax dollars fund purely redistributionist aims, and I do not think there are very many plausible justifications for the amount of redistribution we do (though there are probably some cases where it's justified, particularly where negative externalities are imposed on the public by private actions).
I get the impression that some of the basic ideas of Georgism/LVT may be compatible with my view, but presumably someone who paid the value of land, and never improves it, can only sell for the (present) value of the land. Any "profit" they make is down to fluctuations in the market that are beyond their control. One of the most basic rules of business associations law is that whoever bears the risk, reaps the reward. The way you've described LVT here ("tax away the value of the land"), privatizes risk of holding unimproved land, while publicizing rewards. That seems to me just as objectionable as publicizing risk while privatizing rewards.
But I have not made a careful analysis of Georgism (beyond reading what Scott says about it) so I'd be interested in any corrections you might be able to offer my view.
The degree to which "Biden is not in control" satisfies the ingroup narrative criteria for "too good to check" is extreme.
However, consider the current White House webpage on Edith Wilson:
After the President suffered a severe stroke, she pre-screened all matters of state, functionally running the Executive branch of government for the remainder of Wilson’s second term.
“Secret President,” “first woman to run the government” — so legend has labeled a First Lady whose role gained unusual significance when her husband suffered prolonged and disabling illness.
This is probably the best (and, today, most celebrated!) example of a president who was not the president. (I suspect, if the script were flipped in a possible world where we had a woman president today, a First Gentleman who stepped in to "functionally [run] the Executive branch" would not be regarded as a hero.) As other posters have noted, "the president is being controlled by others" is a common accusation from any given president's outgroup, but we do have historical examples of it happening, so it's insufficient to write such accusations off without examination.
I don't get the impression that Jill Biden is intellectually up to the task of handling the Executive, but she does seem to have her hands mostly full with handling Joe. Though his gaffe-prone career makes it a little difficult to say with total confidence, he really does seem to be in the early stages of a dementia-style decline. And I would bet that someday, when it no longer carries a political cost to do so, someone will write a book, or even a White House webpage, about the "heroes" who ran the government while Joe Biden was in decline.
(But maybe not--there is some indication, albeit disputed, that Ronald Reagan's final years were somewhat comparable to the current state of the Presidency, but I'm not aware of anything praising Nancy Reagan or George Bush for keeping things running smoothly. I also think that the media's prior enjoyment of accusing Trump of being mentally ill, while today carrying water for Biden, does represent clear bias, but that particular bias likely surprises no one.)
Can an (unlicensed) derivative artwork of copyrighted art be registered as a trademark? I guess that's the question.
Anything can theoretically be trademarked, as long as it meets the requirements. Rather, if you are, without permission, using as a mark something that someone else owns a copyright in, then you would presumably be liable for copyright infringement every time you used it. The USPTO would in most cases have no reason to know whether your trademark registration included unlicensed copyrighted elements; this is a fight the copyright holder would have to raise on their own. Depending on how derivative the trademark ultimately was, the copyright holder would in most cases have no idea any infringement had occurred (minus some whistleblower getting involved).
And why would any content creator sell the unlimited right to their art for the most advanced language model for $0.01 per picture? Disney certainly isn't going to take that.
Statutory licenses are already the legal standard for music recordings and broadcast-to-cable television programming (see table on page 38 of this PDF). When tech innovators clash with content industries, a historical answer has been for Congress to impose a compulsory licensing scheme. I agree that $0.01 per image might be too little, but surely $1.00 per image would be prohibitively high in most cases of model development. The thing is, deciding the right price is something that can be handed to a bureaucracy to determine. The problem right now is that, as far as I can tell, all image models are just straight-up mass infringement. It's Google's "library of Alexandria" all over again, with technological innovation and the letter of the law coming into direct conflict. And it's not at all clear who will win, or what it will cost the rest of us.
It already seems semi-clear that you're not going to be able to eg. trademark a logo you make with Stable Diffusion
Trademark law is quite different from copyright law, I would be very hesitant to stake a claim that nothing made with Stable Diffusion could serve as a trademark.
The companies will argue that a human who views a thousand Greg Rutkowski pictures online and then paints and sells an original painting in a similar style to Greg Rutkowski isn't different to an AI using a training set of the same and producing an original artwork, but this ignores decades of legal precedent in digital copyright cases
Yes, but most importantly, this precedent, which is a shocking timebomb for copyright law generally. It is the clearest example of someone being granted copyright protection for a style, and while I'd like to say "I can't imagine this insanity holding up to continued scrutiny from appeals courts," it's actually all too easy too imagine.
What people forget is that copyright law is a hard case of total regulatory capture. No one cares about copyright law but content industries and aging geeks. The main practical consideration in copyright law is, "does this help content industries make money?" It's extremely likely that, over the next several decades, Congress will adopt some kind of compulsory licensing scheme for original artwork, such that model trainers will owe $0.01 (or $1, or...) per picture they incorporate into their models. This will help to shut down amateur and FOSS efforts toward AI, ensuring that only big players can afford to make advances. The upside for government is, big players are much easier to regulate.
I'm locked into starting a career in tech, in one of the wokest cities in the nation.
At the risk of fighting the hypothetical--why? Assuming the nation you're talking about is the United States, you're always free to just go get a different job.
I don't know what specifically you do for a living, but if it can be done remotely, remote work is pretty hot right now! Then you can live wherever you like, modulo stable internet access. And even if you can't or won't do remote stuff, there is no shortage of tech jobs in non-woke or less-woke cities. Chances are good that whoever you work for will have some amount of "diversity" stuff going on, but like, even Silicon Valley gets slammed for being insufficiently woke all the time.
Still, if you insist on going forward with this thing that you're apparently afraid to go forward with, I expect you'll find it, most of the time, a lot better than you fear. Even at exceedingly "woke" corporations, there's a lot of real, actual work to be done that just isn't impacted in any discernible way by hyper-obsession with race or gender or whatever. In most circumstances you can literally just ignore it. Some companies do go so far as to "discipline" people who, say, don't add pronouns to their signature block, but the vast majority will never notice or care. When someone passes the plate for Black Lives Matter or Habitat for Humanity or whatever, you just... don't give!
Yes, you'll probably need to bite your tongue from time to time. But that's always true everywhere you're thrown into dealing with people. If you think you have it bad in that department, try working customer service! You'd be amazed how far you can get by allowing people to draw their own conclusions, instead of spelling your beliefs out in excruciating detail at every opportunity. And if you're forced into a mandatory diversity training where an outside contractor with primary-colored hair tells you why you're the oppressor, sit through it, ask annoying questions if you dare, and fill out all the anonymous feedback follow-up paperwork with "this was a huge waste of everyone's time and money and it makes me ashamed to be employed here."
In the vast majority of employment cases you're going to be fine being honest, as long as you're not an asshole about it. "Thanks for the input, I'll take it under advisement" is wonderfully noncommittal. "Is there any specific thing you would like me to do at this time?" is also a great way to scatter vacuous calls for increased wokism, which often never make it past the "raise awareness" stage of organizational activism. I do this with my own superiors every year: "Is there anything I am doing that you would like me to stop doing, or anything I am not doing that you would like me to start doing?" They have rarely considered my performance in those terms, and so they have nothing to say, and so I am free to continue doing as I please. Of course, you might get specific feedback ("add some damn pronouns to your signature block!") and then you'll want to follow it (or start sending out resumes, depending on your value to the company), but extracting specific feedback also gives you an opportunity to demonstrate compliance, which is itself a form of currency in employment negotiations.
Basically: you'll be fine, don't worry. But if you can't help but worry, you should keep in mind that you may be better off looking for a different job.
I am far from an expert on cars. However, my general impression is that hydrogen powered cars overcome many of the individual downsides of EVs--at the cost of reinstantiating many of the broader downsides of fossil fuel vehicles.
For example, you can fully "charge" a hydrogen car in 5 minutes, and its range will be close to that of many fossil fuel vehicles. Even with a "fast" charge, an EV is going to take 15+ minutes to get 200 miles of range, and more often you'll be charging it overnight (and never taking it on road trips). If you have the ill fortune to get caught in a blizzard, a hydrogen vehicle will be much safer than an EV, both in terms of staying functional and keeping you warm. But the technology is costly, charging stations are uncommon, and every new advance in battery technology brings EVs closer to parity with hydrogen performance.
The big picture, though, is that the charging infrastructure overhead for hydrogen (producing, transporting, and storing it) is basically the same as fossil fuels, minus the more complicated stuff that happens in refineries. Most current methods of hydrogen production are energy-intensive and carbon-positive. At best, you get the same problem as with EVs charging off coal; at worst, you're essentially selling EVs with an even higher carbon footprint (and increased thermodynamic waste along the way).
So, basically, in an alternate universe where we already built out a bunch of hydrogen charging stations and brought the cost of production on hydrogen fuel cells down through mass production, people might be wondering why anyone would want a slow-charging, short range EV! But I suppose it's possible the EU intends to subsidize that world into existence, and is counting on fusion or renewables to make electrolysis a more economical approach to hydrogen production. There are definitely possible futures where hydrogen cars are far better than EVs, but I'm skeptical that we'll bring any such future to pass.
I don't have anything useful to say about this... I don't think Kanye is a mentally stable human being, but I'm not sure many humans at that level of fame can be stable. Existing on that scale is so far outside the ancestral environment that I suspect brain stuff just gets weird.
What immediately struck me about this case was how clearly it feeds Kanye's argument. When saying "the Jews are shutting down everyone who disagrees with their agenda" gets you shut down by organizations substantially owned and/or operated by Jews, like, what--you think he's gonna conclude "oh, I must be mistaken?" This is on the same rhetorical playground as the well-trod "canceling conservatives just gets them bigger book deals, 'left media bias' is obviously a myth."
I can't help but be reminded of Whoopi Goldberg's suspension over what sounded to me as mostly weird commentary--not anti-Semitic. The antipathy or even just skepticism so many black Americans have expressed toward Jews is remarkable. But I can imagine being a black person whose community openly expresses frustration at whites or Asians or Hispanics "keeping me down"--in such an environment, why wouldn't a statistically wealthy, powerful group of phenotypically white people be permitted targets of the same basic criticism?
It also seems related to stuff like this. Armed black militants demanding reparations and a closed border seems like evidence that some blacks, at least, have decided that they don't want to be pawns for either "Left" or "Right" politics. Not sure that works out for them, in a two-party left-right coalition environment... but maybe?
And yeah. Twitter delenda est.
Well, yes, but do you see from what I wrote why that is entirely beside the point?
Without, I think, entirely meaning to, @ZorbaTHut once upon a time took the weight of the SSC sub's "Roundup" culture almost entirely on his back, and has been carving out refuges for it, to greater or lesser extent, ever since. Some things have fallen off, other things have been added on. But something Zorba has been repeatedly clear about from the beginning through today is that growth and life are not the primary objectives. Would we like to see fresh insights from new users on a regular basis? Yes. Are we willing to give up on the foundation to make that happen? No.
This is unusual for an organization, even an informal and largely ad hoc organization like the Motte. Virtually all organizations hold, as a stated or unstated assumption, that any of their principles may be abandoned in order to preserve the functioning and existence of the organization itself. This is a big idea in wartime jurisprudence, of course. But also consider Google's abandonment of "Don't Be Evil." Or watch the ACLU bail on free speech, or watch Methodists approve gay marriage, that's two consequential examples from a single month in 2021. Something I admire a lot about Zorba is his willingness to act on the idea that, no--we're not going to worry about survival, we're going to do what the foundation suggests, and if we die, we die! I'm far more conservative; I opposed the Motte's exile from SSC, I accepted an invitation to moderate without having much faith in the longevity of the sub, and I would not have initiated the move offsite without much stronger censure from the reddit admins.
But here we are, and we didn't die immediately, or even see a substantial dropoff in posting. That violates my nervous expectations, again. We may yet die! But if we die--we die. And while that's not the conclusion we're aiming for, it is a conclusion I think we are all able to accept.
spouting this cowardly garbage
I'm not totally happy with the level of charity in this thread, but certainly your rhetoric here has crossed over into "unnecessarily antagonistic" territory. Please don't.
Where are new users going to come from?
Where do new users ever come from? Why did people go to the SSC sub in the first place? Why did they follow Zorba over to the Motte sub--but perhaps more importantly, why did they follow Zorba over to the Motte sub, instead of going to the CWR sub, or later to the Schism sub? Why have so many people actually come over here onto Zorba's server?
We have a community, and we have an ethos (the "foundation"). On reddit, it was easier to keep the community churning, but hard to preserve the ethos--and getting harder every month. Here, it may very well be harder to keep the community churning! But the ethos will remain intact. Neither the current SSC sub nor the ACX comments section handle culture war discussions as well as we do (it seems to me). I don't think any of your concerns are wrong in any obvious way. I just feel like you are overlooking (ignoring?) the very public justification Zorba has been giving all along: better the community die on its own terms than live with a compromised foundation. I hope the community does not die for quite some time--if ever! But if we'd stayed on reddit, death would have been at least as inevitable--it just would have been a death of our ethos rather than a dissolution of our userbase.
I think the move off Reddit will come to be seen as a big mistake.
Why--because the forum will die? That's a possibility, however (1) the number of CW thread weekly posts hasn't noticeably dropped since the move and (2) Zorba was pretty explicit that "keep our commitment to open discourse and die" was a preferred outcome to "capitulate to limiting discourse on especially difficult topics and live." Plenty of people predicted we'd die after splitting of from the SSC sub, too. We frequently had users point out ways in which they regarded the sub as "dying." But several years later, well... maybe we're still dying? Very slowly?
the main thing that drew admin attention was a few trans activists reporting gender-critical posting
While there was certainly some of that, the co-founder of TheSchism explicitly owned up to drawing the Eye of Sauron to the sub in the first place, because he uncharitably interpreted some conflict theory posting as "calls to violence." And there were other things that AEO didn't like, for example (((parenthesis))). You may be right that radical trans advocates seeking to shut down open discourse were the main problem, but the list of problems was not short, either.
The main pipeline for new and interesting users is now cut off.
Eh. Striking the balance between Eternal September and Eternal Silence is tricky, ongoing, and probably not indefinitely maintainable regardless. I will continue to post our AAQCs in the subreddit until someone stops us, probably. The barrier to participation is a little higher, now, maybe, but in some ways that can be as much a feature as a bug.
Lol what.
This is low-effort and antagonistic. You're welcome to ask for clarification on a claim that confuses you, but this is not the way to do it.
Has it actually been demonstrated that most of these students are actually incapable of learning algebra? Or is it more that the school needs to slow down, separate out the high achievers and the actually retarded, and maybe adjust the teaching strategies(all things that the Obama admin strongly rejected trying in favor of doing the same thing, but more expensively).
I mean, some of the kids we're talking about in the public school system are profoundly mentally retarded, so you can't just discount them entirely.
But after that, it depends on what you mean by "demonstrated" and "incapable," I guess. Suppose, for example, there were someone who actually could learn algebra, but only if they have one-on-one tutoring for eight hours per day for five years? Of course, you have no way of knowing that's true at the outset, so: at what point between just "send them to a standard high school algebra class for a semester or two" and "expend every possible resource teaching this person algebra" do you conclude that they are "just not capable?" Or if "incapable" is just an off-putting word for you here, at what point do you conclude, "we've made every reasonable effort, at this point if they want to learn algebra they're just going to have to find the time and resources on their own?"
Slowing down and adjusting teaching strategies may not be what the Obama administration favored, but I know many schools have taken that approach anyway. I'm not aware of any impressive results that didn't experience regression to the mean in pretty short order, but naturally I'm not aware of every experiment anyone has ever done! But I've discussed educational experiences with a lot of students, and a large number of them manage to master just enough algebra to squeak out a "C" so they can graduate. The movement to abolish algebra requirements seems like some evidence that many educators have concluded, yes--some people are just never really going to get it, or at least not in a reasonable enough timeframe to justify the effort of teaching them.
Well, it's very literally co-incidence; things corresponding in both nature and time of occurrence. On one hand, cheating has been happening forever; we have cuneiform tablets from 1750 B.C. complaining that someone delivered the wrong grade of copper ingots. It has even been theorized that sapience is the evolutionary result of a runaway cheating arms race. So, like, you're definitely not noticing a new development in human behavior.
On the other hand, we could say the same thing about, like, transsexuals (an example I pick in part because of the advantage, arguably unfair, enjoyed by males participating in women's athletic competitions). Men living as women, and vice versa, are attested anciently, though it is hard to separate ancient record from ancient rumor. The fact that something has been happening forever isn't proof that it's not happening more now. And it is manifestly true that there are a lot more people claiming to be something they aren't today, than there used to be--to the point where some people get conspicuously upset when it gets phrased that way (notably, Simler and Hanson observe that the best way to persuade someone of a falsehood is to first persuade yourself!). Nevertheless, the act of sending social signals that deceive regarding one's sex appears to operate in the same mental realm as sending signals that deceive regarding one's fidelity to one's spouse, or the poker hand one is holding, or the like.
The trouble with your hypothesis is that even if you are noticing a genuine trend toward something like "increased social or personal acceptance of cheating," it's going to be difficult to measure empirically. You could try to capture it within some particular domain, but the very nature of cheating is such that your ability to measure it depends on your ability to detect it, and the whole point of this kind of behavior is to pass undetected. This is the standard difficulty with claiming that e.g. certain kinds of crimes are underreported, or that certain kinds of crimes are even occurring. You will also, per the example above, run into people who want to say cheating is not really cheating--to give another example, is extramarital sex "cheating" if it's consensual (i.e., open marriage)? Or is that just an extremely elaborate form of cheating (e.g. deceiving regarding the nature of one's love and affection, to the point of effectively gaslighting your spouse into believing it's okay)?
So I am open to the possibility that we live in an society that has become so "individualistic" in its priorities that individuals are more expected to pursue their own conscious aims than ever before, even at the expense of unlegislated cultural norms, and expected to allow others to pursue those conscious aims even when they appear, to our anciently-evolved cheat-detection software, to be cheating. In formal competitions we may still get upset about clear rule-breaking, if we catch people doing it, but I don't think I'd have to look very hard to find a Marxist willing to claim that "get yours, screw others" is very much a late-stage capitalism thing, or words to that effect.
But I think it's going to be very difficult to demonstrate, and extremely prone to being one of those arguments that strengthens your priors whatever those priors happen to be, e.g. "the real cheaters have been my outgroup all along!" That doesn't mean you're actually wrong--and the difficulty of the argument may make it one of those that turns out to be exceptionally fruitful when made well. But off the top of my head I can't think of a good way to explore broadly-defined "cheating" in a clear empirical way.
No, your mistake was contributing nothing but heat to what was a relatively anodyne post. "Oh, that went well, but you know my outgroup could have made it much worse, and probably would have just last year" is unnecessary heat. When your outgroup fails to be as horrible as you expect them to be, let them.
And the constant whiny bitching and crying by artists about AI art has made me suspicious of the motivations of these so called "artists"
Write like you want to include everyone in the conversation, please. This is unnecessarily heated.
This is really unnecessarily antagonistic. If you're unfamiliar with the idiom "borrowing a jack," you should read about it. There are plenty of examples of people out there actually doing stupid or horrible things; there is no need for you to invent extra examples from whole cloth.

I was raised in a religious community and I marvel at how many of today's social justice advocates are literally the same people who were the nosy church ladies in decades past. Not just the same sorts of people--the same specific people. Some of them are still church ladies, too--but those who have stopped being church ladies did not ride out on a wave a new atheism. Instead they rode out on a wave of righteous indignation concerning gay marriage or some other social issue they saw their church as being "out of touch" on. Thinking through my extended family, this category covers about a third of the women, but not one man in ten.
Actually, now that I'm drawing up tallies, I'm realizing with a dull non-surprise that none of the formerly-religious men in my extended family who took up atheism in the last, oh, three decades or so have adopted any "social justice" views as a result, while far more than half of the women (a smaller absolute number) who severed ties with their churches are now extremely vocal leftists. This harmonizes with demographic reports I've seen but I'd never before sat down and really thought about it.
It's hard for me to model such a complete lack of principles without referencing the NPC meme. But the best I can manage is just that these are people who are predisposed, for whatever reason, to enforce social expectations to the best of their ability. One day they woke up and saw that the social expectation that they go to pride parades was stronger than the social expectation that they go to church potlucks, so they stopped making casseroles and started making rainbow flags. Charitably, social cohesion is just the point for them; less charitably (but maybe more accurately from an evopsych perspective), the opportunity to snub others while raising one's own status in the most powerful in-group may also be an attractive position.
More options
Context Copy link