@naraburns's banner p

naraburns

nihil supernum

11 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 04 19:20:03 UTC

				

User ID: 100

naraburns

nihil supernum

11 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 04 19:20:03 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 100

I'm curious as to why you're vaunting this current state of affairs as Western Civilisation

I mean, first, I think I was pretty clear about that--both in terms of technology and art, things are going very well--but second, you seem to be attributing to me a great deal of confidence that I don't actually feel. Rather, I identified a few possibilities, only one of which I "find myself increasingly favoring"--a far cry from "vaunting," I think! I understand your pessimism, but you should still at least be realistic in noticing the good stuff, such as it is.

There is still a nonzero amount of good things about the West, but every day there seems to be yet another erosion of norms and as time goes on more and more people appear to be hitting the defect button.

Yeah, what I'm suggesting is that this is the result of the "interfacing," rather than the result of Western Civilization per se. One possible response would be that we should cut back (or entirely) on the interfacing. If there were no other civilizations with which to "interface," that might lead to a stagnation problem instead, but all I'm suggesting is that it's not Western Civilization to blame, it's the step to "Universal Culture"--which turns out to be a misnomer and maybe ought to be abandoned. Only certain kinds of people can do Western Culture (and that extends to most Western people, who benefit from Western Culture but do not contribute to it, but thanks to value compatibility at least do not create the same kind of drag as the "interfacing" does).

The western position in the world is less assured than triumphalists seem to think it is, and its biggest and most formidable competitor is China; possibly the least western modernised country on earth, the one least integrated into the Universal Culture in their beliefs, values and traditions and which has charted their own relatively singular course to modernity.

You seem to regard me as among the "triumphalists" here but I was pretty explicit about the rise of other cultures potentially being a good thing for Western Civilization--not only through competition, as I mentioned, but also just through the reduction of demand for interfacing. Imagine the pressure it would take off the U.S. if suddenly the Islamist world was obsessed with doing terrorism in China instead of the U.S., or if China became the preferred target for illegal immigration from around the world.

Every country is self-serving, Western nations certainly wouldn’t be the first ones to be so, but the glazing does not correlate with what's going on in the real world.

And yet it is only the West that has liberated the world, ever. So far! None of this should be taken to suggest that the West is somehow unusually moral or never responsible for skullduggery or whatever. I have said "there is a lot of great stuff in Western Civilization even today" and your response seems to be something like "the West is not perfect and is often quite bad" and to that all I can say is "I never claimed anything to the contrary." You're talking past me. If you think that, on balance, Western Civilization really is dead, or bad, or whatever, like, I don't have a lot to say about that. That's a slightly different topic than whether it still exists at all, or whether it still makes valuable contributions to its constituents or others.

I’m not "anti-Western Civilisation" per se.

I mean, you do seem to be very clearly anti-Western Civilization, though.

But I am a cynical doomer par excellence who believes that ideology is often just a smokescreen for uglier, baser human tendencies, and I can't get myself to share this outlook.

To the contrary, you seem to be holding out quite a lot of hope and optimism with regard to e.g. China, which you expressed pretty clearly above. I could pretty easily write a laundry list of sins perpetrated by the CCP, but I doubt any of it would be news to you. I don't think you've said anything, in either of your posts, that strikes me as clearly false or wrong. You just don't seem interested in applying your cynicism evenly across all ideologies. In my experience, this is almost always how "critics of Western Civilization" end up: expert at criticizing one (what is often their own) civilization, often in totally legitimate ways, while nevertheless weirdly fawning over (typically, foreign) alternatives that are either not obviously better, or are in fact obviously worse.

I’ll be sure to actually use an AI to dumb it down next time so even you could understand it. Go be a troll somewhere else.

Don't speak to other users like this. It has been a while since your last ban, and you've accrued some QCs in the meanwhile, so I'm not going to ban you, but please consider this a stern warning.

Culture war material goes in the Culture War thread. Thanks.

I am pretty sure there was, at one point, such a thing as western civilization. I think it included things like dancing around maypoles and copying Latin manuscripts. At some point Thor might have been involved. That civilization is dead. It summoned an alien entity from beyond the void which devoured its summoner and is proceeding to eat the rest of the world.

Whenever I read this, I feel like something is being missed. It might just be that none of us is fully capable of truly appreciating our own culture, because we are too close to the situation. Or a slightly different problem--maybe it is that there is no and has never been any truly great culture, but only the appearance of culture through rose-colored retrospection.

Or maybe--and this is the explanation I find myself increasingly favoring--Western Civilization is so amazing that basically all rational people want to participate in it, but the vast majority of living humans do not have values that are actually compatible with that participation (at least--not fully). Western Civilization hasn't gone anywhere, it's still landing rocketships and producing art and what-have-you. But it is sometimes hard to see, because we have attached a multitude of converter arrays, siphons and interfaces and other cultural technologies intended to "share" the beauty and bounty of Western Civilization with the billions of people who are only capable of appreciating those parts that happen to be "legible without context, pleasurable without effort, and cheap to reproduce." Such people always existed, of course! Most Romans were neither poets nor sculptors nor philosophers, after all. But never in history have so many people directly and indirectly benefited from the cultural superiority and magnanimity of so few.

And because one of the great insights of Western Civilization is a broad-based humanism, it generously, even gregariously invites these interfaces to take everything, forever, without payment, without gratitude, without apology.

It speaks to the greatness of Western Civilization, really, that it manages to survive the process at all. A pessimistic viewer might call this a "bloodletting" and suspect that, despite its strength and superiority, Western Civilization is doomed to eventually collapse from exhaustion and perish altogether, perhaps taking the entirety of humanity with it. But pessimism is not the only option! Optimistically, the more the rest of humanity takes from Western Civilization, the more it comes to resemble Western Civilization. A group with partly or wholly incompatible values today need not have incompatible values later. And what's more--one of the values of Western Civilization is improvement through competition! As other cultures arise and develop in the wake of the magnanimity of the West, they can serve to reinvigorate Western Civilization. Yes, we lose the unipolar pax Americana, but what we gain instead is an opportunity to enter into renewed competition and conflict.

I sympathize with much of what you say--certainly contemporary architecture needs to die a horrible, screaming death--but I actually love so many new things, Western or otherwise. Video games especially, but also novels, anime, even Hollywood continues to produce the occasionally fantastic movie. AI technology is awe-inspiring, even if it might also be our doom. Medical technology is increasingly just straight-up miraculous. Most of this is either directly or indirectly attributable to the operation or influence of Western Civilization. Which is why I increasingly suspect that people are only losing sight of this because so much energy is getting poured into somehow finding ways to share the bounty with people who neither understand nor appreciate it, but seek to benefit from it only because the benefits are too great and obvious to be ignored.

I was previously modded for reacting with excessive heat.

Well yes, that too!

I'm demonstrating a pretty significant level of restraint and non-reactivity.

I agree that you showed some restraint. But you still wrote a rule-breaking post, and that's what counted against you here.

Also, "ad hominem"? I was condescending, but I didn't substitute insult for argument.

Ad hominem literally translates "to the man." Its use here identifies your excessive focus on georgioz and his characteristics, to the detriment of your engagement with the substance of your argument. When we talk about ad hominem in the context of moderation, it is not an academic critique of your grasp of informal reasoning, but rather a suggestion that you should spend less time casting aspersions on your interlocutor and more time addressing the substance of your discussion.

(Fun fact: I am a philosophy professor. I make my living, in part, teaching both formal and informal reasoning!)

No, I'm not. I am criticising the kind of moderation policy that leads to this outcome. People are absolutely going to compare bans, and it's unreasonable to just declare that it's some kind of fallacy to do so. . . . you know exactly what I'm saying: these bans are absurd and unjust, relative to each other. Declaring the two incommensurable doesn't retroactively change what I'm saying. Reputation should only go so far.

I see. Well, it's an unforced error to insist on things that "I know" when I have not told you that I know them; as a rule, I am not hiding the ball on that. I can be mistaken. We can disagree. But I'm not pretending, and now you're making the same mistake with me as you made with georgioz.

But now that you've spelled it out more clearly, okay! You don't like the way we moderate based in part on reputation, as it sometimes leads to results that offend your sense of fair play. Your complaint has been noted. In hopes of managing your expectations: so far, the moderation team does not agree with your position on the matter, and has no plans to adjust our moderation approach in response to your complaints at this time.

equivalent

What I am trying to communicate is that the length of the ban is not strictly determined by the specific offense, so you are drawing a false equivalence in your perception of the ban lengths in this case. They are incommensurable.

Basically, you seem to be saying "georgioz got off light!" And we are saying, "yeah, he's a really good poster normally, so we let him off light this time, hopefully he was just having a bad day."

Or maybe instead you're saying, "I was punished too heavily!" Maybe so? But you admit you were engaged in condescension, despite it being reactive, and reactivity is exactly what you've been moderated for in the past. It's true that we frown heavily on telling other users to "fuck off." But that doesn't mean we don't frown on users for less vulgar ad hominem attacks.

I would just encourage you to not read too much into the precise length of anyone's bans, yours or others. It's not a science. It's just feedback.