@porkpiehat's banner p

porkpiehat


				

				

				
1 follower   follows 0 users  
joined 2026 August 20 02:20:22 UTC

				

User ID: 4571

porkpiehat


				
				
				

				
1 follower   follows 0 users   joined 2026 August 20 02:20:22 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 4571

Mestersvig

Apparently the Mestersvig base will be near a potential 13 billion barrel oil field. If the oil field ever gets developed Greenlanders will be the richest people on the planet. Eat your hearts out, Guyana.

It is the judges who produced the ridiculous result. I mean, these two delightful young women won a judged debate. Should we just accept they are skilled debaters because of argument from authority? Or are the judges just as bad as the debaters?

No one who matters was convinced, even though some rationalist made noises like "this updates me towards zoonosis".

I agree that Fat Tony is only a heuristic, but it's a mode of thinking that most rationalists are deficient in. This is where the quokka meme comes from. And I also think, in the real world, the quokka's weaknesses are more severe. I'd much rather have Fat Tony than Scott Aaronson at the head of my army.

My wish is that the United States will provide an immigration pathway for all the "Nicolas, 30 ans" people to seek a better life in the U.S. If we elect Vance in 2028 there is a chance.

Europe hates and punishes the people who keep their society afloat. Let's bring them to America.

It's a shame because Europe has a lot of advantages and is truly beautiful in many ways.

Of the many many more crowded and indoor areas for a leaked virus to spread, it happened to be the one place, and only the one place, where natural origin makes the most sense?

The wet market is not the one and only place where zoonosis makes sense.

The zoonosis theory is that bats spread it to an intermediary animal (like a raccoon dog, civet, or pangolin) and from there to humans. So anywhere that one of these animals were handled or sold could spread it to humans, literally thousands of places. People have some of these animals as pets even. And the zoonosis people still have no idea which animal is the missing link. No animal sold at the market had a natural reservoir of the Covid-19 virus in its native population.

No, it's worse than that. The DEFUSE plan from 2018 explicitly proposed gain-of-function research on bat coronaviruses modified with human-specific cleavage sites and that this research was to be conducted in part at the Wuhan Institute of Virology.

The whole plan is spelled out.

This is more than "hanging around with fraudsters". This is "making a specific plan to defraud the lottery".

I think we're broadly in agreement, but it's imperative that we don't put the same people in charge of the cleanup that caused the problem in the first place.

I'm not even talking about China. I'm talking about the gain of function researchers in the US. I'm talking about Anthropic setting up a biolab. I'm talking about the people whose bungled response caused an order of magnitude more damage than the virus itself. Nothing was learned. Putting Fauci in prison would at least "encourager les autres".

And HIV too of course. But these viruses have been around since at least the 1970s, realistically much longer. Africa today has a population far greater than when these diseases developed. Why aren't we seeing like 10x the number of new diseases?

And why not India which even today has the same population as Africa and historically was much more populated.

Clearly there is more to disease formation than just raw human population.

You actually don’t have to act in demonstrably stupid ways. Consider, again, the abortion bombers who accomplished nothing vs the patient legal process which eventually overturned Roe. Consider the Leftist street riots of the 1960s that put Nixon in charge vs the patient march through the institutions that radically reshaped America along leftist lines.

You don’t start a nuclear war because China did an oopsy. You figure out a way to make yourself less reliant on them.

This is that same argument that comes up with abortion.

"If they are really killing millions of babies every year shouldn't there be terrorists trying to bomb abortion clinics?"

I mean, yeah, there were. It just made pro-choice stronger and then the perpetrators went to jail, solving nothing. Lashing out like a retard doesn't help anyone.

If I truly believed that China had released a nearly holocaust amount of deaths onto the Earth I would be calling for flattening the country's leaders.

You would? You would start a likely nuclear war that would kill many times more people than Covid? That's deeply insane. In any case, China didn't try to start Covid, and the US is far from blameless.

Man, after punching you in the face, "Really when you think about it, there is no reason for us to fight. I was mad before. You are mad now. Suffice to say we both experienced madness and it's time to bury the hatchet."

I agree that we should patch the vulnerabilities. But the people patching the vulnerabilities should not be the same people who shut the world down and tried to create a global censorship regime. It matters.

He didn't "say something silly" in the course of his walls of text. His conclusion distilled from those walls of text was ridiculous: 1 in 50 septillion.

Would you care to engage with the thoughts and arguments presented here? Or are you just looking for a fun slam dunk and people who agree with you?

I think we can do better than this.

I wish they would also update that it wasn't just bad protocol at Chinese labs, it was also irresponsible behavior by people like Dr. Fauci who were pushing gain of function research in the first place. Even though everyone knows it's a lab leak now, no one is acting like it. People on the left still treat Dr. Fauci like a hero.

Here's a better analogy.

  1. John Q and the lottery director conspire to create a way for John Q to win the lottery that spells out in exact detail how they will do it.

  2. The lottery directory says, "no, we won't actually do that" but John Q continues researching lottery hacks anyway

  3. John Q wins the lottery

  4. Anyone who questions John Q winning is a conspiracy theorist

But his results (1 in 50 septillion odds for a lab leak) are so ridiculous they should be rejected outright. I know that RootClaim couldn't just say "um, no" because they had this big important debate that was supposed to set the standard for debates. But they ended up with this ridiculous result and no one is convinced.

Once again we've proven that rationalists have wisdom as a dump stat. It's very concerning that these same people could end up with outsized power in an AI regulatory regime.

In the Roomclaim debate, Peter Miller, arguing for zoonosis, assigned 1 in 50 septillion odds to a lab leak being the cause of pandemic.

If this is "rationalism", I'm going to go with Fat Tony.

That's an interesting thought. But then, naively, wouldn't we expect diseases to form almost exclusively in places like India or Africa where density is high and medical treatment is poor? Why haven't we seen more diseases?

One possible explanation: Even though today's humans represent 7% of all the humans the have ever existed, we represent a tiny fraction of all the mammals that have ever existed.

A plasmid might emerge from a bat, land in a pangolin, then later escape with a mixture of bat and pangolin DNA, etc.

This would seem to contradict the previous idea as there aren't that many pangolins. Bats seem pretty good at serving as disease reservoirs, being numerous and close together. If Covid-19 emerged close to a population of bats known to harbor coronaviruses, the zoonosis case would make more sense. Sure wet markets an all that, but now we're chaining together multiple things that have to "go right" to create Covid. The lab leak theory on the other hand seems quite straightforward.

Will we ever get the truth about the origins of Covid?

Venture investor Bill Gurley recently appeared at the All-In Summit to give a talk about how journalists and investigators uncovered the truth about various disasters like the Challenger Space Shuttle and the Boeing 737 Max. He talks about searchers, who look for the truth, and blockers, who try to keep people from finding it.

Then he talks about the origins of Covid.

While admitting he does not personally have a definitive explanation for the origins of Covid, he talks about how people who questioned the zoonosis hypothesis were repeatedly sidelined and ridiculed.

He gives one intriguing example of something which is not exactly a smoking gun, but still a giant blinking arrow pointing at the problem.

In 2018, there was a proposal made to DARPA called DEFUSE, in which bat coronaviruses would be studied. Human-specific cleavage sites would be added. Transmissability would be increased via gain-of-function. And this would happen in the United States in collaboration with, you guessed it, the Wuhan Institute of Virology. DARPA ultimately rejected the $14 million proposal.

In the word of Nassim Nicholas Taleb, please explain this to Fat Tony and tell him that Covid-19 wasn't a lab leak. Tell him that a bat (living in Laos) spread it to an animal (possibly a Pangolin!) and then from there to a wet market in Wuhan, the exact city where they (definitely weren't) doing the exact research that would allow Covid-19 to be created.

"But Fat Tony, I only had the exact idea for how to create Covid-19 in a lab. I didn't actually do it. It was the pangolins. Tony, no, please, not the blowtorch.... "

I'm also aware of the Root Claim debate which I've encountered as a wall of text and like 30 hours of videos. I'd love an explanation of why this debate matters, but my tendency is to dismiss it as a gish gallop.

In any case, I recommend giving the Bill Gurley talk a listen. He's got a nice drawl.

This is going to be similar to self-driving cars where it's impossible to reduce the failure rate to zero, but the robots will outperfor humans by so much in aggregate that we'd be foolish not to use them.

Doctors are in general one of the highest IQ professions and are often quite practical as well, working as close to the public as they do. But I think most of us have had the experience of dealing with doctors who are midwits, lazy, or checked out. I have myself received extremely bad medical advice from doctors on at least 2 occassions.

If I had to choose between Astra and a replacement level telemedicine doctor who couldn't write prescriptions or examine me, I would choose Astra every time.

In 15 minutes, I was able to use O-3 (an ancient model at this point) to correctly diagnose my father's medical condition which mystified multiple doctors. It really was pretty obvious in the end, but that's where the laziness comes in (compassion fatigue more generously).

For the things I use AI for, hallucinations have become rarer and raret. I almost never encounter them anymore. I think we'll get there for medicine at some point too, but I do acknowledge that AI's are really bad at physical and spacial reasoning at this juncture.

There aren't enough pristine white schools to give an extra ~5% minority population.

This is the problem isn't it. I'm all for giving disadvantaged minorities a leg up, but our changing demographics means that there are too many disadvantaged minorities to spread out. I'm fine sending my kid to a school that's 5% or 10% black. I'm not fine sending my kid to a school that's 50% black. So people pull their kids out, or move to a different school district, and pretty soon we have schools where everyone is a disadvantaged minority and they all suffer.

I live in a lily-white area of a lily-white, high income town. But when I looked up the demographics of my local high schools, I was shocked. It's like 25% black and 25% Hispanic. Where do these kids come from? The school is still doing pretty well by state standards, but I imagine it's not that far from tipping into dysfunction.

Literally who?

I don't doubt the chronology, but the stage has to be set ideologically. The spark didn't really cause the fire, it was inevitable with enough dry timber. If Dylan Roof, who I honestly don't remember, had never existed do you think that the schools wouldn't have been renamed? Of course they would have. And if a Dylan Roof didn't exist it would have been necessary to invent him. Like we have now with the lynching hoaxes.

Not a question, but a recommendation.

We recently had a discussion about rare earths re: Greenland. I think this guy's video on rare earths is good and that his channel is good in general. Entertaining, informative, non-cucked. I watch it while on the treadmill.

One thing I don't understand is that, at some point not too long ago, Confederate apologia was relatively common in the North. I mean, for Pete's sake, a Canadian band wrote a sympathetic song about the South, "The Night They Drove Old Dixie Down".

Now the common take is that the south was evil, no good, they sucked in every way, etc... The Dixie Chicks are just the Chicks. Lady Antebellum is Lady A.

What changed?

Its not what we would normally expect. In the 1920s I would expect the antebellum South to be the outgroup. In the 2020s, they are the fargroup. You would typically expect hatred to lessen as the conflict becomes a distant memory. Instead, it has increased.

Regardless, I thank God for the defiant oppostionalism of the Borderers. They guard my right flank. Without them, the leftist hate mob would be after me.

I’ve been trying to live it up for the same reason but failing, mostly due to having young kids. Any suggestions on how to turn money into happiness would be much appreciated.

Yeah, I'm reading Grant's memoirs right now and he mentions often how his troops were able to eat on the land from abundant food resources during his campaigns in the west.

I recently read 1776 and there was a similar theme of armies finding abundant food as well, even to the astonishment of British troops unaccustomed to such agricultural wealth.

America really is the land of plenty.

Okay, you clearly know a lot more than I do. I'm slightly skeptical of the value of black troops in northern service only because of the culture war implications where obviously any modern historian is going to be forced to say they were incredible fighters and even contemporaneous accounts from northern leaders would not want to cast shade on their own troops. I wonder what southerners said about them.

In any case, what would you do if playing as Jefferson Davis to try to win the war?