@porkpiehat's banner p

porkpiehat


				

				

				
1 follower   follows 0 users  
joined 2026 August 20 02:20:22 UTC

				

User ID: 4571

porkpiehat


				
				
				

				
1 follower   follows 0 users   joined 2026 August 20 02:20:22 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 4571

Why I don't invest in energy, Europe, and especially European energy. They embrace poverty on an almost spiritual level.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2026/sep/18/eu-europe-fuel-prices-calls-windfall-tax-energy-firms

European governments have discussed imposing a bloc-wide windfall tax on energy companies, as near-record fuel and gas prices pile pressure on leaders desperate to contain mounting public discontent and the challenge of the far right.

With elections due next year in eight EU countries including France, Italy, Spain and Poland, leaders are scrambling to head off the potential fallout from what analysts have warned could be one of the continent’s biggest energy shocks in decades.

Germany’s finance minister, Lars Klingbeil, called on ‌the European Commission at a meeting of EU finance ministers in Dublin on Friday to propose possible ways to tax what he described as the excessive profits of oil companies.

"Several member states have been calling for models for a long time,” Klingbeil said, demanding proposals by next month. “People can see how oil companies are exploiting the situation, overcharging and significantly increasing their profits.”

Okay, actually I do invest in Norwegian oil tankers, but don't tell anyone.

Interesting. I knew that my post would bring out some people with deep Civil War knowledge. I'll fully admit that anything I can think many others have thought of before, more deeply.

When it comes to the slaves, I wonder if hundreds of thousands of freed slaves streaming North would ultimately have become a burden. Potential culture war issue: were regiments composed of freed slaves actually useful (I don't trust the academy to give me an honest answer here).

Definitely the south should have never fought outside of an intrenched position, but they did so regularly and at great cost, even when defending their own territory. But I can imagine why soldiers and commanders would prefer gallant charges over sitting inside fortifications for months making staged retreats.

The biggest difficulty I see for the south is that Union naval dominance was inevitable. Perhaps the Union could have fought its own defensive war and just starved the South out over time via naval blockade without taking a lot of casualties. I wonder if President McClellan might have gone for that.

Agree about nuclear investments but what about Sprott Uranium fund? The thesis is that we’re short on uranium, Chinese plants are coming online, and uranium cost is a tiny fraction of a percent of operating costs so the price could 10x without demand destruction.

I own some but I have to admit I’m getting bored and it doesn’t feel very prosocial to hoard uranium so I’ll probably sell and pay cap gains next year.

You're allowed to play as Jefferson Davis which means exercising a lot of dictatorial powers, but not unlimited power. You could try to abolish slavery. But if you did, you'd probably get deposed or killed which would end the game in a loss.

One weakness, if you could call it that, that the North had is that they were unwilling to really go after the civilian population. I am not sure they'd have been willing to do the necessary to root out civilians who were harboring rebels. I'm sure people could point out counterexamples, but in general I don't think northern soldiers would be willing to commit atrocities against southern whites in order to win the war.

The South probably couldn't have stopped the North from taking cities, but I doubt the North could have fully suppressed the countryside. But maybe the South would have had its own motivation problems if Richmond, Atlanta, and New Orleans all fell without big battles.

Let's say you're redoing the Civil War and you get to play one of two characters: Abraham Lincoln or Jefferson Davis.

Would it actually be easy to win the war playing as Jefferson Davis?

Obviously, the South would never have been able to conquer the North. The North had immense economic, technological, naval, and manpower advantages. But they didn't need to. They just need to impose enough of a cost on the North that the North would come to a settlement. This doesn't appear that far-fetched. The re-election of Abraham Lincoln was no sure thing in 1864. Had the war not turned decisively in favor of the Union, its possible that McClellan could have won. In the end, he still captured 45% of the votes and won three states (NJ, DE, KY). If McClellan prosecuted the war as President like he did as a General, its likely the South could have held out for a long time. Situations like the starvation of Union prisoners in Andersonville, and the sheer awfulness of the conflict would have likely have proven intolerable without a sure path to victory.

So what could the South have done?

Fabian tactics. They should have simply refused to give battle whenever possible, and harassed Union communications. Johnston did just that as he retreated in the face of Sherman's army. But then he was replaced by the Confederate government because they preferred someone who wanted to fight. Then Sherman took Atlanta.

Lee's incursion into Pennsylvania was a fatal mistake that did more to weaken the Confederate cause than anything. He may have been a good tactician but this strategic blunder is unforgivable.

But the real weak point here is Jefferson Davis. He often involved himself in military decisions and wanted commanders who took an aggressive posture. While appropriate for a stronger force, this is entirely inappropriate for a weaker one. Confederate doctrine should have been preservation of precious manpower, avoiding giving battle, never fighting when not intrenched etc... That last part is also key since the Civil War showed some signs of a proto-WWI type environment.

In any case, in hindsight, the war seems eminently winnable for the South. Which character would you play: Lincoln or Davis?

I think this is an accurate take. It's possible that Canada and EU will sign some sort of fake deal that does nothing except affirm that the Orange Man is indeed bad.

The EU, of course, would love to take Canada's natural resources and give them some hostile MENA immigrants in return. I think Carney's too smart to let that happen.

From a perspective of what's best for Canada, they should just give the US whatever it wants, deregulate, shut the border, and watch GDP per capita soar to a level above that of the United States. Their relative poverty is only due to a weakness of spirit. Based on natural resources and human capital, there is no reason for them to be so poor. But at least we're not Americans, eh?

I don't think that rare earths matter to this story and I doubt that the US will profitably extract them from Greenland.

China controls the rare earths market not because of superior geology but because of superior refining capacity. For a long time, China has sold rare earths for below the cost of production, driving western competitors out of business. Molycorp is the most famous example.

The US has ample supplies of most rare earths. What we lack is refining capacity. Fortunately, efforts are underway to create a price floor which will generate the necessary investments. And substitution is a real possibility as well. Tesla recently removed rare earths from its EV motors entirely.

What the US wants in Greenland is not rare earths, but to deny China naval and airspace real estate. Sure Denmark may have been unlikely to grant China access, but isn't it nice to have it in writing?

I think your calibration is off about when to trust Trump and when not to and that the details of the deal will broadly match his post on X.

Will update if wrong. Hope you do the same.

He says Trump stuff and then no one questions his policies. It’s a luxury few enjoy.

Yeah, what’s up with Carney? It’s a bit right? I have a hard time believing he’s some kind of Canadian patriot given how he had UK and Irish citizenship until last year and he has lived, worked, and vacationed in the US extensively.

It’s a good bit though. Reducing immigration and lowering taxes to own Trump is a nice touch.

No this is not the US narrative on Denmark at all. To the extent that there is a narrative it’s that Denmark is a uniquely competent and capable socialist country (left view) or that they are surprisingly based on immigration (right view).

Of all the countries in Western Europe, Denmark is among the most successful. But you know which country is absolutely fucked? Belgium. Seriously look at their demographics. They are done. Something might be salvaged by Flemish independence but I wouldn’t get my hopes up. Belgium also happens to contain the capital of the EU and of NATO. Conditioning US military dominance on NATO might not be a winning move long term as weaker countries get picked off by Islamic immigration, reliance on Chinese imports, and energy poverty.

Fully agreed. I still wonder why Denmark would say yes.

Consider, for example, Canada. Their leader just goes around saying anti-Trump stuff and then gets to rule like a king because that's the only thing anyone cares about. Seems like a formula that would work almost anywhere.

Unless Trump's post is straight up wrong, it seems that we already know what the US received, which is not insignificant.

I'm asking what they gave Denmark in exchange.

But you are right that Denmark/Greenland did not give up anything tangible, only veto power. US control of the island is good for them and Chinese investments would ultimately be counterproductive. It's a win win.

Fair enough. I trust your lived experience. But listen to software devs when they say that AI works now, it hallucinates a lot less, and it has gotten remarkably better in the last 12 months, even the last 6 months. I use it every day. It is does not hallucinate much.

Harnesses such as Claude Code and Codex have changed the game.

So something actually happened regarding Greenland.

Details are fuzzy, but Trump just posted that the US made an agreement with Denmark and Greenland gives the US permanent military control over Greenland, the right to expand its military presence there and, most importantly, to veto any foreign intervention on the island.

This will not make Greenland a part of the United States, which means Mercator Projection dominance lies beyond our grasp for now.

Critics will point out that this doesn't really change anything since the U.S. already had de-facto military control over Greenland. I think in these case the critics would be wrong. If Trump's post is accurate, this does seem substantially different from the previous agreement. It's permanent, the US can expand with Denmark's permission, and they can deny foreign expansion without Denmark's say so.

It's unclear exactly what the US gave up in order to get these concessions, but Trump says it will cost the US taxpayer nothing. Perhaps there are trade concessions?

What's somewhat interesting is that the US barely has a presence on Greenland at all anymore. At one point, in the Cold War, it stationed 10,000 troops there consisting of a quarter of Greenland's population. Today, just 150-200 unlucky souls man the Pituffik Space Base in northern Greenland. Perhaps that's what makes this agreement valuable. The U.S. can now deny adversaries such as China a perch in Greenland without having to actually send in troops.

Weird. This is so far from my experience that I wonder what you guys are even doing? Like, you only tried AI twice?

If you’re a senior dev, and AI is not banned by your org, and you’re not personally using AI, that seems very inefficient.

Definitely. It’s the same problem that self driving has where every Tesla that crashes with FSD is nationwide news even though it’s 10x (or more?) safer than average drivers.

Do you use these tools on a regular basis? My experience with hallucinations is that they are extremely reduced.

Oh, I'm fully aware of the many reasons that micropayments have failed to get traction. It would have to be handled at the DNS layer or something and bundled through on your internet bill. Anything that asks users to pay a separate bill is going to fail.

What's different now is that we might have a forcing function when there are hacks that carry a significant price tag.

But yeah, it might be such a hard nut to crack that the internet just doesn't work anymore. My confidence in all of this is low, and despite everything, I rate "nothing happens" as most likely.

The hallucination argument is losing power. Harnesses will fix hallucination much like they have for coding.

I'm not going to straight up ask Astra to do my taxes, but I'm fully confident that Astra+harness is capable. So now we just wait for the harness. No doubt lots of smart people are working on it.

Accountants don't get the numbers right anyway which is why I do my own taxes now. It's a boring, frustrating job and attracts people who like money more than having interesting work with predictable effects.

Of the job categories listed in the 1960 US Census, supposedly only one has disappeared completely: elevator operator.

Nevertheless, I think the complexity argument might fail for accountants. Complexity actually favors AI. They are good at it.

When you talk to rich people, everyone is looking for an accountant. They all think that their accountant is bad and want a better one. I've only had bad ones personally. Now I just do things myself because I don't want to deal with errors. AI has been a godsend. I think it's likely that AI will do my taxes in April 2028.

But there is a silver lining for accountants: knowing which rules to bend or break. If it treats taxes like it treats code, AI will happily fill out a 500 page form so you can pay $0.04 to the state of Arkansas for some K1 you got from an oil services company. The accountant knows to throw it in the trash. They can tell you to ignore that letter from IRS because it doesn't get serious until the nth notice. They know how to ignore the rules that contradict the other rules. They know that certain tax dodges are okay because all their clients do them and never get audited.

I think it's somewhat similar to driving. The system only works because people know when to break the rules. Will AI break the rules? If so, will they be liable for that? Humans might stay in the loop just so they can break/bend the rules.

what becomes of the internet writ large, if/when we do actually get open-sourced Astra+ level models which any skiddie can plausibly prompt with the Navy Seal copypasta and point at any website or domain of choice?

I've been thinking about this a lot lately. Predicting what will happen is tough but I could see a couple things happening.

  1. Cloudflare maximalism. One thing that's changed post ChatGPT is that nearly every website is now behind CloudFlare. This reduces automated traffic a lot (at the expense of a single point of failure). We might take the next step and give Cloudflare or a company like it control of the server architecture too so that my server is running on a known secure architecture that is regularly patched. No more just standing up a LAMP stack on Amazon.

  2. A new internet protocol using some cryptographically secure identify verification with payment. So if I want to visit themotte.org, my account will be charged like $0.0001 per request, possibly handled at the DNS layer. Of course people have been proposing this for email for ages and it never happened.

We're probably going to stay on our current course until some big financial institution gets hacked.

This seems awfully bullish on Anthropic considering that OpenAI is at their same level, and other labs are only maybe 6-12 months behind.

Wow and he was able to work these 12 years through the height of cancel culture.