sodiummuffin
No bio...
User ID: 420
This is a pretty AI-savvy forum. Arguments like "Pangram is itself AI so it's bad/unreliable/hallucinating." or "This other AI detector didn't work and they're all the same, right?" may work on Reddit, but I don't think very many people here find them convincing. Pangram has been under significant scrutiny lately, aside from their own studies people have been putting quite a lot of effort trying to find false-positives without success outside of very short passages, low detection scores, and a poem where the same 6 words are repeated four thousand times. I know it's embarrassing to admit to undisclosed AI use, and dramatically more embarrassing after you've already denied it, but what you're doing now is, like the initial denial, just making it worse. Knowledgeable people reading your posts know that you're lying or, at best, using something like Grammarly or Copilot In Word that you don't realize is AI.
If you really are the first guy whose writing style creates Pangram false-positives, find a pre-2020 false-positive and collect your $4100. I predict that won't happen and that, like every other case of "Pangram thinks my writing style is AI", your writing only started detecting as AI after high-quality text models became available.
Pangram says 100% AI and it's obvious AI writing style, who are you trying to fool?
If your next argument is that Pangram is prone to false positives and you just happen to write like an AI to both human and Pangram's perceptions, note that there is currently a bounty of $4100 ($500 from this guy plus others offering their own funds) for a lengthy false-positive written before AI was available. Maybe some of your pre-AI writing is worth money?
https://x.com/Nition/status/2115166531462259163
I'm offering a USD$500 reward to the first person who can present pre-2020 human-written text that the latest version of @pangram flags as AI.
The specific requirements to claim the reward are:
- At least 750 consecutive words.
- Pangram flags it as 75% or more AI generated.
- You provide proof that the text was first written in 2019 or earlier and is unmodified.
- The text was ostensibly human written. This requirement only exists to avoid trick answers like output from GPT-2, machine translation, markov chains, the same word 500 times etc.
Don't use AI to write your posts, it's annoying to read and I don't want to dredge whatever point you were trying to make out of the morass of AI filler.
There was a guy on the Slatestarcodex subreddit that, based on the idea that some activities were more efficient at combining multiple benefits, tried to figure out what activities were most efficient. His candidate for the most optimal activity was playing sports outside in the sun with your friends.
The foremost benefit of sports is not "self-confidence", and it certainly isn't providing an advantage in zero-sum college admissions (which could likely be revised directly if you had the power to abolish women's sports). The foremost benefit is fitness, and secondary benefits include recreation, both spending time with people you know and meeting new people, etc. Competition provides a framework that encourages all of those benefits.
So why are middle and high school sports this one, weird exception where everyone wants segregation?
Middle and high-school sports? What's with the age-segregation? Why shouldn't middle-schoolers try to compete in professional adult sports leagues along with everyone else? The answer, of course, is that this would amount to them not having the benefits of organized sports at all. Abolishing women's sports is the same, but for half as many people.
You might ask, but wouldn’t this stop girls from playing sports? No, I don’t think so. They’ll still be on the team, they’ll still practice and compete. It just might stop them from being starters, because they’re probably not good enough for that. But that’s the same problem that most boys have, too. It’s not some fundamental human right to have a starting spot on the varsity basketball team.
This seems to contradict your other post:
It's disengenious to talk about how the boys' league is "technically open to all" when we all know darn well that will never happen.
In any case, it's wrong. Open leagues are both unrealistic and sometimes dangerous for women to compete in, if that wasn't the case far more female athletes would participate in the current open leagues for the bragging rights, fame, and superior competition. Indeed, it's already fairly common for female professional athletes to compete against high-school boys teams as practice, because that's the sort of gap needed to make it reasonably even.
The girl who was the star of her girls’ field hockey team gets a full-ride scholarship to Harvard, then gets recruited into a hedge fund, where she is quickly promoted to make diversity quotas. So she becomes an extremely confident, ego-tripping, “girl-boss,” with immense power to make bad decisions that damage the world, or at least her company. She makes life hell for her subordinates, and loses all attraction to any normal men. She advocates strongly for feminist programs that benefit women like herself: more money for girls sports, no trans girls allowed in girls’ sports, and more female executives.
This seems like something you should check before assuming, because I'm pretty sure it's all completely wrong. For starters, this study found no correlation between women's sports participation and attitudes towards sexism except in highly inegalitarian countries such as Iran. And of course opposition to MTFs in women's sports is more popular among right-wingers and thus would negatively correlate with support for diversity quotas. Also, I think if you took away their hobby in the name of anti-feminism that would make feminism more popular among women, not less. (Compare to SJWs censoring videogames in the name of feminism - how successful has this been at making more men feminist?)
Scott post about the paper from when it came out in 2018:
Asian-American women are not OK, at least if you go by what they write about.
Well, what they write about in "notable" books, which often includes going through the funnels of getting published and winning awards in an environment where [minority] writers talking about [minority] issues is highly prized. It's entirely plausible that if you went by either raw numbers of asian-american writers or by aggregate sales they're mainly writing self-published romantasy or the like. Part of the reason for the sameyness and triviality is that asian-americans don't have much in the way of potential racial grievances, especially if affirmative-action is off-limits.
- Prev
- Next

It's easy to forget today, in an era where so much of religion has retreated to views like "separate magisteria" and "well I guess God acted through evolution", but for millennia the existence of life was the best evidence for God's existence. Not "we can imagine a version of God that doesn't directly contradict the evidence" but "God is an intuitive explanation for this obvious phenomenon that we don't otherwise have an explanation for". Why do people and nature both clearly have so much purpose - eyes to see, teeth to eat, hands to hold, minds to think? When you drop some pebbles on the ground they don't assemble themselves into a sculpture and then start walking around, how did it happen with life?
An obvious answer is because someone chose to make them that way. That wasn't the right conclusion, even then: guessing a designer with a mind like we have was too much of a leap and equating that with [your culture's specific religious beliefs] was a much bigger leap. And while nature bears countless marks of purpose it also has a lot of elements that don't really make a lot of sense as a deliberate creation, especially not a deliberate creation by a single being with a unified purpose (for the monotheists), and especially not an benevolent one (this is presumably the inconsistency that the Garden of Eden myth was created to help explain). The right answer was "I don't know." But when one view has a specific intuitive explanation and the other has "maybe it was designed that way by someone unknown, maybe all life just appeared spontaneously the way maggots spontaneously appear in meat (another thing I can't explain), maybe there was some other unthinking process that I don't understand" it is understandable that people went with the first explanation.
The theory of evolution changed that. Suddenly there was a real explanation other than God, not just "I don't know but the burden of proof says...". Now, you might argue that as a practical matter the cat is out of the bag and writing arguments against evolution isn't going to convert millions of people to Christianity, but people don't think like that. Scripture provides non-evolutionary explanations for life and for centuries those were considered straightforwardly factual, not something to be excused away with "well the 'days' in which God created those things are a metaphor for the millions of years during which God was invisibly guiding natural processes such as evolution". It makes sense that some Christians would continue to argue on behalf of the explanations that were a core part of Christianity for so long, and with evolution as the dominant alternative that means trying to find arguments against evolution.
More options
Context Copy link