sodiummuffin
No bio...
User ID: 420
Scott post about the paper from when it came out in 2018:
Asian-American women are not OK, at least if you go by what they write about.
Well, what they write about in "notable" books, which often includes going through the funnels of getting published and winning awards in an environment where [minority] writers talking about [minority] issues is highly prized. It's entirely plausible that if you went by either raw numbers of asian-american writers or by aggregate sales they're mainly writing self-published romantasy or the like. Part of the reason for the sameyness and triviality is that asian-americans don't have much in the way of potential racial grievances, especially if affirmative-action is off-limits.
- Prev
- Next

There was a guy on the Slatestarcodex subreddit that, based on the idea that some activities were more efficient at combining multiple benefits, tried to figure out what activities were most efficient. His candidate for the most optimal activity was playing sports outside in the sun with your friends.
The foremost benefit of sports is not "self-confidence", and it certainly isn't providing an advantage in zero-sum college admissions (which could likely be revised directly if you had the power to abolish women's sports). The foremost benefit is fitness, and secondary benefits include recreation, both spending time with people you know and meeting new people, etc. Competition provides a framework that encourages all of those benefits.
Middle and high-school sports? What's with the age-segregation? Why shouldn't middle-schoolers try to compete in professional adult sports leagues along with everyone else? The answer, of course, is that this would amount to them not having the benefits of organized sports at all. Abolishing women's sports is the same, but for half as many people.
This seems to contradict your other post:
In any case, it's wrong. Open leagues are both unrealistic and sometimes dangerous for women to compete in, if that wasn't the case far more female athletes would participate in the current open leagues for the bragging rights, fame, and superior competition. Indeed, it's already fairly common for female professional athletes to compete against high-school boys teams as practice, because that's the sort of gap needed to make it reasonably even.
This seems like something you should check before assuming, because I'm pretty sure it's all completely wrong. For starters, this study found no correlation between women's sports participation and attitudes towards sexism except in highly inegalitarian countries such as Iran. And of course opposition to MTFs in women's sports is more popular among right-wingers and thus would negatively correlate with support for diversity quotas. Also, I think if you took away their hobby in the name of anti-feminism that would make feminism more popular among women, not less. (Compare to SJWs censoring videogames in the name of feminism - how successful has this been at making more men feminist?)
More options
Context Copy link