Indeed. GTA6 has a 99, but 4 and 5 managed 98 and 97, respectively, and no one now considers them worthy of those scores.
- Prev
- Next
Indeed. GTA6 has a 99, but 4 and 5 managed 98 and 97, respectively, and no one now considers them worthy of those scores.
Mafia is certainly a fascinating game. It is essentially the game that the GTA series has been trying and failing to be since GTA 4 - the serious, narrative-driven open-world crime game. There's much that can be said about why 4 and 5 couldn't match a game made 10 years before them on a fraction of the budget, but the more interesting part is to @Rov_Scam's point about how to go about making an open world game that is at once both realistic and still not filled with tedium.
Mafia 1 was made by Daniel Vavra, who would later create the Kingdom Come: Deliverance series, with all three titles sharing a similarity in being highly realistic near-simulations that are nonetheless considered great gaming experiences. The big thing with Vavra is that he is first and foremost a very talented game designer; he didn't make super realistic 1930s or 1450s worlds because he was autistically obsessed, but because the realism informed the kind of game he wanted to make. Mafia 1 was supposed to be a serious title, but you couldn't expect players to buy in to the narrative if the world surrounding it was as wacky and chaotic as that of GTA3. Getting pulled over for speeding immediately grounds the expectations of the player. But the game makes it pretty easy to avoid or simply outrun the police, so the average player probably stops a few times across a 10+ hour game. Similarly, making weapon limits that are based on what you can fit in your coat both informs how combat is designed in each mission. There are lots of little things like this, but I think you get the idea.
With Grand Theft Autos 4, 5 and seemingly 6 based off initial feeling, you get the impression that Rockstar don't really have game designers. They are great at creating these immensely detailed worlds that are great as sandboxes, but within the story and missions things fall apart. Rockstar want to have their cake and eat it, giving players max freedom to cause chaos in their world while hoping they will also plug in and pay serious attention to their mediocre storylines and characters. The tedious tasks at the beginning of GTA 6 are not there because they are key to setting player expectations or telling a story, they are just there because Rockstar spent billions on mocap and animations and want to show off all the minutiae of their world.
This is the answer to Rov_Scam's query about why games could never fill in that realism part. The majority of developers, Rockstar and others, do not know how. They don't design games that are realistic and build that realism into the core structure of how the game works, which Mafia did to great success. For Vavra, he looks at the fact that police enforce traffic laws and figures out how that would fit into a game world. For Rockstar, they look at the fact that sometimes your friend calls you up and asks you to go bowling, and that's it. They put it in the game, and it's just there.
Now obviously GTA6 is only just released and perhaps it will overcome this and be a counter example to this whole post, but we'll have to wait and see.
edit: I should also add that an even better example of this is the remake of the original Mafia that released a few years ago, made by a different studio. It's still a good game because the original was so good, and some of the updates and changes were clearly necessary. But it's so obvious that the new studio did not understand why Mafia made the choices it did, and they throw out all kinds of key pillars of the game in the name of accessibility/QoL/whatever
More options
Context Copy link