@stoatherd's banner p

stoatherd


				

				

				
1 follower   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 December 03 22:28:01 UTC

				

User ID: 1961

stoatherd


				
				
				

				
1 follower   follows 0 users   joined 2022 December 03 22:28:01 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 1961

A reminder of the quote I'm replying to:

The 12 year old must have had it coming.

Support a child predator on accident? The 12 year old must have had it coming.

Yes, your personal political enemies are all cartoon villains, as always.

Are you pretending the content of their message is an untrue reflection of their opponents' beliefs? Because you keep avoiding addressing this.

I don't consider you a serious activist group; does that mean your comment is untrue?

Never said either A or B of this.

So back at your words, try replying to what is in my comment.

So, I ask you a clarifying question: "Are you saying X?" I also add: "If you're NOT saying X, then (...)"

And, in your world, asking the question means I'm not replying to your comment?

That's pretty disingenuous.

They'll receive brownie points for citing statistics once they stop trying to ruin the lives of scientists who provide inconvenient statistics.

Could you try replying to the words in my comment?

To be clear, your position here is "Republicans are truthfully spreading the things their opponents believe, and this is a bad thing"?

If so, I'm confused at why you're comparing it to "Black Propaganda", which is definitionally about untrue stuff (according to Wikipedia, which is only honest).

If your position is that Republicans are untruthfully spreading things their opponents don't actually support: which things? It might help your comment to be explicit.

Eric Schmitt embarrasses himself with a flawed accusation (...) there is no apology for the false accusation

Imagine falsely accusing someone and then not apologising for it! You're right, that would be embarrassing.

I'm sure you personally didn't do exactly the same thing to me lower down in the thread, where you mistook me for another commenter and threw a bunch of accusations at me:

this is the most hilarious nitpick I've ever seen

Truly incredible. You dismiss the prediction markets as fantasy

This is how you act anytime someone points out verifiable facts that go against you

you just throw a tantrum and try to divert the topic.

The odds are the odds and your behavior doesn't change that

reality will not bend because it triggers you.

Then, when I pointed out that I hadn't said any of the things you were accusing me of, what was your response?

Yep I double checked and you're a different person than who I originally responded to.

Nice apology after accusing a person of throwing a tantrum based on your lack of reading comprehension.

The absolute chutzpah to accuse your political opponents of beclowning themselves with false accusations, and then not apologising for those false accusations, a couple of hours after doing the exact thing yourself. Truly incredible.

I think it'd be fair to call their position the null hypothesis from which to argue from

Not in general, and certainly not for culture war issues. That's handing a gigantic unearned advantage to any political positions aligned with LLM biases, which are well documented.

Frontier models are definitely a form of evidence

Yes, in the same way that everything is evidence. But that doesn't make their opinion valuable when arguing stuff here.

If we're arguing over some factual point, e.g. "are tomatoes a vegetable?", it might make sense to invoke an LLM's response (though linking to an actual source is probably better). But when we're arguing over some high-level subjective thing (e.g. "who broke more norms, Biden or Trump?") then going "Claude agrees with me that Trump is worse!" is not useful evidence.

The point of this place is to actually discuss things, make arguments, and defend positions; not to invoke an LLM's opinion as an authority.

And the response you got from claude barely disagreed with MK

  • mkc said that prediction markets were the best predictor.

  • Claude said they are not the best predictor.

If mkc believes prediction markets are very good, that's fine. Calling them the most accurate is a deliberately strong (maximally strong) claim. Words do actually mean things. You don't get to make the strongest form of your claim for convenience, then swap it out for a weaker claim when "disproven".

Let me try asking you again, as you've somehow ignored the important part of my comment.

Do you at least agree that, in principle, if I could show an LLM outputting beliefs you believe are wrong, that this would suffice to show that LLMs' high-level opinions shouldn't be cited as evidence on the Motte?

I accept your apology for falsely attributing a bunch of claims to me.

I don't disagree much with Claude's take here!

Dude, I know. I actually agree with you on the object level. I'm trying to get you to understand that what LLMs believe should not be presented as evidence on the Motte.

You claimed that prediction markets are the best predictor.

Claude disagrees.

No one said "radical" disagreement. I'm solely pointing out that, according to Claude, you are wrong. (I actually back you over Claude here; that's my point!)

This is how it reads whenever someone else posts a comment, and you respond by going "well Claude says not-X". Claude saying not-X isn't relevant! It's just going "my LLM could beat up your LLM".

Do you at least agree that, in principle, if I could show an LLM outputting beliefs you believe are wrong (which I think I'vce done a couple of times by now), that this would suffice to show that LLMs' high-level opinions shouldn't be cited as evidence on the Motte?

Yes, I do actually agree -- AFAICT, proper prediction markets consistently outperform other predictors in this domain.

My goal here is just to get magicalkittycat to acknowledge that Claude saying X shouldn't be used on the Motte as dispositive towards X being true.

I'd hoped that by bringing up an example where mkc and I actually agree on the object level (that prediction markets are very good, actually), this might be enough for mkc to recognise the point.

Unfortunately, this isn't what has happened.

Stop lying.

You dismiss the prediction markets as fantasy

Stop lying. Where did I say that?

your own attempt at a defense admits they are really good

Stop lying. Where did I say that?

This is how you act anytime someone points out verifiable facts that go against you

Stop lying. Where did I say that?


Are you confusing me with a different user? Because none of what you've said is in my comment.

I actually think that prediction markets are very good. But my comment is about getting you to acknowledge that LLMs are not a source of evidence. This takes basic reading comprehension to understand, so I get that it's easier to make up a bunch of stuff I didn't say. But could you maybe try being honest for once, instead of just lying?

the most accurate forecasting method we have

As you regularly invoke LLMs' opinions as evidence, I went ahead and asked Claude Opus 5.5:

Are prediction markets the most accurate forecasting method we have?

Its answer begins:

Not clearly. Prediction markets are among the best general-purpose forecasting tools, but the evidence doesn't support calling them the most accurate method overall. (... +500 words)

Claude made it clear that the answer varies based on topic, so I went and asked whether prediction markets are the best forecasting method for predicting who will win in a given state. Its answer:

In general, no single method is clearly the most accurate at predicting which party wins a US state. Markets, poll-based models and expert ratings perform about equally well, and averaging them tends to beat relying on any one.

Is this enough to get you to admit that LLMs' opinions aren't actually conclusive evidence?

You do, actually, have to pick one:

a) You were wrong to call prediction markets the most accurate forecasting method.

b) You shouldn't cite LLMs' opinions as evidence.

an accidental release just happening to point to the wet market is incredibly odd too.

It's not even odd, let alone "incredibly odd". I hope Scott didn't say those exact words; it's foolish.

Does it really need explaining why a wet market is better for spreading a virus than an apartment complex?

In what apartment complex do you get:

  • Thousands of people constantly brushing past each other
  • Bodily fluids from many different animals, exposed to air and skin contact
  • Organic materials passing between strangers
  • Animals and animal products kept in close proximity with each other and humans

You're a virus, intent on spreading as much as possible. Do you want to spawn in (a) a wet market, or (b) an apartment complex?

It's utterly absurd to suggest that it just "happened" to be a wet market, pretty much the optimal place for a virus to spread. You know this, obviously.

The lab leak theory can either say "that's how well it was covered up" in which case okay you can just do that endlessly there is no beating an argument that lack of proof doesn't matter

Not an argument, which is why you gloss over it. And if "lack of proof" doesn't matter, your comment doesn't matter. Evidence is what matters, and that's a little more complicated than just scoffing at people.

"I believe we have major issue X" directly suggests the line of action "let's try to counteract X". Where is that?

Everywhere you're refusing to look? Plenty of people are vocally against gain-of-function research entirely because of covid.

You have an incentive to pretend that this isn't happening, because you've constructed it as this bizarre presuppositionalist argument that lab leak proponents actually deeply believe in zoonosis. That isn't the same as it not actually happening.

Choosing at random one of the many issues to respond to:

Lab leak theory proposes China killed almost 2 million people in the first year alone

... as does zoonosis. So, as you ask: where's the war? It seems like you have a missing mood.

There was that unrest in the UK after a Sikh man stabbed a guy to death

But that unrest had nothing to do with the proposition that Sikhs are all/mostly stabby.

The issue was that the police, who are ostensibly supposed to facilitate justice, handcuffed a dying man who'd just been stabbed. He told them he'd been stabbed, and they said: "don't think you have, mate".

The issue was that they allowed an innocent man to bleed out, while treating his killer as a victim, based on their race. This was not an isolated incident; this is in the context of the police systematically siding with people based on the colour of their skin, rather than whether they need immediate medical attention due to having been stabbed.

I appreciate that you're making a general point. But the specific examples need to support it. So this might go some way to dissolving how mysterious you find the phenomenon: sometimes, the thing you perceive as people blaming an entire group for individual actions isn't actually what's happening. It's a convenient cudgel for people to be able to dismiss the outrage over Henry Nowak's murder as "oh, that's just a bunch of racists who are blaming sikhs", but that doesn't make it true.

I hadn't come across Tracey before. He writes like someone who is probably interesting and worth taking seriously. But on this topic, his take is really bad.

Don’t worry ladies: I definitely have some critical observations I could share about your collective reasoning tendencies as well, but that can wait for another time, because it’s the guys who are really beclowning themselves on this one

It's men who are "beclowning themselves"?

It's the pro-Clancy apologists (who, yes, are generally women) who are making videos saying things like: "it was definitely the husband who murdered the kids, because he's a capricorn, and has the same birthday as Donald Trump, which proves he's a violent killer". Or draping themselves out of windows to show solidarity with Clancy. Or describing how they can easily imagine themselves, or their friends, as killing their kids.

But no, to Tracey, these aren't worthy of being labelled beclownment: the real embarrassing thing is to hold the position of "killing your kids is extremely evil" without sufficient nuance. And the people who lack empathy aren't the ones who describe how they can imagine themselves killing their kids; it's the people flinching away from this and calling it evil.

There is a real point underneath what Tracey's saying, but what he's actually saying is ridiculous.

(Note, also, that while he's castigating men for apparently lacking empathy, he's doing so with exactly zero empathy. He's being pointlessly nasty and aggressive. If he wants "men" as a class not to be blamed for being emotionally stunted etc, it might be a good idea for him to lead by example.)

you don’t get the moral highground because you’re willing to declare it’s bad for mothers to kill their babies and toddlers. Yeah, we know. Thanks. Literally no one who’s sane disagrees with that

The issue is the non-sane people who are doing apologism for that! "literally no one who's sane" is doing all the heavy lifting! And he must know this, because otherwise he'd just say "Literally no one disagrees with that". But because there observably are people who disagree with that, he knows he can't say that, so he has to qualify it; but somehow, in the qualifying of it, he doesn't realise (or deliberately ignores) that the qualification contains the counterargument -- which is that these people are behaving insanely.

[men have] somehow come to think that it’s a referendum on “women” in general, or how women are “never held responsible” for anything. What? If that’s what you’re really set on extrapolating here, it’s your own bizarre problem

Absurd gaslighting. The issue that I predominantly see his hategroup pointing to isn't the court, or expert opinion, or Clancy herself -- it's of the disturbing number of people (yes, essentially 100% women) whose entire thing is not holding Clancy responsible, because she is a woman.

Tracey has (correctly) made this a gendered thing. He cannot possibly fail to notice that Clancy's gender is a critical part of why so many are defending her. Within her supporters, the positions of "Clancy did it, but she's a victim!" and "the husband did it, and he's a monster!" coexist without tension, because it's about not holding specifically women responsible.

This isn't the soft bigotry of low expectations; this is Tracey applying zero expectations to women, and then excoriating men over behaviour that's orders of magnitude more reasonable, just, and empathetic, but not perfect. Shockingly, women are in fact capable of being very intelligent, decent, and reasonable. If stuff like "husband is capricorn, therefore murder" doesn't beclown women, but "killing kids is evil and there's no discussion to be had around psychosis" does beclown men, then that speaks to how wildly Tracey has miscalibrated his expections of each gender.

For the record, I largely agree with the psychosis defence. And I agree with @czr: "Whether she spends 50 years behind bars or 50 years in a mental institute doesn't make a difference to me, really." The issue that Tracey has papered over (deforesting the Amazon in the process) is the response of Clancy's supporters, not the psychosis defence itself. Tracey offhandedly going "yeah yeah, maybe some women have bad takes too, but that's so unimportant right now, let's focus on the MEN" is ridiculous.

consider the difference in both amount and style that The Spectator covered with Arday vs Epstein and his associates.

What was the Spectator's coverage of Epstein?

Your link only shows "the Spectator published 12 Arday stories over a 14-day period". I can't see any info about their Epstein coverage. It invites us to compare them, but doesn't actually present the latter thing to compare.

So: what are we supposed to be comparing? Epstein is a story that's been running for a decade or so. Is the complaint that Epstein should've been more prominent than Arday in that 2-week window? Or that, at the peak of the Epstein scandal (I guess around his suicide? idk) the Spectator published fewer articles than they did around Arday at his peak scandal? I expect that, on net, the Spectator published an order of magnitude more articles on Epstein than Arday. So is the issue the timing, the density, the frequency, the consistency, the tone, or what?

I have no opinion on the Spectator, and I'm certainly willing to be persuaded that they under-covered Epstein. But the tweet and your comment both take it for granted that we all know exactly what their coverage was, with no summary or evidence provided, and I'm reluctant to just accept that without even knowing exactly what I'm supposed to accept for the comparison.

And 12 stories over a 14-day period, by itself, seems completely reasonable to me, given how egregious the situation was. Arday wasn't excessively covered, regardless of whether Epstein was under- or over-covered.

Look dude I pointed out to you already where I said assume

"Now we can all assume" does not posit a hypothetical.

If you'd like, I can patronisingly link you to the definition of every word in that sentence, as that's the level of discourse you've decided to operate on.

That's reasonable. Thanks for taking the time to explain.

I want to record some general observations — they're not specifically about mkc, but obviously the context of this interaction is going to be read into them.

  1. There are corrosive patterns of behaviour that exist below the level that most people would want to report, or that would generally be modded. For example, repeatedly and egregiously lying about what other comments have said.

This is difficult to mod. Some people are going to call it "subjective" — I disagree, but there's a grey zone. Modding this too heavily is going to cross into tone policing, or outlawing people just misunderstanding each other. It's reasonable to err on the side of not modding this.

But it's still corrosive! Consider this exchange:

ALICE: Water is poisonous. BOB: Water isn't poisonous. Maybe you're confused about "dihydrogen monoxide" [insert effortpost] ALICE: if you're confused about the existence about poisons, I recommend this link. Obviously water itself isn't poisonous (idiot). If you're imagining that poisons can't be dissolved in water, I'm prepared to prove you wrong on that stupid position.

In this situation: does Bob report Alice? I don't think so. Maybe it's worth putting in more effort to point out the bullshit Alice has just pulled by lying.

But multiplied across many interactions... Alice can keep lying with zero effort, while the truth has to put in tons of effort to constantly correct the record.

If that's the recommended paradigm (I'm uncertain to what extent you endorse this), then backseat modding is kinda an implicit pillar of this ecosystem. People have to keep putting in effort to point out "no, you just lied — you said X earlier, and now you're pretending you said Y".

I'm aware that this gets under my skin. I'm correct to get really, really annoyed by this. I don't care if a person is a rightist, a leftist, or whatever — I care when they lie in a way that's easily disprovable by looking at the transcript, but that the average Motte reader wouldn't bother to go and read.

The correct behaviour is for me not to respond to this by flipping out, as I did in your link.

... but it's also a problem that someone keeps lying so much that they make someone flip out. You don't actually need to have a long list of shit posters who aggravate you.

I'm not proposing banning anyone for being annoying, or for having the wrong politics (that would be insane). I just want to register that there's this middle ground where disingenuous people can DDOS the Motte with truth-agnostic comments without any kind of restriction or punishment, so long as they stay below the level where they'll get actively modded.

I don't know the solution, I just don't think the current situation is... eh.

All I can do is give some hypotheticals, which is If we assume this recent statement is true from Vance because we assume he isn't lying to our faces

That isn't what you did.

I can't tell you which way is which cause I don't know

Then say that up front, instead of pretending.

Thus within this hypothetical

Your original comment had nothing to do with hypotheticals.

If people want to explore the alternative assumption where Vance is lying

People want to explore the alternative timeline where you say what you mean.

You think it's cute when you go "oh, you disagree with my unflattering framing X? Well, if you want to explore even-less-flattering-framing-Y, go ahead!"

The problem is that this hinges on everyone around you being stupid.

You are being criticised for obfuscating your position to try and head off specific criticism.

No one is saying "hey, you're being too charitable when you said Vance isn't a horrible liar!"

Please stop pretending that the latter is the case.

What they shouldn't do is blame their inability to properly read on me proposing a hypothetical

You are lying.

You did not propose a hypothetical.

Stop blaming people for not reading something you did not write.

I apologise for what comes across as backseat modding — I don't agree with the characterisation, but it's a reasonable one, and I might be wrong.

I don't agree that pointing this out contributes to the degradation of the Motte.

I didn't think that mkc's comment was bad enough to warrant reporting. I thought about it, but that seemed petty and wrong. If I'm wrong about that, I'd welcome the correction.

Here is the actual guideline at the top

Yes, I read this. I figured the additional context weighed in favour of pointing out the rules violation, not like some gotcha that I'd missed.

This applies to, for example, pretending you are arguing one thing when you're actually arguing something else, or implying something that is so unclear so as to invite confusion or misunderstanding

This is exactly what mkc is doing. My comments explain how.

If I'm backseat modding: fair. Ding me for that.

But I literally explain how mkc is deliberately avoiding holding a stance so that it's impossible to debate him.

I don't think that deserves a ban or anything, so I didn't report it. But if the rule is I can't even point that out, then that's a bad rule. And I don't think that is the rule.

I don't have an issue with mkc being annoying. I'm annoying!

I want him to commit to a position so we can discuss it.

You know what also contributes to the degradation of the Motte? You losing your temper with someone who seems to get under your skin

Yes, I correctly received a ban for this, and said so at the time.

Given that we agree on this, I'm not sure it's relevant to what we're talking about now.

If your position is that I'm doing the same thing again, which I don't think it is, then that would be relevant.

You are demanding the impossible, I can not know what is and isn't truthful in Vance's statements.

No one was asking for that.

No one even remotely hinted at asking for that.

I asked you to state what you believe.

You are the only person who finds that to be an insurmountable burden, or who deliberately conflates it with being asked for a perfect factual assessment of the world.

Stop lying.

I will not make bold claims like "Vance is definitely lying" when I can not know that

No one asked you to.

if we assume Vance is being truthful

That's not what you did.

You stated, while making the patented magicalkittycat ":3" face, that Vance was being truthful.

My entire point is requesting that you cut out this bullshit, and do the thing you just pretended you were doing all along. If you want to construct a hypothetical, construct the hypothetical.

But you don't. You want to dunk on people you think are less intelligent than you, and then pretend you weren't doing it.

I have no idea who you think this onanistic farce is fooling.

"Speak plainly", how about you bother to read instead?

Wish granted: I already read everything you said.

You always say this when you run out of arguments. It's lame. Try speaking plainly instead. Other people don't find it hard.

Again even if we flip the assumption around and observe the hypothetical where he is a liar, it doesn't tell us what parts are a lie and what is truth.

Another masterful exercise in completely ignoring the thing you just quoted.

What are you even doing?