@stoatherd's banner p

stoatherd


				

				

				
1 follower   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 December 03 22:28:01 UTC

				

User ID: 1961

stoatherd


				
				
				

				
1 follower   follows 0 users   joined 2022 December 03 22:28:01 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 1961

I feel like you're telling on yourself [etc etc etc]

This convinces approximately no one, by the way.

No offence (as, apparently, those are magic words that allow you to cause offence), but trying to smear FtttG like this is pathetic.

We're not "talking past each other"; you are being deliberately obtuse.

As has been explained to you multiple times, by multiple people: "the police sometimes arrest both people in domestic violence" cases has nothing to do with "the police arresting solely the guy who had been stabbed instead of his murderer".

Fortunately, as you continue to pretend not to understand what people are telling you, we can defer to ChatGPT. Normally I wouldn't do this, but you, specifically -- magicalkittycat -- as a poster, have previously claimed that AI output is "impartial" and "neutral", which you then use as evidence for your positions ("the robot agrees with me!"). So let's see what it says:

The comparison is weak for a few reasons:

Where it has merit: The general point — that police sometimes arrest victims due to incomplete information — is legitimate and worth acknowledging.

Where it breaks down:

In domestic disputes, mutual arrest is a known policy response to ambiguity. It's procedural, not ideological.

The claim in this case is specifically that police believed one party's narrative over another's based on racial dynamics — a different kind of error.

The forum argument deflects from the specific allegation (racial bias in credibility assessment) by substituting a structurally different scenario.

The comparison isn't useless, but it doesn't really address what's being alleged.

So, would you prefer to (a) retract your claim that the domestic violence thing is relevant, or (b) retract your claim that AI is neutral and impartial, and never use it again to try and score points on TheMotte?

Dude, apparently it didn't get through when FtttG said it, so let me try (using his exact words):

We're not talking about police arresting both parties out of an excess of caution. We're talking about the police arresting one person, and it being the wrong one.

It's not "vaguely analogous", and he explained exactly why. The words in people's comments are there to explain things to you; they're not just for decoration.

Nice judo flip, but -- like you're doing with my comment -- you're deliberately trying to mislead anyone reading.

You claimed this isn't unique. Both FtttG and myself asked you for examples of it happening with different ethnicities. You don't get to then go "Oh, you're claiming that there are a thousand Henry Nowaks?!?" to distract from your failure to actually answer the question, twice.

There's barely any of those

Are there... more than zero?

Because you're the one saying this isn't "unique", it's not representative of a pattern, yawn, it's an everyday occurrence, nothing to see here.

You present a completely unrelated category of domestic abuse as if it proves your position.

When asked for evidence (by two different people!) you pretend that your previously-presented unrelated category is the thing they asked for, and they apparently just failed to read your comment correctly.

When pressed further, you say "there's barely any of [the thing you asked for]". Well, sorry, but I don't even believe you have any of the thing I asked for, or you'd have triumphantly presented it.

I restate that you wouldn't be putting in a fraction of this effort to obfuscate the truth if the ethnicities had been different. I don't pretend to understand why you do this, but I see you doing this.

The UK has, in the past few decades, generally been a place where you can assume you're not going to be murdered by a man with a sword.

People in the UK have adapted to the social reality that you are not going to be murdered by a man with a sword.

We can call this quokka behaviour, but I think it's quite reasonable to expect -- once your society has established that murder-by-men-with-swords is a completely bizarre and outlandish thing to happen -- that you are not going to be murdered by a man with a sword; any more than you're going to be mauled by a dinosaur or beamed up by an alien.

Calling the guy who was murdered "very stupid" for not expecting to be murdered by a man with a sword, in a culture where being-murdered-by-a-man-with-a-sword is extremely unexpected, is itself Very Stupid, and in rather poor taste.

Calling him "retarded" is also retarded.

Meanwhile, in my actual comment -- not the more convenient one you're invented to respond to -- I was asking about where this has happened with the ethnicities flipped.

In my reply to your comment, I was aware of the examples you gave in your comment; this is how time works. Those are not examples to my actual question, as you know.

A brown man stabbed a white man. The police showed up and arrested the white man. I can't imagine a good-faith version of your comment where you transport this into "Well, sometimes the police arrest both people in domestic abuse cases!"

Fortunately, I know now not to waste time attempting to imagine the hypothetical good-faith version of such a comment.

You could apply this retort to 90% of political opinions on the Motte.

I could; and if I did, I would be incorrect.

I thought the words in my comment made this clear, but I wasn't generically responding to a comment I disagreed with: I was observing that magicalkittycat, consistently, as a poster, is not a person who I would believe is (1) making that comment honestly, and (2) makes comments honestly.

On that matter, I don't believe you have any principled reason behind making this post either

That's fine; you are wrong.

Like, you're welcome to hold that belief, but you are factually incorrect and holding it for poor reasons. "I can invoke a superficial symmetry" is not a universal counterargument. Happy to expand on why you're wrong -- I obviously don't expect this comment to suffice as reasoning.

I don't believe for one second [etc]

That's fine; again, this reflects on a flaw in your reasoning process, not mine.

Right-wingers will continue posting things that make the Right look good are actually a big deal. [...] Left-wingers will continue doing the same

Yes, this is true. I don't believe it's true of "90%" of posts on TheMotte, and I don't believe you really believe that either. Otherwise, what's the point in us being here? I'm happy to be here because I don't believe it's true. If you believe it's true, then you're the one who needs to explain that.

Should we all just pack up and go home?

No, I think that would be an absurd and stupid thing to think. Why would you ask that?

Its a sad situation but nothing here seems unique or even too particularly culture war.

If it's not unique, please provide the other examples of this happening, but with white/non-white flipped.

I don't believe you're saying these things for remotely principled reasons. Based on the many, many comments of yours I've read, I don't believe for one second that you'd view a race-flipped version of this as: sad, but nothing to see here.

But they don't say that, as you know.

That's an interesting idea with the red/blue button scenario. I don't think it's entirely true, but there are probably some social dynamics things going on that are at least adjacent to it.

But I don't think it's true at all of Newcomb. (Empirically, personally: it's nothing to do with why I'd one-box, or why I say I'd one-box.)

One-boxers are literally answering what they would do, because it's the thing that gets you the most money by the very definition of the problem. We can argue that the problem isn't physically realisable or whatever, but if you accept the problem as stated, then two boxers are just incorrect.

I don't think there's actually a coherent thing that "act utilitarianism" is pointing to. Its conceit seems to be that you can do some kind of causal surgery and ask: "Assuming that there are no downstream effects of this action (beyond some arbitrary cutoff?), and there are no implications of me being the kind of the person to have chosen this action... is it the best action?"

So there's two problems with this:

  1. The distinction between 1st order and 2nd/Nth-order effects is arbitrary; choosing to cut off some effects but not others doesn't really make sense
  2. You can't separate making a choice from being a person that makes that choice.

On point 2, the rule/act distinction is confused in a similar way that two-boxers in Newcomb are confused. If, in the organ scenario, you make the choice to kill an innocent person to take their organs... then you are the kind of person to do that. Which means you live in a society that generates people who choose to kill innocent people for their organs. You can't carve out the naive 1st-order utility calculation from the implications of people taking that choice, any more than in Newcomb you can go "I'm going be a one-boxer so I get the million dollars... and I'm going to take both boxes".

Act Utilitarianism seems to mostly exist as a strawman for people to say "utilitarians would kill you for your organs", which is silly, because they empirically don't.

Yeah but people do this about everything!

True, but also: no!

@FtttG's description resonated with me a lot (thanks for putting it to words).

I think you (rae) are right that the median person does feel a compulsion to push back on things they think are wrong. But... does the typical pushback on social media look anything like the Motte (in its best, idealised form)? Most popular pushback takes the form "your political bloc is dumb and stupid and evil, here's why".

Everyone (including people like me, and presumably FtttG) probably feels an urge to drop zingers on people who say dumb/evil things, and to push back against our tribal enemies. Call this "Pushback Type 1". PT1 lets us feel smart and good, and signal to our tribe that we are smart and good, and to enjoy the schadenfreude of our enemy getting squished. This is probably a universal thing that people are predisposed to like.

I think the thing FtttG is referring to is distinct. Call it "Pushback Type 2". PT2 is about criticising what we think is false even if (a) it can't be done in a crisp, devastating zinger, (b) it doesn't help some tribe we're aligned with, and (c) we don't get to enjoy having put someone down a peg. It's the obsessiveness of going: "This person is wrong, I don't care if the whole world is behind them; I need to explain why!"

The Motte is fuelled by a proprietary blend of PT2 spiked by PT1 (the exact formula is a closely-guarded secret).


There's still the question of why trans stuff specifically has captured FtttG. Obviously that's not for me to say, but a general explanation would be: people with PT2 inclinations can get sniped by any particular instance of falsehoods; it's a crapshoot.

... but I'd also then say: to me, trans stuff is the quintessential example of people "proudly, confidently asserting things I know to be false". I can't think of a stronger example. It's as ontologically broken as transubstantiation.

(I'm very sympathetic to your position of trans people basically wanting to be left alone, btw.)

If trans people are (random number) 2x more likely than cis people to get murdered walking a random street at night, but 5x less likely than cis people to take that kind of stroll where they’d be exposed to that risk, does that count?

Yeah, that's the flipside of what I was gesturing towards with "[making statistical corrections for] dangerous occupations like being a sex worker". I'd say that, in your hypothetical, that would indeed count! It would be a real problem.

... but it's not true. I know you said it was a "random number", but the "random numbers" we choose are typically representative of what we think are reasonable values. Trans people being 2x times for likely to be murdered for walking down the street isn't a reasonable random number. Again: cis men are more likely to be murdered than trans women! Assuming that you're a trans woman, then you are literally safer as a trans woman than your other option (i.e. being a cis man). We can discuss the hypothetical world where you receive a 2x multiplier to being randomly murdered, as long as it's on the record that this is utterly non-representative of the world we live in.

I do know that I feel more uncomfortable in many situations now than before (...) Maybe I’m just being paranoid. It’s hard to tell.

Yeah, sorry about that; that sucks.

For most trans people I know, I'd try and (incredibly carefully) gesture towards something like: "You live in a catastrophically damaged epistemic environment. The people around you take anything less than complete submission to their religion as being literally genocide. Even if you personally don't express stuff like that, the people who say these things are contributing (negatively) to the general epistemic structure around you, and it's fucking with your ability to calibrate. Even high-decoupling, disagreeable humans aren't really built to completely ignore this kind of endemic social messaging -- it's going to seep in and cause you stress, anxiety, and a constant sense of being at war."

I think that's not quite the right message for you (but I'm still going to sneak it into evidence via quotation). I have no idea what kind of environment you're in; and obviously you're, y'know, actually thinking about this stuff already. I guess I'd suggest that your impression of things like trans-related discomfort, rudeness, or social difficulties are probably picking up on a real signal -- but when you hit the threshold of violence/murder etc, there's a good chance you're massively overestimating that stuff for whatever reason. (I stress again that I don't know you or your environment; if you're in a place with atypically high violence against trans people compared to the rest of the West, probably disregard my comment.)

The great thing about AI is that you get impartiality on demand if you make a completely unconnected instance and ask an impartial question

It's possible I'm failing a sarcasm check here or something, but: do you actually believe this?

Like, this is an extremely untrue thing to say. I don't want to put a low-effort comment here saying "this is wrong", but I also don't want to waste time on a long comment explaining it, if it turns out that this was a joke or some kind of unserious comment. So I'm going to flag up that, if you sincerely believe "AI gives you impartial answers", that this is an extremely broken part of your epistemic model, which I can substantiate if it needs to be substantiated.

Not the OP, but a couple of points here. I could very easily say:

in the West, being [male] can lead to discrimination (...) and make you more at risk of low level violence and hate crimes

(I've omitted the ostracisation part, as I don't think that's supported in my parallel; but I don't think omitting it fundamentally changes the idea.)

The above is just true. But if men then had a culture of saying there was a "male genocide", and that their society was "androphobic" because of this, I'd get very annoyed, because -- as @WandererintheWilderness says -- it's an attempt to parlay a weaker, true claim ("men are more likely to be victims of violence") into a hysterical false one ("society is systemically murdering men!!")

Part of why I'm raising the parallel: one way trans activists misrepresent this stuff is by comparing trans women to women rather than to men. IIRC, men have a higher rate of being victims of violence than trans women? (It might require some statistical stuff like "once you correct for dangerous occupations like being a sex worker", or it might just be outright; I don't remember.)

There's something kind of ridiculous about this world model:

  1. If you're born male, your options are basically cis man or trans woman -- you don't get "cis woman" as an option
  2. If a male person chooses to be a trans woman, they are now instantly statistically categorised as "some type of women"...
  3. ... and therefore, any male-propensity-to-get-stabbed is supposed to instantly vanish; and if its doesn't, there's a trans genocide.

Like... no? This isn't even epicycles; this is no model at all. The dangerous portion of being (1) trans and (2) biologically male... is not the trans part. If a soldier chooses to call themselves a "trans accountant", they don't get to go "My workplace death rate is higher than cis accountants -- this is discrimination".

I agree that white Western trans women probably aren’t at an extremely elevated risk of murder

I appreciate you saying so, but this does seem like a weaker formulation than what you should probably agree to. "extremely elevated risk"? Is your position that white Western trans women are at an elevated risk of murder -- possibly even a very high one -- but it just doesn't rise to the level of "extremely"? Because I'm reasonably sure the accurate version of this would just be "they aren't at an elevated risk of murder". Similarly, I wouldn't say "the trans genocide is overblown", I'd say "the trans genocide is fictitious". We can certainly discuss different patterns of violence and how they interact with being trans, but framing that as "genocide" needs to be immediately met with "you are lying for political expediency". (The generalised "you", I mean; you're not lying.)

It's also a bit of a motte and bailey: the bulk of trans activism focuses on white Western culture as performing some kind of trans genocide. Then when criticised, it becomes "Well, in this non-white, non-Western part of the world, these non-white-non-Western cultures are dangerous for trans people!" Again, you're not personally responsible for what other people are arguing; but you get how this is frustrating, right?

It's an argument against Utilitarianism only if you ignore 2nd-order effects. (This happens a lot with arguments against Utilitarianism.)

Take the extreme variant of the trolley problem, where a doctor has 5 sick patients who each need a different organ transplant. In the doctor's waiting room, there's a healthy patient. Should the doctor kill the healthy patient and use their organs to save the 5 sick people? After all, it'll be saving 5 lives at the cost of one; Utilitarianism demands that you kill the healthy person, right? It's exactly the same as pulling a lever on the train track to save 5 people, right?

... except no, because no one wants to live in a society where at any moment you can be righteously murdered for your organs. That's an insane way for a society to function. Everyone would be terrified all the time. No one would set foot in a hospital. There'd be constant revenge killings against doctors. Everyone who could afford bodyguards would hire them. Everyone would carry whatever weapons they could get their hands on. Society would collapse in about two days. The outcome is: you get no organ transplants, because you've destroyed the mechanisms that allowed for organ transplants in the first place.

Same thing with Nazi experimentation on live prisoners. The Utilitarian argument against it isn't just "the prisoners suffering is bad", it's that plus "if your society has a policy of experimenting on live prisoners, that generates a bunch of horrific problems", such as:

  • Significantly increased terror among the population
  • Dehumanisation of prisoners and any social group they're drawn from
  • Slippery slope to even less humane treatment of people
  • Slippery slope to expanding the number of valid targets
  • General breaking of bright lines around things like bodily autonomy, torture, etc

... so it's very much not an "unalloyed good", even leaving the suffering of the prisoners aside. (For that matter, even if we ignore 2nd-order effects, I'm not sure that the medical advances necessarily do outweigh the suffering of the prisoners! Then there's also the fact that there's no single unambiguous way to add up "greatest utility for the greatest number". You can absolutely have a version of Utilitarianism that prioritises additional utils for people at the bottom. And then, on top of that, there's no single way to convert pain/pleasure/satisfaction/whatever into utility; pain might have a much stronger contribution than pleasure. The weakness of Utilitarianism IMO is that it's inherently flexible and ambiguous like this.)

It might well be possible to construct a situation where Utilitarianism does give an unacceptable answer. But I don't think this is it. And typically, when these arguments go "Utilitarian says we should do X, which we can all agree has bad consequences" -- that's almost intrinsically self-defeating, because Utiliarianism is all about weighing up the consequences and minimising the badness!

Google gives me this for the definition of "genocide":

the deliberate and systematic killing or persecution of a large number of people from a particular national or ethnic group with the aim of destroying that nation or group.

This comports with a couple of dictionary definitions I checked.

The key part, and the part you're trying to emotionally invoke, is the killing of people. That's the central concept of genocide, and it's what people who say "genocide" are trying to lean on. When people hear "genocide", they're supposed to think "murdering an ethnic or national group"; they're supposed to think "sending people to the gas chambers".

Is that what you think Trump is threatening? If so, where does he say anything remotely like that?

If, instead, you think Trump is threatening something that's still bad -- such as regime change that will inherently come with collateral damage, or the destruction of civilian infrastructure -- then say that. It will still be bad! But calling those things "genocide" is co-opting a stronger word purely because it's a stronger word. I don't believe you actually believe Trump intends to murder "a significant portion of the members of the civilisation" (please tell me if I'm wrong), so I don't take that as a sincere defence of using the word "genocide".

Do you think this is actually calling for genocide, or is it just strategically useful for you to call it genocidal?

When Trump refers to the "civilization" dying, do you sincerely think he's referring to mass-murdering the civilians in the region, rather than the obvious reading that he's referring to the society and regime?

If so, why didn't he just say that?

Iranians have, in fact, never had the genocide of Americans ... to be their policy

Where has America had the genocide of Iranians to be its policy?

Here's a few related concepts:

  1. Sturdy belief that you can accomplish what you're currently doing
  2. General belief in yourself as a competent, valid, effective person
  3. Being unconcerned with the idea that you might fail your current task
  4. Generally being chill and non-anxious
  5. Ability to project "this is the thing we're doing"
  6. (5), but automatically and unselfconsciously

All of these could reasonably be called "confidence". I'm not staking any kind of linguistic claim, where the thing I'm pointing at is definitionally some distinct thing from confidence.

The distinction I'm making is this. Informal uses of "confidence" (particularly in the context of male dating advice) are a blend of 1-4, maybe with a sprinkle of 5 and 6. It's usually an internal thing. A lot of "just be confident!" advice is about being comfortable with yourself and accepting outcomes -- it's not about controlling the Narrative.

For example: a manservant might be very confident in their role (i.e. they feel non-anxious, they're competent and know it, they're unflappable in the face of failure) -- but they wouldn't generally be someone who projects "this is the thing we're doing".

What are your equivalent percentages for women?

Also: the idea that 50% of men would be crazy manipulators in the absence of social consequences invites one of two replies, depending on your gender:

  • If you're female: the sample of men you interact with is not randomly chosen, and is not representative of the statistically average man.
  • If you're male: would you be a crazy manipulator if it were consequence free?

That's a bit of a sleight of hand.

What do you mean by "the men"? 99% of men have already been reformed (usually preemptively), because 99% of men are not crazy, evil manipulators. (Same goes for women)

There will always be a tiny minority of men (and women) who are evil manipulators. I guess you can always point at the male portion of that cohort and go, "why aren't we reforming these people? Is it because men are low agency? (troll face)" -- if you choose to ignore that you're sampling the worst of one gender, because the better people have already been reformed.

... meanwhile, what's the percentage of women who experience some version of the OP, where they make self-damaging choices? 50%, maybe? I don't know, but it's definitely an order of magnitude greater than the percentage of men or women who are crazy, evil manipulators.

It's perfectly reasonable for us to go "hey, why are large numbers of women having this bad experience?" without having to go "men are the problem". But yeah, raising the slightest spectre of women possibly not being perfect is never going to go down well.

I can't imagine any evo-psych explanation for this

Will you accept an even less rigorous, non-falsifiable, ad-hoc explanation in its place? If so, here's my framework for understanding this stuff.

An instrumental goal for any evolved brain is: "Figure out what the heck is going on, figure out your place in it, figure out what you need to do."

For social animals, this gets refined into: "Figure out the Narrative, figure out your place in the story, comport to that role."

The Narrative started (probably) as a way of coordinating individual hunter-gatherers into a single super-organism. To do that, there needed to be a shared "thing that we are doing", with roles assigned within that story. Leaders who could enforce that Narrative (e.g. with violence) ended up being more successful than ones who couldn't; non-leaders who could quickly and adeptly take their role in the Narrative ended up being more successful than ones who couldn't. So I imagine humans have a really deeply ingrained goal of "figure out your role in this story and follow it".

Chuck in some standard sex-based differences around appetite for risk. If you're a middle-of-the-pack male, it might be genetically worth it to try out the high-risk Narrative "I should be king"; less so for his female equivalent, who will be genetically "safer" in following the dominant Narrative around her.

If all of this is true: then people will generally be susceptible to things that hijack the Narrative-identifying mechanism. Women will tend to be more susceptible to attacks that strongly and bluntly overpower the dominant Narrative; men will tend to be more susceptible to Lady-Macbeth-type "you should be king" attacks that provide a risky status-enhancing alternative Narrative.

Some loosely associated stuff that might support this:

  • Hypnosis
  • Tarot, astrology, anything that abdicates responsibility to a supernatural power
  • Friendship groups generally responding better to "let's do X" than "what do people want to do?"
  • BDSM things that establish rigid social rules around exactly what everyone is supposed to do
  • A fifth, better example

Connecting this back to, y'know, your actual point: there are people, usually men, who instinctively broadcast an aura of "this is what we're doing". It's typically unselfconscious and unaware of even the possibility that this isn't actually the thing we're doing. It's just happening. When they do this, it seems to activate that ancestral Narrative-seeking DNA. People fall into their roles. It's like picking up a kitten by its nape.

(This kind of attitude is easily mistaken for confidence, and I reckon is a big part of why men are told "just be confident!" when dating.)

If I can add another layer of evopsych to my tower of unsubstantiated claims: if women are generally looking to find the dominant Narrative and comport to their role in that story, then there's a huge selection pressure for men who can trigger those dominant-Narrative identifiers. But if these identifiers are too legible, then lots of men are going to consciously cultivate them; so there's a pressure for the identifiers to become illegible (or hard to fake). So you can end up with men who aren't good, or even good-looking, or even any other legible markers of sexual success -- but they have this illegible way of making people go "yes, we're doing what this guy wants".

... so, yeah, when encountering people like this, some women are going to make superficially inexplicable decisions that probably felt completely right from the inside. A million years of evolutionary optimisation is a hell of an opponent.

I said up front that this was non-rigorous and non-falsifiable, so naturally I will not be accepting criticism at this time.

No.

I'm not saying "you must publicly disavow anyone in your movement who says X, otherwise you're complicit, and deserve to be hurt". That's the idea of "Silence is Violence".

I'm saying:

There are feminists like Goodguy who (roughly) describe themselves as being solely pro-gender-equality, with none of the nastier parts of feminism in them. (That's good!)

However, whenever I observe these people in a context where a nastier feminist is doing/saying evil things, I don't observe these milder feminists pushing back or disagreeing. This is both in a personal context -- e.g. at a social gathering, a work event, whatever -- and in the public or social media context as well. In fact, it's not even that they'll be fully silent: they'll nod along, support the conversation, and do everything short of saying "yes I fully agree that men are pigs".

Also, the nastier parts of feminism have a pretty well-observed pattern of bullying the hell out of anyone who dares to push back against them.

The combined effect of this: feminism, despite being apparently "many different things", ends up being a coalition that reliably pushes in a single direction. If a subgroup of feminism doesn't push back on X, and instead just is silent on X (but passively/socially supporting the parts of the movement that push for X), then these groups aren't meaningfully different, and do function as a single block that can be meaningfully criticised.

To put it another way: I'm not telling Goodguy "You must push back on X, or you're complicit!" -- I'm saying "Because feminists don't push back on X, you don't get to make the argument that actually feminism is made of lots of different things".

I think that's a pretty obvious difference between what I said and "Silence is Violence".

EDIT: Here's a right-wing equivalent.

ALICE: Republicans are homophobic.

BOB: Republicans are many different things, so it's meaningless to criticise "Republicans".

ALICE: But among all the Republicans I know, even the "mild" ones who say they're pro-gay-rights -- whenever a more homophobic Republican says "God hates fags", the supposedly milder Republican never pushes back. They just smile and laugh along, nodding their head.

BOB: Wow, sounds like "Silence is Violence", huh?

ALICE: No, I'm saying the supposed variation in your group doesn't prevent that group from having an emergent, collective goal, and I'm allowed to criticise it for that!