@token_progressive's banner p

token_progressive

maybe not the only progressive here

0 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 October 25 17:28:07 UTC

				

User ID: 1737

token_progressive

maybe not the only progressive here

0 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 October 25 17:28:07 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 1737

I don't follow sci-fi cons all that closely but I do follow some authors on Twitter Mastodon that care, and I recall them being pretty upset at the idea of Worldcon in China with Cixin Liu as a guest of honor (given his public positions on the Uyghurs). And I didn't remember the details mentioned below of accusations that an organization within China rigged the vote (by purchasing lots of voting memberships), suggesting the general Worldcon community wasn't a fan of holding Worldcon in China.

I was pretty surprised by your comments in this thread about the left giving China a pass... but I think there's a difference between business/media and individuals here. Left-leaning business and media rely on China's business enough that they don't they want to say much. But left-leaning individuals on social media have plenty negative to say about China's government in my experience. Some of it complaining about Disney appeasing China.

The fewer hours worked, the larger proportion of your working time is overhead seems like a sensible observation. But it doesn't lend itself to any specific choice of what amount of overhead is acceptable. And there's also a trade-off of the more hours worked, the larger proportion of your working effectiveness is lost to fatigue. And both of those trade-offs likely vary widely job-to-job. And possibly in non-obvious ways, given that as a knowledge worker, my time "not working" regularly includes having some work problem in the back of my mind.

I wonder if 8 hours of work a day for the 5 workdays managed to become a popular standard due to it cleanly cutting in half the 16 hours a day that most adults are expected to be awake. It's just easy to wrap your head around the idea of cutting up the day into thirds of 8 hours each.

This was explicit in some of labor movement arguments for the 8 hour workday. For example, Wikipedia has this banner reading

8 hours labour

8 hours recreation

8 hours rest

There's also https://getindie.wiki/ specifically for the fandom wiki problem.

I'm not even sure what you're trying to say. I guess civil rights is a bare minimum I'd hope minority interests being represented in government to accomplish. But there's a lot more to representation than not having basic rights withheld from you.

No, although I'm not sure how strongly I feel about that as it may be possible to design a direct democracy that doesn't have the problems that stem from its simplest form.

Part of making sure everyone feel represented is to structure the government to 50%+1 can't overrule the rest easily and not having direct democracy is part of how we do that. Although I suppose there's no reason you couldn't have non-representative democracy but still require a higher threshold than 50% or a more complicated threshold like 50% of every region for some definition of region (or some other way to slice the population?).

Ballot initiatives are a form of direct democracy and I do think they give a good alternative for when elected legislators fail to be representative... but they also don't provide a way to negotiate details or amend the text, so they often result in poorly written laws. For instance, for the states that voted on recreational marijuana via ballot initiative, those initiatives weren't just "should recreational marijuana be legal", they were "should recreational marijuana be regulated by rules X, Y, Z". Maybe you could have a technological solution to that looks something like liquid democracy and Git forks/pull requests on legislation... but no one has done that, so it's hard to know whether there's actually something feasible in that design space.

I recently traveled to Italy and was surprised that just about no one was wearing mask.

My friends who lived in NYC in February 2020 are very over COVID and have been for a while. On the assumption they they all got it already, so it's over for them. It would make sense for Italy having been hit hard early to have similar feelings.

I'm suspicious of the concept of "good" governance divorced from asking who it is good for. Although I'm pretty comfortable drawing an age line somewhere and declaring everyone younger than that is a child and too immature to know what's best for themselves. Politics involves a lot of balancing competing interests and the interests of people who are not represented are unlikely to be given much weight. I see people talking about that in this thread about poorer people voting less so not needing to worry as much about their political opinions. I see people in left-leaning spaces complaining young people don't vote enough so politicians don't have to care about the future (read: climate change). The point of the OP's proposal is to more strongly represent parents so their interests are more strongly weighted, with the idea that those interests would hopefully align with their children's future interests and therefore the future of the society as a whole. None of these groups' interests are a priori the "right" interests for a "good" government to focus on.

But in a democracy, I think it's important that the people believe they are represented, even if everyone would be happier with the policies chosen by genius dictator @token_progressive. (Please don't make me dictator. I'd be really bad at it.)

I want everyone to feel represented and like they are part of society. People who feel like they aren't part of society tend to make for poor neighbors and sometimes attempt revolutions.

And I think that politicians that feel like they have to convince more of the population to vote for them are more likely to enact policies that are good for everyone as opposed to a narrow section of the population. Even if I happen to be part of the narrow slice of the population my elected politicians happen to decide is worth listening to (I don't seem to be currently), I'll always live near people who aren't.

letting teenagers vote will often not be ideal, but I think I would be in favor of such a policy?

While it's a very different policy than the one under discussion, I'm pretty strongly in favor of lowering the voting age to 16 as a way to encourage youth voting. The idea being that voting is habit; people who vote are a lot more likely to vote in the future, and building that habit seems much more likely to happen while living at home and having the influence of parents and high school civics classes than while 18-year-olds are adjusting to being out in the world on their own as adults (whether or not they're in college).

I'd consider the fact that 16-year-olds likely are heavily influenced by their parents and may just vote in line with their parents without really thinking about their own political beliefs and interests as a major downside of that idea. And I'd expect that effect to be significantly stronger the younger the child.

This is a very strange assertion. That photo of Zooey Zephyr looks like someone early on in transition to me. I've seen multiple people like that in queer spaces (adults who started their transition as adults) where 2-3 years later they look more or less like a woman because they've actually been taking hormones long enough (and possibly have gotten some surgery, idk, I've never interrogated any of them on the details of their transition). I guess it's a little surprising to me that she's not closeted or identifying as non-binary at that stage in her transition. (I did some superficial web searching and couldn't find any information on when she came out as trans.)

Are you using FB Purity? My normal ad-blocker doesn't do much on FB.

I think you might be in more of a bubble than you realize. It's a regular talking point in progressive-leaning political forums to claim horrified that conservatives treat their children like property. It's surprising to me to see people like you in this thread literally saying as much in so many words.

(fanfiction is illegal)

The Organization for Transformative Works would disagree. That's the non-profit that runs AO3 and was pretty explicitly created to make sure AO3 can be run as a non-profit legally. The community is pretty aggressive about making sure fanfic they host is not even getting close to edge of "not for profit" (e.g. I see posts telling people to not mention on AO3 if a particular piece was commissioned and not to explicitly mention accepting donations), but they're pretty sure fanfic is legal even if charging for fanfic is not. Of course, there's plenty of sites that host derivative works that have ads that haven't gotten sued, so who knows where the courts would actually draw the line.

There were a bunch of Apogee platformers of various themes. Commander Keen was the most well-known, but Bio Menace (gameplay video) and maybe Crystal Caves (gameplay video) fit the setting of "factory or laboratory" best, I think. (Also, even if they're not the games you're looking for, they're both good games; there were three in both series, I believe.)

If you want health information, you should talk to a doctor about what kind of genetic testing, if any, is appropriate for you. They will probably not recommend 23andme.

Why do you need an app and not a website? There's plenty of ways to make simple websites without coding knowledge and websites work just fine on phones (if you want an app icon, select "save to home screen" from your mobile browser's menu).

Yeah, it's more a question of exactly what workarounds would get invented once the tax is in place and how well the legislature adjusts to them.

For another example, if used items aren't taxed but services are, then buying a (used) plane which and hiring someone to fly it would be untaxed (erm, what is the difference between paying for a service and hiring an employee such that the former is taxed and the latter isn't, anyway?), but buying plane tickets would be taxed.

Similarly, wealthier people buy "used" houses to live in which would be untaxed while poorer people pay rent which would be taxed. I assume no individuals buy skyscrapers new or used, so they would never be taxed in whole, although the rent (or pieces of them sold to individuals as condos) would be.

I guess the idea is that the tax should be set high enough that the "used" cost prices in the tax that had to be paid when it was new, so buying something "used" you're still sorta paying the tax indirectly?

I'm not any kind of expert in business or tax evasion and I can come up with a list of ways that FairTax is far more regressive than it looks at first glance. I'm sure the experts can come up with more, which is a general problem with any attempt at a simple tax proposal; having multiple taxes makes it harder to evade all of them, which part of why we have consumption+income+property+excise taxes (there's currently no consumption tax at the federal level, but FairTax covers a similar set of transactions to state level sales taxes).

It's hard for me to tell exactly how much of a bubble I'm in with respect to COVID precautions. I see plenty of comments online like yours suggesting the world looks to you just like 2019 except for occasionally encountering posts online to the contrary. I believe you, I'm just trying to understand how that can be.

I understand that I'm in a city where COVID precautions were more popular; masking in public is certainly not a majority here, but I would find it actively surprising to go to the grocery store or get on a bus/train and see no one wearing a mask. Certainly at any larger (i.e. 10+ people) social gathering I'm at, some of them will be wearing masks, but that's my friends group, so even more narrow than my neighborhood/city. (I know many of my friends test regularly (... although free tests may be going away, so that might not continue...), but that's not visible. It's pretty common for weekend-long-type events I attend to request negative tests.)

Trying to cast a wider net, I went looking at rules for recent conventions. PAX East (March 23-26, 2023 in Boston, MA) required masks. Anime Central (May 19-21, 2023 in Chicago, IL) only recommends masks (their publicity photo from a previous iteration on the top of their website shows everyone wearing masks; perhaps from a previous year when they were required? I've generally noticed events wanting to downplay masks use pre-2020 photos); maybe that's part of a trend towards loosening mask requirements at conventions? Of course, "geek conventions" is its own narrow group, and very well may itself be a hot spot for COVID precautions. Maybe my hobbies and the hobbies I'm aware of happen to be outliers in COVID-cautiousness?

(Replying here, but @anti_dan's sibling reply makes some similar points, so tagging them, too.)

I pretty often see low-effort comments on /r/politics and similar spaces accusing the Republican Party of being the party of pedophiles, providing evidence like their support for child marriage (which, in current law, is actually pretty mixed between red and blue states, more common in blue states, if anything), inspecting children's genitals to maintain sex segregation in sports (that link is Politifact calling BS on that claim), and politicians convicted of child molestation (obviously, that was an older case, actual comments often include more recent cases that haven't actually made their way through the legal system, so it's less clear they're even actually true).

In case I haven't made it clear in my tone, I think claiming the Republicans are pro-pedophile is absurd. As far as I can tell, everyone is anti-pedophile (and, similarly, anti-rape) right up until someone in their in-group (for some scope of in-group) is accused and then they don't want to do anything about it. I doubt there's a meaningful difference there between the left and right on that, and trying to cherry-pick examples is just culture warring.

Depends on what gets defined as "consumption" (to be fair, our current tax scheme has no shortage of problems with what gets defined as "income"). Wikipedia gives a description and the big one that jumps out at me is investments are not taxed, which makes sense, but buying companies for control over them is something the very wealthy spend their money on, which would not be taxed at all under FairTax. Lower down the economic ladder, tuition is also excluded and is something wealthier people spend a lot more money on (both college and private school). Strangely, health care is taxed under the proposal, despite it currently often coming out of pre-tax money in our current system (at least if you have an HSA). It also applies only to personal purchases, and pretending personal purchases are business purchases is already a way people evade taxes, and would continue to be so under FairTax.

On top of that, "used" goods don't get taxed and I'm not sure exactly how much of a loophole that is. I'd expect poorer people probably buy used goods more often, not sure how that shakes out, although cars are a particular big ticket item that could mean people buying new cars would be paying a lot more tax. But I'd also be worried about games getting played with the definition of "used", just like games get played with the definition of "personal" vs. "business" purchases that are technically illegal but poorly policed.

I think COVID was a problem, and obviously people did die. It just turns out that unless you had a pretty serious health condition, if you were under 50, you could go on about your life and never get anything that much worse than a bad flu.

This is false.

We can argue over exactly what rate of death and severe side effects is acceptable and what mitigations are acceptable to reduce those rates, but COVID-19 causes a lot more of both than any flu we've seen other than the 1918 one, including among the young and healthy. Previously young and healthy people becoming majorly disabled by Long COVID is something that happens, albeit rarely. I'm not sure where to get the best data on this, but the death rate across all age groups appears to be ~3x for COVID-19 vs. a normal flu season, but that's not counting post-COVID sequela which we know is significantly more common than with the flu but difficult to measure, partially because studies vary widely in their definitions. And it's unclear how to define a fair comparison because getting the flu rarely happens more than once a year and usually significantly less often while COVID-19 infections happening multiple times a year is common.

Mind, the flu poses very little danger to the young and healthy, so even a lot more dangerous than the flu can quite reasonably fit inside your acceptable risk profile. But treating them as the same is not accurate.

(And, uh, maybe it wouldn't be terrible if we took some measures to strengthen our protection against airborne pandemics like improving ventilation and accidentally reduced flu prevalence as a side effect.)

Wait, the BBC is pro-caring about COVID now? The people in the UK I follow on social media are pretty annoyed at them for being part of downplaying COVID, similar to how I see people on the left in the US annoyed that US media is downplaying COVID. I guess they're annoying both sides.

Is it really that hard?

Strangely, yes. They own a few random really small breweries. Wikipedia lists all of the brands they own, which includes some really small ones that appear tiny and independent at first glance.

I'm not sure how you got that from my comment. But also, I don't think I knew any (out) trans people before my mid-20s, so I can't make any strong claims about how I would have acted around them at that time.