@token_progressive's banner p

token_progressive

maybe not the only progressive here

0 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 October 25 17:28:07 UTC

				

User ID: 1737

token_progressive

maybe not the only progressive here

0 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 October 25 17:28:07 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 1737

I thought the topic was "do masks work?" not "do mask mandates work?". These are very different questions, and can be broken down further with questions like "do N95 masks worn by untrained people work?" and "do fit-tested N95 masks work?", without even delving into the details of how we want to define "work", presumably some measure of reducing the incidence of COVID-19 in the mask wearers, although looking at reducing the incidence of COVID-19 in people around the mask wearers is also an interesting question.

The summary of the study that I referenced suggests the study answered the question of "does having masks vaguely nearby that you wear inconsistently reduce the incidence of COVID-19 in mask wearers?" and got the utterly unsurprising answer of "no". Maybe that's a realistic view of what behavior under mask mandates looks like, but that information doesn't really give us any hints on the answers to questions like "does training our medical personnel and requiring them to wear fit-tested N95s at all times reduce the transmission of COVID-19 in our medical facility?" or "does an individual choosing to wear an N95 while on transit / in airports reduce the chance they'll get COVID-19?".

surgical / FFP2 mask

Those are very different things. Wikipedia defines an FFP2 mask as the European equivalent of an N95, i.e. what it normally used for repository pathogens like SARS-CoV-2. I'm used to surgical mask being used to refer to the masks you see on surgeons in medical shows which are intended to block exhalations/spit/sneezes and do not have a seal so they have limited to no expectation of preventing breathing in airborne pathogens.

What's your evidence that "Caring About Other People" (which people? caring how?) delivers superior outcomes to "not" caring about other people?

Apologies for the confusion. I had no intention of claiming one set of values is "superior" to another. In fact, I thought I directly stated that the difference in goals meant that debating which approach is "superior" isn't a meaningful conversation to have in this context.

In all of these cases, the counterargument, as I understand it, is that while these things might be good for the current residents of my neighborhood, they’re not good for the potential future residents of my neighborhood. This is where I find it difficult to rebut the argument on its own terms, as it is evidently coming from a perspective of utilitarianism with little or no discount as one moves out the concentric ring of association. I don’t share that perspective and feel little or no responsibility to make my neighborhood more accessible to those that aren’t presently members.

It sounds like you've narrowed down to a specific value difference. While NIMBY isn't particularly strongly associated with conservatism/Republicans in the US (although, the left is often calling out liberals/Democrats, too), I often see people on the left asserting the strawman that the conservative worldview is "I've got mine, screw you." or the related "I Don't Know How To Explain To You That You Should Care About Other People" (I haven't actually seen that article before, but I've certainly seen the line repeated on Twitter a lot; scrolling down, that article also contains "I’ve got mine, so screw you").

I'm not sure there's much to gain by discussing further. You've found the fundamental values difference. Except maybe the YIMBY side could come up with arguments that your positions are actually somehow counterintuitively working against that value, but that seems unlikely. I guess there's the problem cited elsewhere in this thread that if you want businesses near you staffed with low-paid service workers, then those workers have to be able to afford housing of some sort vaguely nearby.

Just before seeing this post, I saw an article on social media arguing it was misleading: The Conversation: "Yes, masks reduce the risk of spreading COVID, despite a review saying they don’t". The summary of that article is that the review finds weak effects because it mixes together too many things that you would expect to have weak/no effect:

  • "mask" includes cloth/surgical masks (as opposed to [K]N95+ or equivalent masks) that we don't expect to work except maybe as source control.

  • Related, none of the studies look at masks as source control. i.e., they only study individuals wearing masks, not groups.

  • Most of the studies only had people wear masks in "high-risk" situations (i.e. around known-infected individuals) as opposed to, say, all the time while at work. Any consideration of the claimed mechanism of airborne transmission often from asymptomatic cases would lead you to expect that to not work, especially where "work" means medical settings where you have higher expectation of infected people around.

  • Bonus: none of the studies compare mask wearing to not masking wearing, only being advised to wear masks to not being advised to wear masks.

The articles claims if you pare down to only the studies looking at "Does wearing N95s all the time reduce COVID-19 transmission?" the answer is in fact "yes", the opposite of the headline.

This is nonsense resulting from trying to apply macroscopic intuitions at a microscopic scale. Completely unintuitively, N95 masks filter particles smaller than 0.3 microns better, even though the macroscopic intuition is that smaller particles would more easily fit through the holes. Here's a pop-science explanation from Wired.

Wikipedia is pretty convinced that N95 masks are technically "respirators" as well, but, yes, one advantage of P100-style respirators is that they are easier to fit correctly.

I think the usual claim is that all media companies are owned by rich people with a vested interest in exercising their editorial control to limit talk of class consciousnesses.

The coverage of Occupy Wall Street was probably the place I can recall where this was most blatant, where working class solidarity got to be big enough a news item that the news media couldn't completely ignore it, but instead did everything they could to downplay it and not talk about the goals of the protests. Even so, the protest managed to have one meme that was too good/pithy for the media to completely suppress, the idea of the "1%" vs. the "99%", which is a pretty concise message of working class solidarity, although Sanders's focus "billionaires" may be a clearer version of that message.

The Toxoplasma of Rage should probably also be considered: that is, you don't need a secret cabal pushing Culture War items, modern (social) media structurally encourages Culture War content because it maximizes engagement=ad money.

Sorry, perhaps I was unclear. I understand why people buy actually new items instead of used items. The question is how the law defines "new" vs. "used" to avoid legal gymnastics to allow for legal tax evasion.


Thrift stores currently exist, many of them nonprofits. Why would anyone not buy all their clothes there at a 50-90% discount from retail?

This actually seems to be an interesting cultural thing. While division probably isn't actually quite so clean, I feel like a lot of people I know can be divided into "buys all clothes new, would never occur to them to shop at a thrift store" and "buys all clothes used, would never occur to them to buy new".

Clarification: Drawing the detours isn't that annoying by itself. What's annoying is the accumulation of little things that the engineer has to do for each detour.

Yeah, that entire list sounds completely mechanical and not like something that a human should be dealing with. But perhaps there's more creativity involved than it sounds like.

As a programmer who regularly writes scripts to automate things both for work and personal things, it bothers me to see repetitive processes being done on a computer. Realistically, writing software to actually automate parts of that process would likely be a fair bit of effort and expensive since your department probably doesn't employ any programmers.

So why don't I sell all items "new" for 1 cent to myself (well, presumably a fictional legal entity so it counts as a sale) and then sell them "used" for the real price?

Think content farms, but fully automated: millions and millions of genuine looking wordpress websites filled with plausible looking nonsense answering every possible question a user can possibly have.

When's the last time you've tried to use Google search to answer a general knowledge question and clicked one of the links that didn't go to Wikipedia, Quora, StackExchange, or Reddit (i.e., some site where humans are moderating the content)? Because that's what's it's looked like for years now. I'm sure you're right that in the future the nonsense will be written by better AI models and therefore take a bit longer to recognize as nonsense. But the existing content farms have poisoned the well enough that I'm not sure I would ever click one those links to notice.

From my, non-American, understanding there is a corrupt relationship between TurboTax and US lawmakers which leads to this proprietery software being basicly required to file taxes.

Yeah, here's the latest Propublica article on the topic with back links to their earlier reporting: https://www.propublica.org/article/what-to-know-about-turbotax-before-you-file-taxes

Like other replies, I also do my own taxes. But I'm under no illusion this is a realistic option for most people.

One issue is that the IRS very threatening about any mistakes bringing very serious consequences, including jail time. In practice, they do tend to be understanding and work with people to correct mistakes. But many people don't know that... and that might not be the experience poorer people have. Tax prep companies provide legal guarantees that mistakes are their problem not yours.

There's no reason (other than lobbying by the makers of TurboTax) for the IRS to not send you everything they know, which should cover your entire tax situation if you just have W-2 jobs, investments through a brokerage firm, and a mortgage, all of which are already reported to the IRS and if you omit or typo any of the information that was sent to both you and the IRS, then you're in trouble. In practice, this "trouble" usually means the IRS contacts you saying you made a typo, they fixed it, and here's your recomputed tax amount, but you did have to sign saying they're well within their rights to throw you in jail instead.

That sounds like a major loophole. If "used" goods aren't taxed, why would anyone ever sell "new" goods?

It sounds like your professional opinion is that the vast majority of this work is providing no value and just shouldn't be done in the first place. And the rest is being done very inefficiently. I'm not sure exactly what's involved from your high-level descriptions, but some of this seems like software could be doing it for you, at least things like drawing detour routes which sounds like something Google Maps more or less already does (if it knows about the closed street, which it often doesn't). Likely some of the other steps could be faster with better software, but it sounds like a lot of your problems come from bad data and it's not obvious that can be fixed other than through collecting better data and organizing it better.

It seems like the actual problem is that there's no one responsible for figuring out how to get all of this done more efficiently, and I'm not sure how to fix that.

401ks are a massively underappreciated piece of social engineering. They were a genius move on the part of capital to defend their interests.

I think "seemingly" may be doing a lot of work there. While certainly not universal, a lot of the people (most?) I've encountered on- or off-line who are outspoken about their left-leaning beliefs are pretty strongly anti-capitalism and talk about economic issues a lot. That is, looking for why there are fewer economic Marxists might be the wrong question; you should be asking why you don't hear about them and their beliefs. The generally proposed answer is that the Culture War is an intentionally imposed distraction from real economic issues, but that doesn't really answer the question (imposed by whom and by what mechanism, for instance).

The fact that fluids diffuse/disperse is fundamental to my baseline understanding of the physical world. In that what I intuit about physical reality without exercising any thought. I wonder what went wrong for anyone to mask outdoors ever at all and not see the futility of it.

Basically everyone has experience with dispersion in air from people breathing out via seeing visible breath in cold weather or seeing/smelling smoke from someone smoking. The former is generally visible about 1-2 feet away at most while the latter is quite noticeable several feet away. I'm not sure if it's obvious whether viral transmission is analogous to the first, the second, or neither. My layman's understanding is that smoke goes a lot further than viruses because the relevant particles are a lot smaller/lighter, but that's not obvious and I've seen tweets explicitly using the intuition of smelling smoke far away as a justification for outdoor distancing/masking.

For whatever reason, as of 2019, works are actually falling out of copyright in the United States. Maybe Disney is less powerful somehow? Or maybe copyright is long enough for them and they don't see the point anymore? Or maybe they missed the 20 year calendar reminder they set in 1998 and forgot and will get right on extending copyright soon.

Commenting on how the Harry Potter world is problematic and proposing fan fiction/head-canons to fix it is a whole genre of Tumblr post that dates back years. If anything, paying attention to the problematic aspects of Harry Potter has become less popular, only because paying any attention at all to Harry Potter has become less popular with the whole "Rowling is a TERF" thing.


It's not a book with that supports the "trust the experts" style of government that's been a staple of leftism for a long time but has ramped up even more since 2016.

This is a strange complaint. YA/children's literature as a genre practically requires authority figures be useless or oblivious (or the problems be so small in scale they're appropriate for adults to ignore) because otherwise the adults would be the protagonists and it wouldn't be a YA/children's story. Harry Potter isn't exactly dystopian fiction, but it sorta fits into the genre of children/teenagers having to do the right thing against an oppressive/corrupt government.

Note that the epilogue of Harry Potter involves the government becoming good and competent once the main characters have fixed the government and Harry (at least, I forget who else) has become part of it.

I'm afraid I can't access any counterarguments from your video since it's nearly 2 hours long.

BTW, the show notes point to the research papers discussed on the podcast if you would rather see the arguments in that format (providing quote from the internet archive because the TWiV website appears to be down for me at the moment):

The podcast is an interview with the lead author on the papers going over the arguments, although presumably in less detail than the papers themselves.

My understanding is that the first paper shows that the cases show a pattern that strongly suggests the first human cases occurred at the market and not at the lab. And the second paper shows there were multiple spillovers both at the market, which is also inconsistent with the source being the lab.

https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/the-covid-lab-leak-theory-just-got-even-stronger/

This link predates the publication of those papers by a few months. I acknowledge that the lab leak theory wasn't a total nonsense conspiracy theory, but the accumulated evidence points pretty strongly against it at the moment. And, more importantly, whether or not it's right, it's a distraction from actions we already know we should be taking (but aren't) to prevent future pandemics.

You don't need wild hypotheticals about a lab leak that probably didn't happen to find negligence leading to the COVID-19 pandemic. China actively covered it up for weeks (months?); not sure that's really even "negligence" at that point. Although the US's CDC not catching on sooner due to removing the person whose job it was to keep them honest in July 2019 probably does count.

And the leading scientific theory (spillover resulting from improper handling of market animals) implies that COVID-19 is due to Chinese government negligence. After SARS they clamped down on live animal markets, but over time, while they remained illegal, the government didn't seriously enforce the laws against them. In other words, they knew what they had to do to stop a pandemic, tried, and failed (or gave up). That makes them look culpable and/or incompetent, so they don't want too high a confidence assigned to that theory.

What are you trying to accomplish with your charity? You say

Homeless charities don't want to end homelessness.

so maybe you want to do something that will reduce homelessness or help people get out of homelessness. Maybe providing more permanent housing than a shelter? Maybe helping them get jobs (which could take a lot of forms)?

Other posters suggested getting involved with government somehow. Actually working on campaigns (or running for office yourself) isn't the only way to influence policy. There's also single-issue activist/lobbying organizations like FairVote. If there's some policies you believe in, maybe you could be working to convince other people of those policies, which may be preferable to getting directly involved in government.

Also, while I do feel the same desire to try to direct charity towards fixing problems instead of treading water dealing with them... even if they work structural fixes are slow and people are poor right now. Long-term fixes are important but I wouldn't completely dismiss the value of short-term band-aids.


(If you're writing any charity a check of any sizable amount, you may be missing out on the tax benefits of donating appreciated stock. See your brokerage for more information.)

[...] in terms of restrictions etc?

Once you're talking about things like how we should handle restrictions, you run straight into the problem that it's way easier to have documentation on who has been vaccinated and when than who has been infected and when. IIRC, in Europe restrictions based on vaccination or recent infection did exist in some places. The US does have checks of vaccination or prior infection for some diseases... well, at least chickenpox, not sure of any others, but that's partially because prior infection is a contraindication for that vaccine.

Countermeasures against the immune system developing antibodies to it? I'm pretty sure it doesn't; that's kind of the whole point of the immune system.

And countering the immune system is kind of the whole point of viruses. All viruses have countermeasures against the immune system of some sort. At least, all viruses fit enough for us to notice them, otherwise the immune system would do its job well enough we would never observe them. These countermeasures include hiding the proteins from the immune system that would be the most effective targets for antibodies, which is why we have spike-only vaccines for COVID and why we have to get a new flu vaccine every year (trying to get the immune system to pay attention to the right proteins on the flu virus is an open area of research). The implementation is different but both viruses trick the immune system into primarily targeting the wrong part of the virus. (Viruses can also have more involved countermeasures like taking on shapes close enough to things that are supposed to be in humans that the immune system has trouble targeting them and more directly interfering with the immune system functioning.)

I don't know if this is sufficient to cause the COVID vaccines to provide better immunity than a prior infection, just that it's not a priori obvious without doing the studies.


An actual infection tends to do both, however -- so one might think that it would be the best of both worlds in terms of protection.

Yeah, that suggests the research towards doing some of the vaccine doses as shots and some as nasal spray might result in a better vaccine. No results yet... but no one seems to be funding vaccine research very heavily since the initial vaccines were released.