wemptronics
No bio...
User ID: 95
Oh no, that's covered big time.
penetrative sexual activity between people who a reasonable person would think are related, or pretending to be related, in a certain way. This includes depictions of close familial relatives such as father and daughter or brother and sister, and certain step and foster relationships where one person is, or is pretending to be, under 18
This is from the government's guidance page. From the statute:
It is an offence for a person (P) to be in possession of an image if—
(a)the image is pornographic, within the meaning of section 63, (b)the image portrays, in an explicit and realistic way, a person
(A) sexually penetrating— >(i)the vagina or anus of another person (B) with a part of A’s body or anything else, or (ii)B’s mouth with A’s penis, (c)a reasonable person looking at the image would think that A and B were real, and (d)a reasonable person— (i)looking at the image, and >(ii)taking into account any sound or information associated with the image, would think what is set out in subsection (2) or (3).
(2)That A and B were related, or pretending to be related, such that A was related to B as parent, grandparent, child, grandchild, brother, sister, half-brother, half-sister, uncle, aunt, nephew or niece.
(3)That— (a)A and B were related or had been related, or were pretending to be related or to have been related, such that A was or had been related to B as step-parent, step-child, stepbrother, stepsister, foster parent or foster child, and (b)at least one of A and B was, or was pretending to be, under 18.
Last week, in its dogged commitment to a free and open internet, the UK has instituted a criminal prohibition on certain pornography in England and Wales. It is now a criminal offense to view or possess pornography that depicts "strangulation" including choking or "face sitting", incest including depictions of step siblings, and any depictions of underage roleplay. The penalty for viewing or possessing any of these categories is a prison sentence that ranges from 2-3 years. Publication of these materials has a punishment of up to 5 years in prison.
Before a conservative cheered the prohibition of pornographic materials as a buttress against the immorality of modernity I'd remind him it is worth keeping in mind the context. The UK has been on a tear the past couple decades when it comes to regulating the internet. These efforts did not go without results, culminating most recently in the Online Safety Act of 2023 which pushed an age-verification regime. The OSA is not limited to porn sites to ban minors, but also potentially hits app stores, vendors, payment intermediaries, and more that extends the tendrils of the state into the internet.
Feminists and Labour politicians who hate violence against women, think-of-the-children conservatives, Christian organizations, and Ofcom the regulatory agency which, surprisingly, tends to voice support for more regulations-- what do these constituencies all have in common? It's not the weirdest coalition to lock arms in solidarity, but it's strange bedfellows. Public choice theory stays winning. Many are saying.
I can't claim abstinence, but I am not a big fan of porn. I don't think productions involving toasters are a social good and children should not watch porn. However, what I suspect laws like this to be in practice is to function as a carve out for a censorious state with neurotic apparatchiks to punch up criminal charges whenever they feel like. The next time Tommy Robinson gets picked up for violence they can hit him with the lude pornography laws. There will be no reduction of Violence Against Women when so many report sexual choking as consensual and pleasurable.
If you peruse internet commentary on the Crime and Policing Act 2026 you will find a lot of people who agree with me. From reddit to X, everyone has criticisms that this is selective or ineffective. If you stopped there you wouldn't know that some surveys indicate the majority of Brits support the ban, if not the criminalization. To properly do this experiment Brits must go full bore with social taboos, reverse the sexual revolution, and enforce criminal statutes to that effect. Reinstitute sodomy laws. The cowards will never.
Comment sections under your local sports team podcast are where you find vital discussions about sports team happenings. Reddit is where the latest narrative is propagated so they're still useful for casual fans.
Since I was banned I went through my subscriptions for the first time in forever. I realized there are only a few subs I still weakly rated. /r/slatestarcodex as a link aggregator since discussion is now pretty bad. /r/supremecourt where mods have made a real effort, as good as it gets which is not great or even reliably worthwhile.
Part of this is aging out in interest. We are an aging breed after all, us highfalutin types who can remember, and a man can only see so many flamewars. I accept that. It is hard not to notice the rest of my former subscriptions look like a boneyard for old, used up machines. Subreddit after subreddit sitting out in a desert victimized by growth and entropy.
Still, I do hope that if activity on this forum declines too much we give Reddit another go.
This forum cannot exist on reddit. Maybe a couple years ago when admin actions chilled out, but reddit has implemented their own AI censorship/safety tools to police comments since then. In 2026 these are turbocharged, clearly designed to be dumb keyword enforcers, and it will go around deleting comments or banning users who merely mention bad ideas, i.e. suicide, capital punishment, and anything deemed sensitive. I suspect they still keep badlists of naughty subreddits for extra attention which The Motte would qualify for ten times over.
I had my very old account banned by reddit robots this year allegedly for spam. I post on reddit once every few months and am a more mild commentor by The Motte's standards. Most regulars here would need to use some kind of coded 1337 speak to go back to posting on reddit.
This piece suspiciously confirmed my preconceptions of this genre, but I also haven't read any of it for myself and I do not know this writer. Are we all doomed to read 1000 pages worth of stories for a particular ethnic identity crisis before we can call ourselves responsible thinkers? Epistimic humility has forsaken us.
- Prev
- Next

As someone with an anthropological interest in niche subcultures and oddities I do appreciate this. The fact there are grown men who are into soiling themselves in diapers is like that of a humorous freakshow. The concern I have is not for the bearded lady who found her people in a community of carnies. This must have been better for her than life as a complete outcast. My concern is that I doubt the bearded lady would have recommended the average person follow her path, and today I think there are far more average people who, without exposure, would otherwise find paths to live within the bounds of normal interests. They would find average communities for average people with an average chance of happiness and fulfillment if they didn't get stuck on the idea of toasterfucking.
Subcultures are great as refuges or islands, but normalizing them defeats their purpose (which destroys them) and they are by design not load bearing for something larger. For the outcast, the true freak, there is no other option but to live with themselves and find their people. I don't think it should be illegal to choose to indulge odd fetishes or attend the odd fetish convention, it is a freedom that probably carries a cost for individuals, our society, and culture.
More options
Context Copy link