yestrusocialist
No bio...
User ID: 2545
That is a fake alternative, made up by the left. More detail here: https://www.themotte.org/post/3493/culture-war-roundup-for-the-week/405679?context=8#context
No, this is a made-up misdirection from the left.
Employers are not the villain here - employers are legally required to accept any "reasonably genuine" documents that appear to relate to the employee, even if they are not ultimately confirmed by e-verify. Employers cannot terminate an employee simply because they believe they are an illegal immigrant. Doing so may result in anti-discrimination lawsuits against the employer, which are far riskier and carry heavier penalties than hiring illegals.
If an employer reports a worker to ICE as potentially illegal, the employer may get into trouble with anti-retaliation law. Additionally, claiming the employer is retaliating against you can be a pathway to getting 6 more years in the US - i.e. the illegal alien is financially motivated by the government to cause further trouble for the employer.
I don't think this works, as there are also relatively right-leaning libertarians like Bryan Caplan who are also in favor of more immigration.
Caplans position is actually quite far from the left. He favors a UAE type model: let the world in and deport them instantly if they jaywalk or consume any welfare. Also they and their America-born children get no political representation or welfare ever.
Apart from the complete inability to politically maintain this situation, it's a good plan.
Obama campaigned on a paradigm shift from Bush and the forever wars in the middle east.
Obama chose Biden as his VP and Clinton as secretary of state.
Anyone who was fooled into thinking he was anti war or pro civil liberties wanted to be fooled.
you don't have principled economic reasons to oppose immigration.
The principaled economic reason to oppose immigrating in this case is that you want immigrants to be net taxpayers, and also work in jobs complementary with (most) Americans rather than in competition with them.
For example, high skilled specialists we just don't have enough of. (Original use case of H1B, before it got exploited as a source of cheap accountants and php drones.)
On the immigrants thing, they can easily be doing both. Any immigrant with income below approximately the 60th percentile of income is a net negative to the taxpayer.
Then they are both taking our jobs and being net consumers of welfare.
- Prev
- Next

I agree that it would be great to dismantle antidiscrimination law. It is not true that this could be "easily cleared with legislation" - among other things one would also need to eliminate leftist judges and other instruments of left wing anti democratic power.
More options
Context Copy link