site banner

Culture War Roundup for the week of November 10, 2025

This weekly roundup thread is intended for all culture war posts. 'Culture war' is vaguely defined, but it basically means controversial issues that fall along set tribal lines. Arguments over culture war issues generate a lot of heat and little light, and few deeply entrenched people ever change their minds. This thread is for voicing opinions and analyzing the state of the discussion while trying to optimize for light over heat.

Optimistically, we think that engaging with people you disagree with is worth your time, and so is being nice! Pessimistically, there are many dynamics that can lead discussions on Culture War topics to become unproductive. There's a human tendency to divide along tribal lines, praising your ingroup and vilifying your outgroup - and if you think you find it easy to criticize your ingroup, then it may be that your outgroup is not who you think it is. Extremists with opposing positions can feed off each other, highlighting each other's worst points to justify their own angry rhetoric, which becomes in turn a new example of bad behavior for the other side to highlight.

We would like to avoid these negative dynamics. Accordingly, we ask that you do not use this thread for waging the Culture War. Examples of waging the Culture War:

  • Shaming.

  • Attempting to 'build consensus' or enforce ideological conformity.

  • Making sweeping generalizations to vilify a group you dislike.

  • Recruiting for a cause.

  • Posting links that could be summarized as 'Boo outgroup!' Basically, if your content is 'Can you believe what Those People did this week?' then you should either refrain from posting, or do some very patient work to contextualize and/or steel-man the relevant viewpoint.

In general, you should argue to understand, not to win. This thread is not territory to be claimed by one group or another; indeed, the aim is to have many different viewpoints represented here. Thus, we also ask that you follow some guidelines:

  • Speak plainly. Avoid sarcasm and mockery. When disagreeing with someone, state your objections explicitly.

  • Be as precise and charitable as you can. Don't paraphrase unflatteringly.

  • Don't imply that someone said something they did not say, even if you think it follows from what they said.

  • Write like everyone is reading and you want them to be included in the discussion.

On an ad hoc basis, the mods will try to compile a list of the best posts/comments from the previous week, posted in Quality Contribution threads and archived at /r/TheThread. You may nominate a comment for this list by clicking on 'report' at the bottom of the post and typing 'Actually a quality contribution' as the report reason.

6
Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Welp, turns out more Epstein files are finally getting released!

Apparently there will be a vote coming out to release even more, but the docs released so far have been negative for Trump's claims to be innocent of the whole matter.

This, combined with the ruckus over Trump arguing we need foreign talent, has caused a massive cratering amongst online confidence in MAGA. From my perspective, confidence in MAGA at least online is the lowest it has ever been. Many feel betrayed by Trump when it comes to his America First promises.

Add in the storm over Fuentes and Israel, and I feel I'm seeing the conservative coalition fall apart in real time, extremely quickly.

Is this inevitable, the narcissism of small differences? Or is it just Trump not being a very principled man?

...the docs released so far have been negative for Trump's claims to be innocent of the whole matter.

Do you have some example in mind, here? Everything I've seen from this latest release appears to simply confirm what has long been known: that Trump and Epstein were substantially birds of a feather, but Trump kicked Epstein to the curb for stealing his girls. Since that time, Epstein has occasionally ranted about having some kind of dirt on Trump, which for some reason he never actually used and of which there is (still!) apparently no plausible evidence.

I would stop well short of describing Trump as "innocent" of anything and yet the plainly intended implication of all these reports--Trump had sex with underage girls on Epstein island or at least with Epstein's knowledge or assistance--appears to still remain purely in the realm of the undemonstrated, indeed, in most contexts the unstated. Nobody wants to get sued for defamation, and they all know Trump will happily sue them for defamation, so they are just continuing to parrot vague claims while winking and nodding in the direction of Prince Andrew, producing many guns but none smoking, nor even bearing fingerprints.

Trump has spent his adult life a man of wealth and fame, albeit also the butt of many jokes. I would honestly be surprised to learn he hadn't had more than a little bit of illicit sexual contact in his life; I would in that case need to revise my priors on the nature of rich, powerful men. But it seems like there are a lot of people out there who are utterly convinced of the details on this, who keep telling me that some bombshell or other is going to drop (including Pam Bondi!), only for those bombshells to never actually manifest. It was the same with the whole "Russian watersports" thing ten years ago. If Trump were guilty of 1% of the weird, crazy, illegal things he's accused of doing, I would expect at some point for someone to be able to produce hard, non-circumstantial evidence of something. Instead we get lawfare on novel legal theories and this recurrent "this time, we've got him!" nonsense from breathless (and brainless) journalists.

I'm open to evidence! I would not be at all surprised to see it! But again, it seems, no such thing is on offer.

Is there any clarification on "by underage we mean 17" or "we mean 13"? Because I've seen plenty of online 'it's true he's a pedo he raped 13 year old sex slaves' stuff but nothing concrete (the Katie Johnson case seems to be smoke and I have no idea what exactly Virginia Giuffre was claiming happened. If I go by Wikipedia, she was allegedly 17 when Maxwell and Epstein approached her, which is not at all the same as 13 year old).

In one way, I think the very murkiness of the term "underage girls" works for those who want to get Trump; it's easier to convey an impression that this means "13 or 14" and not "17 or just under 18 or even that legally a minor is under 21 in some states". See The Onion; yes this is satire, but they're making it satire on "fucking a 13 year old" and not "fucking a 16 year old":

“Epstein was no friend of mine, and I never drew us becoming knights and competing at a joust for the virginity of a 13-year-old Eleanor of Aquitaine,” Trump said when asked about Time Pedophiles by a reporter, suggesting that someone else could have written, inked, and lettered the series before falsely signing his name. “Anyone who knows me knows I wouldn’t draw myself in a covered wagon picking up minors on the Oregon Trail, nor would I write a story arc about going back into prehistory, long before humans invented the age of consent, to hit on Cro-Magnon girls. Sorry to disappoint, but the fact is, I don’t draw cavemen.”

...The storylines in the series are largely driven by the reliance of Epstein’s time machine on Enigmium, a mysterious substance that “never ages” and can only be obtained via sexual encounters with girls between the ages of 12 and 17.

Is there any clarification on "by underage we mean 17" or "we mean 13"?

They mean 16-17. If they were 13, they'd have said 13.

The anti-Trump faction has a significant, perhaps even majority, element whose entire objective is to pretend there isn't a distinction between 17 and 13 in this matter. Pointing out the adultery adultness of these women works against this goal, so they won't do that.

The pro-Trump faction is well aware of the above, but they also don't have any other effective tools to oppose that viewpoint other than flagrantly ignoring people who claim they're the same. Saying "well, akthually, they're adults" works against this goal, so they won't do that.

The demand for sex crimes (as with hate crimes) vastly exceeds its supply.

Ins't the US age of consent 16? Now you can well argue that these 16 year olds were coerced but then having sex with them would be rape regardless of whether they were 16 or 21 so the age factor would drop out of the equation completely and it just becomes "Trump used coerced prostitutes" which is a much weaker story and would have dropped out of the news years ago (see the Stormy Daniels saga, although she wasn't coerced). The fact that it's continuing means at the very least some of the people were under 16 when the relevant events happened.

  • -14

Depends on the state, but crossing state lines to have sex with a woman under 18 is probably illegal somehow, even if the states involved have a lower age.

I wonder what odd juxtapositions exist in places like Nevada where prostitution is legal and the age of consent is 16. Like if you’re a teacher at a public high school and some kid there is employed at the Mustang Ranch, is it legal to go and fuck your students? That always seemed disgusting as fuck to me.

Whenever you see an age of consent below 18 it almost always is actually accompanied by a number of caveats. Prostitution, pornography, age difference and the adult being an authority figure being very common variables to be taken into consideration.

IDK about that, but Texas has an age of consent of 17 unless you have some legitimate reason for knowing the minor in question, in which case it's 18, and flat out bans school district employees from having sex with the students. These seem like obvious rule patches.

This page indicates that the minimum age for prostitution in Nevada is 18 or 21, depending on the county.

Trump used coerced prostitutes

Everyone knows that's false, though, for reasons Sloot covered above. And most claimed "coercion" is just progressive/selfish-woman-speak for "he said he wouldn't keep supplying/buying me X if I didn't put out/consent" anyway, so using that standard I'm forced to conclude it's very unlikely the Rotherham girls were coerced either.

The fact that it's continuing means at the very least some of the people were under 16

In a landscape where the media tends to blow its load all at once I sincerely doubt this is the case.

I'm forced to conclude it's very unlikely the Rotherham girls were coerced either.

The Rotherham girls were a lot younger than the women/girls on Epstein's island. The official report states that the majority were between the ages of 10 and 16.

They were also threatened with/subjected to violent reprisals.

Ins't the US age of consent 16?

Like everything else in America, it varies by state. However, since Hollywood is in California, 18 has been memed into the canonical age of consent throughout the country (and, indeed, around the world).

Critically, 18 is the age at which normie parents - and particularly normie red tribe parents - stop thinking "What if this was my daughter?". Of course the reality is that Mirpuri rape gangs, Jeffrey Epstein, your local street corner pimp etc. all preferentially go after kids without high-functioning, involved parents, so it was vanishingly unlikely to be your daughter. But I don't think normies get this.

If it was your teenage daughter, the age of consent in your jurisdiction wouldn't be relevant to your desire to wreak terrible revenge against the sleazebag.

The fact that it's continuing means at the very least some of the people were under 16 when the relevant events happened.

I don't think that follows. I think the fact that it's continuing means that, at the very least, the people who are continuing this believe that they can create a public impression that some of the people were under 16 when the relevant events happened. Hard to say if the people who are continuing this also believe that some of the people were under 16 when the relevant events happened, but their belief regarding this doesn't matter, it's the belief of the voting populace that matters.

Some US states have their age of consent at 18. But even if it wasn't, it's not like the moral outrage would stop over that. I notice that people who loudly decry sex with late-teen girls generally aren't considering local ages of consent as a valid argument in favor. It would simply shift to "they weren't adults".

If they were 13, they'd have said 13.

That's what I'm getting at: they can't say "the girls were 13" because they weren't ('Katie Johnson' aside), but if it's "yeah he foozled around with hot 17 year olds" that's nothing really. It might be grubby, but if it's generally considered that 14 year olds can be mature enough to decide to have sex and go on birth control, it's tough to argue that 17 year old is too young to have sex.

But the insinuation that "Epstein liked 'em very very young, and Trump was a big best pal of Epstein's and liked to party with him, so you know what that means" is what they're going for to do the damage.

but if it's generally considered that 14 year olds can be mature enough to decide to have sex

It's not. In the US this is actually a very controversial statement. Most Americans do not think middle schoolers should be having sex with each other, even on birth control, and a significant percentage of the population thinks the same about high school seniors.

Most Americans do not think middle schoolers should be having sex with each other, even on birth control

I really hope this is so, but you know yourself: the Very Online Activist set that arrange protests with pink knitted hats and had Kamala Harris making speeches about how she was fighting for reproductive justice (or whatever the term of art is today) are the ones who like to use these examples of "so you're gonna put a 15 year old on the sex offenders list just for sleeping with his girlfriend, huh?"

Yes, but they don't represent the median american. The 'you-should-live-together-before-marriage' public does not think middle, or early high schoolers, should have sex with each other.

if it's generally considered that 14 year olds can be mature enough to decide to have sex

With each other.

it's tough to argue that 17 year old is too young to have sex

With someone much older.

You may or may not think this distinction relevant, but it is drawn by those advancing the aforementioned propositions.

Not just with each other, with someone X amount of years older than them, the precise number of years depending on the state and the law.

If 14 is old enough to decide to have sex, then by 17 you've been sexually active for three years, making decisions about your fertility, and should be experienced enough to decide if you want to sleep with a 30 year old, right?

That's the equivocation that sticks out like a sore thumb to me: 6 year old Johnny or Susie is old and mature enough to have a solid grip on their gender identity and know if they're really a boy or a girl; under-18 year old Susie is mature enough to decide for herself to have sex and can get a judge's decision to circumvent parental notification laws if she needs an abortion; 22 year old Susie was a poor helpless immature girl coerced into an unequal power-level relationship by wicked 28 year old Johnny!

"Children" to the modal mind is prepubescent innocents who elicit protective instincts. Definitionally it also includes adolescents that are protoadults. Conflating the two is necessary to get the moral value immediately realized, and any attempt at deeper examination is met with hysterical screeches of "ARE YOU A BIGOT". Refugees are always stated to be "women and children" but you never get a picture of these huddled masses because people don't process bearded males as "children". The assumption that Epsteins sex island was a San Francisco Armory dungeon filled with crying prepubescents being abused by leering rapists is as rampant as the assumption that Rittenhouse killed 3 unarmed black men, and of course equally as fictional.

you never get a picture of these huddled masses because people don't process bearded males as "children".

Ironically in this context, there's a current murder investigation about asylum seekers as "unaccompanied children" who were put in emergency accommodation meant for minors, and it now turns out one of the "minors" may in fact have been a legal adult.

Vadym Davydenko (17) died following a serious incident at an apartment complex in Grattan Wood, ­Donaghmede, on October 15.

He had been in Ireland for four days and was staying at a Tusla facility for juvenile international protection applicants separated from their parents.

A suspect was later arrested as part of the investigation and charged with Vadym’s murder.

The male was also residing at the juvenile care facility at the time of the incident. His age was given as 17 in his first court appearance with his case last heard before the Children’s Court last month.

The Irish Independent has now learnt that inquiries have led investigating gardaí to believe that the suspect is in fact an adult male and not a juvenile.

Examinations into his background, including procuring a birth certificate from relatives, have indicated that he was over the age of 18 at the time of the incident.

Gaming the asylum system, you say? Surely not!

When Kabul fell to the Taliban, there was a widely shared picture of an overcrowded C130 filled with refugees. I love that picture because it is FULL of men, with barely any women or children. I contrast that with the fall of hanoi where evacuees had women and prepubescents. My liberal friends actually had to stop for a second to wonder what "women and children" really meant, and anytime refugees got raised in any conversation subsequently they all bit the bullet immediately before I could play the photo card.

Sorry to butt in but I don't know what you are saying here. And what's the "modal mind"?

The phrase *women and children " brings up mental images of adult human females and children of both genders typically lower than puberty age. The actual "women and children" used in politically sensitive messaging like Palestinian populations attacked by Israel or refugee migrants to the west is actually dominated overwhelmingly by males of "indeterminate" but definitely postpubertal age, with the generous lower bound being 15 years of age and typically presenting as 17-25 year olds, which fits the legal definition of "child" if you flatten every bearded youth as a 17 year old.

When you see pictures of "women and children" refugees look for whether it is a candid shot and not a file or staged photo. The afghanistan evacuation c130 was a candid photo that revealed most "refugees" are healthy adult males, not sympathymaxxing weakling women or babies. Noticing that these adult males are the ones seeking help invites the question of where are the women and if the women are safe where the males are fleeing then why are the males fleeing to begin with.

Sure. The term 'child' is flexible in the media. Can't always blame the young men/boys for being simple opportunists though? Maybe they're trying to escape a very likely death or torture after being forced into the conflict in some way or another. They're the ones more likely to die vs other groups.

When the term is dragged in the other direction, some countries like the US will count any 15+ year old male as a likely terrorist who can be killed without anyone caring.

And 'modal mind'? Only thing I can think of is stuff like working memory vs long term memory etc.

I have no idea what exactly Virginia Giuffre was claiming happened

Nothing. She claimed nothing happened.

It's all tangled up, though, with Prince Andrew (who is losing everything over allegations that he may have had legal-in-Britain sex with her) and the overall media presentation that Epstein was providing 13 year olds for his rich and famous clients to fuck on his private island. "Okay I said I was a teen sex slave for Epstein, but that particular client nothing happened" is too fine a distinction for the current meat-grinder to make (particularly since Giuffre is now dead so we can't get her version of what did or didn't happen, or if she would change her mind and suddenly remember 'oh hold on, yeah I blocked it out because it was too traumatic but now I remember that Trump did rape me' like E. Jean Carroll).

As an American, I have to say I don't give fuck about British royals. We knew they were degenerate retards in 1776, and a couple of popular Queens notwithstanding, why should we believe that has changed, or care?

The only Trump-related thing in the current meatgrinder is years-old nothingburger. Giuffre had a job at Mar-a-Lago; she was one of the girls that Epstein poached. She's talked about a lot of people, including Trump -- and said nothing bad about Trump. If the Democrats were trying to make some hay involving ex-Prince Andrew, they would have used her name. Instead they redacted it so some people wouldn't realize it was her they were talking about.

If you're going to hypothesize that she would have accused Trump if she were still alive, this is just making shit up out of whole cloth. Maybe Jimmy Hoffa would accuse Trump of putting out the hit on him if he were still alive too.

At this point, Nybbler, I think all the waters are sufficiently muddied that we'll never know who actually did what (apart from Epstein and the previous underage sex charges brought against him, which were explained in a previous comment on a different thread).

Giuffre and what she might or might not have said - her book is out now and a lot of media commentary on it was dragging in Trump's name. I could well believe she might be coaxed into dropping hints about Trump and Epstein in order to sell the book, were she still alive; it seems she did exactly this (changed her statements) about her husband:

Giuffre also talks about her husband, Robert Giuffre, extensively. In the main body of the book, she generally portrays him in a positive light, describing him as a supportive partner and the person who "rescued her from Epstein and Maxwell's clutches". However, this positive portrayal became a point of contention after her death. In the weeks before her suicide in April 2025, Giuffre made public accusations that her husband had physically abused her during their 22-year marriage, and she expressed a desire to revise the book to reflect this. The book's co-author, Amy Wallace, addresses this conflict in a foreword, explaining the situation and the reasons why Giuffre might have initially chosen to remain silent about the domestic abuse in the manuscript itself. The published book therefore contains her original, more loving descriptions of her husband, alongside the foreword and other editorial notes that acknowledge the later abuse allegations.

So when there's money to be made, victimhood status, and pressure to 'name names' on someone probably not very mentally stable, I am ruling nothing out.

At this point, Nybbler, I think all the waters are sufficiently muddied that we'll never know who actually did what

After entertaining various noxious allegations and then finding they are unsupported, it is at the very least discourteous to then fall back on invincible ignorance.

Yeah, nothing big do far, but some small evidence that they were talking in 2017. Still, I'd say Trump acts differently compared to other allegations, how it's "boring" and so on. Some sycophants already try "it's actually ephebophilia", but I doubt it's that. I can't figure out what he's scared of now that didn't scare him off earlier. Guess we'll find out.

I've slowly come over to the view that it's a good thing Trump was restricting immigration of the best and brightest so they instead went elsewhere. As they say: Democracy is the belief that voters know what they want and deserve to get it good and hard. We've seen the humiliating climbdowns against China and if this policy of being unwelcoming to high end immigrants continue I suspect we'll see plenty of self-flagellation from the US 10 years down the line when it's trying to rebuild up its attractiveness for such people.

  • -27

The best and brightest aren't getting kicked out by a 100k charge. As lovers of subcontinental culture we should be thankful that the happy medium tier remains and is given opportunities to affect systemic reward. It would be a tragedy and an utter betrayal of one's fellow man to abscond to go play zero sum games in the West

A large portion of people get dissuaded from making significant purchases based on a single extra click being required (hence the huge amount of money platforms like Amazon pour into optimizing their process). This effect isn't particularly dependent on intelligence either, smart people also get put off by a significant degree due to needing one more click to buy a product.

Similarly even the fact that there's discussion of a 100k charge going around will be enough to dissuade some of the best and brightest on the margins, let alone actually implementing a policy like that.

Dissuade the best and brightest? Not the employers? It's not like the bestest and brightest are the ones paying directly.

I thihk the best pathway would be for the best and brightest to go back to places of origin and work super hard to develop their own competing paradigms. Every best and brightest who's working on product management or consulting or zero sum finance nonsense is somebody who could be making an active difference in the future. Sadly most lack the personal courage to build a future for themselves.

I thihk the best pathway would be for the best and brightest to go back to places of origin and work super hard to develop their own competing paradigms.

This is going to bite the US in the ass so hard in the next 15-20 years. It's already happening with China etc., see how good Kimi K2 Thinking is as well as GLM-4.6 etc.

  • -16

If the USA keeps importing the "best and the brightest" it will eventually turn into the country you are so desperate to run away from in order to get to the USA.

Or I am mistaking you for some other Indian commentator who constantly goes on about how they want to get to the USA for the big bucks and freedom of opportunity, are instead stuck in the UK which doesn't pay half as well, and there's a snowball in Hell's chance you'll go back to your native country because it's too poor and full of not-the-best-and-brightest?

You are, actually. Burdensome has a different pattern (and iirc is Pakistani, not Indian).

Ah, right. I knew someone was complaining about being Indian and not being let into the USA, but I didn't make any particular notes of user names.

Nah, I'm happy here in the UK, I'm in one of the few industries where the pay disparity between the US and UK is tolerable (plus the pay is high enough anyways). Since the Trump election (and even for a while before then) I've found the charms of Old Blighty (minus the people) growing on me.

Sure, sure, we'll totally regret it. Just stay out.

You and @HereAndGone both - stop taking personal shots at people however annoying you may find them.

China has the benefit of a capable, talented hardworking base with motivations beyond their own immediate paycheck. Unfortunately other potential players are needful of the same dedication and commitment.

The best and brightest aren't getting kicked out by a 100k charge.

Not per se, no. But it will reduce the relative attractiveness of the US as an immigration destination.

Also, the fee is only the tip of the iceberg. It is clear that the Trump administration -- and the people who voted for him -- really get off on kicking foreigners out of the country. Sure, he is unlikely to send random knowledge workers to some El Salvador megaprison without any due process, but most people would prefer not to go to countries which do not want them, all things being equal.

I think a lot depends on the specific migrant and their relative prospects in different places. There are very likely fields where someone who could become a world class researcher in the US can only hope for a meager career outside the states, and Trump can squeeze these people's balls as hard as he wants and all they will say is thank you. In other fields, things are different, and the impact of Trump plus visa costs are enough to make Cambridge more attractive than Harvard. The fact that the universities are generally on Trump's shit list will not help matters, here.

For companies, the calculation is rather similar. The answer to "do we open another research campus in the US or elsewhere?" might be different under Obama and Trump.

I suspect we'll see plenty of self-flagellation from the US 10 years down the line when it's trying to rebuild up its attractiveness for such people.

Taking what you've said at face value, possibly. If the US actually pursues going closed-borders-for-everyone, maybe it will be overtaken by China, given the slight national IQ advantage (I hedge my bets with the qualifiers because Europeans were the ones to conquer the world a few centuries ago, despite being lower IQ, so shrug)

Of course, you elide the obvious, though politically incorrect, question: What race are the immigrants? As I concede, it may be true that the US will need the best and brightest of foreign Aryans, East Asians and Jews (i.e. high-IQ races) to stay on top - but what of the best and the brightest of the Third World?

I think it is true that, for a sufficiently selective (and then properly enforced) immigration policy, we can have eugenic immigration from the Third World. But, due to HBD, the amount of additional value from Venkateshes and Bhargavas is going to be much less significant (because there are just not as many of them, and just less total human capital altogether to siphon)

On the other hand, once we hop over this fence, there is the constant danger of somehow (fraud, relaxing the bar for "skilled", etc) then allowing a less filtered, and hence dysgenic, influx. This leads to pretty serious harm - either these people assimilate (and hence lower the quality of the nation's gene pool) or you get a permanent racial underclass. In practice, this might lead to, say, your capital city becoming minority White, and the replacements actually being worse on average.

If we are looking at this purely from the perspective of national self-interest, I think this is overall a net negative. There is obviously a moral argument about helping unfortunate people who could thrive in a 1st world civilisation but were born into a low-IQ race, so it is worth the necessary overhead to carefully filter these people out and let them in (and of course, the more extreme one, which is to just let everyone in so everyone in for equality-of-opportunity reasons, and just accept the nation becoming Third World)

With the substance of my reply out of the way: why do you do this? As in, I know you are a high-IQ Third World immigrant, so I'm guessing you are not super thrilled about the recent vibe shift on immigrants: you personally haven't ever done anything bad, how unfair is it that some people implicitly blame you for (or at least associate you with) stuff like Rotherham, etc.

But you've had many conversations in the past with White identarians on this forum, so I'm pretty sure you are aware of this line of thinking, and then decide to constantly post as if you are some bluepilled liberal normie. I think it's bad form to psychologise your interlocutor, so I won't speculate why any further.

I will just ask - is there anything in what I've said that you actually factually disagree with? And I stress the word factually (since your claim that the US would fall behind and later on regret its current immigration policy is a statement about descriptive reality)

Do you not believe in HBD applied to racial groups? Do you dispute the Lynn IQ numbers as being roughly accurate? Do you dispute that IQ is a decent measure of a person's ability to function well in a society? Do you think that it doesn't make logical sense to make probabalistic judgements about groups of people on the basis of race given HBD? Do you think that the issues with Third World immigration that have occured in the past (e.g. Indians in Canada) are actually very easy to prevent if we just do X? etc

You know brahmins are a high IQ group, right?

Thank you for bringing them up! This seems to be a fairly esoteric HBD claim that is stated very matter-of-factly (iirc you said in the past that you think the Tamil Brahmins have IQ on par with the Ashkenazi) by various race realists from different backgrounds.

I don't think it's an obviously crazy assertion: there are Brahmin STEM nobels, fields medalists, and the Indian per capita income in the US is extremely high: 72k vs 36k for Whites (but as I long suspected, the household income chart showing them blowing everyone else out the water is misleading - they just live in bigger households - they come in 2nd to Taiwanese, also Jews aren't listed, I'm guessing they come 0th)

And the national IQ of India is 75IQ (according to the Lynn numbers), roughly on par with Sub Saharan Africa, and they have no STEM nobels, and I don't think there are any SSA diasporas in first world countries that exceed the White household income significantly.

So I believe it is justified to complicate our model from just a single 75IQ-centered bell curve to a mixture, at least a mixture for Brahmin vs. non-Brahmin. To explain a real and significant difference from a mean 75 population.

Now the question of whether the higher IQ of the Brahmins is actually "high" (75 is a very low bar to be high from!)

The obvious thing is to look stuff up online. There is some guy called Anatoly Karlin who talks a lot about it but doesn't give any numbers. All the actual analysis I can find goes back to this paper: Lynn, Cheng 2018 Mankind Quarterly

It is too late in the night for me to go through this paper properly... so I'll just take the abstract at face value. They claim that Brahmins are more intelligent, by 5IQ points, giving an IQ of 80, i.e. on par with North Africans and Arabs (and they do indeed manage to get STEM nobels, so this feels reasonable to me now)

But wait, there is a point you did not bring up in this comment, but you (and others) bring up elsewhere. What about Tamil Brahmins?

I cannot find any estimates on this online. I suggest a crude method of estimating it though: regress IQ from STEM nobels per capita.

Let's get the Lynn IQ numbers, and also STEM nobels- I define a "STEM" nobel to be Physics, Chemistry, or Physiology or Medicine (so exclude Peace, Literature and Economics) - I got these counts by scraping the wikipedia page for nobels by country. This isn't great, as it lists by nationality instead of race. But just doing a cursory reading I didn't find much sillyness (there's a "Belarusian" winner who is Jewish, and a few Chinese / North Africans for France, but not that much, anyways this is crude - I didn't bother correcting this stuff)

We get the following plot. To clarify: a lot of countries just don't have any STEM nobels (for IQ / low population reasons, those are the red "x"s on the left of the plot. As you can see, the 0s really do span the full IQ range (it's not just SSA countries with red xes), so I think it is reasonable to discard those data points and do a linear regression on the remaining countries-as-proxies-for-races (blue dots)

The red line is just the line of best fit (minimising least squares: beta = 7.47, intercept = 142)[*], so now we just need the STEM nobel per capita for TamBrahms. If we survey the wikipedia page again, I find 4 Indian STEM nobels:

  • Venkatraman Ramakrishnan (Tamil)

  • Subramanyan Chandrasekhar (Tamil)

  • Har Gobind Khorana (not Tamil)

  • C. V. Raman (Tamil)

So 3 TamBrahm STEM nobels[**], but what about the population? This sounds easy, but I literally cannot find it online. The only quantitative information given is in the Wikipedia article, in a subsection about a specific kind of Tamil Brahmin called Iyers (but there are only 2 apparently, so close enough):

They [Iyers] are concentrated mainly along the Cauvery Delta districts of Nagapattinam, Thanjavur, Tiruvarur and Tiruchirapalli where they form almost 10% of the total population. However the largest population reside in Nagercoil, making up to 13% of the city's population

So, if we just use these cities (and assume that is most of the TamBrahms in the world), we get: (102_905 + 58_301 + 916_857 + 289_916) * 0.1 130k population So as a lower bound, let's say 1e5 TamBrahms. And as an upper bound, let's say 1e7 (this is 10% the population of all of Tamil Nadu)

So using the population estimates, and then fitting using our model we get the following IQ estimates for Tamil Brahmins (depending on population size):

pop 1e5: 108 IQ

pop 1e6: 101 IQ

pop 1e7: 93 IQ

So, using this estimation technique, in the very best case, the Tamil Brahmins have an IQ of 108 (clipping the lower end of Ashkenazi IQ estimates: 107-115, and aligning with your claim elsewhere that they are on par with Jews), and in the worst case they are on par with trans-hajnals.

I'm pretty skeptical myself of what I've written, mainly because of how I discarded all the countries without STEM nobels. But I've been putting off researching this question for almost a year now, so for my own sake at least, I thought it was worth writing down my crude estimates and resaoning on the matter, as someone who has not done any serious reading/research in race science / genetics / etc - so I can test my possibly shady thinking on this (and "quantitative" HBD in general)

So now I ask you - what is your reason to think that (Tamil) Brahmins are high-IQ? (also I would like to ask @self_made_human and @2rafa, as they make this claim too) For Tamil Brahmins is it based on similar calculations as mine? And what about for generic Brahmins? (as I mentioned, online sources just give the generic Brahmin IQ as 80. My model gives a more favourable 88IQ, but even that is not very high)

[*] As a separate interesting point, and sanity check, if we do the regression of log10(stem nobels / capita) onto IQ, we get a beta of 0.048, i.e. increasing a population's IQ by 15 makes each person 5x more likely to be a STEM Nobel. Which sounds... reasonable?

[**] The fact that 75% of the Indian STEM Nobels went to TamBrahms was also why I originally decided to entertain the sub-stratification of Brahmins into Tamil Brahmins. Even at just n=4, this seems so significant, it is reasonable to me to look into this even smaller subpopulation without risking overfitting.

Great question and certainly an interesting topic.

So now I ask you - what is your reason to think that (Tamil) Brahmins are high-IQ? (also I would like to ask @self_made_human and @2rafa, as they make this claim too) For Tamil Brahmins is it based on similar calculations as mine?

At some point, you have to ask yourself why half the Indians you meet at the top of every high performing PMC job belong to a tiny minority that makes up 0.15% of the Indian population. Something similar happens when you realize that in many cases it feels like a majority of PMC Africans in the West in fields like medicine, finance, big law etc are Igbos (although the outperformance is less great; there are a lot of Igbos). In both cases there are partial emigration dynamics explanations - the socialist government of Tamil Nadu after independence forcibly acted against the dominance of the Tamil Brahmins, stripped them of their caste names, removed them from positions of power, and drove many into exile, and of course for the Igbos there was the whole Biafran War thing, but those explanations are insufficient. Plenty of other tribes, after all, have faced similar circumstances without that outcome.

You also become adept at recognizing Tamil Brahmins, even if they no longer have the Iyer/Iyengar names because of anti-casteism policies in their home state. I see them everywhere now, they are impressed when I recognize them, although they can instantly recognize each other.

Quantitative data is limited; it is sometimes forgotten that the only reason we have good data on Ashkenazi Jewish outperformance and various European groups in general is that they were present and recorded in the early 20th century at the height of the scientific study of group differences; Tamil Brahmins were not (certainly in large numbers). Data is more limited. Nobels tell part of the story but, like chess competitions, far from all of it. Performance can be depressed in various ways. Clearly today when international emigration is commonplace, Tamil Brahmins outperform almost all other ethnic groups per capita in terms of leading roles like making it to the top of US corporations, senior PMC jobs, especially when accounting for legacy effects (like a corporation run by a Jewish or white gentile guy appointing his son, nephew or whatever as his successor) that they don’t have access to.

Nepotism is a poor explainer; there are so few of them and North Indian Brahmins, who are far more numerous, often look down on them for being from South India, having darker skin (lighter than all other Tamils, but certainly darker than northern Indian Brahmins) etc.

And what about for generic Brahmins? (as I mentioned, online sources just give the generic Brahmin IQ as 80. My model gives a more favourable 88IQ, but even that is not very high)

Generic Brahmins are best seen as the hereditary ancient higher segment, but remember that there are almost a hundred million of them, in some places well over 20% of the population. The best analogue is to the aristocracy in somewhere like early modern Poland where 15% of the population were technically nobles. A tiny percentage of them were actual elites, lived in palaces, had hundreds of servants, owned lots of land. Most were essentially kulaks, smallholders, people who would be considered barely above (or indeed) peasants in more restrictive European estates systems. Most Brahmins in India are rural poor, the average urban middle class person of any caste is much richer.

If the US actually pursues going closed-borders-for-everyone, maybe it will be overtaken by China, given the slight national IQ advantage

China still has the strongest handicap that isn't genetic or physical. Communism.

I agree with HBD. That doesn't mean there are no 130+ IQ Africans that it's good for a country to bring in. Yes there's some reversion to the mean but that just means increasing the thresholds on what you admit people so that even their children are still significantly above the western average.

I do dispute the Lynn IQ numbers. They're really not accurate. Sasha Gusev had a pretty good writeup a while ago. But that's neither here nor there for my main argument.

I agree IQ is a very good measure of who you want vs don't want. I agree it's fine to make probabilistic judgments. What happened with Indians in Canada was Canada's own stupidity in importing low IQ Punjabi farmers by the boatload, which they are now paying for, it's got nothing to do with importing top tier human beings. The reason low tier people are imported is that there are lots of low tier jobs that must be done which top tier foreigners or low tier natives refuse to do at reasonable wages, it's a completely separate problem to that of high skill immigration. I'm perfectly in favour of a policy which puts the yoke back on the necks of low tier natives so that they do low tier jobs for proper pay (thereby removing the need for low tier immigrants, what I find galling about low tier natives is not tha they are low tier, but that they are low tier but pretend to be equal to their betters) but democracy means they have more votes than me...

Somehow the United States needs to keep importing “the best and brightest” forever, or we’ll lose. What happened to the best and brightest we already imported? Guess they weren’t the bestest and brightestest.

The one principle I'm learning from the neoliberals is that the importing of the best and brightest must never stop. Can't stop until the white supremacists on Twitter are, themselves, replaced by Indians.

or we’ll lose

Not in an absolute sense, no. Plenty of countries are very livable without immigration. But I do not think you will keep your role as tech leaders without immigration.

What happened to the best and brightest we already imported?

Regression to the mean.

I mean, to be fair, it did work with German scientists. Unfortunately, people die.

The real question is how much the current immigration system actually resembles that.

Has the Trump administration actually changed the way the O-1/EB-1A visas work?

This is like when Russia had Trump’s pee tapes. Or when Stormy Daniels had Trump’s blackmail. Or when the courts would finally prove Trump raped that woman in a shopping plaza thirty years ago and she forgot about it until just now.

There is no pedophile network running Washington DC, Donald Trump is neither a child rapist nor a sex trafficker, Trump’s connections to such are extremely thin and the emails being discussed don’t even show what people claim they do.

No one will remember this in a few years because the evidence is so embarrassing it expires and becomes unappetizing like refrigerated fast food. Cold French fries. Hopefully sooner.

While I get the impression you’d say this no matter what was in these files, even a stopped clock is right twice a day.

I don't think this is the right analogy here. I'm not sure if there's a comparable platitude, but the stopped clock one implies a 1% success rate that happened to get lucky, while I think this is more of a 99% success rate that we should expect to generally be right.

The vast majority of people are not child rapists or sex traffickers. Even if we restrict ourselves to wealthy powerful people, the vast majority of them are still not child rapists or sex traffickers. Even if we restrict ourselves to wealthy powerful people who are kind of sleazy like Trump, which probably have a much higher rate of child raping or sex trafficking, the rate is still much much much lower than 50%. The only reason Trump was ever suspected at all was because of wolf crying: his political opponents really really want it to be true, so they preemptively say it's true. That's not actual evidence, it should do nothing to shift our priors.

A broken un-watch that always tells you the time is NOT 6:30 is not very useful, but it's more truthful and less annoying than a broken watch always telling you the time is 6:30 and letting off a constant alarm that won't turn off.

Any wolf crying on the part of Trump's opponents is a relatively recent phenomenon. The narrative among the conspiracy-minded for the better part of the past five years was that the Biden Administration was concealing the Epstein Files to protect prominent Democrats, and that Trump would release them so these people could face the music. Or at the very least everyone would learn how depraved they all were. The only comments about this I ever heard from IRL friends on the left was that the logic behind this was ridiculous because Trump was close with Epstein and it would take a lot of faith to believe in the conspiracy yet not any involvement from Trump. And it wasn't a topic that came up that frequently. I didn't hear Democrats talking about this much at all until Trump went out of his way to say there was no conspiracy and prominent Republicans started echoing that sentiment. People like Charlie Kirk reversed course on the whole thing. Now my friends on the left started saying that they weren't suspicious before but were now because otherwise why would Trump be so adamant about keeping these confidential?

The Epstein-Trump stuff is recent, but I'm talking about more broadly. Trump has been accused of being a racist, nazi, rapist, pedo, Russian plant, etc, since he announced his candidacy for President in 2015. This is one more thing in an unending series of accusations that's been happening for a decade. If you had told me ten years ago that there would be a list of people who were somehow vaguely connected to a pedophile but the exact nature of these connections was ambiguous, and Trump might or might not be somewhere on that list, I would predict exactly this response from the left. Scott made a post in 2016 called You are still crying wolf.

I am admittedly more suspicious of Trump than I was before, because if he wasn't on the lists at all he would have pushed super hard to get them released. But "Trump friendly with Epstein in a way that looks bad but no real proof of wrongdoing because he didn't actually commit any crimes here" is exactly in line with my priors, and consistent with Trump being hesitant to release them but not freaking out or abusing his power to suppress them either.

Scott made a post in 2016 called You are still crying wolf.

You are Still Crying Wolf is specifically about claims that Trump is racist/white supremacist, and arguably about the even more specific claim that Trump is openly racist (which Scott correctly points out he isn't). The Rightful Caliph considered Trump utterly unsuitable for the position of Grand Vizier in almost every other respect on grounds of character.

Trump is certainly unsuited for Grand Vizier. The Grand Vizier is the one who stays in the background, whispering things into the sultan's ear and manipulating the visible actors from behind the scenes. Like all administrations, Trump's is full of aspirants to that position, but Trump never seems to listen to any of them for long.

I was referring to the Epstein stuff specifically and make no comment on anything else that may have happened. I've written about this extensively in the past; suffice it to say that I don't think there are going to be any bombshells, and I doubt that there are any "lists" at all. I don't like Trump but I'm more suspicious of him than I was previously for the simple reason that he leaned into this whole conspiracy until it was time to release the files. There's obviously something in there he'd rather not make public, or, alternatively, he hasn't seen the files and there's something in his past that he's worried may come up. I don't think it would be criminal. My first guess was going to be that he stayed in contact with Epstein well after any decent person would have cut ties, but the recent emails seem to undercut that theory; in the "dog that didn't bark" email he talks about Trump in a manner that suggests they aren't in regular contact.

The thing that's weird to me about the whole thing is that anyone who has studied this closely and isn't a total hack like Daryl Cooper would be of the opinion that it's highly unlikely that anyone other than Epstein and a few select people were involved in the wrongdoing. Nothing about Trump came up in the civil lawsuits, and the 2020 report about the original prosecution made it clear that no one in the Justice Department even knew that Epstein had famous friends until his attorneys told them. To be clear, the "Epstein Files" as it pertains to this case only involve the files from the Federal Investigation, and the only investigation that could have possibly revealed anything spicy would have been the 2019 investigation.

Any wolf crying on the part of Trump's opponents is a relatively recent phenomenon.

About him being a paedophile and child sex trafficker, maybe. They were crying wolf about his genocidal ambitions, alleged Hitler parallels, aspirations to transform the US into Gilead etc. throughout the 2016 election and the entirety of his first term.

No, "Trump went to Epstein's island" and "Trump was on Epstein's plane" and "Trump was in the files" have all been said before. As far as I know the latter two are technically true and the first is outright false.

Theyve been said before but theyre one of the few things still being said. Turns out "Trump is a racist nazi who wants to deport all brown people!" turns out to be the reason why he was voted in, so the attack angle must be retired. Maybe a few months later the progs will examine why that statement didn't work, but the priority is to find something that sticks.

For the 99%, the Stormy Daniels scandal puts him far, far closer to the ethics of someone who'd have sex with a minor. Now, not pre-pubescent, and not personally involved in trafficking or grooming, but a recipient willing to look the other way or even believe nothing (else) criminal preceded the encounter.

"Well, if you were as rich and connected as him, you'd try to bang a porn star too! All men think about it and want to go through with it but not all have the means."

I actually don't think that's true.

There is a sufficient sample size of well connected and extremely wealthy celebrities to say that most of them don't cheat on their pregnant wives with porn stars.

Given that the clock in question is 'unwarranted claims that this is the scandal that will sink Donald Trump,' is there a reason to believe the clock is stopped?

No, not that one. I was talking about the clock with 20 comments, literally all of which are praising Donald Trump.

This is my take as well. Every time I hear someone bring up Trump in reference to Epstein it just makes me roll my eyes and yawn. I want to say to them, “Yeah. Trump’s a pedophile and a pervert.” And then move on from that and watch the weather report.

Unless there’s truly something damning and huge in the files, the hype surrounding the matter and the “what’s to hide,” vibe people keep letting off has only reminded me that the average person loves a conspiracy and is duped pretty easily.

Its just oppositional. Bill Clinton got a sloppy from an intern while Kennedy was railing Monroe. Hillbots emails are a nonissue but got traction because everyone fucking hated her. Progs managed to hold their nose about Bidens only "flaw" which was the crime bill, and cons had to dredge up Hunter Biden level irrelevance to attack him.

Trump has been in public forever and has a whole suite of weird shit that is somehow teflon. All that weird Ivanka sex shit is fucking cringe but no one gives a fuck. Epstein is a last gasp for the moment, and when it turns out no one gives a shit about a glorified party host that brought in groupies for boring losers people will cast about for other shit. Music groups are full of teen and even preteen groupies and they still get defenders. No one really cares about the crime, only the one they want cast as a criminal.

I thought it was hilarious that Bidden couldn't stop himself sniffing and handling teenagers in front of dozens of cameras.

Its how pop-pop showed he loved me back in the day and Ol Joe gotta keep up the good old ways. Plus their hair smells of strawberry and its just so nice you know.

Well, Trump kinda promised he would release the Epstein files while campaigning, and I think someone in his administration claimed that she had the files on her desk after he took office.

So him going "nothing to see here" makes people wonder why he has changed his mind.

For the left, this is such a good dead horse to keep flogging because "elites are raping kids" is an evergreen hit with large parts of the MAGA base.

Personally, I do not think that the files contain video evidence of him raping some 13yo. If the Biden DoJ had this level of dirt on him, they would have leaked that.

Yes, I see "Epstein files" and my eyes immediately glaze over.

Who nowadays remembers the great scandal of 1977, "Koreagate"?? Took over all the front pages for weeks.

Hadn't heard of that one, but looking into it at least one member of congress served actual prison time over it, so that sounds like a big deal to me.

A lot of people haven't heard about the government (together with Quaker Oats) feeding radioactive oatmeal to retarded kids without their (nor their parents') knowledge for a science experiment but that doesn't make it any less bad.

I think it is very relevant even today that threats to withdraw US military forces abroad are met with bribery from foreign agents.

This is like when Russia had Trump’s pee tapes. Or when Stormy Daniels had Trump’s blackmail. Or when the courts would finally prove Trump raped that woman in a shopping plaza thirty years ago and she forgot about it until just now.

Yeah, these and the Epstein file situation feel/felt like seemingly never-ending anime filler episodes that eventually just get quietly dropped as possible plotlines.

An amusing recent example of trying to insinuate that Trump is some sort of sexual predator was the seethe over the Gatsby-themed party, which allegedly featured young attractive women dancing in skimpy outfits. Because among men above age 29, only pedophiles don't mind looking at women whose brains haven't fully developed yet (or have only finished developing for a few years). Plus, everyone knows that young women hate being sex objects and would never teehee around in skimpy outfits unless they were coerced, manipulated, or trafficked.

There was also the Motte-and-Bailey—at least in distributed form—in the bailey of seething at Trump having young attractive women dancing at the party, to the deeper bailey of seething at Trump having a lavish party while SNAP recipients supposedly starve, to the Motte of seething that the optics of Trump having a party while the government was shutdown would cause many to be upset. The Motte of which is a self-reinforcing claim.

Is this inevitable, the narcissism of small differences? Or is it just Trump not being a very principled man?

In part, it’s something like the narcissism of small differences, but more specifically it’s the nature of coalitions and the big-tent two party system.

When out of power (or at risk of losing power), the optimal move is to rally around a unifying platform or candidate who can both rally the base and bring in independent/non-aligned voters. Typically this involves sweeping major differences in ideology, policy, and values under the rug for the sake of winning the next election. Strange bedfellows and all that.

When in power, the optimal move is to fight and horse-trade for your niche, sectional interests, in the hopes that the aforementioned bedfellows just don’t care as much as you do, or are willing to compromise for something else in return.

The empire, long divided, must unite; long united, must divide. Thus it has ever been.

Also everyone has 2028 in the back of their mind, and the various sub-groups of the Trump coalition are starting to jockey for pole-position in the post-Trump vacuum. And given the possibility that the Democratic might actually just collapse (the recent races were promising for them but it’s no guarantee of survival), it makes seizing control of the GOP especially important.

I was recently watching a new TV miniseries, Death by Lighting it’s about President Garfield’s assassination. This was during the Reconstruction era when America was basically a one-party Republican state. One thing that struck me was how vicious the intra-party jockeying was back then in the absence of a robust opposing political party.

I don't know that this is a great analogue, but I'm reminded of around 2008-2012 when all the people with basic human decency - like me, at the time - were excited about the prospect of a permanent Democratic majority in the USA due to demographics and such. It's hard to parse out the causal factors, but one possible effect was that the most extreme factions saw this as an opportunity to push their ideology to the top, and one of the more extreme factions - what is generally known as CRT/identity politics/social justice/woke-ism/postmodern neo-Marxism/the ideology that shall refuse to be named/basic human decency - had positioned itself over the course of half a century to be in that sweet spot of being extreme enough to make partisans feel like they're righteous freedom fighters but not so extreme or personally costly as to turn them off.

I'm not alone as a Democrat who thinks this has been disastrous for the world, for America, for American society, and also for Democrats specifically. But there's potentially some good that did come out of it, such as catching predators like Cosby & Weinstein during the #METOO fervor of the late 2010s, or bodycams becoming far more common in police. Arguably, these would have happened anyway, but also arguably, this ideology helped make these happen more quickly, which matters. Which makes me think of what good could come out if, say, the Groypers were to prove to be the successful right-wing analog to the successful left-wing "woke-ism?" The first thought that comes to mind is widespread knowledge and acceptance of HBD could be a positive consequence, for helping us to build better policies, because a more accurate model of the world should allow us to better design policies for accomplishing the goals they are ostensibly meant to accomplish.

the prospect of a permanent Democratic majority in the USA due to demographics and such.

I think this was actually plausible, it’s just that Democratic strategists badly misread the thesis of The Emerging Democratic Majority and so they fumbled the ball. The thesis was that if Democrats could maintain the Obama coalition of minority voters and college educated suburban white voters and white working class voters, they would have an unassailable majority. The party seems to have misread this as “minority voters=win” and told the rest of that potential coalition to go to hell.

The party seems to have misread this as “minority voters=win” and told the rest of that potential coalition to go to hell.

I don't think that's quite what happened. The Democratic party as it exists today is essentially a high-low alliance between affluent (predominantly white) liberals and the (predominantly black) urban underclass. This transition started under Clinton and was cemented under Obama. The problem this coalition presents from the perspective of establishing a "permanent Democratic majority" is that the only things these two groups share culturally are an affinity for identity politics and an animosity towards members of the working class.

The under-employed college grad saddled with debt resents the high school grad who's making more money than they are managing a Gas Station. The urban underclass hates the manager of the gas station for chasing them off his corner, and being "pro-cop".

Keeping the working class inside the Democratic Party coalition was never a realistic ask, it just took half a generation for the new coalitions to shake themselves out.

Just pointing out, the stereotypical gas station owner is a minority immigrant who almost certainly votes D, and both Trump voters hate him(for not assimilating) and lower class minorities(for making them miss the white owner-men), but the hyper-educated parts of the democrat base do not hate the middleman minorities that own gas stations.

The stereotypical Gas Station owner is either a local, or they are a Christian refugee from someplace like Syria or Nigeria. In my experience the locals are too "pro cop" to vote D in a post BLM environment and I don't think those refugees are voting D either. I think that if the hyper-educated parts of the democrat base were to talk to them for more than thirty seconds and become aware of their opinions on things like Israel Vs Palestine (the problem with HAMAS is that the Jews haven't killed enough of them) or illegal immigration (I did it the right way why cant they?) they would learn to hate "the middleman minorities that own gas stations" very quickly.

Texiera (author of The Emerging Democratic Majority) and on a meta level Fukuyama assumed the Obama ascension was a teleological endpoint: the old order of stale white christians is over, we have in our unconstrained state decided that a young charismatic black man with 00s liberal sensibilities and economic acceptance of "help us to help you" support. These commentators failed to predict that the neoliberal equilibrium would be actively disrupted from within by insurgents looking to seize the spoils for themselves. Texiera was sounding the alarm by the end of Obamas second term about the social justice movement cannibalizing public patience, and now Texiera is considered a nazi by whatever progressive commentariat exists.

At the time the democratic supermajority was pronounced it wasn’t entirely unreasonable to somewhat nod your head and think the case they were making had a logic foundation to it. I remember sort of nodding my head slightly but still not abandoning the general pendulum effect politics has. I was never in doubt that their hubris was going to cause them to eventually eat shit after sniffing each other’s ass so much.

Two things the democrats missed. One was a fairly well known fact people didn’t attach significant weight to that they should have, namely that minority immigrants are some of the most staunch supports of pulling up the ladder after themselves once they’ve made it, and many of them are often highly racist against other demographic minorities or subcultures in their original country. These are not people who are going to be sympathetic to your liberal idealistic wishlist. On that point the ball is in the Republican’s court with their responsibility not to fumble the advantage they have.

The second point was the less well known but later empirically adduced Cultural Backlash thesis by Norris and Inglehart. The nativist reaction to systemic cultural, demographic and social changes greatly empowered a political hiccup like Trump to gather as much appeal as he did. A lot of people initially were in denial that this was ever a factor because they see America as a post-racial, post-identity country when it isn’t. We faire a lot better and are more progressive than Europe is historically, but just because these issues are taboo in society doesn’t make them go away in the minds of most people. You see it embodied in debates between people like Mearsheimer and Pinker. I think Mearsheimer is completely right and Pinker always struck me as the quintessential Shitlib Intellectual.

It's hard to parse out the causal factors, but one possible effect was that the most extreme factions saw this as an opportunity to push their ideology to the top

Isn't that effectively part of the game-theoretic stability of the two-party system? If you assume voters can be mapped to a normal distribution on a single axis (a poor model, but probably serviceable here) and have democratic selection within the parties, the left half of a left party claiming 60% of the total would get better representation for their views if they shifted the center of "left" towards their side, and dropped to 51% of the total but still winning the overall. The same applies in reverse for the right side.

I think you're right. Back then, I stupidly believed that the left, as the side that represents actually getting things correct rather than getting things according to our preferences, would properly moderate the ideology of the Democratic party, in order to actually get things correct (which necessarily means giving more leeway and charity to one's ideological opponents than to one's allies) and thus keep holding onto power. What I stupidly didn't notice was that the left half of the left half were actually at least as religiously and arbitrary-preference-motivated as the right half of the right half, and they had spent decades from well before my birth laying down the groundwork to manipulate people like me to believing that there was any there there. When you're naive and looking from the top, turtles all the way down can be confused for a really tall tower of turtles.

… the optimal move is to rally around a unifying platform or candidate who can both rally the base and bring in independent/non-aligned voters. Typically this involves sweeping major differences in ideology, policy, and values under the rug for the sake of winning the next election. Strange bedfellows and all that...

The unstated irony in all of this, funny enough, is when all the major parties talk of unity and coming together to defeat the other side, you’re still mandated to follow rank and file under their banner. “Everyone has to be united under my way of thinking. I’m not budging for anyone else!” Nick Fuentes can make the same argument. Is the Republican Party going to move in his direction? That was always the clearest admission to me of the gatekeeping of the party duopoly.

Yeah unfortunately this seems to be the case. The dynamics of the two party system are screwed. There are issues with other setups like Kingmakers, but still. I wish their stranglehold would drop...

”Is this inevitable”

Probably. Intra-coalition jockeying always peaks around this point in the election cycle. Remember all the Kyrsten Sinema hate back in the winter of 2021-2022?

Regarding this cycle specifically, the Republican coalition that won the election was pretty united that mass immigration is bad, but they weren’t in agreement on why it is bad. Some people think it’s bad because “we must secure the existence of our people and a future for white children.” Some people think it’s bad because it drives down wages. Some people think it’s bad because immigrants are poor and stupid. Some people just think it’s unfair that illegals get to jump the line literally and figuratively. All of these groups will be more or less sympathetic to different particular types of immigrants.

Why does it have to be "white children" and not "American children"? Why can't a man (or woman for that matter) want to secure both a future for their family and a living wage for their neighbor?

It's a reference. My list was of course not all-inclusive. I assure you however that there exist people who are okay with white immigrants and not okay with any other immigrants.

Why make that reference? Are you trying to imply that Trump voters are Nazis?

White nationalism is in fact getting more popular. It seems to be a very common replacement for religion among male exvangelicals, for example. Go ahead and insert the Douthat quote.

Go ahead and insert the Douthat quote.

Which quote would that be?

'If you don't like the religious right you'll hate the post-religious right' or something like that.

Thanks. A quick Google turns up the original phrasing, which searched in turn gives Douthat's original 2016 tweet:

A thought sent back in time to the theocracy panic of 2005: If you dislike the religious right, wait till you meet the post-religious right.

I don't think it's controversial to imply or state that some Trump voters are self-identified white nationalists. I don't think they represent a majority of people who voted for Trump, and would hazard a guess that there might be fewer than 1 million self-identified white nationalists in the entire US. But if I were to meet an American who described himself as a white nationalist, I would put money on him having voted for Trump over any competing candidate.

But if I were to meet an American who described himself as a white nationalist, I would put money on him having voted for Trump over any competing candidate.

You probably haven't listened to anyone over at therightstuff.biz, then. Several of them openly supported Biden over "Zion Don," and some of them even Kamala — because there's plenty of open "anti-Zionists" over on the Democrat side, while Trump is "practically one of the Tribe" since he "gave his daughter to one of (((them)))." That the "Russian Collusion" narrative about 2016 was right in every detail… except that it wasn't Moscow that meddled to install Trump and give him his weekly marching orders, it's Tel Aviv. That, contrary to what many on the right claim, Trump did accomplish in his first term everything the people who got him into the White House put him there to do: he moved the embassy to Jerusalem and gave tax cuts to Jewish billionaires.

I don't doubt that some self-identified white nationalists have voted for candidates other than Trump. But I think it's reasonable to assume the majority of such people have voted for Trump in every election they've been able to.

I would put money on him having voted for Trump over any competing candidate.

Maybe I am over-indexing based on X.com, but I would take the opposite bet. The impression I get is that the most strident racialists are also often the most anti-populist and anti-MAGA.

There are also interesting leaks from DropSiteNews who obtained Ehud Barak’s hacked emails. Epstein helped write Barak’s op-eds for war in the Middle East, aided Israel’s security deals in Mongolia / Russia / Africa, hosted an Israeli intelligence officer at his apartment for weeks… the notion that Epstein was an independent agent or a CIA affiliate is no longer tenable.

Nothing in this evidence contradicts my theory. Certainly nothing suggests that Epstein was plucked out of his high school teacher job (or perhaps placed in it, as the Barr theories suggest - even though they don’t even understand the forward passage of time) by Israeli intelligence in the mid-1970s and given a world-historical mission by the Mossad, which is what is widely alleged.

That Epstein befriended Barak in the 1990s and that his personal assistant (the “Israeli intelligence officer” in question, since most senior personal staff to Israeli leaders come through intelligence) enjoyed Epstein’s hospitality as his boss did were both widely known. I explicitly stated that Epstein had worked his way into powerful circles by the late 90s (his friendship with Prince Andrew only the most famous). He “brought some leaders together” (as I have said, much of this was braggadocio), opined on American and global politics and wrote articles for said powerful foreign friends (or had associates do so).

What would convince you that Epstein was Israeli intelligence? The emails show Epstein advising the former PM of Israel (& head of military intelligence) Barak on sensitive Israeli security matters and spy tech transfers. He ghostwrote Barak’s pro-Israel editorials. Barak’s intelligence officer assistant stayed with Epstein unaccompanied by Barak on multiple occasions. We have two confessions (Jane Doe #200, Hoffenberger) and one confirmation (Ben-Menashe told by Robert Maxwell). Two American former senior intelligence analysts believe Epstein was Mossad (John Schindler / John Kiriakou). He was funded and gifted by Wexner, receiving literally nothing for his funding, and Wexner ran a secret group of Jewish billionaires who funded Israeli and Jewish causes in America. His accomplice Ghislaine was the daughter of an Israeli “super spy”. The extent of surveillance in his residences makes no sense except for kompromat purposes. Israel has a history of rigging apartments for blackmail.

Surely the chance of Epstein having all these close relationships is statistically improbable. He just happened to be funded by Israel’s top billionaire, happened to be working with the daughter of a super spy, happened to be best friends with former intelligence leader of Israel, happened to also help him with sensitive security issues…

His accomplice Ghislaine was the daughter of an Israeli “super spy”.

She was the daughter of a man who facilitated arms deals from the Eastern Bloc to Israel early in its history and so was held in very high regard by the old cadres of the Mossad several decades later, sure.

What would convince you that Epstein was Israeli intelligence?

The Israel connections came through Wexner, whom he met in the late 1980s in Palm Beach. Israel didn’t need Epstein to build relationships with wealthy Zionist billionaires. He used Wexner’s network to meet other billionaires and because Wexner was/is a passionate zionist, others like the Mega group / Ron Lauder.

What would convince me? Very simple. A single shred of evidence that Epstein had even the faintest connection to Israel or Israeli intelligence before he became a close associate of Les Wexner. Given that, as I have documented extensively, Epstein’s self-professed connections to the world of Annan Khashoggi in the arms market in the early 1980s were largely or entirely fabricated (by himself), I think none exists.

A single shred of evidence that Epstein had even the faintest connection to Israel or Israeli intelligence before he became a close associate of Les Wexner.

What's the actual point of this argument? "Oh Epstein isn't Israeli Intelligence because he only became Israeli Intelligence later in life"?

It’s a widely made argument that Epstein was an intelligence agent from the start. If he was merely a rich guy with influential friends who occasionally brokered largely made-up intelligence for fun or minor favors as a side hobby in late middle age, then a substantial part of that argument collapses, he’s just another informant, not an agent. It also challenges another argument of the agent thesis, namely the mysterious source of his wealth (which, again, has been shown relatively conclusively was Wexner). This in turn ties into things like an alleged blackmail operation (targeting…already zionist billionaires) being largely about his personal fetishes, which he occasionally invited friends to participate in, rather than an intelligence-led scheme. So yeah I’d say it’s relevant.

Epstein met Wexner in 86-87, before he began trafficking girls (90s) and right before the scam with Hoffenberg (87). The chronology is in line with Wexner (Israeli intelligence via Wexner) facilitating Epstein’s activities in the 90s. Whatever Epstein was doing before then doesn’t mean much IMO, as his charisma alone would have made him a useful sayan. Was he loafing around and ingratiating with the elites? Useful. Was he already engaged in the underworld? Even more useful.

The claim that Robert Maxwell was a spy (or more accurately sayan) can be sourced from Ostrovsky’s Way of Deception:

Suddenly, the sinister nature of what was being done with Maxwell became clear to me. In his zeal to cooperate with Israel, and even though he was not an agent himself {as the British had made clear when I had spoken to them in Washington), Maxwell was a sayan on the grand scale. The Mossad was financing many of its operations in Europe from moneys stolen from the man's newspaper pension fund. They got their hands on the pension funds almost as soon as he'd made his purchases (initially with money lent to him by the Mossad and on expert advice he received from Mossad analyses). What was sinister about it, aside from the theft, was that anyone in his news organization, anywhere in the Middle East, was automatically suspected of working for Israel and was only one rumor away from the hangman's noose. I explained to my host, as I had to the British, that in the beginning the Mossad would help Maxwell purchase the newspapers by lending him money and causing labor disputes and other problems, making the target purchases more vulnerable. Later, the tactics changed; they would target in advance a paper that he was to purchase and start it on a collision course with bankruptcy using all available strategies, starting with workforce agitation and ending with pullback of funds from the paper through bankers and advertisers sympathetic to the Mossad. Then, once the target was softened, they'd send Maxwell in for the kill.

[…] The ties between Maxwell and the Mossad went back a long way. Elements within the Mossad had offered to finance Maxwell's first big business ventures, and in later years Maxwell received inside information on global matters from the Office. Maxwell was originally code-named "the Little Czech," and the sobriquet stuck. Only a handful of people in the Israeli intelligence community knew who the Little Czech was, yet he provided an unending supply of slush money for the organization whenever it ran low. For years, Maxwell would hit financial lows whenever the Mossad was in the midst of expensive operations that could not be funded legitimately and when other less legitimate sources were unavailable, as was the case after the American invasion of Panama in 1990, which dried up the Mossad's income from drug trafficking and forced Maxwell to dig deep into his corporate pockets

Wait, what? @Rafa, does this change your calculus about Epstein?

Not at all, in fact I discussed Epstein’s personal connection with Ehud Barak several times in my posts; they met in the 1990s as Epstein was rising in the world and as he was courting various world leaders. The “Israeli intelligence officer” was Barak’s personal assistant, who travelled with him. The op eds he wrote were for mainstream newspapers, it would make sense as a foreigner in the pre-chagpt era to get your rich, charismatic, native English speaking friend to write them instead of doing so yourself.

Interesting. Thanks for the reply.

I still suspect there was probably cooperation with the CIA, hence why they never did anything about this massive security breach.

I think it's partly inevitable when you've got a lame duck president, especially one 79 years old like Trump. He's not going to be on the ballot anymore, and his time in power is limited, so there's no reason any individual member of the party should look to him for leadership anymore. Trump is just focused on getting through the next 3 years, but a congressman or young activist still has decades of political career ahead of them.

The only reason I suppose someone would still look to Trump is only for picking up where he left off, and extricating whatever’s valuable from his political playbook from the standpoint of an outsider who bulldozed his way into the presidency.

Trump can still be a starmaker for three years, he can still endorse and attack, he can still appoint to sinecures and fundraise for. Any Republican would-be titan can be easily placed in a position of power by Trump, and that won't entirely evaporate upon his death, Sauron like.

Plus, somebody is going to get his dying endorsement, and that will count for something. I don't think enough that it can win anyone the presidency, but probably enough that it can keep any other Republican from winning it.

Plus, somebody is going to get his dying endorsement, and that will count for something. I don't think enough that it can win anyone the presidency, but probably enough that it can keep any other Republican from winning it.

Trump is sufficiently popular with the GOP base that anyone he endorses will sail to the nomination in 2028 (with the possible exception of family members). For there to be an effectively open primary, you need one of three things:

  • Trump loses his base by late 2027 - I think this is unlikely, even if he loses the rest of the country.
  • Trump is visibly too senile to govern but is retained in office Biden-style by his family and/or his core White House team - such that his endorsement is worthless but Vance can't run as an incumbent.
  • Trump can't make an endorsement because he is still acting like he is running for a third term (it doesn't matter whether he is serious or trolling).

In all three of these scenarios the 2028 election should be a walk for the Democrats, although the Democrats have got very good at blowing winnable elections lately.

I'm looking forwards to Harris losing to Vance or Abbott or Rubio because she deserves this.

I'm looking forwards to Harris losing to Vance or Abbott or Rubio

But how would she do against DeSantis?

I mean, it’s Harris. Probably not well.

Agreed, the Republicans I've seen who have political ambition either seem to be jockeying for Trump's favor or attempting to distinginguish themselves from him to try and steal the torch of party leader. Either way, Trump is still the locus of Republican energy and the lions share of political action these days seems to be done in reference to him, not just for its own sake.

This, combined with the ruckus over Trump arguing we need foreign talent, has caused a massive cratering amongst online confidence in MAGA.

You really see the craven lack of any consistent position across the congressional (and executive, but Trump’s loyalty to himself is widely known) GOP here. Weeks ago, MTG was arguing in her big Reason interview that actually deporting non-criminal illegal immigrants is a bad idea and implying, essentially, there should be some kind of pathway to citizenship. Today she’s criticizing the administration for being soft on immigration.

Miller opposes both illegal and legal immigration. But the reality is that deporting illegals (which can be done without congress) is higher priority than deporting H1B workers or ending legal work visa immigration, which requires congress to repeal laws it passed and where even minor measures like the $100k new application fee are likely to be successfully challenged. Importing an Indian elite, 150,000 people a year at a time, may be an issue in the medium to long term, and I find that argument persuasive, but on a fundamental priorities basis it’s low skill illegal immigration in the millions, primarily from Central America, that is far worse for the future of America when it comes to crime, schooling, welfare, tax receipts, public services and general civilizational quality.

But of course MTG (herself a construction business owner) and various other Republican congressmen work in states where red business interests rely on illegal labor, whereas H1B Indian immigration is a distant thing that’s easy to performatively oppose because it’s concentrated in a few coastal cities and the constituencies that like it are either WITCH outsourcing firms owned by non-Americans or big tech companies in California.

Trump’s loyalty to himself is widely known

I don’t know how there are people who aren’t loyal to themselves.

Absolute loyalty to your personal self interest over anyone else’s is widely considered a bad trait in politicians given that perceived personal self interest (especially financially but also in terms of influence, donations and so on) is rarely absolutely aligned with public support.

Personally I see it often as a good trait, because it is predictable and easy for the population to align it with their own interests. Trump is a self-interested narcissist who wants the adoration of the masses, and maybe be remembered as a "big important" president like Reagan? Then all he needs to do is do a good job according to half the population and everyone gets what they want. The ones that are harder are those with complex or unscrutable loyalties. The Bushes, Hillary, McCain, etc... People that you can suspect have a long list of favors to repay once and if they get the big job.

Apparently there will be a vote coming out to release even more, but the docs released so far have been negative for Trump's claims to be innocent of the whole matter.

Because the Democrats are releasing old nothingburgers with enough redacted to make them hard to identify, and people are falling for it.

My suspicions (which I'll admit are low-confidence and might be wrong) are that (1) there's a lot of smoke there, but not much fire regarding actual criminal acts on the part of major politicans, and (2) "the files" contain stuff that the government considers sensitive, but not necessarily in a way that is directly related to (1).

For (1), I'll observe that the previous blue administration previously held these files, and I doubt would have held off on either prosecuting (if sufficient evidence exists) or at least making it an embarrassing spectacle during the election (leaks or off-the-record comments). The only reason not to is if the evidence is particularly weak, or if the story implicates enough collateral damage to other Powers That Be --- the former seems more plausible to me. For (2), the entire investigation wasn't done anticipating direct public release, and it seems quite likely that some of the investigation would be politically damaging to reveal: someone here previously gave the example of "we were tapping Prince Andrew's phone even before we started the investigation", but generic "sources and methods" is probably correct in some sense. Also for (2), the side demanding the release of the files has shifted and (overall) stayed with the party opposite the executive.

Its probably something boring yet procedurally ruinous, like the party island being access capitalism at its finest and attendees not disclosing their presence. A guest list showing Pelosi at the same venue as Sheikh Iwantobuyalotofjets and CEO of myjetsareITARconstrained can be coincidence but its still fuel for congressional investigations.

It seems very unlikely to me that everything works in a sufficiently mechanistic or rules based way that 1) photos exist of Donnie snuggling a teenage girl, 2) they are in the possession of the federal government, run by Donnie for some time now and by his sworn enemies for years before that, 3) We've never seen them before, meaning that his sworn enemies were too principled to leak them, 4) they haven't been destroyed, meaning that Trump is either too principled to have them destroyed or in some kind of power struggle with someone within the federal government.

This all just seems to be way too much "playing by the rules" on all sides to be credible for me. The theoretical FBI agent who is too principled to leak it under Biden, and too principled to destroy it under Trump, while also being too powerful to be fired by either, doesn't strike me as a realistic character in our drama.

Apparently there will be a vote coming out to release even more, but the docs released so far have been negative for Trump's claims to be innocent of the whole matter.

So far I haven't seen anything that would prove this. They are however optically negative for Trump. The only thing I find interesting about them is "why now?". The democratic party was in charge for 4 years and they were trying to take down Trump all along, why not release them earlier? Why not release them in 2024 to improve the chances of victory of Kamala?

Releasing them now means they have the smallest effect they could have possibly had. Even waiting until 2028 would have had a greater effect.

The documents we are seeing now are in response to a subpoena to Epstein’s estate. As for DoJ/FBI my guess they couldn't reach “beyond a reasonable doubt” standart. So they don’t bring it and they don’t release investigation evidence.

My null hypothesis was that the people in charge of making that decision didn't really think Kamala would win, and decided holding one last ace up their sleeve in reserve was better than blowing everything they had on a losing battle, and being totally powerless once Trump inevitably took office.

The right wing is sailing through an interesting storm at the moment.

On one hand you have a very public clash between the donor class and the pundit class on the topic of Israel. Where the donor class seems to have lost control over a portion of the latter. How or why is not necessarily clear but it seems like the long awaited beacon of solace that can deliver the USA from ZOG is finally lit. It took a decade or so longer than the earliest prophets would have hoped, but the internet is finally facilitating a mainstream zionist critical stance through some of the biggest right wing pundits in cyberspace. Candace Owens, Tucker Carlson, and Nick Fuentes.

On the donor side, we still have Sean Hannity and Laura Ingraham on FOX standing strong in televised media. With Mark Levin allegedly making a case for himself on the radio waves. Along with Ben Shapiro's Daily Wire. But all of these voices are far less impressive when it comes to internet reach. Whilst Shapiro does have a strong base and a large Youtube channel, the internet presence of every mentioned donor class pundit, along with the entirety of Daily Wire, fits snugly within Candace's Owens reach alone when it comes to active internet views. Which would be inconsequential if not for the fact that the youth of the republican party is not listening to radio or watching TV. They are on the internet.

It's worth noting that there are large portions of the right wing media sphere that are completely divorced from this discourse. Choosing to simply sail past it. To that extent it might be a step to far to say the right coalition or media sphere is crumbling. But judging by how things are developing, the topic of Israel is fast becoming something to avoid. Why risk saying something wrong on such a polarized topic and risk the ire of the youth mob or the zionist mob? Just keep your head down and talk about the loony left or the government shutdown.

There are plenty of online right wingers with large followings who are doing just that. What will be interesting is to see how much cross contamination there is between those shows and the zionist critical ones. But to that extent, any expressed support for Israel is effectively a step towards a landmine that risks blowing the discourse up again. This puts neutral pundits in an awkward position. What good are they to the donor class if they can't voice support for their cause? But on the flipside, what good are they to the donor class if they fracture and lose their own audience?

I doubt we will see any resolution soon. Barring any major blunders from the zionist critical side, which is not that unlikely all things considered. But it's hard to imagine that this won't leave a lasting mark on right wing politics. There is an entire right wing generation on the way that simply doesn't fit within the traditional GOP mold. And it's the one demographic they would have dared to rely on. Whether that will have a transcendental effect, or if the future political landscape of the US will be too alien to have it make a difference...

American politics is so much fun. I have a hard time believing it's real.

biggest right wing pundits in cyberspace. Candace Owens, Tucker Carlson, and Nick Fuentes.

This seems very

  • You go to war with the army you have, not the army you might want

  • You can only play the cards in your hand

  • Piss with the cock you've got

November 2nd was Patrick Buchanan’s 87th birthday.

In defense of all who came after Buchanan, they are only where they are because of his failures.

https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2025/11/dungeons-and-dragons-elon-musk/684828/

In This Thread, 2D3D Wonders Why Race Concern Shit In Pop Culture Still Matters

So, Elon Musk apparently had a spergout over WOTC because WOTC apparently did a faerun land acknowledgment and apologized for racially essentializing... well, anything (or everything, I can't tell).

Per the article,

After a designer at Wizards said that the company’s priority now was responding to “progressives and underrepresented groups who justly took offense” at those stereotypes, and not to “the ire of the grognards”

And that made Musk tweet an implied consideration to buy out Hasbro, owner of WOTC. Perhaps he should keep away from napkins and lawyers for a few weeks, but WOTC staff and progressives have more to lose from a Musk takeover than Musks does if he accidentally commits to the sale.

My questiob is WHY do progressives still want to fight dead battlegrounds either lost permanently to the enemy or scorched to irrelevance.

I trust this forum understands the broad strokes enough to make a culture war summary unnecessary. Anything white nerds love must have more women and minorities and it must explicitly come at the expense of the white nerd favourites. Duke out details in the comments if necessary, the battle itself isn't the point.

The progressives won the previous round already. They got the victory lap of defeating racial essentialism by incorporating noble blacks, I mean orcs, in the rulebook a few years back. Vice, Kotaku, Polygon spammed articles about how this proves the rejection of white supremacy by the powers that be. Hooray for the Resistance, we are now the New Republic. Did I mix my factions? It doesn't matter, and apparently neither did the battle. Because WOTC still saw fit to dig up ancient corpses and put them on trial for heresy.

Except it is patently clear that the audience for this public shaming doesn't exist anymore. The volume of pop media culture wars has deflated in the face of victory, and perhaps Sydney Sweeney deadeyeing a millennial journo hoping for self abasement to atone for even being proximate to white advocacy is emblematic of how irrelevant this public opinion war is. You can, in fact, yeschad someone trying to make you feel guilty for not grovelling for zillenial approval.

But what exactly is the battlefield now? Racial/sexual/gender/whateverfuck representation? Moral ambiguity of 'bad' people unless the bad guy is generational trauma/white supremacy? Sinecures for adherents via "narrative consultancy"? Is the objective to win a battle or just to make noise.

Theres a destructive incentive structure here that I can't parse out fully. The unwoke are perfectly happy to sit back and be gradually edged out, as seen from the ready faggification of media starting with Will and Grace and reaching a high point (maybe) in Bridgerton where intraracial relationships are the enemy (maybe, I don't watch Shondaland slop). Or maybe the ongoing media projects where you can't have minorities be bad guys anymore - its always a white guy somewhere at the end pulling strings. Except if its Giancarlo Esposito.

Back to topic. The unwoke are silent dragged along consumers, the woke think they can accelerate the slide or celebrate the slide, suddenly reactionaries Notice and generate backlash, and the woke get smacked in. Retreating in confusion, they conclude that the issue is the message not being made clear enough, and the message is doubled down despite vocal opposition.

Rinse and repeat, but always back into defeat. Social justice went fucking nuts in 2016 because Trump descended from his golden staircase to snatch victory from Hilary Clintons anointed hands, and without the popular vote it seemed that this was merely a technical mistake, one that needed to be message disciplined to ensure the course of history is maintained. Biden won as a moderate but governed as a progressive because his brain turned to soup about a year in and the entire white house was Jill roleplaying Eleanor except without enough balls to lead a relatively competent cabinet, so the progressive staffers wrote every communique and channeled The Groups. Opposition was simply the last gasp of straight white men (and blacks and gays and women and asians and latinos and....)

Then Trump won, the illusion shattered for about a year. But now the same dead fights are being rehashed.

I don't really have a concrete point to interrogate in this culture war. My stance that any media featuring a minority front and center being likely to suck because it always means the writers room can't have room to criticize stupidity is enough for me to optimize my consumption because I'm an old moron and nostalgia for old shows from my youth gives me enough tinglies. Yet the strength of reactionary pushback to culture war attempts clearly shows that this is a conflict progressives seem intent on reigniting, and it should be clear that they not only lost the previous rounds but the upcoming battlefield is likely lost. The Dispatch sold a million copies and none of their characters were "body positive" in any way. Contrast that with Concord that literally was dead on arrival with their fat ugly minorities, making me wonder if the skirmishes being reignited are just masochists indulging in a public humiliation/victimization kink.

There's an interesting dynamic to this kind of thing in fantasy universes.

The original Star Trek was revolutionarily progressive in having a multiracial crew. There was a presumption of American leadership (Kirk), but it also featured a Japanese crewman twenty years after Hiroshima (Sulu), a Russian during the height of the Cold War (Chekov), and a black woman during the civil rights era. Trek unites all of humanity by creating an alternative "other," the Klingons. The displacement of the kinds of stereotypes that we used for the Other and the Enemy, the Russians/Japanese/Blacks, onto the Klingons inevitably leads those who feel othered to identify with the Klingons. So then we have to reform our views of the Klingons in TNG, and so we need the Borg to be the new absolute villain.

Same thing happened in WoW, the Orcs go from bad guys to misunderstood victims.

Speaking of Star Trek, I notice that in their future they've also cured humans of religion and homosexuality.

However, in the newer series they've reintroduced homosexuality. I wonder if we're just a few years away from the new first officer [1] of the Enterprise F showing off an ingenuous device that will let him know which way on the starship to face so he can pray towards Mecca.

  1. who takes orders from a badass girlboss captain of course

an ingenuous device that will let him know which way on the starship to face so he can pray towards Mecca.

I unironically like that idea, though? How to incorporate religion into sci-fi is always a neat thing when done well. I'd also like some discussion about communion wafers/wine made via the replicator device, and any potential implications of that.

Regarding Catholicism, at least, you could replicate wine and unconsecrated wafers (as long as the elements were in line with the rubrics). You can't take a consecrated host and replicate that as a communion host, though. You'd need to have a priest there to perform the consecration.

For the Protestant denominations where it is an ordinance not a sacrament, replicating wine and wafers would seem to be okay. Make that grape juice and wafers, I imagine, for those with the prohibition on alcohol. I can't see much difference between replicator communion kits and these (your choice of juice and cracker or wine and round wafer! now gluten-free!).

You'd need to have a priest there to perform the consecration.

Real life naval vessels have chaplains on board so this would not be a stretch.

Mass onboard ship has been discouraged in the past, although I'm not sure what the current rules are. In the middle ages there was a specific 'missa sica' performed onboard ship with no consecration of the host.

Aircraft carriers usually have regular Catholic mass, I don’t know about ships with smaller crews.

And would it be okay to name a starship the USS Corpus Christi?

Heh.

Only if it's named after the city, I guess!

It's a good sci-fi idea in general. It would be a great fit in, say, Babylon 5. But I take the point to be that it's iffy at best whether it fits the Star Trek universe as established in the first few series and first ten or so movies.

It's true that it'd fit the B5 setting, but I wouldn't have trusted the writers to do it well. Most of their handling of religion gave the impression of a good-faith attempt by people who have never met anyone that actually believes his religion in real life.

It did work well for the Centauri, though, given their sincere but not earnest regard for tradition.

Early scifi dealt with it a lot; I'm thinking Arthur Clarke (The Star, the Nine Billion Names of God for a more comedic take that would be up the alley of our Caliph) or even Asimov with The Last Question. It probably only really stopped being a thing once scifi became a mass-market endeavour.

Yes. Whether or not I find this stuff to be stupid cope IRL (I did amuse myself watching Muslims trying to figure out how to fast in northern regions with very short spells of sunlight) it can actually add a bit of reality to the character and world.

Utopian scifi needs to get over its religious hangup.

in the newer series they've reintroduced homosexuality

What do you consider new Trek?

The Outcast with an "ambiguous" kiss, Rejoined with a "symbiote confusion" lesbian kiss, and The Emperor's New Cloak with a "dark mirror universe" lesbian kiss are all prime time line. More than, about, and just less than 30 years ago respectively at this point.

I haven't seen, and do not consider to be head cannon, anything after Voyager. I suppose the more recent series have explicit homosexual characters, where it's a recurring part of their character rather than incidental to an episode theme?

In TNG era they were relatively slow with their introduction, with only moderate controversy following each showing. It probably doesn't hurt that Terry Farrell as Jadzia Dax is pretty easy on the eyes.

There is a difference between the occasional queer-coded alien and just outright portraying homosexuality as if it were normal. Not a huge difference (it's pretty clear the TNG actors wanted to push the gay agenda and had to be reined in by the producers), but still a difference. It's the next step in promoting deviancy.

I'd be pretty comfortable letting kids watch TOS-era Star Trek, somewhat comfortable with letting them watch TNG-era Trek, and very uncomfortable letting them watch NuTrek.

Enterprise tried to be The Smexy and just ended up embarrassing everyone.

At the end of season 1 of Picard they have 7 of 9 getting romantic with that alcoholic woman. For example.

Though you draw the line at Voyager, so that's that.

Oh, I didn't go next, nigh or near any Trek once Disco hit the screens. I stayed well away from Picard (once bitten, twice shy) and by all accounts that was the best decision, though even there apparently they had to go back to classic Trek roots for the ending?

Snakeroot addict ex-officer Raffi livin' in poverty in the desert because the system and The Man done her dirty and down - ugh. Yeah, drop that anvil on our heads several times so we get the point about WOMEN, MINORITIES, SYSTEMIC RACISM, WHITE MALE PRIVILEGE, why don't you?

That's not Trek, not TOS Trek and if it's gone downhill to that degree by Picard's time then we really are in the Reboot timeline and not Prime.

There was also that terrible episode with Riker and the non-binary alien, which was supposed to be an After-School Lesson about gayness and tolerance, but which could also be applied to transness if one wanted.

It was done so badly, though. Riker of all people?

The better one was with Dr. Crusher and the Trill character where Crusher is in a relationship with a male Trill, he dies, the symbiont has to be placed in a new host, and that one turns out to be female. The symbiont/new host is willing to keep the relationship going, but Crusher eventually turns it down.

So far as I remember, the reasoning behind all the gay relationships being lesbian is because they could get lesbian kisses past the censors, but no way (at the time) would two guys in any kind of explicit relationship be acceptable.

I suppose the more recent series have explicit homosexual characters, where it's a recurring part of their character rather than incidental to an episode theme?

Oh, God. Disco Trek. There was a gay couple there, which in itself wasn't the worst thing. The worst thing is that one of the couple was the crazy mushroom-obsessed engineer, and once they introduced the spore drive (don't ask) I couldn't watch any of this show for the amount of wincing I was doing.

Mind you, if we are talking about Trek and homosexuality, this is the fandom that invented (or at least popularised) slash 😁

I've never watched TOS, but based on the fanfiction I've read it has to have been among the most pro-gay shows ever made.

...why would you read fanfic of a show you have never watched?

TVtropes highlighting particularly egregious examples.

Because it was recommended on /r/rational or TVTropes, in my case. Also because Naruto moves at a glacial pace and fanfiction does not.

who takes orders from a badass girlboss captain of course

Trek had that during the good years, Voyager remains my personal favorite in the series as it is the one I grew up with.

Janeway isn't a girlboss. She's just a boss and a stone cold bitch and I love her.

Star Trek (in the more modern incarnations) tried to be "spiritual not religious". The Bajorans got to be religious, but there was always the clash (once made explicit) about "yeah we know the Prophets are in fact Sufficiently Advanced Aliens".

Chatokay, God help that character, got stuck between "I want to practice my native heritage traditions but I can't believe in them as religious because my mother knocked all that nonsense out of me" so we got the worst of both worlds there: using the trappings of (all chucked in a blender) indigenous traditions from North and South America which came off looking a bit patronising at best, but no actual "why yes I do in fact believe in the spirits" because this is the future and science rules.

To be fair, TOS Trek includes some pretty clear allegory where conflicts with the Klingons and Romulans (one episode of basically submarine warfare) are also themselves allegorical for the Cold War. The movie Star Trek VI is pretty interesting to watch because it's loosely portraying the end of the Cold War that had just happened (complete with a coup attempt, but no *Swan Lake).

But the recycling of villains into friends did occur multiple times (see also the Ferenghi) and you have a pretty reasonable take on how that was done more broadly.

But the recycling of villains into friends did occur multiple times (see also the Ferenghi) and you have a pretty reasonable take on how that was done more broadly.

The implication here being that Ferengi were modeled after Jews and they work in industries of vice? Bad joke/observation aside, the culture that early Trek embodied was if you want to call it the right kind of progressivism at least for the day, if not in an objective sense. I don’t think anyone here would disagree with that.

The implication here being that Ferengi were modeled after Jews and they work in industries of vice?

They were explicitly compared to "Yankee traders" at their introduction, so wrong minority group offended, I guess?

Right, the Ferengi were supposed to be Americans. (Presumably Outgroup-Americans, but Americans nevertheless)

At least in TOS, I think the intended comparison is between the Vulcans and Jews. The Vulcan hand sign is also used in Judaism.

I see what is happening to D&D more like a Geek, MOP, sociopath thing than a CW battleground.

There is a reason why the birth of D&D 4 -- where WotC started to streamline things to make the game more newcomer-friendly -- drove fans to the fork of 3.5 called Pathfinder.

My exposure to D&D started with the Bioware game Neverwinter Nights (which was particularly notable for its easy to use level editor, which lead to thousands of authors creating adventures for it), so D&D 3 always seemed normal to me.

I later played the Baldur's Gate games which ran on 2nd edition, THAC0 and all.

--

Recently I have played BG3, and while I found a lot to like, I mostly hated what I saw of the underlying game mechanics. I get getting rid of skills -- characters mostly maxxed out a few skills in any case, but the changes to spellcasting felt deeply offensive.

Like, traditionally wizards and sorcerers would both have spell slots for different spell levels. However wizards had to assign spells to slots during rest at night, while sorcerers could just decide which spell of their (smaller) repertoire to cast. This created meaningful mechanical differences -- a wizard who had prepared for a specific encounter was more dangerous than a sorcerer who was in turn more dangerous than a wizard who had prepared for a very different task.

With D&D 5, there is no need to assign spells to slots any more. Instead, you have to decide which spells you want to be able to cast after rest, and are limited to a frankly ridiculously low number, I think on the order of a dozen or so in the BG3 endgame, where in 3.5 you could go into combat with six different L1 spells, six different L2 spells et cetera. (Of course, the level capping at 12 instead of the more traditional level 20 does not help either. What good is a necromancer who can not cast finger of death? Not that a FoD whose best outcome is mere damage is much fun, either.)

--

On the CW side, D&D races have always been more than halfway towards species, really. Sure, you have (fertile) half-elves and half-orcs, so a full speciation between these groups has technically not happened. (I do not consider thieflings to be evidence that devils and demons share the same species as humans any more than I consider Jesus or Greek heros to be evidence of God or Zeus sharing a species with humans, in either case it seems like magic is involved in the conception.)

Still, the D&D 'races' are clearly much further apart than most populations of homo sapiens sapiens are. And they used to get their mechanical differences, which ties the fluff around them to the game mechanics. Yes, that means that no halfling is ever going to be the realm's best melee fighter. That is life. They are 3 feet tall and weigh 20kg or so. Last time I checked, no elementary schoolers were beating up grown men at MMA either.

It seems pretty obvious to me that racial and sex-based bonuses exist in the real world. If a kid wants to become the worlds best long distance runner, but is a girl of European origin, then I am sorry to say that it seems very unlikely that she will ever beat the best male long distance runner from Kenya.

Of course, sex-based bonuses, while clearly present at least for physical (and social!) attributes in the real world, are totally absent in D&D. Women melee fighters are just as viable as men, and most non-evil societies are shockingly egalitarian compared to a medieval baseline. And as far as racial bonuses are concerned, the almost exponential scaling of power with the character level means that a STR-based halfling fighter will still be slaughtering creatures twice her size by the dozen eventually. So in a sense, the game mechanics of D&D were more woke and blank-slatist than reality for a long time.

--

The lack of alignment also strikes me as silly, it was always a defining characteristic of D&D. Sure, I can see how the Always Chaotic Evil trope might be Problematic, but this can be fixed without getting rid of the E-word altogether. Just say that most goblins follow evil goblin gods, problem solved. And of course, the cosmology of D&D has not suddenly changed merely because alignment is not a stat any more, it is pretty clear that the followers of Baal or Shar are evil even if you do not spell it out.

I also do not think that the alignment system lead to an overall reductionist morality, you could still have plenty of shades of grey. Or even two lawful good characters going to war with each other if loyalties and circumstances conspire to pit them against each other.

--

Personally, I think what killed D&D was WotC dumbing it down to increase mass appeal, not SJ. My understanding is that most fans of the earlier editions got off the bandwagon when 4e arrived. If among the myriad ways WotC are pimping out the rotting corpse of D&D is also apologizing for Gygax having done a racism somewhere, I can not say that I find that uniquely upsetting.

With D&D 5, there is no need to assign spells to slots any more. Instead, you have to decide which spells you want to be able to cast after rest, and are limited to a frankly ridiculously low number, I think on the order of a dozen or so in the BG3 endgame

It's based on level + int modifier, so yeah a dozen or so is about right. That said, the 5e magic changes are on the whole a breath of fresh air. Vancian magic in prior editions (my experience is with 3e, which itself was a softening of the system by including 0-level spells) is a terrible, actively un-fun system. It sucks ass to find yourself in a situation where it sure would be nice to cast (insert spell here), but you only prepared one copy and you already cast it so you're SOL.

The magic system envisioned by Jack Vance, where wizards cast world shattering spells that are so complex that you have to lay them down in your mind in advance, is very cool for a novel. It is not at all pleasant as a game mechanic, however. There are a lot of changes 5e made which are questionable but I disagree that this was one.

5e's equivalent problem is only having space on your preparation list for a very short list of spells. It also sucks to take Fireball and find out that you actually needed Lightning Bolt or something situational like Feather Fall.

I preferred the 3.5e system because in this situation it means I still got to use that ideal spell once, and the larger quantity of memorized spells gave more space to take something experimental or niche without leaving a massive gap in my spell list.

I suppose that's true to some extent. But I can't say I ever felt limited by it, 15 spells (assuming max int at level 10) is enough that you can have a pretty decent distribution of utility spells along with a couple of workhorses. YMMV of course, it depends greatly on the individual player and the game you're in.

I decided to try Sorcerer in 5e so it's possible some of the problem came from having to make changing my spell list a multi-session affair. I think they've since made the UA which let you change spells without levelling up official which is a positive change.

However, I did feel like 5e gave a much greater pressure to have something optimal if you want to to properly contribute to a fight. Preparing multiple options to diversify across different saves, different damage types, and single-target vs multi-target ate up that list quickly.

From what I remember of 5e, I think the "ritual" tag was supposed to handle a lot of the situational utility stuff.

Edit: I also prefer the 3.5e system, because I like my wizards strong and versatile. Pathfinder tried to balance them a bit by making the spells weaker (I think), but overall Pathfinder wizards are still acceptable to me (even if I don't care for the default Pathfinder setting all that much).

Spontaneous spell casting is more convenient and fun than prepared spell casting for most players, I believe. It's also more powerful, so it's not surprising that the game designers try to balance it in various ways. Originally with the Sorcerer, that was with fewer spells known. Pathfinder has an Arcanist class that instead tries to balance it with fewer spell casts. 5e's Wizard class tries to keep both the large number of known spells and the number of spells cast, instead reducing the number of spells prepared (and giving metamagic to Sorcerers).

Honestly, I think the concentration mechanic and spell nerfs that 5e did are the bigger sticking point for me.

Honestly, I think the concentration mechanic and spell nerfs that 5e did are the bigger sticking point for me.

They probably had more impact on my enjoyment when actually playing, but I have some sympathy for these two changes because they did at least partially solve issues that were widely complained about in 3.5e.

Spellcasters ignoring the recommended adventuring day to dump everything immediately made fighters feel irrelevant, which is less of a problem now that the spells are weaker. I also don't think anyone liked the pre-fight buff dance that happened whenever a party got to surprise their foes, which has been killed off entirely by concentration.

I disagree but I can see someone liking those changes enough to outweigh having less interesting and impactful spells.

On the other hand, the loss of proper prepared spellcasting feels like almost entirely downside since we went from having a choice between wizard and sorcerer to two flavors of sorcerer.

From what I remember of 5e, I think the "ritual" tag was supposed to handle a lot of the situational utility stuff.

I think they might have initially intended this, but most of the best utility spells got left off the ritual list. That was a good decision. Characters being able to cast Detect Magic and Leomund's Tiny Hut effectively at-will was enough of a problem. The idea of dealing with characters who get to cast Fly, Fabricate, or Clairvoyance any time you let them sit still for half an hour should fill any DM with dread.

Rituals were a mistake and if WotC ever gets tired of making slight iterations on 5e I hope the next edition removes or reworks them. At least make them limited by something other than just time!

Vancian magic in prior editions (my experience is with 3e, which itself was a softening of the system by including 0-level spells) is a terrible, actively un-fun system. It sucks ass to find yourself in a situation where it sure would be nice to cast (insert spell here), but you only prepared one copy and you already cast it so you're SOL.

But 3e/3.5e also had more robust magic item buying/crafting rules, so it was easy to spend a little extra money to have your highly situational spells as scrolls or wands for when you need them, so you could reserve your spell slots for your more generally useful spells.

True. Though in fairness, you can craft scrolls in 5e just fine so the same would really apply to that (albeit the DMG gives almost zero guidance to the DM on how to implement magical item crafting, just hand waves a few broad guidelines). And in BG3 specifically you have scrolls coming out of your ears.

Okay, I should add that I have mostly encountered D&D in single-player computer RPGs. There, the impact is much lessened. First, most of the focus is on combat even more than with pen and paper D&D. Either you win an encounter, in which case the fact that you were unable to cast the ideal spell for the situation is moot, or you get a TPK, so you reload and prepare differently. Outside combat, you are not on a timer and can rest whenever you like. Where a barbarian player would certainly have their character complain about having another rest despite the party being in good shape simply so that a spellcaster can prepare a utility spell, and a DM would be quick to point out the side effects of wasting another day, NPC party members typically are much more accommodating.

I see what is happening to D&D more like a Geek, MOP, sociopath thing than a CW battleground.

Geek, MOP, sociopath IS Culture War. It is describing how the Culture War battle is lost by the geeks by the entryist sociopaths.

I will grant you that it is a culture war, or even more accurately, a common trope encountered both in isolation and in the context of larger culture wars. Once the sociopaths are in charge, they will be willing to open the gates for whatever side of the larger CW going on at the moment is beneficial to their goals, with little concern about the ideological compatibility with the movement they just took over.

There have been multiple large culture wars in history, but the one which is roughly SJ vs MAGA is the one which I would identify as The Culture War in the context of this thread.

My point was that WotC is better seen as a sociopath org than as a SJ org. Sure, they will happily crave to the demands of the SJ crowd if they see it as advantageous to do so, but if for some reason Trump expended enough political capital to influence D&D, they would be equally willing to write how hobgoblins are strong, smart, handsome, modest, and peace-making, but unfortunately slandered by the jealous tree-hugging elves all the time.

But Trump wouldn't expend political capital to influence D&D. He doesn't give a shit. If you tried to make him notice, he'd probably call it a kid's game and insult the users or something. Same goes for D&Ds more traditional enemies, the religious who call it Satanic. They didn't want to take over D&D, they wanted to ban it. In a different world, perhaps Geek, MOP, sociopath could describe something other than part of the larger Culture War, but in the real world the entryist sociopaths ARE SJW/woke.

There is a reason why the birth of D&D 4 -- where WotC started to streamline things to make the game more newcomer-friendly -- drove fans to the fork of 3.5 called Pathfinder.

I'm not sure I would describe 4e's sin as being "streamlining" or "being too beginner friendly." They made the decision to use grids instead of feet, but the earliest editions used table inches. They replaced 3e's point-based skill system with a simple yes/no, but most TSR editions didn't have a general skill system by default. They threw the lore in a blender, but by the end of 4e's life the World Axis lore had basically everything from the Great Wheel, and it almost ends up being a change of emphasis and presentation more than an actual, substantial change to things.

Heck, it's a bit silly to say that 4e was the start of D&D trying to make itself newcomer friendly, when there is an entire line of Basic D&D under TSR (BX, BECMI and the Rules Cyclopedia) that all manage to be pretty easy to play and run, and are still playable to this day.

It seems pretty obvious to me that racial and sex-based bonuses exist in the real world. If a kid wants to become the worlds best long distance runner, but is a girl of European origin, then I am sorry to say that it seems very unlikely that she will ever beat the best male long distance runner from Kenya.

Of course, sex-based bonuses, while clearly present at least for physical (and social!) attributes in the real world, are totally absent in D&D. Women melee fighters are just as viable as men, and most non-evil societies are shockingly egalitarian compared to a medieval baseline. And as far as racial bonuses are concerned, the almost exponential scaling of power with the character level means that a STR-based halfling fighter will still be slaughtering creatures twice her size by the dozen eventually. So in a sense, the game mechanics of D&D were more woke and blank-slatist than reality for a long time.

I agree with you to an extent, but 1e did allow for superhuman stats for humans: 18/100 for males and 18/50 for females. A cap reminiscent of Hercules vs. Xena levels of strength.

However, my feeling is if you're going to allow for larger than life heroes with more strength than is actually humanly possible, who cares about maintaining strength differences between sexes? I'm genuinely fine with either option - either different superhuman caps for men and women, or superheroic men and women being potential equals - but I have a slight preference for the latter, since we're not even talking about real biology anymore anyways.

Heck, even Greco-Roman mythology had Camilla and the Amazons as examples of warrior women with immense strength, so it is hardly "woke" to allow for them in fantasy.

The lack of alignment also strikes me as silly, it was always a defining characteristic of D&D. Sure, I can see how the Always Chaotic Evil trope might be Problematic, but this can be fixed without getting rid of the E-word altogether. Just say that most goblins follow evil goblin gods, problem solved. And of course, the cosmology of D&D has not suddenly changed merely because alignment is not a stat any more, it is pretty clear that the followers of Baal or Shar are evil even if you do not spell it out.

I also do not think that the alignment system lead to an overall reductionist morality, you could still have plenty of shades of grey. Or even two lawful good characters going to war with each other if loyalties and circumstances conspire to pit them against each other.

The weird thing is, they haven't even gotten rid of alignment. Flip through the 5.5e Monster Manual, and you'll see that every monster statted there has an alignment. 5e and 5.5e just de-emphasized alignment (most spells and effects like "Detect Good and Evil" interact with creature types like Celestial or Fiend instead of Alignment itself), and presented things slightly differently. (Like, the 5.5e Monster Manual says up front that all of its alignments are suggestions, and you as DM can change them if you want, but has that ever not been the case? Even if, say, 1e doesn't give you explicit permission, what DM is so devoid of creativity that they couldn't conceive of the idea of a fallen Astral Deva/Angel?)

The big change is in how they emphasize and present humanoid creatures. The 5.5e Monster Manual basically defaults to making the DM do homework and apply racial traits to the NPC stat blocks for all of the humanoid races (including orcs and drow), and shunts a lot of creatures that were historically humanoids into other categories (like goblins becoming fey, and lizardfolk becoming elementals.) I don't like most of 5.5e's changes, and have continued to run 5e with my local group (with a healthy dose of OSR philosophy and sensibilities because I love that playstyle) but it is simply false to say D&D got rid of alignment.

The weird thing is, they haven't even gotten rid of alignment.

I misspoke. What I meant was to say they got rid of alignment for player characters, at least if BG3 is any indication. In 3e, every character, including mortals, had an alignment which was tracked and could be detected. A decent fraction of classes (paladins, clerics, druids, probably more) had alignment restrictions, so there was a mechanical effect even in computer rpgs. (Naturally, with tabletop gaming, a DM is much likelier to intervene if a divine spellcaster strays to far from the purpose of their god, and they can do that in any edition.)

If doesn't surprise me they got rid of alignment in BG3.

5e still has alignment for player characters, but it doesn't really do anything mechanically. The one effect I can think of off the top of my head that cares about PC alignment is rakshasas still being vulnerable to piercing damage wielded by good creatures.

I see what is happening to D&D more like a Geek, MOP, sociopath thing than a CW battleground.

There is a reason why the birth of D&D 4 -- where WotC started to streamline things to make the game more newcomer-friendly -- drove fans to the fork of 3.5 called Pathfinder.

Paizo has, among other things, removed slavery from the Pathfinder campaign setting because some SJWs found it offensive (see the edit at the bottom with Paizo's response). In case anyone was wondering why the rulers of Cheliax who worship Asmodeus (the ruler of Hell with Tyranny as one of his divine domains) have canonically abolished slavery. Whatever else is happening, culture war is as well, and not just as a cover for other motives.

On the CW side, D&D races have always been more than halfway towards species, really. Sure, you have (fertile) half-elves and half-orcs, so a full speciation between these groups has technically not happened. (I do not consider thieflings to be evidence that devils and demons share the same species as humans any more than I consider Jesus or Greek heros to be evidence of God or Zeus sharing a species with humans, in either case it seems like magic is involved in the conception.)

I think this is the wrong way to think about it. "Race" as a term for a group with a shared ancestry predates and has a broader definition than modern biological classifications. D&D used the term race and not "species" because Tolkien and other fantasy authors did, and the reason why they used it is due to writing settings that are descended from premodern myths/fairy-tales and that are meant to evoke a premodern sense of the world. Heck, in 3.x (the edition I'm most familiar with) the apes in the Monster Manual literally have claws, I'm guessing because someone made a deliberate decision to not base them on real-life apes but instead inaccurate medieval bestiaries. So there's no reason to assume D&D crossbreeding follows the rules of modern biology in the first place.

Always Chaotic Evil trope

One annoying thing about discussions of D&D racial alignments is how rarely they engage with the actual text. "Always [alignment]" was of course invented by 3rd edition and used for outsiders like demons, some undead like ghouls, and a handful of other creatures like dragons and mind-flayers. Orcs by contrast are "Often chaotic evil". Those terms were defined thusly in the Monster Manual glossary:

Always: The creature is born with the indicated alignment. The creature may have a hereditary predisposition to the alignment or come from a plane that predetermines it. It is possible or individuals to change alignment, but such individuals are either unique or rare exceptions.

Usually: The majority (more than 50%) of these creatures have the given alignment. This may be due to strong cultural influences, or it may be a legacy of the creatures' origin. For example, most elves inherited their chaotic good alignment from their creator, the deity Corellon Larethian.

Often: The creature tends towards the given alignment, either by nature or nurture, but not strongly. A plurality (40-50%) of individuals have the given alignment, but exceptions are common.

If they actually engaged with it I wonder if a lot of SJWs would actually find this more objectionable. "Skewed distributions of traits, not absolute rules" are, after all, the sorts of differences based on race or sex that people tend to believe exist in real life.

Paizo has, among other things, removed slavery from the Pathfinder campaign setting because some SJWs found it offensive

Of course, Malediction is still on the book. Personally, I would much rather be worked to death in some Cheliax salt mine and face Pharasma's judgement than be summarily sent to spend even a single eon in the tender cares of Asmodeus.

I think the underlying thing is that for SJ, the topic of slavery is simply sacred, and can only be mentioned in sufficiently pious, orthodox works, and an RPG which lets you play evil characters simply does not qualify. (Of course, half of the sacredness is in the word slavery, if the game had simply called an enslaved person a serf (and perhaps gotten rid of the slave markets), most of the objections would have gone away.)

Personally, I have a strong preference that worldbuilding should include organizations whose attitude to diversity is different from a 2015 tech company. I think that fictional racism/speciecism is fine, and actually a good way to tackle these topics without stepping on the toes real world people (except for the professionally offended). Pratchett did this masterfully in Discworld with the ethnic tensions between trolls and dwarfs. Likewise, slavery and serfdom were unfortunately common in a lot of human societies long before Europeans settled in the Americas.

Nor is including a price range for slaves per se offensive. Most reasons why a DM would require this information are non-malevolent, like "can we afford to simply buy our source and set them free instead of breaking them out". Per default, the adventurer lifestyle does not lend itself to slave ownership.

Now, if the source books had made special accommodations for PCs owning slaves -- like saying and you can get a discreet obedience tattoo for your slave which will force them to obey you, I would consider that in poor taste, just as I would consider an info box on how to use the grappling rules to rape someone. But on priors, I doubt this was what happened here.

Anyhow, I am looking forward to seeing how long it will take for SJ to get universal franchise for all residents of Cheliax.

My question is WHY do progressives still want to fight dead battlegrounds either lost permanently to the enemy or scorched to irrelevance.

It's been, what, two years since woke "died"?

It's still omnipresent in every large financial institution, it still carries the majority of the Western population under age 40, and even the most "based" right-wingers are still tiptoeing around the most important cornerstone of Woke - racial biology (which even Nick Fuentes, the new media appointed archdemon, is unwilling to broach - he's on the side of 'Based Blacks').

Anyone talking about the death of woke is a Chinese man talking about the death of Maoism in 1965 because it suddenly went quiet. You're in for a very rude shock come 2028. Steve Bannon is right to be worried about being jailed when the Republicans lose the next election.

Look, people can privately fantasize over their weird racial utopia or idealistic society whatever have you, but it’s not going to happen without a radical (and radically violent) civilizational upheaval of modern day civil society. And nobody wants that. I hate living in a radically progressive society, but I recognize to some extent that’s the cost paid for all the other benefits that get provided to me. Society isn’t going back to some purified white ethnostate out in the American northwest somewhere. It’s just not going to happen. I could go back and live with distant relatives I still have some connection to in Scandinavia but I wouldn’t because it’s too foreign to me, even though I’m genetically indistinguishable from them. I actually ‘feel’ much more connected to my friends who are Hispanic, white, black and Asian than I would with other whites who can’t speak English or speak it with an unintelligible accent.

What are people like Nick supposed to say on this “racial biology” point? “Race” is a biologically fuzzy concept. Even population geneticists behind closed doors have admitted that you can talk about biology at the level of the gene itself without commitment to now outdated and pseudoscientific categories like comparing Nordics and Teutons and Alpines and Slavs, etc. Most genetic traits today are polygenic (i.e. single genes don’t code directly for most traits, multiple different genes contribute some proportion) and some are in fact omnigenic (at the genetic periphery, and genes only contribute very small, indirect effect sizes to a trait). What is this racial significance supposedly sitting there in the corner that nobody is talking about?

“Race” is a biologically fuzzy concept

Race being fuzzy doesn't mean DEI doesn't work. It doesn't prevent people worrying about the right representation of race in the military, in academia, in politics, in media, in jail. When I apply for a job, I am asked about my race. They don't do that for no reason. Indeed, HR will admit to discriminating against white men: https://www.resumebuilder.com/1-in-6-hiring-managers-have-been-told-to-stop-hiring-white-men/

Race is no more fuzzy than bullets are fuzzy. What is a bullet? Can it be made of copper, lead, ceramics? How about glass or wood? Can it be spherical or pointy or a dart-shaped flechette? Maybe it has explosives in it, maybe not. Huge diversity here!

But the key essence of a bullet is that you fire it out of a gun to hurt something. A really fine definition of bullet isn't needed to fire a gun. We don't need to nail down the exact nature of all the polygenic traits affecting a racial group to use it politically for X, Y or Z. Recognizing race is an extremely basic skill that children learn early on. Farmers made use of heredity in their animals centuries before anyone knew what genetics was.

There are no Black STEM Nobel winners, no Black Fields medallists, no impressive technical or civilizational achievements, much evidence of dysfunction wherever they go (the murdery parts of Detroit, the murdery parts of Washington DC, the murdery North of Brazil, sub-Saharan Africa, Haiti, South Africa, even Sudanese gangs in Melbourne). Yet there's a powerful lobby for capitalizing 'Black' and decapitalizing white, for giving blacks more privileges and status in society, which really complicates the situation when you observe that Nigeria alone has more births than Europe (Russia included).

So if we stick with the status quo of valorizing blacks while propagating stories of white racism and wrongful, evil discrimination against blacks, it seems highly likely that the Western world will be overrun with blacks who are incapable of running it but world-class in wrecking things, while also motivating them to do so by creating and incentivizing this animus. What idiot would want to live in Nigeria when they can move to Britain, Australia or America instead and get guilty white people to give them free stuff and special privileges? And only a racist is going to have the guts to actually block them, for they don't care if it's against 'international law', 'human rights', 'historical debts' and other such things.

This is in addition to the huge deadweight costs of existing DEI and black-valorization policies. So the racial significance ranges from 'gross misallocation of resources in the present and injustice' to 'looming demographic disaster'.

This sort of post is obviously against the rules here, as you appear to be aware. You have no mod history, positive or negative. This is not a great way to start things off. You don't have to agree with people, or even like them. You may even believe that they are enemies who should be fought to the death. But here we do not fight over words, but meet the arguments of others with arguments of our own.

Normally we start with a warning, but again, you seem to understand the rules and are choosing to egregiously ignore them. Banned for three days, and if you continue to communicate in this way, the bans will escalate rapidly.

I don’t know if I’m being asked to defend DEI policies here or what, because I most emphatically do not, and I’m all for dismantling them. Nor do I see the relevance of your comparison to bullets. What’s in there that’s supposed to be significant about race somehow? Do people identify with phenotypic familiarity? Obviously. The science of Genetic Similarity Theory (GST) has received substantial support since its development. Does that mean there’s some ‘gene’ out there that predisposes one group to create civilizations that other groups lack? Highly doubt it except in only the most extreme and fringe examples.

We don't even need to know what genes are for race to be politically, economically and socially significant. The DEI people don't even think race has anything to do with genes, which is silly beyond a narrow word-games sense. Despite that, they can use race politically. No knowledge of genes is needed, only observation of outcomes and trends.

The ancients didn't need to know why arsenic was poisonous, only that it was. That's the key information.

Western world will be overrun with blacks who are incapable of running it but world-class in wrecking things, while also motivating them to do so by creating and incentivizing this animus

You just described Rhodesia and South Africa. Theres a fun discrepancy playing out here too: Rhodesia under a strongman shit the bed hard, South Africa seems to have collapsed into incompetent grifters stopping grift purely to spite other grifters.

No matter how much progressives cheer on blacks destroying hated wypipo institutions run by Those Other Whites, blacks will turn on each other at the power consolidation stage and often before that. Farrakhan and MLK, Zuma vs Ramaphosa, Tutsi vs Ibo, etc etc etc.

Looming demographic disaster is quite possible in aggregate, but survival can exist next to the chaos. Scott Alexander and his coterie of Aella rationalist adjacents can thrive in San Francisco isolated from the decay in Tenderloin and even if the rot spreads they just become islands floating in swamps. I visited a friend in Mumbai where his place was more opulent than estates of Indonesian tycoons, but all the windows had to be closed because it was surrounded by literal filth. Not that he would care because he would be rich eternally, probably off the backs of the peasants drowning in the filth out the back.

None of that has anything to do with my point. Even if HBD is objectively untrue and completely useless, it is the one inviolable taboo of 'Wokeism', far moreso than anything to do with trans people, and the supposed "death of woke" has done absolutely nothing to change that.

My point is that woke isn't dead, it's just a little dormant at the moment, and is about to come back with a screaming vengeance. Progressives acting like it hasn't gone anywhere are acting rationally. Conservatives parading about and doing victory laps without actually doing anything to change the institutional and demographic factors at play are the ones behaving irrationally.

“[It] isn't dead, it's just a little dormant at the moment, and is about to come back with a screaming vengeance.”

Common words uttered by a man to a woman after a long night of partying.

“Race” is a biologically fuzzy concept.

You can take an MRI or CT scan of someone, feed it into a neural network, and it can classify their race to a very high degree of consonance with their self-identification. It can even do this if you remove the low-spatial-frequency or high-spacial-frequency information. Everything in biology is fuzzy to some degree, even such concepts as "alive" and "dead". But race is reasonably solid.

Even population geneticists behind closed doors have admitted that you can talk about biology at the level of the gene itself without commitment to now outdated and pseudoscientific categories like comparing Nordics and Teutons and Alpines and Slavs, etc.

Sure, they can speak in coded language to avoid being canceled or just losing research funds. That doesn't make the reality go away.

Everyone is dancing around the two issues that are verboten to explicate, especially in the USA: that a common overculture conflicting with libertarian sensibilities is a good thing for cost effective social organization, and that implementing said overculture onto culturally disparate populations inevitably requires sacrificing some forms of cultural identification which is impossible when cultural identification carries local power. 1950s postwar USA had a common commie enemy, a distinct life path that was socially sanctioned and available to most, and rising quality of life that could be enjoyed guiltlessly because envy was itself more transgressive than "greed".

Race is shorthand for culture, and much easier for progressives focus on race because it externalizes white blame onto immutable characteristics that therefore must be protected. Igbo and Yoruba are physically identical to outsiders but if I say that in Lagos I'd be lynched. Minnesota just had an election where the white winner Jacob Frey won by preaching unity across somali tribes and the somali contender lost because his tribes opponents refused to vote for him. Culture is what matters more, and even though race is the obvious proxy, it is imperfect enough to distract from tangible effects.

Obama was the genius that played both sides of the race angle: raised ENTIRELY white (his black father left him), dons a fro in college for black points and speaks legible jive for white curios and black hoodrats to feel equally comfortable with him. The significance of race died with him... until Michael Brown. I think Ben Shapiro is a dolt whose claim of right wing racial resurgence is only due to Obamas claim that "Brown looked like he could have been my son" is thin, but it did reflect an implicit race war rearmanent: shifting from grudging complaining to rahowa (directionally). The racialization of US politics (and all western politics are downstream of US politics like the fucking BLM shit in goddamn Berlin or Defund The Police in UK) is objectively a bad thing and any restarting of it is a fucking horrible outcome, yet the progressives insist on restarting it whenever they muster the brain cells to agree on an action befitting the progressive stack.

which even Nick Fuentes, the new media appointed archdemon, is unwilling to broach - he's on the side of 'Based Blacks

Is Nick an HBD believer? AFAIK he's preposterously antisemitic and quite misogynistic under any possible definition of those terms. But his racism seems generally just... not directed against blacks.

One of the pet theories I have is pure economics. It is a public knowledge that women make 85% of purchases and they account for 80% of consumer spending. We also have predictions about "sheconomy" by Morgan & Stanley that 45% of women will be single and childless by 2030. By the way sheconomy is an interesting choice of a word for what is named as “male lonelines epidemic” on the other side of the gender coin, but that is besides the point.

Now what is more important is what is left unsaid. Yes, women used to make most purchasing decisions - because they went shopping using their husband's credit card. If 45% of women will be single by 2030, it by virtue of mathematics also means, that there will be similar number of single men in charge of their own spending, men who are increasingly moving to the right compared to women. This means that in totality the purchasing power of male population is probably going to increase significantly, and that pandering solely to increasingly progressive women by companies and advertisers may no longer be the winning strategy as Gillette or Anheuser-Busch learned the hard way. We may see some more surprises in upcoming years solely due to economic factors outside of any culture aspects.

Sometimes I wonder if "the powers that be" have arrived at the conclusion that letting 20-40 year old women run up insane amounts of credit card debt, that they then pay the minimums on until they die on welfare, raises the GDP more than the alternatives.

At a certain point, the credit card debt is just made up money. When you pay the minimums, you pay so many multiples of what you actually borrowed it's a joke. If you default after paying back 3x the money you borrowed over 20 years, yeah, there is some opportunity cost for the banks that lent you the money, but nobody lost money in absolute terms. And hyper consuming childless 20-40 year olds probably raise the GDP a lot!

That the well dries up eventually... well... there's a new sucker born every minute. And if there aren't enough the US... well... you know my shtick already.

I don’t deny that TPTB have policy levers to Goodhart metrics like nominal GDP—for instance the classic Keynesian “pay workers to dig ditches and then fill them up again”—but this particular one doesn’t seem especially plausible, unless the government bails out the creditors, in which case the situation you are describing is just stimulus checks with extra steps.

On some level, it must be the case that the expected present value of credit card payments (adjusted for default risk) is positive, or else credit card companies wouldn’t be able to raise money (relevant xkcd)

Now, it’s entirely possible that everyone is wrong about these expected value calculations and in fact the rate of default is (or will be) so high that the credit issuers will lose money—in other words, that we are in a consumer credit bubble. If you really think so, then post stock portfolio or gtfo. Less snarkily, what’s your explanation for why, of the big bubbles of late 20th and 21st century history, none of them were primarily about consumer credit card debt?

I saw a peak behind the curtain when a buddy of mine negotiated with his credit card to forgive his debt.

It turns out, when the CC company forgives your debt, they get to write it off, and it gets put on you as income. So, to give you an idea of how it worked out for my buddy. He lived his best life in his 20's, struggled to pay off his credit cards, got it negotiated, and had probably low 6 to mid 5 figures "forgiven". A sum of money which after 10 years of struggling with the debt, and generally making payments, probably bore no relationship to the amount he actually borrowed. He was then hit with a tax bill on that "income" so high he had to sell his jeep and cash out his 401k to pay it off.

I can only imagine how phenomenal this is for the companies bottom line, and all their shareholders. They get to generate virtually unlimited tax write offs. Every bullshit fee they ever stick you with is win/win for them. Either you pay it, or they write it off in which case you pay the government ~25% of it.

So, in a way, the tax code is the government bailing out the creditors. They get to make up an outrageous almost nonsensical amount of money you owe, forgive it, and then push the tax burden onto you adding insult to injury.

>Lend $100,000
>Know chud can't pay it back
>I have a plan though
>Forgive the debt
>He won't know what hit him
>Write it off and get a reduction in tax liability of $21,000
>All it cost me was $100,000
>What morons, heh

That would be after collecting monthly payments for a long time. Turning a profit in aggregate for a large pool of lenders.

Doesn't work that way. The credit card company can only write off the amount they paid, and any interest they recognized but didn't actually receive. The debtor, on the other hand, has to report all principal, interest, and fees as income. The IRS is the only winner.

nobody lost money in absolute terms

I'd argue that the person paying the minimums did.

Men tend to spend less than women, though. Like there's men that are into guns(but firearms companies were never 'woke') and motorbikes and stuff, but few men shop for fun.

A more correct statement would be that they used to spend less than women, because women used to spend their money. The modern world of loneliness is unlike anything we have seen before. If you have tens of millions of single men, they will spend their hard earned money on something. What it will be is anyone's guess, but it will be a seismic shift.

I'm not sure how true that is. Lots of men love spending money on games, gadgets, hobbies, etc. and I certainly like going around the relevant stores for fun.

One of the pet theories I have is pure economics. It is a public knowledge that women make 85% of purchases and they account for 80% of consumer spending.

No, this is just a layer of the justification onion, it's not really a reason for woke media. You can see the justification fail with things like the Gillette me-too ad, female Ghostbusters and other properties that didn't appeal to women either, pushing all the trans stuff in, etc.

This is interesting as I completely agree with you but for other reasons. The Gillette me-too ad made their CEO doubling and tripling down, costing the brand decades of goodwill and brand power valued in billions. The 2016 Ghostbusters was a flop costing the studio somewhere in the range of $80 million.

This exactly shows my point, it is no longer wives that buy feminist razors for their husbands, or boyfriends taking their girlfriends to movies they maybe like. If anything, you provide prime examples of how the situation changed, and it will get more polarized in the future. If western companies won't provide what men want, there are always entrepreneurs from other countries willing to accommodate.

Nothing woke BECAME popular, popular things became infiltrated and then woke and then shitty. Tumblr clapbacks are mistaken for dollar spend. No population of genderqueer women rushed to play Dragon Age 2 because they finally felt representation with Taash, women play hotter characters in MOBAs of all stripes, women were the ones that used the armor set change thing more than male players and women used it explicitly to make off meta but attractive outfits visible on their characters.

Look if you want to see what pop culture women spend money on that men don't its not girlboss Rey or Junker Queen fatsuits, its romantasy billionaire bedroom bestiality or instagram experience photoshoots. In China women spend hundreds on Imperial Banquet cosplay dining experiences where they are dressed as noble consorts to be served hand on foot by nubile waitresses in delicate filigree.

Women applaud inclusive options for a theoretical other woman that wants to be catered to, but they aren't going to spend money at the Lesbian Collective Art Fair themselves. At the much maligned dashcon 2014 there was much clowning on the genderqueer performative identity panels, but what the girls attending were REALLY fired up on was the discussions on superwholock slash. Woke shit is just signalling, actual consumption is marginal at best.

I would love for D&D to be taken away from WotC and put in the hands of someone who will make some fucking content for it.

Also, this battleground isn't dead, the 5e player-base is fucking ridden with leftists that will eat up queer land acknowledgements. There legitimately is a market for their products. The biggest blow they took lately was the OGL fiasco and how it made all the big-deal podcasters (who have mostly drifted towards being Leftist or Leftist-safe if they weren't there already, to my understanding) try to swap to third-party systems.

This has driven a lot of the growth in the OSR scene... which is interesting because now you can watch in real time as outsiders and entryists accuse the OSR community of being full of fascists, while inside the community it's roughly divided between "I just want Old School orcs" and "We must make it clear that the OSR community is a welcoming and inclusive space."

WOTC making orcs basically humans with an odd skin tone is an unusually poor choice. Really speaks to them missing the fundamental purpose of morally unambiguous enemies in a game. I get the real point is they don't want a race of dumb savages so they have to change them into human with oddly colored skin. Like an identifiable group of real life humans drawn in fantasty style.

I don't play tabletop game any more, but if I did I'd want old orcs and racial bonuses.

WOTC making orcs basically humans with an odd skin tone is an unusually poor choice. Really speaks to them missing the fundamental purpose of morally unambiguous enemies in a game. I get the real point is they don't want a race of dumb savages so they have to change them into human with oddly colored skin. Like an identifiable group of real life humans drawn in fantasty style.

I think the strange thing to me is the weird double think involved. 5.5e turned humanoids into homework monsters by making the DM have to manually apply racial traits to the NPC statblocks, and reclassified a few humanoids as other creature types, but it still has bioessentialist "evil" races all the same. Even if the front of the Monster Manual clarifies that alignment can be changed by the DM, it is really hard to imagine, say, Mind Flayers ever having a good relationship to humanoids, given their diet.

And 5.5e still has monsters that are practically only ever going to be used in a "horde of unambiguous evil" way, like undead and fiends. Like, sure, it might be fun to have an antihero vampire or a risen fiend under certain circumstances, but most DMs are not going to put much thought into it, and just start breaking out the undead or fiendish hordes.

What's weird about it? It is as you said: Mind Flayers are an acceptable "evil" race because they are literally an obligate predator of humanoids. Traits that aren't present in real humans are an acceptable factor to base "evilness" upon. Aside from small clusters of the kind of people who hate Frieren for writing demons as evil anyway.

WOTC making orcs basically humans with an odd skin tone is an unusually poor choice. Really speaks to them missing the fundamental purpose of morally unambiguous enemies in a game.

From a gameplay perspective, if you want the tabletop equivalent of a video game beat-em-up title, it makes sense that you want a race of always chaotic evil antagonist who exist in endless supply and can be mowed down with no moral compunctions. It's the same reason we have zombies, or Nazis. But, from a worldbuilding/roleplaying perspective, that seems both pretty boring and also kinda unrealistic? Not unrealistic in the sense that you cannot build a world where it doesn't make sense; with enough effort, I'm sure you can. Unrealistic in the sense that it doesn't map to anything in the real world.

I get the real point is they don't want a race of dumb savages so they have to change them into human with oddly colored skin. Like an identifiable group of real life humans drawn in fantasty style.

If they are going to turn a monster race into fantasy Mexicans, then I prefer goblins. They are much cuter.

Best orcs are Project Long Stairs orcs. Wattsian P-Zombies that breed explosively and instantly learn and integrate any tactical behavior they observe.

OSR?

Old School Renaissance/Revival (generally, clones/imitations/enhancements of the first two editions of Dungeons & Dragons)

I would actually say that the center of gravity of the OSR has shifted to 0e and Basic more than 1e or 2e for quite some time. OSRIC was the first OSR game, and it was based on 1e, but most people have moved on to other clones or NSR games these days.

Old School Renaissance/Revival. Basically, D&D going "back to its roots" (generally 1st or 2nd edition AD&D, depending on who you ask, but sometimes Basic or even Chainmail). There are a host of Old School "retroclones" which are all variations on the old "6 stats, class/level, d20" fantasy game, but the aesthetic is generally to appeal to 70s and 80s kids disenchanted with everything post-TSR and all the newer games. Unsurprisingly, there is a large overlap between OSR fans and gamers sick of "woke D&D," though it's by no means an entirely right-wing or anti-woke movement.

Yeah, I'm at the front lines of it. Every few months, we get a scare where a leftist theater kid or a straight woman who keeps talking about Queerness turns up and calls things problematic or harumphs at someone's accent.

Yes, just recently ran into another hobby drama, and learned that about half the super-mega-permaban-list was for saying a nono word on unaffiliated discords. People have been announcing the death of wokeness since... well social justice started maybe 4 years before Trump was elected, and its been 9 years since then.

Why do progressives still want to fight dead battlegrounds? For the same reason that Jehovah's witnesses keep knocking on doors. It's the nature of religion. Keep doing what is "good", so that you yourself remain "good".

A lot of people seem to think of a religion as something that addresses big spiritual questions like death and meaning. But I would argue that the defining feature of a religion is a monopoly on morality, just as the defining feature of a government is a monopoly on violence. And because of this societal confusion about what constitutes a religion, the "woke" religion has been able to fly under the radar without calling itself what it actually is.

When you look at it this way, it makes a lot more sense. When you believe in the absolute morality of what you are doing, the odds don't matter. The pay doesn't matter. Nothing matters besides doing what is "right". It doesn't take too many of this kind of true believer to tip the scales on an issue, since they are willing to push the cause forward at great personal cost (friendships, jobs, family, etc).

I think historically this is probably why most states were unwilling to tolerate other religious systems anywhere near the levers of power. The monopolies of violence and morality are most stable when they walk hand in hand. But here we are, buried under centuries of enlightenment thinking, unable to see something so obvious that a peasant from the middle ages would have likely scoffed in disbelief before shuffling away to thresh more wheat. So why do progressives still want to fight dead battlegrounds? Short answer - John Fucking Locke.

But I would argue that the defining feature of a religion is a monopoly on morality, just as the defining feature of a government is a monopoly on violence.

This is the most satisfying definition I think I've ever heard for religion. Most have trouble with the fact that there exist "religions" like (some of) Taoism and Confucianism that don't rely on the existence of divine deities per se.

I'm not even sure it holds for the pre-Christian world? The philosophers at the time criticized the traditional depictions of gods as immoral and you could go to a philosophy school or learn something like Stoicism parallel to your existing religion and not replacing it. Religions did have moral content (the first commandment being to be good to your god so they'll be good to you) but they don't seem to have been totalizing.

The inordinate focus on morality in all dimensions seems to be a particularly Judeo-Christian thing.

How many societies allowed open condemnation of the gods by philosophers? Ancient Greece, maybe. But even there, if you pushed too far, you ended up drinking hemlock.

Epicurus got away with it. So ancient Greece yes.

Epicurus claimed to believe in gods, though. His gods were just non-interventionist. It's also clear from the works of Philodemus that early Epicureanism had a much more accommodationist approach to traditional religious rituals than later Roman Epicureans like Lucretius did.

Heck, even the Stoics got away with some "blasphemous" ideas, since they seemed to believe that temples and other houses of worship were unnecessary, and that the Logos/God/Zeus could be found out in the natural world. They were pious and impious at the same time.

The Greek religion at least did seem to have a moral code- woefully incomplete by our standards, but the gods were believed to punish transgressions against sacred hospitality, certain sexual taboos, cannibalism, etc quite harshly.

Not all religions have a commitment to the supernatural in this sense. Theravada Buddhism has always remained a classic “atheistic religion.” You can split hairs further if you want to just call it a moral philosophy, worldview, philosophy of life, etc., but as a religion it’s still suitable.

Morality is still the major game religions play, and only because we’re never going to recover the original trappings of a pious life, circa, say 300 B.C. The demoniac theory of possession is gone for all time and has been taken over by neuroscience.

Religion today is full of items we no longer pick off the shelf of our holy books. We walk with what is relevant or want to be true in the present day and then claim that’s what the religion is and has always been.

The demoniac theory of possession is gone for all time and has been taken over by neuroscience.

No it isn't. There are exorcists running around today. People go to them.

Oh yeah. People do that. But if I ask you if you start hearing voices in your head one day are you going to go to an exorcist or a neurologist, I’m pretty confident about what kind of answer I’m going to hear.

I guess it's not all that surprising though if you've never encountered a religion like that. It's the quintessential black swan fallacy. If every religion you've seen has a deity, you'll assume that it's an essential feature, not a useful adaptation.

They would 100% not put out today the version of D&D that Gygax put out in 1974. No sane business that wanted to make lots of money would. And you know exactly why. It would offend way too many customers for no good reason. Not a good business reason and not a good artistic reason, (unless you squint really hard).

So, I think this means it's not a dead battleground. Though I would go on and say it's different; this isn't the same stuff as making elves black.

Then Trump won, the illusion shattered for about a year. But now the same dead fights are being rehashed.

Just because Trump won an election doesn't mean you can ignore the racial demographcs of your potential customer base (>30% black or hispanic, 50% female) along with half of the white people stressing out about things they see as bigoted.


I'm mostly not up to date on this issue though, and found this discussion on r/KotakuInAction informative albeit a bit circle jerky.

From that link

In the 1970s, historical wargamers in America were predominantly white, middle-class men

Who would have thought that a nerdy (demographic primarily male) tabletop game (demographic primarily male) created in the US (demographic primarily white) and written in English (demographic primarily white) would be predominantly populated by white males

What a fucking mind-blowing concept

and

White men (and later men in general) were the main consumers at the time because they were ruthlessly mocked by women just for playing the game. Women thought it was lame and wanted nothing to do with it. They only became interested after it became trendy to be a nerd and after watching Critical Role.

Whites have slipped demographically but also D&D is mainstream now.

The slipping demography of white America and the not-exclusively-for-hideous-neckbeardedness of D&D anymore explains the behavior a lot better than progressive dead-battlegrounding, IMO. Though of course the woke ideological shit-tests are a part of this too.

In order for women to mock men for playing D&D, they'd have had to know what it is, and plenty of women plainly like some element or other of the concept of the game (they like roleplaying tea parties).

The main issue was that they wanted nothing to do with the men that played it.

Women who play dnd roleplay alot more than munchkin. Killing baddies is the boring part for girls, just like dialogue filler is boring for guys. The girls (including autogynephiliac men) I dm'ed for back in college were really into their female characters being put into near rape scenarios ("I remove my clothes in this prison to increase my stealth check roll!" "uh... ok...you can just stay in your enchanted leather..." "I roll for wisdom check if I remember that the enchanted leather is stealthy enough" "pass" "fuck roll again"). I know that a pbp forum had to offload all ERP because the main threads were getting clogged with sex roleplay and wasting turns for the rest of the party.

True that the girls never wanted anything to do with the guys playing. Creeps or munchkins are equally irritating. and the presence of a woman just makes that much worse. Though I have seen relatively healthy dnd groups among younger kids where girlfriends tag along just for shits and giggles, and thats honestly one of the best outcomes for an irl dnd session. Getting epic failstreaks to be funny requires good DM and good players and thats generally pretty rare.

"I remove my clothes in this prison to increase my stealth check roll!"

See also the A Dance With Rogues NWN module. Not that I'd know anything about that sort of thing.

The girls (including autogynephiliac men) I dm'ed for back in college were really into their female characters being put into near rape scenarios ("I remove my clothes in this prison to increase my stealth check roll!"

The Noticer in me couldn’t help but be reminded of an irl parallel: chicks dolling themselves up, putting on slinky outfits, slapping on high heels to go out, get drunk, and teehee and stumble around late into the night.

I think it is possible to overstate this thesis. I think D&D has a Star Wars-like thing going on with it: Star Wars was a massive blockbuster, watched and enjoyed by tons of men and women. It is also the case that autistic men gravitated towards it as a long-term special interest at a much higher rate, and so they became the core of the Star Wars fandom.

D&D Red Box was a huge Christmas smash hit the year it came out. While I have no doubt that male players outnumbered female players back then, I would find it extremely plausible that tons of kids, male and female, got D&D Red Box in their Christmas stockings, tried to start a campaign and had it peter out after a few weeks or months, and that this group constituted the majority of all D&D players back then. The ones who stuck around were probably disproportionately autistic men, but it wouldn't surprise me to learn that if you subtracted them you would have a much more gender-balanced (though still skewing male) early audience for D&D than you might expect.

Generally I ignore WotC. I think it was some 5-10 years ago a bunch of their higher ups said something like "We need less white dudes in this hobby" and I decided not to give money or attention to people who hate me. But a buddy of mine sent me this video reviewing a book of short adventures WotC published. His conclusion is that WotC has forgotten how to design adventures. Cool dunk bro.

But it occurs to me, a few days later, what might really be happening. Because all these adventures are criticized for being too linear, too bare bones, no room for fleshing out a world or inventive problem solving. And I think, not unlike how D&D in the 00's had MMO/Video Game envy, and aspects of it's design leaned into what they thought people wanted in MMOs and other CRPGs, I think D&D in the current era has Youtube envy and is trying to lean into what they think people want when they watch Critical Roll.

Because short, on rails adventures are perfect if all you want to do is play a session about as long as a youtube play session, and act out imitations of what you saw watching other people play D&D on youtube.

I donno, it's a theory. I have no interest in exploring the current era of D&D products to confirm it, on account of them hating me and all.

Generally I ignore WotC. I think it was some 5-10 years ago a bunch of their higher ups said something like "We need less white dudes in this hobby" and I decided not to give money or attention to people who hate me. But a buddy of mine sent me this video reviewing a book of short adventures WotC published. His conclusion is that WotC has forgotten how to design adventures. Cool dunk bro.

I mean, D&D is under a Creative Commons license now, so no one needs to care about what WotC does ever again. Doesn't matter if they go woke(r) or if Elon Musk turns it into another chud hobby, the books are free for anyone to modify and change forever.

Even if you want to pay money to companies actively supporting a contemporary game, there's plenty of options across the political spectrum from relatively woke companies that still make decent products (Paizo, Kobold Press) to more right-wing or neutral companies (a fair few OSR publishers.)

D&D is under a Creative Commons license now

This is not a very informative phrasing, because there are several different Creative Commons licenses and some of them are very restrictive. More specifically, D&D is under CC BY 4.0, the Creative Commons attribution-only license, whose restrictions are minimal.

I certainly didn't expect someone to read my comment, and just start publishing D&D content without any further research, but I suppose the further clarification for those interested is nice.

It's just good practice to specify which Creative Commons license you are talking about whenever you mention one, because each of the six different licenses has wildly different implications (the NC option is particularly dangerous). Saying "under a Creative Commons license" is like saying "owns a four legged pet" instead of "a dog", "a hamster", "a pony", etc; it's not as natural of a category as you might think.

This I think might be useful.

Edited to link the most recent version.

My questiob is WHY do progressives still want to fight dead battlegrounds either lost permanently to the enemy or scorched to irrelevance.

First, I doubt they'd believe that anything can ever be permanently lost to their enemy — after all, "the arc of the moral universe is long, but it bends towards justice." It's a pattern in progressive historiography where prior failed attempts at pushing some cause are lauded as prefiguring the later successful ones. Second, I must once again quote Mrs. Britten's English Zone:

Early literature written by Puritans in America often appeared as first person narratives in the form of journals and diaries. Early American colonists wrote their accounts of immigration, settling in America, and day-to-day life in journals to pass their stories down. Many Puritans also wrote letters to send back to Europe to family and friends they left behind. Very little fiction appeared during this period; Puritans valued realistic writing with an emphasis on religious themes.

…

Even the letters they wrote to friends and family in Europe performed more of a purpose than simply communicating about their lives and keeping in touch. Puritans' religious beliefs affected their lives on all levels, and their writing illustrated their religion's values, such as the importance of the church and the influence of God in their lives. Writing often became instructive, teaching Christian values. The Puritans did not believe that literature was for entertainment; therefore, they frowned upon "entertainment" genres such as drama (plays) and fiction novels.

How do you demonstrate that you are one of the Elect, if you aren't promoting Virtue, fighting wickedness, and serving Christ DEI in everything you do?

serving Christ DEI in everything you do?

I don't think it was intentional, but the fact that it is spelled the same as "of God" in Latin from a group of that seems overall against overt Christianity is funny to me in a very deep way. "In this house we believe in DEI. Agnus Dei to be specific." Imagine if conservatives started requiring stated support for "Graciousness, Openness, and Dialog" for red state faculty positions.

The sometimes-mentioned alternate "JEDI" also has some religious overtones.

If Scott read this, he'd be kicking himself that he didn't think to include it in Unsong.

None of this is a coincidence because nothing is ever a coincidence.

Because the proponents are Calvinists who swapped gods and kept the Calvinism.

And that made Musk tweet an implied consideration to buy out Hasbro, owner of WOTC.

Forget DnD, save Magic: The Gathering please. They of the negro Aaragorn card need it more than most.

This is where the praying man meme goes. "I see what you've done for others, Lord..."

Please please please don't let Elon buy it. I don't need yet another thing I own or do to become Chud coded. Not because I think he would fuck it up, but because I'm trying to survive in a blue town here.

Introducing GrokProxy: a on-demand AI art service that will gamer up the babes in your trading card game and print them out to order.

Apparently they also race-swapped Théoden (while retaining the Rohirric elements) which made me go "what the what?" But this was all back in 2023, I think?

If you're gonna go "Théoden is a proud Anglo-Saxon-African", then why not give him other African cultural elements? This is just "how can we squeeze some more coin out of the consumers?" and not anything more deep than that.

Or maybe the ongoing media projects where you can't have minorities be bad guys anymore - its always a white guy somewhere at the end pulling strings. Except if its Giancarlo Esposito.

I claim a better model is that you aren't allowed to make minority characters embody (real-life) negative group-level traits.

There are more counterexamples to your theory than just Gus Fring:

  • In Brooklyn 99's "The Box" (S5E14) is an episode solely focused on Holt and Jake trying to break a cold-hearted bastard Black male murderer - but Davidson portrays an affable middle-class evil. He is a dentist who got addicted to pain pills, and most of the episode he is shown outsmarting the interrogators. This is fine by my model, since he is technically a Black criminal, but not a reflection of the typical Black underclass criminal.
  • Ditto for Gus Fring. No white guy behind Pollos Hermanos pulling the strings - he is the ultra-competent mastermind pulling the strings (how many times throughout the show did characters remark how evil, but clever, Gus was?). And of course, after his fall, the next business partners for Walt is a savage gang of (White) Nazis covered in swastika tattoos. Ignoring the moral valence of the characters, this is clearly an inversion of the real-world analogue (e.g. South Africa) where actually the White group is pulled down and replaced by a less intelligent Black one.
  • In a sillier setting, there is the Black Dean of the other non-Greendale community college (like White Dean, he is an effete queer weirdo)
  • In the Good Place, lots of the demons were minorities (Vicky, an Indian female, was the only non-side-character example iirc) But in the humourous self-aware way.
  • Brooklyn 99 literally had a recurring character that was a Black male serial carjacker (Doug Judy), but he was again portrayed as an intelligent gentleman villain (sort of like a Black Neal Caffrey), he might make unreciprocated romantic overtures at Rosa, but he's not going to actually grab someone's ass or catcall.

I think my explanation makes more sense: you are allowed to show members of protected groups being villains (this is not contrary to standard progressive ideology), but you cannot show them being villanous in a way that reinforces pre-existing "stereotypes" (according to progressive ideology, the stereotypes are totally socially constructed without basis in reality, so they only exist due to media)

And actually I think it has nothing to do with villainy at all. You also cannot show them fulfilling stereotypes as good guys. In the good place, the main 4 were essentially inversions of their respective stereotypes:

  • Jason is a good-looking dumb, borderline retarded, East Asian (technically Fillipino iirc, but he is obviously presented as an East Asian, and looks close enough) - that is fine, because East Asians have a high IQ (but he would not be allowed to be Black/brown)
  • Chidi is a Black professor of moral philosophy. He is neurotic, bookish, non-confrontational (except for that time he punches Brent Norwalk... but that was portrayed as a man pushed to the limit and defending himself) and completely out of touch with the real world living in an ivory tower of academia. This sometimes leads to him failing others because he is paralysed by indecision - but that is fine, because it's not the stereotype (I wonder if a Jewish Chidi would be allowed?)
  • Tahani is a beautiful dark-skinned upper-class British-(South Asian) socialite. She is bad because she is shallow, status-obsessed and effete. In particular, it is constantly stressed how beautiful (and tall, for some reason) she is, how many times does Eleanor (the older blonde woman) fawn over how hecking hot she is?
  • Eleanor is a (White) woman. Her flaws are being lecherous, loud, rude, and gluttonous. Generally she just acts as the oppposite of a woman, and embodies the worst traits of a man.
  • Janet is a (White) woman, and a literal robot. A perfectly rational calculating machine (other than that time she fell in love), at one point even consoling Michael as she assures him he has to kill her.

The usual Who? Whom? applies when it comes to minority stereotypes and Hollywood depictions. South or East Asian American men can be depicted as dorky and effete with little fear of blowback, in contrast to depicting blacks or latinos as low-IQ high-crime net-tax consumers.

The introduction of a second axis can indeed be value-add here. That is, we can imagine a graph and map characters onto a horizontal dimension, with increasingly dumb as you move farther toward the left side and increasingly intelligent toward the right side. The vertical dimension would be increasingly "good guy" as you move farther toward the top, increasingly "bad guy" farther toward the bottom.

There would be far more black characters (as a percentage of black characters) on the right than white characters (as a percentage of white characters) relative to what one would expect based upon the average IQs of blacks and whites (perhaps even in the absolute sense), and far fewer on the left. There also would be far more black characters (as a percentage of black characters) on the top than white characters (as a percentage of white characters) relative to say, their crime statistics (especially violent crime statistics, or perhaps even in the absolute sense), and far fewer on the bottom.

The most disproportionate quadrant in terms of blacks being overrepresented relative to whites would be the top right quadrant: intelligent good guy. However, I posit the second most disproportionate quadrant would be bottom right, intelligent bad guy—and not top left, dumb good guy (which would be third). The most disproportionate quadrant in terms of blacks being underrepresented relative to whites would be the bottom left quadrant: dumb bad guy (like the aforementioned Neo-Nazis from Breaking Bad).

That is, the black/white disproportionality is greater along the intelligence dimension than the good guy/bad guy dimension when it comes to media portrayals.

This makes sense since a staple of American culture is prioritizing the status, feelings, and well-being of blacks over that of whites. And for most people, being viewed as stupid feels worse than being viewed as bad. Ask someone to think of an intelligent bad guy and they probably think of some cool edgy intimidating badass like Lalo Salamanca (if we're sticking with the BB/BCS universe). Ask someone to think of a dumb good guy and they probably think of some lame goofy doofus like the TravelWire employee who Lalo nonchalantly murders.

Much has been said by many about the glorification of violence and criminality in US black culture, where many blacks celebrate blacks behaving badly in a "das rite" manner. In contrast, while things such as trying hard in school may be mocked as "acting white," stupidity per se is not celebrated. If anything, the opposite: variations of "u stupid" as an insult between blacks can be readily found in online exchanges or fightporn, WorldStarHipHop, or publicfreakout-type videos (with little sense of irony or self-awareness).

The Chidi stereotype isn't just a paint-it-black version of a Jewish stereotype, it's been around before as black stereotype, notably Steve Urkel, and to a lesser degree Carlton on Fresh Prince of Bel Air.

And you're being a little unfair to Eleanor; she also had quite a few stereotypical female flaws, such as being vain and self-absorbed.

My questiob is WHY do progressives still want to fight dead battlegrounds either lost permanently to the enemy or scorched to irrelevance.

If you've convinced yourself that how we talk and what we consume determines reality why would you not fight over every crumb? The trigger for Basecamp offering employees who were offended at a list making fun of customer names buyouts to purge the company was an ADL pyramid that started with light mockery on the bottom and genocide on the top. If you believe this shit, then you should try to fight for every minor space no matter how dead it seems.

It's actually a great way to get otherwise politically inert people - or people who don't care to do any of the ugly tedious work of real politics - to feel like they're doing something. They can help where they are. Your hobby isn't childish or simply irrelevant to important matters, it's another way to do good.

Except it is patently clear that the audience for this public shaming doesn't exist anymore.

It never needed an audience. It's always been a relatively small number of people doing it--these people just have a lot of power. It doesn't matter that, for instance, Disney refuses to make white men a big part of its audience most of the time. So they lose some money, they don't care. They aren't going to go out of business or get fired because of it.

Also, bear in mind that woke media can get popular. The audience is probably race blind and sex blind in the way that used to be considered good and now marks you as a fascist. They don't actually object to the media being woke at all unless it's very over the top (lectures about how straight men are evil, 100% female cast, etc.)--it's just that if the writers put a high priority on woke, they probably put a low priority on everything else such as good writing, so the odds are against woke things getting an audience. But it can still happen (Baldur's Gate 3 for instance).

They don't actually object to the media being woke at all unless it's very over the top (lectures about how straight men are evil, 100% female cast, etc.)

I'd argue that's the difference between "woke" and "progressive/raceblind" media. Like, if you have a new superhero that you're going to launch, and you decide that it'll be a Latina woman and most of the story is going to revolve around a hispanic community in Texas - that's not a problem at all. I may not be interested in it, but I'm not going to say it's necessarily bad. If you're going to take a superhero who was "pale, male, and stale", and make them into a Latinx girlboss who don't need no man - then you've just made a garbage piece of media.

Baldur's Gate 3 is actually a great example of something I'd say isn't actually "woke" - it's just progressive. I'm going to compare it to the recently developed "Siege of Dragonspear" expansion for Baldur's Gate 1&2 - if you aren't familiar, one of the major characters in Siege of Dragonspear has a fairly big arc where it is revealed that they are transgendered, and it's considered to be a big deal that they're living their gender expression and they're so brave for doing so. However, if anyone here has played Baldur's Gate 1 - you'll recall that one of the first items you get in the game (literally in the third explorable area) is a belt of gender changing. In a world where there exists a magic item common enough that a random ogre can have one - being trans just doesn't make any sense. By comparison, Baldur's Gate 3 has progressiveness "in the water" so to speak - characters are gay, multicultural, etc. But from my recollection, it doesn't have any major plot points that rely on progressive shibboleths to make sense - there's no "ACAB" making it so you can never trust the guards, there's no situation where the only competent person is a female POC who is being shouted down by the bumbling men, and there's no plot point that relies on realizing all orcs are actually noble and that the orc opposing you must be a mind controlled victim.

Hasbro is limping along by milking Magic the Gathering for everything it's worth. D&D was never all that profitable, but Critical Role helped bring a resurgence. Thing is, that's the theater kid crowd. The grognards can either accept it or fuck off. They weren't that profitable anyway.

I think that the model of the progressive mind is that minorities will appreciate the work they are doing, the median American may not notice or care but won't mind, and the right are a tiny percentage that will impotently rage (which is a bonus). I don't think they're entirely wrong about the median American not caring, but they think they can maintain quality while not just giving half the country the heckler's veto. Heck, they veto it themselves before any heckler can even get the chance. But eventually they're recycling the same safe stories and people get bored. They spent all their time on stuff they admit only a minority care about, and the normies will still eventually subconsciously feel that something is missing.

isn't this now a genius strategy to get your company bought by elon. also, the article reminded me a lot of geeks, mops and sociopaths (https://meaningness.com/geeks-mops-sociopaths)