@07mk's banner p

07mk


				

				

				
2 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 06 15:35:57 UTC

				

User ID: 868

07mk


				
				
				

				
2 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 06 15:35:57 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 868

So if the fallacy of the left is to expect that any inequality of the racial distribution of tenured faculty is proof of unfairness, the fallacy of the right is to believe that any inequality of the political distribution of tenured faculty is proof of unfairness.

There's a distinct asymmetry here, though. In that there are loads of documented recent evidence of people in power explicitly and openly encouraging unfairness of the latter kind, while you have to go back quite a few decades before you encounter anywhere near the same density of such official documentation (well, at least in the direction that is being discussed, anyway; certainly there's no shortage of recent official documentation that explicitly calls for discriminating against members of white/Asian races in academia). Perhaps, more importantly, diversity of political orientation is material to an organization's ability to perform academic research (and more generally to discover truth) in a way that one's race isn't. As such, there's an argument in favor of AA in cases of political orientation that doesn't exist for race or other immutable-characteristic-based ones.

I still think this would cast MAGA as hypocrites and unprincipled, but mainly because (a) they're unprincipled hypocrites anyway for independent reasons and (b) the people who would judge MAGA as unprincipled based on this are motivated to be sloppy in their thinking in order to judge as such no matter what, anyway.

"I'm not worried about bad CONSOOOM, because the future has so much better CONSOOOOM!" This is no future at all. @2rafa nailed it with the Wall-E references and @IGI-111 brought up a worthy pondering point from the Matrix. Purpose in life is not the pursuit - or even attainment! - of pure pleasure. Especially when that pure pleasure is actually a pretty paltry fake world.

This is a pretty common perspective, and one that I just can't fully grok. Pleasure is pretty great, but pleasure is evidently not the only thing people go for. People will pursue all sorts of things when it comes to the capabilities of AI-generated media, and that will include pleasure, but that will also include things like meaning, depth, insight, or whatever other fancy-sounding term people like to use when they describe the value they get out of things they consider high art (I chose those terms because they apply to me with respect to works of fiction I consider great in some "high art" sense, such as The Shawshank Redemption or Crime and Punishment).

And the great potential for gen-AI I see is its ability to create these things without having to have someone intelligent and eloquent and talented enough to think about it and put it together. Films of the quality of The Shawshank Redemption was only possible due to the hard work of many extremely talented individuals working together to express something meaningful.

And yet, the film is just a sequence of grids of pixels flashing 24 times a second in sync with audio, and there's no rule of the universe saying that AI couldn't have generated those pixels and those sound waves (more generically, the precise sequence of 1s and 0s contained in an 8K transfer or whatever onto digital media), and the film would be no less inspirational, no less insightful, no less meaningful if it had been created that way. Likewise if it had turned out that Dostoevsky was an avid juggler who wrote Crime and Punishment by labeling balls with letters, then adding a letter every time he dropped a ball during his practice sessions, this wouldn't change the meaning contained within the novel at all.

And I see no reason to believe that gen-AI won't be able to order pixels or letters in a way to create new works of fiction that also provide insights and meaning of similar depth, around other topics, merely by training on what sequences of letters or pixels cause people to respond with, "Wow, that's really meaningful and deep!" versus "Wow, that's such vapid slop!" and everything in between and around. Because I don't think there's anything magical happening in the mind when someone thinks of something, notices that their mind judges that thing as "meaningful, deep, inspiring, etc." and then writes it down with intent to convey that sense to others.

And so instead of meaningful, deep, [insert other positive word here] works of art being limited by how few talented/skilled artists there are and how little time they have to produce art due to needing all that sleep and food, it'd be limited by how fast and common AI software and hardware are. These limits seem to be far looser than human ones, and so I see great hope for a future world where novel works of art that provide real, true, deep meaning will be as commonly encountered as a toilet or a microwave oven is today. There's potential downsides from being overexposed to too many works of art with too much meaning and depth and insight into the human condition, like how the downsides of social media and negative effects of overexposure to other people's approval and disapproval were both underestimated. But that doesn't seem like an awful problem to have.

the woke parasitism reduced the value of their output (by diluting it with nonsense)

Depends on what you mean by "value," doesn't it? If you consider the primary value of universities to be truth discovery/generation, then yes, woke parasitism reduced the value of the output to arguably negative (even the good stuff is no longer credible, because the ability to discriminate between the good stuff and the bad stuff has been corrupted). But if you consider the primary value of universities to be to validating your worldview and political ideology, then, depending on your ideology, it substantially increased the value. In fact, in that case, it took it from negative to positive, since truth discovery was an existential threat to your ideology.

This is what I don't understand. If I'm a cynical conflict theorist who wants nothing more than to utterly crush my enemies, see them driven before me, and hear the lamentations of their women, then I have a great motivation to become as strong as possible. In order to become as strong as possible, I need to train myself against adversity - true adversity, not a strawman adversity that just sits there while I pepper it with punches and my buddies all slap me on the back for what a badass I'm being. For that, I need both challenges to my ideas and criticism of my arguments. True challenges, true criticism, the sort that is motivated by a genuine desire to crush me and my ideas and the sort that actually has a real chance of changing my mind (this, of course, requires me to keep an open mind - so as to better improve myself to better crush my enemies and erase them from history).

I don't see how one accomplishes this without free speech. Without critics feeling free to yell their most malicious criticisms towards me without a single fear of consequence, I can't trust that my ideas or I have been properly tested, and so I have less confidence in my ability to crush my enemies, and I'm more vulnerable to being crushed by my enemies instead. I don't want that. So I want free speech.

Main thing about running LLMs locally is that GPU VRAM is probably the limiting factor in most cases. 3090/4090 with 24GB of VRAM or 5090 with 32GB are OK, but for hobbyists really into it, they've made custom GPUs like soldering 24GB more VRAM to a 3090, or using dual-3090 for 48GB of VRAM (spreading it out over multiple GPUs works for LLMs). The speed differences matter, of course, but 3090 with 48GB of VRAM will likely enable more than 5090 with 32GB due to being able to fit bigger models.

This was my thinking too. The New York Yankees used to have a rule against beards that they would enforce on their 8-figure salary professional baseball players, with the rationale being purely about uniformity and discipline. It seems that it would make at least as much sense in the military where people must have smaller egos for the apparatus to function and where their actions actually have consequences more meaningful and often more deadly than a baseball game.

Now, the rationale to begin with, does it make sense? I don't think there's any way to do the moral calculus on that in an accurate way. It's sensible on its face, at least.

Goodhart's Law becomes an issue here, though. It's been common knowledge for at least a decade that leftists have been adding more and more letters to the whole "rainbow coalition" in a way that appears absurd to the outsiders in the more and more fine granularity with which it divides minorities and also groups disparate minorities together. As such, anyone motivated to appear as a leftist would know to use the proper absurdly-long acronyms for this, and so this signals a desire to appear leftist, rather than leftism itself.

"People who disagree with trans ideology are a dangerous threat to trans people" appears to be a mainstream, possibly a supermajority-support Blue Tribe position.

Within the Blue Tribe enclave in which I reside, it doesn't appear that way to me. I'd say that it's a mainstream opinion, but certainly a minority one, and not a big minority. That said, a supermajority would support the statement "People who disagree with trans ideology are being unjust or oppressive towards trans people," certainly publicly and likely privately as well.

Now, I could see a way in which your apparent observation makes sense; a supermajority of Blue Tribers, when surrounded by other Blue Tribers and interrogated in a leading way, would eventually be pressured to appearing as if they genuinely support (which, let's be clear, makes one exactly as responsible for genuinely supporting it as actually genuinely supporting it) "People who disagree with trans ideology are a dangerous threat to trans people," where "dangerous threat" implies literal physical violence. To be completely fair, from the outside, this would appear almost indistinguishable from a supermajority of Blue Tribers supporting the statement.

There are a lot of Blue Tribers who equate "oppression" with "dangerous threat," but because of how loose the definition of "oppression" has become (in 2025, arguably, it means nothing more than "something that is currently being applied to a [person that I like or that is an opponent to someone that I dislike]"), most Blue Tribers tend to grok that it's just not a big deal. The notion that "We're all racists/misogynists/White Supremacists/homophobes - and that's OK" (of course, just because we're all equal doesn't mean some of us aren't more equal than others) has become close to the water that we swim in in the Blue Tribe.

Trans themselves appear to be overwhelmingly Blue Tribe/leftist, like 99%+

I'd suggest this is a selection effect in terms of which trans people are most likely to make lots of noise or be otherwise noticeable. I'd guess a majority is Blue Tribe/leftist, certainly, but 99%? I'd want to see the actual stats and methodology.

Hard disagree. Cleaning house with half as much enthusiasm as fighting the outgroup is an eminently reasonable standard for any movement to hold itself to (I'd argue that it's too low by at least 50%, but it's in the right order of magnitude), at least if they want to be considered meaningfully better than the outgroup; it's this very ability to credibly signal that one is cleaning house at least as much as they're cleaning things outside the house that justifies believing that we're better than the outgroup. Otherwise, we're just arguing about how chocolate is just such a better flavor than vanilla.

I find that rather perverse. Our commitment to lack of political violence in favor over our own pride or reputation ought not be contingent upon the behavior of people we have determined as being politically inferior to us, because that commitment is a good in itself. Otherwise, that commitment becomes merely a tool to cynically use to help one's tribe win instead of a principle of how no amount of opinions in politics ought to rise to violence.

This is actually a great point that didn't even occur to me. We've seen what leftists can do to punish people who say things they don't like. I am personally against all cancel culture everywhere for any reason, and I would fight this tooth and nail. But I would admit that a pro-cancel culture leftist who proved that they were willing to direct the cancel culture apparatus towards leftists glorifying anti-rightist violence - or even not maximally disapproving of it - is someone who has proven a commitment to reducing political violence. It'd be a deranged sort of commitment, but a true commitment nonetheless.

I think what the left should be doing is taking full-throated ownership of these murders pre-emptively, in a way that shocks the right with how quickly we're jumping to conclusions that we caused this murder, sans evidence of such. This sends a costly signal that we take the potential for violence to be caused by our violent rhetoric seriously, that we consider it more important than our reputation or pride.

And then take steps to implement policies that are supported by the attacked or rejected by the attacker. I've said similarly before; we need to send a signal to the other side that we take political violence as seriously as they do, that we consider it unacceptable to engage in it, irrespective of the political beliefs involved. So the signal must be costly for our political preferences, in favor of liberal democracy. Committing to an incentive gradient that discourages political murder, even if it means some of our political preferences don't get met seems like one of the most obvious costly signals for something like this.

EDIT: It also occurred to me later that a presentation of a certain attitude to actively seek out costly and effective signals I think would also be almost necessary. Most CW arguments involve someone nitpicking some suggested fix, finding problems here and there for why it wouldn't work, and such. And any specific fix can be nitpicked to death by someone who's motivated to appear as if they're goodwilled - this is the grain of truth in the whole "tone policing" complaints that became en vogue in SocJus spaces around 15 years ago. A full rejection of that attitude and embracing the attitude that, "If this particular costly action wouldn't properly send the signals in a way as to accomplish our goals, then we'll spend twice as much, work twice as hard and long to find some other costly action that would signal what we want in such a way as to accomplish our goals." I consider it a sort of "first derivative" commitment. We're not committing to a particular action, we're committing to a particular way of choosing our action, based on a commitment to do what it takes to figure out a way to reduce political violence, in a way that is costly to our political desires.

As long as these concessions are specific to the people decrying the violence, in a way that's contradictory or at least counterproductive to the goals of those celebrating the violence, I think such concessions would work very well. These would actually be possible, since there are many substantial disagreements between the peace-wanting left and the bloodthirsty left.

No, ANTI ICE clearly indicates an anti-global warming leftist who wanted to protest internal combustion engines for producing so much CO2.

As a complete non-sequitur, as someone who was a child when Ice Ice Baby hit, I recall hearing from people older than me that his "word to your mother" was considered a legit controversial line at the time. Which I found confusing and silly. I also recall that Zinedine Zidane, one of the best French soccer players of his era, in his retirement game, got red carded for obviously intentionally head-butting an opposing player, and some of his fans defended him on the basis that the opposing player apparently made some insult about Zidane's mother. Finally, one of many things that I recall about the 1980 film The Terminator in terms of how the culture it depicts is different from the culture I'm familiar with was one of the detectives responding to a playful insult with a simple "yo mama" in a completely unironic way (others include the 80s hair and waiting on hold for 911).

Of course, mothers being sacred is a common trope in reality, but I found it curious just how seriously some people seemed to take it, to the extent that some off-hand insult directed at a generic "your" mother causes offense, or that it would justify headbutting someone during your send-off game after one of the best soccer careers anyone's ever had. It just seems strange when the syllables coming out of someone's mouth are clearly intentionally designed to upset you, the response is to be upset instead of ignoring.

Perhaps this isn't so much about mothers as it's about the talk about honor culture and all that that are happening elsewhere in this comment section. That there's a perception that it's not only justified but actually your duty to respond to someone obviously fitting themselves into the role of "intentional provoker" by fitting into the separate role of "the one who is provoked to shut them down," lest you sully your honor, instead of just saying "I have better things to do than LARP with you."

Rock didn't really get in any hot water over the bit in a way that compelled such a response, though. Even before his public acknowledgement about these potential issues, his bit was considered an absolute banger in the "funny because it's true" sort of way, and I recall his acknowledgement being a footnote, an interesting piece of trivia, in terms of how well publicized it was, so I don't think that had much of a factor.

I think the main difference was that Rock's thing was purely a comedy bit. He didn't have any extra messages before, after, or surrounding his stand-up act berating the black community or whatever. Cosby probably incorporated plenty of comedy to his messaging, but he was perceived as actually trying to push ideological and cultural messages as a comedian, putting himself into an oppressive patriarchal role. Rock was trying to make you laugh by hitting on a shared truth about culture that is taboo to say, which feels almost like the archetype of a stand-up comic - "If you want to tell people the truth, make them laugh, otherwise they'll kill you" - "only one who's allowed to tell the truth in the king's court is the jester."

Which “actual accusation” are you referring to? I obviously agree that the expansion of “hatred” to mean “supports policy positions which are less-than-maximally-optimal for some specific group” is a transparently bogus rhetorical trick.

The "actual accusation" would be that Harris "genuinely hates white men.". Which would be roughly equivalent to, "Kamala Harris feels similar antipathy for white men as is claimed about Trump feeling antipathy for women when his haters accuse him of 'hating women.'" Once we get to the colloquial definition of "hatred," we're not dealing with the accusation, but something stronger.

If she still did, I find it highly unlikely that the “compartmentalization” or “cognitive dissonance” which you propose exists would long ago have broken down and some inciting incident or slow buildup of aversive incidents would have caused the breakdown of the relationship.

We have very different intuitions around the power of compartmentalization and cognitive dissonance, it seems. It's hard to get rigorous empirical evidence around this in general, but my experience is that there is no such thing as overestimating its ability to allow people to hold self-contradictory beliefs. Even presuming the colloquial definition of "hatred," I've seen it happen too many times that someone absolutely hates someone that they also love, and other times someone that they convincingly act as if they love, and I've seen it happen for decades at a time. But for the deranged meaning of "hatred" being invoked in this topic, I'm absolutely certain that the stress of this level of cognitive dissonance would just be noise relative to the general stresses and suffering of everyday life.

Alright, fair enough. If you're saying you genuinely buy this argument and genuinely don't consider it discredited, then I have no grounds with which to claim that you are wrong. But, honestly, none of this is galaxy-brain contrarian psychobabble. The ability of humans to compartmentalize apparently-contradictory views is something that has been observed long before anyone ever came up with modern critical theory.

More to the point, the word "hatred" when used to describe someone like Harris "hating white men" is clearly meant to invoke the same kind of meaning as when someone claims that someone like Trump "hates women" or someone like Charlie Kirk "hated gay people." It's perfectly reasonable to complain that this re-definition of "hatred" in order to keep the negative affect and connotations while expanding its scope to include entirely loving and empathetic behaviors towards someone is dishonest. I consider that as a non-discredited way of arguing against accusations of hatred: my behavior only counts as hatred under your deranged, stupid re-definition of hatred, and I don't respect your deranged, stupid re-definition. But I do consider the argument that "this other behavior I engage is inconsistent with someone who hates [x]" as fully discredited, because it's neither engaging with the actual accusation nor engaging with the reality of cognitive dissonance.

That feels like someone riffing off of the "This machine kills fascists" sticker that was somewhat en vogue in the 2010s that people would stick on their laptops. Not that common, but common enough to form a stereotype within my blue tribe enclave of a keyboard warrior who genuinely believed that his activity on the internet via his laptop would play out eventually in killing fascists (or just preventing them from existing, I suppose). As you say, it's pure applause light.

And yes, it is an attack. Being vague about it won't change it.

This is where I disagree. I believe that being vague about it would have been more than enough to paper over it to not look like an attack. Perhaps an extra step of vagueness by excluding "blacks" altogether and just saying "Pete polled poorly in key voting blocs we needed," and then deflecting with word salad when pressed on the details would've been needed. But underestimating the ability of motivated voters to fill in vagueness from people on their side with good things for their side and bad things for the other side is something that has burned me too many times to fall for again.

Nothing in your comment indicates that people actually genuinely believe the argument you're making, over the ones I pointed out. I don't doubt that somewhere, someone likely had a genuine reaction of "he's married to [x], therefore the likelihood that he has hatred for [x] is lower," if only for Bayesian reasons. But, I'll reiterate, I've never actually observed this happening anywhere. By my observation, people consider it exactly as discredited as the "My best friend is black/gay/trans/etc." explanation for why someone isn't racist/homophobic/transphobic/etc. in basically exactly the same ways (note that some people will say that this is discredited because it's a lie - this person's best friend actually isn't black/gay/trans/etc. - this is one form of discrediting it, but the more common one is that presuming that that statement were true, it still says nothing about whether or not that person has hatred for [x]). Because "hatred" is such a loose term that can encompass a near limitless range of behaviors and attitudes.

I honestly think Harris's chances at becoming POTUS in 2029 would've skyrocketed (to single digits) if her book and her interviews had that tone.

I don't think I've ever seen being married to [x] as being genuinely interpreted as evidence against hatred against [x]. Because of limitless ability for people to practice cognitive dissonance and compartmentalization, and also because "hatred against [x]" never literally means "hatred against each and every last individual who belongs to [x] category, without one single exception even theoretically possible" (otherwise, the amount of accusations of "hatred against [x]" would drop by several orders of magnitude lower than it is now). In practice, one common trope is "one of the good ones," where "hatred against [x]" actually describes a bigoted negative affect one attaches to individuals belonging to [x] category, and "one of the good ones" is someone for whom whatever negative bigoted beliefs they have about [x] either doesn't exist or exists in small enough amounts to be overcome by their positive attributes.

which is just transparent 'cede to all of my group's demands or you are a whateverphobe'

Yes, yes it is. That you noticed this doesn't mean you have any ability to stop it from working, though.

The point of the deflection is that it's not accusing blacks of homophobia. Again, this is an invisible fig leaf, an Emperor Has No Clothes sort of situation, but one of the biggest takeaways from the past couple decades of US politics for me has been that the least believable part of that story was that the crowd had to pretend to see the Emperor's clothing, rather than the crowd genuinely experiencing the qualia of seeing their Emperor wearing impressive clothing, because they were motivated to see such a thing by their superiors. And Maddow herself, along with the remaining audience of Maddow seem far more likely than the general populace to see that fig leaf if Harris points it out.

Instead, Harris came out looking homophobic to that same audience, and stupid to a wider, likely overlapping, audience. Which, perhaps doesn't speak to her incompetence as I had initially thought, but a rational calculation that, as a black woman, she has the privilege of copping to homophobia without being politically punished. Perhaps I ought to give her credit for taking personal responsibility for making a homophobic decision, unlike most of her other comments about her campaign, even if she probably did it unintentionally.