The progressive idpol ideology that has been dominant in the Democratic party for the past decade+ groups all dimensions of anti-[demographic] bigotry into one, and more generally all dimensions of oppression into one. This is why AGW/climate change activist Greta Thunberg also happens to be a socialist who is pro-Palestine, and why mainstream journalism outlets publish opinion pieces about how "fatphobia" is rooted in white supremacy and misogyny.
As such, if Trump has ever said anything that could reasonably be construed as transphobic or sexist, then the people criticizing him over such things also genuinely, honestly believe that that necessarily means that he's also homophobic and racist and fatphobic and pro-fascist. So whether or not Trump ever said anything homophobic (or displayed any signs of having any particular antipathy towards homosexuality) is neither here nor there for determining whether or not he is a vile homophobe who would homophobically weaponize Pete's homosexuality against him for electoral gain.
That's probably oversimplifying a bit, but I don't think the idea that "victim blaming can be bad" is wrong per se, just misapplied.
Indeed, absolutely. The key thing here, though, is that "victim blaming can be bad" was already the default state of modern culture, heck even BEFORE the 1st 2 waves of feminism. The idea that "X can be bad" no matter what X is is a pretty good default that almost everyone has about anything, and the idea that blaming someone for something can be bad had already been built into society for centuries, as evidenced by legal justice systems.
The part that progressive idpol added was the enforced misapplication.
You're right, but also, this just fits more into the pattern of "They say lots of things, but anything that's good isn't new, and anything that's new isn't good." The idea that saying "Well if you're going out doing XYZ you can't be surprised if somebody rapes you shrug" to someone who's been raped is rude or bad doesn't come from progressive idpol, it was already baked in to the existing system as just a form of manners that much of American culture already bought into. The innovation that progressive idpol added is that even neutrally stating that, empirically and physically, certain behaviors can influence one's vulnerability to being raped, in any context even without any specific or hypothetical rape or rape survivor involved, is still exactly the same as explicitly saying that rape victims deserved it because they were asking for it.
I live near an East Coast city, and I too see masked-up young-looking people (seemingly) every time I take the bus or subway or go to the mall. They're not common, they're definitely a small minority, but they're common enough that I continue to notice them during my day-to-day times in public spaces.
Which makes it not exactly baffling that this happens, though it is baffling that nobody seems to be trying to fix it on the cultural level. There are lots of attempts to blame the police and reduce their aggression towards minorities, but I don't see the same level of impetus towards teaching minorities "Don't fight the police!" When this is the obvious and easiest solution to the issue. It's not that minorities need to be extra submissive towards police, it's that everyone needs to submit to police, but certain subsets of minorities haven't caught on yet and need to be brought up to the same level as everyone else.
Is this really that baffling? The last several decades have seen the continual rise of an ideology that is based on dividing populations into groups, declaring some of them "oppressed" and others "oppressor" and declaring that the former has zero responsibility to improve things and the latter has full responsibility to improve things. A prominent example of this phenomenon in a different topic (with mostly the same players) is "rape culture," where even advising a woman against putting herself in a position of vulnerability around strange/potentially malicious men with alcohol or other drugs involved is considered full-throated justification for her being raped. Heck, even pointing out the fact (citation needed) that this raises one's odds of being sexually assaulted has been equated with explicit condoning of rape.
As such, any sort of recommendation that black people adjust their culture such that the rates of violent or otherwise troublesome encounters with police go down is verboten. That's condoning White Supremacy which we can always invoke as blame-worthy (of course, abstract concepts like White Supremacy can't really catch blame - people that you think of when you think of White Supremacy, such as white people, or brown people who disagree with you, OTOH...) in any troublesome encounter between any black person and any cop for any reason. Whatever culture that black people have, it's either innate - and good and to be supported in and of themselves, because everyone (that we've deemed sufficiently oppressed) deserves to be not just tolerated, but celebrated, intrinsically for who they are - or an adaptation that they had to take on just so that they could survive in this oppressive White Supremacist world they were unjustly thrust into, and so it's 100% the responsibility of White Supremacists to modify the policing system such that black people have to spend zero effort to change their culture and the rate of troublesome police incidents involving black people goes down to zero.
So all these people subscribing to ASMR content producers must have an unusually wide gap between the threshold of pleasure and the threshold of disgust/pain, just like these people who blanket their food with cayenne powder or subscribe to /r/popping do.
I have similar issues with ticklishness like you described, but I also enjoy ASMR and enjoy blanketing my food with whatever spice I'm into at the moment, so this is probably specific to the stimulus. Never been to /r/popping or know what it's about, but based on context, that sounds disgusting & I'd rather stay away.
Someone left-wing will quite naturally think that permitting Holocaust denialism would be much worse than permitting arbitrary thuggish looting and mayhem, because the former is the first stepping stone on a road that leads potentially to dictatorship and genocide, while the second (they perceive) is only ever going to be a marginal problem, not an existential threat to civilization.
I'm on the left, and I disagree heavily. And many on the left do as well. That thought process requires buying into a particularly anti-liberal view of the world, which many progressive leftists certainly do, but which is nowhere near defining or universal among leftists. Notably, believing that one knows so much about the future and cause-and-effect that they can have confidence that permitting Holocaust denialism would be more likely to lead to dictatorship and genocide than less is certainly a massive act of hubris and could only be justified through faith, given what we know about history. Which is all well and good, but it certainly should be openly stated.
As a Blue Triber, I could not disagree more with this and find this description almost derogatory; a Red Triber could hardly insult the Blue Tribe better if he tried. Blue Tribers tend not to like guns and tend not to use guns, but gun-toting/gun-hobbyist Blue Tribers aren't unicorns. They're just rare, and the idea that gun usage is so out-there for a Blue Triber that simply knowing how to operate such a thing would be viewed with noticeable suspicion is something that could only apply only to particularly secluded/sheltered members of the Blue Tribe, not to just a typical Blue Tribe. I've lived in especially urban, especially sheltered Blue areas for most of my life, and even there, demonstrating/stating knowledge of how to operate a gun and even admitting a hobby of shooting guns wouldn't raise an eyebrow.
I repeat zeke5123a's statement that this is nonsense. The idea that there could be any sort of honest point to be made about concluding that the murderer was "one of [MAGA's] own" given the evidence available at the time is such transparent motivated reasoning that, as a leftist, it makes me angry to see other leftists discredit our side like this, which demonstrably fails in meeting up to our actual claim of being meaningfully better than the right.
This is what I'm explicitly against, ideology-based redefinitions that are clear perversions of the words, themselves, generally for the purpose of leveraging positive/negative affect for ideological purposes. War is Peace and all. No, sorry. We already have definitions.
Fair enough, but terms mean things based on how they're used, and the progressive identity politics crowd have done a pretty good job using this term (since they're generally the only ones who want to use it anyway). These people own the humanities and the media, so it'll be hard to keep them from redefining words as they see fit.
My personal attitude is that a rose by any other name smells just as sweet. Let's call it a microaggression and also acknowledge that microaggressions can be aggravating, they can be totally awesome and positive, they can be neutral, and anything in between, depending on the details. Just like how a White Supremacist can be a black egalitarian in treating individuals as individuals rather than representatives of their race, which means that white supremacists can be awesome people that we want more of in this society, depending on the details.
I'm sure they genuinely have no idea that by doing this redefinition, they're microaggravating me. But if their definition holds, then again, they are committing a little act of violence against me every time they use the term that way.
Absolutely. What did you think decolonization social justice meant? Vibes? Papers? Essays? No, it's righteous violence to take away the chains that people we've judged as the oppressors are using to oppress the people we've judged as the oppressed. See, they've already depicted themselves as the Chad and you as the soyjack judged that they're fighting for Justice and that the people they like really are The Oppressed, which means that your complaints about them microaggressing upon you don't count.
It's impressive what you can accomplish when logic, rationality, and reason are deemed as oppressive tools of white supremacy that should be discarded used selectively as needed to achieve the desired outcome.
You're trying to work out the definition based on the etymology. Words generally don't work that way, and especially so for ideologically invented terms like "microaggression." The function of the word "aggression" in there isn't to describe what happened, it's to provide negative affect for anyone listening to the term.
The defining portion of a microaggression is that the microaggressor genuinely has no idea that he's doing anything aggravating to the microaggressed-upon. Their failure to model the other person well enough to recognize that what they said would be aggravating to them is enough to describe as an act of (micro) aggression. Implicit in this is the belief that all of society ought to restructure itself so that people who have been deemed "oppressed" doesn't suffer any sort of annoyance from others that they judge as "oppressive," without limit. This kind of pattern might appear familiar, because it's one of the guiding principles of modern progressive identity politics that you've probably seen play out all over the place.
A microaggression properly understood is a deliberately microaggravating comment, knowingly pitched by the offending party as a subtle enough thing that it has inherent plausible deniability and affords them the ability to deny any ill intent while still getting the satisfaction of making the receiving party momentarily uncomfortable.
No, this is a misunderstanding of what microaggression means. A microagression, by definition, requires no intent or deliberation on the part of the aggressor. The fact that it's made with good faith effort to be decent or positive is the defining factor that makes something a microaggression. An act similar to a microaggression, but made deliberately with intent to have plausible deniability is generally called "being passive-aggressive" and has been considered rude generally long before the concept of microaggressions were invented.
The key thing about "microaggressions" is that they're entirely dependent on the mind state of the person who believes they've been micro aggressed upon, and, as such, provides unlimited leeway by which people who have been labeled "oppressed" can accuse anyone else of being oppressive via microaggression.
This is why, eg a classic example of a microaggression is a woman grabbing her purse more tightly when a black man walks into the subway car, which is a microaggression regardless of if she noticed that he had entered, noticed he was black, or if she was holding her purse closer for independent reasons. If the man perceived that action as being an act of stereotyping him as a potential mugger based on his race, then the woman has certainly committed a microagression on him.
I certainly think he could have beaten Trump for the standard reasons. Clinton almost beat him, and I think Sanders would've leached off more populist-type voters from Trump than he would've lost relative to Clinton. The type of Clinton voters who would've been upset enough at Sanders not to vote for him seems likely to be small, particularly Clinton partisans also tended to hate Trump even more, and Sanders's downsides to them were things he shared with Trump, i.e. old white guy. No way to know for sure.
I believe that at least some parts of woke would've carried on mostly the same way, which is everything to do with trans. The writing was on the wall beforehand with parallels being made between trans and gay in terms of being something innate to oneself that one discovers by being true to oneself, versus being something that can be influenced within people, especially impressionable young people in whom certain amounts of hormones are flowing for the first time, with the emotional influences thereof. The situation with Lia Thomas, the MTF college swimmer who's caused controversy for obvious reasons, probably would've happened regardless. I have to wonder, though, if we would have learned about WPATH suppressing research in order not to give political ammo to their critics.
Entertainment media is where I think there might have been a noticeable difference. Living in a blue area, I've yet to see it overstated how much President Donald Trump seemed to have broken an unfortunately significant number of people's brains, and this seemed to have been especially true in Hollywood, which I think probably led to more messaging being prioritized over quality, likely in subconscious ways. I can't remember any in particular now, but I'm pretty sure I've read a number of interview answers by directors, writers, and even video game devs who said their work was inspired by the idea of fighting against the rise of fascism in the USA in the form of Donald Trump. President Sanders probably wouldn't have inspired such works, and maybe execs might have had a slightly higher priority on profit over in-group approval among political peers such that some of, say, Disney/Marvel's downfall due to woke-ifying old franchises could've been slowed down.
Wouldn't it be more like saying England bombed Pearl Harbor? And Germany's the one that's saying it, making fun of USA for being dishonest enough to insist that the attack could have come from Japan.
Thing is, taking offense to Kimmel's comment isn't a right-wing thing. It's an anti-tribalism thing, which has few members in both the left and the right. It doesn't matter if the right is being insulted; it's the whipping up left into a frenzy (which may be background noise, but this rises to something beyond that) that's the offensive part. Even if every right-winger were a principled free speech absolutist, it wouldn't make Kimmel's behavior any less offensive.
I don't think I assumed such a thing. Sans any new evidence, I'll firmly presume that this conditional hasn't been met and insist that that's the right thing to do for anyone, and I'll also admit that my presumption isn't necessarily true. The comment to which I was responding was general about this cancellation being risible conditional on Trump's behavior, regardless of if my presumption were true or false. I was pointing out that if my presumption were false, then that statement is utterly ridiculous. It's also ridiculous if it were true, though not as ridiculous, since Trump being the leader of the government creates a deeper connection when we believe that the government coerced this cancellation.
This seems to be to be a very different ideological position from the belief that protests are very important and if the government's support of them is suspect, then it's better not to have them intervene at all than to risk their suppression. A moral stance of "I would rather (n) murderers walk free than have one innocent man behind bars" is not the same as support for murder.
That only works if you support actually investigating and prosecuting murderers and have credibly demonstrated that if the murderer is your friend murdering your enemy, you will stamp down on that murderer just as hard as the other way around. Blackstone's formula certainly can justify complete non-investigation of all murder - this will guarantee that no innocent man goes behind bars, at the cost of all murderers walking free. It's possible that these protests-turning-into-riots is a case where this applies; however, anyone who agrees with the protestors is obviously necessarily too hopelessly biased for making a reasonable judgment call on that, merely because they're human like the rest of us. This reality about bias is pretty much common knowledge, at least among the educated, and as such, anyone who's educated, supports these protestors, and trusts their own judgment that these protests are so important that it's worth letting riots happen so that legitimate protests don't get stamped down is someone who has figured out a way to support rioting without affecting their conscience.
The issue isn't the oppression calculus, it's the micro in microagression. A microagression, by definition, is a behavior that, to a neutral and fair observer, looks indistinguishable from an entirely innocuous, possibly even positive, action towards someone, which is judged only and purely by the person receiving the action as being bigoted in some way. If it were actually identifiable by an unbiased party as being an act of aggression, it would just be aggression, not a microaggression.
Misleadingly misattributing the murderer's political ideology to one's political enemies is something that people would tend to recognize as an aggression, which disqualifies it from being a microaggression.
What's confusing about it? I pointed out that taking Kimmel off the air, if decided independently by the owners without government influence, would be entirely justified and a reasonable and good thing to do, and this goodness doesn't change in any way based on Trump's words. I still stand by this statement.
This feels a lot like wordcel lying where what is said is truthful but it is deliberately structured to give an impression to the audience that is incorrect.
I mean, this is certainly what's going on. This is standard operating procedure for all non-fictional media on all sides of the aisle all the time. As such, people in media who practice this have no plausible deniability; either they're following this playbook knowingly, or they're so oblivious to the reality of such a playbook (intentionally or not) that everyone listening to them is dumber for having listened to them, they should be awarded no points, and may God have mercy on their souls.
Now, wordcel lying is infinitely adaptable to circumstance, but that doesn't mean the adaptation always happens. The part where I see the biggest weakness, by wordcel lying standards, is the inclusion of "desperately" in describing the MAGA gang's actions. The "desperation" implies a sort of losing battle that they're grasping at straws to prove something that's factually wrong, rather than simply stating truths that are obvious, evident and obviously evident. "Desperate" is a subjective judgment call, of course, so Kimmel absolutely deserves zero government censorship for this, by my lights; all it does is show that his judgment is so bad that it reflects poorly on the judgment of people who hired him as a host for a show like that. That MAGA was trying to characterize the murderer as anything other than MAGA is arguably a bland, neutral fact about reality, but that MAGA was desperately trying to do so is a judgment call that shows extremely poor ability to observe reality or to discern reality. Which many many people find perfectly fine in their late night talk show host, as long as that poor ability pays out in making fun of people they disagree with. It's just that, if even more people (or possibly the people with the actual power, like the owners) seem to believe in some higher values than just beating up people they disagree with.
Calling such a view "questionable" is overselling its plausibility. I'd say it's almost risible! Like, it's possible - and unfortunately, due to the FCC's own choices in public statements, we'll never know - that the owners did it independently, but anyone who doesn't automatically default to presuming that this was coerced by the government and requiring a very high bar before believing otherwise is someone whose judgment I'd question greatly.
Yes, almost certainly, a majority of children of rightist Red Tribe parents are rightist Red Tribers, and the mirror image is true too. Both intuition and my memory of the stats says this, and so, from a naive Bayesian perspective, if all we knew about someone was the politics/Tribe of their parents, we should probably default to presuming it's the same or very similar. Conditional on [having so much antipathy towards Kirk that he had a desire to see him assassinated], having Christian conservative MAGA parents, I'd wager, is more indicative of the person falling into that leftist-child-of-rightist-parents stereotype. And even moreso conditional on [carrying out that desire].
There were people here desperately trying to spin it away from the obvious (prioritizing indeterminate evidence while ignoring damning evidence).
This appears like another typical instance of the "CAN I believe [my side did something good/their side did something bad]? Then I will," and "MUST I believe [my side did something good/their side did something bad]? Otherwise, I won't" phenomenon.
What's really galling about this is that this phenomenon is quite well known. Not common sense to the layman, but it should be common knowledge enough to people paying attention to western culture wars over the past decade or so, since active participant/observer Jonathan Haidt publicized this phenomenon quite a bit in that time. Which means that anyone who wants to make an accurate assessment about reality will actively counter this bias in themselves by choosing to hold evidence that proves [my side did something bad/their side did something good] to an almost unreasonably low standard and vice versa.
As such, those who don't do this are openly signalling a commitment to partisanship over a commitment to truth. Which is fine when that's honest, but when one's side identifies as the side of truth, science, and progress, then anyone on that side who falls into this bias without credibly attempting to counter it is perfectly comfortable with actively discrediting their own side, just for temporary tribal benefits.
I don't know, you're the one claiming it should play a role. In any case, even presuming that this were government influenced (I would bet on it, and I would absolutely default to believing that it is, because any FCC official speaking about putting pressure on anyone necessarily influences the owners towards firing them), Trump's penchant for lying has nothing to do with this being wrong. We have no law, Constitutional clause, or general ethical principle that says that the honesty we hold ourselves up to shall never be greater than the honesty we hold our political leaders to. It's wrong because the government should play basically no part in enforcing speech among people who have been given the privileges of using our public airwaves to spread their message, with the few exceptions having to do with the well known exceptions like true threats, imminent lawless action, slander, and the like. The harm that such things cause to innocent individuals in society is not contingent on the honesty of the president.
The only almost-halfway plausible argument I can think of is that the president is the leader of the country and sets the tone and standard by which other people in political discourse are judged, but this argument still isn't plausible. If we want to talk about nebulous effects of what the pattern of honesty that one particular role has on the entire country, then we have to consider all equally nebulous, equally plausible effects, such as the honesty of journalists, honesty of academics, honesty of other government officials, honesty of other people in authoritative roles, etc. and actually prove that there's something about the president's honesty that makes it more influential or more meaningful. This argument hasn't been made and, AFAICT, can't be made in an honest and correct manner, because the idea of the president as a role model for all Americans to follow in terms of honesty is not something that has been considered true for at least 3+ decades by my observations.
I wonder where this meme got started. I saw a clip of Destiny appearing on Piers Morgan's show where he was asked about condemning the shooter (or condemning those who praised the shooter and/or minimized the shooting?), and he kept deflecting by saying something about how he won't condemn anything until Trump says something to lower the temperature or something. It's such a transparently obvious piece of deflection and whataboutism that, if I weren't familiar with Destiny via his tweets, I would have had a hard time believing that Destiny could actually believe that he was coming out looking as anything other than trying to distract.
Not that Reddit posters care about the truth, but that’s another story for another day.
Indeed, and what's becoming more and more clear is that the types of Reddit users that are the source of the stereotype of Redditors don't even care about appearing to care about the truth.
Given that hyper-progressive/leftist children of hyper-conservative/rightist parents is common enough to be a stereotype and cliche unto itself, and that these types of people are rather well represented on Reddit, as well as how much extrajudicial violence against people with opinions one dislikes is an unironically supported idea among those groups in a way that it isn't among conservative/rightists families, the line of reasoning that leads to concluding that the shooter is likely to be right-wing is so blatantly and obviously faulty that it's less charitable to presume honest incompetence than to presume intentional motivated reasoning. It's a strong message that says, "I don't care about believing the truth, only about believing narratives that flatter my side, and I want you to know that I want you to know it."

This was roughly my immediate response upon seeing Harris's answer to Maddow. I found this disconcerting for a few reasons.
One is that other excerpts reveal that she's aware of the "word salad" criticism, and yet she clearly hasn't taken it seriously enough to polish up her interview/conversation/PR skills. Either she lacks the desire to improve, or she lacks the ability to improve, neither of which is a good characteristic to have in the leader of your party.
Two is that she presumably provided this answer with the expectation that the audience would go, "That is a reasonable response that properly negates Maddow's supposition." This either speaks to her having extremely low opinion of voters' understanding of logic or her lacking an ability or desire to engage in logic. Again, not what I want in the leader of my party.
Three is related to two, and it's that there was an OBVIOUS deflection RIGHT THERE! Just say that Pete polled poorly with blacks - which is a bloc we need to keep heavily shifted in our favor - for a variety of reasons. Truly, it's a mystery wrapped in an enigma, a question for the ages, something as hard to figure out as how many licks it takes to get to the center of a Tootsie Pop (if you're not a snarky owl, anyway). And in 107 days, we simply didn't have time to do the deep analysis needed to figure out what was going on and how to fix it, and so we decided to go for someone who polled better among blacks. It's an invisible fig leaf, but for people who want to see the leaf, this could've provided them enough ammo with which to convince themselves that the leaf is visible and to bully others into loudly proclaiming that the leaf is visible. And Maddow herself certainly has the motivation for the former.
More options
Context Copy link