@07mk's banner p

07mk


				

				

				
2 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 06 15:35:57 UTC

				

User ID: 868

07mk


				
				
				

				
2 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 06 15:35:57 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 868

I haven't watched the show or plan to, but your description of the phenomenon surrounding it reminds me a bit of the Netflix show Jessica Jones from about a decade back. Not nearly as big a deal in terms of being talked about for ideological messaging as Adolescence, but I ran into more than a few mentions by people about it as some great demonstration of "rape culture." When I watched the show, it was a decent superhero dramedy that was so extremely far removed from anything approaching social reality that the notion that it was some meaningful social commentary to anyone who's not actively trying to twist it that way seemed utterly absurd.

Which, I think, points to why the people talking about these shows this way are doing so: they're actively trying to twist it that way. The mainstream ideology that these people follow posits that fictional works always and inevitably have political and ideological meaning, which is why the followers so often decrt media that has the wrong messaging and also try to create media that has the right messaging. This show Adolescence seems to have enough features that allow them to see the correct patterns that properly flatter them and their messaging, and it's apparently well made to boot, so they latch on to it.

The funniest possible thing to happen now would be the writer(s) of the show being proven beyond a reasonable doubt to be unremorseful sexual predators.

This is a moral panic that Labour and the Guardian have ginned up out of literally nothing?

I don't know the answers your questions specifically, but it wouldn't surprise me if the answer to this one is Yes. Are you aware of how many actual children were confirmed to be ritually abused by satanists in the 1980s?

Basically blame the framework for brain washing people, not the people who got brainwashed.

I blame both. The framework didn't fall from the Heavens on a tablet that we must follow lest we be barred from Paradise forever, it was formed by individuals making individual decisions. The framework of brainwashing is maintained in a large part by people who were - and continue to be - brainwashed in the past, and it is only maintained because people are willing to be brainwashed. Refusing to blame the brainwashed because of the framework just reinforces the framework.

Perhaps critical thinking in higher education is truly almost all gone - I'm skeptical that "almost all gone" is an accurate description, but it's not an absurd proposition - but it's not all all gone, and it's also something individuals can develop on their own. Anyone who's intelligent enough to become a doctor - or any other sort of high level professional in such an academic field - has the full capability to develop in their own. They can notice the framework and play the game while not being subsumed by it, so as to improve the framework in the long run. Yes, it is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it, as Upton Sinclair said - this is a fairly well known quote, and educated people ought to be expected to at least understand the concept and to counter it in themselves. After all, it's difficult, not impossible, and one of the entire points of being a professional in an academic-related field is that they're capable of doing things that are intellectually difficult.

There was no Emperor of Medicine that made medical professionals overall trustworthy to the general public in the first place, either. I'm thinking that it was probably done piecemeal, by having doctors be credible by actually correctly diagnosing and fixing problems based on research that other doctors did, and having organizations that certified these people as competent being correlated with these doctors actually being competent, and the like. So this could be repeated, where whatever organization these researchers are part of taking the steps SubstantialFrivolity suggested, and this being repeated by other organizations whose employees and associates did similarly untrustworthy things. If the organizations are too big with diffuse responsibility, then we can get smaller, to the departments these researchers were part of. If the departments are similarly too big, then we can get down to the individual researchers themselves. It just needs to be done rigorously, each and every time, and eventually, over time, the overall credibility of the field will go back up, though perhaps never reaching what it once was.

They are just as fooled as everyone else, even the bad actors in this case think they are helping and doing the right thing because "these things are true, if the data doesn't match we must have done something wrong!" after years of being brainwashed.

So I don't know if this is the point that Listening is getting at, my take on this is that anyone in academia - which medicine counts as close enough and people who do medical research certainly fit - who is brainwashed is entirely responsible for their being brainwashed. One of the core themes of academia is to be skeptical, especially of oneself. This requires checking things against objective reality and listening to people who disagree with oneself, especially when it comes to narratives that sound convincing. If they bought into the propaganda efforts by the university administrations and journalist classes, then they ignored these basic, fundamental "warnings" that are core to any form of higher education.

When I'm giving my intake speach to interns and new hires I talk about "the 9 nines". That is that in order to have a minimally viable product we must meet or exceed the standards of "baseline human performance" with 99.9 999 999% reliability. Imagine a test with a billion questions where one additional incorrect answer means a failing grade.

I'm not sure what "baseline human performance" means in practice, but regardless of what actual objective criterion that means, we just have to get the error rate to be under 1/10^9 to be effective as a product, right? I don't understand how that, or any other rate you might choose, couldn't be reached, in principle.

Unimportant aside: I don't think 1 mistake in a billion is reasonable for any human or any tool, but, again, I don't know exactly what you're talking where the rubber meets the road - do you have any examples of interns who fail this or are just on the threshold, where you calculated that they fail at 1.1/10^9 or 0.9/10^9, to better illustrate this concept? But regardless, the exact number is unimportant.

In this context "Humans also hallucinate" is just not an excuse. Think about how many "visual operations" a person typically performs in the process of going about thier day. Ask yourself how many cars on your comute this afternoon, or words in this comment thread have you halucinated? A dozen? None? I you think you are sure, are you "9 nines" sure?

It's not meant to be an excuse. I'm actually not sure how many 9s sure I am that I didn't hallucinate anything in my commute today, and I'm not sure that anything in my life exceeds 9 nines certainty. I'm not sure what point this exercise is supposed to make, though. Could you explain how my not being 9 nines certain that I'm not hallucinating things like this very conversation (I'd guess I'm 3 or 4 nines sure at most?) affects the point about an LLM's ability to be useful as intelligent, semi-autonomous tools if we lower their error rate to be beneath that of a typical human serving a similar role?

The "hallucination problem" can not realistically be "solved" within the context of regression based generative models as the "hallucinations" are an emergant property of the mechanisms upon which those models function.

What does "solving" the hallucination problem look like, though? Humans also hallucinate all the time - in fact, arguably, this is one of the core reasons for the existence of this website and specifically this CW roundup thread - and it is something we've "solved" through various mechanisms of checking and verifying and holding people accountable, with none of them getting anywhere near perfect. Now, human hallucinations are more well understood than LLM ones, making them easier to predict in some ways, but why couldn't we eventually get a handle on the types of hallucinations that LLMs tend to have, allowing us to create proper control mechanisms for them such that the rate of actual consequential errors becomes lower than those caused by human hallucinations? If we reach that point, then could we say that hallucinations have been "solved?" And if not, then what does it matter if it wasn't "solved?"

From what I know about Rowling's past, I think the "ultra" part is overselling it, but not completely unwarranted from a certain point of view. But the bigger question is, is "so infected with ideological brainrot that they can't help but overtly infect their fictional stories with their ideology" just a part of the definition of "old school leftie ultrafeminist?" I feel like that's more a characteristic of the modern variety.

I don't know what Rowling was thinking when writing the books, but I figured she wanted to tell a good and market-appealing story first, which in this case involved a boy protagonist, and she did put in bits of 90s-feminist messaging like the hypercompetent Hermione as one of the core supporting cast. Like how the Disney cartoons in the 90s were clearly generally feminist but sometimes involved a male protagonist getting the girl as in Aladdin or the female protagonist finding love with a man as in The Little Mermaid.

The point of my thought experiment was to demonstrate that in principle there can be cases where it's correct for a humanities teacher to mark down a student based on the positions they hold, and not just the quality of the argument. I'm not convinced that "any non-trivial question in the humanities will simply fall far far below that bar". Perhaps bringing HBD into it confused the issue - suppose a student handed in a paper arguing that the pyramids were built by Atlantean aliens from Planet Theta. Wouldn't that be pretty analogous to the flat-earther geology student? Wouldn't you want a serious history teacher to mark down the paper relative to an equally-eloquent one that presented a basically sane theory of the pyramids' origin?

I'd want the serious history teacher to mark down the paper only if the argument that the Atlantean aliens from Planet Theta built it was truly bad. Which should almost definitely be the case, if we're in reality. If it is the case that, somehow, the student was able to form an argument based on the best available empirical evidence and best available analysis using the best available methods that was exactly as rigorous and fact-based as another student's argument that it was built by Egyptian slaves or whatever, then I'd want the history teacher to give that student the same grade. I don't know why you write "eloquent" in this example, when eloquence has almost nothing to do with the quality of an argument.

If there is blame to be assigned, it goes to the architects of the conspiracy, not to people in unrelated fields who go by the mainstream scientific consensus. And if you go by the mainstream scientific consensus, then "racism explains Africa's subpar development" is trivially false and dangerous misinformation, in the same way as "the Earth is flat".

Perhaps my assignment of blame to the history teacher was more severe than is warranted. If it is indeed the case that the entire field of history (or humanities in general) is so biased that any typical history teacher can't be reasonably held to account for believing the bias, this speaks to even more horrific levels of incompetence in the entire field. What you're describing is a situation that's similar to what I described, but severely worse. As in, to refer back to my earliest comment in this thread, the situation in academia is even worse than the worst things that people here were criticizing with respect to ideological bias in academia and similar institutions.

What's unfortunate is, I think you're probably right on this.

In Thought Experiment Land, sure. But in the real world, it would be clear that the student had started from the bonkers conclusion and worked backwards, and I would want the teacher to mark him down, both to make it very clear to him that the claim is nonsense he should un-learn ASAP, and to teach him that you shouldn't assume the conclusion in the first place, let alone a crazy one.

You're the one who brought us into Thought Experiment Land, though. The point of TEL is that it's analogous to the real thing we're talking about, and so I was simply explaining the analogous setup. All analogies are faulty, and so comparing Flat Earthism with racism/homophobia is also faulty, and the fact that Flat Earthism is obviously and absurdly wrong by empirical evidence is something we'd have to accept as a fault in the analogy and work around, so that the analogy makes sense, i.e. that it's entirely reasonable for someone to use best practices and best evidence to come to the conclusion of Flat Earth. This would be absurd in the real world, but, again, we're not in the real world, we're in Thought Experiment Land, by your own choice.

That's a fair point. But to the extent it holds, to the extent that homophobia or racism are moral issues and therefore different magisteria from science - then students shouldn't be "arguing in favor of" them either - any more than teachers should be looking for the converse.

Hard disagree. The point of humanities is, in part, to learn to argue for squishy things like morals or politics or ideologies, and that's done in a large part by having students actually make arguments in favor of these things with the understanding that their grading isn't based on the "correctness" of their conclusions, but rather the quality of the arguments they make. This was pretty standard fair when I was in school, where, in history class, we did roleplaying to argue in favor of and against things like slavery, democracy, monarchy, and the like. Sometimes we were assigned roles, other times we chose roles based on our own preferences, and either way, the education occurred through our thinking through these arguments and we were graded on the quality of those arguments. I think this is a good thing and useful for students to learn. This goes double for concepts and ideas that are well outside the Overton window and specifically ones that people in authority find offensive or dangerous.

So when you wrote "arguments in favor of homophobia or racism" I assumed you meant answers to questions of fact where some claims are designated as racist or homophobic - "claims about how homophobia and racism affect society and individuals within it,", as you say. "Why is Europe more successful than Africa" is a valid historical question, for example, but one for which some factual answers would be deemed racist - eg "because blacks are genetically dumber and more violent than caucasians".

(You might, of course, believe there is something to that, as a question of fact. But assuming we take the opposite to be definitive, demonstrated scientific fact on par with "the Earth is round" - or, simply, assuming the history teacher believes it to be so in good faith - then it doesn't seem to be wrong on the history teacher's part to mark down an essay which takes it to be true, no matter how eloquent it is.)

Right, if the history teacher is assuming this to be true, in good faith, that speaks to a truly horrific level of incompetence and bias by the history teacher, in terms of epistemic certainty about history or sociology or the humanities in general. There are very few things in reality that are as well demonstrated as "the Earth is round," and any non-trivial question in the humanities will simply fall far far below that bar. Anyone with any appreciation for academia, and especially one whose role is to teach students, ought to be aware of this. Especially if we're considering a case where the history teacher is judging the veracity of claims like "Europe is more successful than Africa because [XYZ]" based on the fact that [XYZ] was deemed to be racist, rather than on the specific scientific claims of [XYZ] and the empirical evidence surrounding it, which seemed to be the implication in the original situation and is certainly the case in most such cases I've observed both in and outside of academic settings.

The modern iteration is…an activist

So fittingly enough, she was the paradigmatic young woman, in the context of the Modern Audience^(tm).

If a geology student used all the best scientific practices and all the best available empirical evidence and all the best arguments by the standards of all the best geologists that somehow ended up with a convincing conclusion that the Earth was flat, then the geology teacher would absolutely be in the wrong for marking down the student.

In any case, questions of moral truths like "is homophobia or racism wrong" is categorically different from questions of empirical facts like "is the Earth flat," and to whatever extent academics conflate the two, they ought to be called out and actively denigrated for it. The purpose of humanities education is to teach how to properly think through these moral truths (as well as other things), not what to properly conclude about these moral truths.

A sociology class that deems certain moral truths out of bounds isn't a sociology class, it's a religious sermon. Sociology can make claims about how homophobia and racism affect society and individuals within it, and the teacher can even make the argument that these effects are bad, but once they cross the line into demanding that students conform to their own judgments of what's bad and good, they're taking on the role of preacher, not teacher. "Deleterious" and "wrong" are not synonyms.

Zegler isn’t ugly but next to Gadot Zegler looks like a soft 6. Relative casting matters.

Given how they apparently changed the way "fairest" meant in this remake, I actually wonder if the relative looks here was the point. Of course, they couldn't hire someone outright ugly as the lead, but making sure that she's significantly and noticeably less attractive than the Evil Queen (very easy to do when you cast Gadot as her) could have been consciously intentional for the purpose of sending little girls the message that good looks are bad, actually. It's interesting, though, that the original film had a pretty overt message about the evilness of vanity, which gets lost when you replace the Evil Queen's obsession about being the fairest-as-in-beautiful to fairest-as-in-just. I don't know how the remake justifies it, but it seems bizarre that a Queen who intentionally sends her King off to die and oppresses her happy subjects would obsess over a magic mirror's judgment of her as being fair-as-in-just. Perhaps there's some way the Queen's perspective is presented in a way to show that she actually genuinely believes that she is a just ruler? Given how much Disney's been into redeeming female villains like Cruella DeVille or Maleficent, this could've been a good opportunity to show her as a misguided soul who was traumatized by a man in her past that led her to an obsession with being a just ruler that nonetheless turned into evil. I haven't heard that from any reviews, though.

It sounds like much of the film was written with conscious messaging in mind, based on the descriptions I read and saw of the plot, which seems to involve pretty unambiguous pro-Communist messaging, and also an addition of a plot point presenting Dopey as someone unfairly bullied for his muteness and who turns out to be able to talk in the end.

Assuming all of this is entirely accurate, it seems exactly as bad a situation as the worst things that people are complaining about here. In a humanities course, someone being marked down for making arguments in favor of open homophobia and racism is utterly horrifying. It defeats the entire purpose of a humanities education to judge students' capabilities based on the conclusions they land at, rather than the arguments and reasoning they use to land at those arguments. Some professors might claim that only bad reasoning could land at those conclusions, but that, in itself, would be even more perverse, in a humanities professor being that simple- or closed-minded as to hold such a belief.

I didn't think that was the point of the dog analogy, but if that were, then indeed, you're right it's a poor analogy for this.

The joke isn't a scenario where the dog plays chess under such unusual circumstances that it doesn't mean the dog is smart.

I don't think it would make sense for a dog to be able to play chess at all while also that not meaning that the dog is "smart" in some real sense. Perhaps it doesn't understand the rules of chess or the very concept of a competitive board game, but if it's able to push around the pieces on the board in a way that conforms to the game's rules in a manner that allows it to defeat humans (who are presumably competent at chess and genuinely attempting to win) some non-trivial percentage of the time through its own volition without some marionette strings or external commands or something, I would characterize that dog as "smart." Perhaps the dog had an extra smart trainer, but I doubt that even an ASI-level smart trainer could train the smartest real-life dog in the real world to that level.

And imagine that it's 1981 and someone is showing you their brand new ZX81. The exact same thing happens that happens with the dog, down to you saying that the chess program can be beaten nine times out of ten. Should you conclude that actually, ZX81s are really really smart because playing chess at all is impressive? Or should you conclude that even though humans use general intelligence to play chess, the ZX81 instead uses a very nonhuman specialized method, and the ZX81 isn't very smart despite how impressive playing chess is?

This last sentence doesn't make sense to me either. Yes, I would conclude that the ZX81 uses a very nonhuman specialized method, and I'd characterize its "ability" (obviously unlike a dog, it has no agency) to play chess in this way as "smart" in some real, meaningful sense. Obviously it's not any sort of generalized "smartness" that can apply to any other situation. If we were living at a time when a computer that could play chess wasn't even a thing, and someone introduced me to a chess bot that he could defeat only 9 times out of 10, I would find it funny if he downplayed that, as in the dog joke.

If a few years later the ZX81 was replaced with a Commodore 64, and you couldn't beat the Commodore 64 in chess, would you decide that the ZX81 is dumb, but the Commodore 64 is smart?

I'd conclude that the Commodore 64 is "smarter than" the ZX81 (I'm assuming we're using the computer names as shorthand for the software that they actually run on the hardware, here). Again, not in some sort of generalized sense, but certainly in a real, meaningful sense in the realm of chess playing.

When it comes to actual modern AI, we're, of course, talking primarily about LLMs, which generate text really really well, so it could be considered "smart" in that one realm. I'm on the fence about and mostly skeptical that LLMs will or can be the basis for an AGI in the future. But I think it's a decent argument that strings of text can be translated to almost any form of applied intelligence, and so by becoming really, really good at putting together strings of text, LLMs could be used as that basis for AGI. I think modern LLMs are clearly nowhere near there, with Claude Plays Pokemon the latest really major example of its failures, from what I understand. We might have to get to a point where the gap between the latest LLM and ChatGPT4.5 is greater than the gap between ChatGPT4.5 and ELIZA before that happens, but I could see it happening.

Wokeness is a reaction to that memeplex and is part of the antibody response to further your analogy, it's actually part of the dealing with the overreach.

If we're going by this analogy, I'd say it's far more accurate to say that wokeness is a sort of autoimmune disease on the antibody that's making the antibodies less effective while also taking up the resources that the original infection would've taken up. Like, the principles that make the antibodies effective against the religious memeplex are being actively destroyed by wokeness, and though it's also attacking traditional religious memes, it's doing so by replacing it with progressive religious memes. It's clearly not the antibodies, but STRONGER, it's something else entirely that looks very similar to the original infection that the antibodies are attacking, but with the right signal proteins or whatever that causes the original antibodies to welcome them.

As designed, harm has not occurred in these situations. Do you feel like the people (who indeed are numerous) who feel something morally reprehensible has occurred in both are engaged in silly superstition, or are you willing to concede that morality has more dimensions than the singular concern for harm reduction?

I always used to be confused why people considered this a gotcha or a particularly interesting question, cuz I thought it was obvious that there was absolutely no moral impropriety in either case, that only people who held on to silly superstitions would think otherwise, and I thought that this was basically the the position of most Democrats/liberals.

Now I understand that I was the weird/foolish one for actually believing people when they said that they were liberal.

It's still silly superstition, though.

I suppose there's an untapped market for specific fan fiction/ slashfics for niche fandoms, but archive of our own and fan fiction.net are chock full of almost anything you would want to read in this regard.

This is where I disagree, at least in the realm of weeb fanart (I don't read/write fanfiction, but I imagine it's not dissimilar). There are orders of magnitude more possible niches and tastes than there are artists to fill them, such that I regularly run into concepts that I want to see that I simply cannot find that even one amateur illustrator has created and posted online.

For a concrete example, one common "genre" of fanart is having two characters voiced by the same voice actor cosplaying each other, sometimes in a way that directly copies official art of the character. I wanted to see fanart of Jean from Genshin Impact cosplaying Hitagi from Bakemonogatari (both voiced by Chiwa Saito), and done in a way that copies official promotional Bakemonogatari art, in a style as if drawn by Akio Watanabe (the actual artist who drew the actual official promotional art and did the character designs for the anime). Searching the usual places like Danbooru or Gelbooru or Pixiv, I found that not even a single example of such a cosplay fanart existed, much less one that directly copied official art and in the same style as the official artist. So I made some using Stable Diffusion. I've done similar things with other bits of fanart, based around scenarios I like to imagine they encounter in their fictional everyday lives, or in an alternate universe or whatever; unpopular characters don't get much fanart to begin with, and them doing niche activities is even rarer. Combine that with desire to see it in certain artists' styles, and you get a combinatoric explosion of possibilities that the rather limited number of skilled human illustrators simply can't fill.

I imagine fanfiction could have even more possibilities that go unfulfilled if not for generative AI, due to how many different combinations of character interactions and plot events there are. There's probably a million different Harry Potter/Ron Weasley slashfics on AO3, but does it have one that also sets it in the backdrop of a specific plot that some particular fujoshi wants, with the particular style of writing she wants to read, and with the specific sequence of relationship escalations and speedbumps that she wants to see? Maybe for some fujoshi, but probably not for most.

They didn't, because 1) They don't in general see a DEI statement as being analagous to supporting Trump or a wall. They see being anti-racist as something any decent person should do.

This just seems like describing the how, rather than contradicting the notion that they metaphorically put up walls and man the gates against conservatives so firmly: they do so by genuinely believing that being anti-racist (by their conception of anti-racism) is something any decent person should do and rejecting the contention that this belief is due to their partisanship rather than due to it being true. It's particularly a severe failure for academia, where one of the ostensible main themes is the inescapability of individual bias and the need to correct for it through multiple contrasting perspectives.

If the dog was playing chess using some method that was not like how humans play chess, and which couldn't generalize to being able to play well, the joke wouldn't be very funny.

Humor is subjective and all that, but I don't understand this perspective. I'd find the joke exactly as funny no matter what way the dog was playing chess, whether it was thinking through its moves like a human theoretically is, or, I dunno, moving pieces by following scents that happened to cause its nose to push pieces in ways that followed the rules and was good enough to defeat a human player at some rate greater than chance. The humor in the joke to me comes from the player downplaying this completely absurd super-canine ability the dog has, and that ability remains the same no matter how the dog was accomplishing this, and no matter if it wouldn't imply any sort of general ability for the dog to become better at chess. Simply moving the pieces in a way that follows the rules most of the time would already be mindblowingly impressive for a dog, to the extent that the joke would still be funny.

In this specific sort of example, the cheat code that people discovered was claiming that due process that includes things like trying to figure out the facts of the matter based on evidence was misogynistic when applied to women accusing men of bad sexual behavior. This, I think, was an instantiation of the larger principle that "lived experiences" described by people who were categorized as "oppressed" were incontrovertible. It seems to me that more and more people are growing wise to this vulnerability, which makes me wonder what the next cheat code will be, to circumvent inconvenient things like the sort of due process you're talking about.

Ultimate is a team field sport with a lot of running and jumping, so I'd guess the male advantage in ultimate is even more pronounced. In mixed leagues, person-to-person defense is almost 100% on a same-sex basis, with very few exceptions when there's a woman who's particularly tall and/or athletic (this never happens in the top levels of the sport, but at the levels that I play, it's been known to happen).

I imagine the sex differences in disc golf have primarily to do with distance in throwing, which is very easily observed in ultimate as well. Each point begins with a "pull," which is like a kickoff in American football, where one player on the defensive team throws the disc from behind their own end zone line (running start allowed, but disc must be released before they cross the line). At even medium levels, men regularly throw the full 70 yards of the field, and at top levels, they regularly throw the full 90 yards that includes the 20 yard end zone. At the top levels, it's the rare woman who's able to cover the full 70 yards of the field. This difference is present and quite noticeable in long throws during the point as well, where, at the top levels, men's games tend to be more huck-heavy, since they can score with one throw from anywhere on the field, while women's games tend to be more based around shorter throws. This isn't universal, though.

Is it some kind of some kind of moral self-validation first and foremost?

I think this is a major part of it. There has been plenty written about how the purity-spiraling progressive left, i.e. the woke/idpol/crt/dei/sjw crowd, are following a religion that fills a vacuum left by the rejection of traditional religions, so I won't reiterate it here. The thing about religions is that you don't need to win in any way that makes sense in the real world to win according to the tenets of your religion. In the case of this religion, being more pure than thou is one way of winning.

And likely there's a major self-validation component to it as well, in that this group of people tend to be far more individualistic than most people, valuing freedom and self-expression far greater than most people. This is evident in many things, including their hair/tattoo/piercing/fashion choices and their support for transing children. Thus it would make sense that they put greater value in the individual feeling of righteousness they get from putting down someone less pure than them than in their movement winning more supporters and becoming more capable of affecting change in this world.

Competitions are mainly about status and the purpose of sex-segregated sports is not to keep the league fair per se. It is really because society intuitively understands that regardless of the differences between men and women, female athletes should not be penalized in status. The same is true for disabled athletes, which is why we have the special olympics and other sporting events like that.

This reminds me of a serious argument I've seen someone make in the ultimate Frisbee community, for why transwomen ought to play with women despite admitting that transwomen, especially ones who haven't done any sort of medical transitioning, have a physical advantage: that transwomen suffer so much bigotry in their everyday lives that we just ought to accommodate them in this one thing. It doesn't make sense from a fair sports play perspective, but from the perspective of just seeing this as a question of status, it kinda does.