I thought that what we were interested in was 1 - we want to know the real process so that we can shape or modify it to suit our needs. So I'm confused as to why, it seems to me, some commentators behave as if the thought box tells us anything relevant.
I think all 3 are interesting in different ways, but in any case, I don't perceive commenters as exploring 1. Do you have any examples?
If we were talking about humans, for instance, we might say, "Joe used XYZ Pokemon against ABC Pokemon because he noticed that ABC has weakness to water, and XYZ has a water attack." This might also be what consciously went through Joe's mind before he pressed the buttons to make that happen. All that would be constrained entirely to 2. In order to get to 1, we'd need to discuss the physics of the neurons inside Joe's brain and how they were stimulated by the signals from his retina that were stimulated by the photons coming out of the computer screen which come from the pixels that represent Pokemons XYZ and ABC, etc. For an LLM, the analog would be... something to do with the weights in the model and the algorithms used to predict the next word based on the previous words (I don't know enough about how the models work beneath the hood to get deeper than that).
In both humans and LLMs, 1 would be more precise and accurate in a real sense, and 2 would be mostly ad hoc justifications. But 2 would still be interesting and also useful for predicting behavior.
No one is under the delusion that the "thinking" box reflects the actual underlying process by which the LLM generates the text that does the actual decision making. This is just like humans, where no one actually expects that the internal conscious thoughts that someone uses to think through some decision before arriving at a conclusion reflects the actual underlying process by which the human makes the decision. The "thinking" box is the equivalent of that conscious thought process that a human goes through before coming to the decision, and in both, the text there appears to influence the final decision.
Well, if enough people are bad at using language properly in the exact same way, then I'd argue that it's the language that's not proper, not the people. It's hard to say where the tipping point is and if the tipping point has been reached, though.
Traditionally, yes. But just like how people keep using "could care less" to mean "couldn't care less (because I care so little that it is physically impossible for me to care any less than I already do now)," people keep using "reign in" to mean "rein in." I think "could care less" has become common enough to become a correct version of the phrase, and I think "reign in" is getting there in terms of how common it is, at least in online text.
I've come to terms with the fact that "could" actually means "could not" when it precedes "care less," but I think I've yet to come to terms with the fact that "reign" actually means "to restrain or stop, like pulling on the strap for controlling a horse" when it precedes "in."
Post hoc justification might explain some of it, but given how much this idea of "overwhelmingly male hobbies like scifi, comic books, and video games are leaving money on the table by designing products to cater to them, and they could make unalloyed gains just by making changes in accordance with my ideology" was in vogue in the 00s well before Star Wars was even bought by Disney, I think the pre hoc justification makes more sense.
It's not actually clear that "the oppressed" succeed less in the industry. They succeed at different things because groups are different. Barbie dragged up Oppenheimer's numbers, not vice versa. It's just a naive form of blank slateism at play.
The rest of your comment explains the blank state-ism causing these issues well, I think. But this part, I don't think it even goes that far. Oppression and privilege, as used and defined by SocJus/idpol/progressive left/woke/whatever the fuck they refuse to be called on this particular day, are fundamentally faith-based. There's a veneer of science based on academic literature, but even the most cursory look at the primary documents shows that it's all just made up ad hoc, with essentially infinite degrees of freedom. And when you have that many degrees of freedom, you can always position [person you like] into [position that will allow them to extract resources from others] and vice versa. The underlying facts simply don't matter, since you can always add more epicycles as needed in order to land at the correct conclusion.
Imagine if the Cocoa Cola company had responded to the New Coke debacle with a bunch of attack ads implying their customers were just idiots with bad taste. Or if Johnson & Johnson had responded to the Chicago Tylenol killings with a series of bus ads that read “Tylenol: It’s perfectly safe, you’re just a fucking pussy”
Imagine if you grew up all your life surrounded by people who browbeat each other into certain political/ideological positions through calling them bigoted. Imagine if your entire political/ideological ecosystem of figuring out truth and values is structured around this sort of behavior. Imagine if your entire social media ecosystem is structured around shutting up people that you dislike, while creating just the right amount of space for disagreement to convince you that you're seeing arguments that challenge your beliefs and values without actually challenging your beliefs and values, and you see the people who control the social media companies reinforcing and strengthening this sandbox more and more.
You just might start thinking that this strategy would work when selling products to a mainstream audience. In fact, you might think that you'd be utterly foolish not to use this strategy.
The problem is that Trump isn’t bad enough for this to work. Whether you agree or not, the worst things you can say about him are things that are positive. He’s doing exactly what he said he would do, and he’s taking a sledgehammer to the federal government and cleaning up redundant positions. It just doesn’t work to make an entire political party be the anti-Trump when you can’t actually make a case that he’s doing something wrong.
Perhaps you can say that many of the "bad" qualities of Trump are actually considered good-to-neutral by many of the group of people who aren't rabidly anti-Trump. But the proof of the pudding is in the eating, and the eating hasn't taken place in his second term yet. We'll see how the various issues play out, but I'm personally pessimistic about the economy, and that is likely to be a major factor in swinging voters if he makes things worse like many economists are predicting or even if he doesn't make things better by enough.
In terms of the strategy in 2024 and leading up to it, I'd mostly agree. Even before the election, the electorate's dissatisfaction with the status quo was a major talking point (though I'm not sure that that many people saw it as the major factor), and so without a clear vision for how the current sitting Vice President would change things other than just being the First Black Woman POTUS and Not Being Trump, complaining about how extreme Trump was not a good move. Hindsight is 20/20, of course, though, and I won't claim that it was obviously a losing move, at least not to me.
Democrats have mispositioned themselves for the past couple years, but they can jettison the most unpopular parts of their electoral coalition and come back again and win.
They certainly can. I hope they will. I'll just say, fool me once, shame on you, fool me... you can't get fooled again.
All I see in the DNC is weird ideological crusades, corruption, and zero sum power jockeying.
I think SSCReader explained this pretty well. Basically, if all you see besides corruption and zero sum power jockeying - which are about as universal to humanity as death and taxes by my lights - are weird ideological crusades, well, there's a good reason for that. It was way back in 2014 that I noticed that SocJus was clearly a religion that was intrinsically faith-based, and I'm quite sure I was nowhere near the first to notice that. The past 10 years has only made me more sure of this, and it has also convinced me that there's some veracity to the theory that the typical human mind has a god-shaped hole in it that necessarily gets filled by something.
Ukrianian corruption has no relevance in the context of the Russian invasion. Ukraine could be a hellhole, and it still doesn’t deserve to be invaded. Bringing up “Ukrainian corruption” is repeating Russian propaganda in an attempt to justify the invasion.
I disagree. I think Ukrainian corruption is quite relevant when it comes to how and how much 3rd parties might want to fund Ukraine's defenses. Just because Ukraine doesn't deserve to be invaded doesn't mean that it deserves to be helped in its defense by anyone else. The world isn't just, and it's also not anyone's responsibility to make it just. One can certainly argue that we ought to make it more just by making sure Russia's unjust invasion doesn't get rewarded, but taking that point for granted amounts to treating it like a religious crusade rather than politics and war.
More broadly, jumping to conclusions about motives and implications based on simple statements of judgment is something I'd rather see much less of in all contexts, and certainly on The Motte, and if you believe that doing so is correct, I believe you are correct that you'd be better off just ignoring this site.
I don't intend this to sound condescending, but this parallel has been so obvious to me for probably the better part of a decade by now, that I'm surprised that someone on TheMotte would only notice it now. Though perhaps it actually speaks ill of me and my hobby of paying attention to the culture wars around popular media that I noticed the parallels so early and found it so obvious.
The all-woman Ghostbusters remake came out in 2016, almost a full decade ago, and that was one of the earlier big examples of the whole "we didn't fail the audience; the sexist, misogynistic audience failed us by not giving us money to spend 2 hours watching our film" narrative being made. That was 2 years after Gamergate, which wasn't quite that specifically, but it was a major flashpoint in video game culture where major video game journalists, devs, and commentators were explicitly telling their customers that their tastes were wrong, and that they had a responsibility to submit to the enlightened, correct tastes of the then "social justice" (equivalent to "woke" today) crowd. This knocked over some dominoes that resulted in many video games designed to appeal to that SocJus crowd being released 5-10 years later, i.e. the last 5 years. Examples of these include failures like Concord or Suicide Squad: Kill the Justice League from last year, as well as successes like The Last of Us: Part 2 and God of War: Ragnarok (I suspect that it's not a coincidence that these successes were both sequels to hugely popular games that built on a strong base).
In film, besides 2016's Ghostbusters, 2017's The Last Jedi, as well as most Star Wars works that followed, and 2019's Captain Marvel, as well as most Marvel movies that followed, were major examples of this phenomenon. And though many of these films did fine or even great in the box office, they had plenty of controversy around more old-school fans reacting negatively to various plot points and characterizations, and then being called bigots in return both by filmmakers and commentators. There were smaller examples as well, such as Terminator: Dark Fate or the Charlie's Angels remake-remake, both of which bombed in 2019.
A big part of it, I think, is that SocJus mentality, of all of reality being dominated by power differentials, and as such, each individual of [demographic] is necessarily disadvantaged compared to each individual of [some other demographic]. This means that if that individual of [demographic] fails or just doesn't succeed as much as they imagine an individual of [some other demographic] would have, then their failure is due to the bigoted society that created these power dynamics that made them disadvantaged, rather than due to that individual's own flaws. This, of course, is how millionaire stars can claim to be lacking in "privilege" - the claim isn't that they're not wildly successful, but rather that they aren't as wildly successful as an equivalent person of [some other demographic] would have been. Also of course, this is completely unfalsifiable.
And if you approach things with that mindset, that belonging to [demographic] means that any failure is due to the structural bigotry that reinforces the power dynamics of society, then naturally, when your film/video game/electoral candidate fails, you're going to blame structural bigotry. I.e. your audience, the gamers, the voters.
Also of course, if you just blame external factors, it hampers your ability to self-improve. But you can still succeed as long as all those external factors submit to your demands; if calling someone racist can get them to buy your game, then that's just as good as just making a better game. In practice, this doesn't really work. But the people making these decisions seem to be in echo chambers where calling people racist does get them to submit to their demands. And while everyone lives in echo chambers to some extent, the left/progressive/Democratic crowd has been very openly and very explicitly calling for strengthening the boundaries of their own echo chambers through censorship of opposing voices. Which leads them to model the general audience very poorly. Which costs you money. If you have a big bankroll, you can keep going with that for a while, but eventually, that money runs out. I think 2024 was a big year for when many of these decision makers finally recognized that they were able to see the bottom of the barrel of money they've been feeding their projects. In video games, we might see an actual closure of Ubisoft this year, depending on how their next Assassin's Creed game - one that had direct inspiration from the BLM riots of 2020 according to a developer, IIRC - does, after the mediocre reception of their Star Wars game last year.
I wonder if the Democrats will eventually have a moment when the stark reality of their failures simply can't be tolerated anymore, resulting in a change in tact. I was hopeful right after the election last year, but most signs since then have made me pessimistic. I just hope it comes sooner than later, because, as bad as SocJus is, I fully expect Republicans to be just as bad if they find that they have nearly unchecked power without a strong opposition party.
Does a union work rule have any jurisdiction in how one controls one's own electronics in one's own home? The only way I could see that applying is if someone rents from a landlord that has some exclusive deal with some union to maintain the property, which seems possible but I have no idea how common that is. I was also under the impression that even renters have substantial rights over their homes that override the desires of the landlord. In Massachusetts, I know that landlords aren't allowed to enter the premises without the renter's permission, for instance.
IANAL, but I also can't see such a rule being enforceable or legal, given how much of a personal and public safety issue that unpowered smoke alarms can cause.
Maybe we should distinguish our terminology somewhat - perhaps the Doom demons are intelligent but not sapient? And I previously used the word 'intelligence' synonymously with sapience, rather than with this lower level of simulated agency?
I'd agree with this characterization. I also would say that, personally, I don't associate intelligence with deserving rights. That opens a door that I'd rather keep quite shut. I don't think these terms are completely clear cut, but it seems fair enough to say sapience, sentience, consciousness, ability to suffer, are things id associate with deserving rights.
I'd say that, if your laptop is running Doom with its artificial intelligence runtimes controlling the way an imp moves around on your screen, then it's displaying intelligence. Likewise if it's running a local LLM to produce text based on text-based inputs. I see intelligence as the ability to solve complex problems, such as making brown pixels appear as a demon attempting to murder you or producing text that appears as a conversation partner in response to a prompt. Where exactly that line for "complex" is drawn is admittedly pretty vague and correctly controversial, though.
I think many parts of AI hypotheticals are interesting, including whether or not they're conscious or have agency and whether or not they're dangerous. But in terms of real-world applications of modern and upcoming AI, I think the danger/use part is far more interesting than the consciousness part. I expect that, for the near future, it's highly unlikely that we'll get AI that we can say with any meaningful level of confidence is "conscious" or has subjective experience or whatever, but it's almost certain that we'll get AI that's useful/dangerous (arguably, this has already happened). I think there's a high chance we'll get AI that appears to have agency in the near future as well.
Also, about the affirmative action argument, yes, this is why it's a super questionable solution. Can't you imagine some world though in which the de facto violations of meritocracy are so bad that a de jure violation might actually end up improving the de facto situation? I definitely agree that it's usually not a good idea to use bad means for what you think will be good ends.
One major problem with this situation right now is that, for as much as we can certainly imagine that world, the organizations and individuals that society has relied on to check if our real world is at all similar to that imagined world have so destroyed their credibility that we can't actually trust their claims that they verified that our world is similar to that imagined world. It may be possible to regain that credibility within my lifetime, but I'm skeptical that that will happen, and I'm pretty sure it won't happen in any time frame meaningfully shorter than that.
Which is to say, the very notion that there are good ends to be pursued here is contingent upon something that we have no way of verifying is true. That doesn't mean it's not true, but it does mean that it should be taken about as seriously as people claiming that some Jewish conspiracy is what's making Jews so successful or whatever.
I find this argument strange, because being able to kill me is not evidence of a machine being conscious or intelligent.
Thus I'm going to give the chad "yes". Maybe one day I get killed by a robot, and maybe that robot is not conscious and has no self-awareness. That it killed me proves nothing.
It seems to me that you pretty much agree with the commenter you're responding to, that it simply doesn't matter if the AI has consciousness, qualia, or self-awareness. Intelligence, though, is something else. And whether or not the AI has something akin to internal, subjective experience, if it's intelligent enough, then it's both impressive and potentially dangerous. And that's the part that matters.
There's something funny in a through-the-looking-glass sort of way about the way the term "woke" has evolved the past decade or so. In entering the mainstream, it became a way to describe old-school racism/sexism/bigotry/etc., just in a "progressive" direction, using a term that sounded nice, in a way that would be palatable to people who liked to think of themselves as against old-school racism/sexism/bigotry/etc. But it quickly became identified with that underlying thing it was describing, and now it's being used to describe the old old-school racism/sexism/bigotry/etc. in the traditional direction, as a way to denigrate it. Perhaps because terms like "racism," "sexism," etc. lost their edge due to constantly being used to describe completely innocuous and often virtuous things, while terms like "woke" kept being used to describe things that were traditionally called "racist," "sexist," etc.
I've quoted Shakespeare before, that a rose by any other name smells just as sweet, and shit by any other name stinks just as foul. Observing this real-time shuffling of words around meanings has been fascinating. It seems that activists who helped to popularize the term "woke" have a real, good faith belief that changing the words we use really, truly, actually changes the underlying thing in some real way - they get high off their own supply, so to speak.
Other times, your foot gets infected, and if you don't cut off everything from the knee down, your entire body shuts down. And other times, some cells in your breast starts reproducing uncontrollably, and if you don't cut off most of the breast, again, your entire body shuts down. The pain and loss of those healthy cells - a majority of the cells that were cut off were probably healthy! - are real and shouldn't be downplayed. But sometimes it's the least worst option.
I'd say that infections that spread toxicity through the rest of the body or a cancerous growth that grows uncontrollably in a way that crowds out and kills the healthy cells are better metaphors for this situation in academia than a prefrontal cortex sometimes not making the best decisions.
I don't see how this responds to anything I wrote. The idea that a house elf in Harry Potter or an elevator operator in Brave New World is "downtrodden" due to "power inequalities" is, in itself a rejection of transhumanism. It just seems to me like you're just trying to have your cake and eat it too.
To get back to the topic of this scifi gender-dysphoria-B-gone pill vs sex-change-down-to-the-molecular-level surgery, I still contend that a desire for transhumanism can't support the latter without supporting the former. There could be other reasons for supporting the latter without supporting the former, but that'd be something like believing in the sanctity of the mind over body. Which many people do believe in, on the basis of the eternal soul. But which also isn't convincing to people who don't believe in souls.
Such is the trap of value systems, you can't really live without one and any sort of conscious change to yours may run against your current one, like in the tale of Gandhi and the pacifism-reducing pills. Even those mindsets that the orthodox consider "deviation" and "degeneracy" are, by definition, part of the human condition. There is nothing in the Codex of Transhumanism that says we ought to keep our minds so open that anything can fall in.
Sure, and that's not an argument against what I pointed out. Again, there's no particular reason to believe that those societies would be "failure modes" of a transhuman future.
Like, the whole house elf analogy just reminds me of Brave New World, which was a novel that played around with that concept quite a bit more than in Harry Potter. I don't see any good reason why a transhumanist wouldn't consider that society a perfectly cromulent one. And personally, I would see that world as a very good one to live in, if not to aim for achieving in our own.
But calling those "failure modes" seems, in itself, to be against transhumanism. You or I with our value systems shaped by our human society and human biology and psychology might find those to be failures, but who knows how someone who's transcended their humanity would judge it? Fundamentally, there's no way to tell, and so if we want to keep in the spirit of transhumanism, we ought to keep our minds open.
I'm also skeptical that the typical person encountering this hypothetical is considering the things that you're positing, not even implicitly or subconsciously.
Similarly I would rather be more attractive than be able to tolerate the fruits of being less attractive; would rather be able to achieve my goals with less work than be able to work more, etc.
These don't seem similar, though. If we applied the framework of these things to being trans, it would mean that a transwoman isn't someone who simply feels like a woman and thus wants to change his body to match it, it's someone whose goal is for other humans to treat him like a woman (analogous to your 1st example) or whose goal is to physically appear as a woman (analogous to your 2nd). Those are different things.
It's also not clear to me how it's more freedom to change one's body than to change one's mind. From my experience, changing one's body quite drastically is often quite easy, but changing one's mind even a little is often quite difficult. It's fundamentally difficult to compare the two, but I'd argue that being able to manipulate our minds as freely as we manipulate our physical bodies is more transhumanist, not less, than just wanting to manipulate our physical bodies to match our minds. I think, to most people, a non-humanoid like a cartoon cat or non-android robot that seems to think and behave like a human is "more human" in some sense than something that appears biologically like a human but seems to think and behave in a way that's completely foreign to humans. At the extremes, I think that people consider ChatGPT "more human" in some way than an android sex doll. So it seems to me that if we want to transcend our humanity, having the freedom to manipulate our minds as easily as taking a pill is at least as significant as having the freedom to manipulate our physical bodies to be the other sex.

This is what would make sense to me, but over and over again, I see people claiming to believe and acting like they believe the opposite, that good poll numbers for a candidate actually encourages more people to vote for that candidate rather than the candidate's opponent. I don't quite get it, but, well, people behave based on what they believe, not based on what they should believe.
More options
Context Copy link