@07mk's banner p

07mk


				

				

				
2 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 06 15:35:57 UTC

				

User ID: 868

07mk


				
				
				

				
2 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 06 15:35:57 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 868

I'm hoping this was some sort of high water mark for ultra fast paced filmmaking and everyone will take a deep breath from now on.

Either that, or with generative AI, we're at the cusp of an era that makes the current pace and everything that came before it look sluggish.

I do think the rapid pace at which they pump these out is definitely a factor. Again, I don't understand the mentality of the execs who signed off on this kind of crazy release schedule, where we're getting like 2 or 3 live-action remakes a year, including ones dumped onto streaming and such, and a similar number of Marvel shows. Strike while the iron is hot, get while the getting's good, and all that, but did the idea that audiences have a refractory period between big releases and so finding the right rhythm of releases instead of just flooding them with content just not occur to them? And obviously the quality suffers, with CGI being a well known issue but also the important stuff like writing.

It's like the execs thought their audiences were vending machines, where you just insert latest content and get money back out, and the more content you insert, the more money comes out, with no limits. It doesn't take a genius businessman to know that this isn't how that works, and Disney isn't just a business, it's the top of the top of the top in its industry, the metaphorical New York Yankees of Hollywood. These execs should know enough about business not to treat their audiences like that, if only out of naked selfish interest.

what do you think is more probable, that the Doomers saw Terminator in theaters when they were children or that they watched Anime related to AI doom?.

I mean, neither is particularly probable, since the popular/good Terminator films are rated R, and I don't really know of anime related to AI doom in a similar way. I don't think Doomers tended to get their inspiration from fiction they watched as children, though, since the narrative of the Doomers tend to be very different from the AI doom narratives seen in fiction.

but Doomers are not a majority of people and are, IMHO, very different from regular people.

that is a major disagreement we have there. To me Doomers and "rationalists" in general are just regular people very good at rationalizing their biases.

I don't see where the disagreement is. I believe that Doomers and rationalists in general (two different though overlapping sets of people) are just regular people very good at rationalizing their biases too. That doesn't mean that they're not very different from regular people, because "being very good at rationalizing one's biases" isn't the one and only characteristic that defines humans. Regular people don't tend to look into technology and try to project it decades into the future to predict where things will go, which is how Doomers seem to have come to their conclusions. Regular people tend not to have much interest in AI or robots or technology at all, where as Doomers almost by definition do.

Personally, I think Doomers, again, largely got inspiration from looking at technology and projecting it to the future in a way that is... rather hubristic or conceited. I'd call them a modern iteration of an apocalypse cult, much like idpol/SJW/CRT/wokeness/etc. is a modern iteration of a religion. It fulfills all the roles of such things while transforming just enough things to be convincing to modern educated people who consider themselves scientific and rational, since the old versions of these had too many characteristics that were too obviously incompatible with science; so they just made them less obvious. But I don't think either were inspired by The Terminator or other such works of scifi.

I think it's sarcasm. Would you have accepted a no?

It didn't look like sarcasm to me, but either way, obviously I would have accepted a no. It'd have been surprising, but I wouldn't see any reason for guesswho to lie about that, other than just trolling, I guess. Which could be what's happening with that comment, to be sure.

In terms of comparative analysis, I don't really think there's much of a way to do such a thing with anything approaching objectivity. Maybe ChatGPT, though then the question of validity arises. Again, from my own subjective analysis, the specific bad faith style looks very similar to Darwin and also quite different from the typical ways that a typical person with SJW leanings would make bad faith arguments. I suppose the only way to truly confirm would be to ask Darwin2500 on Reddit and if he says Yes, that'd be beyond a reasonable doubt at that point in my view. If he said No, then clearly there'd be some lying going on somewhere, and I'd probably lean towards it being different people, since Darwin2500, for all his bad faith, tried to stay away from blatant lies in that style and also his trolling tended to be content- and argument-based.

Edit: Also he did refer to me as if he knew me from Reddit, when he accused me of attacking his character on Reddit. Again, this could be a lie, especially since I don't remember attacking his character on Reddit but his belief about what conatitutes an attack on character seems to be different from mine.

Just wanted to say, I agree with you here in that it's not obviously him, and it behooves us not to jump to conclusions, but for whatever reason, Guesswho himself decided that FCfromSSC was correct that it was, in fact, obvious. There's always the chance that Guesswho is a liar and copycat, but I think the most likely explanation is that it's indeed him. Again, I don't think it was obviously so, but at least more likely than not before this comment, but now I'm sure with a high level of confidence.

I'm with you. Given the general lack of success of media companies to manipulate the audience into having preferred beliefs through putting out content pushing preferred messages, and the likely fact that in porn, if anything, the audience tends to be more motivated by pure id than with media in general, flooding sites with this just doesn't seem likely to work at all. Like, I've heard people talk a lot about incest porn and also "extreme" porn involving choking women and such taking over porn in recent years, but as a pretty regular consumer consoomer coomer who doesn't enjoy such things, I barely ever run into such things by accident, and even less when I'm looking for something specific. In fact, I don't think I've seen a single porn video of a woman being choked. Incest and pseudo-incest porn, it's easier to accidentally encounter, but also very easy to just find a near-equivalent video without it. It's just not that hard to avoid porn you're not into.

Given the visual style of the CGI remake, my guess is that decision maker is less a furry and more an enthusiast of actual interspecies erotica. By which I mean that I'm guessing Jon Favreau likes to fuck cats.

I'd like to complain more about Disney being dumb enough to hire J. J. Abrams to kick off the Star Wars sequels ... except that their decision making hasn't started to backfire until many years and billions of dollars later, so can I really call it "dumb"?

I think you can. The counterfactual of someone other than Abrams directing episode 7 is likely a film that still made a billion dollars, possibly even more. Even if they went with the same basic awful soft reboot of episode 4 as the plot, I don't think anything about Abrams's trademark Mystery Box storytelling added anything good to the film. I recall that line "that's a good question... for another time" about Luke Skywalker's lightsaber was made fun of when the film came out, and even moreso when "another time" never came in the following two films, despite Abrams directing episode 9 as well.

I think the real dumb move was probably not having a set outline for all 3 episodes that was planned out with all the writers and directors on board from the start. But then again, perhaps that's just equivalent to hiring Abrams because Abrams and planning-for-the-ending are basically water and oil.

It gives the impression that they are a wholeheartedly partisan organization that is only taking up this fight in a ploy to maintain an image of impartiality.

So, I think this is a reasonable takeaway, but another would be that ACLU is so principled that they are openly stating their hatred for an organization while still defending its civil liberties.

Now, the past decade or so has made it clear that "ACLU" and "principled" should only be in a sentence when there's an odd number of negations in it, but hey, organizations can turn a new leaf.

Live action Beauty and the Beast was inferior to my memories of the old animated version. Not sure why anyone had any inclination to make that movie.

I think the cliche that as movies have become more expensive, pre-existing franchises that already have fans and/or that can play on nostalgia have become more appealing to studio execs is probably true. And I'm guessing Beauty and the Beast was well into production before the The Jungle Book live-action remake made almost a billion dollars, but it probably helped to motivate Disney to fast-track all the ones that came after. And, to be fair, they kept making money, and lots and lots of money, until they didn't.

To me, the whole thing has the look of a kind of cargo cult. They saw the massive success of those old movies and thought they could replicate it in live-action for even more success, and it worked for a while, since they did get a lot of the superficial similarities right. But as they kept making more and more, the audience has been wising up to the fact that they really lack the substance that made the originals great.

What I don't get is how Disney execs could be so incompetent as to not understand this. Their flagship films like The Lion King (CGI remake) make basic, fundamental, amateur errors in things like writing, acting, cinematography, even music (the entire sequence where Nala discovers adult Simba - a pivotal, very important moment in the film's narrative - is egregious in all of these, including setting the song Can You Feel The Love Tonight during the day). From what I've heard, their more recent ones like The Little Mermaid are even worse in many ways in that regard. It's like they tried to build all the decorations of a house to look like an older house without bothering with the foundations and support structure. Studio execs, just out of naked selfish interest, should understand that it's important to get this right! And studio execs at the exact same company 30 years ago seemed to understand this! Where did all that expertise and knowledge go?

And with Star Wars, Kathleen Kennedy, the president of Lucasfilm, gets a lot of the blame, but she herself was a producer in the old Indiana Jones films, i.e. the good ones. Where did all that filmmaking expertise that she herself had go? How could she sign off on "Somehow, Palpatine returned?"

Okay, thanks for confirming, Darwin. I have no interest in attacking your character, only in pointing out the pattern of bad faith you have displayed over the years. Please consider this conversation to have been completely and utterly "won" by you - or perhaps just "lost" by me for spending any sort of effort reading and writing arguments as if there was any chance of good faith discussion.

Right, a majority of people think of Arnold or HAL, but Doomers are not a majority of people and are, IMHO, very different from regular people. Regular people don't really think about this stuff and just connect the superficial similarities between Terminator and AI Doom in the future, whereas AI Doomers seem to have arrived at their position by looking at actual current science, not science fiction, and extrapolating into the future in a way they find plausible. I think inspiration by fiction, whether that be The Terminator or anime, is a tiny factor when it comes to AI Doomers.

Also, I'm assuming AIM doesn't stand for AOL Instant Messenger, but I don't know what it refers to.

All 3 were ad absurdum examples demonstrating the crazy steps you would have to take to make the future look like the past, in the 'roll back the clock' or 'return to glory days' way that I think people imagine.

But they aren't such examples. They're just absurd ideas that you pulled out of your ass without even explaining that this was the point being made; except you didn't even make a point; you just made naked assertions that such absurd things would be required to roll back to the past, without making a supporting argument. At best, you were playing an obvious bad-faith shell game of equating "SJW" with anything relating to rights or things like genetic intellectual superiority, which fools no one, since those are simply milquetoast liberal things, and liberals are almost definitionally anti-"SJW."

The obligation you talk about is not placed on you by the person who considers themselves trans. The obligation is placed on you by the society that believes and wants to respect that fact. The obligation is placed on you by your own desire to be a part of that society and interact with it nicely despite disagreeing with it on this point.

Sure, and we live in a world where society hasn't decided that we want to submit to trans people. Some people in society have, others haven't, and it's under discussion now.

In order to have a world where sports and shelters don't spontaneously choose to include trans people, you would have to change their opinions about trans people to something different than they are today. In order to live in a world where there's no social consequence to misgendering trans people, you'd have to change everyone's opinion about how rude that is or isn't.

This, and honestly the entire last part of your comment, is just consensus-building. I'd prefer if you didn't do that, since it's dishonest, and it's also not fooling anyone. It's also you just playing another transparently bad faith shell game of claiming that sports and shelters "spontaneously chose to include trans people." Whether or not they chose to include trans people is not in contention; if you combined the people who believed transwomen should compete/shelter with females and those who believed transwomen should compete/shelter with males, that would cover basically everyone. It's not a question of "including" them, it's a question of how you include them.

I don't see how you imagine a social structure in which you are not required to 'submit' to this agenda, without requiring that everyone else submit to your agenda by changing their opinions and preferences to match yours.

This is another shell game. No, it doesn't require that everyone else submit to my agenda. It requires me convincing enough people that freedom speech is worth protecting (admittedly a losing battle these days). This is especially rich when the very agenda that you are claiming these people have is submission. It's not about submitting to an agenda; it's that the submission is (part of) the agenda. This sort of transparently bad faith shell game where you elide between submitting to some sort of claimed-to-be-popular agenda and submission in itself being the agenda itself doesn't fool anyone.

I'd also like to ask directly, have you ever gone by a username "darwin2500" or something similar on Reddit or the SlateStarCodex website? That's honestly the first thing I'd like to know, so that I have a better idea of if this kind of bad faith is the norm to expect from your comments.

I've seen people talk mention The Terminator a bunch with respect to inspiring AI Doomers, but I just don't see it. Obviously the plot of the films helped to popularize the idea of AI killing us all, but the line of thinking that AI Doomers display seems to have no connection to those films, which posited an AI that quickly decided that getting rid of humans was in its best interests and decided to use a nuclear war to help to accomplish this, followed by robots and cyborgs like the "terminators" to hunt down the survivors. This is very different from what I hear coming from Doomers, which involves an AI or multiple AIs that have no antipathy for humans or particular desire to hunt them down and also posits that the mechanism of robots hunting us down would be silly compared to easier methods they have at their disposal (and also that if robots did hunt us down with AI, then they would do it pretty easily, since their reaction times, accuracy, and precision, to say nothing of mental focus and stamina, greatly outstrip our own, by orders of magnitude).

I have a hard time accepting that things just are (the way they are) in the sociopersonal space. In that if you do X, the signal that you do X might predict that you do Y, but, that intuition is useless. In other words, knowing aggregate trends helps little on a single data point. Predicting aggregate -> aggregate is easy. Making a prediction is hard, this is almost always because (Lewontonins fallacy, minus the fallacy).

I have a similar - perhaps reversed - experience as this. I chalk it up to my upbringing, being consistently taught and reinforced that stereotyping someone is only one notch above imposing something like literal chattel slavery on them. As such, as Arthur Chu might say, I was trained to periodically "mind-kill" myself to never predict the behavior of someone based on other signals without some specific independent evidence. If I ran into a burly man with face tattoos in a dark alley in an area known for gang activity, it would be evil to treat him any differently than if I ran into an old lady in her 70s who has to take deep breaths every few steps; the burly man could just be a tattoo and fitness enthusiast, and the old lady could be an armed robber with a hidden gun. The relative odds of these scenarios don't matter; in fact, even considering calculating it is, again, evil.

I've been trying to learn to think differently, since I noticed that even the people who push this stuff clearly don't believe it, as shown by their revealed preference and, more recently, just explicit praise of the moral virtuousness of stereotyping in [circumstances]. It's not easy to navigate out of decades of propaganda that started since grade school, though.

No, I just meant anyone who's not in the category of rabid reactionaries who have similar desires to grab ahold of the steering wheel in order to take society on a long road trip and unlike reactionaries have actually fulfilled that desire. Normies, almost by definition, don't really have much of a desire to grab ahold of the steering wheel.

I just wish we didn't have to live through this happening in real-time with non-rabid non-reactionaries. It's one of those things that's fun to think about, but hellish to experience.

As a cat person, I honestly think cats probably are stupider than dogs. It's difficult to quantify, since you can't give these animals IQ tests or even proxies of such, but IIRC some measure of brain complexity showed dogs' to be more complex, which is at least a crude and noisy proxy for intelligence. Which largely conforms with common sense formed from general everyday experiences people have with these creatures. I wish more cat people were just accepting of this instead of treating "stupid" like an insult or "smart" like a compliment about virtue. Cats are stupider than dogs, but that doesn't change the objective fact that they are better than dogs.

A side note: I sometimes worry that modern spay/neuter campaigns are, on net, reversing the domestication process for cats. Practically the only individuals that are allowed to reproduce these days are 1) expensive purebreds and 2) feral cats so averse to humans that they escape TNR programs. If you have a snuggly, trainable one, let her make more!

This sounds like fodder for a The Time Machine reimagining involving cats evolving into cat-Eloi and cat-Morlocks. Maybe mix in some genetic engineering with Elon making catgirls real, to justify the cats gaining enough intelligence to form actual societies.

I thought this was just another generic bad faith poster, but now that you pointed out the actual meaning of the name, I'm realizing this very well could be Darwin just having some fun with his username. It's been a long time since I've read his posts with any sort of regularity, but this definitely fits the pattern of obviously bad faith strawmanning that I remember.

Having gotten a couple cats recently, I've ended up down a YouTube rabbit hole of old Animal Planet episodes of My Cat From Hell and It's Me or the Dog, shows where a celebrity animal trainer comes and helps out an owner of a misbehaving cat and dog, respectively, and the contrast in those perfectly matches what you've noticed about cats and and dogs, as well as the wider stereotype. In the cat show, most of the trainer's work is in creating indirect benefits for the cat, including better home environment, a schedule, exercise routine, and such, which ideally results in the cat being able to better channel their instincts towards behavior befitting a pet cat rather than a feral predator. In the dog show, most of the trainer's work is in directly engaging with the dogs and training them to respond to specific commands in specific ways that directly address the exact behavior problems they have. Though the latter does often involve the indirect stuff like routine and diet, too.

This absolutely matches my experience, having gotten a couple cats about a month ago. I've been training one to follow my finger, but it really is following my finger, not where my finger is pointing, and so I have to actually physically place my finger at the platform or whatever I want him to go to; if my finger is hovering a few feet away from the platform, then it's well less than 50/50 that he'll go to the platform. Whereas the dogs I've encountered in my life seemed to just intuitively understand to look at the direction I was pointing at.

Hm, good point. I suppose my thinking was that it's higher status to be a husband of a harem than to be a playboy or serial monogamist, but in the brave new world, that's certainly not a safe assumption.

That's the beauty of polygamy, he won't leave you for a newer model! The newer model just comes in and raises his status which means it also raises your status (while also lowering your status relatively due to having to share with one more woman; whether this is a net gain or loss depends a lot on the details).

There is perhaps a third option, in which Dr. Gay cracks down hard on anti-Semitic speech and makes an example of a few students or staff who crossed the line, thus blaming it on a few bad apples and going back to the status quo.

Why not take the mirror image of this third option, where Dr. Gay and other Harvard leadership make commitments not to crack down on all "hate speech" that is similar to the antisemitic stuff we see today, just directed at other, less acceptable targets, while continuing to let the antisemitic stuff go free? This would be my preferred option. Making a credible commitment here is likely to be difficult, so it would have to be costly, though, like liquidating entire departments both administratively and academically.

Polygamy, the natural mating equilibrium of humanity, will reassert itself.

Nah. I sooner see people pacifying themselves with porn, AI companions, and cats. People still having sex will probably stand by marriage. It's too good of a deal for all parties involved.

I feel like this would just result in polygamy reasserting itself. I would expect the people who pacify themselves with porn, AI companions, and cats to be majority - likely overwhelmingly - male, leaving a smaller number of males having sex than women (there's some indication that this is already happening). Marriage is indeed a good deal for all parties involved, but when you have such an imbalance of people still having sex, then polygamy is a pretty natural outcome. I'm sure the modal woman would prefer the currently-typical two-person marriage between one man and one woman, but when that option isn't available, why not choose being the 10th wife of a high status man than turning to AI companions and cats? I suppose part of it will have to do with how good AI companions get in the future; if the AI can actually manipulate the user's mind into genuinely believing that they're having a real relationship with a real flesh-and-blood-born-from-a-real-womb human who is high status, then all bets are off.

People stop thinking 'trans' is a thing and it's illegal to call someone by different pronouns than they were born with?

I just want to comment on this one thing, which is that this matches a pattern I've noticed by many people where they just project their own way of thinking to the other side, just reversed. The notion that any meaningfully mainstream pushback against SJ would involve illegalizing calling someone certain pronouns is pretty absurd. It's the SJ side that wants to illegalize such things, and the pushback is by people who want the chips to fall where they may without legal coercion.

Similarly, the pushback against SJ in transness isn't that "trans" isn't a thing - it's that it's a very different thing than what SJ claim it is. Of course, many in SJ would claim that that's the same as saying it's not a thing, but that's just word games; the fact is, the JK Rowlings of the world acknowledge that there is a category of people who identify themselves as "trans" - this clearly is all that is required to think that "trans" is a thing. They just don't believe that "trans" is the kind of thing that places obligations on other people to submit to the person who believes themselves as "trans" in terms of things like pronoun usage, prison assignments, shelters, sports, etc.