@07mk's banner p

07mk


				

				

				
2 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 06 15:35:57 UTC

				

User ID: 868

07mk


				
				
				

				
2 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 06 15:35:57 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 868

I think there is no more value to be gained from continuing this discussion. So we shall, as you say, agree to disagree.

I'm impressed by the balls you have to repeatedly put false words in my mouth and to project your own insecurities onto me and then end with an "agree to disagree." It's legit admirable.

Yeah, fair enough, probably "much better" was overselling it, and it's not the kind of thing that would have allowed some threshold to be crossed. Like you allude to, that it's IRL acquaintance is pretty significant.

I'm no expert on this, but off the bat, there are two things I believe you did wrong.

One is that you did it via text. Text might be okay for relationships that form over text (e.g. OLD or internet friends), but if she's someone you have any sort of IRL contact with, I believe finding a way to ask her out face to face would have been better.

Two is that you hedged with the last part, showing a lack of confidence in your part. If you had ended it before the "if you're interested," that alone would have made the message much better. Even better yet, remove the part that starts with "I think" and ends with "pretty and." Just state your intent and desire, and let her do the work of shooting you down if she chooses to. Preceding with compliments just screams insecurity to my eyes.

There's, of course, always the possibility of the zeroth thing you might have done wrong, which is just not being attractive. This is the biggest factor that dominates all other factors, including the content and medium of your request, which could very well have had literally zero impact on the results, depending on how "wrong" you were on this. But that's outside the scope of this post.

Nowadays there are guys that brag with their inability to change a flat tire (true story).

I'm actually curious, what exactly is the brag here they were making? I've encountered people who can't change their own flat tires, but I've yet to encounter one who was anything less than sheepishly ashamed of this, much less proud enough to brag about this lack of ability on their part. Is it just that they enjoy such a luxurious life that they can just throw money at people to do this for them, even in unplanned emergencies?

Nowadays we live in the opposite culture - knowing is discouraged. The car works by magic, the iphone works by magic, the washing machine too.

I'm reminded of anecdotes I've heard from teachers mentioning that their students today don't understand computer filesystems. Everything is just done via app, and the idea of using a browser to download a file to a folder on their hard drive, then navigating to that folder in an explorer program, copying the file to another folder where it needs to be, and opening it with another application or whatever is completely foreign to them. It sort of makes sense given the environment in which they grew up and learned computers, and it seems similar to my own attitude towards cars, which is that they really are just a black box magic, and if something goes wrong, I go to my local mechanic magician to get it fixed. Because learning the magic myself just seems like more trouble than it's worth. When I was learning computers, I had to learn the filesystem to actually accomplish anything. Now, kids don't have to, so they don't.

I'm not sure if this is a good thing or a bad thing or either.

You are an outlier. Congrats!

The probability of an obese person attaining normal body weight is very small.

I'm an outlier in terms of an obese person successfully becoming normal body weight, but I don't know that I'm an outlier in terms of an obese person who experienced a loss in appetite due to just reducing caloric intake. That study doesn't - and can't - say anything about that. I don't know how many obese people have really committed to even 10 days straight of strict caloric restrictions to see how their appetite, energy levels, and mood would react and how the experience was like for that subset of obese people who did try that.

The mod creator appeared earnest in recommending other mods that whitewashed black characters.

The comments on the mod itself by defenders were of the "woke double standards" type, which genuinely angers some anti-woke types.

This is additional information that one had to look up about the modder - the point of contention here is on whether "your very deliberate modding choices don't at the very least say something about where your lines are," and these go beyond the modder's very deliberate modding choices. If you want to say that this specific modder was likely racist because of the various lines of evidence that we can see from that modder's behavior, I would agree with you 100%. That's not what what I'm arguing about. And talking about "context" doesn't actually add anything to this, because "context" isn't the issue; the modding choices didn't tell us anything about whether the modder was racist, with or without the additional details that added context - it was those additional details that told us whether the modder was racist.

Yes, I determined the context. I am allowed to state what that context is and why I think that is. If you find it unconvincing, so be it, but it's telling that you don't afford me enough charity to not claim I'm trying to decide everyone's opinion.

I mean, fair enough if it's "so be it." Your statements seemed pretty definitive, that you found absurd my belief that a modder's deliberate modding choices can't be used to pass non-trivial judgment on the modder's thinking, but if you just agree to disagree, that's fine as it is.

So why don't I see you in every thread about progressives reminding everybody that they don't know why progressives do what they do beyond an individual level?

Well, one reason is that when people are talking about "progressives," they're usually talking about a set of people who voluntarily signed up for a particular sociopolitical cause. There are loose boundaries, blurry lines, edge cases, and controversy of course, and I'm against psychoanalyzing in almost all cases, but I'm of the opinion that someone's publicly stated sociopolitical positions do provide information about their sociopolitical positions in a way that someone's published entertainment products doesn't. It's certainly true that people here leap very far to conclusions that are entirely unjustified, based on projecting their own insecurities and bitterness onto these "progressives," and I would say that's just as unjustified as claiming that modding a video game to change a character's race is indicative of the modder's racism. It's just that such lines tend to be just one-off low-effort swipes rather than substantive points about how we can divine people's inner sociopolitical beliefs based on their behavior in other realms such as art. The low-effort swipes are bad and lower the standard of discourse here, but I'm not a moderator.

I also personally find it hard to argue against such psychoanalysis of progressives when they perfectly match the mentality that I myself lived through as a progressive. Of course, I can argue just as well as anyone that, just because I happen to be an existence-proof of the reality of the mentality of the progressives that someone is bitching about here, that doesn't mean that any other progressive than me has that mentality. It's that when I see someone who clearly understands my own thinking so well despite never having met me, much less been within my mind, it gives me pause and makes me want to listen rather than argue. I don't experience this when it comes to people accused of being racist due to their creation of entertainment products, since I find the claimed mindset quite foreign.

So when you tell me that there's no limit as to why a person may want to make a black person white in Stardew Valley, your next step, if you were intellectually honest, would be to start assigning probabilities to each of those reasons. Do that, and I suspect you're going to quickly get into very small numbers after 5.

And this step, if one is intellectually honest, is to admit that we can't assign meaningfully accurate probabilities to these reasons that aren't just dominated by our own biases. If we had some sort of empirical evidence to rely on that shows some relation between "make a black person white in Stardew Valley" (or more generically "make [X] person [Y] in [ENTERTAINMENT PRODUCT]") and "racism in the creator" (obviously can't be mind reading, but racist is as racist does, and so this can be detected through other actions), we could perhaps discuss these probabilities with some very large error bars. Unfortunately, the very mechanism by which we can collect this sort of evidence has largely discredited itself in this realm, and so we're mostly left grasping for straws.

This matches my experience too, and I've heard similar accounts from many people. With sweets, it does seem like people's sensitivity for it is highly malleable, and so reducing or quitting sweets for even a short period of time tends to cause noticeable increase in sensitivity to it. Which means same amount of sweetness for fewer calories. If I abstain from sugar for a week, then a single cookie might be enough to satiate my sweet tooth where in the past I might have needed 3.

Generally, I think part of the difficulty of starting and maintaining dieting is the difficulty people have in imagining themselves to have different preferences in the future. Cutting down or out food quantity or quality (in terms of taste) can be painful at first, but it's the very act of cutting it down or out that modifies you to desire less in the first place, thus allowing you to enjoy that new reduced amount just as much. The transition is the tough part.

And a diet that causes hunger and lethargy can never be sustained in the long term. If your body is fighting to return to a higher set point, then you need to fix that somehow. Otherwise you must either be fat or miserable.

My experience as a formerly obese person was that the surest way to fix that issue of hunger and lethargy caused by a low calorie diet was to continue the low calorie diet and push it even harder. The exact same diet that caused hunger and lethargy on day 1 can be entirely fulfilling on day 10. Of course, days 1-9 might not be pleasant, but day 9 was significantly less unpleasant than day 8 which was significantly less unpleasant than day 7, etc., and it's not like going a couple weeks while suffering from hunger and lethargy is particularly difficult or painful, compared to going even a month of simply living while obese, much less the many years I lived as an obese person before the dieting.

At this point, I'll mention that the best diet is never to become fat in the first place.

This, I agree with. One thing I've personally noticed about having been obese is that I'll never be "un-obese." In the roughly 15 years since I came down from being obese, I've stayed within healthy-to-underweight range while keeping active and even athletic at times. Yet not once have I felt fit or, in fact, as if I was anything other than an obese person, even during the height of my fitness when I was sprinting about on the field with the best of my peers. Being obese an experience that can stay with you forever, no matter how you physiologically modify yourself out of it. It's one of those things that can irreversibly, permanently, change you, and I don't think in a good way.

I'm a short thin man who drinks a lot of alcohol and also has lots of sugary drinks alongside that. I can't subsist off one meal a day. there is no way anyone else can either. What kind of meals are you eating that you can fit 2,200 calories on one plate?

I've subsisted on one meal a day plenty of times while not losing weight. I'm average height and average build (5' 9", around 160 lbs most of the time). Eating around 2K Calories in one sitting isn't that tough if you plan for it. It's frighteningly easy to get that many Calories by accident with unhealthy foods like french fries or crisps, but if you're trying to eat healthy, it's probably going to be a heavy, fatty meal that will take some acclimating to, but my experience was that the acclimation was surprisingly quick; just a couple days. The really tough part is going around 23 hours every day in a row without eating. This, too, is a case where the acclimation was surprisingly quick. Normally, I would get hungry 4-6 hours after the previous meal, with the hunger getting worse over time; I found that the hunger stopped increasing pretty quickly and, in fact, went back down over time with just a couple days of experience of that 23 hour fasting cycle.

Apparently, no one is allowed to conclude that a person is more likely to be racist if they download a mod that makes the only black person in a game white even though there's no world-building reason against his presence.

Correct, because that would be leaping to conclusions. Your expression of incredulity that someone won't leap to the same conclusions you will doesn't make that leap any less of a leap.

By all means, propose alternatives for why this person is making this mod. I can think of only one other.

First of all, I don't need to propose alternatives, because the conclusion that they're doing it out of racist motivations isn't some "default" or "safe" conclusion that we can just draw. But just off the top of my head, the first obvious reason is to troll the types of people who would get their panties in a wad over things like this. Those people might contend that the trolling is racist, but of course that's by no means a commonly accepted meaning of "racism" - in fact, it's a highly contentious one. This took me all of 5 seconds to think of. Which, again, is not at all necessary; it's the leap from "he changed some colors of fictional characters in a video game" to "he has racist motivations" that needs the justification. It took me another 15 seconds to think of the explanation that the modder finds the stylized representation of the character in the game to look better with a certain color scheme over another color scheme. Both of these could be motivated by racism, of course, because literally every action, innocuous or not, could be motivated by racism. But leaping to the conclusion that they are requires actual additional, specific justification.

To me, it feels like an overly restrictive and closed view of the diversity and idiosyncracies of humanity to believe that one can just simply conclude from "He changed all the black heroes to white heroes"

I made it clear that context matters in my various responses in this thread. I don't think there's anything racist in the creation or use of that one BG3 mod that makes characters fit the established lore on appearances better. But you don't get that justification for something like Stardew Valley because the "lore" reasoning doesn't apply.

You make it clear that you can say that context matters while also insisting that you get to determine the context based on your own personal idiosyncratic views on the matter. But the reality is that we aren't mind readers with very little insight into the internal and unique thinking process of other people. There's no limit of the number of completely innocuous, non-racist reasons why someone could have changed the only black character to white in a way that is irrelevant to the lore, even if you or I couldn't think of any of them (which isn't the case, since I can think of some of them, but that's besides the point).

So you're saying that the middle initial has to be J?

I'm wondering, is there some sort of economic or logistical justification for this fee? Like, does it cost Unity something each time this happens? I had thought that once you develop a game using the engine, then the code is the code, you can deploy it as you wish. Which could be reliant on having constant access to online services or something, but this seems universal for all games. So if you have a chunk of code lying on your SSD that someone pays you to download a copy of, then they install it on their own computers, what's Unity's justification for taking a cut of that particular interaction, given that their input ended once the chunk of code got finished and went gold? Is it just pure rent seeking? It almost feels like Unity wants to insert itself in like an actor earning royalties off syndication, which isn't the most unreasonable thing to try for, but then it seems like these royalties should be taken off the earnings like a tax, rather than off installs, which often don't generate any revenue at all.

This is an interesting definitional question. I would say No to both questions, though it's almost a Yes for the latter one. Racism is necessarily interpersonal, but it doesn't require some form of direct interaction/exchange. But it does need to play out in some form of interaction/exchange, even if theoretical or intended. If I go to a bunch of other Korean-Americans like myself and tell them to go out and shoot up a bunch of Slavs because Slavs deserve to be shot or whatever, I'm not directly being interacting with Slavs to be racist towards them, but I'm clearly setting up a chain of events meant to create a direct interaction between members of different races to act in racist ways towards each other.

If you spend 10 minutes meditating on how much you hate black people, but then that meditation doesn't affect how you treat black people or how you tell others to treat black people during the other 23 hours and 50 minutes of the day, then I don't see how it could possibly be racist.

Why did someone make or install this mod? It clearly didn't come into existence because particles randomly happened to generate the mod. If the reason was one we would call racist, then yes, we can reasonably infer that someone at the very least made something racist that may indicate their own racial prejudice. Sure, we can't prove racism totally. But I think it is entirely reasonable to be at least somewhat more convinced that the creator is racist.

You jump from "why" to "it's entirely reasonable to be at least somewhat more convinced [of a conclusion]." I disagree with this. I think the entirely reasonable thing is to say "We don't know," and being convinced, somewhat or otherwise, of the creator's racism or other beliefs sans external independent evidence, is unreasonable. Yes, if the reason the creator made the mod were one that we would call racist, then it's entirely reasonable to say that the creator is a racist racist who racistly created a racist mod in order to spread his racism. That's a big if, one that can't really be checked by observers only from looking at the mod.

You either believe in an overly strict chain of causality and inference, or you are trying to establish a principled stance that you don't actually uphold in real life.

??? I don't see what's overly strict about this chain of causality, and I don't see on what basis you get to claim that I don't uphold this in real life. To me, it appears like you're doing here to me the same thing that I'm accusing you of doing with this mod theoretical to the modder, which is projecting your own biases onto the situation and asserting that someone else must be (somewhat more likely to be) acting in a certain way because of how your projected biases relate to their observed behavior. To me, it feels like an overly restrictive and closed view of the diversity and idiosyncracies of humanity to believe that one can just simply conclude from "He changed all the black heroes to white heroes" or "He changed all the demonic enemies to cis white people, to be murdered by the POC champion protagonist" that "He did this out of his sociopolitical beliefs that are in accordance with the direct, straight-up pattern-matching against this mod (i.e. that if I modify a work of fiction to more glorify white/black characters at the expense of black/white characters, that implies I hold some sort of belief or bias in favor white/black people and against black/white people IRL)."

Man, if I killed someone with a gun, I'd love to have you as my defense attorney. "My client didn't intend to kill someone, your honor, he just pulled a piece of metal/plastic on a product he owned while it was aimed at a person for two minutes straight!"

This is, to be frank, an insane comparison. Pointing a loaded gun at someone and pulling the trigger is the literal physical act of killing someone, or at least causing injury with the high likelihood of killing. This has no comparison to how changing some pixels - or anything else - for a virtual game relates to racism. There is no physical reality that connects the playing of a game with racism the same way physical reality connects shooting a gun at someone with murder. Many people believe that the contents of a modded game can exacerbate racism, but this is by no means a well-supported view, and is certainly a far less consensus view than "shooting someone with a gun has a high likelihood of kill them," and the leap from "I personally think this mod could exacerbate racism" to "therefore, this modder, even if possibly subconsciously, had racist motivations in creating this mod" is unjustified.

By this logic, I could download a mod that changed "white" to "cracker" or "cracker-colored" and no one should assume I'm being racist.

Absolutely. I would 100% not assume you were a racist and I would defend you as being a non-racist, at least on the basis of this one decision. This would remain just as strong even if, say, you modded Doom to change all demons to cis white men and the player character to an amalgamation of Ibram X. Kendi and Robin DiAngelo. The only conclusion we could draw is that you wanted to make a Doom mod with these properties, and any sort of speculation about your personal beliefs about the politics surrounding people like Kendi, DiAngelo, and cis white men would be just that, speculation, and you would be responsible for exactly none of the speculation that many people could (and would likely) speculate about your principles and beliefs that motivated you to create such a mod.

And, needless to say, in neither your example nor mine, would you actually be being racist, since there's no one to actually be racist towards in a situation where you're just writing some code in a computer and offering other people the choice to download and use that code.

The OP is clearly saying you cannot infer anything about their beliefs or worldview on the basis of the mods they play. That is what I don't agree with. Those are not trivial things.

Indeed, and I agree with the OP and disagree with you. "Anything about their beliefs or worldview" is different from "anything [at all]." The deliberate choices one makes when modding falls into the latter category but not in the former category. E.g. if someone decided to make a mod that changed some pixels from brown to beige, it tells us that that person decided to make a mod that changed some pixels from brown to beige, which falls into the latter, but not the former. I doubt the OP would disagree with the notion that a modder deciding to change some pixels from brown to beige tells us that the modder decided to change those pixels from brown to beige, but he can speak for himself, I suppose.

Not every possible explanation is equally possible. I don't think people are missing the fact that the mod they were downloading, in the SV example, was explicitly about making a black character white. That context matters. Is it by itself enough to say a person is racist? Maybe not. But it does make it more likely.

Does it? It's possible that it does, but I dispute that you can believe with any meaningful level of confidence that it does make it more likely. This is the kind of nice-sounding narrative that intuitively makes sense and sounds plausible, and as such, if we believe it without doing the hard empirical work to check that it's true, then we should be highly suspicious that our belief in it is due to how plausible it sounds and how much it is in concordance with our intuitions, rather than how true it is. Again, in that SV example, it is, by itself, absolutely not enough to say the person is racist. Is it enough to imply that that modder is more likely to be racist than the typical SV modder or player? It might be, and it might not be, and we haven't done the hard empirical work to figure out which.

What I reject is that idea that it doesn't say anything about you.

In the literal sense, nobody takes the other side of this, though. Trivially, if I make deliberate modding choices, then that tells the world that I made those deliberate modding choices. I think so few non-schizophrenic people would disagree with this as to be irrelevant. So claiming that it says something about me is meaningless: of course it does, because every choice I make trivially tells the world that I made that choice.

The point of contention is on the specific claims about what else these choices imply about me or any other generic choice-maker. E.g. if someone modded Stardew Valley to transform some brown pixels to beige ones, it's entirely possible that such a decision was motivated by the modder's deeply held philosophical/political/personal/etc. views which are bigoted, hateful, or whatever, but that can only be supported by additional external information. And merely knowing that this person made such a mod doesn't actually add any information or give us any data from which to construct the truth about that modder's motivations or beliefs or where their lines are. Again, with the exception of the trivial truth that it tells us a lot about the modder's desire to transform certain pixels.

It's one thing to say that, for example, watching MCU movies because they're "in" at the moment doesn't mean you endorse the idea of capitalism, it's quite another to say that your very deliberate modding choices don't at the very least say something about where your lines are.

Sure, those are two different things, but the important thing is that they're both true. Deliberate modding choices don't tell us anything about where your lines are, except strictly within the realm of deliberate modding choices. To extend any implications outward to something else, like one's political opinions or personal ethics or whatever, is something that needs actual external empirical support. One doesn't get to project one's own worldview onto others and then demand that they be held to that standard.

I didn't say it was strong evidence or good evidence.

We don't want to establish a precedent that other states can just ship people they don't want here without our prior consent.

That precedent was established a long time ago when CA and TX (and other states involved) joined the United States with the expectation of free movement of people between the borders. If TX officials are handing out bus tickets to people, and those people are voluntarily choosing to use those bus tickets to transport themselves to other places within the United States as they have a right to do, then the Union is working as intended.

If TX officials are using coercion, manipulation, or even just the slightest bit of pressure to these migrants to "ship" them off to other states, that's certainly an issue, though it's one between the individual migrants who have been wronged and the government officials who have wronged them. From what I can tell, there's likely some evidence that something like this took place, and justice for these wronged migrants seems worth pursuing. But if the objection is to a different state handing out resources to its inhabitants which then free them up to voluntarily choose to move within the United States to one's own state of residence, then, again, I don't see how to interpret that objection as anything other than the declaration that those people are "undesirables" in some meaningful way.

This requires admitting that immigrants are "undesirables"

No, it requires admitting that TX regards them as such.

The whole issue here seems to be that states other than TX, such as CA, finds it undesirable that TX give these people bus tickets that have places like CA as the destination. I'm not sure how it's possible to frame this in a way that doesn't fully admit that the decisionmakers in places like CA that are complaining or at least pushing back at this action by the decisionmakers by TX are seeing these immigrants as "undesirables."

weather forecasting as I see it isn't much better than an old man and bad knees.

This was a common sentiment back when I was growing up in the 90s. Even back then, it was a silly sentiment and wrong, though it wasn't completely wrong, but it's certainly completely wrong today. Even since the 90s to today, weather forecasting has improved substantially. This makes sense, because there's a ton of money to be made by forecasting weather slightly better than the competition. Weather drives energy usage patterns to a significant extent - think air conditioning and heating - and being able to predict those patterns more accurately than someone else allows one to make bets on the energy markets (things like electricity, nat gas, coal, oil) to make more money. An old man with bad knees and a team of professional meteorologists both get things wrong from time to time, but how often they get things wrong and how severely they get things wrong are very very different these days.

I haven't looked into this deeply, but I recall when Impossible and Beyond were first coming out, all promotional material conspicuously ignored commenting on how healthy the food was, which is highly unusual for a plant-based meat-imitation product, and all independent analysis tended to point out that they were, pound-for-pound, less healthy than actual meat. This led me to conclude that they were almost definitely at most as healthy as regular meat and likely less healthy, even if I don't recall what the exact reason was; I think higher saturated fat than regular meat?

Is there a way to make prisoners use their tablets to somehow manually work on archiving that internet content? Maybe they could earn their fun time on the internet by putting in work time on the internet that benefits the rest of society.

With sufficiently good AI art, it won't be possible to tell the difference. If nothing else, it craters the value for anyone who would create the real deal for money.

I don't know that it wouldn't have the opposite effect. We won't be able to tell the difference just from the pixels, but the pixels aren't the only way to tell the difference. If there's enough demand for the real deal, then people will provide the requisite verification and certification of the unethical sourcing, and that extra status - compared to all the unverified images that could very well be AI generations where the viewer can't be sure that no child suffered to produce it - could very well allow them to demand more money.