I haven't run into the word "bussy" much, but I never got the sense that it had anything to do with transwomen. If anything, it was more associated with gay men. Or rather, with boys who were to be the receivers of gay men, whether or not those boys themselves were gay.
I don't think that 28/34 fraction means a whole lot, necessarily. Sequels can be different from predecessors while being even better sometimes (The Godfather: Part 2 comes to mind, along with Terminator 2 and Aliens), and that's even more the case for spinoffs within the same universe (e.g. Rogue One being a spinoff of the Star Wars films). Remakes/reimaginings can also be perfectly good and creative depending on how they're handled - e.g. I haven't watched either Scarface film, but I've been told the remake from the 70s was even better than the original from the 30s. And if that 28 includes adaptations of stories from other media, then there's just no issue; making a film version of a written story is a new creative endeavor in itself, and there are countless examples of great, creative films that have come from adapting existing stories.
So the fraction might not be indicative of anything, but I do think there's something going on with the lack of creativity in Hollywood the past decade. The rise of the soft reboot (e.g. Jurassic World to Jurassic Park, The Force Awakens to A New Hope, Ghostbusters to Ghostbusters, and even arguably The Incredibles 2 to The Incredibles if you squint) does show some lack of creativity; these aren't remakes/reimaginings that try to present a fresh take on the same story, they do the exact opposite by dressing up the same stale core with minor cosmetic changes. And there are the Disney live-action (CG) remakes of their old cartoons, which they're pumping out at astonishing rates and which either add nothing to the original story (e.g. The Lion King which also took away a whole lot including one of its best songs) or just miss the entire point or "soul" of the original story (e.g. Mulan where the titular character literally had The Force magical chi powers, or Pinocchio where the titular puppet never makes any mistakes and is also rewarded for lying by having his nose grow long in a way to help him get the key to his cage). These show both a lack of creativity and a lack of understanding of what made the original works so beloved. Then there's Marvel, where every character feels like they're trying to imitate Iron Man with their sarcastic quips and every film has the same tone due to that.
Perhaps there's some truth to the idea that these studios have gotten very risk averse in part due to how much these high production films cost to make. Maybe there's something to it; after all, The Force Awakens and The Lion King both made a billion dollars. But I also have to wonder if that's the kind of trick you can only pull off so many times before the audience catches on, and Hollywood isn't adapting all that quickly. My hope is that with the rise of generative AI, we'll see the costs drop so drastically that indie studios - perhaps even dedicated hobbyists - would be able to put together 2-hour long films with the production values - encompassing everything from the visual effects, sound effects, set design, costume design, acting quality - of a modern Hollywood blockbuster. Hollywood still owns most/all of the well-known brands, and they also have the industry expertise to use these tools better than most, so they could still thrive in such an environment. But more independent filmmakers making something equivalent to Avatar 2 in production values could mean more creative and imaginative films in the landscape in the future.
If you think it's possible for an artist to have any rights at all over whether their work is used for AI training or not, then clearly they should be able to seek redress for images that have already been used without their permission. Trying to get off on a technicality of "aww shucks, maybe if you had published your work back in 2015 along with an explicit notice that said 'you do not have permission to use this image to train any AI models' then you would have a case, but, you didn't, so too bad..." is just silly.
I think it's possible for an artist to have such rights, but IANAL, and that's ultimately a question for the courts to decide. But in any case, no artist would have had to predict the advent of machine learning if they didn't want their images to become part of, to quote aqouta, "general inspiration in the air;" they could have just gated their images behind license agreements that included standard boilerplate stuff about how anyone who downloads the images are only granted rights to do XYZ, all other rights reserved. Again, IANAL and I don't know if the courts would see their lack of such gating and license agreements as giving implicit permission for viewers to use to train ML software, like how it gives other implicit permissions to viewers. Honestly, all this is so new that I'm not sure even a lawyer would be able to make a meaningful prediction on how things will go.
In the case of images for training image generation AI, I don't think they were published on the internet with license agreements stipulating limitations on what people could do with the images after downloading them. IANAL, but I think if you publish an image online and don't gate it in some way like behind a password login and license agreement, you get nothing beyond the default basic legal protections for how people use it, i.e. not publishing a copy or derivative work and whatnot.
It's argued that the people in question just destroy those things publicly and then need to go buy new ones, meaning it doesn't actually cause any financial harm.
I've seen this thrown around more as low-effort jabs on Twitter than a serious argument, and in multiple directions, e.g. pointing out people burning Harry Potter books or replacing the covers with Rowling's name removed, to protest Rowling's anti-trans-activist stance. The low-effort jabs tend to be responses to similarly low-effort posts where someone shows a video of themselves shooting the product in their backyard or whatever, which I don't think were meant as serious demonstrations of boycott, but rather as virtue signalling.
That's a fair point; perhaps Hollywood is doomed anyway, unless they can get AI into the executive suite as well as in the writer's room.
But I also have to wonder if the terrible writing in those Disney films is because they didn't have access to writers good enough to write good scripts while meeting the constraints placed on them by executives. Perhaps the constraints that executives place on the writers makes it literally impossible to write a good script, in which case the prior paragraph holds, but what if it's just that the writers weren't skilled enough to figure that out? I don't know what sorts of constraints the execs at Disney and Lucasarts placed on the writers for Rise of Skywalker, but perhaps a more skilled writer could have written a script that was at least half-decent? And what if AI could/would have elevated those writers to such a level?
As stark as 20% drop within a month is, I don't think you can declare a loss in your prediction yet; we've still got a long ways to go before the 6-month mark. I admit, I predicted similarly to you, and I too am surprised, and I could see the boycott having legs for 6 months and beyond, if regular consumers switch over to Coors Lite or Miller Lite or whatever and make it their habit. 6 months is more than enough time to develop a new habit that one sticks with. I personally don't drink much light beer at all, so I can't say if these products are sufficiently interchangeable that Bud Lite drinkers could stick with the change long-term; the beer snob in me would say obviously they're fungible, but that's obviously not accurate. So maybe the people who are angry/hyped enough to switch over for a month could only handle forcing down Coors Lite for so long before they have to switch back to their favored Bud Lite.
On the boycott itself, though, has any organization come out and called for people to boycott Bud Lite/ABI? I feel like I've seen a lot of people talking about not buying them in reaction to the Mulvaney marketing, but I haven't seen any widespread calls for solidarity coming from big names/organizations. Then again, I'm not much in the target audience for something like that, and I also don't remember much of that during the recent boycott against Hogwarts Legacy, so maybe I shouldn't expect to see something like that.
My main thought here is that, compared to 2007, the competition for eyeballs is much more fierce. Even ignoring social media and video games, unscripted streams and independently scripted free YouTube videos offer video entertainment accessible to the masses that Hollywood has to prove themselves better than. Their production values are still much better than even the best independent professionally produced non-Hollywood stuff, but that advantage keeps getting chipped away. The one advantage they won't lose anytime soon is ownership of lots of intellectual property, which gives them a legal monopoly on producing certain stories. I think they need to hold onto this with a death grip if they want to keep being prosperous in the future.
And to do that, they need to make sure the IPs they own are associated with high quality content. Regardless of AI, this has been in some trouble lately; e.g. for all the money MCU and Star Wars films make, the trend has clearly been negative in recent iterations, both in box office numbers and sentiment from longtime fans. A large part of that has to do with the quality of writing, which I imagine AI could help with. In the meanwhile, we're likely to see independently produced scripts become higher quality thanks to AI aid, and with the production values also getting better for similar reasons, Hollywood probably needs to make sure they're at the cutting edge in using these sorts of tech; for as well an independent creator can use this tech, Hollywood has the resources to do it 1000x as much and better.
Given that, I'm not sure that this kind of limiting of AI in script writing is viable. Looking at the quality of writing in modern Hollywood scripts, it's quite clear that an amateur writer with ChatGPT and rudimentary understanding of storytelling principles could write better-than-median quality scripts right now. And it will only get better. Perhaps the writers' guild can group together enough and prevent scabs, but then the entire industry has to compete against independent producers whose quality would go up. If the quality of writing in mainstream professional films and shows go down during this strike and/or fewer such mainstream professional films and shows get released, resulting in less prestige in the IPs that these companies hold, followed by the guild getting what they want in terms of AI leading to them having a harder time competing against AI-assisted independent creators, it could end up with less overall money flowing to Hollywood, a Pyrrhic victory for the writers.
The extent of DEI training at my own workplace in Boston has been our company president spending 1 minute talking about how much our company values diversity in our employees and such during a speech she gave at a party after offices reopened in 2021. I was worried that this was a portent of a coming DEI initiative or the like, but there's been literally nothing. I'm guessing this sort of thing is not uncommon in workplaces, and it's really just the notable outliers that gain attention on Twitter. I do think it's probably a crapshoot, with higher risk in certain parts of the country that a company you start working at could have struggle sessions, but there are plenty of opportunities for employment where they're completely avoidable.
We should really be asking why it took until 2014 for it to happen since this began in the 1960s.
My pet theory is that it just took that long for enough true believers to filter into roles of power and authority. When it was still cutting edge in the 60s and 70s, perhaps you had some or many educators pushing it, but students still had plenty of exposure and access to other views, and the educators themselves had never been taught it as dogma when they were students. As those students grew up to be educators themselves, the proportion of believers became higher, but still they weren't true true believers, since when they were students, they had been sullied by exposure to other viewpoints. But when the next generation of educators came around, they had only ever been taught by believers who themselves had been taught to believe since a young age, giving them a truly pure and immaculate belief in the ideology. I think a little bit after that was when this stuff finally did explode out into the mainstream, and now we're seeing the next generation of students - who had only been taught by believer teachers who had also only been taught by believers - age up to positions of power and authority.
Obviously this is a very simplified model, and there's been plenty of leakage and counterforces along the way, but I think it's the general outline of why it took so long.
I still stand by my original statement. 1.5% of an opioid overdose death is a much scarier possibility than the apparently 1.02% chance your child gets a gender dysphoria diagnosis.
That's still a 1.5% lifetime chance of opioid overdose death versus the dysphoria diagnosis in a 12 year period. I don't know how one would convert the 2, but they're still not like-for-like. Also, is getting a gender dysphoria diagnosis a prerequisite for getting HRT or puberty blockers?
Gender affirming care for transgender children is medically necessary.
Is this really believed by almost all Democratic politicians? I'd thought that medical transition of children as being necessary was still not universally accepted in the left. I've seen my share of left-leaning activists who are rather skeptical of it at all, much less believe it necessary. And Democratic politicians tend to lag behind the SocJus/idpol left in most issues like this.
It might be right 99% of the time, or even 99.99%, but like self driving cars this is exactly the kind of case where being good but not quite as good as a human is really dangerous.
Is getting things right 99.99%, or even 99% of the time not quite as good as a human doctor, rather than much better than a human doctor? I honestly don't know, and I'm not even sure how to quantify something like this to make like-for-like measurements. But surely at some % rate of success, the LLM would be getting things right at a rate better than could be expected of a typical (or even nth percentile) human doctor.
Which is scary in its own way. An LLM's "thought process" is currently completely unknowable, unlike that of a human doctor. So the types of mistakes it makes are likely to be more mysterious. Yet if it makes fewer mistakes and/or those mistakes are, on net, less harmful/unhealthy, then would it be our moral obligation to use those LLMs over doctors?
This situation is especially hilarious considering what the CP in NAACP stands for.
Personally, I don't really think of piracy as an ethical issue at all. Intellectual property is a legal fiction that exists for the purpose of incentivizing people to create more and better works of art and inventions, for the betterment of society. This is accomplished by restricting most people's right to speech - their right to transmit certain strings of 0s and 1s to others (which are usually representations of certain strings of letters or certain grid-arrangements of pixels) - while granting other people (i.e. the rights holders) the privilege to express that speech. Like all rights, the right to free speech isn't absolute, and this, like true threats or slander, is one of those exceptions that exist as a compromise to make society more functional and generally better for everyone. But I don't believe there's some sort of natural right that is ethically granted to creators and rights holders to restrict the types of 0s and 1s that 3rd parties are allowed to tell each other.
I do think there are more general ethical issues about simply following along with the prevailing legal norms in society; breaking those, no matter what they are, involve some level of unethical behavior, due to its degradation of the structure that keeps society running. But most people do agree that laws and ethics aren't the exact same thing, and sometimes breaking the law can be ethical; I think most times, piracy doesn't have a sufficient counterbalance to make it, on net, ethical, but sometimes it could. But either way, I don't think the ethical right for rights holders to restrict how 3rd parties transmit 0s and 1s to each other is part of it.
I do think the mainstreaming of digital media over the past couple decades has made it so that the younger generations of today take intellectual property rights as a sort of default correct thing more than younger generations of before. Of course, books, cassettes, and CDs were all real and all copy-able before the 90s, but they were still generally considered physical objects that needed physical action to copy. But the internet has caused the concept of entertainment media to be almost completely decoupled from physical material, and so kids have grown up in an environment where "intellectual property" exists as a concept and is enforced through restricting how 3rd parties communicate to each other is the norm. It'd be natural for them to come to believe in the ethical right to that in such an environment.
For my personal behavior, I used to pirate heavily 10+ years ago for basically all of my digital entertainment. The advent of Steam and more specifically its improved ease-of-use with its central marketplace and library, along with its cloud saving, made it so that I basically don't pirate video games anymore. I also personally get a little value out of knowing that I helped, even in some minor near-imperceptible way, incentivize the creation of more video games similar to the one I purchased. For films and TV shows, I still primarily pirate through torrents, though I try to watch through my Netflix subscription when it's available that way; it's usually just more convenient, and I keep my Netflix subscription primarily due to momentum. For music, I don't listen to music for the most part anyway, and the advent of YouTube as a near limitless free music resource has meant that the few times I do want to listen to music, I can freely access whatever I want. I do think the bit about convenience being the solution to piracy has a lot of truth to it in my behavior.
Wow, I thought Trudeau's "peoplekind" comment was just a completely tongue-in-cheek joke, but it looks like it's a serious term that people are seriously trying to adopt. I would've thought "humankind" was good enough, assuming someone had a problem with "mankind," but perhaps the presence of the word "man" in "humankind" still made it problematic?
An accusation of "We genuinely just searched for that which is great and good that fit the market and it happened to be comprised mostly of X" cuts both ways, y'know?
Is this something decision makers are actually claiming, though? I'm not all that familiar with the literature publishing industry, but if it's at all like other fictional media industries like movies, TV shows, and video games, almost everyone would be openly and intentionally discriminating their hires based on various identity markers, including sex and gender, rather than genuinely just searching for that which is great and good that fits the market.
I was going to guess Duke Nukem as well, before I read that it was Commander Keen. Funny to think, both of those 2D platformers were the predecessors to revolutionary genre-defining first person shooters in the 90s, Duke Nukem 3D for the former, obviously, and Doom for the latter. Duke Nukem 1 was the first game I ever beat all the way through, thanks to it both having a save system and being easy enough for a fairly uncoordinated kid like me to beat. I played it using a joystick, one of those flight joysticks that you grip with one hand with thumb buttons at the top, just because I thought that's how I was supposed to play it; in retrospect, simple keyboard controls would've made the game much easier.
I have a hard time seeing it as a veneer of materialism. The “immaterial forces” are something like justice or fairness. I think those have a pretty solid foundation in materialism.
I was actually referring to "oppression" (or "systemic -ism" or "patriarchy" or "white supremacy" or other similar terms). It's certainly the same word as one that's used to refer to a real concept with a solid foundation in materialism, but as used by the religion in question, it refers to an essentially magical concept due to how it is claimed to have impacts on interactions between individuals, while lacking the sort of scientific backing to support such claims. Again, I think this is ingenious for its ability to convince otherwise secular/materialist people of this supernatural force, but it is a veneer, and scratching the surface reveals that it's magical thinking that fundamentally rests on faith, not dissimilar to a belief in an omnipotent God that works in mysterious ways.
I think in practice it's comprehensive enough and addresses fundamental questions, particularly about how we humans relate to one another, and one of its great innovations is in doing so in practice while having the actual written-down tenets not actually look like they're as comprehensive and totalizing as they are. Likewise, I think, at best, one can say that its duties of conscience are anchored in something that has a veneer of materialism, but underneath that veneer is a fundamentally faith-based belief in immaterial forces that guide human relationships. And even if we could quibble about just how comprehensive it is, I think the fact that it is fundamentally anchored to a faith such that its tenets exist necessarily downstream from that faith makes it fit the category of "religion" for the purposes of limiting the US government's promotion of it. I objected to public schools teaching intelligent design on this basis.
But IANAL, so perhaps I'm mistaken on exactly how US 1st Amendment gets applied. If so, this seems like a massive hole in the law; if faith-based cults can get government sponsorship just by not being sufficiently comprehensive in their tenets, this would provide a mechanism by which the US government would be allowed to promote virtually any religious view. Perhaps what we're observing right now in real-time is a religion that has managed to exploit this security hole and US society and legislators scrambling to patch it before the exploit causes too much harm.
Personally it also stems from the fact that I wish I’d transitioned when I was younger, and like many other trans people, would like to spare others from the hell that’s going through the wrong puberty and be stuck with a body you hate that you want to surgically alter.
This is a very reasonable motivation, and the mirror image of this would be people who transitioned when they were young and regret it, knowing that they would have been happier if they had just waited it out and realized that they were cis. I've personally known someone like this, who started transitioning FTM in her late teens only to regret it and try to reverse it in her early 20s, which still left her with many permanent changes that she didn't like. There's also the fact that if I had been a preteen in the current social environment, there's a high chance I personally would have been convinced to transition MTF, which, as an adult now, I know for a fact would have been vastly harmful to my life.
Unfortunately, until we achieve true technological transhumanism, false positives and false negatives will always be with us and cause immense suffering for the people in those groups. I do think it's incumbent on anyone who wants to make life better in the future for children to acknowledge the downsides of both and to seek out better ways to identify and prevent them. This not only means more concern for making sure that kids who believe themselves to be trans have to go through sufficient screening to determine if they truly are trans, but also making sure that kids are provided the resources needed to even know what transness is and whether or not they actually fit it. Which I see both the self-proclaimed trans rights activists and their opponents mostly failing at, respectively.
This seems to be really reaching for things that weren't in the above comment. It's not that people can't rationally argue for things that are in their own interest, it's that they can't be trusted to do so. That doesn't mean we should automatically disregard her arguments, but it does provide one explanation why her arguments are so bad when judged on its own merits, in this particular context. And it means one should be extra skeptical of their arguments and look out for sleights of hand that allow them to gerrymander the desired results, since the desired results are the only allowable ones that the person is likely to engineer their arguments around.
Can we disregard any arguments about the existence of God from religious people?
Presuming "religious people" refers to people who lack the ability to be convinced of the nonexistence of God, rather than merely people who follow or believe in some religion, we can't automatically disregard such arguments, but certainly it would explain why their arguments are so bad.
Arguments about why cancel culture is bad from people who have been cancelled?
Being "canceled" doesn't automatically imply that one has a dogmatic belief that "cancel culture" is bad. Plenty of people who have been "canceled" believe that their own "cancellation" is bad for the specifics around their own "cancellation" but that the general concept is okay. Heck, I think JK Rowling is one of them, though I'm not sure she's made any specific comments about "cancel culture" in the past. So this analogy doesn't really work.
This is one reason why, as a progressive, I believe that a strong and vibrant conservative movement is not just desirable but necessary for progressivism to succeed. Progressivism is supposed to be about progress (I think the term has been mostly redefined due to use by its own proponents to mean something else in recent years), and progress isn't the same thing as change - for change to be progress, it has to be forward in some meaningful way, in this context something like better. Anyone is going to have the bias that the change they want will accomplish something better than before, and so progressives can't be trusted to accurately assess whether the changes we're calling for is actually progress or just change that we genuinely believe is good. So we need people to argue and fight against us so that the strongest, most correct changes are the ones that stand up to scrutiny and are actually implemented, while the weakest, most misguided changes get trashed. It's highly imperfect and messy, but that's the best way I can see for us to even make a sort of attempt at achieving actual progress rather than merely change that I've convinced myself is progress.
I see where you’re coming from, but disagree that DEI is a religion. Or, at least, not “specifically and openly” one.
I did not write that DEI is "specifically and openly" a religion. I wrote that it's "a specifically and openly faith-based worldview with certain morals that follow downstream of that faith." The ingenuousness of it is that it's a religion that wins over people who have largely been inoculated against religions thanks to our modern secular culture. But perhaps it's more correct to say that DEI is a specific practice of a religion, in the same way that Baptism or praying to Mecca 5x a day aren't religions in themselves, but specific practices of Christianity and Islam, respectively.

This only strengthens your point, but I think The Mummy was a remake or reimagining of an older film from the 30s.
More options
Context Copy link