@07mk's banner p

07mk


				

				

				
2 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 06 15:35:57 UTC

				

User ID: 868

07mk


				
				
				

				
2 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 06 15:35:57 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 868

I do think it applies to "groomer" as well, and the people who call others "groomers" for advocating for minors to take steps towards transitioning, particularly in-secret-from/overruling their parents may very well be successful in their (re)defining of the term. Who knows how it will play out; certainly it's being pushed back on heavily, not least because "groomer" is a slightly more generic word than "transphobia."

That is exactly the meaning that both the people using it evidently intend, and the people listening to them evidently derive from their arguments. If words derive meaning through usage, where can that meaning possibly come from but how they're used and understood?

This is a fair point, and the other half about how they're understood is something I didn't consider properly above. What I think is happening is that the people using that term are relying on the inertia of the term to get the people who listen to the term to experience negative affect from the term. That is, when someone hears "-phobia," it automatically triggers a sense of observing some sort of irrational/severe fear, hatred, or bigotry, and the people using the term are relying on this. However, the actual concrete thing that they're describing do not fit those things; they're merely things like disagreeing that trans women are real women. This is probably an intentional tactic, learned from observing the success of similar usage of other terms like "misogyny" or "white supremacy" in similar ways. As they say, the market can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent, and so they're able to bankrupt plenty of their perceived enemies along the way while the market sorts itself out and figures out what they actually mean when they use these terms.

I'm not sure it's "ok," but does that really matter? People choose to do things not based on whether or not it's "ok" in some abstract moral sense, but based on whether or not they can get away with it. The people who are defining "transphobia" to mean "disagrees with me on trans issues" seem to be able to get away with it. They're probably being intellectually dishonest - at the very least, intellectually lazy - but it's not like we can impose negative consequences on them for being so. My personal approach is to just embrace and accelerate the redefining; yes, it's transphobia, and transphobia is the morally/logically correct position to take.

I think we'd all agree that someone advocating for a return to chattel slavery (at least assuming they had a real chance of success) would justify the use of "cancel culture" tactics today (if anything could), but this simply wasn't a morally obvious truth in the 1850s.

You think wrong. I would disagree, and on the strongest possible terms. Not unless that advocating took the form of, say, literal kidnapping and enslaving of people or even calling for specific sorts of actions by his followers to do the like. If someone were to write essays, make YouTube videos, give speeches, run for office on a platform, etc. where they explicitly called for the repeal of the 13th Amendment and legislating the chattel slavery of certain types of people, I would support their right to do so without impediment or difficulty in their livelihood and such. Now, the "assuming they had a real chance of success" is a very difficult theoretical to imagine, as such a world would look vastly different from the current one, but if we're in an environment where someone like me would find chattel slavery to be as obviously morally wrong as the real me does now, it would have to be one where that person also has a very real chance of failure due to the incredibly strong political will to prevent return chattel slavery. And I would direct any and all energy that might have been used in "canceling" this person towards amplifying the voices of the political figures who would defeat this guy and his ilk in the polls, as well as other influential people who could sway opinion in the masses. Perhaps I wouldn't have the energy left over after that to fight against whatever people might be trying to "cancel" this guy, but I would certainly want such "cancel culture" attempts to not exist.

It doesn't really affect my point, because I specifically qualified the use of "cancellation" on the legitimate belief that it would prevent his rise.

I think part of the issue here is that a legitimate belief isn't necessarily a correct belief, and someone who genuinely wants to do good in this world has the responsibility to make sure that his beliefs are not just legitimate but also correct. That's an endless endeavor, of course. But in this particular case, one could argue that someone who has a legitimate belief that this sort of "cancellation" would prevent the rise of Hitler in the 1930s is someone who hasn't take on the proper responsibility of figuring out if his legitimate belief is also a correct belief.

This is rather far away from the initial discussion about "cancel culture" and its possible usefulness in general, though.

What does it mean to be "transphobic"? Could one not be "transphobic" and still refuse to acknowledge that "trans women are women"? Because I would like to say that I'm not "transphobic" on the basis that I don't think trans people should be denied rights that we accord to others, or that they should be forcibly prevented from dressing like women, or even (if over 18) allowed to surgically alter themselves to match their desired gender identity (perhaps with some reasonable safeguards).

To state a truism, words gain meaning through usage, rather than through some sort of application of logic on first principles. "Transphobia" might have components that imply that it should mean something like "irrational or severe fear/hatred of trans people," but that's not what it actually means. In practice, the people who use the term "transphobia" - and hence the people who most get to define what it means - use it in such a way as to describe people who refuse to acknowledge that "trans women are women" and more generally just disagrees with self-proclaimed trans rights activists on anything trans-related. Obviously that's an imprecise definition, but words tend to have imprecise definitions, and I think, based on observations of self-proclaimed trans rights activists, refusing to acknowledge that "trans women are women" is solidly in the "transphobia" camp.

If, say, someone was going around and gathering a following by literally advocating for the murder of Jews, I think a lot of us would agree that public shaming (at the least) would be appropriate. That means that one must always have some object-level discussion about what people are being cancelled for before one can reasonably argue that any given cancellation is unacceptable. It's hardly a groundbreaking observation, but it's true nonetheless that there must be a line somewhere that would make "cancel culture" type tactics acceptable; we're all just debating where that line is.

This looks like the fallacy of gray to me. Yes, (just about) everyone carves out an exception to free speech when advocating for literal murder is involved, but the advocating for literal murder is one of those things that's close to black and white, with many mostly well understood and mostly agreed-upon boundaries. And for things like the kind of things that fall under the "transphobia" umbrella, it's quite clear which side of those boundaries they lie on. This, I believe, is why so many self-proclaimed TRAs claim they're fighting against "trans genocide," in a way to evoke the affect of crossing that boundary, even as each individual specific example of such "genocide" clearly falls on the other side when examined closely. Self-proclaimed TRAs aren't unique or even unusual in this, though.

They should, and they 100% have the legal power to, AFAIK. But not all supervision is reasonable, and at some point it can go into micromanagement territory that does more harm than good. E.g. legislators could theoretically explicitly mandate by law that the trash collector must wear shoes that have 8 shoelace holes on odd-numbered days and 10 shoelace holes on even-numbered days, since trash collectors are employees of the state, but that would be a ridiculous level of micromanagement, and most people would agree that legislators drafting laws to that effect and specificity would do more harm than good. I lean towards believing that the legislature having specific mandates about tenure in public universities is micromanagement rather than reasonable supervision, though I'm not strong in this belief.

I don't have an opinion on tenure, and I lean on the side of thinking that legislation ought not to interfere with the operations of even public universities to the extent of banning it. Likewise, I'm not sure that legislation ought to specifically compel firings of professors spreading odious views, including "belief that any race, sex, or ethnicity or social, political, or religious belief is inherently superior to any other race, sex, ethnicity, or belief." As described by Aaronson, the professor would have to at least attempt to "compel" this belief, but that could mean something as innocuous as stating it in class and winking, for all I know. I don't know if setting the precedent for such legislative micromanaging causes more harm than good.

But for SB17, as described by Aaronson:

The Texas Senate is considering two other bills this week: SB 17, which would ban all DEI (Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion) programs, offices, and practices at public universities

seems like a very straightforward implementation of the first amendment religion clause. DEI is clearly a religion, a specifically and openly faith-based worldview with certain morals that follow downstream of that faith, and much like how public universities ought not push Christianity or Islam on its faculty or students, it ought not push DEI on them either. The devil's in the details, I suppose, since public universities certainly can make accommodations for religions including having services, and maybe this law might go too far. I would think that such a specific law wouldn't even be required, though, since the Constitution already covers this.

Thanks for clarifying, though I admit I'm still confused. In that case, what you meant by bullet B is "Code in a box gains the ability to solve some problem at all," and I'm not sure what that actually means. People write code in boxes specifically in order to solve problems, so trivially code in a box can solve problems. So clearly that's not what you're referring to. What's the differentiator that allows us to distinguish between code in a box that has the ability to solve some problems at all and code in a box that lacks that ability, given that all code in boxes exist purely for their (purported - depending on the coder's skill) ability to solve some problem?

I assume the creator chose this because he couldn’t make a pie chart that cheats so hard.

I can't recall where I saw it, but I saw some newspaper clipping a while back that just straight-up had no correlation between the pie chart size and the percentage. With subtle manipulation, this would be hard to detect and could even be plausibly denied as intentional manipulation rather than carelessness, but this one, IIRC, had a sliver with a number greater than 50% over a slice whose arc was clearly under 180 degrees. It certainly made me more careful about paying close attention to every part of a chart and their correlation to the underlying data whenever I encountered a chart in some article. Which kind of defeats the purpose of charts, but what can you do.

I was thinking that too as I read that comment, but that objection seems to be covered by "(F): Such machines independently achieve C sans A and/or B" - C being FOOM, A being sentience, and B being ability to solve out-of-context problems (I'm personally not even sure what this B actually means).

P.S.: in my likeliest scenario you personally are quite plausibly among those that are left, so I don't think taking anything you say at face value would do me any good.

I'm curious, what does your likeliest scenario look like, particularly in terms of which people are left and which people aren't? If it's a millionfold reduction in human population, that'd mean a population of around 8,000, and I'd be surprised if anyone using this forum were one of them outside of just pure dumb luck. But I don't know the details of the mechanism to get there from here, so obviously I'm missing something.

Terminator: Genisys was the monkey paw version of that film, and at its release was by far the worst Terminator film, by a very large margin. And Terminator 3 wasn't even particularly good. I don't know if that's changed now with Dark Fate, since I didn't watch that one.

Personally, I think the Terminator franchise ought to remain as is, rather than exploring the origin and takeover of Skynet. The original film was a slasher horror film with the AI takeover time travel premise as almost just a framing device, and the 2nd film was almost a remake of the 1st film in that same basic structure. They succeeded because the execution of the horror and action scenes were incredibly good, and the emotional plot and character arcs were good as well. The scifi premise wasn't there to be taken seriously or explored in depth.

Taking this guy's metaphor seriously, there's quite a bit of self-own aspect to it, given that X-Men's plot largely centers around the government actually wanting to genocide mutants in the sense of hunting them down and locking them up in camps/killing them. And mutants in X-Men also tend to be shown as superior to non-mutants in some meaningful concrete sense, which is what allows them to be the comic book superheroes they are (though there are plenty of downsides too). Also, he seems to be conflating "mutants" with "aliens" when he talks about mutants from outer space; mutants are definitionally humans with mutated genes.

I think if this clip gets any sort of traction in the progressive left, it will just be fairly standard fodder for "look at what this ignorant hateful bigot is saying about this oppressed minority. This is a truly mask-off moment that shows that our outgroup really is as evil as we say they are and all that talk about just protecting children and whatnot is just camouflage for their true desire to literally murder trans people." The fact that he's black wouldn't really play much into it, since black people (and other minorities) who don't toe the party line have generally not gotten any protection at all from the backlash; if anything, it tends to heighten it due to being perceived as a traitor to the cause. That latter part probably won't play a factor either, though, since blackness and transness, though grouped together under the wide umbrella of "oppressed minority," are still considered fairly distinct. And antipathy between black people and sexual minorities, particularly gay people, has been well known; and the sexual minorities win that oppression Olympics conflict at least 99 times out of 100.

I'm actually curious, in what ways would it be worse if more transwomen could convincingly pass?

Allegedly he's had facial surgery, I don't know. His face is still very masculine and doesn't do him any favours in some pictures.

I don't think Mulvaney comes anywhere close to passing, but when I look at that picture in particular, the face doesn't stand out to me as particularly masculine. Perhaps it's because it's an exaggerated facial expression that distorts the shape quite a bit, but if I didn't know who I was looking at, I could be convinced it's an older cis woman (though my 1st guess would be trans woman).

I 1st saw him in this clip of the guy on Price is Right a couple weeks ago, on Twitter by, I think Sarah Haider (president of Ex-Muslims of North America) who was commenting on the person clearly being someone with an unhealthy need for attention. Even despite the fact that Haider isn't the type to shitpost, I genuinely wasn't sure if this wasn't some SNL-style parody of someone. After seeing the clip, I just moved on but kept seeing his name come up here and there on Twitter, but it was only when this Bud Light thing happened that it just seemed to be everywhere. But never through running into actual primary sources; it was only through culture war discussions on Twitter or Reddit. From everything I've seen, it does seem like Mulvaney either has a great talent for grabbing attention or an unhealthy compulsion for it, and perhaps we're playing exactly into his hands here. There's definitely something about him that makes it hard to look away when I do encounter him, but I don't feel the desire to seek him out and do wish I ran into him less often.

the right wing is proving that it’s every bit as susceptible to purity spirals and moral panics as the left wing.

I find it fascinating that this is a claim that's being talked about. When I was a child/young adult in the 90s and 00s, the very concept of "moral panic" was considered a distinctly right wing phenomenon, associated with stuff about fear mongering violence in video games or evangelical Christian busybody Moral Majority types. Perhaps in the back of our heads, we acknowledged that it could happen on the left, but a left wing moral panic was basically considered an oxymoron. Things sure have changed since then, to reach this point where the left wing owns the concept and it's a revelation that the right wing can be just as bad. The thing about history being cyclical or a pendulum might have some truth to it.

Eh, kind of? Clarence Thomas benefits from the anti-racist fight even if he doesn't want to, same with any trans person who isn't aligned with the movement.

This presumes that both the anti-racist fight and the trans activist movements, by their actions provide benefits to black people and to trans people in general, respectively. I don't think that presumption is well justified generally and particularly for the latter. Certainly if one subscribes to whatever ideology is in question, then seeing their favored ideology pushed and succeed can provide benefits, but whether or not the success of the ideology provides benefits to the subjects of the ideology is an open question.

I started listening to the audiobook of Robert Heinlein's The Moon is a Harsh Mistress this past week. It wasn't some conscious choice, just a novel I'd heard a lot about and had bought on my Audible account a couple years ago which I happened to notice after I had finished my previous audiobook (Dark Harvest by Will Jordan, who is perhaps more famous by is YouTube persona The Critical Drinker - after listening to it, despite the author being an excellent critic of fiction, I don't think he's a particularly good creator of it), and I was surprised to learn that starting on chapter 1, an AI program that manages logistics on the Moon was a major plot point/character. It plays a practical joke before the events of the book by giving some janitor something like a trillion dollars more on his paycheck than normal, which causes the protagonist to be contracted to fix it, leading to them forming a sort of relationship, which includes discussions about humor and jokes and the AI's ability to understand humor. I found it interesting that the AI was depicted as actually having some competence in understanding humor, not too far from that of a typical human and perhaps even to the level of a socially inept human, in contrast to how I'd normally see AI depicted in 20th century media, lacking emotion for the sake of pure logic. It's not too far off from the kind of humor I've seen ChatGPT4 generate, indicating it still undershot how good an AI would be at this kind of conversation by the time we're using one to manage infrastructure.

The one joke that I heard the AI actually make up is "Why is a laser beam like a goldfish? Because neither one can whistle." When I asked ChatGPT to come up with a punchline for the same joke, it said "Because they both have great aim but a short memory!" which isn't any funnier, but gets a bit more at what a punchline should look like.

There were other parts in the 1st few chapters that reminded me a lot of stuff often discussed on The Motte/SSC. There's also talks of labor movements and violent suppression of such, along with multi-generational polyamorous marriages (the protagonist literally calls one of his wives "mom," and their conversations are far more similar to that of a worrying mother and son than a wife and husband), and an out-and-out rape joke told by a woman sarcastically claiming the protagonist raped her to a third party, which is purely played for laughs. It's often fascinating seeing scifi works from the past after the march of progress has worn away at that "fi" portion, and this one is definitely no exception.

I'd guess there's a bunch of reasons other than just plain old coincidence. One is that there just aren't that many female programmers, so there's a relatively higher proportion of MTF women in the industry. Also the well known male/female difference in interest-in-things versus interest-in-people could be resistant to whatever the cause of an MTF transwoman to be a transwoman rather than a cis man, and also resistant (perhaps not fully immune, but resistant nonetheless) to whatever treatment they might undergo as part of the transition. And there's also some (weak) indication that autism is correlated with transness. The latter 2 don't automatically translate to someone being better at programming, but it's not hard to see why someone who's further on the autism spectrum and with a greater interest in things could develop programming skills further than otherwise.

The 1st 2 could be attributed to patriarchy under standard modern feminist ideology. Not having roughly same amount of female programmers in the industry as male ones is, tautologically, an indication that society hasn't been engineered in such a way as to equalize the proportion of the sexes within this industry, and this is attributable to patriarchy no matter what the mechanism. If society has largely provided women the freedom to pursue whatever careers they want and they're just choosing not to pursue programming - which is likely the case in most western societies - that means that society has sent girls some sort of messaging that has discouraged them away from pursuing programming, which is a form of patriarchy. For the 2nd, the same reasoning applies, just to the interest-in-things/interest-in-people difference. The fact that there's some measurable difference between the sexes in this dichotomy means that there must be some sort of messaging, possibly starting even from the womb, that girls receive that pushes them towards greater interest in people rather than things. The messaging can take forms that are literally invisible and undetectable, but it must be there, and it must be an indication of patriarchy, as long as the results are the kind of imbalance we're talking about.

For the 3rd one, I'm not sure what feminist ideology has to say about the apparent correlation between autism and transness - it might not exist in any case, since I don't think this has been studied much. But there's got to be a way to attribute it to patriarchy somehow if it turns out to be the case; it's just that both autism and transness are considered to be "innate" or "born with it," and I'm not creative enough to come up with a way by which patriarchy can be attributed to a correlation between the 2, but that doesn't mean nobody is that creative.

As for why we talk about those who physically transition, that should be obvious. The ones who don't want to never get media attention on them. Action naturally attracts attention in a way that inaction doesn't.

Well, they sometimes do, in the context of specifically transwomen being allowed in female/women's spaces. The idea that any random male could declare herself a woman and expect to walk into a female locker room or bathroom is something that's caused some controversy. But it's the kind of thing that has happened rarely enough that it hasn't attracted as much attention as kids transitioning (beyond just the fact that controversies involving kids automatically tend to punch above their weight).

Trans activists are fighting for all trans people, regardless of whether they transition physically or not. This has never been in contention.

I think this is in contention. Perhaps I'm just being pedantic, but who trans activists are fighting for are trans people of any stripe who also happen to agree with the activists' ideology. I believe it's an open question as to whether this constitutes all trans people or enough to round up to all or even most trans people - trans people are so few and dispersed that I'm not sure it's even possible to do a credible random sampling of them to get some accurate view of what they tend to believe.

There's a bit of a chicken-and-egg issue in this as well, in that there's indications of a social contagion, especially among girls, where there's actual causality - people who were led to being trans from their ideology.

And no one else will pick it up because essentially all the marketing people who would be hired into a big brand are aligned.

Burgers?

I also wonder a fair bit about the fact that outrageously distorted caricaturization seems to be less of a thing with females who live as men (or even as non-binary). Most of the "trans" females I encounter are just not-very-girly lesbians using counterintuitive pronouns. I don't know if this is because it would be difficult-to-impossible for someone with a female body to convincingly parody masculinity (at least without the aid of dangerous quantities of illicit steroids)

I think this is at least a large factor; visual stereotypes of masculinity tend to be indicative of some level of hard work and accomplishment, such as big muscles or outward confidence that's hard to fake without having competence to back it up. I think there's also the fact that stereotypes of masculinity is less associated with fashion; men's fashion is well known to be conservative, far moreso than women's fashion, and to whatever extent men deviate from the conservative norm, they tend to be considered less masculine. So caricaturizing that conservative-ness in a way that stands out is inherently difficult to pull off. Whereas many of the distorted caricaturizations of femininity by transwomen one sees is reliant on taking the creativity or outright flamboyance of stereotypically feminine fashion up to 11 and beyond.

I too doubt any sort of boycott would have any measurable negative impact, much less a meaningful one, to these companies, but I also wonder how well this sort of marketing will work out for Anheuser-Busch. The types of people that I know who would be attracted to a brand by Mulvaney's endorsement are also the types of people who wouldn't be caught dead drinking Bud Light (though something by a brewery owned by Anheuser-Busch is another question), and I can't imagine this allowing them to overcome that distaste. But the people I know are obviously not representative of such a population, so maybe there are a lot of people who would be converted to drinking Bud Light that Anheuser-Busch's marketing identified. The effects of marketing is well known to be illegible even by marketers, so perhaps it's just a more general latching-onto-the-bandwagon thing. Actually, now that I think about it, it could also be an investment in the future: as current preteens and teenagers - a population I believe is more skewed than the rest of the population towards being positively influenced by Mulvaney's endorsement - age up into drinking age, their mental association between Mulvaney and Bud Light, now reinforced for multiple of their most impressionable years - could push them more towards that beer.

Bouncing off Tanista's comment quoting a British writer, maybe we could get an MCCU - the Morally Correct Cinematic Universe - in contrast to the MCU. A whole series of historical docudramas showing us the "imaginary, better version of the world" with consistent actors playing the same historical figures in multiple films and all that.