As I understand it, progressivism cannot exist alongside conservatism, because all of the progress done by the former will always be challenged by the latter.
This is almost the exact opposite of my understanding of progressivism and conservatism. Progressivism must exist alongside conservatism because the progress done by the former will always be challenged by the latter. Every ideology must be challenged in order for that ideology to be strengthened and corrected by attack from its strongest opponents, with the weakest and most harmful parts of that ideology not surviving that contact, which only benefits that ideology. Any ideology that must have its opponents not exist is one that is also a totalitarian dogmatic religion, and I don't believe progressivism is one. Subjecting one's ideology to its opponents is the basic scientific way of approaching ideology, which, again, I used to think was what progressivism was all about. Again, over the years, I've certainly become more cynical about how progressive people view progressivism, but I've personally tried to keep by the tenets myself.
In my opinion, the value of a forum like this is that it allows progressives, at least such as myself, to observe a rich diversity of right-winged thinking to identify the more insidious and subtle dogwhistles indicating the traits of a conservative, so one may steer clear of them in IRL interactions.
In my younger years, I would have thought that this sort of intentional closing off to other perspectives was definitionally antithetical to progressivism, but I must admit that my own cynicism about the supposed tenets of progressivism has grown in the past decade or so. I personally try to hew to the tenets of progressivism and expose myself to such conservatives in IRL interactions as much as I can (which, to be fair, is very low due to the physical location in which I reside, where IRL conservatives are about as common as a zebra/unicorn hybrid), but I do understand now that different progressives understand progressivism differently from me.
If EU starts discussing a TikTok ban as well, I wonder how that would affect this strategy (they'd probably just move to another platform, though).
Given how much platforms like YouTube, Facebook, and Twitter have been pushing their own versions of portrait-aspect-ratio-short-videos, that's what I'd guess too. The extent to which YouTube has been pushing their "shorts" to me as a viewer has been... almost upsetting, TBH. And from what I've heard, they've been pushing creators to it as well for better overall treatment by "the algorithm," though I take that with a grain of salt. This sort of follow-the-leader effect by TikTok has been by far the worst impact of TikTok I've noticed, as someone who doesn't use that platform.
I must admit I'm a bit surprised, both in the direction and the magnitude of the direction. A priori, I would have guessed that the strong norms of free speech and personal liberty would have made it so that Americans would generally be against a government-mandated ban on TikTok. The trends between Republicans/Democrats and conservatives/liberals doesn't surprise me, at least, since I would expect the former to be more prioritizing of stuff like protection of children from social media brainrot and protection of US citizen data from Chinese governments over freedom of people to use social media services that could be harmful to themselves and others. On a personal level, I think TikTok is probably a net negative both to US society and to US citizens, but I also think that the government setting a precedent of banning TikTok is probably a much bigger net negative to US society and to US citizens.
There aren't very many Democrats or progressives on this forum and I'd hazard to guess most of them view trying to push back to be a waste of time
This is likely true. But as a progressive Democrat myself, I wonder how many people here are like me in that I don't particularly want to push back but rather read and learn. It's pretty easy to see countless arguments that Donald Trump is a particularly norm-breaking POTUS practically everywhere I look, but it's harder to see arguments of the "sore loser" theory, especially any good or strong versions of those arguments. A large part of my motivation in reading posts in this forum is to see such things in the hopes that they actually challenge my biased perspective on various CW issues including Donald Trump, in the hopes that I can form a more accurate view of them.
For this particular issue, what I'd most prefer to see is a progressive Democrat make a case for the "sore loser" theory and a MAGA Republican make a case for the "Trump was a particularly norm-breaking POTUS in a way that was genuinely dangerous to democracy" theory, not out of charity but out of genuine, heartfelt belief. Because those are the arguments that I would find the most credible and most valuable for triangulating the actual truth of the matter. Unfortunately, such people don't seem to be particularly available, and so I want to see the strongest version of the theory I personally find distasteful or wrong on a visceral level, which is the "sore loser" theory.
I'm reminded of the very first episode of one of the most CW-involved TV shows of all time, South Park, which featured an adult teaching kids to hunt and instructing them to always shout "He's coming right at me!" before shooting any animal. I think it was a commentary on gun control or hunting licenses or something, but perhaps all of the culture wars are just that same phenomenon in different forms.
In fact, I get the sense that this is fully in effect whenever culture war escalation occurs from either side. Saying that you would be more successful at winning over supporters of the other side by following a principled position close to the centre is perceived by culture warriors as akin to "you shouldn't dress so provocatively next time".
This is the kind of attitude that only seems possible if one is dogmatically confident about one's own sociopolitical views. Without such dogmatic confidence, you welcome the opportunity to receive criticism that makes your messaging better and, more importantly IMHO, makes your own position more correct. As a young left/liberal/progressive/Democrat in the 00s-10s, I had thought that my side was the side against dogma as a very concept, and that those various sociopolitical views associated with that side like pro-gay marriage, feminism, atheism, pro-immigration, etc. were the downstream consequences of that rejection of dogmatism (and embrace of science), but since then I've come to learn that this was not the case.
Fair enough. "Understand" is a pretty underdefined term in this context, and I was thinking of our internal feeling and experience of knowing that, say, "chair" refers to a certain concept, but that's not the only thing "understand" can refer to. Certainly an AI could be said to "understand" the meaning of something if it behaves in a way that is equivalent to someone who understands the meaning, even if it doesn't experience qualia or have consciousness, and thus it has no internal experience of its own. For a chatbot like ChatGPT, that would be producing text that looks like it was typed by someone who understood the meaning of the prompt. It's not clear to me how we can tell that some text produced by ChatGPT crosses some threshold where we can say that it shows some level of "understanding" the meaning. It certainly makes errors often where it clearly doesn't understand the prompts, but humans often don't understand the meaning of what is asked of them either, and so a perfect record would be too high a bar. I was just curious where you would place the bar.
If we had an AI that actually understood the meaning of what it was being asked
How would we actually detect this, though? I don't think we know how to detect qualia or consciousness yet.
Perhaps the game could be f2p but with paid DLC for customization to reduce the effective costs? With AI tech getting better, it might be feasible in the near future to have players to pay to get their classmates and teachers into the game as NPCs, mimicking their looks, their voices, even their personalities and gaits, by having the players just submit video of the people in question. Even modeling maps after their own real schools might be possible (are public school blueprints available anywhere?). Or maybe a sort of gacha system - which is notoriously profitable for targeting people with poor impulse control, which teenagers tend to be compared to adults - for getting famous people and famous schools in. Imagine pulling on a banner so you can virtually shoot the cast of whatever high/middle school sitcom is popular among the kids these days in a virtual representation of the actual school depicted on the show.
Where would we draw a line? What's the red flag for undue influence?
For better or worse, I don't think we have any easy answers to this. But one major factor I think is as close to a red flag or bright line as anything can be in this context is whether or not the activists are open to some sort of the scientific method being applied to their claims and methods. Activists are sometimes helpful and sometimes not, and we need a way to actually figure that out on a case-by-case basis, and the only way to do that is if their specific claims can be analyzed by both oppositional and disinterested parties. If the activists have a pattern of pushing back against scrutiny and skepticism instead of embracing them as ways to make their own activism better and more helpful, then they're trying to cheat - both others and themselves - and ought to be kicked out of the game.
There's a balance that needs to be struck, because no one can spend all their time addressing every counterargument or demand for access someone might throw at them, and it's reasonable to demand limits to such things. But I think it's often not too hard to figure out the underlying attitude from general patterns of what are rejected and what reasons are invoked and the like. There will always be a subjective component to this, but I'm not sure we can get brighter lines or redder flags than that.
I'm still working on fixing my dihydrogen monoxide addiction.
This whole situation seems like a perfect storm of... a lot of things, starting with the fact that it's fundamentally about children, which tends to bring out the least rational, most passionate sides in people, both for better and for worse. I've only heard of this Mermaids group in passing so I'm not intimately familiar with them, but the way you describe them and your further notes about trans activists speaking on behalf of trans kids brings to mind this old blog post that resonated with me, particularly "It felt like I was talking to an AI designed to maximize the number of trans people." The idea of such activists having any influence on actual care providers seems completely FUBAR to me, and likely to cause truly monstrous travesties.
I admit part of my reaction here is colored by a couple of personal factors: 1. I knew a temporarily FTM transman who decided to detransition back to woman partway in and who had felt betrayed by the community that had pushed her to transition and the permanent physical changes she had gone through during her initial transition as a girl in her late teens, and 2. I could easily see myself as having been pushed to transition MTF if I had been born 30 years later and grown up in the same places I have; I am quite fine with being cis male now as an adult. These make me feel that the dangers of false positives are very important to acknowledge and work around. It's only through cold empirical study that we can nail down the proper ways to detect and serve the true positives and false positives, and activists whose motivations seem to be to maximize the true positives with little-to-no concern for everything else should have precisely zero influence in that study.
I think back in 2016-2018, on the actual Slatestarcodex comment section (likely one of the open threads), I had a conversation with someone who believed that calling out the media lying/misleading about Donald Trump in a negative way was worthy of derision, because doing such would help Trump to get (re-? I don't remember the exact date)elected. I disagreed strongly, because my view was that the media spreading such deceptions was discrediting itself, and it was only by calling out such deceptions that the media could be pushed to correct itself and stop its self-discrediting, and it's only by having a credible media that the populace could be expected to take seriously true negative things that the media claimed about Trump. And as someone who felt very strongly about not wanting Trump as POTUS (or as 2-term POTUS), I wanted the media called out on each and every such deception, as harshly as possible.
I feel similarly about this situation. Medical care for potentially trans kids is very important to nail down, and whatever medical institutions come up with the standards for care need to have credibility that they did their homework in a scientific, rigorous way. If there's any indication of undue pressure by certain activist groups to these institutions to put their thumb on the scale, that destroys their credibility, leaving us at square 1 on figuring out this very important issue. So I would expect that anyone who actually cares about helping potentially trans kids would make it a high priority to make sure that such credibility-destroying influence gets called out and corrected. And contrapositively, anyone who's hesitant to call out such influence for whatever reason is someone who can't be trusted to actually want what's good for such kids. And this goes just as strongly for any sort of anti-TRAs that might exist who behave in a way as to maximize the number of true negatives, even if that means maximizing false negatives, who might have undue influence on medical institutions.
That's all pretty meta, and I wish I could form some meaningful opinion at the object level, but at this point, I'll admit that for most CW topics, and certainly this one, I'm just mostly suspicious of anyone who has strong opinions either way at the object level due to how, at the meta level, the ability to find actual true knowledge of the object level concepts seem to have been so corrupted, often intentionally.
That is the quiet part being spoken out loud.
I don't think it's even the quiet part. From what I've seen, conservatives are perfectly open about saying that men and women are fundamentally different, including men having a greater tendency for violence and general aggression, and openly use this as justification for harsher penalties on men and greater protection for women around men.
We’re not going to show the full statue of David to kindergartners. We’re not going to show him to second graders. Showing the entire statue of David is appropriate at some age. We’re going to figure out when that is.
This really caught me off guard. Really, not to kindergartners? He states it as if it's just obvious that no decent person would show this famous statue in its entirety to kindergartners just because it has anatomically correct genitalia. I don't know if it's American prudishness even as an American, since American prudishness has changed a lot in the past 30 years I've lived there. I have to wonder if Donald Rumsfeld's John Ashcroft's, per correction below practice during Bush 2 of covering up breasts of statues when he was speaking in front of them had downstream effects I didn't anticipate.
But I think there's at least something to it; when I was growing up in Korea, it was pretty normal for cartoons and comic books for kids to have full frontal, often in comedic contexts (and always in non-sexual contexts - since sex didn't even mean anything to the target audience of <10 year olds). This was the case for Dragon Ball, a Japanese comic book series which is internationally popular including in both Korea and the US, and in which I discovered censorship of the protagonist Goku's dick and balls when I came to the US and read English localizations.
Also, I was randomly reminded of something from the DVD commentary of the 1999 film Election, a very good comedy about a high school president election, where one of the last scenes of the film starts with a close-up of the genitals of some statue at the Metropolitan museum. Apparently for TV/airplane/otherwise age-restricted versions of this R-rated film, they had to cut that opening shot, despite the fact that the statue was right there at the front of the museum for anyone walking in front of it to see.
So by saying that they are a type of cultural activity for trans people, isn't OP conflating them?
I don't think the OP was saying that drag performances in general are a type of cultural activity for trans people; taken literally, the statement seems to be that drag performances for kids are a type of cultural activity for pro-trans activists (which, notably, is a different set of people from trans people, something I myself missed in my previous comment). Drag performances for kids (or, to use the OP's exact terms, drag activities in children's spaces) is a sufficiently specific and niche thing even among drag performances in general that it wouldn't even occur to most people to characterize it as a type of cultural activity for drag performers. I think the interpretation that the claim is "having drag activities in children's spaces is a type of cultural activity for pro-trans activists" makes at least as much sense as the interpretation that the claim is "performing drag activities in children's spaces is a type of cultural activity for trans people."
Which is itself a pretty suspect claim. Maybe it is a form of cultural activity for the activists who encourage and organize these performances - I haven't asked - but I feel like it's more of a "fuck you" to what they see as the conservative establishment and its oppressive gender norms. Which, to be fair, might be a form of cultural activity in itself, but then that gets into a more philosophical/definitional question of what is a "cultural activity" anyway?
The basis of the conflation is that the activists are the public face of the community--whether or not they are even members!--and get to define the community, including socially policing dissenters.
That sounds to me like false or fake basis, not a real one.
"Offending trans people in general" simply does not matter; it's the opinions of the activists that carry social consequences for those who challenge self-ID uber alles.
The claim being discussed was
Likewise, misgendering a transgender criminal is offensive to all trans people because it denigrates the trans criminal for being trans, not for being a criminal.
(emphasis added)
If you want to discuss whether or not this matters for one's own personal survival and well-being in our current cultural and social reality, that's an important discussion and something where I'd probably agree with you, but that's a different discussion.
That was not what OP said. Rather, OP equated drag performers with transgender persons, and that is empirically false.
I don't think that's what OP did. I think the relevant parts of the OP are (correct me if I missed something):
Here’s an odd little dynamic: halting drag activities in children's spaces is trans genocide for both sides, but in different ways!
For pro-trans activists, halting them is halting a ritual cultural activity, and hints at a wider cultural desire for eventual trans elimination through murders of the outed and the suicides of the closeted. It also removes an avenue for trans youths to discover their true gender and thus leaves them in a spiral of depression heading toward suicide.
I bolded the parts that I think are particularly relevant. The claim seems to be that "drag activities in children's spaces" is a form of "ritual cultural activity" for trans people. This could be taken to mean that "trans people have a ritual cultural activity of doing drag in children's spaces," but I don't think this necessarily means that. Rather, it could be taken to mean that having drag performers performing in children's spaces is a type of cultural activity for trans people. This is, in itself, suspect, and the most charitable way I could interpret it is that it's claiming that trans people value such subversion of traditional gender stereotypes for helping to enlighten potential trans kids of their innate trans-ness. Which I still find very suspect, to say the least. But it doesn't require an equality between drag performers and trans people.
Why would those things be flaws?
This is where I'm at, too. I honestly think it was too late by the time the first machine that could be called a calculator was created; the dominoes were already falling at that point, and only something almost as bad, like nuclear holocaust, was going to be enough of a barrier - and likely even that would have only delayed it. Given that, we're not in control of our own destiny with respect to whether or not AI will destroy us all, and if so, our best option is to party until the lights go out. And the faster the development of AI is and more easily accessible it is to everyone, the better that party is. And if the lights don't go out, then faster development of AI and greater accessibility of AI is also good for future generations. So either way, I want AI development to go forward with few impediments.
Right, so it's offensive to a certain subset (admittedly a very large and mainstream subset) of trans activists. And such trans activists are not shy about trying to conflate their own opinions with that of trans people in general. But such conflation has no real basis, and offending those activists doesn't imply offending trans people in general.
But I don't understand the argument "I thought you were a legitimate trans person, but then you committed a crime, which proves that you were malingering all along!" The two things don't have anything to do with one another.
That's not the argument, though. Charitably, the argument would be more like, "My choice to respect your preferred pronouns as a trans person is contingent on you not committing a crime (implied: of certain severity)." And that's also not my argument, and I don't subscribe to it myself. My argument is that somebody who does subscribe to that argument is not denigrating all trans people by subscribing to and living out such an argument, certainly not in a way similar to denigrating all black people by calling a particular black person "nigger."
I don't see how this analogy works. The 1st part seems right to me; calling a black person "nigger" in a derogatory way necessarily implies something negative about all black people, due to the history and connotations of that word. But misgendering a trans person doesn't denigrate all trans people; it just says that you don't consider that specific trans person as belonging to the gender they're claiming to. This doesn't denigrate them for being trans; at worst, it says that respecting their identified gender is conditional on that person not being a criminal. Which means not submitting to the "self-ID is definitionally correct" standard, but that's not denigrating the criminal for being trans.
Agreed. I think calling something like this "memocide" or "memetic violence" just puts a different label on the basic concept of "arguing with words," which is no worse and no better for whatever label we put on it, even if it has "-cide" and "violence" on the label. I think it's akin to how "transphobia" has come to mean things like "believing that MTF transwomen are biological males," which don't gain some sort of irrational fear/hatred attached to it just because "phobia" is now part of the label, or how "racism" has come to mean things like "believing that differential racial outcomes aren't definitionally proof of bigotry," which don't gain some sort of bigotry attached to it just because "-ism" is now part of the label.
A rose by any other name and all that. And to quote another famous saying, this might not matter much, because the market can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent: the negative affect of these new labels could (and has) bulldoze plenty of plenty of innocent bystanders while the actual meaning of the terms flow through to all of society.
Trans Resistance Network has 500 twitter followers and no links to any external organizations in their profile, do they speak for anyone significant? It's kind of frustrating that the decline of mass-membership organizations means that we don't have a trans NOW or NAACP to present some sort of 'official stance of the trans community' on a variety of issues.
This is definitely a big issue. People calling themselves pro-trans are in the habit of claiming to speak for all trans people despite having no actual evidence of significant backing by the "trans community," and the rest of us are demanded to just take their word for it. Given that, even some apparently tiny "organization" like this Trans Resistance Network can claim to speak for the "trans community," and the rest of us are conditioned to just take their word for it. If there were some sort of meaningful gatekeeping by such activists to authenticate who can actually speak for the "trans community" by numbers or whatever, we wouldn't be here, but, well, here we are.

I can understand the desire. If you're using your phone on public transit or walking, it's significantly more convenient to hold it in portrait mode than in landscape mode. At a minimum, it's more comfortable to the wrist, and due to how big modern phones tend to be (which is a problem in itself; don't get me started about the lack of sub-5" flagship phones, when sub-4" should be the actual standard), the button placement might necessitate the use of 2 hands. For me, I just don't have any interest in watching short 15-60 second videos, portrait or landscape. It seems like a pathway to addiction and constant dissatisfaction over needing the next bite-sized thing, which I get enough of in text form on Twitter.
More options
Context Copy link