It’s interesting because iirc there is very little to no evidence that transmen taking male hormones makes them more violent (eg. the rate of transmen prisoners, when controlled for the usual factors, is similar to the rate for cis women), even though testosterone is linked to criminal behavior and is generally believed to be a reason men are more violent than women.
Is this also controlled for women tending to get lower sentences than men for similar crimes? I would (wildly) guess that both FTM and MTF would gain some of this advantage, though FTM would gain more. I've anecdotally heard of FTM transmen becoming better at spacial math and more horny (including both from NPR of all places), so I wouldn't be surprised if FTM transmen also experienced increase in aggression to be more like males, though I would also guess that without going through male adolescence, that the level of violence inflicted would be lower on average due to lower strength, even if they had exactly as much of a tendency towards violence as males.
Again, anecdotal and wild guesses, but I'm also guessing that there just isn't much knowledge on this at all due to a dearth of trans people in general on which to do research on this type of stuff.
I'm going to interpret this number as "youths enormously over-report being trans".
This might be correct, but also not contradictory to Williams Institute's claims. There's no strict definition of "trans," and I don't know what Williams Institute considers "trans," but one mainstream view among people who consider themselves as "pro-trans" is that reporting oneself to be trans means that one is trans. Under this framework, youths enormously over-reporting themselves as being trans would be equivalent to youths being trans at a higher rate than if some other (transphobic, by the POV of the people who push this standard) standards were used, such as experiencing gender dysphoria or socially/medically transitioning.
For ecgtheow's analysis, I don't know what definition of "trans" would be most relevant, though.
I think there's a lot of truth to this. A couple years ago, I started mentally replacing "empathy" with "submission" whenever people called for more of the former, and it was almost always the more accurate word in those contexts.
It's hard to say what will happen with these stock phrases in press releases like this one, because they have to be published widely, and faking sincerity in text is almost trivial. I'd guess that since the possibility for insincerity has always been present, AI won't make too much of a difference.
But for individual cases, I'd guess things would go in the opposite direction. Instead of submitting some diversity statement, I think you'd have to go in person to talk to a DEI administrator to convince them of your sincerity through your genuine flesh and blood interactions. Not only text, but video will be easy to fake in the future, so only in-person interactions would suffice. Once we get Terminator-level robots and Oscars-level acting technology, then things might break down since even in-person interactions could be faked.
I'd second this. And when people accuse others of lacking empathy, what they actually mean is that the others are having empathy for the wrong thing, and they should have empathy for the right thing instead. Again, without being conscious of this. This lack of consciousness on this is a very powerful tool to use for manipulating others into submission, because it allows people who consider themselves generally decent and non-manipulative to do so.
I used to love Picross on DS back in the day when the DS was a recently released system. I dropped it after I finished the cartridge, but I got into it for a few months a few years back on the phone. It's definitely my favorite of the simple time-waster logic puzzle games, but I haven't thought about it in a while.
I'd characterize woke censorship as social hyper-literacy rather than illiteracy, since it usually improves the social status of those who call for the censorship. I could see it being illiteracy of a different kind, but not socially.
Here's an argument in favor of explicit, quota-based affirmative action compared to what exists now: it adds transparency instead of driving it underground. Clearly adcoms want to engineer the racial composition of their classes and will do so by whatever means possible. But avoiding explicit quotas just shifts AA mechanisms to illegibility and makes it impossible to discuss. Any debate around the extent, values, and goals of AA gets obscured by a bunch of sand being thrown up in the air. "We are objective and meritocratic, it's just that Asian Americans have ineffably worse personalities" and all that dross.
People can debate the value of AA itself (I'm probably more supportive of it in some circumstances than most here), but it's surely better to make it explicit so people can reasonably discuss it instead of getting sidetracked about what's actually happening. And psychologically it's better for students to know that they're being held to different standards instead of gaslighting them about mysterious personality defects that they all have but group X doesn't.
I agree with this, though I admit I haven't thought too deeply on it. Clearly the desire to discriminate against Asians is there, and this desire will be fulfilled one way or another due to the people who have this desire being the same people who control the levers to power in this context. It's best if it's all out in the open, so that potential applicants, their parents, and others can more accurately assess both their chances and the standards of Harvard and other universities.
However, I suspect that the obfuscation is a very important part of the point that is also desired by the people who desire to discriminate against Asians, and as such any implementation of AA will inevitably have to be obscured. AA's value in providing a nice-sounding mechanism for engineering the admissions results they're targeting would be lost if everything were out in the open, and that function might be a critical, irremovable portion of it.
Again, clearly the people here don't perceive people as "still" doing it (or perhaps "ever" rather than "still"). It seems your question can be answered entirely with just a difference in perception.
OK, so there's your answer to your question then: the people here likely didn't live through whatever internet wars you did and as such, their perception of atheists is different from yours. Specifically, when they read your stuff about "they confuse methodological constraints for a metaphysical theory," they perceive this as a strawman - a weakman at best - not worth engaging with, and as such they don't engage with it by, e.g. pushing back on it.
For example, science takes as constraints certain assumptions on observability, repeatability, testability, etc. There are different ways of formulating these assumptions, but they are constraints on what types of things the method can speak to.
Metaphysics, uh, kind of is? The core error is that we can just do away with any metaphysical questions, we can just boldly declare that the only one true possible metaphysical theory, must just be exactly the things that are within the constraints of this one particular tool.
Thank you, there's a lot more meat on this bone now. I think this "core error" - "that we can just do away with any metaphysical questions, we can just boldly declare that the only one true possible metaphysical theory" can't be ascribed to atheists (or theists) to a meaningful extent, though. I don't see atheists saying we can do away with such questions and that there's only one true possible metaphysical theory.
Read the specific comment I linked to. I know it's long, but it very completely describes the problem long before it even uses the word "shoe".
I did read that specific comment, and it was that specific comment to which I was referring. It's highly muddled and goes all over the place, and, again, it doesn't answer the actual question I had, which was about what this whole deal about "implying shoes are atheists" is all about. My best guess is that it has to do with some sort of claim that people are declaring that shoes are atheists, but this seems like a largely random statement that has little relation to what actual atheists say. I mean, I'd guess that somewhere someone ran into an atheist who said that, but that's not very interesting when we're talking about atheism or atheists in general.
From what I've gathered, I think the answer to your original question is that people here generally try not to engage with weakmen (try being the operative word), and the stuff you're describing are so much weakmen as to border on strawman territory.
they confuse methodological constraints for a metaphysical theory. That is, science has methodological constraints; it makes certain assumptions and speaks only to things within the constraints of those assumptions. But instead, folks want to claim that those are not constraints on the method; they're constraints on reality.
Sorry, this just seems to be restating the part I quoted before, just in more words. Could you please be specific about what specific methodological constraints and specific metaphysical theories and specific assumptions and specific constraints on method versus reality are being involved here?
Sorry, the post in that link was more muddled and confusing than enlightening. It seems to write about "shoe atheism" as if the reader already understands what that refers to, which is specifically the thing I don't understand. Who's saying or implying that shoes are atheists, and what does this have to do with the above statements about metaphysics versus methodology?
In most states, getting a license at age 18 requires no test, only for the earlier age 16 license is a road test required.
Is this true? In Massachusetts, you need a road test no matter what age you are, but if you're 16-17, you also need to have taken driving classes before taking and passing the road test. In either case, you need to have a permit first, which requires passing a written test. I was under the impression that this was pretty standard in the US. In which states can an 18 year old just walk into the RMV and get a driving license after at most a written test?
But consider the idea that methodological constraints actually are a metaphysical theory, or further implying that shoes are atheists. These ideas are, I think, even less likely to be true than the idea that there is no difference in intelligence between different genetic groups of humans (at least the latter can be empirically shown true or false; the former is just a category error).
whereas the claims that atheism makes go so far beyond typical constraints of the scientific method that one actually does just quietly make an exception for it because its claims are fundamentally viewed as being orthogonal to scientific investigation (and people just fail to ever mention such)?
I think this is the crux of it. Though I admit I don't quite understand what you're saying here. What are the specific claims that you believe that atheism makes, and what do shoes have to do with it?
I think (hope) it won't be long before there's a browser extension that can do this with just a couple clicks for any text field on any website.
Isn’t it strange that when they marry, women do a 180 on what they want in a man?
Calling this a 180 seems akin to saying it's a 180 that a man would want a virgin bride but then after they got married, he'd want her to be sexually available to him whenever he felt the desire. It's just a bizarre framing.
I've heard a variation of this joke, that a man marries a woman hoping she doesn't change, which she inevitably does, and a woman marries a man hoping he will change, which he inevitably doesn't.
Specifically, it refers to an individual's self-perception and subjective experience of their gender identity, often aligned with societal norms and expectations.
Again, by this (somewhat circular - using "experience of gender identity" to define what "identify as [gender]" means) definition, I don't "identify as" a man. And my sense of men and women in general is that they don't "identify as" a man or a woman by this definition. So I think the premise that roughly half of people "identify as 'woman'" and roughly the other half of people "identify as 'man'" is false. Roughly half of people recognize they are women, and roughly the other half of people recognize they are men, in the context of gender.
I've never tried reading any "sympathetic to the monsters" Lovecraft-inspired fiction, but I would argue that Lovecraft himself was good at writing them in a way that was both alien/horrifying and understandable/sympathetic (in the cases where it served the purpose of the story), despite him writing horror in which it was almost never a primary emphasis.
I haven't read much Lovecraft-inspired fiction, and it's been a while since I've read Lovecraft himself, but I'd highly recommend the PS4 game Bloodborne for a great "sympathetic to the monsters" Lovecraft-inspired fiction. If you don't like games or don't have access to a PS4/PS5. I thought it did a great job of doing exactly what you're describing Lovecraft himself as doing, presenting these elder gods as both alien/horrifying and understandable/sympathetic. And it doesn't go for the obvious "humans are the real monsters" approach, presenting most human characters as parts horrifying and sympathetic, and the whole story just feels very tragic on all fronts for all characters, including the elder gods. This being a Fromsoft game, the story is cryptic and difficult to make out from a single playthrough, though there is no shortage of YouTube videos that dissect it. Perhaps unsurprisingly, Fromsoft is a Japanese company with Japanese writers and developers, and their style of writing and game design tends not to be heavily influenced by Western/American norms, despite most of their famous games, including Bloodborne (set in heavily fictionalized Victorian London), being set in Western settings with Western characters.
I'm coming from a place of complete ignorance here; before reading this summary, my best guess at Gilmore Girls would have been that it was some dramedy about a friend group of female senior citizens. Do you know how longtime fans of the original series tended to react to the Netflix sequel? The way you describe it would make me guess that it got a mostly negative reception, similar to many sequels/reboots/reimaginings/etc. that have come out in the past decade, and I'm curious what the actual reception was.
Who wants to arrange play dates with the little tyke who innocently announces he needs to take a shit?
Apropos of nothing, I have an anecdote tangentially related to this. After moving from Korea to the US as a 1st grader, I was obviously taught English, but for whatever reason, my parents taught me that "shit" was the correct word for fecal matter. By the time I was in 3rd grade, I knew that "poop" was common term that kids used, but I had thought that it was the crude kiddy version of the word and that the technically correct term was "shit." So when my 3rd grade teacher asked the class one day "What smells bad in the woods?" (I don't recall the context), I dutifully raised my hand and said "shit," which resulted in uproarious laughter among my classmates and my teacher being absolutely flummoxed. I was genuinely confused at what was so funny or unexpected about what I said, and to my teacher's credit, she was quite understanding, and I didn't get in trouble, though I heard later that during some PTA meeting, she brought it up to my parents. Apparently my parents initially thought she was referencing me being a joker or something for bringing up fecal matter in reference to that particular question, rather than the use of a swear in class, which they only realized after my teacher explained to them.
I don't think it had much of an effect on my getting play dates, though, which I would guess was at a pretty typical rate for a boy that age.
I'm not even five sentences into the linked post and I have to ask, "since when has a 73% been enough to earn any student a fucking A?"
This was uncommon but not unheard of when I was in college. There's no particular reason why a certain percentage should correspond to a certain letter grade, as the difficulty of the test relative to the material is a choice made by the test maker with a lot of degrees of freedom. I never had a test where 73% would've been enough to get an A, but I had enough where 75 was enough for A, 55 was enough for B, and 35 was enough for C, just due to how difficult the professor decided to make the test. Very few people got A's in those tests.
Across the globe, roughly half of the population identifies as the folkloric entity known as "woman", while the other half identifies as "man".
Is this true? I certainly don't identify as a man; rather, I recognize that, in the context of gender and how society treats me and vice versa, I am a man (versus in the context of sex and how my biology is being a male, I am a man).
What does "identifies [self] as" mean in this context anyway? If the above is actually enough to qualify myself as "identifying as 'man,'" then this seems quite different from what trans people mean when they say they "identify as [gender]" (I think this is more common than saying "identify as 'trans'").
I saw a post on here recently that resonated with me - that it's not uncommon for transgender folks to be those that failed at being their birth gender.
I've heard the term "transmaxxing" thrown around the past couple of years to describe a portion of this phenomenon.

I generally agree with the 2nd paragraph. The 1st one, though, I think there is enough national security justification to ban private companies from publishing apps that send data about the nation's citizens to a different nation's government to at least investigate it. I don't know enough about the inner workings of TikTok to have an opinion on if a TikTok ban would be justified under such reasoning.
Circling back to the 2nd paragraph, I agree that this isn't the role of the government, even if TikTok were rotting our children's brains with its addicting content and such. It's ultimately the responsibility of the individual or of their adult guardians not to fall for the app's siren's song, and the government has no business censoring it. At best, I could see an argument for age restrictions like for tobacco or alcohol (or, as is the case in more and more states, marijuana), if there is enough scientific evidence for the harms it can do to developing brains.
Now, I'm not sure how much scientific evidence would be enough to convince me, though. I would like it if more resources were devoted into researching this, given that there are at least signs that it's harmful. And to combine the 2 issues, I've heard that China itself censors certain content for children on its own local TikTok which are allowed in international TikTok, like certain vapid/borderline obscene content. Presumably the idea is to help to prevent rotting their kids' brains while letting kids of other countries rot theirs, hopefully to help China gain advantage in various international contexts as the children grow up to be adults running the next generation. I'm skeptical of the strength of this, and even if it were true, the liberal in me says that if letting American kids watch TikTok means America falls behind China on the international stage, then so be it, at least we didn't encroach upon our citizens' freedom on the way, but it does seem a serious enough thing to consider that I'd like to see much more research into it.
More options
Context Copy link