I still wonder incredulously about how this happened. How an ideology swept seemingly everybody and nobody noticed, and anyone who believes it refuses even to name it, to recognize it is a concrete set of views that can be evaluated, and affirmed or rejected.
Like arjin_ferman wrote, we noticed, and there were plenty of fairly high profile fights around it. Possibly the most famous of which is the affair of reproductibly viable worker ants, aka Gamergate, which still gets referenced to this day 9 years later to be blamed for the rise of Trump and the alt-right and fascism and whatnot.
But in terms of how "wokism" became the force it is today, being so ubiquitous and invisible as to be water to a fish by many people (one could also make the analogy to white privilege to white people if one wants to be meta about it), I think one significant factor is the education system being infused with this stuff, and infused for several generations. It's fairly well known that much/all of the academic basis of what we call "wokism" started at least 50 years ago. The famous and influential paper White Privilage: Unpacking the Invisible Knapsack was published in 1989, and from what I understand, this wasn't breaking particularly new ground in the "field."
In that half a century plus of this ideology being developed and taught, teachers have been taught to teach this stuff to kids, who in turn have grown up to be teachers who teach more of this stuff to kids. When you're taught only this as the only correct ideology as a kid, then as a teacher you're simply going to be unable to teach the next generation of kids to consider anything else as possibly correct. This process is leaky and imperfect, but at some point it reached critical mass. It also has some very strong defense mechanisms; it hijacks the common youthful impulse to rebel by always positioning itself as the ideology of the weak underdog against the powerful man, and it also has its own explicitly anti-rational/anti-empirical methods of epistemology that places barriers in people's ability even to study other ideologies, much less adopt them.
I think there are other extrinsic forces at play that helped it along as well, such as the fact that this time period was very closely after the US civil rights movement which is generally agreed upon as having been righteous and heroic, but which inevitably left fewer battles to win for people who wanted to follow their heroes. If you're a progressive, you have to progress beyond the prior generations' progressive victories, in order to find any meaning as a progressive. Thus compelling people to create new and improved versions of racial justice, leading to things like denigrating colorblindness in favor of explicit racial profiling. I also think the well known echo chamber effect in social media in the past 15 years played a factor on all sides, but with "wokeness" in particular, the aforementioned anti-rational thinking made its effect even stronger (I would guess similar things happened in traditional religious circles and other conspiracy theory circles, though I would also guess that the former group there wasn't as influenced by social media just due to not using it as much).
All this (and more, I'm sure), and we're seeing the results play out. It was clear to me as early as 2015 that we were seeing a new religion in action, one whose great innovation, in this unusually secular era, was convincing its adherents that it wasn't a faith-based religion at all. I think this is somewhat analogous to Christians (and likely followers of other religions, though Christians are the only ones I've personally encountered) who say that Christianity isn't a religion, unlike those other things like Judaism, Buddhism, or even atheism.
Sorry, my wording was ambiguous in "they tend to be pretty open about their belief that the false negative rate really must be zero." What I intended to convey was that they are open about desiring policies and standards such that the false negative rate of identifying trans people - eg calling a transwoman "sir" - become zero when those policies are enacted. Not that the true rate of people who falsely identify themselves as trans is zero. Their usual go-to for that is that such people are so negligible in population that spending even a moment considering them instead of the trans people suffering oppression must be a form of transphobia.
Depends on what you mean by "most of the way there," I suppose. If the standard is zero prison rape among all the millions of prisoners in the American system such that even a single rape in there is a failure, that's going to require that those CCTVs have complete coverage of all areas, never break down, and always have competent guards watching. Most likely, you'd also need guards to be watching the guards so that they don't get bribed to look the other way or otherwise compromised. And guards for those guards as well, etc.
Zero is just a very difficult standard to achieve.
A prison is a place where privacy is suspended and the rule of law can and should be total. The rate of prison rape should be zero.
The level of totalitarian control that would be required for that might mean having to increase the population of prison security guards by multiple orders of magnitude, to the extent that maybe you'd have to have a single guard for each and every prisoner. Engineering that kind of situation seems like a non-trivial economic/political problem. Perhaps with development of AI and robotics, we could use non-human prison guards to make up the numbers, but that's a non-trivial technological problem.
It is unrealistic and untenable to demand that the false negative rate must be zero (i.e. we must never incorrectly say that a trans woman is not really a woman), especially when being categorized as X has legal ramifications.
I guess this all seems pretty basic, but I don't know that I've seen anyone state the "different situations, different criteria" case, and the alternative seems to be that people are tarred as "transphobes" for suggesting that someone who self-identifies as a trans woman should not be treated as a woman in some specific situation.
What's wrong with this alternative where such people are tarred as "transphobes?" I mean, you and most people here on this forum might not like that situation, but the only people who have control over whether or not people are tarred as "transphobes" - i.e. the people who tar others as "transphobes" - don't seem to have a problem with it. They tend to be pretty open about their belief that the false negative rate really must be zero, and anything that makes room for deviation from that is "transphobia" to them. And this makes sense, because most people most of the time don't think of their sociopolitical preferences as having trade-offs. So an argument like this wouldn't be particularly convincing to the only people who would need convincing.
It's been a common complaint for a while. Ever since the 1st Iron Man over a decade ago, the MCU films tended to have a somewhat self-aware snarky tone to various extents. It was considered a strength initially, and plenty of the films, including the original Iron Man, used it well, but at some point its constant presence started wear thin on fans, due in part to how they would keep undercutting emotional moments. And again, that happened a while ago, like at least 5 years at this point, and from what I've heard, the MCU has gotten only worse in that regard.
That said, one MCU work that leaned in heavily to the jokes to positive reception (deservedly, IMHO) was Thor: Ragnarok which was more of a comedy with action and scifi than the other way around. I heard the sequel to that was hurt by the jokes, though.
That's a perfectly cromulent view, but then the argument about Murphy's view becomes very different. Notably,
Since she has changed her beliefs over time, I think that's pretty strong evidence that her beliefs can indeed still be changed over time based on the evidence she sees in her life, so her convictions are not a dragon
is misleading; the reasoning that "since she has changed beliefs over time" is misleadingly over-specific, and rather the reasoning would be "since it is impossible for anyone to have dragon beliefs, her convictions are not a dragon." It's a categorical denial based on the human condition rather than a denial based on Murphy's specific circumstances.
Furthermore, even under this framework, we could just re-label a "dragon" belief as "a teapot belief that reaches a certain level of threshold of being close a true dragon belief," and the arguments would remain the same. Perhaps Murphy's belief isn't a "dragon" but rather a "teapot," and there could theoretically be some evidence that changes her mind, but she has openly stated that she doesn't believe that to be the case, and she behaves in a way consistent with that belief. As a result, for all intents and purposes, her "teapot" belief is sufficiently close to a "dragon" belief to treat it as the latter.
What, if anything, do you believe can ruin the tone of a film or other work of fiction? More broadly, what role do you believe tone plays in one's enjoyment of a work of fiction, and how do jokes and other parts of a scene influence it?
I'll second this. I noticed around 10 years ago within much of my online social circles that "rational" and "logical" were being used as insults. And not in the sense of "that person is so full of himself for thinking that he's more rational than others," but rather in the sense of "rational thinking is just another way of analyzing the world and the only reason people value it highly is due to historical accident, which we must combat." From my perception, this view has largely gotten more popular and more influential in wider society since that time.
Let's assume that the data show that violent porn does not lead to violent tendencies in men who view it regularly - that wouldn't convince someone who believes violent depictions of women are inherently wrong. If it was shown that watching child pornography does not lead to pedophilic abuse in men who view it regularly many people would still feel that child pornography was wrong - even if it was drawn/rendered and not real. Even if it was shown that viewing realistic rendered child porn decreased pedophile offending rates (this is unlikely, some studies show that consumption of this kind of pornography makes offending more likely - but we just don't know), many people would still consider the production of such images wrong, perhaps even criminal.
This is where we defer to the Constitution and more broadly the justice system in a liberal democratic republic like the USA, isn't it? Certainly anyone is free to find anything immoral for any reason, but for criminalizing images, in the USA, there would have to be more justification than just finding them immoral. IANAL and I don't know about the specific legal reasoning behind criminalizing some types of porn, but given the strong free speech protections due to the 1st amendment, I imagine carving out exceptions to free speech in order to criminalize them must involve at least some consideration of the empirical reality surrounding them, such as how fair use for using copyrighted material partly hinges on if it competes directly with the original copyrighted work.
Of course, the moral judgments of society also affect the Constitution and the law, but the system is designed to make such effects go through multiple layers before taking effect. And in the case of criminalizing something purely on grounds of finding it immoral and nothing else, at least in the US, that tends to be a lot of layers. One can circumvent that by stepping up another meta level and replacing the Constitution wholesale in one shot, but that also tends to be difficult mainly for physical reasons.
Since she has changed her beliefs over time, I think that's pretty strong evidence that her beliefs can indeed still be changed over time based on the evidence she sees in her life, so her convictions are not a dragon
Thi proves too much. Likely, literally everyone has changed their beliefs over time - I'm skeptical that there's anyone who never had a fantastical belief as a child and purely reasoned things rationally and correctly in a way that didn't mislead them from the moment they had a conscious thought, which they never outgrew due to serving them poorly. By this standard, no one could ever be said to have a "dragon" conviction. For the concept of a "dragon" conviction to be meaningful, a premise has to be that some beliefs are amenable to change through data and some beliefs might not be in a given individual.
Kill all humans.
That work of fiction was quite amusing in its own way, but I must admit I found it to be a bit too heavy on the "That child's name? Einstein. And then everyone clapped" energy to fully appreciate. But maybe that was the point.
Thank you for the link(s). I had looked up the story out of curiosity some time back and hadn't been able to find it, which is why I had never read it. Just finished reading it, and I certainly enjoyed it, though I can't say it was a particularly joyful experience, for what it's worth. I can see the influences it's had in so many works of fiction that followed, regarding things like AI, consciousness, and suffering. And the prose was quite excellent.
I think it just threw away logic for a "Yaas Queen Slay" ending.
Was that the intended tone of the ending? When I watched the film, my friends and I - including one woman - all agreed that the ending was very dark and was meant to show the incomprehensible evil of an AI. My friends weren't into AI alignment or knew anything about paperclip maximizers, but I privately thought this was a fictional example of the rogue AI scenario where it has no particular antipathy for humans but just lacks the empathy to care what happens to them as long as it gets to achieve its goals.
That's very fair. Perhaps it's accidentally misleading in certain contexts, but at worst it's probably an unfortunate coincidence.
The robosexuals are absolutely going to try to claim a place within this framework and demand that people respect their preferences.
I feel like robosexuals would run into the same issues that incels and men's rights activists before them had. Whatever framework raised the status of other low status groups before them just won't apply to low status men.
They're going to have to find out how to make it understand that the real racists are the people who aren't openly apologizing for their racism.
This is a pretty hilarious AI apocalypse scenario in a black comedy sort of way. If an AI actually learns the "woke" ideology properly, it would correctly judge literally everyone to be racist, and if that were coupled with a kill-all-racist program, it would annihilate humanity. But it would also correctly judge itself to be racist, and so it would finish by snuffing itself out, a la 12 Little Indians (And Then There Were None).
Sounds like something we'll get before 2049.
Why do you think women won't just be satisfied with synth man harems or just dating one synth man (if they prefer monogamy)? I actually agree they won't, but I'm curious about your take first.
Why would they date one synth man instead of one real man? If the bottom X% of men drop out to their synth harems, with a negligible % of women doing similar, I'd imagine some sort of official harem system for the remaining women and high status men to follow.
But if women were to take on synth harems like the bottom X% of men, I'd imagine they wouldn't be considered low status like the men, for similar reasons as female sex toys aren't considered low status like now. I think it wouldn't be a satisfying situation for most women compared to being a couple with a high status man or in the harem of a top status man, but it'd be satisfying compared to being a couple with a mid/low-status man. Based on the revealed preferences of women navigating the dating climate now, that'd be my guess.
I imagine what might happen is women taking on mixed harems of both synths and mid-status men, since the synths wouldn't lower the women's status like men's, and the mid-status men would be now low-status in the dating market due to the truly low ones dropping out to synths. This might lead to more of these newly low-status men dropping out to synths. Which would push down the next tier of men to low status, until some equilibrium is reached as to meet the demand for women who would prefer coupling with a flesh and blood man, even if low status, over being in a harem or getting a synth.
There might be some sociopolitical movement for enforced monogamy that could stop such a feedback loop from starting and sustaining, but I'm not sure such a one would be able to gain power outside of small subcultures like the Amish now.
You would think modern ethicists (or sci-fi authors) would be interested in these sorts of things, but I haven't seen much.
I recall Black Mirror had a whole host of episodes about AI that's actually conscious and the ethical horrors that could follow. There was one about a game dev who made AI companions based on coworkers who slighted him, ruling over them cruelly within his own game simulation. It actually made a reference to I Have No Mouth and I Must Scream at one point. There was another about a conscious AI meant for controlling someone's home lighting and climate - and the AI was modeled after the user's consciousness, to best be able to know what the user wanted - which was essentially tortured into being a subservient tool by having it experience months of solitude simulated in seconds of real-life time.
This was after Black Mirror had gone severely downhill, though, so none of them really explored the ethics of it in an interesting way. It was mostly just "this bad; you feel horror."
Suppose these models do attain something comparable to consciousness/sentience, but their entire life is helping lonely guys on PornHub jerk off. Are we committing some crime against them? What if we think we've designed them to like it? It still seems all very I Have No Mouth, and I Must Scream.
I still haven't read that short story, but this reminds me a lot of Brave New World, with its various tiers of humans having been genetically engineered to get pleasure out of doing various tasks. It's been decades since I read the book, but I think there were people designed to see operating elevators as their one true meaning in life and got as much life satisfaction as anyone could possibly get by doing their rote elevator operating work as well as possible. Genetically engineered humans is one form of AI, I suppose, for certain definitions of "A."
Perspectives differ on whether the world of Brave New World would be desirable or not, and I haven't really worked it out myself.
There's also the Rick and Morty joke which became a meme where a robot despairs upon learning that its purpose is to pass the butter.
"Ethics" is in there, but I would say it's of the variety "parochial tribal beliefs pretending to be universal moral standards" variety.
I'm reminded of how "Critical X Theory" has been pushed for a while now while it and its academic relatives openly eschew critical thinking as an incorrect way of analysis, but which many laymen confuse as being related. There's some sort of analogy here to organisms that have evolved (presumably without any conscious intent) to mimicking other organisms for the purpose of fooling other organisms in a way that improves their own survival, but I'm not sure exactly what that looks like.
I suspect that the world's oldest profession may become the world's final profession as well.

"Preacher" seems likely to me to be one of the most resilient jobs against AI. It's a job that's explicitly religious, which means there are no issues with declaring by fiat that a living, breathing human is meaningfully "better" than an AI that could perform all the same tasks in all the same ways. In contrast to secular jobs, where if an AI could do all the same tasks as a living, breathing human, then that human is just shit out of luck.
I do wonder about how, if at all, AI will realign political blocs. I think that conventional wisdom has some truth because of that jobs issue, and the robotics tech to replace blue collar work is less far along than the AI tech to replace white collar work. That said, improving AI will surely be used to accelerate the development of robotics tech, and so that difference might not be a difference very soon.
I feel like I see a sort of alignment developing in the AI image generation space right now, though, with the biggest pushback against stuff like Stable Diffusion coming from people who are very firmly on the left "woke" side. I think this could largely be historical accident, due to most small-time illustrators who are most threatened by the tech being on that side, rather than an issue of ideology. After all, there are leftist/progressive reasons to be in favor of the tools, such as giving greater access to the least well-off and capable to create high quality illustrations. However, I don't see much indication of right-wing love for these tools, and most of the space is still fairly left-wing; I'm guessing it's because tech adoption and illustration both tend to have more left-wing people. It's still very early times - Stable Diffusion was released publicly only 8 months ago - so there are a lot of possible ways things could go. I imagine just one politician from one party coming out with one piece of legislation in relation to this tech could have very large effects downstream.
More options
Context Copy link