How does traditional machine learning even begin to address these problems? One way would be to say, feed it the sheet music for Beethoven's Fifth, and then show it as many recordings of that piece as you can until it figures out that the music lines up with the notation. Then do that for every other piece of music that you can. This would be a pretty simple, straightforward way of doing things, but does anyone really think that you could generate reasonably accurate sheet music to a recording it hadn't heard, or would you just get some weird agglomeration of sheet music it already knows? After all, this method wouldn't give the computer any sense of what each individual component of the music actually does, just vaguely associate it with certain sounds.
Why wouldn't it? I imagine there would be issues where it gets stuff weirdly wrong like Stable Diffusion's famously mangled hands or ChatGPT's famously incompetent arithmetic, but I'd expect such a trained model to generally get the sheet music right. No idea how it would compare to a typical real trained human musician at this - my guess would be that it would be similar to how Stable Diffusion can get you images that clearly look very close to something a human artist might draw based on the prompt, just with bizarre artifacts like the aforementioned hands (and eyes, and continuous objects disappearing/getting misaligned when hidden behind stuff, and hair blending into clothes, and clothes blending into skin, and...). I think existing machine learning tools show that the upper limit of precision and accuracy of "vaguely associate it with certain sounds" is (potentially) very high.
(Which raises a question: If the "bait" is good enough that you can never quite tell whether it's bait or just a difficult question, does it actually stop being "bait?" Or does it make it the worst, most insidious kind of "bait?")
If a bait is so poorly placed on the hook that it's trivial for fish to eat it without any risk of getting caught on the hook, is it still bait?
But throw enough vitriol at someone, and odds are some of it ends up looking like specific, actionable plans and demands.
Some of it certainly does, I agree. In my experience, again, a vast majority of it doesn't.
"The lives of you and yours are unfortunate because you are intellectually inferior and there isn't much that can be done about that,"
Again, I don't think this is the message. There are plenty of things that can be done about lower intellect to give people better lives - just as many as can be done to effectively improve people's lives by countering historical discrimination or institutional racism, by my lights - and plenty of people specifically push for policies designed to do just that. I do think the message gets negativity attached to them because of the lionization of "intelligence" as the indicator of worth or value in a person, but then the solution is clearly to get rid of that lionization. I'm pretty sure concepts like physical strength or martial prowess used to be a far greater indicator of someone's worth as a human being (at least among males) in the past, but that association is mostly gone now in modern society. I think we can do the same for intelligence. And, frankly, I think we must if we are to create at all a functional society going forward.
Note that none of this is me claiming that these gaps can't be real. I'm just saying that if you were a black person seeing how poorly your fellow black people are doing in the world and told "Sorry, it's just your bad luck to be born the race whose dump stat is Intelligence," you would probably have a problem accepting this with equanimity.
This isn't the message, though. Being born to a particular race certainly can be bad luck depending on the race and society based on the discrimination that goes on in that society. But the average IQ - and more broadly the average of any trait - of your race has no real bearing on your lot in life. It's your own personal intelligence that has the bearing on your life. And that personal intelligence isn't influenced by the average intelligence of your race - it's the other way around, where the average intelligence of your race is influenced by the personal intelligence of you and everyone else in your race, because that's literally how one would calculate that.
99.9% of so-called death threats on the internet fall into one of two categories; faked or implausible. Neither of them can be said to be real to my mind.
I actually feel like at least 90% of so-called death threats on the internet aren't even death threats. The vast majority of the times I see someone claim that they received death threats, the actual text says something like "You should die," or "I wish you would die," in more flowery language and palpable details. These aren't death threats, merely death wishes. A threat would be some sort of actual intent to carry out the wish.
The opinions of women should not define what it means to be defective as a man. If you define defective to mean purely what women think, then it loses meaning for any other use we might want it for.
Yes, I think this is the crux of the matter. "Defective," like most words, isn't strictly defined and has loose boundaries. Whether or not opinions of women should define "defective," I think it does define "defective" for a certain common way of defining "defective." This is somewhat different from the way one might use "defective" when describing "Henry" as "defective" and "Tesla" as "not defective," but since they're the same word, I think there's an impulse to take people who are "defective" by the former definition and fit them into the box of the second definition.
Of course, the choice of the term "defective" is also somewhat arbitrary. It's really just a shorthand for a general cluster of negative affect one might attach to someone.
Sorry, I think this must be a reference to something, but I don't understand it. I had to Google what a longhouse was and, as I had initially guessed, it seems to be a house that is long. But I'm guessing you're referring to something more specific.
I think that was the one.
I broadly agree with many people here that this is more indicative of wokeness having completely won rather than of it being in decline. To use the same metaphor as someone else here, there's no need to hammer down nails when none are sticking up.
But one area where I think we may be seeing signs of the start of a decline is in certain areas of pop culture. The complete failure of efforts to boycott Hogwarts Legacy based on Rowling's refusal to tow the woke line on trans issues has been discussed plenty here, and that follows a number of other high profile woke failures.
About a month ago, HBO released Velma, a cartoon spinoff/reimagining/prequel of Scooby Doo featuring Velma as the protagonist, along with all the main cast members of the show (except the dog himself, who is completely absent) go through high school (in modern times with smartphones and all that). It was very openly woke with every character being race-swapped except Fred, and the show starting off with Velma narrating that this is her origin story and that "normally origin stories are about tall handsome guys struggling with a burden of being handed even more power," and by all accounts that tone only got more heavy-handed as the show went on. It was also completely panned by critics and fans alike, receiving some of the lowest scores ever from both in places like Rotten Tomatoes or IMDB. This doesn't mean it was a failure, and it seems to have been renewed for a 2nd season - possibly due to "hatewatching," possibly due to a 2nd season already being too far along in the pipeline - but at least it indicates that it's something the general audience doesn't really want to tolerate.
Before that, last year there was Saints Row, a video game reboot of the Saints Row franchise, which was initially a sort of GTA clone back in the day designed to appeal to a more edgy crowd (I never played any of the Saints Row games, so I'm going off 2nd hand information). The woke messaging in this was pretty minor by all accounts, but it featured a lot of changes to the franchise clearly designed to appeal to that crowd, including making the protagonists a diverse set of 20-something recent college graduates trying to make it in an expensive city, who start the eponymous Saints Row gang in part as an effort to pay back their student loans while also fighting for enacting what they see as justice in the world. While in the original, I believe that the protagonist was just a random guy working his way up the gang hierarchy and becoming a ruthless kingpin because he wanted power and money and women. They also changed some running jokes in the franchise presumably for sensitivity reasons, including changing a mechanic shop name from "Rim Jobs" to "Jim Robs," and a fast food chain from "Freckle Bitches" to just "FB's." The game was roundly rejected by both critics and fans, and seems to have bombed financially. Much of the criticisms had to do with the game's buggy state and poorly designed/implemented game mechanics, but, of course, those are not characteristics that exist independently of it being "woke."
Late last year, there was also Rings of Power, a prequel TV show to Lord of the Rings based on some supplementary material by JRR Tolkien, which Amazon famously spent $1bn+ for production and made a big deal of including diverse racial representation in populations where it wouldn't make sense from an anthropological perspective. It also featured as the protagonist Galadriel, an elf who appeared in the Lord of the Rings and who was clearly better than others in almost every way including her fighting skills and intuitions about Sauron's return while also being highly aggressive and abrasive towards others in displaying that superiority. The show was mostly rejected by critics and fans. I don't think Amazon released viewership numbers, but I recall reading that after the initial 2 episodes which were released together, the show's viewership dropped precipitously.
Also late last year, there was the TV show She-Hulk: Attorney at Law on Disney+, which featured quite a bit of woke messaging, such as a monologue in the 1st episode where She-Hulk goes off on the Hulk: "Here's the thing, Bruce. I'm great at controlling my anger. I do it all the time. When I'm catcalled in the street. When incompetent men explain my own area of expertise to me. I do it pretty much every day because if I don't I will be called emotional or difficult or... might just literally get murdered. So, I'm an expert at controlling my anger because I do infinitely more than you!" Along with the main plot point of the season being about a group of angry men trolling She-Hulk online, culminating in them crashing a ceremony for her winning a "Best Female Lawyer" award and playing embarrassing videos of her for the audience. This one had a bit more critic support, but fans seemed to pan it for various issues, including the woke messaging, poor use of breaking the 4th wall, and bad CGI.
Now, woke works in pop culture failing is nothing new; in the past, we've had films like Terminator: Dark Fate or the Charlie's Angels (Elizabeth Banks version) or TV shows like Batgirl bombing. Even The Last Jedi counts despite the massive amounts of money it made, because of how it poisoned the franchise, preventing it from making as much money as Disney clearly expected to make from buying that franchise from Lucas. But generally those works still got massive support from critics with the bigoted fans being reprimanded for not supporting these great progressive works of art. Some of that happened in these cases, with probably Rings of Power the biggest example. But it seems to me that there's more rejection of works like this by critics than ever before, and they're no longer so willing to circle the wagons to protect some work if it clearly lacks the basic fundamentals of what makes works of fiction like these actually good. And I can't recall ever seeing so much rejection like this happening back-to-back-to-back so quickly.
Maybe it's just a blip, and maybe it's just a tiny bit of overreach being pulled back before "progress" continues unabated, but I think there's an optimists' case to be made that this might be a turning point. The Hogwarts Legacy situation feels like it could be a sort of Emperor Has No Clothes moment as the masses realize just how much power the woke have with them going all-in on trying to "cancel" the game and having essentially negligible - and possibly positive - impact on its sales.
The sense that I get is that this can't possibly work that way, because women are the ones who define what "defective" means. By definition, 0% of women are defective, and X% of men are defective as determined by the judgments of the women which play out in whether or not one of the women chose to marry the man. I think this underlies most of the discussion on this topic, and trying to reason why those X% of men might have negative character traits is just a long-winded way of trying to avoid recognizing this. Those men are defective, by definition, but for whatever reason, people in our society don't like to think of ourselves as judging people as "defective" based purely on their romantic success, and so we come up with other reasons to justify this judgment that avoids the obvious answer.
Those are preferences, not standards. Yes, obviously, every man would prefer a 10/10 supermodel with huge tits who will act like a lady in the streets and a whore in the sheets and never ask for commitment (or, better yet, two of them), but most are perfectly happy to marry the 6/10 girl next door as long as she is still young and virginal.
This brings to mind something I heard from some podcast by 2 women a long time ago. I forget what podcast and who, but the women would sometimes judge men's fuckability/marriageability using a score system, with the scores being 1 or 0. This is in contrast to the near-universal score system of 1-10 that straight men tend to assign to women. Obviously no one knows for sure, but I was told by a woman that the 1/0 scoring system is much more in line with how women in general tend to judge men. The sense that I get is that this is broadly true, and if we were to try to convert one scale to the other, that the bar for reaching a "1" in the former scale would roughly correspond to 8.5-9 in the other scale.
I've noticed something similar to you as well. As hanikrummihundursvin said, the reason JK Rowling is hated is because, by the definition of the term as used by the people who most use the term, she is a transphobe. It just happens to be that the definition of the term encapsulates entirely reasonable and non-hateful, kind, non-bigoted opinions and behaviors regarding trans people. It's the same sort of phenomenon as the redefining of "racism" and "sexism" to encapsulate similarly reasonable, non-hateful, non-bigoted opinions and behaviors. These terms seem to have continued to hold onto the negative connotations through the redefining, which was the apparent goal of the people doing the redefining, and it remains to be seen how well that will go for the defining of "transphobia."
If you're testing in the 97th percentile I can't imagine why you'd feel biased against IQ tests, which seem to be telling you something most people want to hear: that you're really special! This may be muted because you don't feel special (possibly as a result of IQ filter bubbles), or because the way in which you are special doesn't amount to much if it isn't paired with some mixture of conscientiousness and luck.
I think, in modern times, the latter part about conscientiousness and luck, particularly the conscientiousness, has a lot to do with it. If it is true that IQ is largely innate and predictive of one's success in intellectual fields (as well as non-intellectual ones, for that matter), then if you have high IQ, then your success in intellectual fields can largely be attributed to luck of birth, akin to living a wealthy luxurious life because your parents happened to be billionaires. This, I think, is highly damaging to the ego of many people who like to imagine themselves as having worked for their success, and notably worked harder than all those other people who they had to outcompete in order to succeed. I personally believe that this is one of the main drivers of the widespread rejection of IQ and heredity thereof among the educated academic group.
Of course, there's also the issue that conscientiousness itself may also be just as "innate" as IQ (for however "innate" any such characteristic can be said to be), which is a whole other can of worms.
My online social milieu is filled with people who couldn't seem to stop talking about Hogwarts Legacy last week and the literal murder of trans people that were being enabled by daring to even watch someone else playing this game, and this is the 1st time I've seen it referred to as "hogleg." A pretty good abbreviation IMHO, much better than "The Wizard Game," and somewhat reminiscent of how they tend to abbreviate terms in Korea and Japan by taking the 1st syllable(s) of each word (e.g. "air conditioner" becoming "aircon" or "remote controller" becoming "remocon").
Knowing the context isn't the issue, though, since even knowing the context, I didn't find the meme at all funny or interesting or offensive. It just... was.
Alice's Adventures in Wonderland; a classic written over a century and a half ago, little to be controversial here, surely? -- banned in New Hampshire for allegories of sexual fantasies
I read this for the first time a couple years ago, and I'd describe it as more bizarre and surreal than anything else. I tried to think of what could have been allegorical of sexual fantasies in what I read, but I couldn't come up with any, and it does look like, if this link is correct, this had entirely to do with the author rather than the text itself:
In the early 1900s the state of New Hampshire banned the book from all public schools because the novel was accused of promoting sexual fantasies and masturbation. This accusation most likely refers to the questionable sexual activities of the author, not the novel’s content.
Everything old is new again, I suppose.
I second this. This was like 15 years ago, but I remember trying it and wondering what all the fuss was about. It wasn't even good, much less great enough to be worth the hype. And I normally love sweet drinks.
One theory I've seen bandied about is that the recording industry has a long and storied history of being very trigger-happy with lawsuits about their intellectual property, which led to AI devs being a bit more hesitant about training models on professionally published music. This is in contrast with Stable Diffusion, ChatGPT, and GitHub Copilot, which were all trained on publicly published but copyright protected images/text/code as well as public domain works. I don't know how much of an impact this actually had, but I imagine it's something at least on the back of the minds of devs. That said, there's no shortage of public domain music out there, and I wouldn't expect an AI trained only on classical music to be particularly bad - just limited.
Also, perhaps data size is an issue. A typical 3 minute song, even compressed, is far bigger in filesize than a typical image or text file. Sheet music could be used, though I'm also not sure how easy and cheap it is to get huge databases of sheet music. Scraping the internet for songs is also likely a bit more complicated than doing so for images and text, since generally music tends to be streamed by services which try intentionally to make it annoying to download the actual files, versus images and text which are trivial to right click + save.
There was, a couple months ago, some Stable Diffusion enthusiasts who developed what they called Riffusion which made use of the Stable Diffusion architecture to generate music. It involved training a model on image representations of sound waves, making the model generate new images of them and converting them back to sound. They got surprisingly decent results but the state of the tech then didn't seem like it could be used for much more than a toy, due in part to how short each output was. There are obviously workarounds to such limitations, but I don't know how far the development has come since then on actually bringing those workarounds to reality. Given that using Stable Diffusion to generate music is a hack, I'm not sure it'd be particularly worth it for devs to keep following that thread, but it's still a really clever and fun application of the tech.
That being said turning a prepper whose “clinging” to his guns into a closeted homo might make the “woke” bar.
I'm not watching the show, so I can't make a meaningful judgment on this specific case, but that's possible, depending on the execution. Closeted homosexuals is something that's been explored in fiction long before wokeness, such as American Beauty (which ironically starred a famously homosexual man as the straight protagonist), and I don't see the concept of turning a stereotypically conservative prepper into a closeted gay man to be automatically woke. From the other comments here, it seems that, if anything, having this be the 3rd episode in a way that breaks up the pacing of the show might be the strongest case of it being woke.
And some of you seem to be concluding if the art is done well and feels natural it then can by definition not be woke since woke can only be things we don’t like.
Hard disagree. It's to differentiate "woke" from "standard liberalism." These are different - though related and somewhat similar - clusters of ideologies, and "woke" is "woke" by how it differentiates itself from "standard liberalism." If a show can't be distinguished from what a standard liberal would make in terms of integrating their political messaging into the work (ie in a natural way that is meant to enhance the work by those traditional standards of how shows get judged, rather than supersede them), then I don't think it makes sense to call it "woke."
To be, the important thing about woke content is that it lies to us about the natural relationships between people. Instead it substitutes a fake, aspirational, version of reality where, for example, a woman is just as strong as man. Woke content is especially awful when it distorts the plot or makes its characters mere shells who exist to hammer a political point down the viewers throats.
I'm not sure about the specific criterion, but I broadly agree with this. A "woke" show (or film or game or etc.) isn't "woke" merely by having diversity or messaging that appeals to woke people. It's something that specifically reflects the woke mentality in contrast to the standard 90s-00s liberal "diversity is our strength" mentality. Which is that the world is a constant war between different oppressor/oppressed classes, and that TV shows are just another battleground where the messaging or representation has direct downstream effects that play out in literal people being killed or injured or otherwise going through unnecessary suffering. As such, the primary determinant of the quality of a TV show is its messaging, with trivial matters like likeable characters, character development, intriguing plot, clever writing, visually appealing cinematography, engaging pacing, satisfying character arcs, and the like, taking a very far back seat.
If a show just integrates concepts like diversity into its script in a way that's natural and meant to play into those traditional or outdated ways of making a show "good," then I don't think it's reasonable to consider the show "woke" in any way. It's just a standard liberal show.
This is a mostly random and unrelated comment, but any time I run into the name "Aretha Franklin," I'm reminded of how for the longest time, I had thought that her name was "Arethra Franklin" due to a typo in an MP3 file I downloaded from Napster back in the day. Having never run into either "Aretha" or "Arethra" as a name before, I used its similarity to "urethra" as a mnemonic device to remember the name of that singer who sang "Respect." I thought the similarity was pretty weird, but names in general can be pretty weird, so I didn't think much of it until I was corrected some years later.
The simulated “brain” that simulates the heart is a simulation of the brain and the heart.
This seems reasonable. And, again, going off this statement, it renders your original statement below completely wrong:
To have qualia you would have to simulate more than a brain, as qualia isn’t just felt or (in many cases) felt at all in the brain.
Because then we don't need to simulate more than the brain; we just need to simulate a brain which also simulates a heart (as in, the simulated brain creates the qualia of feeling a heart, without the programmers actually simulating a heart). So whether or not programmers simulated a brain AND a heart (AND a stomach and any other organ one might say is involved in qualia or feelings) really doesn't matter for the question of whether or not a simulated brain can have qualia. A simulated brain could just simulate those things.
Words gain meaning through usage rather than from first principles, so I'm not sure "accurate" is the right way to describe this. You make a compelling argument for why one ought to call TERFs "sexist" rather than "transphobic," but my sense is that this argument wouldn't be particularly convincing to the types of people who actually tend to use these terms "in the wild" and thus have the most influence in what these terms mean.
I agree with all of this, though the last part about what a "software algorithm" really is seems more a matter of philosophical worldview than anything else. I think it's important to note that in each and every one of these cases, including the software being written on a board, saved on GitHub, or even just existing purely in someone's head because they've never written it down, the "software" we're talking about exists in physical reality, whether that be markings on a board, the arrangement of atoms on the storage drives on GitHub's servers, or in the patterns of how someone's neurons fire and are connected.
One could hold the worldview that all software already exists, and programmers are merely "discovering" them by writing the code, in a Library of Babel sort of way - all books already exist, writers are merely "discovering" them when they put words on paper, or all paintings already exist, painters are merely "discovering" them when they put brush strokes on canvas - but I'd wager that's a highly atypical way of viewing the existence of software. Most people would agree that Mark Zuckerburg and his team didn't "discover" Facebook, but rather "created" it, even if it was "created" the moment they thought of it before even thinking of what language to program it in.

If a student in the middle of the bell curve in intelligence, I'm not sure they have much of a choice in this. A student in the middle of the bell curve in baseball ability doesn't have much of a choice in whether or not they play on the varsity baseball team. And if by some weird confluence of events they end up playing on the team anyway, then if the coach is at all competent, that student will find themselves riding the bench more often than not.
More options
Context Copy link