@07mk's banner p

07mk


				

				

				
2 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 06 15:35:57 UTC

				

User ID: 868

07mk


				
				
				

				
2 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 06 15:35:57 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 868

Dualism in this context is generally taken to mean the belief that there is a 2nd "realm" of reality beyond physics, and usually that our conscious minds are are somehow connections to that "realm" - usually that connection being to our "soul" that exists in this non-physical "realm."

If you believe that the various sets of personalities that arise from your body are "you" such that if your body changed causing your personality to change, then that would no longer be "you" or that "a part of you" was "killed," that means you believe in some cluster of personalities that forms "you" that exists independently from your body. That's an implicit belief in a non-physical "realm" where your "soul" (i.e. the cluster of personalities that you identify as "you") resides. If you in this hypothetical didn't hold an implicit belief in dualism, then you would accept that whatever changes to your personality that arises from changes to your body is still "you," because you identify "yourself" as the physical and experiential consequences caused by the interactions of particles in and outside your body. Rather than some specific set of personalities that exist independent from your body.

At a certain point, if your personality changes drastically enough, that's not "you" anymore, regardless of whether you believe in dualism.

No, that is the belief in dualism. Believing that the "you" is some set of personalities and a body that goes along with, rather than the set of personalities that arise from the body is dualism. Of course one can and does care about one's personality regardless of dualism; one's personality, to a large extent, determines the level of suffering one experiences, among other things. But that's a separate question from whether changing one's personality through a pill is something that partially kills you or tears away your soul versus just another intervention that manipulates your body in some way, in this case as to change your personality.

I don't see why it being a consequence of biology is relevant. My point is that people really do consider their personalities to be their souls.

I didn't claim that the cause of your detail-oriented personality is your soul. The cause doesn't matter. What matters is how much you value that personality now that you have it.

You seem to be expanding on the very implicit belief in dualism that I mentioned before here. I'm not sure where you disagree with me, based on reading this. Yes, many people do consider their personalities to be their souls, and that implies that they believe in a sort of dualism. Many people are attached to their personalities and would prefer not to take such a pill, and that in itself doesn't require a belief in an immaterial soul. But to believe that taking such a pill - assuming the personality change is drastic enough -is partial murder would require an at least implicit belief in dualism.

This is true regardless of the immaterial soul thing, no?

No. For instance, in your example, being logical, detail oriented, artsy, or creative (the latter 2 and former 2 don't seem to be at all in conflict with each other, for the record, making the analogy rather off) aren't things that exist independently of the body. These personality traits come about as a consequence of the biology of the brain which is affected pretty directly by the biology of the rest of the body, such as hormones. The reason I might be any of these things isn't because there's something fundamentally "me" about being logical and detail oriented or whatever, it's because my physical body caused that to arise in my sets of behavior and my consciousness.

A pill that changes my personality in that way would be a pill that changes my personality in that way. It would be changing my biology the way pills tend to do, and I do consider it quite a stretch to say that that's partial murder.

At the end of the day, we can't really tell who's got a more perception, I guess. My thinking is that much of the philosophical basis I hear from the left around trans issues seems to implicitly posit a sort of dualism, that there's some immaterial soul that has a gender that is decoupled from the sex of the body. As such, I would predict that for most of the left, a pill that makes someone identify their gender with their birth sex would be akin to a pill that tears off a part of the person's soul. It's the same reason why I would guess that even if gay conversion therapy were proven to be effective and with low risk/benefit ratio for a medical/psychological intervention (neither of which seem plausible to me), I doubt there would be much support at all for it from the left.

My perception could easily be colored too much by the leftists I interact with, though. And it's entirely possible that the implicit dualism I see being invoked is just a tool being used to push forward policies intended to reduce the suffering of people with gender dysphoria, and in the scifi scenario that a pill is invented to painlessly do just that, the dualism basis would get dropped entirely. Most leftists aren't activists, and most people aren't principled left or right, so it could take just a few activists supporting it and the regular everyday people going along with it to make it popular among the left.

What do you mean by "support this?"

For me, "support this" would involve something akin to being either ambivalent to or promoting of a medical/social standard where when someone believes they have gender dysphoria and wants to explore options to progress from there, this pill is presented by doctors/psychologists as an equally helpful option to address their dysphoria as medical/social transitioning, modulo the relative risk/benefit ratios of the different processes. This is a pretty muddy and imprecise standard, but that's hard to avoid when talking about something as broad as "leftists" "supporting" "this."

I'm a leftist who would support this by the above standard, but I have to honestly say that I'm skeptical that agreeing with me would be popular or even common among leftists.

Any random girl can believably claim to have a stalker, though. The bar for being good looking enough to have a stalker is... so low as to be literally impossible to trip over, IME.

You're right that many female streamers cultivate an audience in this way, but some female streamers do not and yet still have deepfake porn of them made.

Is this actually true? I'm curious to learn of some examples for, uh, research purposes.

This kind of comment with deliberate shock value in an obvious attempt to cause an extreme emotional response to create a sort of "ad absurdum" proof (i.e. implicit message being "according to your stated values, this EXTREME and OBSCENE thing happening to YOU would be allowed; your stated values don't look so good now, does it?") happens every once in a while in this forum, and though I've often found it amusing, I've also started to find it frustrating. Because when they inevitably get the types of responses that this one got, (i.e. "Yes, that'd be fully allowed. And?"), there never seems to be any follow-up to continue the conversation. And that's a shame, because I feel like there's potentially an interesting conversation here. It's legit fascinating to me that some pixels arranged to look like a photograph of oneself doing XYZ could be offensive to one based on how offensive XYZ are, and not only that, that it's so obviously offensive that it's used as an "ad absurdum" endpoint to use as a "gotcha" against someone's values.

There's already a very well developed fully general explanation for anything of this sort, which is that Black Americans are oppressed in this white supremacist society, and as such, they have greater stress on their lives leading them to make more mistakes, or they have fewer resources to turn to, leading them to turn to crime to make ends meet. This is actually generalizable - and often generalized - to any subgroup that has been deemed to be oppressed.

Evidently the problem is not the fraud, but the detection [and corrective action] of said fraud. The implication is that blacks should be allowed to do fraud. It sounds dumb but this is the only possible conclusion I can draw from this article, which is probably why they didn't want to specify a remedy.

This seems isomorphic to other conversations about achieving social justice, where they're often spoken more explicitly. In affirmative action, for instance, one of the main pro- arguments goes that blacks/women, at the moment of applying for a job, on average are less qualified for the job than whites/men, and this lower qualification is due to the bigoted discrimination they faced in a white supremacist/patriarchal society limiting their ability to fulfill their potential. As such, it is the responsibility of the individual company to make up for the injustices perpetuated on those blacks/women by society by putting their thumb on the scale in their favor at the moment of hiring. Usually, one of the handwaving justifications for this is that by giving certain individuals within these subgroups a leg up, it will lead to those individuals having greater ability to contribute back to their communities of similarly oppressed subgroups, helping to uplift them out of the hole that the oppressive society placed them in. Perhaps the handwave for this IRS situation hasn't been developed and matured to the same extent yet, though I imagine adapting the existing one to this one shouldn't be hard.

The way I think about this is by considering that a strong enough AI program would be theoretically capable of using a clothed picture of someone to actually reconstruct the way the exact way they look naked, which would be quite literally equivalent to the aforementioned situation/looking at them with x-ray glasses, etc. which again (I think) we and most people agree would be wrong. And so, less-powerful AI capable of doing something similar seem to be at least on that gradient of wrong, if not exactly as bad.

Barring some development in physics that enable something like time travel, I don't see how an AI program like that could even theoretically be possible. The information just isn't there, and it's trivial to come up with extremely plausible examples where no AI could reconstruct the exact way someone looks naked - e.g. if someone has a tattoo on their stomach or something.

As such, I don't see this as a gradient. When we're talking about AI or deepfakes, we're necessarily talking about using computers to create brand new illustrations that didn't exist before. In the future, AI could (and likely will) get so much better that we could use clothed pictures of someone to easily and quickly create illustrations of that person that look, to a very high degree of accuracy, as if it were just a nude photo of that person. However, given that that accuracy can't get to 100% or even all that close to it, it's categorically different from, say, snapping a nude photograph of that person.

To me, the strongest argument against deepfakes is the potential distress caused to someone who might accidentally (or intentionally, for that matter) run into such things of themselves. I place this in the same category of suffering as the suffering of some Fundamentalist Christian or Muslim at observing gay people kissing or a cartoon of Mohammed; given how much damage some gay couple or a bunch of pixels can do to these individuals (i.e. none) it's suffering caused entirely by the individual's decision to deem those things as causing themselves suffering. A bunch of pixels that are arranged to look like an accurate photograph of someone nude simply lacks the ability to do anything to affect that person beyond what that person chooses. At best, perhaps a bunch of people jacking it to pictures of someone would lead to those people treating that person differently, but a. I don't particularly see why this would be true and b. even if it were, the issue would be the people choosing to treat that person differently, not in them having access to such pictures.

Is it? I thought I heard some urban legend about how "intent to distribute" was something they could tack on just on the basis of sheer mass, but that it still required meeting some minimum threshold. But the drug war hasn't been something I've paid attention for a long time.

But isn't the common belief that very high IQ people are contingently but empirically correlated with cognitive disorders such as e.g the autism/asperger spectrum?

The common belief is that this common belief is caused by a common misperception. Very high IQ people who lack cognitive disorders are less interesting than very high IQ people who have cognitive disorders, so they're less noticed, in favor of very high IQ people who have cognitive disorders. And so people falsely get the notion that having cognitive disorders is more common among very high IQ people.

However, that is just a common belief. I don't know if there's extensive research on this, and even if there were, if the extensive research is credible.

Possibly the most popular right wing thinker today, Jordan Peterson, advocates a meat only elimination diet for health reasons.

I haven't paid much attention to Peterson in a few years, but is he really that popular? But more to the point, when I did used to pay attention him, he never advocated the carnivore diet for others but just talked about it as something he and his daughter found useful. His daughter had some sort of consultation service to help people get on the diet, but it was the kind of thing you had to really dig through to find, not something he publicized. Has he changed his tone from "this diet worked for me and my daughter, maybe it's something you could try out to see if it works for you too" to "you should adopt this diet" at some point?

You make a good "spherical cows" argument which shows how we would want things to play out. I think there's a big gap between that toy model and real courts, though. Copyright laws might ostensibly primarily be for the purpose of promoting and incentivizing the creation of original works, but I think they're actually primarily for the purpose of appeasing entities who financially benefit off of being able to own intellectual property. Now, there are many such entities on both sides of this culture war, so I think which side wins in the courts will come down largely to who can grease more of the right palms than the opposition rather than any principles.

of course Dall-E 2 (and the next model that's allegedly called Flow and will be integrated with GPT-4) can be artistic enough to compete with human artists, even if it won't be mimicking their particular styles. Indeed, it'd be more interesting to push those models to develop novel styles of their own.

I don't know much about Dall-E 2 or Flow, but this is the sort of thing I'm particularly excited about in this space in the near future. I'm reminded of how AI learning how to play chess or go resulted in novel, unexpected behavior that caught human experts in such games off guard, showing us humans just how limited our understanding of the space of possible chess/go moves was. In the case of AI generated images, an AI can explore the space of possible pixel arrangements in a grid in a way that's far more flexible than a human with their human constraints can, and I wonder just how much beauty there is in this space that were previously impossible or extremely difficult to access due to our human constraints.

The risk is that there’s simply a blanket ban on copyrighting anything that contains AI art, with a full provenance pipeline required if any suspicions arise. Can’t use it for a logo, for corporate art, for media that you intend to sell, in the workplace etc.

I don't think there's a particularly high risk of that. Full provenance pipeline requirement would essentially make the entire creative industry non-viable, and creating a new "infectious public domain" category just for AI generated images - where not only are the images in the public domain, any media that uses such images also become public domain - is sufficiently new and disruptive that whatever political will can be scrounged up to push for such a system seems likely to be crushed by the might of entrenched interests like Disney or Microsoft who would essentially see their entire film, TV, and video game divisions destroyed if they allowed it to happen.

Overfitting is a thing, and it's certainly possible to use the base Stable Diffusion model to recreate closely-enough-to-count-as-infringement some famous artworks such as the Mona Lisa. Dunno if there are any non-public domain artworks for this applies, though, and in the general case, certainly these models don't particularly enable someone to create copies of copyrighted images.

I'm not sure if such details matter, though. The lawsuits seem to be claiming that the very act of training on the copyrighted images is infringement, and I don't know if that argument relies fully on the false notion that the models allow for reliable reproduction of training images outside of extreme edge cases.

Some more heating up in the AI image generation culture wars, with stock image company Getty Images suing Stability AI over alleged copyright violations. Here's Getty Image's full press release:

This week Getty Images commenced legal proceedings in the High Court of Justice in London against Stability AI claiming Stability AI infringed intellectual property rights including copyright in content owned or represented by Getty Images. It is Getty Images’ position that Stability AI unlawfully copied and processed millions of images protected by copyright and the associated metadata owned or represented by Getty Images absent a license to benefit Stability AI’s commercial interests and to the detriment of the content creators.

Getty Images believes artificial intelligence has the potential to stimulate creative endeavors. Accordingly, Getty Images provided licenses to leading technology innovators for purposes related to training artificial intelligence systems in a manner that respects personal and intellectual property rights. Stability AI did not seek any such license from Getty Images and instead, we believe, chose to ignore viable licensing options and long‑standing legal protections in pursuit of their stand‑alone commercial interests.

This follows a separate class action lawsuit filed in California by 3 artists against multiple image generation AI companies including Stability AI, Midjourney, and DeviantArt (which is an art sharing site, but which seems to be working on building its own image creation model). According to Artnews, "The plaintiffs claim that these companies have infringed on 17 U.S. Code § 106, exclusive rights in copyrighted works, the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, and are in violation of the Unfair Competition law." It seems to me that these 2 lawsuits are complaining about basically the same thing.

IANAL, and I have little idea of how the courts are likely to rule on this, especially English courts versus American ones. I know there's precedent for data scraping being legal, but those are highly context-dependent, and e.g. the Google Books case was contingent on the product not being a meaningful competitor to the books that were being scanned, which is a harder argument to make about an AI image generator with respect to a stock image service. In my subjective opinion, anything published on the public internet is fair game for training by AI, since others learning from viewing your work is one of the things you necessarily accept when you publish your work for public view on the internet. This includes watermarked sample images of proprietary images that one could buy. However, there's a strong argument to be made for the other side, that there's something qualitatively different about a human using an AI to offload the process of learning from viewing images compared to a human directly learning from viewing images such that the social contract of publishing for public consumption as it exists doesn't account for it and must be amended to include an exception for AI training.

Over the past half year or so, I'm guessing AI image generation is second only to ChatGPT in mainstream attention that has been directed towards AI-related stuff - maybe 3rd after self-driving cars, and so it's unsurprising to me that a culture war has formed around it. But having paid attention to some of AI image generation-related subreddits, I've noticed that the lines still don't really fit with existing culture war lines. There's signs of coalescing against AI image generation in the left, with much of the pushback coming from illustrators who are on the left, such as the comic artist Sarah C Andersen who's one of the 3 artists in that class action lawsuit, and also a sort of leftist desire to protect the jobs of lowly paid illustrators by preventing competition. But that's muddled by the fact that, on Reddit, most people are on the left to begin with, and the folks who are fine with AI image generation tools (by which I mean the current models trained on publicly-available but sometimes copyrighted images) are also heavily on the left, and there are also leftist arguments in favor of the tech for opening up high quality image generation to people with disabilities like aphantasia and others. Gun to my head, I would guess that this trend will continue until it's basically considered Nazism within 2 years to use "unethically trained AI" to create images, but my confidence level in that guess would be close to nil.

From a practical perspective, there's no legislation that can stop people from continuing to use the models that are already built, but depending on the results of these lawsuits, we could see further development in this field slow down quite a bit. I imagine that it can and will be worked around, and restrictions on training data will only delay the technology by a few years, which would mean that what I see as the true complaint from stock image websites and illustrators - unfair competition - wouldn't be addressed, so I would expect this culture war to remain fairly heated for the foreseeable future.

I wanted to share a kind of an amusing intersection of a bunch of topics that's often discussed here, which include some minor culture war issues. A couple of weeks ago, a software developer who goes by Vedal started streaming on Twitch using an AI-run vtuber by the name of Neuro-sama. There is one AI to learn how to play the rhythm game Osu that would play on screen, while a different LLM AI (not OpenAI or anything close to it, I think) would read chat and respond to messages using TTS as well as as subtitles on screen. I'm actually not 100% sure how the vtuber model is controlled, but it doesn't seem to be particularly active, so it might just be a generic video game NPC cycle.

Amusingly, I think the first prominent Vtuber was Kizuna Ai whose persona was that of an AI, but was obviously puppeteered directly by humans.

I actually started watching the streams about a week ago, despite not having an interest in vtubers or Osu. It's essentially a public LLM chatbot with TTS and anime girl avatar, and so the "conversations" go like you'd expect, with plenty of nonsensical statements and wild inconsistencies both between statements and within statements. I think the creator was clever to use such a child-looking vtuber model as a way to lean into this, enhancing the sense that the audience is interacting with someone who's still developing mentally, because I've undeniably found it cute and funny at times in a "from the mouth of babes" kind of way.

But of course, in a public website like Twitch, you should fully expect trolls to do troll things, and one managed to get through by getting Neuro-sama to question the Holocaust. This (presumably - I don't think there's any official confirmation) resulted in a temporary ban of the Twitch account, which is still ongoing. This sort of thing was bound to happen at some point given the current level of sophistication of LLM. And Twitch sometimes has the etiquette of the streamer reading aloud a chat message before responding to it, which Neuro-sama follows sometimes, and unlike a human, her quotation-reading voice and regular-speaking voice are identical. It occurs to me that Twitch's ban was justified given that they shouldn't particularly care that it's an AI controlling the voice, as long as the on-stream persona is still saying it. This is something anyone who wants to run an AI vtuber would have to account for, and I'm guessing Vedal had protections in place that were circumvented, and if not, certainly they must be scrambling to put one together.

It's fascinating and amusing for me to see this play out in real-time. The concept of AI-run celebrities has been around for a while in science fiction, and we're transitioning into it being just plain reality. At least, maybe; 1 example does not a trend make, and the novelty might wear off with a few iterations. Still, I'm glad to see someone experimenting with this kind of thing, and I'm surprised we're already at the point where someone is able to crudely but successfully staple together some modules to make this AI-run e-celeb. Interestingly, since the streams are on the creator's channel, a lot of the conversations are about Neuro-sama's relationship with her creator Vedal, resulting in Vedal also becoming a sort of e-celeb.

Also, recently Neuro-sama started singing full songs on stream, which is more in line with AI celebs in scifi. I don't know how that is accomplished other than "cheating" by using some preset, even if the voice is generated real-time. I'm pretty sure whatever AI model they're using isn't figuring out the pitch and pronunciation of each syllable in these full-length mainstream songs as it goes.

But yeah, fascinating intersection of AI alignment, holocaust denial, online moderation policies, and weeaboo culture that I wouldn't have seen coming even just a couple months ago.

One can respect people who are not one's equals yes, but I think this is conditional on one not thinking very often, or at all, of the ways in which one is superior, particularly if intellect is the disparity.

I don't think this is true at all, and I don't see any reason why it would be true.

Which suggests a way forward here, since it doesn't seem like individualism will be making a comeback: the truth about black IQ can't be in the water supply. It probably can only be safely handled in the ivory tower, though even there there's a vigorous effort to squelch it.

I disagree with both sentences here. Despite all the efforts by extremists on both (all) sides of the political spectrum, individualism is still around, even if weakened, and the idea that truth about IQ could only be handled safely in the ivory tower just seems like baseless scaremongering.

I mean, can one respect someone while simultaneously claiming they're duller?

Yes, obviously? Why would someone being duller than me have any sort of connection to my respect for them?

Seems like it would take some real contortions, common-sensically, once you feel someone is not at least your equal, you don't respect them.

I run into people who are not my equal all the time and have no trouble respecting them. Some of them are shorter than me, physically weaker than me, or stupider than me. Everyone runs into people all the time who are not at least their equals, if they function in society. It is essentially a necessary component of a functioning society that people are able to respect others regardless of others being at least their equals or not. Choosing how much you respect someone based on whether they're at least your equal or not isn't common sense in any way.

Sure, you can still feel compassion for them, but it sounds very disempowering to say "whites should be compassionate towards blacks". Arguably, that's the attitude wokes take, but I think that's the reason they often say things that sound awfully racist.

That's the attitude wokes take, yes, and that's indeed a reason they often say things that sound awfully racist. So to avoid that, we can say that "individuals should respect other individuals without care for their intelligence." And then really live it.

There's no particular reason the truth can't have negative repercussions, such as lowering the status of black people, which I think most would agree would be racist.

I think most people would agree that black people having their status lowered (specifically as black people in comparison to non-black people) would be racist. It does not follow that if the truth was one of the causes of this, then the truth is racist. Something having racist repercussions does not imply that it is itself racist - if it did, then we would necessarily conclude that literally everything is racist, which would strip "racism" of any meaning and make it a non-word that has neither negative nor positive connotations.

Particularly considering that "lowering the status of black people" isn't something the "truth" can do by adjusting the dial or something; it takes the active effort of millions of humans making individual idiosyncratic decisions in reaction to the "truth" to accomplish such a lowering of status. In this specific example, the racism seems pretty clear to me sourced from individuals' reaction to the truth, not truth itself.

Movies can be great even if they go heavy on the DEI side of things: see Everything, Everywhere All At Once, which, although polarizing, definitely stands out in good ways.

Everything Everywhere All At Once didn't go heavy on DEI, though. At best, it went somewhat light with some promotion highlighting the Asian/middle-aged woman/gay representation. For it to go heavy on DEI would require something more overt, like the Asian protagonist's daughter being inexplicably black or the protagonist being humiliated over her homophobia regarding her daughter's sexuality. A film that happens to feature minorities as the protagonists isn't one that's going DEI, heavily or otherwise.