Yes, that sounds like it'd be quite doable and unsurprising to have within the next few years at most. That seems like it would be largely the oral version of the manual fiddling that's going on now.
I agree, and I think the time scale is more likely to be in months than years at this point. But "drastically less manual fiddling" is still likely to be a lot of manual fiddling I think, because of just how imprecise the language model is. Perhaps I'll be able to easily generate an accurate and error-free image of, say, "a short white man wearing a blue collared shirt standing in front of a bus stop with a sneaker advertisement that has an accurate Nike swoosh with 'Just Do It' in comic sans font on it" in the future, but when the AI generates the image, it will be left out of my hands where on his shirt the wrinkles are, or the exact shape of a weed that might be growing in the sidewalk or the way the light reflecting off the man's cheek onto the bus stop causes the bus stop to have a slight warm sheen or etc., and these would require manual fiddling to get it to match one's initial vision. Eventually eventually, even all those details might be able to be figured out by an AI, but I'm not sure how, in principle, an AI could get that level of specific information without some sort of brain reading technology. At which point the technology involved is something very different from the AI image generators of today.
Of course, there can (will?) be AI tools to further help along the manual fiddling. I see this as further increasing actual skilled artists' leverage, since they're the ones who get to start with good images due to their skills, while unskilled folks like me have to start with crude drawings or just latent noise.
I've been pretty obsessively playing around with AI image generation the last 3 or so weeks, and after learning what I have in that time, it's struck me how the culture war arguments seem to miss the contours of the actual phenomenon (i.e. like every other culture war issue). The impression that I got from just observing the culture war was that the primary use of these tools was "prompt engineering," i.e. experimenting with and coming up with the right sets of prompts and settings and seeds in order to get an image one wants. This is, of course, how many/most of the most famous examples are generated, because that's how you demonstrate the actual ability of the AI tool.
So I installed Stable Diffusion on my PC and started generating some paintings of big booba Victorian women. Ran into predictable issues with weird composition, deformities, and inaccuracies, but I figured that I could fix these by getting better at "prompt engineering." So I looked at some resources online to see how people actually got better at this. On top of that, I didn't want to just stick to making generic pictures of beautiful Victorian women, or of any sort of beautiful women; I wanted to try making fanart of specific waifus characters doing specific things (as surprising as it may be, this is not a euphemism - more because of a lack of ambition than lack of desire) in specific settings shot in specific angles and specific styles.
And from digging into the resources, I discovered a couple of important methods to accomplish something like this. First was training the model further for specific characters or things, which I decided not to touch for the moment. Second was in-painting, which is just the very basic concept of doing IMG2IMG on a specific subset of pixels on the image. (There's also out-painting which is just canvas expansion + noise + in-painting). "Prompt engineering" was involved to some extent, but the info I read on this was very basic and sparse; at this point, whatever techniques that are there seem pretty minor, not much more sophisticated than the famous "append 'trending on Artstation' to the prompt" tip.
So I started going ahead using initial prompts to generate some crude image, then using IMG2IMG with in-painting to get to the final specific fanart I wanted to make. And the more I worked on this, the more I realized that this is where the bulk of the actual "work" takes place when it comes to making AI images. If you want to frame a shot a certain way and feature specific characters doing specific things in specific places, you need to follow an iterative process of SD-generation, Photoshop edit, in-painting-SD-generation, Photoshop edit, and so on until the final desired image is produced.
I'm largely agnostic and ambivalent on the question of whether AI generated images are Art, or if one is being creative by creating AI generated images. I don't think it really matters; what matters to me is if I can create images that I want to create. But in the culture war, I think the point of comparison has to be between someone drawing from scratch (even if using digital tools like tablets and Photoshop) and someone using AI to iteratively select parts of an image to edit in order to get to what they want. Not someone using AI to punch in the right settings (which can also be argued to be an Art).
The closest analogue I could think of was making a collage by cutting out magazines or picture books and gluing them together in some way that meaningfully reflects the creator's vision. Except instead of rearranging pre-existing works of art, I'm rearranging images generated based on the training done by StabilityAI (or perhaps, the opposite; I'm generating images and then rearranging them). Is collage-making Art? Again, I don't know and I don't care, but the question about AI "art" is a very similar question.
My own personal drawing/illustration skills are quite low; I imagine a typical grade schooler can draw about as well as I can. At many steps along the process of the above iteration, I found myself thinking, "If only I had some meaningful illustration skills; fixing this would be so much easier" as I ran into various issues trying to make a part of an image look just right. I realized that if I actually were a trained illustrator, my ability to exploit this AI tool to generate high quality images would be improved several times over.
And this raises more blurry lines about AI-generated images being Art. At my own skill level, running my drawing through IMG2IMG to get something good is essentially like asking the AI to use my drawing as a loose guide. To say that the image is Artwork that 07mk created would be begging the question, and I would hesitate to take credit as the author of the image. But at the skill level of a professional illustrator, his AI-generated image might look virtually identical to something he created without AI, except it has a few extra details that the artist himself needed the AI to fill in. If I'm willing to say that his non-AI generated images are art, I would find it hard to justify calling the AI-generated one not art.
Based on my experience the past few weeks, my prediction would be that there will be broadly 3 groups in the future in this realm: the pure no-AI Artists, the cyborgs who are skilled Artists using AI to aid them along the process, and people like me, the AI-software operators who aren't skilled artists in any non-AI sense. Furthermore, I think that 2nd group is likely to be the most successful. I think the 1st group will fall into its own niche of pure non-AI art, and it will probably remain the most prestigious and also remain quite populous, but still lose a lot of people to the 2nd group as the leverage afforded to an actually skilled Artist by these tools is significant.
Random thoughts:
-
I didn't really touch on customizing the models to be able to consistently represent specific characters, things, styles, etc. which is a whole other thing unto itself. This seems to be a whole vibrant community unto itself, and I know very little of it first hand. But this raises another aspect of AI-generated images being Art or not - is it Art the technique of finding the right balance when merging different models or of picking the right training images and training settings to create a model that is capable of generating the types of pictures you want? I would actually lean towards Yes in this, but that may be just because there's still a bit of a mystical haze around it to me from lack of experience. Either way, the question of AI-generated images being Art or not should be that question, not whether or not picking the right prompts and settings and seed is.
-
I've read artists mention training models on their characters in order to aid them in generating images more quickly for comic books they're working on. Given that speed matters for things like this, this is one "cyborg" method a skilled Artist could use to increase the quantity or quality of their output (either by reducing the time required for each image or increasing the time the Artist can use to finalize the image compared to doing it from scratch).
-
For generating waifus, NovelAI really is far and away the best model, IMHO. I played around a lot with Waifu Diffusion (both 1.2 & 1.3), but getting good looking art out of it - anime or not - was a struggle and inconsistent, while NovelAI did it effortlessly. However, NovelAI is overfitted, making most of their girls have a same-y look. There's also the issue that NovelAI doesn't offer in-painting in their official website, and the only way to use it for in-painting involves pirating their leaked model which I'd prefer not to rely on.
-
I first learned that I could install Stable Diffusion on my PC by stumbling on https://rentry.org/voldy whose guide is quite good. I learned later on that the site is maintained by someone from 4chan, and further that 4chan seems to be where a lot of the innovation and development by the hobbyists is taking place. As someone who hasn't used 4chan much in well over a decade, this was a blast from the past. In retrospect this is obvious, given the combination of nihilism and degeneracy you see in 4chan (I say this only out of love; I maintain to this day that there's no online community that I found more loving and welcoming than 4chan).
-
For random "prompt engineering" tips that I figured out over time - use "iris, contacts" to get nicer eyes. "Shampoo, conditioner" seems to make nice hair with a healthy sheen.
Well, I guess I really think the main objection in this case is a reflexive distaste for billionaires, of which Elon is perhaps the most visible. Whether this is survival instinct, envy, or class consciousness? Who can say?
I think there has to be more than that, since it's not like Twitter wasn't owned by a billionaire before Elon. If it was truly reflexive distaste for billionaires, it would be odd for it to be triggered just now. Elon is perhaps the most visible billionaire, but I think the distaste directed his way before the Twitter deal, which seems to be the main source of the distaste towards the deal, wasn't primarily because of him being a billionaire that was the most visible. Rather, I think him being the most visible billionaire is in a large part due to the distaste he garners from people for his awkward public appearances and statements where he shows off his all-too-techbro/classical liberal stylings.
The Stable Diffusion subreddit has a decent links post with lots of guides. However, at this point, the ability of the model to generate highly specific images like that is very limited, and it'd likely take less time to generate a picture of nuthatch and then use inpainting to generate a navy captain's hat on its head than to find the right prompt-setting combination to get the image you want.
No. I'm saying that it's entirely possible for Politico to have diminished Lawrence-Hardy's qualifications without criticizing her legal qualifications, and it's misleading to state as if them not criticizing her legal qualifications has any implication on the spokeswoman's claim that Politico diminished Lawrence-Hardy's qualifications. I'm ignorant of the specific statements Politico made, but presuming accuracy from NYTimes, my conclusion is that no one at Politico called out Lawrence-Hardy for not having the qualifications to be a lawyer. If I want to figure out if the spokeswoman's claim about Politico was true, then this NYTimes article doesn't help me other than pointing me in the direction of the primary source. Which would be all fine and good, if the NYTimes article didn't also strongly hint that the spokeswoman's claim about Politico were false while still avoiding explicitly saying it.
Mmm, this seems to be splitting hairs to me. The legal nuance seems fine considering the original statement referred explicitly to an "attorney." If we were litigating over a physician, it would seem fair for the follow on sentence to editorialize with medical qualifications.
No. Claiming that one is "diminishing the qualifications of an attorney" implies something very different from claiming that one is "criticizing her legal qualifications." The former brings to mind her quality as an attorney; the latter brings to mind actual legal qualifications.
Of course, there's barely enough plausible deniability there that someone who is sufficiently motivated could believe that the 2 phrases are similar enough that it's just an innocuous rephrasing. And that's what makes it so slimy, because (intentionally or not) they're relying on that plausible deniability.
NYT chose to make a more falsifiable statement using the word criticize, and I think the inclusion advanced rather than diminished the average reader's comprehension.
No. NYT's sentence here was in response to what the spokeswoman Espinoza said. Espinoza claimed something about what Politico wrote - it might be true, it might be false, it might be misleading, but what she claimed is what she claimed - and NYT commented on a different but related thing that Politico could have done (an didn't do). This muddles things - either they're misleading the reader by changing the topic without notifying them or they're misleading themselves by believing that they can read minds and figure out that when Espinoza claimed that Politico "diminish[ed her] qualifications" what she really meant was that Politico "criticized her legal qualifications." Either way, it's bad journalism and slimy.
If the writer wanted to contradict Espinoza in an open and honest way, he could have asked her for clarification and/or examples and then analyzed Politico's statements on those grounds. Or just stuck to the original meaning of what Espinoza claimed.
Xakota Espinoza, a Fair Fight Action spokeswoman, also sent a statement to The New York Times: “It was deeply disturbing to see an attempt to diminish the qualifications of a nationally esteemed Black, woman attorney.”
No one in the Politico article criticized the legal qualifications of Ms. Lawrence-Hardy.
This sort of editorializing is so slimy, and transparently so. It's obvious that the last paragraph is meant as a follow-up to the sentence before that, in a way appears to counter it to a typical inattentive reader. But it doesn't counter it at all, since there was nothing in the quotation from Espinoza that implied that her accusation was that the attempt was to criticize the legal qualifications; she specifically used the term "diminish" and didn't imply any sort of "legal" conditional on the qualifications of the attorney. There are a million and one ways the Politico article could diminish her qualifications without criticizing her legal qualifications in any way. And the NY Times presenting the latter statement as if it's in any conflict or even any discord between the 2 reduces their credibility in my eyes. Either they're purposefully misleading, or the writer and editors lack the capacity to understand that it's misleading.
Fair point, but I'm referring to phenomena like "buying into the official doctrine that the personal is political" when I refer to "manipulation."
I don't know that a handful of morticians and pathologists noticing something rises to the level of being notable enough that it attracts lots of real investigators to actually look into it as some widespread phenomenon, which is likely why all you see online is culture war stuff right now. If some undeniable pattern or trend comes out, maybe we'll see some real inquiry into this, but as of now, it's not surprising to me that almost no one has asked even the most basic question of "Is it even happening at all or is it a hoax?"
And speaking of the culture war,
Do people care more about culture warring than survival?
I know this is rude, but blindingly obviously yes? One of the things about the culture war is that it manipulates people into believing that their own culture winning is synonymous with their own survival. As such, people become convinced that caring about the culture war is how one guarantees one's survival, with the result being that they care more about culture warring than their own survival.
Your explanation and my explanation are almost the same, but also impossible to check against each other, in my view. If one is sufficiently morally motivated, one can convince oneself of the profitability of any endeavor one believes is morally correct. Or non-profitability thereof, as the case may be - sufficient moral motivation isn't just a hell of a drug, it's the hell of a drug. I think the producers are sufficiently morally motivated to believe that having DEI in their work would make it profitable.
Or with more nuance, there are many decision makers in many teams that went into making any show like Rings of Power, and some of them push for DEI out of a genuine desire to make the world a better place, while others push for DEI out of a cynical belief that it will be more profitable, with that cynical belief caused by a genuine desire to make the world a better place, and with even more people lying somewhere in between.
I wouldn't describe it like that. I don't think the producers are shoving in world-breaking diversity for the sake of harming their enemies by planting their flag in some major IP or whatever. If you squint, you can make it look like conflict theory in how the show producers believe that audience attention is a zero sum game (actually true) and as such it's their responsibility to fill it with as much of the Objectively Morally Good Content as possible which involves squeezing out the Objectively Morally Bad Content, but I think that's still pretty far removed. I think it's that they genuinely, mistakenly, believe that Objectively Morally Good Content is synonymous with Good Piece of Fiction and so optimize for Objectively Morally Good Content - which means awkwardly shoving in diversity without caring for the world-breaking it causes.
How hard is it for people to understand that something like this will usually make people okay with diversity in shows like this?
...
Now compare this with the LotR show where people are just randomly a different race and it's ridiculous. It just blows my mind people can't just do this for all these shows.
You seem to be misunderstanding the thinking of the types of creators who make casting decisions like in Rings of Power. The thinking isn't, "How do we maintain a high quality product while adding in these bits of diversity and representation that we believe can make our artwork be forces of good in this world?" This was the mindset of many creators (still is) over many many decades already, and it's nothing noteworthy. What sets recent works, such as Rings of Power, apart is that they eschew that mindset and instead go to "How do we add quality to our product by pumping in more diversity and representation so that our artwork can be forces of good in this world?" It's not that the quality of the product is dependent on things like writing, world-building, acting, pacing, etc. and we can maintain those things while adding diversity. It's rather that the quality of the product is directly improved by adding diversity, far greater than bad writing or world-building could harm, and as such we do it by hook or by crook, regardless of how much it worsens the writing or world-building. When people say that they care a lot about diversity and believe it really matters, it's best to believe them.
Which is the problem with that test: my answers and those of bonafide right-wing white nationalist would be indistinguishable.
I don't think the test is meant to distinguish between those, though. It's not a generic political-position test, it's just a test for wokeness. As someone who is also a liberal myself (I don't know if I "pass" for one hereabouts, but I identify as one), I would classify myself as 100% anti-woke and I would expect an accurate test for wokeness to classify me as such, in a way that's indistinguishable from, say, a MAGA Republican. Because regardless of our differences, a MAGA Republican and I both are completely anti-woke.
Whenever this topic comes up, I think of a (likely apocryphal - I've never once been able to find where the name actually came from) story about "heroin," that famously addicting opioid. The story goes that when heroin was invented, existing opioids had a bad reputation for being extremely addicting, and so the drug makers gave it a name that was a homonym of a word that meant a woman with brave and admirable qualities. Unfortunately, the intrinsic qualities of this drug - being extremely addicting, sometimes to great detriment to the user - made it so that the term "heroin" now mostly has negative connotations.
The terms "social justice warrior" and "woke" strike me as quite obviously positive terms when read literally, though I doubt they were purposefully engineered to be as such as in the above story. Perhaps the "warrior" part has some negative connotations about being violent, but being violent for the sake of justice is mostly seen as a good thing in most contexts. And "woke" is meant to invoke a sense of being "awake" in contrast to being "asleep," i.e. actually aware of the reality around them instead of blissfully ignorant in one's slumber.
However, inevitably, the intrinsic qualities of the ideas and people these labels were put upon won out, and so they became terms of insult.
The term "red pill" I think is an almost perfect mirror-image analogue to "woke" in the right-wing.
The concept of "lived experience" being that, when someone belonging to a demographic group that has been deemed oppressed claims something, it is to be believed without skepticism. Any sort of good-faith questioning or checking is deemed to be a form of oppression. This concept is repeated in many places, such as the "microaggression," which is, by definition, a behavior that the "microaggressor" doesn't perceive as being an aggression and is entirely up to the judgment of the "microaggressed upon" but which is still something that the potential "microaggressor" has the responsibility to avoid doing. There's also "believe women" and "believe all women," which are slogans designed specifically to push people away from applying basic good-faith skepticism to claims of fact when women make claims of specific sexual assault against individuals.
Of course, in practice it's impossible to apply this sort of thing in a consistent manner; if 2 different black people claim contradictory things to each other, then what do you do? In practice, it just means you have license to believe whoever is more convenient for your own social status and comfort while dismissing the other through various means (e.g. "internalized white supremacy"). And this sort of thing can lead to self-reinforcement, because by believing the right people, you can lead yourself to the conclusion that concepts like logical consistency and empirical science are themselves merely tools of the white supremacist patriarchy designed for the purpose of oppressing minorities; and it doesn't get much more anti-critical thinking than that.
First of all, I do think this post is pretty much just "why is my idiotic outgroup so idiotic as to believe in idiotic things?" and not the kind of thing I like seeing here, personally.
Second, I think the things you describe about biology-denial is common not just in "wokes" but in much of the general population as well. The wokes certainly are the most fervent believers in it and also one of the primary driving forces that push it onto the general populace, but they're by far not the only ones to buy into the denialism hook-line-sinker.
Third, I think the answer to your question is just that most people don't actually care to do the research into this stuff. Most people, wokes included, follow a sort of cargo-cult version of principles that happen to be convenient for them in the moment, not principles themselves. An example that comes to mind - because it was one of the first I noticed back in my SJW days - was wokes (perhaps proto-wokes? "Woke" wasn't nearly as common a term back then as it is now, and they were usually called SJWs) calling opinions they disagreed with "gross" as a way to denigrate them. It came as a shock to me, because those same individuals had spent the past decade denigrating the notion of objecting to something on the basis of personal disgust in the fight for gay rights and gay marriage. Yet there they were, objecting to something on the basis of personal disgust. It made me realize that they mistakenly believed they were principled; it wasn't that they believed in the principle of non-judgment on the basis of disgust while their conservative opponents didn't, it was that they just didn't find gay marriage disgusting and so had no issue with using such a principle as a convenient momentary tool with which to beat down their conservative opponents.
So when it comes to science and specifically the evolution of the human brain and human societies, they don't actually follow the principles of science to do the research into figuring out truths about the universe, they just think cheering really loudly for the banner that says "science" on it while pushing all the same ideas they already believe in is what it takes for them to be pro-science.
I don't think this is unique to wokes. It's perhaps particularly worse in them than many other ideologies, because woke-ism specifically has concepts designed to turn off critical thinking. But then again, that's not exactly unique to woke-ism either. It just happens to be the one that is acceptable to people who consider themselves pro-science through optimizing itself to have the most convincing, shiniest pseudo-academic/pseudoscientific veneer that hides the fact that it's all made of cardboard.
BIPOC is generally known to be an acronym for Black, Indigenous, and People of Color. Given that People of Color covers the 1st 2 anyway, it seems like there's an implicit "other" before "People," and it serves as a rank ordering.
I'm reminded of a couple of famous quotations.
"The Net interprets censorship as damage and routes around it"
-John Gilmore
"Life, uh, finds a way."
-Dr. Ian Malcolm
I've been doing a no-health-upgrades challenge run of Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice the past week. I've made it up to Genichiro (about 40% of the game) after about 8 hours, 3 of which were just stuck on the Blazing Bull. The only other Fromsoft game I played was Bloodborne, which I absolutely loved, and I beat both Bloodborne and Sekiro in their hardest difficulties (or rather, the highest NG+, which are 6 & 7 for them respectively), but I've yet to do a challenge run of this sort, and it's definitely quite something. The enemies may be tougher in NG+, but at least the longer health bar provides decent room for error in fights, whereas on a fresh playthrough with base HP, there's many more one-shot deaths. And having to find/farm upgrades along the way means less access to tactics for cheesing bosses. Only solution is just to get good and consistent enough at the basic deflection gameplay to get through every encounter. It's difficult but exactly the kind of thrill I was looking for when I decided to try this challenge.
Being a tech bro is also vastly higher status than most people working in tech. Most people working in tech aren't doing cutting edge innovation, they're debugging old code for some obscure system or programming some website that gets 2 hits a day or even just tech support. This whole thread is mostly just the apex fallacy, either comparing high status tech workers to average-status artists or high status artists to average-status tech workers in order to get the comparison that's favorable to one's particular narrative.
One related but not direct example of a man doing something like this would be Shaun King in the USA.
As I already stated, the technicalities of what constitutes "copying" or not are quite beside the point.
I mean, the whole subthread started from your comment:
but when they copy art on the other hand...
Which I guess you're walking back from with your further clarification in this post, I suppose.
Similar to how Microsoft can say "here are some free bits, just don't use them for enterprise software development", an artist should be able to say "here are some free bits, just don't use them to train an AI model". The fact that the artist's bits represent an image rather than a compiled binary doesn't seem like a relevant difference.
This is a good point, and I agree that the artist should be able to say that. Any artist who publishes their art somewhere where viewers agree to license that demands as such before viewing that artwork - much like Microsoft has the end user "sign" a license agreement at some point before running their free software - is on solid ethical (and legal I think, though IANAL) grounds to complain if someone uses it for AI art model training. Plenty of artists already do a similar thing with paid art on places like Patreon where the end user has to agree not to share the art with anyone else.
If they publish it on a public forum, then that's a different matter. They don't get to publish something publicly for free public consumption and demand that others don't view their art and take inspiration from them; that'd be having their cake and eating it too.
We asked white people to give up their segregated spaces to EVERYONE back in the day. Asking women to give up their spaces for trans women isn't asking them to give them up to EVERYONE, just an additional subset of people. A closer analogy would be if we asked categorically that no women-segregated - cis or trans - space ever exist.

Well, not out of seemingly nowhere, is it? Siri and other similar applications came out like a decade ago, and it's clear that both the industry and academia have been working on improving that sort of technology ever since.
More options
Context Copy link