@07mk's banner p

07mk


				

				

				
2 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 06 15:35:57 UTC

				

User ID: 868

07mk


				
				
				

				
2 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 06 15:35:57 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 868

If it is the case that such words really do have magical properties, then using them in front of impressionable children will demonstrate the magic - i.e. someone will mess your life up for using them - and children would notice that and learn of those magical properties. If using them doesn't result in such messing up happening, then it would demonstrate that, No, those words don't have magical properties, and there are contexts when they can be used without people messing you up. Impressionable children wouldn't necessarily pick up on those contexts, but I posit that (1) information about taboos around slurs is so plentiful anyway that watching/reading some adult use them has minimal impact and (2) children get much more leeway in breaking such taboos due to their natural lack of experience and maturity and learning the right contexts when to use such terms through experience and experimentation is part of growing up.

Even if we assume a uniform distribution, wouldn't it still be the case that the distribution of those you notice would still get sparser when you get towards "better at passing, but where I can still notice them?"

Like, imagine a toy model where there are 300 total MTF trans people, with 100 who are bad at passing, 100 who are better, and 100 who pass perfectly. You'll always notice the 1st 100, you'll notice the middle 100 about 50% of the time, and you'll never notice the last 100. By your observations, then, you'll notice 100 poorly-passing MTF and 50 better-passing MTF. Since the middle group is better-passing, you'll also notice that those 50 are qualitatively different - i.e. noticeably closer to actually passing - from the 100 in the 1st group, besides just noticing them only 50% of the time. But it would be wrong to conclude from this that then it follows that there are even fewer people in the 3rd group.

While I grant that I may be falling for the "passing tranny fallacy" (IE transwomen who pass don't get recognized as transwomen) pretty much every example of AI generated text and images I've encountered has struck me as painfully obvious. Whether it's GPT-x or DALL-y it's all very obviously not human, not even close, and thus I find myself wondering what all the furor is about.

First of all, I think sans some sort of blinded test, the "passing tranny fallacy" (or the "toupee fallacy" as I've more commonly seen it called) should be the default conclusion.

However, I do suspect that even if you did do a blinded test, you would find that you could tell better than chance. Presuming that you would, I think the furor is about the potential future, not the present. If we compare what AI generated images looked like in October 2021 and October 2022, the difference is stark. We can't extrapolate directly to October 2023 or 2030, but we do know with pretty good certainty that it will be no worse, and there's good reason to suspect that it will be better, and by a significant amount.

Which then raises the question to me, what do you mean by "not even close?" "Close [to human-made art]" is a subjective measure, of course, but is your opinion that AI art is currently just so far away from human-made art that the idea of it getting "close enough" to substitute human-made art in many significant contexts within the next 5-10 years is science fiction?

Sure, but impressions can go in many directions. Using terms like "n-word" or "f-slur" when "nigger" or "faggot" would be more appropriate can give impressionable children the false impression that these words (and possibly, slurs in the general sense) actually have magical properties that make uttering them cause harm or whatever.

The reasoning seems pretty simple to me. AI is an extremely powerful tool by which greatly reduces the effort involved in creating high quality art. Without it, people won't be literally "locked out," but the much higher barrier to entry and costs would mean that it would be immensely harder for independent creators to contribute high quality art at a meaningful level.

An analogy might be if only a select few megacorps had access to cameras. Independent creators could still learn to draw photorealistic drawings or perhaps hack together some sort of crude camera system, but compared to megacorps that can just have their employees snap a 20 Megapixel photo with their DSLRs, the quality and quantity of content independent creators could produce would be lower by a tremendous amount. In such a universe, the culture of photography and more generally photorealistic art would likely be dominated by megacorps.

FYI: I wasn't going to downvote your comment until I got to the EDIT part. Then I did, because any post that makes any references about its (or its author's) downvote status is one that I always downvote, regardless of the rest of the contents.

Anything from an uncreative tweet, a poorly conceived thought, an unlikely empowering experience, whatever is usually met with pats on the back snaps (sensory issues!) and good boys persons.

Analyzing a social phenomenon is one thing. Analyzing a strawman.

Is the quoted part supposed to be a strawman? As a leftist who used to hang out in a lot of leftist spaces, I find that to be a fairly accurate description of them the vast majority of the time. The only parts I would object to are the last parts about "snaps" and "good persons," since those specific phenomena accurately characterize only the most extreme versions of such spaces, but the thrust of the message seems 100% on point. It also happens to be one of the main reasons why I stopped hanging out in as many such spaces as much.

I'm a non-native English speaker as well, though I might as well be due to immigrating at a very early age, and I second this and will go even stronger: it doesn't matter if there are impressionable children around, because they don't need to be protected from encountering the pain of seeing a specific set of characters in a specific order. Letters placed or syllables pronounced in some specific order are not magical spells, and it is bad for adults to behave as if they were in front of impressionable children.

It isn't like "a better way to make cheesecake", where the AI is churning out industrial-recipe amounts in an industrial process. It's reducing creativity and imagination to a set of standard tropes for lowest common denominator appeal, like the production line of Marvel movies which, I think, people are beginning to get tired of because it's all too much and too the same

(Emphasis added). I'm not sure where the bolded part came from. What reason is there to believe that AIs would reduce creativity or imagination to a set of standard tropes for lowest common denominator appeal? Nothing about the actual process of the creation of art by AI would imply that. If we look at usage of AI in other fields like, say, go or chess, AI has been known to display creativity far beyond what the best humans have been known to come up with.

I think the deeper question is a feeling about how much the AI is actually creating art, and how much of it is just "it got trained on a zillion images and it's just cutting and pasting according to your prompts; you tell it you want a buxom blonde woman in a bikini sitting on a beach and it selects out of all the stored images of buxom blonde women, beaches, and bikinis and trims it as you refine your prompt".

If this is the deeper question, then it seems to come from just a fundamental misunderstanding of how AI art works. There's no cutting or pasting going on. Not unless you want to say that a human artist who develops his own personal style through observing pre-existing pieces of art and experimenting with what he can draw is just "cutting and pasting" from the images saved in his head from those observations.

EDIT: Unfortunately, this dropped the day after I wrote my post, so I didn't get a chance to comment on it originally. Based on continually accumulating evidence, I may have to retract my original prediction that opposition to AI art was going to be a more right-coded position. Perhaps there are not as many aesthetes in the dissident right as I thought.

I suspect that pro-/anti-AI art won't cleave neatly along existing ideological lines, but I do think for now, there's good reason to believe that pro-/anti- will be right/left respectively. The 2 dominant factors that would drive this are (1) most pre-existing artists are on the left and (2) AI art makes censorship tougher. Why (1) would lead those on the left to be against AI art has been expounded upon plenty in this very thread. For (2), when it comes to the most mainstream instantiations of art, i.e. pop culture, the dominant narrative for the past decade+ from the left has been that art that doesn't fit neatly within certain boundaries can cause literal harm to real humans and thus must be censored or at least censured in some meaningful way, for the prevention of harm to innocents. AI art - or more specifically easy access to AI art tools - would open up the floodgates to everyone being able to create art that is deemed harmful, in a way that our current censorship technology just couldn't keep up with.

I wonder if this will hold in the long run. There are plenty of leftist reasons to support AI art (e.g. more access to sophisticated art creation by people who otherwise would be unable to do so) and rightist reasons to be against it (e.g. traditional and/or religious reasons of being against degeneracy which AI art would enable like nothing before). It's just basically impossible to predict the way things will go when it comes to which subgroups within each tribe will win out.

It was indeed not Stross, at least I don't recall it being someone by that name. It was a tweet thread online by some woman I had never heard of before or since. It does seem that the concept was largely the same as that 3rd bullet point in the post you linked, though the Twitter thread I'd read expanded on it quite a bit more, including explicitly making the claim instead of the implausible-deniability-language of "Consider, for example, that a restricted diet stunts growth, and that average adult stature tracks food availability by a generation or three, and ask why men are, on average, taller than women" that tries unconvincingly to make a claim without taking responsibility for it. The fact that the thread was passed along approvingly within my circles is likely more a reflection of how niche and extreme my circles were than anything.

How do you underfeed the person who is doing the shopping and the cooking to begin with?

Internalized misogyny is a hell of a drug fully general explanation for any behavior by women that seem to go counter their interests.

I think the ugliness is a consequence of the implicit belief in the blank slate that underlies so many current progressive beliefs. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder, of course, but what if the judgment of every beholder is determined almost entirely by their oppressive social programming? Surely the only reason some things are considered beautiful and some aren't is the oppressive patriarchy programming our judgment that way. In order to break free from that, we must radically challenge that by celebrating things that the patriarchy considers ugly. We can deem them by fiat to be beautiful, just like how the cis white supremacist patriarchy deemed them by fiat to be ugly. There's little room to appeal to beauty when you believe that all judgments of beauty are merely instantiations of oppressive brainwashing.

I just finished listening to The Stand by Stephen King on Audible yesterday. Still not sure how much I like the climax and ending, but at least in terms of the characters and intrigue, along with the quality of the prose, I thought it was easily as good as everything I'd heard of it (which, TBH, wasn't much beyond that it was fantastic). It tickled me to learn that a miniseries adaptation of it had come out in 2020, given that the plot is about a superflu that nearly wipes out all of America and what happens to people both during and immediately after it runs its course. Even more amusing was learning that Amber Heard was in it, playing Nadine Cross, who was a less than fully mentally stable character in the book, to say the least.

I feel similarly about ultimate Frisbee, which I think has a similar phenomenon as tennis. At the top levels, most male players can throw the full length of the field, and there's more room for error in bad throws due to higher acceleration, jumping height, and top speed, which results what I would consider mostly boring points where whichever team starts with the disc scores without trouble the majority of the time. But even at the top levels, there's only a handful of women in the world who can consistently throw the full length of the field, and the greater likelihood of a turnover from bad throws means there's much more volatility in every point, with possession changes being much more common.

Man/lady were replaced with 'female-matching' and 'male-matching.'

Ultimate Frisbee? I'm still getting used to seeing "FMP" and "MMP" in team emails.

This is the part that's so weird to me. There's not really any plausible proposed mechanism there, just a handwave at generic oppression.

One proposed mechanism I saw online about 5 years ago was the claim that, throughout history, men underfed women in their patriarchal society, resulting in women being undernourished and thus weaker than men on average and in the extremes. It seemed to subscribe to a Lamarkian-esque view of evolution except descent along sex instead of actual parentage, and also seemed pretty ahistorical with respect to the level of nutrition people used to get in the past. I wish I had saved it somewhere, because it was a really fascinating and deranged idea, and I recall it being passed around approvingly within my circles.

Many academics posit that the concept of mammalian sexual dimorphism is a conspiracy of straight white men to oppress everyone else.

I don't think "conspiracy" is the right term for what they're positing. They don't believe in some smokey room where all the old straight cis men gather around to coordinate how to socially engineer everyone else to their liking. It's rather an emergent phenomenon in society that is downstream from all the old straight cis men oppressing everyone else. The upshot is that they get to claim vast nefariousness akin to a conspiracy but also get to stay strong in their views when all the evidence indicates that there's no actual men in smokey rooms coordinating anything of the sort. It really is an innovative worldview that has just enough layers of obfuscation to be acceptable to people who consider themselves intellectual while also retaining the passion and fervor that grand conspiracy theories can inculcate in true believers.

And notably, this phenomenon itself seems to be an emergent one, rather than the result of a bunch of power-hungry "academics" coordinating with each other to produce the ideology with the perfect combination of contagiousness and fervor for their audience. Rather, I think it's the result of simple evolution, as similar ideologies that were too conspiracy-minded or not totalizing enough got weeded out, leaving behind the highly optimized ideology that has been so successful in taking over so many institutions today.

Yes. Given how easy it is for someone to die just by hitting their head on the ground from a simple fall, if someone's rushing you with clear intent to harm, then that means either they've decided that your life is forfeit or that they've recklessly disregarded the value of you staying alive. Either way, this entitles you to defend yourself with deadly force in my view. Obviously kids should be arrested and punished for blowing up someone else's property, but getting your property blown up doesn't entitle you to carry out that punishment yourself.

The following is only glancingly related to this top-post, but I didn't want to make a top-post itself, and I'm also curious how it relates to Canadian polarization:

I stumbled on this article today about how "special consideration for Indigenous people accused of crime can be extended beyond sentencing into the trials themselves to reduce the effects of discrimination and disadvantage, Ontario’s top court has ruled." The specific case involves an indigenous person who shot and killed someone and the judge during the trial preventing parts (not all) of the defendant's criminal history from being told to jurors. According to the article, the defendant when requesting this made this argument on the basis that "because he was Indigenous and from a deeply disadvantaged background, special considerations should apply to what the jury could be told," which is something with precedent in the Canadian legal system, just not for this specific type of thing. The Ontario Court of Appeal which upheld this decision (the upholding being the actual topic of this article), stated "Trial judges must take notice of the fact that Indigenous people are often the objects of racism outside and inside the criminal justice system" as part of their reasoning.

As an aside, for this specific homicide, based on the description in this article, it seems to me that the acquittal was the correct decision; armed or not, if the person who was killed was running after the killer with clear intent to harm him, then the killer had every right to defend himself with deadly force. There are grey areas that different people can hold different opinions on depending on if the killer started the altercation or the person who was killed did, but it's my personal opinion that that doesn't matter if the killer was running away as described. As such, I don't know that this decision by the judge had impact on the jury's decision.

But more to the point, I'm wondering if anyone is familiar enough with the Canadian criminal justice system to say what, if anything, would be the outcome of this. This seems to give responsibility and a lot of power to judges to determine how to properly counter the racism Indigenous people face all throughout their lives in order to produce a fair process. Which I wouldn't think that judges are particularly qualified to do, but then again, they're judges for a reason, and it looks like it was already their responsibility to begin with; this just expands the scope of it. Is this sort of thing just "baked in" to Canadian politics, and will the various parties in the Canadian CW just not take notice?

And as an American, I'm curious if anyone knows enough of the differences between the American and Canadian legal systems to say the likelihood of this kind of thing being implemented in the US. Clearly the laws and legal history and the constitutions are very different, and currently there is no such explicit instruction to American judges to provide special treatment to individuals on the basis of the history of the demographic groups - but not of those individuals - to which they belong. But the philosophical principles behind the decision clearly exist in both Canada and the US, and certainly we see the exact same type of thing happen all the time in the US in non-criminal contexts (e.g. school admissions). Indigenous people seem to have a special spot in Canadian society in a way that Native Americans in the US don't, but in the US black people have a special spot due to its history with slavery and anti-black racism. Native Americans have various legal carve-outs in US law, but I'm not aware of any for blacks, and I'm not aware of any for anyone when it comes to criminal justice. Is it reasonably likely that, say, 20 years from now, the US criminal justice system will have standards for the judge to treat defendants differently based purely on the defendant's ethnicity/race/etc.? Again, the principles that led to this decision in Canada are about equally popular and powerful in America, so it seems possible if the proponents of those principles have their way, but I'm wondering how any sort of pushback in the American system might differ from the Canadian one.

OK, I'm genuinely curious then: if, say, during pre-Civil Rights America some black constituents complained to their mayor about the segregation at the public pool and the mayor decided to prioritize his white constituents' desires not to interact with blacks over the black constituents' desires to use those pool facilities, then black constituents have no grounds to complain that the mayor is not representing black constituents? It seems that, from your posts here, that by your lights, the answer is absolutely Yes, there is no way to state that this mayor is being unrepresentative of black constituents, only that he's poorly representing them. Which then would raise the question: what is the meaningful difference, by your lights, between being unrepresented and being poorly represented, where the rubber meets the road, i.e. actual impactful policy changes implemented by those in power?

I don't think it is. For example, if a white constituent approached her with concerns, I don't think she would summarily ignore them because that person is white. She may choose to prioritize other constituents above them, but that's something all representatives have to decide on how to prioritize.

If this is the standard, it seems like every politician in the US can be said to represent all races, genders, sexuality, etc. I posit that being poorly represented, i.e. one's interest deprioritized based purely on one's race (or gender or sexuality or etc), is sufficiently close to being unrepresented in this particular context that you really can't split that hair.

Q has embraced all conspiracy theories. It is the platonic embodiment of Conspiracy Theory. And like all conspiracy theories, really, what it means is that the people have decided authority can't be trusted.

From what I learned about conspiracy theories and theorists before QAnon was a thing, this seems like something that's just common to all/most conspiracy theories. Conspiracy theories seem to be very highly correlated, so that if someone buys into moon landing fakery, then they're also much more likely than the typical person to believe in Big Foot and/or flat Earthism and/or lizardmen rulers from outer space, etc. and vice versa. As if there's some sort of generic, say, c-factor in humans that predicts their likelihood to buy into conspiracy theories, and the specific conspiracy theory doesn't matter much. Perhaps QAnon is just the current in thing among conspiracy theorists that caught fire due to circumstance.

IANAL, but what laws would you expect to be in the books that that would violate?

However, the actual principles behind self-defense will include phrases like "reasonable belief." What is reasonable? Different people could disagree. One person might say that if you are a minor, and an adult is running after you, yelling at you, and throwing things at you, that you reasonably believe they are trying to (and able to) harm you, while another might say that isn't a reasonable belief. Or the law will contain terms like "reasonable means to escape." Again, what is reasonable?

Indeed, but none of this seems conservative to me. Just knowing basic scientific facts about biology and physics, my conclusion is that the video I saw of Rittenhouse shooting and killing someone was an example of self-defense in the face of aggressors aggressing upon someone who was holding a loaded weapon. What about this is specifically conservative?