That's a fair point, and I was erroneous when I wrote "beyond a reasonable doubt" there. Rather, what I should have written was that the evidence led the jury to conclude that, by the criminal justice system's standards, Rittenhouse's actions were a response against aggressors by someone holding a loaded weapon.
I am an American, and honestly, I don't think there's a way to tell. I don't know of any polls trying to measure this stuff, and even if there were, their accuracy would be quite questionable given the lizardman constant. From my own personal experience, I don't know of anyone who buys into QAnon, but that's 99.9999% a function of the insularity and polarization of where I live, which is basically filled with and run by people I would consider to have QAnon-like beliefs in terms of epistemic rigor, but has no actual QAnon believers AFAICT.
Given the patterns of progressives and the lesson many of us learned from The Boy Who Cried Wolf, gun to my head I would guess this is just the umpteenth example of a tiny, inconsequential portion of the population being blown up like the boogeyman for a politically convenient narrative. But that guess of mine is itself a politically convenient narrative, so should be taken with at least one ocean's worth of salt.
So, any acquittal on self-defense grounds says little about what the jury thought of the defendant, and certainly is not an indication that they decided that he was the "real victim" nor that the decedent was the "real bad guy."
The post to which you're replying was quoting a part that was referring to:
they were aggressors who happened to aggress someone holding a loaded weapon.
Which is different from any statement about who's a "real victim" or the "real bad guy." Given that the jury decided that the prosecutors were unable to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that Rittenhouse did not act in self defense, it seems reasonable to conclude that all the evidence they saw led them to conclude that, beyond a reasonable doubt, Rittenhouse's actions were a response against aggressors by someone holding a loaded weapon.
From the conservative perspective, they were aggressors who happened to aggress someone holding a loaded weapon.
I find this a strange statement. What about this is particular to the conservative perspective? I wasn't under the impression that someone's perception of the physics of an altercation was all that defined by someone's political perspective. E.g. I'm not a conservative, and having watched a video of the encounter, from my perspective, they were aggressors who happened to aggress (upon) someone holding a loaded weapon.
Maybe I’m misunderstanding what a dogwhistle is but if I wrote on here “the rootless cosmopolitan bankers are conspiring against white christians” everyone would understand it’s an antisemitic dogwhistle.
It does sound like you're misunderstanding what a dogwhistle is. If everyone would understand that it means something else, then, by definition, it cannot be a dogwhistle.
Of course, imperfect dogwhistles can exist, as can dogwhistles that no longer work due to information spread (at which point it is no longer a dogwhistle).
I figured it would just take a long time but eventually get full, but is there some equivalent to "water pressure" where it takes more work to get that last 10% in?
This is basically correct. Same reason that quick charge batteries in phones can charge the 1st 60% in like 15 minutes but the remaining 40% take hours. To charge the battery, you need a voltage difference between the charge source and the battery, and that difference gets smaller the more the battery gets charged.
OK, so it sounds like based on this post that when you wrote:
Does it require discriminating against anyone?
about a theoretical generative AI model based around a world that could be (instead of the world as is), you were making a general statement about how no generative AI model could possibly discriminate against someone. Which seems like a strange thing to say about 1 specific type of generative AI model (i.e. based on a world that could be) when discussing 2 different theoretical types of models that are both generative (i.e. the other one being based on the world as it is), but technically true, I suppose.
Yes, but this conversation isn't about an AI that explains things to blind people or summarizes news articles or generates sport news from the match records or whatever. It's about a piece of software that generates rap lyrics about tough black life in the hood while throwing about the word nigga. That specific piece of software - as in, the software that generates those rap lyrics because it has been trained - is a bunch of maths. In my hypothetical, "they" want to "cancel" that. No, they don't want to "cancel" the entire notion of training AI to do stuff (which would also be a type of "canceling" a bunch of maths). They want to "cancel" one particular instantiation of that concept, which is itself a bunch of maths. They don't want anyone using that specific piece of software that generates rap lyrics - i.e. a bunch of maths.
If I oppose you shooting a bunch of cannon balls at my house, I'm not canceling ballistics, I'm canceling your use of ballistics in this particular way.
This isn't analogous to the actual situation in any way, though. It's more akin to you opposing anyone shooting any cannons at any direction. In which case it'd be fairly appropriate to claim that you are canceling ballistics.
The software that generates rap lyrics is a bunch of maths. More specifically, it's an algorithm that takes some set of inputs (I'm guessing some sets of strings and some random numbers?) and produces some set of outputs (in the form of a string of lyrics). It's a bunch of maths much like how the proof that the square root of 2 is irrational is a bunch of maths. In my hypothetical "what-if" scenario that we are talking about, the "cancelers" have a problem with this bunch of maths being used whatsoever, regardless of the characteristics of the individuals involved in creating or running the rap-generation software. This is accurately described as "canceling a bunch of maths," rather than the social context around the usage of such.
So by your lights, what would it take for a generative AI model to be discriminatory against someone? An "AI that does everything like DALL-E except it doesn't need prompt engineering to make 'diverse' pictures" would necessarily involve discriminating against someone when creating the training set; if no such discrimination were required, then the 2 models would be identical. You seem to be saying that that doesn't count. So what would count?
But it's strawmanning them to pretend that they are simply arbitrarily canceling a bunch of math. They are canceling the building of software tools that impersonate black rappers, as a legitimate endeavor out of quasi religious reasons.
No, that's not a strawman, that's a description. By your reasoning, the concept of "canceling a bunch of math" simply doesn't seem to exist; if I decided that "2+2=4" is blasphemous and demanded that all books and teachers making such statements be "canceled," I wouldn't be "canceling a bunch of math," but rather, say, "canceling the expression of certain mathematical equations out of quasi religious reasons." Mathematical equations and algorithms - whether they state some arithmetic fact or they allow the creation of some string of letters that some people find meaningful - aren't just lying around for people to discover; they are expressed and created by humans. Objecting to people expressing and creating such things is exactly what is described when something is described as "canceling a bunch of math."
A model with no anti-bias applied will consider men by by default to be extremely likely offenders, especially for violent crime. It is likely that any model can get a good training score by just looking at the gender and ethnicity, and if it's e.g. an Asian woman just let her off the hook immediately.
This effect will be sufficiently extreme to get noticed, and counteracted, by adding bias in favour of men or against those women
And this is where I think you're missing the point. Perhaps the effect will be sufficiently extreme to get noticed; extreme discrepancies refuse to get noticed all the time depending on political expediency, but this could be one of those that does get noticed. It doesn't follow that there will be any desire to counteract this by people who tend to push for de-biasing such algorithms for the purpose of demographic-based justice.
Also, I don't know how to square your above explanation with:
I am not claiming that society will demand AI models that necessarily treat men more fairly than we do today!
Today, people notice that human-based sentencing systems are "biased" against men in the sense that men and women with equivalent records and crimes get sentenced very differently, with men getting more harsh sentences. People evidently have no issue with this apparent "bias" regardless of whatever lip-service they might pay.
You seem to be claiming that people will notice that AI-driven sentencing systems are "biased" against men in the sense that men and women with equivalent records and crimes get sentenced very differently, with men getting more harsh sentences, and that people noticing this will want to counteract that "bias" by putting their thumb on the scale in favor of men in these AI models. This seems to me to be similar to society demanding that AI models treat men more "fairly" than we do today.
Pretty clear to me that the analogy you deployed was deliberately absurd.
Yes, that was the point of the analogy. Your own reasoning requires that the absurd model I described as "not discriminating against anyone." If you want to describe your theoretical uniform distribution model as "not discriminating against anyone" but my absurd one as "discriminating against someone," you can't have to rely on something other than "this isn't actual people I'm failing to generate or generating excessively" to justify your theoretical uniform distribution model.
But anyway, provided that you clearly label your Pro-White-Women, Anti-Black-Men model as such, go ahead.
Well, I don't need your permission to deploy such a model, and I wasn't looking for it from you or anyone else. I was merely demonstrating one necessary conclusion from your line of reasoning, by describing a theoretical and intentionally absurd model.
I wonder if they would be okay with it if it (the rapper AI) was operated by black people. If yes, then it's not merely about the AI as an object or the math. You have to argue (and I don't think it's hard) that blacks don't have a monopoly on rap, it's not enough to say "hurr durr it's just math".
So I didn't pay much attention to this controversy, mostly out of lack of interest, but also partly out of unfortunate paucity of coverage, but I think the main issue the "cancelers" had with the AI was that it was generating lyrics implying some sort of personal struggle as a black man facing police brutality, and also possibly using certain slurs that are common in rap songs produced by black people. I'm not sure if the "cancelers" would be okay with the AI if it had been operated by black people, or if they would require that the AI also be written by black people. And if the latter, does it have to be written from scratch with no use of, say, open source code created by white or Asian researchers?
Or would even that not be enough, and the mere fact that it's a computer generating these lyrics instead of a human brain belonging to a black man who had actually suffered police brutality generating them is a problem? If so, it seems reasonable to characterize that as people "canceling a pile of math;" however, it's not clear to me that this is so.
Do you really think your example is as egregious as generating perfectly uniform selections for both "good person" and "bad person" (or "criminal" and "Harvard student", for that matter)?
What does being egregious have to do with this in any way? As you wrote, either way, "it's not the Harvard auditions, and this isn't actual people I'm failing to generate or generating excessively." Given that the reason that perfectly uniform selections isn't discrimination has literally nothing to do with the type of distribution and everything to do with the fact that these are generated images rather than actual people, we can change the distribution to anything we want (including my example of encoding "good person" with "white woman" and "bad person" with "black man") and still land at the same result of "no discrimination is taking place."
If my model generates pictures of people from an even ethnic spectrum, I do not believe I am discriminating against anyone. It's not the Harvard auditions, and this isn't actual people I'm failing to generate or generating excessively.
By this logic, then no model is discriminating against anyone. If a model only ever returns white women for "good person" and black men for "bad person," then that's not discriminating against anyone since it's not the Harvard auditions, and this isn't actual people you're failing to generate or generating excessively. Great, looks like we can associate any race with any quality we want in our model and not worry about discriminating against anyone!
If I'm a designer using a generative AI to fill a world of my making, I do not care for "accurate" demographic representation being baked in the model.
Indeed, and notably no one seems to have any problem with such models existing. There's room for multiple types of generative AI models in this world, including ones that have uniform distributions, desired distributions, best-attempt-at-accurate distributions, or really any other arbitrary distributions of demographics.
I don't think I am. I agree that a naïvely de-biased crime model will favour blacks over whites compared to a model that just went for simple accuracy and nothing else, but men will also necessarily similarly have to be favoured. If not, people are immediately going to notice the model convicting men and freeing women even when the facts are identical. There is absolutely no way people are going to accept that; radical anti-racist ideology isn't that powerful.
People have already noticed this IRL and people already accept it just fine, no radical anti-racist ideology needed. It's just the reality of the situation, sans any sort of ideology, that this sort of bias is fully and openly accepted.
But to the actual point of the thread, I think you are missing the point. I don't think sulla is describing a crime model that's de-biased "naively," but rather one that's de-biased in the most likely way that it is to be de-biased, which is by explicitly putting the thumb on the scale against disfavored groups such as whites and men. A universe in which real de-biasing efforts implemented by real institutions tend to follow some "naive" implementation rather than a politically convenient one seems like a neat universe to live in, I imagine.
But this suggests another strategy: don’t train it on the world as it appears to be. Train it on the world that could be.
Is creating such training data trivial? No. Does it require discriminating against anyone? Also no. Seems like a decent idea to me.
Presuming that this theoretical "world that could be" is at all different from the "world as it appears to be", it absolutely requires discriminating against someone. There's just no way to bridge that difference without applying some discrimination against someone at some point in the process; otherwise we'd just end up back where we started.
Wakko's America is a good one too.
No, I think you were incorrect when you wrote "it's just that almost all trans are diametrically opposed to more core values that this forum holds." I don't think it's the case that almost all trans are diametrically opposed to this forum's core values. I think it's the case that almost all trans activists are diametrically opposed to those, and also that trans activists try to give the (unsupported) impression that trans people in general have some meaningful level of agreement with trans activists.
I don't think the forum is anti-trans in principle; it's just that almost all trans are diametrically opposed to more core values that this forum holds.
I don't think this is quite right, actually. People in this forum being "anti-trans" is really only true to the extent that they are against the demands of self-proclaimed pro-trans activists. In terms of the literal meanings of the terms "anti" and "trans," this forum is pretty full of people who aren't anti-trans. Rather, it has to do with opinions specifically about the demands of self-proclaimed pro-trans activists. Obviously this is an easy equivocation to make by accident just because of the literal words involved; my belief is that this type of equivocation is encouraged - and likely even believed in - by the self-proclaimed pro-trans activists; more people believing in the unsupported notion that these activists are speaking on behalf of the actual trans population lends them greater credibility.
I have noticed the analogy, which is part of why I’m slightly surprised that this forum is so pro-AI.
The analogy doesn't quite fit for where the rubber meets the road, does it? When it comes to deeming something created by Midjourney "real art," what does that actually involve for the individuals involved? Nothing, really; a particular arrangement of pixels being "real art" or not is mainly a metaphysical question that doesn't interact with our physical reality to much of an extent. At the end of the day, the arrangement of pixels is the arrangement of pixels, and people will continue to use that arrangement of pixels for things that arrangement of pixels are good at doing, regardless of whether we consider it "real art" or not.
When it comes to deeming a transwoman a "real woman," what does that actually involve for the individuals involved? It means, among other things, having some sort of enforcement regime by which people talking about the transwoman are limited in the terms they can use. It's not just a metaphysical question that people can make an invisible mental categorization as they wish and go about their day; it's a physical question with physical consequences that differ greatly depending on the categorization.
The moral (or rather, social) panic I see isn't about romance novels, but rather about the failure of men as a class to not produce enough of them that meet the expectations of women who want a Mr. Right who's rich, hot, tall, gentle, and a vampire. The analogue for porn would be if there were a moral panic about not enough women being young, attractive, sexually open and skilled nymphoniacs. It's just identifying the societal problem at different parts; for unrealistic expectations set by romance novels, the "panic" is around the failure of men to achieve them, while for unrealistic expectations set by porn, the "panic" is around men consuming and being influenced by them.
I feel like this pattern is borne out among my friends and acquaintances too. I'm in my 30s, and I know quite a few women who have had serious mental health crises (usually associated with high stress jobs, especially in combination with parenting), whereas my male friends have mostly thrived, and now are happily ensconced in their careers and having kids. Quite a few of them had rocky spells in their 20s, but that's a normal part of growing up, especially for men where risk-taking is more common.
I don't understand why people use this sort of heuristic when talking about something like this. By definition, one's friends and acquaintances are the types of people who have friends and acquaintances. The men with porn addictions so severe they "blow up their lives" are ones who have very few to none of those things. Given that, the odds are very good that your perception of the prevalence of such people based on your observation of friends and acquaintances is lower than the true prevalence.
Your other points about lack of evidence has some value, but this one about your own experience with your friends and acquaintances doesn't, and the fact that you seem to be informing your view based in part on this is troublesome.

I had thought that the drama was dead and zombified rather than buried, but perhaps it really is buried by now, from seeing this news about Chick-fil-A opening in Boston last year, 9 years after Boston's mayor had publicly announced that Chick-fil-A would be kept out of Boston specifically for their perceived anti-gay politics.
More options
Context Copy link