Amadan
More equal than others
No bio...
User ID: 297
You've gone to a lot of trouble in this thread to insinuate that people who want US aid to Israel cut just hate Jews.
No.
I said I want to cut US aid to Israel.
There's always been a tension between "opposes Israel" and "hates Jews." I've long found it frustrating that many (usually Jewish) pro-Israel people will go straight to accusations of antisemitism when anyone criticizes Israel. Often this is disingenuous. But often it is not. And increasingly I am sympathetic to a suspicion that opposition to Israel is motivated by antisemitism. I think this suspicion is well-founded when you notice people not applying the same standards anywhere else. I've seen white nationalists who normally despise Muslims in particular whose hearts suddenly bleed for the plight of Palestinians and Iranians.
It is plausible that someone believes supporting Ukraine is in our national interests and supporting Israel is not. I start to have doubts when their concern stops at Israel (because countries listed lower on the list don't matter, but surely if we cut aid to Israel then they'd start worrying about Jordan and Ethiopia?).
It's not "everyone." But my priors, admittedly, have shifted from "some" to "most."
Why does it have to be more money than we give to Israel? If I think we should cut/reduce aid to a lot of countries, and Israel happens to be at the top of that list, I assert that my reasoning is consistent. I claim that people who only talk about cutting aid to Israel did not pick the top country on the list as "the biggest fish to fry first." I claim that if Israel were #2 or #3 or #7 on the list, most such critics would still be making the most noise about Israel.
Indeed, right now Ukraine is the #1 recipient of foreign aid, depending on how you count the money. Some of the same people against Israeli aid are also against support to Ukraine, but not all, and mostly for political reasons, not because they counted numbers.
You were more than mildly condescending. You were both being dicks. I've already told you we're not measuring who generated more particles of offense, though I will certainly agree that in this case, the other person did. The other person also had a very long history of good participation, for which that outburst was notably out of character, whereas you have a... more mixed history in which your loss of composure was not out of character. So you both got a timeout because we are not Lady Justice carefully balancing the scales. We are jannies trying to clean up messes and stop a slapfight from escalating. You've already said you don't want a rebanning or anything of the sort, so at this point I gather you want one of the following:
a) A formal apology and an admission of wrongdoing. This will not happen; you are not owed an apology and no wrong was done to you.
b) For the mods to reconsider how we moderate and make some sort of change so... whatever you think happened to you won't happen again. Naraburns already answered you there; also not happening.
c) To continuously gripe every time the subject comes up because you can't let it go. You are free to do this. You aren't the only one with a long-running gripe about moderation, and sometimes about very specific moderation decisions that still cause the angels in heaven to cry for justice to be done. What I can tell you is that the people who do this wind up no longer being taken seriously (including their reports) because they demonstrate themselves to be obsessive pests and bad faith critics. So I won't tell you to stop complaining. I will only tell you that it is unlikely to benefit you, unless the complaining itself is the benefit.
- Prev
- Next

I never accused you of anything.
Jordan is basically as stable and reliable a partner as we get in the Arab world. So it's in our interests to incentivize that and help keep them stable.
More options
Context Copy link