@Amadan's banner p

Amadan

More equal than others

11 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 00:23:21 UTC

				

User ID: 297

Amadan

More equal than others

11 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 00:23:21 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 297

You were more than mildly condescending. You were both being dicks. I've already told you we're not measuring who generated more particles of offense, though I will certainly agree that in this case, the other person did. The other person also had a very long history of good participation, for which that outburst was notably out of character, whereas you have a... more mixed history in which your loss of composure was not out of character. So you both got a timeout because we are not Lady Justice carefully balancing the scales. We are jannies trying to clean up messes and stop a slapfight from escalating. You've already said you don't want a rebanning or anything of the sort, so at this point I gather you want one of the following:

a) A formal apology and an admission of wrongdoing. This will not happen; you are not owed an apology and no wrong was done to you.

b) For the mods to reconsider how we moderate and make some sort of change so... whatever you think happened to you won't happen again. Naraburns already answered you there; also not happening.

c) To continuously gripe every time the subject comes up because you can't let it go. You are free to do this. You aren't the only one with a long-running gripe about moderation, and sometimes about very specific moderation decisions that still cause the angels in heaven to cry for justice to be done. What I can tell you is that the people who do this wind up no longer being taken seriously (including their reports) because they demonstrate themselves to be obsessive pests and bad faith critics. So I won't tell you to stop complaining. I will only tell you that it is unlikely to benefit you, unless the complaining itself is the benefit.

But that is just veiled ad hominem, and it's spoiling the discussion.

Well, it's spoiling the discussion you want to have. But as I have already told you, you don't get to direct what people want to talk about or how they will respond to you.

You and @FtttG are both reporting each other for "antagonism." It's annoying. This conversation seems largely unproductive, but I really wish people would stop thinking "This person annoys me and is arguing with me and is bad, therefore I will report him for being antagonistic." Stop being a bunch of Karens. If you jump into a fight, don't complain of the wounds.

If you push it, though, here is my take: you are being condescending and insulting, implying in many ways as you can without saying it outright that you think your interlocutor is stupid and wasting your time. We just had another thread where two people were being snippy with each other and both got timeouts. I am not guaranteeing that will happen here. What will happen here is if we have to step in, we will look at both users' respective histories, and the context of the conversation, and the actual words they are using with each other.

I recommend you make course corrections accordingly.

Another example would be that this is an end result of cognitive dissonance. A person who thinks of themselves as open and fair minded with regards to all opinions will feel emotional confusion if they feel a dislike for someone based on their views alone, since that's exactly what they fashion themselves not being. So they seek justification for their dislike. Which manifests itself in all sort of curious ways. It's not that they dislike them for their views, no, It's everything else about them that's the problem!

It's not that complicated. Your theory of mind is entirely wrong.

I can't speak for other mods, but I absolutely dislike some people, and won't deny it for a second. I don't need to find reasons to justify my dislike of people. My reasons are usually pretty straightforward.

It's not just the Joo-posters, I assure you. There are definitely people who, when they show up in the mod queue, I think "This fucking guy again." If anything, this makes me more likely to go easy on modding them. I'm quite aware that mods can easily fall into the temptation of looking for excuses to ban someone they really want to ban. I suffer no cognitive dissonance; I know when I am itching to ban someone, and I audit myself very carefully at such times, and when necessary, defer to other mods.

Apparently I am really bad at finding excuses to ban people since there are so many people I have not banned.

but I do not believe that someone on this forum could post the things I noted here, only swapped out for jews, and not get a mod asking them what's up. Even if just to ask them to cool down.

Mostly, you are wrong. In some cases, I read those posts and tried to do a mental substitution of "Israel/Jews" for "Hamas/Palestinians" and thought, "Yeah, maybe." I know I have at least a couple of times modded people who outright called Palestinians subhuman. So, did you ever actually report any of those posts? If so, why that person didn't get modded could vary for a lot of reasons, none of which I am going to relitigate on a case-by-case basis because we're already covered all the many reasons why the mods might not act precisely according to your desired calibration, but the one reason it is not is because we have a "visceral negative reactions to critique levied against groups our societies have lionized as sacred" (i.e., we all twitch when Jews are criticized).

You think, and care, about Jews far, far more than any of us do.

No Cartesian Daemon fucking with our ability to do logic and philosophy.

Yeah, I basically gave up on arguing with philosophers (sorry, @naraburns!) after an extremely frustrating exchange in which a philosopher (actual Ph.D. in philosophy) would not stop answering every claim I made about what we can observe or think we know about reality with basically: How do you know God/Cartesian demons/the Matrix aren't fucking with you so you only think you know things? Well, fuck, I guess philosophy is pointless if we can't possibly make any statements about reality because we can't prove we're not living in a simulation.

I did read the thread, and I didn't say you behaved "equally" terribly. I decided you were both being unnecessarily antagonistic and needed to step away.

Everything else is asking me to judge fine gradations of offense. No, you are not being held to a higher standard. Both of you need to chill.

It wasn't the "Ok buddy" or the "Excuse me?" that earned you a timeout. You both got modded in the context both of how you are talking to each other and your respective histories.

It looks to me like you're both getting unnecessarily heated and insulting. No mod want to go through a thread and measure how many insult-units each poster scored and when to achieve "symetricality."

If you think @georgioz is being a jerk and you can't respond without getting pissed off, back off. What do you want, for me to reban him for longer so you feel justice has been done? We don't automatically assume two people fighting are equally guilty, but two people fighting and both being nasty about it, like I said, doesn't require a careful weighing and measuring of who's being the biggest ass. So both of you either chill out or continue at your peril.