Think of it this way, imagine two universes where life exists every 100,000 planets and one where life exists every 100 sextillion planets. Life in both universes before contact makes the same observations, that "we exist therefore other life could exist". The beings that exist on all of them no matter the probability have the exact same logic they can use. And if all universes (both likely, unlikely, and everything else) have the same exact observation, then you can not actually tell the likelihood of other life based on that.
Well, maybe. But consider a few counterarguments.
- In general, if you personally see something happen, you shouldn't think that it's fantastically unlikely. Maybe it was, but it's more likely that you saw something relatively common.
- As far as we can tell, life is just a normal physical-chemical reaction. There's no magical "chemical X." We are mostly just bags of water with some amino acids, which are built from common elements.
- Life on Earth developed quickly, just a few hundred million years after the planet cooled down enough to have liquid water. If life is really so rare, that's one hell of a coincidence!
- The universe, overall, is still relatively young. So what a coincidence it is if we were literally the first life to ever develop! We must be truly blessed.
I feel like that's a bad joke, which is also kind of insulting to the many, very brilliant people working on things like SETI or Project Blue Book, who did a lot more than just "put out a sign in front of their house."
Sure, that's one way to look at it. But the other way is to just focus on the raw number. 13.8 billion years is a long time! And even if you ignore the early universe and just focus on type 1 stars like our sun, that still gives like 8-10 billion years. And since humans have only had modern tech for like, 100-200 years, it's not hard to imagine that something could have gotten there slightly sooner.
For what it's worth, I think both of these ways of thinking are equally valid. Hence the paradox.
It's not supposed to generate an answer. The point of it is more to list all the different factors that we need to research, and hopefully boost research in those areas. Which it did! In Drake's time, we had no idea how many other stars had planets. Now we've got a lot of research into explanets, and maybe someday soon the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Habitable_Worlds_Observatory designed specifically to look for them. We also have a lot more information on star formation and planetary atmospheres than we did in Drake's time.
I've heard that before, that they think it's an easy way to just add an extra tag. But doesn't it also detract? Like, a lot of people are going to be sketched out by that, even if it's just thrown in for a few lines. It seems like an extremely weird niche that for some reason they all went for.
So that's start, twice in 2000 years? Seems like a pretty decent track record, overall.
Sorry man. I was once in a bad marriage myself. Eventually got divorced. You have my deapest sympathies.
Maybe not Jack Ma, but I'll bet the CIA could crack this guy: https://fortune.com/article/chinese-billionaire-xu-bo-fathered-100-children-dozens-us-born-take-over-business/
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Sure but that's what I'd call "normal human temptation." We can resist that. But china has a billion people, and state resources to push them at us. That's not just "take your marriage vows seriously," that's "pray to God to save you from the temptations of Satan."
Sometimes i think I'm the only nerd on the internet who actually believes that the Fermi paradox is a good paradox. Maybe because I've actually read the papers by [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hart%E2%80%93Tipler_conjecture](tipler and hart) who lay out the argument in detail, as opposed to Fermi who just... speculated about it over lunch one day it seems? But since then, every nerd on the internet wants to be "smarter than Fermu" so they lay out their totally original shower thought for how "space is big" or "maybe aliens are all different from humans", with zero awareness of the counter arguments that people have been making since the 70s.
One such argument: stars move. You dont necessarily have to travel at all. If you can wait a few hundred million years (and Earth is 6 billion years old), you can just sit and wait for other stars to come to you. Perhaps accidentally, in the case of panspermia.
So, I'm mostly just seeing a lot of jokes and memes about this. Which, understandable, it's a juicy scandal.
But one semi serious response that I saw on Twitter got me thinking. Is this just an inherent weakness in all men? An unpatchable security flaw? We're already vulnerable to just normal human temptation. What are we supposed to do when foreign governments target us with professional seductresses? Should all men in critical positions get castrated for national security?
Is it still a military success if Congress defunds the war Vietnam style?
We could be headed for an interesting constitutional crisis if that happens. The original intent of the Constitution seems to have been that Congress was in charge of when wars start and stop. But the practice for the past 80 years has been that the President has de facto control, since he can just send off the military to fight whenever he wants without declaring war. They've tried to reign that in with the War Powers Resolution limiting it to 90 days, but Trump got around that in Iran by doing a brief cease fire and declaring to then be the start of a new action.
So I'm not actually sure what happens if Congress cuts all funding, but Trump orders the troops to keep fighting anyway. I guess they just don't get paid? It's not like they can go on strike in the middle of an active war zone.
I just think Trump is too old now. He used to sort of break the rules of conventional politics, and get away with a lot because he was so good at answering opponents with funny retorts and social media. But he now he's just kind of old and grumpy and boring, so all of his controversial opinions come back to bite him and the rest of his party.
Trump in his current form reminds me of Biden 4 years ago. It's just darn hard to even understand what he's saying.
I think there are a substantial number of voters who don't think that deeply. They don't understand what "real gdp per capita" means or the difference between nominal and real. So I sometimes think that a cyncial politician could win over the voters by just resetting the currency to make prices go down in nominal terms. Like what Argentina has done a few times, just remove a zero from every price and value. Would't really help anything, but the low information voters would love it.
Maybe I'm misunderstanding, but are you suggesting that the simple way to fix the economy is to build more wind farms and execute anyone who protests? That seems both unconstitutional and... not very useful.
The problem is that "fixing the economy" is very difficult, and people disagree on how exactly they're supposed to do that. Whereas nominating woke people for high level positions is simple and easy.
250,000 seems like a sizeable number though? I've personally met 3 of them, without doing anything special to try and meet them.
Meanwhile the Ukraine war is costing $560.64 per American to empty Ukraine of non-disabled men, freeze the lines of battle as long as the money lasts, and bring the world closer to nuclear exchange. And that’s before counting the higher price of diesel fuel since the refinery bombings.
To be fair, it's also caused a mass exodus of extremely hot Ukrainian women to the rest of the world, who are highly incentivized to get married. That's kind of a big benefit, at least to those of us struggling in the marriage market.
ah, cool. always interesting how these myths have changed over the years.
I was just thinking of the sequels (Ray). I guess I should have said that explicitly.
It sounds like she's some sort of professional editor or manuscript reader. So, unfortunately, if you ever want to publish something through mainstream channels, this is the sort of person you need to convince. So maybe most of us can ignore her, but it does tend to influence the culture over time when every single published books has the same sort of feminist spin to it.
I'm becoming concerned that our culture is losing basic media literacy. It used to be common knowledge that good characters need to have flaws, not just be perfect all the time. So Achilles had his heel as a literal weakness, but he was also full of moral flaws. If he had just been a good soldier who followed orders without pride, the story of the Iliad would have been boring.
Flawless main characters are such an obvious problem that the original "Mary Sue" short story was just making fun of all the crappy fan fiction where people used characters like that. Usually as self-inserts. It's mind-boggling to me that we've reached a point where professional literary critics not only defend that sort of thing, but they actually criticize anyone who dares write in some flaws for their female characters!
It was bad enough when Star Wars did it. But I thought, "fine, whatever, they're not looking for deep literary characters there, they just want someone to look cool on a green screen and sell toys." But now it seems there's a disturbing number of media following this trend.
I was thinking more of how they seem to play a lot of blitz and rapid games these days. Those don't take very long to grind out a ton of games. Plus they just spend a lot of time playing, of course.

For what it's worth, I'm a staunch defender of Oreimo because I think it's funny and artistically interesting. BUT I'm still disgusted by actual incest, or any sort of incest porn.
More options
Context Copy link