site banner

Midterms Megathread

Cause otherwise midterms discussion will be scattered around a bunch of separate Culture War thread posts. And it's nice to have more off-the-cuff rapid reactions in a dedicated megathread.

The first thing I've noticed so far: if the exit polls are correct, Americans are very pessimistic about AI.

13
Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Is this result actually good for the republicans in the next elections? When the democrats had no power, they could not credibly be held to account for the problems under the current administration. Now that they won the midterms, Trump could spend the remainder of his term blaming them for any policy of his that doesn't work.

Rising inflation? Democrats blocked any functional legislation. This was the best we could do.

Iran war? Jew controlled Dems insist on fighting! There is nothing we can do. Or if they want to pull out, blame them for not being able to negotiate a good peace deal.

Falling stock prices? They can't be trusted with any power over the economy.

So on and so forth. Does this actually give the Republicans all the ammo they need to win in two years?

Nothing good for Republicans can happen until Trump is gone. He was acting deranged when he had no opposition. We are going to see him act like a deranged psychopath now. He’s going to crash out and embarrass them weekly. These two years will be rough if you are on the right. It’s why I’m predicting he won’t make it the next two years. Knives are already out.

No, because any legislation has to go through the president. If it doesn't work his party shares the blame equally. If he vetoes it he takes the blame alone. Plus, the "party in power" is who holds the presidency, regardless of who controls congress. Democrats didn't get any credit for not controlling congress during Biden's last two years.

Average person couldn't name any of their congressional representatives if you put a gun to their head. They probably know who the president is though.

On the third, the Democrats won big time thanks to Trump, but they were not the only ones whom Trump helped to victory. More so than even with the Dems, the ones I am talking about are a group I have serious reservations about but whom I nevertheless root for in their conflict against Trump.

I am talking about Iran, of course.

Now, for all my faults, I am not a friend of the Iranian regime. They have an atrocious human rights record, and if the Iranian people can kick them out, I will be very happy for them. (They also sponsor murderous terrorist groups abroad, but let him whose government has never sponsored murderous terrorists cast the first stone.)

But I am a big fan of the international rule based order. This means that I want to see war of aggression fail, preferably fail spectacularly. This is why I am also rooting for Ukraine, for example. With Trump's and Bibi's Iranian adventure, there is no debate whose side is the aggressor. So obviously I would prefer for the US to get an expensive, humiliating defeat to reinforce the idea that wars of aggression do not pay off.

The goals of the Iranian regime are pretty aligned to mine in this. They are fighting a defensive war, they want to maintain as much of the status quo (their infrastructure being intact and their soldiers alive) as they can. But they arguably also want to establish a precedent that attacking them is a bad move.

However, their military capabilities are not up for bombing their enemy leadership, military or schools to try for a regime change (not that this worked for Trump either). So they did what was rational for them and suspended the freedom of navigation through the Strait of Hormuz (thereby likewise violating international law). The Commander in Chief of the US military might be impervious to missiles, but he is very much vulnerable to the whims of his electorate, who are in turn vulnerable to economic pressure.

One of their war goals was "establish that attacking Iran is a presidency-ending mistake". I will admit that we are not quite there yet. But their labors have borne fruits, and now we have a regime change in Texas. Saddam Hussein would have given a hand for that.

Another thing Iran has accomplished is driving a wedge between the US and Israel. For most of my life, most Westerners did not have very strong feelings about Israel. Then Hamas (through their unmatched barbarism) incited them into leveling Gaza, killing 70k Palestinians (mostly likely non-combatants) in the process. We have all seen the before-and-after aerial photos, and some of us (me included) started to find that we actually gave a fuck. Then Netanyahu tricked the gullible Trump (who had already proven his usefulness by bombing IRGC officers in his first term) into spending a few dozen billions on bombing Iran, a move which helps Israel a lot more than it helps Americans.

Now, it is not like AIPAC does not have a majority in Congress anymore or anything, but the mere threat of people voting against their candidates is already constraining what they can do. Hence the decision of Trump and Netanyahu to get rid of the military aid (or at least be a bit more discreet about it). In the very least, it seems safe to say that no future US president will be roped into military action by Israel without carefully considering 'but what if this backfires domestically?'

Obviously Iran has not won yet, but I think the midterms were the most significant development in the conflict. It is a clear sign that the US is not willing to bear the expenses of the war indefinitely. Nor have any other countries been very enthusiastic about defending the freedom of navigation with their navies.

Now, ideally, the US would just pay reparations to Iran and Iran would allow innocent passage again, but realistically that is not going to happen. Still, I do think the US is going to tire of escorting tankers before Iran tires of attacking them, so in the long term we will either allow them to charge tolls or cut some other deal with them.

Now, ideally, the US would just pay reparations to Iran and Iran would allow innocent passage again, but realistically that is not going to happen.

The US would if they could. They even tried. But Iran is obsessed with maximalist demands and likely won't allow free passage as long as the regime remains in power.

Nor have any other countries been very enthusiastic about defending the freedom of navigation with their navies.

Saddest part of all of this in my imo. Every single other country in the world has been begging trump to surrender so that they can pay tolls. Really shows that "freedom of navigation" is just some made up word that actually just means the US running the seas.

Its tough to lose a PR was against Iran and Hamas, but Israel did it. It will be interesting to see how rhetoric around this will change among republicans.

Iran, maybe, but Hamas has perfected the fine art of "shooting from behind their own children, and then when there's return fire displaying the dead body as Israel's fault."

I wonder if, long term, the U.S. just leaves Iran and says to hell with it. Iran can charge tolls if they want. Europe and China will pay the bill. And then things are sort of forgotten. Maybe every 5 years Israel mows the grass enough so Iran doesn't get a nuke. The world has plenty of oil and the Hormuz will becoming irrelevant as countries route around the damage.

I think you're right about a wedge being driven between Israel and the United States. I was hopeful that Jews would realign to the Republican Party given everything that's happened. But apparently, 60% of Jews (not sure how this number was arrived at) voted for El-Sayed in Michigan. So Jews are politically homeless, shunned by the left because of anti-semitism, and completely ungrateful to their only allies (the right).

My own personal stance has definitely changed. We should cut Israel off at this point. As much as I like Israel and don't want them to suffer, they are not worth defending if it causes America to become a socialist state – and we definitely are headed that way. The election results changed my mind.

Voters lean older, thus on average more set in their ways. In the last few decades, American Jews have tended to be liberals in the American sense of the word. That takes time to change. The fact that the radical wing of the Democratic Party hates Israel (and a subset of them hates Jews) may frighten some Jews, but keep in mind that a large fraction of the radical wing of the Republican Party hates Jews. The radical wing of the Democratic Party probably has more political power in its party than Jew-haters have in the Republican party, but the Democratic Party mainstream is not antisemitic, so there is still limited reason for Democratic-voting Jews to flip to the Republicans. Israel is not enough for many, since many Democratic-voting Jews dislike Israel in its current form, they just don't think it should stop existing.

Welp, so much for yesterday's stock market rally. The Nasdaq is off 4.5% today. Looks like it briefly hit 5.4% down. Officially in correction territory now, down more than 10% off the peak, and only up 6% YTD.

NVDA down 8%. Micron down 13%.

The steep dropoff means its likely a fund or two just got blown up. I guess people are digesting the data center votes.

Texas, Georgia, North Carolina, and other states going blue can't help either. Where is stuff going to get built now? Not to mention that taxes are going to go up a lot in 2029, if not earlier.

I've made fun of gold bugs in the past, but I think they might have a point.

I've done a lot of digging and there's no real rational reason for this complete market capitulation beyond election fear. My account is sad, but I'm using this opportunity to buy the dip. AMD has a strong earnings beat and expects continued growth through the next year, NVIDIA hasn't reported earnings yet and their PE ratios are heavily beaten down considering their evaluation.

SpaceX and TSLA would be interesting if Elon actually combines the two companies. I don't have as much cash as I would like but it would be a fun play.

I do wish I ran options, but I didn't predict the level of panic that occurred due to the election. I believe there may be other reasons for the volatility today which are more difficult to report on, but I have no real evidence since I'm not privy to a Bloomberg Terminal.

Crazy leverage in the system means that relatively small shocks can be self-perpetuating. Good chance people saw the market strength day before, went 'phew back to business as usual we're up only', slammed on a bunch more leverage then got caught as market went back the other way.

Thanks for letting me know! I took out about $500 on short-term SPY puts yesterday expecting a downturn. Easiest 10x of my life.

Every degen has his day! Surprised its only a 10x to be honest.

Yikes. Now this is actually bad. I'm literally down mid 5 figures today...

Not good. That’s like 2 years take home pay in Europe.

I know right. I'll be fine, my quant salary and savings will keep me going, but NGL, it hurts.

That's either awful luck with the stock picking, or a million dollar index fund portfolio. If it's the latter, I wouldn't be concerned.

Could be leverage as well...

You really need to be diverting more money into building your country of origin. It's very sad if your quant salary just dissipates into moderate gambling to try and chase a 2BR apartment 'somewhere nice in London' by the time you're automated out of a job in the next couple years.

Build Pakistan! Pakistan #1!

GPUs will not replace us!

One thing I'm very much looking forward to is all the anti immigration types who don't want migrants taking their jobs getting tufted out by GPUs instead, either directly or because the GPUs took over smart people jobs and now those smart people are beating the aforementioned types at their own vocation.

  • -13

I mean doesn't this vindicate the anti-immigration types when it's kind of nonsensical to bring in bulk amounts of new people who are going to be difficult to employ in the current years and therefore add additional pressure to whatever welfare-adjacent system comes up. I know if somebody was to try and immigrate to Pakistan that you'd want them as an indentured servant at best, so clearly your views are purely self-serving.

Malice as a fantasy is a sign that you are lashing out emotionally. You want people who didn't want to lose their jobs to lose their jobs? I wouldn't gloat about that if I were you.

Nah, I want the people who don't want immigrants because they don't like competition for their jobs and want to keep extracting economic rents for being born on a specific piece of rock to be put in their place, and if it's a GPU that does it, so be it.

  • -12

What's the difference between someone who benefits from being born in the right place and someone who benefits from being born into the right caste/family?

What makes you any more deserving of your unearned accident-of-birth benefits?

You're on thin ice with the race-baiting triumphalism you've been ramping up again lately. I'm letting it go because we certainly have white nationalists who say things just as bad about their outgroup, but your history is particularly bad and you're only getting a pass because your last final warning was seven months ago. But I can very clearly see that you're having fun trolling again. I still don't think banning you would be any loss.

He's clearly a troll, but the comment you replied to is a good one. In a post-scarcity world, why should people born in one place get better gibs than others?

Even his trolling pretty cute most of the time, in my opinion. I think we'd be worse off without him here.

He's clearly a troll, but the comment you replied to is a good one. In a post-scarcity world, why should people born in one place get better gibs than others?

It's a fair question, but like many valid questions, there are thoughtful ways to discuss it, and there are belligerently eye-poking ways meant to provoke people. The former is called discussion, and is suitable for a discussion forum. The latter is called trolling, and is not.

Even his trolling pretty cute most of the time, in my opinion. I think we'd be worse off without him here.

I'm sure you do.

That's our magic soil and don't you forget it!

One nice thing about the future is that immigrants aren't going to want to move to the West anymore because there won't be any jobs and the gibs will be airdropped to them locally.

And Westerners will be extremely anti immigration since it will mean they have to share their UBI payments. UBI will turn every citizen into a hyper-engaged single issue voter, much like seniors today.

One nice thing about the future is that immigrants aren't going to want to move to the West anymore because there won't be any jobs

Climate change refugees, or "refugees". It's not just about money. The West is simply more functional than a lot of the world. People won't stop coming, especially as shocks happen.

And Westerners will be extremely anti immigration since it will mean they have to share their UBI payments. UBI will turn every citizen into a hyper-engaged single issue voter, much like seniors today.

That may happen, but fiscal problems from immigration haven't yet stopped immigration in the US (where it impacted blue municipalities under Biden) or Europe (where many migrant groups famously don't pay for themselves and yet there's no stop yet)

Maybe UBI's simplicity will make what's being paid to foreigners more legible to the average man and cause the backlash (Biden almost certainly suffered from the sense that the border was out of control, as well as inflation). But it's not certain.

One nice thing about the future is that immigrants aren't going to want to move to the West anymore because there won't be any jobs and the gibs will be airdropped to them locally.

This is assuming that all countries will be equally good at allocating gibs. Even if ultra global socialism hits I'm still pretty skeptical the people of Gabon will have the same gibs accessibility as the people of Marseille.

Well, I've been lurking in /r/fivethirtyeight and listening to Nate Silver and the FiveThirtyEight alumni on youtube, and a few things pop out that I think mottizens would want to know:


A. Semafor revealed for the shocking win by Annie Andrews against Darline Graham, sister of Lindsay Graham, in South Carolina that: "On Oct. 5, the Andrews campaign received a poll showing her with a 3-point lead over Graham. But the Democrat’s campaign decided against publicly releasing the poll — or any subsequent internal poll — showing Andrews with a lead over Graham, wary of drawing too much attention from national Republicans and jeopardizing a peak at the right time, according to Chas Goldman, a strategist for Andrews."

A.1. I must say this is pretty shrewd and speaks to a certain appetite for risk/bravery from Andrews. I'm just trying to imagine being in the situation where there is unexpectedly positive internal polling, and some advisors would be saying "it's great news, we should release the polls so that we can get more funding and drive excitement" and etc., and then some others would argue the way that Andrews decided on.

A.2.. It was a gamble also that Graham/Trump camp, who hopefully got some pollsters that gave the same numbers, didn't release those same Dem-positive polling.

A.3. We don't have a counterfactual on what would have happened if Andrews did release those polls. But based on what I think of Trump and Musk, there might have been a lot more GOP money pumped in the last few weeks.


B. I don't have a good link or verified these numbers but the bottom 4 states in terms of Democratic shift are Jackson in Maine (+3 shift), Flannagan in Minnesota (+6 shift), Markey in Massachusetts (+7 shift), and El-Sayed in Michigan (+8 shift). All four runs under the +13 national average shift. Bernie Sanders only made 4 Senate endorsements in 2026, three are in the bottom four (Minnesota, Massachusetts, Michigan), and the fourth was Graham Platner of Maine.

B.1. These could be signs that progressive liberal politics really do need a blue tsunami to win any office.

B.2. Or this is particularly prescient of Bernie, as progressive as possible yet still win.


C. On the other hand, Ossof in Georgia is winning a comfortable +18 in 2026, especially compared to +1 back in 2021

C.1. This might mean that once red state citizens get past the fears of a blue politician, they might come to like it.

C.2. Anyone who wants to be part of a presidential primary campaign should come running to Georgia.


D. Can I remind everyone that Angie Nixon who lost by 3 points in Florida is DSA.

D.1. Of the races to sacrifice in terms of national strategy, this is apparently a good one cause this Florida is expensive, big movements here would have gotten Trump's personal attention, and because this is a special election the race would come up again in 2028 anyway.

D.2. I personally think maybe Angie Nixon has a chance to be the Stacey Abrams of Florida. Fight so hard to lay the groundworks and rebuild the Dem party in a ruby red state, then some other guy would swoop in and win on that foundation

D.3. Some Democratic operative somewhere, maybe even the Morris Katz guy, is probably combing for some left-leaning, young, masculine Cuban-American to run in 2028.


E. Adam Hamilton in Kansas , Sherrod Brown in Ohio, Roy Cooper in North Carolina are really good examples of excellent candidate grooming by the Dems.

E.1. In contrast are gonna be the Republican candidates (Roger Marshall, Jon Husted, Ashley Hinson) in these races.

E.2. In a good +6 Dem environment, which was around July-Sep this year based on a quick glance here, these races might have been more nail-bitingly close than this clear Dem sweep.

E.3. This has plenty of down ballot implications which we will only figure out in the days and weeks ahead.


F. Shoutout to Roy Cooper of North Carolina still going undefeated in North Carolina.

F.1. This will be overshadowed because of the Roy Cooper factor but this is apparently an inexperienced Trump pick in Michael Whatley?


G. The crown jewel is obviously blue Texas, and Talarico really ran up the score, which certainly helped Hinojosa.

G.1. For me though the dark crown jewel would be if Mississippi is confirmed flip. And then people can joke about how once Mississippi got a little educated they stopped being red.

G.2. "Pick another protein? I'd rather pick another senator" is the best political ad of the year.

G.3. Talarico in Texas, Hamilton in Kansas, Warnock in Georgia, the Dems have certain individuals that can credibly say counter the image that Republicans are the only one representing the religious of America.

G.2. "Pick another protein? I'd rather pick another senator" is the best political ad of the year.

It's insane that this is the broad consensus, because to me what she said was obviously good advice and they're punishing her for telling them the truth.

"You can't afford beef any more, so don't buy it" is good advice if true. It is also an admission of failure coming from someone whose job it is to ensure that Americans can afford beef.

That reminds me of an old complaint that "the Department of Energy's job shouldn't be to tell people to use less energy, it should be to provide energy".

The Department of Energy's actual job is to maintain the US stockpile of nuclear warheads.

Whoever had the idea for this ad likely single-handedly flipped Mississippi for 6 years.

She's entirely correct, but you're just not allowed to say these things as an candidate for elected office. She was rightly punished for failing a basic competency test.

I meant she was 100% correct, but that ad is also a banger, I'd vote for him based off of the ad alone. This is the problem with human based democracy, you either need to get rid of democracy, or get rid of the humans and have it done via AI agents as the voters instead with the AI agents tasked with choosing for the best interests of all of humanity.

"Hot dogs are five cents cheaper"

"Make your own $20 burrito"

Good advice and true statements, unfortunately, do not win votes. As attack ad soundbites go, this one was probably the least obvious in the moment, though.

It's both. Yes, it's good advice, and personally higher beef prices helped me discover that I actually might prefer pork anyway. And I doubt there's much a senator can do about it. But elected officials or candidates for elected office are pretty much not allowed to tell the public any variation on "deal with it", because they will lose to someone who will say "Unlike my opponent, I will deal with it for you".

It's also relevant that the bougie senator lady more likely than not never once had to adjust her own diet to adapt to economic circumstances. Compare to the ancient "learn to code" narrative, which was particularly loathsome because it was spread by journalists and professional twitterati much more than by working programmers.

To my outsider view the problem isn’t so much ”deal with it” but a mixture of denial ”yes, but this isn’t actually a problem for you” and moralising (talking about ”picking another protein” which is heavily vegetarian coded instead of just saying pork and poultry exist).

this is apparently an inexperienced Trump pick in Michael Whatley

as a resident of north carolina, my response upon hearing his name was "literally who?"

No debate, everything seemed to be attack ads on Cooper's record on releasing criminals, hardly anything positive anywhere. Cooper of course has decades of name recognition to build on, absolute shoe-in.

And then people can joke about how once Mississippi got a little educated they stopped being red.

oh god the idiots will be insufferable.

Pick another protein? I'd rather pick another senator" is the best political ad of the year.

ok yeah that was good.

B.1. These could be signs that progressive liberal politics really do need a blue tsunami to win any office.

B.2. Or this is particularly prescient of Bernie, as progressive as possible yet still win.

The blueness of the territory matters more than the national environment. AOC didn't need a blue wave to win in a deep blue NYC House district, she just needed to win the primary. "Leftist candidates can't win statewide, even in blue states" used to be conventional wisdom, on the basis that no state is that blue on a statewide basis. And that conventional wisdom is in trouble. MA-Sen was always winnable from the left. MI and MN are both coming through with large enough margins that they would still have been winnable with Bernie's candidates in a more normal "bad midterms for the President's party" environment.

So I think this is smart politics from Bernie.

To point B, im just not sure you can apply national averages to every state. The midwest generally had smaller shifts than southern states. States with large black and hispanic populations swung far more on average. That is why Angie Nixon who is actual DSA overperformed Flanagan for example. There is also the case that not every battleground was fought equally hard by GOP. They basically abandonded their senate candidates in North Caroline and Georgia very early in the race.

More than anything election this seems to confirm that if dems focus on ethnic minorities, and manage to turn them out at higher rates, they can win a permanent majority.

Im not sure that is a conclusion this sub particularily likes. For all the focus on El-Sayed, he actually won over a larger portion of white voters in his state then both Talarico and Ossoff. That will also matter for how he will govern.

The Trump admin and the GOP may have managed to turn a once in a couple generation opportunity to fix major structural problems in the United States into the worst political loss since at least the 1974 election a month after Nixon's resignation over the Watergate Coup, but have you considered the worst scumbags around, Republican political consultants like Susie Wiles, Chris Lacivita, and James Blair, got generational wealth sucking MAGA dry?

Wiles, LaCivita, and Blair just spent >$1,000,000,000, the most expensive midterm in US history, in the worst loss in 50 years. They could have scaled up 10xvotes or some other GOTV operation over the last 2 years with that enormous warchest, but that wouldn't have gotten them generational wealth, and so they ran worthless dumb ads while claiming DJT doing a rally in a few states was going to get the job done and blacklisted and attacked anyone attempting to speak the truth or tell Trump the truth.

Let's hear it for these champions. In a just world, these people and the rest of the Florida Mafia would at least be blacklisted from controlling anything more than county dog catcher (not to mention sued into oblivion and investigated for where the money went and what it was spent on), but we can look forward to them joining the Rubio 2028 campaign because that's how GOP politics works.

It's hard to exaggerate just how much of a disaster if not malicious destruction the GOP leadership/consultant class has caused in this cycle, but here's hoping this will cause accountability instead of what is more likely which is to find some scapegoat to blame everything on. The burned MAGA to the ground and got rich in the process. They betrayed their voters and supporters but at least many of them have gotten fabulously wealthy.

And don't forget the paid-for pollsters manipulating access to lie in internals and to the President. I need to make a pollster review and post-mortem effort post about this, but not right now.

Sorry for the rants, I burned bridges and access and money over the last year+ trying to stop this from happening and as you can see I failed miserably. It's simultaneously cathartic but also this loss will just make everything worse.

The Trump admin and the GOP may have managed to turn a once in a couple generation opportunity to fix major structural problems in the United States into the worst political loss since at least the 1974 election a month after Nixon's resignation over the Watergate Coup, but have you considered the worst scumbags around, Republican political consultants like Susie Wiles, Chris Lacivita, and James Blair, got generational wealth sucking MAGA dry?

I think the title for "worst scumbag Republican who caused the midterm losses" is hotly contested. Too bad there is not a Nobel for that.

Trump won two years ago not because he was a particularly strong candidate -- he was anything but -- but because the Dems messed up completely. While I do not deny that he is (was?) very popular with his base, he is very much not some golden boy. Sure, he won a majority of electoral college votes against Clinton, likely his greatest political achievement for the GOP. Then he lost against sleepy Joe, who is basically "what if Obama was white, a few decades older and less charismatic?" as the incumbent because he had spent his presidency on Twitter. His personally greatest political success was doubtlessly getting nominated by the GOP for a third time due to his cult. Winning the election was then mostly a matter of being more lucid than Biden, any Republican candidate of the last two decades could probably have pulled that off.

Trump is in politics to bolster his ego and his net worth, the worst swamp dweller DC has seen in decades. The ego thing sometimes works to the advantage of his base because he is aware that doing things popular with his base (like rounding up and deporting suspected illegals) will make him popular, and he likes to be popular. However, it is not very reliable in that regard, because often it comes with an inflated sense of his own capabilities. He will embark on plenty of foolish quests like his tariffs or his little war with Iran because he genuinely believes that his is much more capable than any president who came before him, and will not update when things will blow up in his face, because his ego can not bear admitting he was wrong.

As the grifter-in-chief, he obviously attracts other grifters. Can't expect a Boomer to build his shitcoin on his own, after all. And I don't think his ego can stand around being anyone who is not a terminal sycophant. "Mr president, I think your cognitive abilities are quite good considering your age and lack of educational attainment" is not the kind of feedback he would take well. It is obvious from his tweets that he has nobody who has the influence to tell him "don't write this, it makes you look delusional (e.g. thinking he might win a Nobel) or like a comic book villain (e.g. threatening to wipe out the Persian civilization)".

Complaining about the Wormtongue types who compete in ass-kissery to be able to manipulate him to their own advantage is like complaining that the stripper you fell in love with is only interested in your money. It is sad but not entirely unexpected.

I am not an Obama fanboy, I merely consider him an ok president. But my mental model of his administration is that there was a lot more room for honest disagreement with him. This allowed him to retain (perhaps even mildly autistic) policy wonks who are actually good at their job rather than a gaggle of sociopaths and fellow narcissists.

Not sure exactly how it compares, but the Democratic Party is definitely overrun with useless political consultants gathering all of the money for themselves, spending a lot (most?) of it on messages for donations which are essentially elder scams. Any blue wave was despite that waste, not because the Democratic Party is great at spending money to get votes.

Does political spending really correlate that well with outcomes? Beyond that, can we show causality in the right direction? Presumably popular, charismatic candidates are good at both raising money and getting votes even before they spend anything, and even generate much more organic, unpaid promotion.

Probably not. I remember a long time ago (so a different political landscape) hearing about the theory that the causation is basically what you suggest: donations are a proxy for amount of support, so work as a weak approximation for how many votes a candidate will get.

I think it correlates in certain situations where exposure is an advantage. If you're running in a crowded primary, having money earlier means you can start running ads and getting name recognition before your competition finds out if they even have donors. This is what happened in the 2014 PA Democratic gubernatorial primary; Tom Wolfe was independently wealthy and was able to get his name out there enough that his polling lead was large enough for him to start challenging the incumbent weeks before the primary was even over, despite being a political newcomer. This year, Stacy Garrity couldn't compete with Shapiro financially and didn't start running ads until very late in the campaign. The result was that for a while after Labor Day something like 30% of the electorate couldn't name the Republican candidate if you put a gun to their head.

With shit like President, I don't think it matters one iota in the general. With Senate it can matter, since an underdog can make an impact they wouldn't be able to make on a shoestring budget. But there are diminishing returns. Once a campaign is well enough funded that they've already done all their ad buys (it's a lot cheaper if you buy early) and they don't have to be too careful about what hotels they stay in, it's not going to do much. Spending a ton of money on late TV buys doesn't have the same impact on voters who have been seeing your ads for months. I almost think it's counterproductive, as there are certain candidates I'd never vote for based on ads alone. That guy from MS put together a good one, but most of them are just black and white shots if the opposition with dire voiceovers saying that they support tax cuts that ship jobs overseas. These are unwatchable but are at least predictable; more often than not, going outside the box makes them completely impossible, like the Stacy Garrity ad with AI Josh Shapiro talking about what a bad candidate he is.

Okay, I at once don't believe you but I also want more. Can you spill the beans, or is this just a tease?

I'm willing to believe.

All evidence points to superior Democratic GOTV this cycle with Republicans drawing even with 2022 and Democratics treating this like a Presidential election. The elderly vote was probably the biggest factor, but obviously it's multifactorial with such a huge swing.

What would you have done differently, Mr. Big Brain?

I feel like we doing the mythical JD Vance account, he's overplayed his hand

What would you have done differently, Mr. Big Brain?

in the future, if you would like some anon on an interwebs forum to put forth significant effort to convince you of something you should steer clear of this sort of behavior

I wouldn't have phrased it that way, but it is a fair question and I'd be interested in knowing how you think the Republicans should have approached this midterm.

how I think Republicans should have approached this midterm given what Trump and the GOP have done over the last 2 years or what I would have gotten them to do differently? We talking a month ago, two months ago, 6 months ago, 18 months ago? What can I change and what can't I change?

two months ago, door knockers were having doors slammed in their faces regularly by Trump voters saying Trump protects pedophiles or was Netanyahu's bitch to give you the temperature of former Trump voters in the midwest

Let's assume that you aren't Trump and have no control over anything he does, and have no control over who the candidates are. We'll also assume that you're in some kind of master position that allows you to coordinate all of the campaigns and how money is spent. All primaries are done the first week of May, giving you six months to work your magic. How do you campaign differently?

I don’t think you are being real.

that's fine

I get the frustration, but I don't know how much more good tzar, bad boyars cope I can handle. The only people giving small-dollar donations to Republicans are 78-year-old paypigs. Maybe the consultants sucked Musk and Adelson dry. Of course, no one can say that Miriam didn't get what she paid for.

Trump betrayed the voters himself. First by playing hide-and-seek with the Epstein Files, then more substantively by starting and losing a war with Iran. Don't think for a second that he isn't okay with whatever brazen corruption is occuring in the campaign finance realm. It is at least a small credit to him that he keeps the corruption network close and in-house, rather than treating it as an expandable franchise enterprise as the Democrats are wont to do.

If you think I'm here to defend Trump, you are badly mistaken. I have written about a dozen comments livid with Trump specifically saying that his behavior is shredding the coalition. At the same time, we need to realize none of this happens if Trump doesn't create the opportunity himself near single-handedly to begin with.

Trump indeed did betray the voters himself, but he's certainly not alone and it's worth it to talk about why and how it went off the rails. You're talking about the donor base after Trump already shredded the coalition.

Your criticism is true for a good portion of people, but it doesn't have much to do with me.

Don't think for a second that he isn't okay with whatever brazen corruption is occuring in the campaign finance realm.

you base this on what, exactly?

Trump isn't okay with brazen corruption, he just largely doesn't know about most of it and doesn't really want to be involved enough to know about it, especially when he feels it's other people making money off of his name (at least without him getting a cut). Trump isn't a details guy or a daily manager guy.

rather than treating it as an expandable franchise enterprise as the Democrats are wont to do

not for lack of trying, he's just not that competent at doing it and the GOP are largely the junior varsity team derps

Exactly. I’m amazed there are still Trump supporters here. He’s not that guy. He’s had 10 years and hasn’t delivered anything meaningful. He has to go. He is the problem. Time to give someone else a chance even if you like Trump’s policies.

"He dunks on the woke" has been absurdly motivating for 10+ years. I don't think its rocket surgery, at least for our cohort.

Trump's gotta go and yet we would be far worse off without Trump creating it all to begin with

I wish some of you were around to the truly dark, pointless days of the GOP under McCain or Romney

Not necessarily. Only if the right seizes the moment because he also radicalized the left.

the Obama administration's behavior, especially post 2012, is good evidence it's not Trump causing the radicalization on the left and they find something to get radicalized and push until they find resistance anyway

no one is coming to save any of us, we're going to have to do something in the real world

I'd argue the cycle of overall radicalization started in 2010 and the catalyst was the Tea Party movement. The OWS phenomenon in 2011 was a direct reaction to it.

People involved at the time thought that OWS and the Tea Party (and the rise of Ron Paul libertarianism at roughly the same time) were blue-coded and red-coded wings of the same movement - a bipartisan anarchist/libertarian-coded populist revolt against bank bailouts and the non-punishment of the morons who caused the 2008 crisis. Obviously this ceased to be plausible after the Tea Party became a mostly anti-Obamacare movement.

I don't know if there was a time when this belief was accurate or not. But I don't think it is fair to say that OWS was a reaction against the Tea Party - it was a reaction against the same establishment failure that the Tea Party was reacting against.

I'm assuming it was a reaction to it in the sense that there was a growing sense of disillusionment with Obama among leftists by 2011 and when they observed the Tea Party phenomenon which they mostly viewed as implicitly racist they must have thought that they should have their own popular rebel movement as an answer.

Obama is nothing like Mamdami, The Squad, and the DSA. Wd have a Muslim mayor of NYC and a Muslim Senator now. Socialism is massively popular now with young people.

The problem with Trump though is that he super charges the left without actually making any long term gains. Obviously they are going to be pissed and that is fine, but he pisses them off and then does nothing tangible. The things he does do well he communicates poorly on and can all be overturned by the next administration

The only thing he did well was blow open the Overton Window on race, immigration, and white identity, but that has no benefit if nobody does anything with the opportunity.

Obama is largely the same as these three, except earlier, more dangerous and effective. Obama winning in 2012 radicalized and emboldened the left. Mamdani and Abdulla are not Muslims in any meaningful sense; they're empty foreigners who are playing racial resentment politics and saying whatever they need to say to get power just like Obama did. They're the solved meta for leftist politics. The demographic replacement happened before Trump "super charged," them with likely 100,000,000 foreigners in the US by the time he took office.

The American economic system is socialism for the rich and the poor and capitalism for the middle-class. Why wouldn't the young be interested in socialism for themselves as well? The current American economic system is everyone gets stuff except for them and they're looking at their lives being far worse than their parents or their grandparents. They would be interested in anything which gives them answers to these problems.

The only thing he did well was blow open the Overton Window on race, immigration, and white identity

even if this was true: Oh? Is that it? As opposed to pre-Trump GOP who were constantly trying to convince their voters for decades to accept illegal amnesty deals and destroying the lives of anyone on their own side who even got slightly close to these topics?

sure dude, this has been a fuckup and a failure and a disaster, but having no Trump would have been worse

not that it particularly matters, we didn't know it would end up like this when we first started and trying anything, especially in politics, means putting something on the table and accepting risk you could fail and things get worse

When is Hitler 2.0 running?

I’d be fine with Vance, DeSantis, or Rubio at this point. As long as Trump is gone. He’s incompetent and chaotic for no benefit. If we’re not getting Hitler 2.0 then let’s just do managed decline and we can all live peacefully. I’ve accepted that’s probably best case scenario at this point.

If we’re not getting Hitler 2.0 then let’s just do managed decline

As opposed to...

Presumably Hitler 2.0 would be immediate and catastrophic decline that leaves the country a bombed-out ruin?

Hitler 1.0 was defeated by the combined armies of white men that are long dead.
Who could possibly stop Hitler 2.0?

Well…himself.

What are these guys going to do?
Could they even win against one of these drunk women the Dems are fielding?

we can all live peacefully.

That's until the President says that that rioter the police shot was his son or some other bs.
Without Trumpian youth American streets would not get pacified. You'll get a cop knocking at the door after your next X (formerly Twitter) post right for tea time. What we've seen so far is the beginning of the bad. Trump put a halt to much of it, but it barely even began.
Remember in 2021 they wanted to get you fired if you did not take a shot.
Have you taken your daily capsule of Anti-whiteness yet citizen? We have reports that bad thoughts were being emitted in your area.

I don't think you understand how fucked we (as in white conservatives) are already. I moved out of Texas recently and it is probably 30% white now. Chicago is noticeably more white than Texas cities. Texas is going to be permanently Blue. All you need to do is go to a Costco to see this. It's done. Trump's antics have radicalized the left so much that if they win all 3 branches of government in 28, they are going to open the borders like we've never seen before. At this point, if you care about demographics, it's either Hitler 2.0 Reconquista right now or it's over. If you aren't down with that (and it looks like America isn't hence the response to ICE raids) then that's about as good as we can hope for. There are no white pills to be had. Vance is the best the dissident right can ever hope for, as sad as that is.

Trump did not make anybody open the borders.
Trump's antics got him elected which is better than any of these other yahoos could hope for.
I don't really care about demographics, maybe local power at this point.
Demographics vote their way into what we have now anyway.

Accelerationists are so tiresome. There are still white progressives in South Africa.

I'm not pro or against accelerationists.
Source on the white progressives in South Africa? A combination of extremely low birthrates and aversion for same-race coupling should lead them to extinction.

Trump is the accelerationist. At this point I want Trump out of the way so maybe we can get a competent Republican in there in 28. I want Trump to step down and give JD a shot at turning this shit show around.

Cool. What’s the most controversial thing you believe which the highest percent of progressives would disagree with about?

Outlaw Islam and Judaism. Tear up the constitution and rewrite it to make America and explicitly white nation. Strip the vast majority of non-white people of their citizenship. Sanction Israel so harshly it doesn't exist anymore (but they'd probably agree with me there). None of the Israelis would be allowed to move to America or Europe. Deport all Muslims from Europe and outlaw Islam there too. Execute Trump for treason for selling out the US to Israeli interests.

Sanction Israel so harshly it doesn't exist anymore [...] None of the Israelis would be allowed to move to America or Europe.

Making the Muslims do your dirty work seems unsporting, not to mention quite fraught wrt. the Samson Option. If you want a job done well, do it yourself.

Strip the vast majority of non-white people of their citizenship.

How considerate of you to acknowledge America's original owners. Less sarcastically, why merely "the vast majority", and if you are (presumably) convinced of the white man's superiority, why do you constrain yourself to America?

Bonus nitpick, but if you're willing to implement explicit ethnonationalism, religious exclusion on top seems a bit redundant - unless you also really hate Albanians/only hate Orthodox Jews for some reason.

More comments

I burned bridges and access and money over the last year+ trying to stop this from happening and as you can see I failed miserably.

Is that you, JD?

Was MIssissippi on anyone's radar? I heard absolutely nothing about the Senate race there, and it's currently too close to call with the Democrat slightly ahead. If he wins, I think he'd be the first black man elected to statewide office since Reconstruction.

I did notice that the polls were oddly close, and that there weren’t very many of them.

Being in position to slam one’s Republican opponent as being anti-BBQ is a good place to be in the South.

That really is a great ad, legit funny and such a clean attack. I can see why he’s doing so well, he comes off very charismatic in just that short clip. Plus, wow, all else aside the GOP really did pull out all the stops to run an awful slate of candidates this year, didn’t they. Paxton, Vivek, Lindsey Graham’s nepo-sister, apparently this lady…

Abdul El-Sayed, Talarico, Amy "AA" Acton, Troy Jackson, Mary Peltola!?

This election had little to do with candidate quality. In Michigan, Mike Rogers was a legitimately good candidate against a legitimately horrible one. Didn't matter.

The Talafreako meme is Republicans being high on their own supply. A good candidate is one who reads as a more charismatic version of a normie to swing voters, which he does. Actual normies don't run for statewide office, and if they did they wouldn't be able to act normal in the freakish situations political campaigns put candidates in.

I think the opposite is true: Talarico is legitimately extremely offputting and a terrible candidate to win Texas as a Democrat, but Republicans were high on their own supply to think that it wasn't a blue enough cycle (and facing a terrible enough Republican candidate) to make him the expected winner. He's just much more tuned to get a committed partisan Democrat to think he appeals to Republican-leaning swing voters than he is to actually appeal to Republican-leaning swing voters, which produces this really distinct dissonance.

Mike Rogers was a deep state goon and proven loser running on a platform of slavish devotion to a country with the approval rating of AIDS.

The only reason anyone ever thought he was a "legitimately good candidate" is that treacherous foreign agents for said country are disproportionately represented among those who own media outlets. The guy was anti-endorsed by Judge Napolitano of all people

That may legitimately be the best political ad I've seen since Christine O'Donnell had to publicly proclaim that she wasn't a witch.

That soundbite is a rival politician's dream. Seriously giving Marie Antoinette vibes.

Part of the problem for Vance and any other Republicans who are performatively distancing themselves from Trump is that a substantial proportion of Republican primary voters still mostly like him and are unlikely to hate him before 2028.

Not only can Trump blame all problems between now and 2028 on a Democratic congressional majority preventing him from doing anything (and he will be persuasive to enough people in doing so) which will ensure he retains at least a core loyal base, but he will also (i) respond extremely poorly to criticism from inside the party and (ii) will be very public in endorsing a preferred candidate or candidates.

This means that even if a Trump-skeptical candidate wins the primary, which would be difficult, they are likely to be heavily bruised by a primary campaign in which he will feature as a looming presence. Trump, who remains a vindictive and capricious person with little loyalty to party, would then also likely criticize them throughout the actual presidential campaign period, reducing turnout in his core boomer base and making an actual victory almost impossible.

In the alternate scenario, if a Trump-endorsed candidate wins the primary, he will require Trump at rallies and in media more broadly to drive turnout among his base to win, which means that he will never be able to criticize him even slightly, and in turn that obviously means that he is unlikely to win swing voters.

Most paths to an R win in 2028 run through AI-powered economic boom. If the Iran War is quietly dropped in the next few months nobody will remember it in 2 years.

If

Iran is going to need some mighty incentives and concessions to get off Trump's back. He did kill the last Ayatollah, isn't that the equivalent of killing the pope then asking for peace with the Vatican?

I had the impression that Iran was holding out this long out of spite in order to ruin Trump’s midterms. They’ve made their point and now everyone can go home.

Depends if they think Trump or the 2028 dem president will give them better concessions. They'll have plenty of time to hear Trump's offer first. Having killed the Ayatollah, he's going to have to really sweeten the deal in a way that persists even if he is impeached and replaced by Vance.

If their internal situation is grim or their hold on power faltering, sure, they might dial back their expectations for something closer to status quo. They seem to be benefiting from a rally around the flag effect, though.

That's why I think DeSantis is the Republican's best bet in 2028. He's the only one not tainted by this mess and he can point to his incredible record as a governor.

Maybe. But DeSantis will look ugly and fat on stage next to slick Newsom. In the battle of the white guys, glistening California will beat sweaty Florida. It would be a campaign with almost zero policy, a lot of traded insults, some macho posturing on both sides, and then Newsom would win.

Newsom is DOA and has no chance getting through the Dem Primary, especially since the 2024 rework of the order the primaries are done to give more power to the Black political machine in SC and elsewhere. Even bringing the guy up is nonserious. You're looking at Jon Ossof, Andy Bashear, Gretchen Witmer, Josh Shapiro in that order.

Shapiro is far too Zionist, he’s openly Zionist, proposed in Jerusalem, tried to ban support for BDS etc, he’s never going anywhere now. Ossoff has moved around on Israel but has been somewhat critical. There is a nebbish energy around him though.

I still feel like there’s a good chance the 2028 Dem nominee is a relative outsider, someone who’s not currently a national name. I’ll be surprised if AOC isn’t a player, although she’s not at all likely to win it imo. Given the way things are going right now I kind of doubt it’s going to be a Jewish guy, either, although that could change. It’s true that Ossoff looks pretty damn good after Tuesday. I do also agree that Newsom is not going to be the guy.

Running Newsom would be a huge mistake. The guy is like a caricature of a smarmy politician. They need Ossoff or Beshear.

That’s why their only hope is to backstab him now. He’s guilty of numerous crimes so this time they can just let Democrats take him out. Trump can’t be president in 2028 if they have any hope of winning. He has to be completely out of the picture and discredited. If he had any integrity he’d resign, but we all know that will never happen.

That was pretty much what McConnell was banking on after J6, and we all saw how that went.

That was 6 years ago. He's 80 and has just been humiliated. Things are different now.

Might be a bit of learned helplessness at this point.

Trump voters aren’t going to abandon him because the rest of the GOP let them jail him. They will stay home and 2028 is a slaughter. Somehow they will need to engage the Fuentes vote and pull Hispanics into the fold.

For that reason Vance is dead. A Hispanic like Rubio will help even though he’s almost pure European or you have to bet on Desantis who might even do well with boomers who see him as a true adult. Either one needs blessed by Trump.

Rubio is DOA and has no chance in the midwest even before the latest neocon adventures. Rubio is how you spell George W Bush in Spanish. The coalition which won in 2024 has no interest in trading the Iran idiocy for a Cuban idiocy to vindicate Rubio's racial vendetta against Cuba.

Picking DEI candidates because you think the right colored Republican will bring racial groups into the fold is something done so many times and failed so many times that it's a meme at this point to make fun of.

Hispanics came out in record numbers for a rich white billionaire in suits from NYC. They want policies and they want action. Maybe we should learn this lesson instead of paying a scummy Republican consultant to find a closeted gay disabled black to run on the ticket... again.

I mean I’m open to a Trump military dictatorship but if I take anything from this election we need Hispanic votes to win in a Democracy and once Trump wasn’t just “strong man Brazil” and actually did deportations we lost the Hispanic vote.

the GOP has been running various races of candidates promising closet amnesty to illegals for decades. In fact, the post-mortem of the 2012 Romney loss was that the GOP wasn't going soft enough on immigration. And then Trump won the 2016 election based on illegal deportations and shutting down the border with the most hispanics vote-share ever

hispanics want illegals to be deported; what they dont want is for their tough guy to get into office and govern for billionaires and foreign countries causing the cost of living to go up

you win the hispanics by playing to economic populism

if MAGA isn't deporting illegals, what's even the point of MAGA?

I mean, to be sure, MAGA is dead and the America First crown is sitting in the gutter waiting to get picked up by someone else

Outside of MAGA, Trump is poison now so they really have nothing to lose by dumping him. They are cooked if he is still around in 2028 so might as well do a Hail Mary. Fuentes people will not vote for anyone associated with MAGA or Israel, and he may have enough power to knock off a half percentage of the vote and cause them to lose.

The Hanania and Fuentes crowd were never going to vote for a Republican of any stripe, and are generally viewed with contempt by the voter base (to the extent that the voter base is aware of them at all). Have you ever seen a more "punchable" face than this one? I don't think I have.

Now while I would never underestimate a Republicans' ability to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory, fact remains that as of today Rubio's Gulf-Coast Coalition remains the most powerful faction within the GOP's internal politics and anyone looking to win the nomination will either have to go through them or get approved by them.

if you think Fuentes (or at least Fuentes-like beliefs) doesn't have sway with most GOP staffers or volunteers under the age of 35, you can look forward to another electoral disaster

the Florida Mafia's power is connected, and tarnished, at the hip to the Trump sinking ship

I think Fuentes has a lot of pull with the sort of person who posts here, but I also don't believe that anyone here (with the possible exception of @Shakes and @100ProofTollBooth) is voting for a Republican (much less working for one).

What? I could name a ton of people here that voted Republican. I personally voted straight Republican myself.

I'm probably the most openly partisan MAGA Republican floating around here but I'd be shocked if I were really the only Republican voter.

fuentes has little pull, but fuentes-like politics is very popular in staffers under 35

voting for a Republican (much less working for one).

well, that's nice but you're wrong

Eh, maybe in some of the state-level machines and edgy college republican clubs who don't have to care about actual electoral politics because they're in D+30 college towns. But DC staffers, the go getters who are going to make up most of the next generation of influential Republicans, are very much not groypers. Those people are mostly the same mix of Squarejaw McPromking and autistic libertarian they've always been.

More comments

Maybe but I would bet good money that Harris and Biden voters here out number Trump voters by a solid 2 to 1. Ditto Talarico vs. Paxton, and El-Sayed vs. Stevens Rogers. While this space has a reputation as being a "right wing" space it's important to remember that it is really only "right wing" within the context of it's founding population of Berkley Area contrarians and edgy-reddit atheists. Pretty much everyone in this forum from @Opt-out to @magicalkittycat would immediately find them selves sorted into the "authoritarian left" quadrant of the political compass if they were dropped into the comments section of someplace like frieghtwaves, ar15.com, or the median IRC channel from the mid 2000s.

More comments

I won’t vote if it’s not maga and there are a lot of me.

Thank you for your service.

Have fun with Democrats controlling all 3 branches then.

Democrats are going to be much more cautious about impeaching Trump as it backfired in the past. The only way I see them moving forward with it would be the unlikely scenario where Republicans are driving the train where they demand it, and these demands continue long enough that enough Senators are on the record long enough and adamant enough that by the time they get to vote for removal there's nothing left to lose. The reason I think this is unlikely is that most of the vulnerable Republicans are already out, and, as @2rafa said, there's enough residual support in the party that it's risky going against him. You can already see this in comments by Ron DeSantis and others, who will blame anyone and everyone for the blowout except Trump himself. DeSantis, in particular, was cautious about blaming the loss on the Iran War without pointing out that Trump was in the driver's seat for that. In MAGA-world, Trump can't fail, he can only be failed. So if the ICE stuff turned people off it was because Kristi Noem handled it badly, if the Iran War was a mistake it was Hesgeth and Rubio's mistake, if tariffs were a bad idea then it was Howard Lutnick's idea, etc.

So in this scenario they quietly or overtly threaten him with impeachment (ie supporting an inevitable Dem impeachment vote) and he pardons himself for absolutely everything, then resigns to give them what they want.

He then spends the next two years talking about his betrayal. All the while, the Republicans are still in control of the presidency, his base is completely fractured with many more conspiratorial supporters thinking he was backstabbed by Epstein RINOs or something, and they lose in a landslide in 2028.

Vance cannot win a presidential election, or probably even a primary.

The big lesson here IMO should be properly understanding the mandate. It won't be learned, but it should. The American people primarily care about bread and butter topics as always, and your win on those as the "best of two evil" does not mean free reign to throw away economic concerns and start doing whatever you want. Like it or not most Americans still think of the parties as giant douche vs turd sandwich, and if you're turd sandwich, you do not pile on extra shit after a win.

But that's exactly what happened. Consider the infamous "Harris is for they/them, Trump is for you" ad. The underlying message painted Harris as an idealogue concerned about irrelevant topics like trans people, and Trump as caring about the real topics. But what did Republicans take away from this? The exact opposite of what they should have learned, they hyper focused on culture war shit. They spent their ad focus and money saying tranny 50 times in a mirror hoping to summon the voters again, and it failed.

And likewise with overreach. Voters are very clear that they don't like trans people participating in their preferred sports, but in general they actually trust Democrats more on the overall topic!. Most voters don't want big daddy government coming in and repressing people's access to hormone treatments or discriminating in employment or anything like that.

Focusing the political discussion on trans people both makes the GOP look out of touch and cruel.

This has happened with Trump on basically every topic. The average voter does not consider the US in an existential crisis that needs 100 million deportations. They want a secure border where criminals can't get in, but they don't want a border so shut down and so hard to get visas with that their favorite voice actors are barred from entering. Yes a single concert by itself isn't a big deal, but it's not just a single concert. It is just one example of the many ways that overreach and a misunderstanding of the border mandate happened. Yet putting extremists in charge who want to limit foreigners of all kinds and of all types into the country inevitably leads to these fuckups.

And then if it wasn't for all this shit, there's also Trump specific problems too. Even if you're a hardcore conservative who thinks two years of idealogical overreach is worth the political sacrifice, Trump is barely even doing that well! He's focusing on his ballroom, the reflecting pool, threatening to invade Canada and Greenland over and over! He's probably spent more time on the white house's furnishings than he did trying to pass real legislation with the trifecta. Certainly even a hardcore idealogue is well aware of how no voter gives a shit about that and watching the president ignore the Real Issues in favor of such nonsense is a bad look right?

The good news for Republicans is that the Dems won this election so hard that they might get cocky overreach on their new mandate and fuck things up. The bad news is that Trump is still president and will not only be causing new issues (if 2025 Trump is threatening to invade Canada, maybe 2028 Trump is threatening to bomb France. Who knows at this point?) but just by having the seat and being the guy in charge will be eating the blame for general problems.

He's focusing on his ballroom, the reflecting pool

The arch too, I think the Dems could trade for a lot (healthcare subsidies) if they would also fund the ballroom and/or arch.

Good post. Trump II has been a colossal, pathetic waste of what was really a historic opportunity for the American right. I’d add that this is the exact same error the Biden admin committed, taking a mandate for “stabilize the government and focus on things like physical infrastructure and protecting the economy” as an opportunity to go Full Woke, then getting thrown out four years later. Trump’s own personal… idiosyncrasies… just happened to turn it to 11 this time around and speedrun the effect.

Good post. Trump II has been a colossal, pathetic waste of what was really a historic opportunity for the American righ

Unfortunately, that opportunity only existed because of him in the first place, so you can't have one without the other.

Indeed. He deserves credit for running a great campaign and creating that remarkable political moment… and then promptly pissing it all away.

I’ve never been a Trump fan by any means (I voted Dem-Dem-Libertarian for president in 2016-20-24) but I actually had some optimism after he won in 2024, and I certainly was enjoying the cultural vibe shift. “The man himself may be a narcissistic idiot”, I thought, “but the movement around him is vibrant and has attracted people who seem to sincerely care about some of the real problems facing the country. He’ll probably do some stupid shit but this is a great chance to make some positive changes too.” The end result has been, while not 100% bad, below my lowest expectations. Maximal burning of political capital for minimal results.

You don’t think that a Romney Republican would have wiped the floor with Harris/Biden? Trump is a unique candidate to be sure in motivating the base, but he also won against uniquely unlikeable candidates in Clinton and Harris.

No, I don't think so. A big part of the revolt that caused Trump in the first place was overboiling frustration at the apparent uselessness of the GOP Congress. Time and again nominally Republican congresses failed to advance the ball on issues that conservatives cared about. The Tea Party movement harnessed a lot of energy and won substantial victories, which resulted in almost nothing except some tax cuts. Even at that time, the constant attempts to sell out the base on immigration and spending were infuriating. Trump's popularity was at least as much a middle finger to the GOP establishment as it was to the Democrats, so in 2016, I don't think another standard GOP Republican could get anywhere near enough of those voters to turn out.

It's possible that the disaffection of the Bernie wing of the Democratic party in 2016 contributed a lot to Trump's ability to get swing votes and even create new swing voters. Perhaps it is true that Republicans would have struggled to win without these voters in 2016, but it would have likely been a nail-biter. My view is that you are underestimating just how much everyone hated and hates Hillary, especially the self-anointed vibe that both she and Harris give off. Given the inflation, senility scandal and overreaches of Biden's term, I have a very, very hard time believing that a non-Trump Republican (Rubio is an obvious example) would not have won against Harris in 2024 - perhaps the only counterargument here is that Trump's first term was actually quite productive and good.

My view is that you are underestimating just how much everyone hated and hates Hillary, especially the self-anointed vibe that both she and Harris give off.

I think you are over-estimating how much Hillary hatred existed among the left prior to her losing to Trump. She did, after all, get about the same number of votes as the very popular Obama did in 2012 against the same Mitt Romney. Even with Trump bringing all these disaffected voters out to vote, she still did get more votes and the election was very close, so if we presume all the disaffected voters stay home, that mostly hurts the Republican and Hillary wins easily.

2016 was just kind of the beginning of incredibly hotly contested elections, i.e., ones in which Trump participates; Obama vs Romney was not nearly so intense. Plus, there is 4 years of population growth so the slightly fewer votes Clinton got vs Obama in 2016 was probably like 3% lower per capita. If Clinton is only against a normal Republican, it is very unlikely that she gets anywhere close to that turnout, while Republicans would have indeed been running against a great turnout motivator in Clinton (or, shit, Sanders; I would have voted for any candidate at all in 2016 opposing Trump or Sanders).

Regarding Hillary hatred among the left, my thinking on this is from my friends and family who, amid the 2016 election and primaries, talked about how much they hated her. As a fan of competence, I liked her, but vibes-based voters absolutely loathed her and pretty much always had.

You don’t think that a Romney Republican would have wiped the floor with Harris/Biden?

You mean "Romney" as in evil theocrat misogynist dog-torturing Bain Capital rich ruthless oppressor of the working class Mitt Romney? The worst possible guy to elect for president (back when he was campaigning)? Literally Hitler Mitt Romney? (Though to be fair, apparently Mittens' campaign drew fire for engaging in the old Nazi hyperbole themselves).

That Romney Republican?

Trump was called worse. Including by GOPers he eventually won over, like Vance.

Yes, I think that a traditional Republican, though sure to be tarred and feathered by opposition operators, would have beaten the widely disliked Clinton in 2016 or Harris in 2024 (even within the Democrat party). Trump only won against particularly bad candidates, and it was pretty close. I think that a more normal Republican candidate would have also won those elections. Romney went against a uniquely good Democrat candidate and was himself probably a better candidate than anyone in the past few decades.

Romney Republicans had zero chance against Clinton or Harris

edit links with past discussions about this topic

No, I think any other Republican candidate gets beat in both those elections, though narrowly. Trump boosted Republican voting by low-propensity voters far beyond what it had previously and had major downballot coattails. Given demographic trends, I think it's unlikely any non-populist Republicans can win national elections. ETA: Obviously, if Hillary won the first time, Biden and probably Harris never happens anyways, it would be 8 years of Clinton

Obviously, if Hillary won the first time, Biden and probably Harris never happens anyways, it would be 8 years of Clinton

Yeah, I agree with that. She would probably have an average first term, then be unenthusiastically but loyally put forward as the candidate for a second term because of incumbency advantage and run against whoever the Republicans could persuade to go in 2020*, leaving the field open for another Democratic candidate in 2024 versus whatever Republican didn't go against her in 2020.

Biden, no matter how pissed-off he is about not getting his turn, never happens if Hillary wins 2016 and Harris stays in California and maybe runs (and loses) against Newsom for governor.

*Jeb! Part II is not going to happen either, hilarious as it might be.

any other Republican candidate gets beat in both those elections, though narrowly

The question is poorly conceived. A Romney Republican isn't going to get nominated in 2020 or 2024 in a world in which Trump wins in 2016, even if he dies of diet coke poisoning in his first term. The GOP had already been running hot with a populist revolt when Trump won the nomination, and that only intensified over the course of the first term. If Trump dies of health complications or just decides he's bored of being president, the likely successor is someone like Ted Cruz cosplaying as Trump. And that would go very poorly - the hardcore Trumpists, at least so far, seem to accept no substitutes, while the people who disdain Trump are not going to be drawn back by that messaging.

On the other hand, if Trump just... doesn't run in 2016, I think the likely nominees (Cruz or Rubio, neither of whom are really Romney Republicans, but close enough) handily beat HRC. Clinton was a WEAK candidate who would have lost to almost any credible Republican after eight years of a Democratic presidency on sheer thermostatic backlash if nothing else.

Trump boosted Republican voting by low-propensity voters far beyond what it had previously and had major downballot coattails.

He also repels a lot of traditionally centrist demographics like suburban professionals and has likely calcified a massive amount of winnable votes as near-permanent Democrats. And the suburban professionals vote every year.

I think the likely nominees (Cruz or Rubio, neither of whom are really Romney Republicans, but close enough) handily beat HRC

I dunno. I'm not seeing Ted beating Hillary, because just the notion of him running as the Republican candidate for president makes me go "no". Hillary versus Marco? Probably closer. But I think the Clinton machine would be just able to pull it off (especially if they dumped the misguided 'Obama won on Big Data, we must copy that' approach which steered them in the abysmally wrong direction). You did need someone with pizazz to appeal to all those unenthused by the prospect of voting for the Empress but dismally prepared to hold their noses and do it since the GOP candidates were as appealing as congealed porridge. And Trump, for all his many faults, had that pizazz.

I don't agree at all. Obama was still very popular in 2015 (for a lame duck President) and Clinton was the designated successor for his political juggernaut of a coalition. She had experience in the outgoing admin, national politics, and Presidential administration, and had a huge base of institutional DNC support. Bill was still widely liked. She was at least as well positioned as HW Bush was after Reagan.

He also repels a lot of traditionally centrist demographics like suburban professionals and has likely calcified a massive amount of winnable votes as near-permanent Democrats. And the suburban professionals vote every year.

They had already been lost to the Obama coalition and weren't coming back. Certainly not for Cruz or Rubio.

I don't agree at all. Obama was still very popular in 2015 (for a lame duck President) and Clinton was the designated successor for his political juggernaut of a coalition.

Given all this, it's pretty notable then that her planned coronation collapsed and she faced a challenge from her left in Sanders - and Sanders was a dark horse; she had to do some work to get Biden out of there first. No one knows what it would have looked like had Joe run then, especially with Sanders also running.

You're not wrong about all of the stuff on paper Hillary had going for her that made her ascension seem certain to Democrats, but the actual public reaction to her was more lukewarm than you'd think just from reading her advantages.

And how would said Romney Republican get into a position to do that? Nikki Haley tried and lost, fair and square.

She lost in the primary to Trump so I’m slightly confused how she would not be a potential counterfactual that could have been the candidate if not for Trump “creating the opportunity”. We would be talking a more traditional style of campaign and policy, probably.

Your response brushed aside the contention that pusher_robot had, that the race against Harris/Biden was only because Trump created the opportunity in the first place. You'd have to establish some mechanism for him exiting the race after his first term. He couldn't and didn't serve just one term, because he's Trump, and he doesn't work like that.

As for my opinion, probably a Romney Republican really could have beat Harris/Biden, and I was really hoping that Nikki Haley would get the nomination.

All it would have taken was him deciding he was too old and lazy and just wanted to golf all day or something. This does not seem that crazy. I do not agree at all that Dem victory would have been inevitable if not for the low propensity voters Trump got support from.

I still don’t understand this “creating the opportunity” idea. The race was always going to be closely contested Democrat vs Republican, in any of 2016, 2020 or 2024.

All it would have taken was him deciding he was too old and lazy and just wanted to golf all day or something.

I am moderately convinced that "leaving the interns in charge" was precisely the main issue with the Biden administration. Voters elected an old man expecting old-school policies and got, well, whatever that was.

I'm not completely convinced that isn't an issue for the current administration, either.

That's the very sad part. Trump created an option to stop America from turning into California and then to Europe, and then he himself - in close cooperation with the GOP - made sure this option was destroyed. Nobody outside Trump on the Republican team is even close to being able to do the same. So people that want change have an option between having no hope at all and having their hopes up and then immediately crushed.

The point of politics isn’t to get your team jobs it’s to do IMPORTANT things. Voter mandates don’t matter.

I think when all the data comes out it’s going to be Hispanics being the biggest swing. And yes the GOP is going to have some serious political questions to think about when like 40% of voters are not Americans. That’s the problem.

That is classist as fuck. I have a PhD and I regularly rely on browser spell checkers to get words such as sycophant spelled right. (I am also not a native speaker, nor an American, but that is besides the point.) I would probably have gotten hypotenuse wrong (it has a th in German and with other words like cathode the spelling stays the same while the pronounciation diverges).

I might as well say "If you do not know what Black Lotus, Beholder, the Red Wedding or Force Choke refer to you should not be voting" to define my arbitrary bubble, or refer to fancy french dinner terms instead.

Spelling correctly is even worse an ability, it is as obsolete as the ability to divide large integers with a pen. Sure, a lack of ability to spell pedestrian or calculate 216/8 might be indicative of some serious gaps in one's education, but it is not per se damning.

The thing I would prefer in voters is if they had good world models. This is a bit harder to quantify that just your class boundary, though. There is also the question if having bad world models in some domains (e.g. believing in astrology) is actually correlated with having bad world models relevant to politics (unless you select your candidates directly be their zodiac sign, in which case I would definitely prefer you refrained from voting).

"Classist" - yeah, I think so. It's mostly supposed to be funny, but I posted it in a comment to someone exonerating voters for voting contrary to their former interests as a punishment vote.

As I already commented to another, I was probably drinking one afternoon back in 2010, and it just popped into my head.

It was directed at my side of the political fuss, back when republicans were flipping their loyalties from Mitt Romney to Newt Gingrich to Rick Santorum, at break-neck speed, over any little faux pas.

The point as I have commented elsewhere, is that one should know by a certain point in their life - what is good for themself, what is good for their family, their neighborhood, their community, and have solid beliefs of what is good for their country. And because of that, they should already know what they will vote for next election, and the next, and the next.

What is this new-fangledness with the spelling of "hiccough", prithee?

In what direction do you expect such a policy to shift the election outcome, and why?

I don't think it would have shifted the outcome of this election.

My call is to preserve the integrity of this country in the Founder's conception and, yes, in my interpretation.

Certain ideas are not good for society, and we have to concede that we (humankind) for the most part, have decided that we want the benefits of that society - more productive, divisions of labor, safety, law and order, etc., so allowing ideas that have no positive grounding in math or history is destructive, and to us all I believe.

In my experience, restrict-voting-to-the-educated proposals mostly come from right-wingers, though I would be unsurprised myself if the effects of such a proposal would end up favouring Democrats.

It is, of course, possible that someone might sincerely, for principled reasons, support a reform that would harm their own side.

(My opinion is that these proposals are misguided - they inevitably hand a huge amount of power over to whoever it is who gets to decide the criteria for voting. I can understand the intuitive appeal of the idea that you should understand the political system and have a basic ability to analyse problems before you can make a choice about it, but in practice I don't think it can be fairly implemented. Moreover, I also tend to think that interests often matter in voting more than intelligence does. I don't expect insert-stupid-demographic-here to be more capable of analysing problems than insert-smart-demographic-here. I do expect, however, the stupid demographic to be more motivated to vote for their own interests than people outside that demographic, and so their voting forces politicians to take that demographic's interests seriously. There is a cut-off below which people are too intellectually handicapped to vote (e.g. someone with dementia, someone with severe development retardation, etc.), and I'd agree with excluding those people, but I don't think that illiteracy, lack of English proficiency, an IQ of 80, etc., should be disqualifiers.)

(In this particular case I think it's interesting that IntoTheWind's screening test is about English language proficiency. I assume he intends it as a proxy for mental acuity in general, but I think its main effects would be to exclude people with low English ability and people with small vocabularies. I might suggest that verbal agility, though, is a skill that one associates more with educated demographics that skew left, so it might not have the effect he wants.)

Is America doomed to fail, and is it near-term? I want to find a solution to this because the answer should be no, but that's not where we are headed. We must conclude that the people who disagree with us, those who voted opposite to our desires yesterday, are who they are, as a product of their environment. Their rearing, their education, their associations, and if what has been inculcated in them has been biased in the opposite of my/our own values their whole life, and if now they are part of the third and perhaps fourth generation holding the same biases down from their forefathers, never having heard anything but that bias, than we understand the unsolvable conflict ripping this country apart today.

How can we reinform those in our society who are tearing down that society? Eighty years of forced contrition? And how do we overcome the captured institutions and the corrupt politicians and unelected bureaucrats to put resolute legislation into effect? Such does not seem workable. Do we let the society crumble until violent revolution is the only alternative left beside our own contrition?

I simply posit the following: The Founders of this country formed the government of The United States and the Constitution protecting it from the best western traditions of representative government from Greece on down. They did so to guarantee that we are a constitutional republic and that we would remain that way. Therefore, no tinkering with the specificities of language or colloquial interpretations thereof, can allow for a change in that intent. I.e. The U.S. Constitution innately protects its own survival. It guarantees the right to personal property, separation of powers, the freedom of religion, the rule of law. It does not allow the substitution or adoption of any other ideology - communism, socialism, etc., to supplant it.

The Oath Clause (Article VI, Clause 3 of the U.S. Constitution) states: "The Senators and Representatives before mentioned, and the Members of the several State Legislatures, and all executive and judicial Officers, both of the United States and of the several States, shall be bound by Oath or Affirmation, to support this Constitution; ..."

Attorney Generals in all 50 states whether corrupt or not, must be made to enforce this law. This law removes the likes of Bernie Sanders, AOC, Ilhan Omar, El Sayed and any others of their ilk from office and should have prevented all DSA candidates from even running. Enforcing this law is the only way we can preserve this country as intended. Enforcing it, may make you mad at me - make you hate my guts - but it does not force you to change your opinions.

The Oath Clause (Article VI, Clause 3 of the U.S. Constitution) states: "The Senators and Representatives before mentioned, and the Members of the several State Legislatures, and all executive and judicial Officers, both of the United States and of the several States, shall be bound by Oath or Affirmation, to support this Constitution; ..."

Attorney Generals in all 50 states whether corrupt or not, must be made to enforce this law. This law removes the likes of Bernie Sanders, AOC, Ilhan Omar, El Sayed and any others of their ilk from office and should have prevented all DSA candidates from even running.

Who was the guy who incited a mob again to storm the capitol to interrupt the certification of an election conducted according to that very constitution? Was it Sayed or Sanders again?

Also, if you want to have a constitution which protects you against socialism, my advise is that you campaign for an amendment. The Takings clause, "nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation." does not say that the government is not allowed to socialize your steel mill. Or you simply amass a larger majority and get rid of the relevant part of 5A, which is also perfectly legal.

It is totally legal to run on a platform to socialize all the means of production. If you try to pass the laws, it would be likely that the courts have a different idea on what "just compensation" entails than what you had earmarked for the buyout. But even that would not make you a traitor to the constitution. It happens quite frequently that the SCOTUS tells an administration "that thing you were trying to do does not work like that due to constitutional reasons". For the most part, that in itself is the fix, you do not generally get branded a traitor for trying to do something which is ruled unconstitutional.

It’s been going that way for a long time. De Touqueville was right in suggesting that once the idea that the government exists to give them personally things, it was all over. Unfortunately that’s the biggest problem with democracy, because the way to win is to promise to do exactly that. You promise to give people more gibs than the other guy, and win. And because democracy is about winning elections and not necessarily governing, you end up with people who know how to pander to their base, to promise various forms of gibs, to loot the treasury and pass legislation that would hand the prosperity of society to your base, and not to run the country in a sane way that promotes growth and security.

True, true, but I may have muddled my point: that the Founders intent should obviously be honored. I don't think the Oath Clause fails as the letter of the law, but if fudging interpretists want to only apply it should you lie about insurrection activities, I believe we must follow the spirit of the law.

Attorney Generals in all 50 states whether corrupt or not, must be made to enforce this law.

Must? Be made to enforce this by whom, and how? As the old cliché goes: you and what army?

It has been suggested to me that a mandamus petition can be filed in each state (They need to be simultaneously filed). That such is an inexpensive filing - about $400 - and that by law, the AG must respond in short order, less than 30 days.

Because we notified every reporting outlet, honest or not, Joe Rogan and his ilk, and included the social media giants of X and TikTok, that we had done so, regardless of the particular blue-state refusals or equivocations, it would force public awareness and a national conversation that couldn't be avoided or completely hidden.

I am soliciting. Any interested takers? FL, TX, AK AG's?

Is America doomed to fail?

Yes, because every government, every civilization, is doomed to fail sooner or later.

Is it near-term?

Couldn't tell you with any certainty. I don't believe so, but I don't have a crystal ball. I don't imagine we will make it another 250 years, nor do I imagine things will fall apart in the next 20, but that's just my guess.

Well, let's at least try to preserve it by honoring the Founders intent.

I see once more we have thought of the novel idea, "What if we could make it so our enemies don't get to vote?"

I'm sorry to inform you that if the American people want to vote for communism or Shariah law or the Hunger Games, the Constitution does not in fact prevent that.

I think the clause speaks for itself, but if unclear, my appeal is to the logic that the Founder's intent should prevail and be respected. If someone is against personal property, the separation of powers, the rule of law, and frankly against Christianity, they are unable to honestly swear to defend the Constitution.

I don't advocate for banning anyone's religion or opinions. But certain positions just disqualify some from holding or seeking office under the Constitution.

I think the clause speaks for itself, but if unclear, my appeal is to the logic that the Founder's intent should prevail and be respected.

That logic is not in the Constitution. You may believe we should "respect the Founder's intent" (and that only Christians should be allowed to hold office) but that's not what they wrote.

the oath clause is pretty much pointless decoration, yeah?

Well, no, you are required to uphold and defend the Constitution, and if someone literally said "I don't believe in the Constitution and I want to destroy the Republic," there'd be a good case to deny that person office. But whatever you might suspect about certain elected officials, merely holding political or religious views contrary to what the Founders would have approved of doesn't mean someone isn't capable of following the Constitution.

"I put a foreign country above the country I swore to serve" is good enough for me that they are incapable of following the Constitution, but I am aware that too many people disagree. Those people are wrong.

I don't actually disagree, but I am not sure what you are specifically proposing. Jews and Muslims and Indians are assumed to be loyal to Israel/Palestine/India, or what? If someone declares their allegiance to a foreign country, yes, they are in violation of their oath. If someone talks about their deep cultural connection to a foreign country and you think that is a foreign loyalty, then you're going to have to exclude Irish-, Italian-, Swedish-, Mexican- etc Americans as well.

If someone talks about their deep cultural connection to a foreign country and you think that is a foreign loyalty, then you're going to have to exclude Irish-, Italian-, Swedish-, Mexican- etc Americans as well.

Roosevelt's speech about hyphens as daggers is a perennial classic for a reason.

More comments

"immediately remove from office any people that profess their adherence to a foreign power over their actual constituents and this Constitution" really should've been an obvious rule to put in there, and yet, they missed it.

Isn't the power to amend the Constitution unlimited? Theoretically, an Amendment could strike out the entire previous text of the Constitution and replace the whole thing with a sentence that says "The purpose of the government of these United States is to implement fully automated luxury gay space communism."

Edit: apparently I was wrong. It's almost unlimited, but not completely unlimited. You have to continue to allow states to have equal suffrage in the Senate unless they voluntarily give it up:

"The Congress, whenever two thirds of both Houses shall deem it necessary, shall propose Amendments to this Constitution, or, on the Application of the Legislatures of two thirds of the several States, shall call a Convention for proposing Amendments, which, in either Case, shall be valid to all Intents and Purposes, as Part of this Constitution, when ratified by the Legislatures of three fourths of the several States, or by Conventions in three fourths thereof, as the one or the other Mode of Ratification may be proposed by the Congress; Provided that no Amendment which may be made prior to the Year One thousand eight hundred and eight shall in any Manner affect the first and fourth Clauses in the Ninth Section of the first Article; and that no State, without its Consent, shall be deprived of its equal Suffrage in the Senate."

affect the first and fourth Clauses in the Ninth Section of the first Article

Your point: The U.S. Constitution does not contain an explicit "eternity clause" ... Correct. That said, some theorists have argued that there may be implicit limits on amendment power, such as a prohibition on destroying the Constitution's fundamental character (for example, abolishing republican government altogether).

This is what I was trying to say. The Founders did their best. Their intent should prevail and be respected.

I mean, you can just amend the constitution to remove this first: Provided that no Amendment which may be made prior to the Year One thousand eight hundred and eight shall in any Manner affect the first and fourth Clauses in the Ninth Section of the first Article; and that no State, without its Consent, shall be deprived of its equal Suffrage in the Senate.

Was this written by an LLM? Could you actually state your thesis? Are you suggesting there's some text in the constitution that forbids "communism, socialism, etc.". That strikes me as an even more absurd claim than believing that supporters of those ideologies have any meaningful connection to the winners of yesterday's elections.

No. Yes. Those that hold and advocate for ideas inconsistent with constitutional values and protections cannot honestly affirm to uphold and protect the Constitution.

Was this written by an LLM?

Doesn't look like it

I wasn't sure because it doesn't have the sentence structure AI tells that I recognize, but it has the similar feel of reading it of feeling contentless/disconnected. I can believe that's it's human-written nonsense.

I.e. The U.S. Constitution innately protects its own survival.

The Constitution is dead. Abstract rules cannot, have not, will not constrain human will.

We cannot agree on what the laws even are, and you propose law as a solution?

Blues have spent decades building systems to divert public money to their perception-shaping apparatus. They finance their political operations out of our taxes, we finance ours out of whatever spare change is left in our pockets. We must destroy their structures and build our own. We should have done this long ago, and there certainly is no excuse for failing to do it with whatever power remains to us and with whatever power we are able to acquire in the future. This is the best use political power can be turned to in the foreseeable future; failure to do so is abdication.

Cooperation with Blues is impossible. Anything that requires cooperation with Blues to function is no longer an option, hasn't been for at least a decade; this obviously includes any foreign war. The Blues have no solutions to any of the actual problems, with one notable exception, so other than that notable exception all those problems are going to get worse. This will make people increasingly angry, increasingly policy-starved, increasingly radical. That anger can and will be harnessed, by Reds or Blues. The only viable path forward is to use that power to make things legibly better, better in terms of actual outcomes, legibly in terms of perception of those outcomes. Long term costs don't matter when there is no long term. It is still conceivably possible to secure wins through political processes, and we should secure as many of them as possible through whatever time the final breakdown of the political process affords us.

Past that time, Shai LeBeouf, Shai LeBeouf, Shai LeBeouf.

Past that time, Shai LeBeouf, Shai LeBeouf, Shai LeBeouf.

Would you be kind enough to explain this to those of us who don't want to read horrible web fiction to get the reference?

Horrible?

Tried reading it once. Bailed after a chapter. I seriously do not get the appeal of some of the works recommended in rat-spheres.

In the story, if you speak the name Shai LeBeouf aloud, Actual Cannibal Shia LeBeouf appears and kills you and many other people in the immediate vicinity. In that chapter, the antagonist exploits this fact to use the name as a cognitohazard suicide bomb.

I am using the reference as shorthand for actively working to destroy the existing sociopolitical structure in ways that are notably effective and difficult to reverse. Sociopolitical scorched earth tactics, literal scorched earth too where possible. The last several years are best modelled as a massive, distributed search for ways to hurt the outgroup as badly as possible without getting in too much trouble; this process is information-based, and it can be manipulated purely by participating in the search in a conscious and intentional manner, thus greatly increasing information flow and search efficiency. This can be done legally, safely, covertly, a switch analogue to Blues' employment of the dial. There's at least an argument that past a certain point it should be done. We are not at that point yet, but we probably moved significantly closer last night.

If not being ruled by people who hate you is a priority, it's probably better to destroy the throne and the crown and the fields, the bridge, the mill, than to allow the other side uncontested control of them. Blues did not actually get more reasonable or moderate last night, just more powerful. Or maybe I'm wrong, and they've learned their lessons, and we're in for an era of moderate, sensible centrism, lol, lmao.