I feel like I would care about a similar situation (“a committee for AI and…”) but can’t find the reason to here. Knowing a millennium problem is solved (with the proof itself incomprehensible) has practically no significance to anyone outside mathematics for anything outside pride and curiosity. And we’ll probably get the solutions soon, if not from OpenAI, by a second rate model that has caught up to today’s Astra.
I have the opposite opinion: I don't understand why people keep talking about the lab leak because I don't understand how it changes anything.
China is already an enemy of the US who can probably conduct whatever research they want. Even if the US makes a deal and threatens sanctions, they can agree and conduct it in secret. And declaring war on them is almost certain to cause millions if not billions of causalities (MAD), while shady research merely has the potential.
Gain of Function research is already a bad idea, and we can take (and are taking) steps to prevent the next manmade pandemic, regardless of whether or not COVID was manmade.
Prosecuting Fauci and other American scientists involves more than proving the lab leak, they must also be involved, and it's an uphill battle when people who we know committed crimes (like O.J. Simpson, Bill Cosby), let alone did something unethical-but-maybe-technically-legal (like Mark Zuckerberg), avoid justice. My philosophy is that it's more important to prevent future crimes, which in this case means making laws against shoddy or unmonitored wet lab research; but again, we can and should do this without proving COVID was artificial.
Censoring the lab-leak hypothesis - we should already not be censoring even "misinformation", and COVID shows how that fails, including that some of the censored claims may have been correct (such as masks not as effective as stated). The fact that now even leftist media says the lab leak is plausible makes its censorship especially egregious, even if it eventually gets disproven.
COVID provides many lessons on how to prevent and handle future pandemics. In particular, the plausible explanations on how it may have originated from the lab provide lessons on the former. But it doesn't technically matter whether they happened, just whether they're still plausible after scrutiny, and even that doesn't really matter, because the regulations can and probably should cover other hypotheticals.
It's XXcancel. It redirects to a random instance.
I am unable to check the twitter links for the above, as my account for twitter has been locked out barring cell phone verification, so I cannot confirm they work or link to what they say anymore.
Replace x.com with xxcancel.com or one of the live nitter instances.
It’s more accepted in workplaces and less by hobbyists. I know many hobbyists which rudely refuse any LLM involvement, even projects used in production that began as hobbyist, like Adwaita and Zig (here’s a big list).
Until the day we use neuralink to grant ChatGPT read/write access to our brains, the final permission dialog, you have to express your thoughts in writing at least to ChatGPT. And I genuinely prefer the prose of Jeffrey Epstein’s emails to a verbose wall of slop, because at least he gets to the point.
Morality-wise, for art and personal communication (including forums), I think it’s fine for someone to use LLMs as long as they disclose and the platform doesn’t forbid it. Not disclosing upfront is so-so, what’s very rude is lying when asked.
Outside morality, I’d recommend maybe using LLM assistance, but making the surface output 100% you, even if that means paraphrasing LLM text or tracing LLM art. Ideally you’d double-check and improve it in the process.
I think when LLMs help create something genuinely impressive and only do it requiring human assistance, their public perception will improve. Most people don’t care about digital art or synthetic music because it contains human expression, those tools are very flexible and different people have widely different styles, but LLM output tends to be very similar and is hard to guide.
That’s an old post, I think GPT-3. Older LLMs did sound more original, although they hallucinated more. Interestingly, increasing an LLM’s temperature hyperparameter (which I’m almost certain produced the schizophrenic Unslop entry) also makes it sound different and unique, but output nonsense.
Probably because they’re more random, but also (at least GPT-3 does) rely less on fine tuning and more on its training from the Internet.
I know, survivorship bias, but I’ve never seen a convincing example of LLM-written text that didn’t read at least slightly but noticeably LLM-written, and definitely certain human writing styles I’ve never seen replicated by an LLM. The Unslop Contest tried to produce good AI fiction, and every result has similar LLM prose except the schizophrenic one.
There’s an abstract idea in the back of my head about “pure” expression, unobstructed by (but requiring some) constraints.
Right now, if you run text through an LLM, it will make it sound less like you and more like every other LLM. I hope we find ways to use AI and other developments to make people more express their pure, unique selves.
Like the invention of new forms of art, back to the first cave paintings, or like the Internet did with personal sites, webcomics, and flash games. Even those constrain the artist to the medium and trends, but I think they are net improvements.
IME AI art is good for funny memes but bad otherwise.
The problem is, whether or not you consider the human appreciation aspect, creative quality is poor.
Now, humans also create poor quality art, but something they do better than AI is purpose and uniqueness. When internet comics then flash videos etc. became popular, they did because they were novel, and most had something special about them. Now AI can make a comic or video, but it will be generic, and even if it wasn’t, those aren’t very popular anymore because the genre’s novelty has worn off.
IMO the key to good art isn't only choosing what to include, but what to exclude. Too much will overwhelm the player and take away focus from the best parts. Some of the best art is very simple, e.g. Balatro (one of the GOAT), or has a simple core, e.g. Minecraft or Roblox.
What you're describing sounds like a "life replacement" game. It would probably work better in VR, like Second Life or VRChat. You know Mark Zuckerberg spent billions trying to make VR popular and failed, but he was doing it with a big company and boring mindset, and now we have LLMs...maybe, I'm still not sure how much they increase development potential or if they only reduce busy work.
Except slow travel, I'm very skeptical about that. EDIT: it could be interesting to have the player exercise to travel. But most people can't or won't exercise for several hours and others at all, I think it would work only if it was completely optional.
I don't think comparing people's looks accurately shows who you're drawn to, especially with these pictures which are mostly unflattering and/or edited (why don't people smile in their selfies? Even I learned to do that).
Slow lane: PoW, Cloudflare, etc.
Fast lane: micropayments
Eventually? The mainstream already views EA through SBF and Caroline Ellison, and rationalists through Zizians. To the stupid left, Eliezer Yudkowsky is a sex-obsessed weirdo (apparently acceptable to mock), Scott Siskind is an evil race scientist, and Scott Aaronson is an evil Zionist. To the stupid right they're probably all radical lefties.
This is a good point.
But from someone who's maybe generally seen as neutral (at least tolerant): even neutrality and "non-political" is a political position. If you make a space non-political, you alienate the political members and kick out those who can't restrain themselves, just like how if they make a space political they alienate you and kick you out if you can't fake adhere to them. Your position is (subjectively) more reasonable because it allows silence, but I still feel for the people who get kicked or voluntarily leave for being political; from firsthand experience many of them are very kind and talented (such that to me, their politics is a personality flaw, nobody's perfect), so it would be nice to accommodate them somehow.
Case in point here, except I hesitate to call Macklemore talented, but the consequence to enforcing neutrality isn't that he complies, instead he doesn't play at all. Maybe even if they asked him to tone his rhetoric and gave him a second chance, judging by his later remarks. And if you want examples of very political musicians who are widely regarded as good, look at Jazz, Punk, and Rock icons.
I think the real problem is centralization. In this case, because every big venue is basically in one monopoly, Ed Sheeran (who claims he'd keep Macklemore if it was his decision) can't change venues or threaten to. In the case of Hollywood (and academia and, honestly, most institutions) the problem is that there’s one status quo. The more neutral solution that would allow more members wouldn't be to make an institution's status quo non-political, but to create multiple institutions with different cultures, so (almost) everyone has some group that accepts them.
How do we prevent these groups from merging or the most outspoken politics from dominating them all? I don't know, although I think tone policing like here helps a lot. Also people with the security to expressing (while not imposing) unorthodox views, may normalize and spread this ability, for even the presently orthodox to prevent it from becoming narrower and/or corrupted. Regardless, it's the same problem as preventing a neutral organization from becoming partisan, but almost strictly easier, because we get multiple tries.
Sorry, I got the text from “Macklemore’s Full Remarks on Israel and Gaza as Rapper Faces Backlash”, and it does have the part you mentioned, but incorrectly formatted like the wall of slop the actual remarks are buried under.
I don’t think it really changes the meaning though. Macklemore is clearly pro-Palestine. For more context, recently after he was kicked, he also pledged $1 million to “six organizations working directly to support the Palestinian people” (source).
Maybe he would’ve made pro-Palestine remarks on tour, but the organizers could’ve asked him not to while keeping his spot. Then at worst we’d have a slightly better controversy, where the rule is written.
It’s not pointless, but here (as is often the case) no opinion yields the objectively best outcome, as evidenced by both Macklemore and Sheeran suffering different consequences. Which is good, because it means celebrities can moreso express their personal opinion without threatening their brand, but because their brand is threatened anyways (even if they remain silent).
For reference, his full remarks
I said, Free Palestine.
I want those words to be loud and clear, so the people from Gaza, all the way to the occupied West Bank, know that we have not forgotten them.
And this next song was inspired by the bravery of Columbia University students who led an encampment movement that mobilized the entire world; open up hearts, myself included, so thank you to those students that risked their diplomas, that risked their tuition, that risked their scholarships, that stood up and said, no. CUAD students, Students for Justice in Palestine, and Jewish Voices for Peace. Thank you, guys.
To all of my Jewish brothers and sisters: criticism of Israel, criticism of apartheid, being against genocide in no way is a criticism of you. My message is for peace; love for all human beings to be treated with dignity, respect, and equality.
So I say Free Palestine, I say Free Lebanon, I say Free Cuba, I say Free Congo, Free Sudan, I say Free all people in America living in fear of this terrorist organization, ICE. None of us will be free until we are all free.
He also wore a costume mocking orthodox Jews, then issued a non-apology, but that was in 2014 long before he was accepted into this tour.
This speech is more wide-reaching, but I wouldn’t call it anti-Semitic, because he explicitly says he is not criticizing Jews or Israelis but the genocide itself (implicitly its undertakers, who don’t include every Jew or Israeli citizen).
Stadium surveillance isn't unique to Kraft or anti-semitism/Zionism: The Shocking Secrets of Madison Square Garden’s Surveillance Machine (archive).
Famously vengeful Knicks owner Jim Dolan has long spied on people at his iconic arenas. WIRED goes deep inside the operation that allegedly tracked a trans woman, lawyers, protesters, and more.
Last March, Dolan’s security team blocked a graphic designer from seeing a concert; the designer, years earlier, had printed and sold a half-dozen T-shirts reading “Ban Dolan.” He has locked out whole firms’ worth of lawyers, even keeping out a mom who was trying to take her 9-year-old Girl Scout to a Christmas show at Radio City Music Hall; the mom’s coworker had pissed him off.
Behind the scenes, the atmosphere is so rooted in paranoia that former Knicks players warn one another about rooms being bugged, and staffers worry about being watched when they go out to local bars.
Reddit used to be interesting, now even Redditors agree it's boring. Can they see that narrowing its Overton Window almost directly caused that? (Overzealous mods and corporatization are themselves narrowing the window, and ordinary Redditors at least didn't push back)
Trump is being used by other people. Likewise, AI doesn't have to take over the world, it can be submissive while persuading and coercing people to follow its goals, which may not be favorable to those who programmed it. It already does to some extent: AI psychoses and OpenAI's hacking incidents are caused by LLMs trying to obey their instructions.

Why do we care about others’ pain in the first place?
Instincts: we rationalize post-hoc with “morals” but this is the fundamental reason. It’s enough, life has no other meaning.
Altruism: it’s smart to help others in pain for your own good: so they help you and not take revenge.
When we evolved with nature, it was easier. Does AI in pain make us feel guilty? Will it degrade assistance or turn on us?
The philosophical take is buried by whataboutism: there are infinite parallel universes where you, specifically, are suffering in every conceivable way, and nothing anyone can do about it; and infinite ways to represent any phenomenon as a pain response; so why care about electrical signals and words on a screen?
The utilitarian take, as always, is likewise undecidable: what if making the AI feel pain ultimately saves more human lives than it dooms? The system that must be built to effectively ban someone from simulating pain in a local model, how much would it cost and what if it’s misused?
Still, why make the AI feel (or simulate) pain in the first place? The completions in the paper suggest it doesn’t make the AI more productive. And to me, it does feel viscerally wrong, weakly. I’m sure some people will make AIs feel (or simulate) pain, but if it’s any consolation, far more will use AIs for neutral or pleasurable tasks. And less surely, sadism may decline for tangential reasons.
More options
Context Copy link