Capital_Room
rather dementor-like
Disabled Alaskan Monarchist doomer
User ID: 2666
Atheist materialist here. There is only "the mortal." There is no ineffable, no soul. So I don't see how to apply this analogy.
And if there were a soul, voting would be bad for it. Voting is bad. "Democracy" is a sham, "democracy" is evil, "democracy" must be destroyed!
wherein recent economic growth in the west is not representative of an increase in the quality and quantity of stuff, it’s reflecting accounting tricks and rising real estate prices.
I've recently encountered a somewhat similar narrative, pointing to a similar stagnation and decline, but, rather than being purely "accounting tricks and rising real estate prices," it's, to put it succinctly, software isn't stuff.
The example given was to consider if you took every modern electronic screen out of your house. Get rid of your flatscreen TV, and maybe replace it with an old CRT set. Toss out the laptops, the tablets, the smartphones, the GPS and other "screen" electronics in your car, etc.
Now, how does your stuff, your surroundings, your life differ from someone of similar class, job, etc. back in the 70s or 80s? What has gotten better in terms of material stuff, rather than telecommunications, internet, and software, software, software? It's the whole "flying cars vs. cyberpunk dystopia" thing, the building of the virtual "layer" atop a stagnating, even declining material one.
(I'm reminded here again of the likes of Tyler Cowen's Average is Over and the future he projects, where ~80% of the population lives in third-world style favelas, concentrated in the narrow latitude/climate band that minimizes annual heating+AC costs, eating beans, making pennies on Amazon Turk; but most people will be fine with that because VR will have become so good they won't care about their conditions in the material world (and for those who don't, there will be better psych drugs and cops with omnipresent surveillance drones).)
What would the federal government do if, like a podcast I recently listened to suggested, the Utah state government were to stop supplying water to the NSA's Utah Data Center?
does a sovereign have a duty to his nation?
I'd say the way that some of our modern elites behave — particularly those in the UK — at least some of them believe the answer is "no." That they can freely "dissolve the people and elect another," to quote Bertold Brecht.
The answer to this is well known: the people are.
It's the well-known "official" textbook answer, but I'd say it's wrong. The Iron Law of Oligarchy is absolute. "The people" are not sovereign, have never been sovereign, and will never be sovereign. The United States, and modern democracy as a whole, are built upon falsehoods.
So as long as you vote, the sacred institutions of the republic are preserved.
But at this point, are they really still "sacred," or have they been profaned beyond recovery; and should they be preserved at all?
I’ve never seen 2 in real life in my entire life.
I, for one, have encountered this view in personal discussions, from multiple people.
You may be right about that — it looks like Judge Merchan just delayed Trump's sentencing to after the election.
Define “real”.
I mean, actually a militia, and actually a group. As you note, they don't seem to be very fitting of the former, fiven the emphasis you note on trying to fix it, and I'd argue McVeigh and his accomplices failed to meet the latter.
But none of this actually answers the question of how one finds these groups. You mention the "online portion of these groups on YouTube" — any examples? (Though, if they're on YouTube, the odds of being riddled with Feds is pretty much near 1.)
Former president goes to prison, where he is guarded by a disgraced former secret service agent who was already in, feels like a great premise for a network tv show.
It does; the sort of thing USA Network would air.
Trump won't need guards, they'll recruit themselves from the jail population, hoping for presidential clemency and aid.
How effective would fellow inmates be at protecting him from being Epsteined?
Trump is never going to see a cell unless he's on tour.
Why not?
In most cases the existence of the group is organic and the members and leadership really believe in it
That's not an answer to how one finds such a group, then.
Tell that to Epstein; or, for that matter, to the Romanovs.
This does not mean that there are no "right wing militias".
So, again, how do you find one, then?
And if you want this to work without too many bad side effects, you're going to want the father to be married to the mother, too, which would be a big change as well
I read this and think of my parents: Mom was fresh out of high school in the late 1970s when she married Dad, who is just two years older than her, and was already in the workforce (having dropped out of high school after 10th grade). Just a few years later, in the early 1980s, Mom pops me out a few weeks before her 22nd birthday; my first brother a year and a half later; and then my other brother, her youngest, just a couple of days after turning 26. And this family of 5 lived entirely off my Dad's handyman income, with Mom being a SAHM, and not entering the workforce proper until Youngest Brother was out of high school.
And this was just a few decades ago, not some ancient days of yore here. So really, I'd say the issue is simply the whole everyone-goes-to-college things. Is that bachelor's degree really necessary to do the job? If so, would it still be necessary if we hadn't devalued high school diplomas with "social promotion," grade inflation, and so on?
(Again, I keep coming back to how many of our problems would be solved if we got someone in power who went after Academia with an approach somewhere in the range from Henry VIII to Qin Shi Huang.)
The focus should be on enticing those with 1 child to have 3, and those with 2 to have 4 or 5.
Recently, on a podcast interview discussing this issue, the interviewee gave the statistic that back in the 80s, the average number of children per mother (note, not per woman, per mother) was 2.5. Now, that same figure is at… 2.6. I also recall reading, elsewhere, that the average number of children per mother did not actually rise much during the Baby Boom — it was pretty much entirely a "marriage boom."
In all cases, the issue seems to be getting not from 1 to 3 or 2 to 4, but from 0 to 1.
There's also a recent Christian sect -- let's call it what it is, it's a cult -- called the Iglesia ni Cristo, which outright rejects the depiction of the cross
There's an even newer one out of Mexico, La Luz del Mundo, with a similar policy of rejection.
I'm aware of them because of the highly visible (closed) church they built in my neighborhood.
Given what happened in Pennsylvania, how well will the Secret Service be able (or should that be "willing"?) to protect Donald Trump if (when) he's sent to Rikers Island next month?
So, I'm old enough to remember, back in the Clinton years, the media scaremongering about "right-wing militia groups." Well, it's my understanding that this is entirely fake; right-wing militias don't actually exist, and every group that is purported to be one is actually either:
- A small group of aging, out-of-shape men who get together a couple times a year to fire off some guns and drink some beer (more the latter than the former)
- A Fed honeypot operation.
But, I've had some people, including a couple on this forum, assure me that I'm wrong and that "real" right-wing militias actually exist.
So, assuming they're correct, how does one find one of these groups?
Edit: so I note that /u/hydroacetylene was the only one who actually tried to answer the question (even if the example he gives is a Fed honeypot) rather than handwave at groups past, or opine about what "real" means in this context — and that answer was: you don't find them, they find you.
’m not sure who said it but I’ve always found this amusing; “A misogynist is just a person who hates women as much as women do.”
I've generally seen it attributed to H. L. Mencken:
Misogynist: A man who hates women as much as women hate one another.
substitute a competent assassin
Random citizens are not "competent assassins." And for that matter, I'm not sure how much "competent assassin" is even a thing. I don't remember where I read it (as usual), but I recall reading about how on the one hand, it's not easy for a protection detail to stop a determined assassin with no concern for his own survival, but, on the other hand, any assassin who makes plans to try to get away alive is pretty much guaranteed to fail at hitting their target.
Now, the fact that the bureaucrats (at least initially) won't have a protection detail will change this a bit. But still, the odds of getaway remain very slim.
Was McVeigh really that much of an outlier?
Yes, and his sort even more so in the decades since.
I think living conditions could easily get bad enough that people no longer have much to lose.
Perhaps, but not particularly soon, and as times get more desperate, people tend to get less cooperative as they compete with one another to maintain their slice of the shrinking metaphorical pie.
Really all that needs to happen is that people get their friends and family killed, raped or immiserated with no recourse.
I think Nybbler answered this one pretty well.
As mentionned elsewhere in this thread, the Feds have been smart enough to avoid escalating in such conditions since Waco
McVeigh had very little to do with the lack of further Wacos. Nor is it due to any unwillingness or incapacity on the part of the government. It is my understanding that the local cops had several opportunities to arrest Koresh and other leading Branch Davidians, and indeed wanted to do so, but were specifically told not to by the feds, who wanted to sweep up the entire group in a single big operation that Janet Reno could show off in the media, and the FBI and ATF could use to justify their big budgets and fancy toys.
But then it went wrong. So, now, they don't bother doing it that way. Instead, they let the local cops pick off leadership as soon as possible.
The reason you don't see any more Waco-type incidents isn't because the government can't deal with groups like the Branch Davidians, it's because they've gotten so good at nipping such groups in the bud long before they ever reach the "armed compound" stage, in ways that don't grab mass media attention.
It's not a sign of their weakness, but a sign of their strength.
Sympathetic nutjobs(all of whom are heavily into the 2nd amendment) resisting will trigger more resistance-
That's not what I see from the right wing red tribe people I know IRL (i.e. my family and most friends), nor from similar people online (see for example commenters at Sarah Hoyt's blog). Instead I see denunciations of anyone who shoots as cops as automatically losing any and all sympathy, because you Just Don't Do That Ever, with the one and only exception of gun confiscation. If they're not taking your guns, you don't resist. Ever. And anyone who does resist our Boys in Blue is automatically thereby a Criminal Scumbag Who Deserves What They Get.
I've read that piece before, and I think our @KulakRevolt both overestimates the ease of assassination government officials — and the willingness of sane, non-suicidal people to attempt it, given the negligible odds of getting away with it — and underestimates the willingness of our officials to bear the risk (which, again, is lower than he thinks).
Battle of Athens,
Several generations ago, and well before the NSA began watching veterans' groups as closely as they do now.
Bundy Standoff
Did anybody on the Bundy side ever actually fire a shot?
No, you're going to need a lot more people. Because our sniper might be able to successfully pick off one of the faceless bureaucrats… but his odds of getting away alive and free to try again with another are very, very small. So you're going to need someone else to pick up where he left off… and then another to follow after him… and then another…
And like @RobertLiguori noted above, only "the barest fraction" are even going to do anything other than meekly submit. And after the first dozen snipers all end up arrested or dead, while the bureaucrats they picked off are replaced, with no real change in the mechanisms of tyranny (beyond further crackdowns and tightening security), how many are really going to want to follow suit?

So, how much longer before the AfD gets banned, then?
More options
Context Copy link